Author Archives | Robert Zaller

Good Trouble: The final gift of John Lewis

There is never a good day to die, but everyone’s time comes anyway. It came for John Lewis on July 17, 2020, and it marked the end of an era — but perhaps, too, the beginning of a new one.

John Lewis was the last surviving speaker of the March on Washington rally in August 1963, and was the last speaker of that day. It may be surprising that anyone spoke after Martin Luther King gave his “I have a dream” speech, the greatest American political speech of the twentieth century, but John Lewis did. He was 23 years old.

Two years later, John Lewis got his skull cracked open trying to cross the Edmund Pettus Bridge in Selma, Alabama, and he told people he thought he was going to die. It wasn’t his time. He lived to be 80, and though there is never a good day to die there may be one which is timely. John Lewis always talked about getting into “good trouble,” meaning nonviolent activism on behalf of social justice. He left us at a time of very bad trouble, with a raging pandemic, a broken economy and a raving clown trying to take us all down with him as he plunges toward ruin. He left us, too, stunned by the image of a man getting the life crushed out of him by a policeman’s knee as he lay handcuffed in the gutter, the horror that finally roused a country that has slept for 50 years.

The horror was not enough, because a political system so long unresponsive to justice, so inured to corruption and state violence, could not be turned by George Floyd or the other cases we are awakening to; it was unable a few months earlier to remove a president guilty of high crimes and misdemeanors at a cost of, as it now stands, more than 150,000 American lives.

We needed something more, an image not simply of the worst within us but of the best, of a deeply noble life lived, as John Lewis must have known it would be after Martin Luther King’s assassination, in a dark time that he could only hope in his last days might be finally lifted. A lot of things paused for the period that John Lewis made his final journey back to his native Alabama; in Selma across what is still called the Edmund Pettus bridge in a caisson drawn by horses; then to the rotunda of the Capitol Building in Washington, D.C. as the first African-American ever so honored; back south to the Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta for the public tributes and eulogies, and finally for burial beside his wife.

But he had some final words for us, reserved for posthumous publication in The New York Times and reminding us that, as John Dewey had said long before, democracy was ultimately not a system of government but a way of behaving toward each other as members of a Beloved Community, the circle of love and respect that enables us to cherish each other in our differences and even disputes. We needed such words from such a man as we have seldom needed them before. But, even in the Ebenezer Baptist Church service that was the climax of the obsequies, there was a painful reminder of how we have come to be where we are and how long the road to travel has become. There was stirring gospel-singing, heartfelt tributes from family members, friends, colleagues and staff, and a fine and wise sermon by the Rev. Raphael Warnock. But then there was the rogues’ gallery. We have five living presidents.

Donald Trump would not come to Atlanta, the man who called John Lewis a man of words rather than actions, and whose own actions are almost uniformly wicked as his words are overwhelmingly lies. Jimmy Carter, bowed with age, could not come, although he sent gracious words. That left Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama. Clinton’s popularity in the African-American community was such that he was for a time referred to as America’s first Black president.

That didn’t last long, and Clinton had given the lie to it on the campaign trail in 1992 when, as Governor of Arkansas, he not only permitted the execution of Ricky Lee Rector, an African-American prisoner whose self-inflicted gunshot wound had left him unable to understand the nature of his crime or the punishment he was about to receive, but traveled home for it to show how tough he was on crime. Under Clinton, two of the most savage statutes in American penal history were passed, the Violent Criminal Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994 and the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1995, which, among other things, added some sixty new capital offenses to the federal penal code and enshrined the notorious Three Strikes rule under which conviction for three felonies, no matter how minor, bought an automatic life sentence.

These statutes helped to nearly double the prison population of the United States by the time Clinton left office, making it the largest in the world. Black Americans were considerably overrepresented in this number. George Bush showed up in Atlanta, his patented smirk intact, but his address should be the Hague. After ignoring frantic warnings about the 9/11 attacks in what may have been the greatest dereliction of duty ever by an American president, facilitating the escape from American jurisdiction of the state actor most responsible for them — Saudi Arabia; attacking Afghanistan instead in what has become the longest war in American history, Bush lied us into war with Iraq, made torture an official instrument of national policy, and left us with the worst economic collapse since the Great Depression. Barack Obama came last.

Far from investigating Bush’s crimes, he chummed with him in a rehabilitation that climaxed in the National Constitution Center’s award of its Liberty Medal, an honor presented to Bush by Obama’s own vice president. You’ll recall the name: Joe Biden. As for Obama himself, he returned Wall Street’s stolen profits with interest while millions of Americans were evicted from their homes, and millions more suffered through the most agonizingly slow recovery since the 1930s.

He withdrew Bush’s torture memorandums but did him one better, not only authorizing targeted assassinations of American citizens but attempting to promulgate what might be called the Obama Doctrine, that due process of law does not require public trial. He praised Bush’s illegal war in Iraq as a crusade for freedom and democracy and doubled down on the one in Afghanistan. He left three other Middle Eastern countries devastated: Syria, Libya and Yemen — the latter in collaboration with our dear friends, the Saudis.

In the waning days of the 2016 presidential campaign, Obama appealed directly to African-Americans to protect his legacy with their votes. Clinton, Bush and Obama could do nothing to dim the achievement of John Lewis’ life. They could do nothing to usurp its glory. John Lewis showed us the road ahead.

The three miscreants who came to bury him showed how long it will be. But, as Lewis told us in his parting words, we must walk it all the way.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Good Trouble: The final gift of John Lewis

On Living in a Pariah Nation

America was a curious country in the 19th century, attracting such figures as Alexis de Tocqueville, Charles Dickens and Rudyard Kipling. By the end of the century, it was a world power. Its own elite, fabulously rich by almost any standard, did the tour of Europe as commercial conquerors and brought home its spoils in art and fashion.

Then came the two world wars. America bankrolled the British and French in World War I, and when that did not suffice entered the war to tip the balance. For a year, the Allies hung on desperately, waiting for the Yanks to arrive. They did, and the Germans gave up. In World War II, the conquered French and beleaguered British waited two and a half years for deliverance until we crossed the English Channel with the greatest flotilla ever seen to once again rescue democracy and capitalism for the Old World.

America then took its pick of Europe’s best artists and scientists in setting up its own imperium not only in Western Europe but around much of what it dubbed the “Free World.” Not only could the rich and the occasional art-tourist like Ernest Hemingway enjoy Europe (or anywhere else they chose to go), but a generation of backpacking, pot-smoking students — blissfully unaware of the shoulders of privilege on which they stood — came to gawk at the Vatican, the Parthenon and the Pyramids.

This was the American Century, proclaimed Time Magazine’s publisher, Henry Luce, in 1941. It climaxed in 1989 with the fall of the Soviet empire, America’s only competitor. Confidently, we looked forward to a world wholly remade in our image, and, not to put too fine a point on it, obedient to our will. One commentator even declared an “end to history,” in which what we called the “American way of life” would become not only the gold standard for the world but the only standard. I doubt that even the Romans were ever that arrogant.

Then came 9/11. Humiliatingly, the largest attack ever perpetrated on American soil was not the work of our Russian or Chinese rivals, but of a ragtag band of terrorists funded by Saudi sheikhs against whom we dared not retaliate. For a moment, our allies united behind us. In Paris, which we’d liberated nearly sixty years before, people said, “We are all Americans.” You aren’t going to hear that again.

Our European allies followed us as we plunged into the quagmires of Afghanistan and Iraq, the first one under specious premises and the second under false ones. In Afghanistan, they shared the battlefield losses, and in Iraq the disgrace of our torture sites at Abu Ghraib and elsewhere, at least by association.

Still, American might remained Europe’s protective shield against a resurgent Russia, and it spearheaded a joint drive to extend the European Union up to Russia’s own borders and then deep into what had formerly been Soviet territory. Moscow’s military response to the American-led coup against Ukraine’s government threatened Europe with general war for the first time since 1945. This gave pause to our continental partners, but, dependent as they were on our arms, they could only watch nervously as the two former Cold War superpowers flexed muscles against each other.

Donald Trump brought these tensions to a head. A real estate tycoon leveraged by Russian oligarchs and politically indebted to Russian intelligence, he expressed contempt for the Western alliance and its leaders, and for the democratic process in general. Isolating the United States by unilaterally exiting the Paris Climate Accords, the Iraq nuclear arms agreement, and the World Health Organization, he threatened as well to leave NATO, for seven decades the cornerstone of American policy. Many had been uncomfortable before with America’s overweening power; now it seemed to be acting as a rogue state, untethered to norms of conduct and shared interests of any sort.

European leaders, no longer able to rely on an American guarantee, began to look to themselves for security and to contemplate a world in which they would have to act on their own. When the Congressional conviction of Trump on impeachment charges failed in February 2020, they had to face the fact that he could not be regarded as a temporary aberration in American politics, but that he might go on to reshape them for good. With a substantial base of support, he exemplified an anti-intellectual, anti-secular and anti-democratic strain in American life that, abetted by one of its major political parties, had now come to the fore.

COVID-19 then moved America from a rogue state to a pariah one. With whatever hesitations and missteps, China, much of East Asia, most of Europe and parts of Africa moved speedily to contain the virus by testing, contact tracing and a rigorous economic shutdown. These tried and true remedies were successful. By summer, they had not only flattened the curve of viral infection but reduced it, despite occasional outbreaks, to a level compatible with the resumption of much normal activity.

This did not occur in the United States, the only country in the developed world that failed to adopt a national strategy for dealing with the virus. The obvious central reason for this was the willful refusal of Trump to acknowledge and act upon the crisis until a stock market crash, the only barometer he would respond to, compelled him to act. In general, America’s shutdown period was the briefest of any major country’s, and its rate of infection was still alarmingly high when it resumed business.

The result was that infections soon soared, and are now threatening to reach levels beyond control in major parts of the country. Europe’s response to this has been to deny Americans entrance across their borders. True, Donald Trump had himself peremptorily closed the United States to European visitors in March, without notice or consultation. Europe had as good reason to return the disfavor. But that Americans, twice welcomed as saviors of Europe in the past century, should now be persona non grata on the very soil they had liberated, was a comedown without precedent in history. My country has become a pariah; I am an undesirable.

As Tom Engelhardt and others have pointed out recently, the moment when friends around the world rallied to our side after the World Trade Center bombing was the beginning of our eclipse, and Osama bin Laden, the architect of 9/11, has achieved a victory beyond his wildest dreams. But our imperial overreach had set us up for a fall long before; even now, our hubris remains largely undiminished and, for the most part, unexamined.

In “The Man Without a Country,” the 19th century American writer Edward Everett Hale depicted a man who, convicted of treason against the United States and renouncing it defiantly, is condemned to live out his days on the high seas. I’m not a man without a country. These days, though, I feel very much like a man living in a country without a world.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on On Living in a Pariah Nation

Donald Doubles Down on his Base

So, what’s a fellow to do these days? Donald Trump was riding high a few months ago. He had what he liked to call a booming economy — that is, “booming” for billionaires, with a stock market in the stratosphere, corporate profits at obscene levels and mega-giants getting rebates instead of paying taxes; a huge campaign war chest and a divided Democratic Party playing Ten Little Indians in the endless farce the DNC called “debates.” Being president was pretty easy when you didn’t have one of those generals trying to get you to read briefing books, and the only decisions you had to make were which environmental regulation to gut or world organization to pull out of next. Life could be great.

Then, the luck ran out.

It’s a truism that the modern presidency is tested by crisis. The last president to get by without one was Calvin Coolidge. He spent six years in office with nothing more serious to deal with than Lindbergh’s flight over the Atlantic, Babe Ruth’s sixty home runs and the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre. Herbert Hoover then found himself facing the Great Depression; Franklin D. Roosevelt had to deal with it, and a world war after that; Harry Truman had the Cold War and so on. Donald Trump had not a worry in the world, and a Teflon suit off which endless scandal bounced off without a dent.

Trump didn’t want to hear about the coronavirus, and he still doesn’t. At first, he tried to will it away — if grown men quailed at his command, how could a thing not even technically alive defy him? — and, when that didn’t work, he resorted to magical thinking: it would simply disappear. At this point, he still has no idea of how to deal with it, and his only response is denial. For one of the world’s most notorious germophobes, this is a strenuous exercise in nonthinking indeed.

The one thing Trump does take seriously is polls, at least during reelection season. When he doesn’t like one, he looks to another. None of them, though, are looking up.

To be sure, the President has some options. In some reptilian corner of his mind, he understands that the fewer people who come out to vote in November, the better for him. He has said as much in effect in his now oft-quoted remark that if voting were not suppressed, no Republican would win an election. In effect: Trump did not say that he would not win a race personally, and he has never identified himself as a Republican except on the rarest and most ceremonial of occasions. He did not run as one in 2016; on the contrary, his main policy proposals — tax hikes for the rich, controls on drug prices, guaranteed insurance coverage for preexisting medical conditions and the like — were populist ploys at odds with standard Republican Party positions.

When he won, Trump turned the Party into a personal satrapy, and what had hitherto been its constituents into a “base,” loyal to him alone. Classically, this is what dictators do. Thus, what Trump means, when he says that no Republican can win an election that isn’t tilted or rigged, is that no Republican can win one without him. When a Republican wins a race, it is his doing; when he doesn’t, it’s the loser’s fault. Strictly speaking, there is no Republican Party without Trump. There is only a Leader, his followers and his enemies: a Mitt Romney, a John McCain.

The Leader does not win or lose elections; he appropriates them.  There is only one legitimate party: his own. Any opposition is simply treasonous. Trump has repeatedly flung such a charge at Democrats, but it should be remembered that Republicans were doing the same when they accused their Democratic opponents of “20 years of treason” in 1952 while he was still in knee-pants. You might say, in fairness, that Trump was not simply a demagogue looking for followers, but the Republicans wanting a greedy man for their boss.

Trump’s problem, however, is that he has not yet simply abolished elections as his erstwhile friend Xi Jinping has in China. He might attempt it, considering his fondness for declaring national emergencies; he is no doubt thinking of it, as his son-in-law Jared Kushner indicated when he said he was not in a position to guarantee that an election would be held on Nov. 3. As of now, however, the Democrats are still a legal party, and their presumptive candidate, Joe Biden, had, at last, a 14-point electoral lead over Trump.

Barring a military coup, then (for which the routing of the Lafayette Park protesters in Washington, D.C. on June 1 by the military looked like an intended rehearsal), Trump must gird himself for the prospect that an election will indeed take place. But the lesson of Lafayette Park was that the generals were not at the moment to be had. So how does Trump, in the midst of a pandemic, economic collapse and seething racial unrest, figure out a way to win?

What he’s doing is what many others have done in his place: going with what brought him to the dance. Trump started out as a salesman; he branched out into being a showman; he sees politics as a melding of the two, with himself as the product. Getting people to buy the product and stick with the brand is his sole objective, and to do that he has cultivated the unthinking adherence he calls loyalty. Loyalty, in his Barnumesque view, is a one-way street, in which what is offered is the illusion of value and what is demanded is the hard coin of support. What bonds it is spectacle, the phenomenon of the rally in which Trump offers himself as the object of his followers’ devotion.

We’ve seen the act before: it’s called demagoguery. Huey Long was a demagogue; so was George Wallace. But no American demagogue was ever president of the United States, and none has ever been more nakedly cynical. Long did build Louisiana; Wallace lived to repent his racism. Donald Trump has never had anything but contempt for his followers, even as he feeds off their adoration.

As Trump’s general public approval has sunk to regions from which few politicians have ever returned, he has been repeatedly urged to reach beyond his base and try, at long last, to unify the country.  Such sage advice completely misunderstands the man. He cannot reach out to anything beyond himself, because nothing exists for this textbook narcissist beyond the ego whose emptiness he must daily fill. For that, he is willing to sacrifice anything and anyone, himself not excluded. The rally he staged in Tulsa the past weekend, poorly attended as it was, still mortally endangered those who attend it and spread the COVID-19 virus to others outside it. Despite the personal precautions he himself took and his apparent belief in his own magic immunity, he risked making himself his own victim.

Many people now are marching in the streets for racial and economic justice, at significant risk of their own. But Donald Trump invites his followers to join a biohazard suicide cult in which he is the master of ceremonies.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Donald Doubles Down on his Base

A battered republican, a tattered Constitution

An oft-told tale: Ben Franklin, when asked what kind of government the Founding Fathers had given us after months of secret conclave, famously replied, “A republic, if you can keep it.” It’s clear at this point that we haven’t been keeping it very well. That would not have surprised the founders, some of whom privately speculated that it might last no more than a century or so. Since it is now 233 years old, we might say that it has passed its original sell-by date and that the only surprise is that it is still around.

The founders worked very hard to ensure that the new republic would not be a democracy. Among them, only Thomas Jefferson believed in majority rule, and he was far away in Paris when the Constitution was actually drafted. The country still does not directly elect a president, rather an Electoral College whose members have until now not been bound to abide by the will of the majority.

In 2000, George W. Bush was declared president by a 5-4 vote of the U.S. Supreme Court, which usurped the jurisdiction of the Florida State Supreme Court and nullified Al Gore’s popular majority in the national vote. The court neither had nor offered a legal rationale for its decision. One of its votes on Bush’s behalf was cast by Sandra Day O’Connor, who had publicly declared that Gore’s election would be a disaster for the country but did not recuse herself. From that, we got 9/11, two failed wars we are still fighting and a financial crash that plunged us into the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression.

In 2016, 46 percent of the voting electorate chose a buffoon, swindler and bigot to be president. Almost three million more voters cast their ballots for his opponent, Hillary Clinton. Donald Trump was elected. In no other country in the world would the loser of the popular vote be declared the victor for its highest office. The Founding Fathers had their wish. America is not a democracy.

For three years, we skated along with a president whose utter unfitness was demonstrated daily. We counted on his very unfitness to protect us. Surely, someone as sheerly incompetent as Donald Trump, someone so ignorant of law, history, geography and just about everything else not connected to real estate fraud would be managed by his Cabinet and staff, perhaps more easily than a person knowledgeable enough at least to do real harm.

We didn’t realize far greater damage could be done by a person whose pathological narcissism, given the powers of an imperial presidency, would turn the world into a funhouse mirror reflecting only his own distorted image. At first, Trump seemed to defer to the grownups in the room. Before long, though, he came to realize that the presidency was an ideal setting for an unfettered ego.

Those he could not command he slandered, often to good effect among an electoral base that derived vicarious pleasure from his riffs against “traitors” who opposed his will. Government was hobbled, critics cowed and civil discourse swamped in the unremitting stream of lies, threats and juvenile insults issued from the Oval Office. By simple, unwitting instinct, and with the help of a few eager tutors, Donald Trump found his way to a political philosophy that at last suited him: fascism.

When the constitutional remedy of presidential impeachment failed last February, Trump was exultant. With a juiced-up stock market and a huge campaign treasury, he anticipated a triumphant reelection. True, he might find himself a minority president again. But the Founding Fathers, in their wisdom, had shown him a way to game the system. It wasn’t how many votes you got, but where you got them — and how many you could suppress. Four more years? Trump’s buddy, Vladimir Putin, was just about to get himself an extra twelve.

Then came the virus. And the luck ran out: Trump’s, and ours. For the first time in four years, Trump was called on to do something he was absolutely incapable of: governing. This was bad news that couldn’t be wished away or denied out of existence. It was bad news that required Trump to deliver more bad news: a lockdown that would collapse the economy, and place his reelection in doubt. True, by taking command of the situation, he might steer the country to a safer place, and for the first time win something that had always eluded him: genuine respect. But that would have required Donald Trump to become the exact opposite of the man he actually was.

And so, here we are. The Founding Fathers erected a system of checks and balances precisely to prevent a man such as Trump from winning the presidential office they had created. It worked, more or less, until it didn’t. There is no perfect remedy because there is no perfect society. But there is at least a guiding principle we might look to. It is the one the Founding Fathers did their best to dilute: democracy.

We need direct popular election of the president, as of all other officials. We need nationwide direct proportional representation by population for our national legislature. That means that the U.S. Senate needs to be completely revamped, if not abolished. The principle we adhere to in general is that all votes are of equal weight. In the Senate, the vote of a Wyoming citizen is worth nearly 70 times that of one in California. This has consequences.

In 2010, the Senate was Democratic. By 2014, it had turned Republican, even though nearly 60 percent of all Senate votes cast nationwide in that period were for Democratic candidates. This is not only undemocratic but racist. Smaller states tend to be more homogeneous in population, so that Blacks, Latinos and other minority groups are additionally disadvantaged in the Senate. The Senate also has the exclusive privilege of appointing federal judges and Cabinet officers, thus extending its exclusive sway into the other branches of government.

The politicization of the courts is nothing new, but it has been elevated into a deliberate weapon of late. This has given conservatives a preponderant and permanent advantage in government as a whole. Conservatives are certainly entitled to their voice on a level electoral playing field. They are not entitled to dominion. The Supreme Court itself is the most undemocratic institution in the land. The Constitution nowhere stipulates a power in the Court to overturn legislation, but the Founding Fathers in effect acquiesced in such a power when Chief Justice John Marshall covertly assumed it.

If the court finds a statute or practice unconstitutional, its duty should simply be to advise the Congress of its opinion. To give nine persons, unelected by the public and with lifelong tenure, the power to alter or negate the will of the people through their elected representatives is the negation of democracy itself. From Dred Scott to Citizens United, the deadly mischief this can do is apparent. Our Constitution served an 18th century world. Much amended, most often in a more democratic direction, it needs now to be rethought. That will be the best way to honor it today, and to give us a government of, by, and for the people in the only way it can truly be had — equally.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A battered republican, a tattered Constitution

The man without a mask

A dark wind is blowing through this country, and we can only await what destruction it will finally bring. Before the coronavirus descended on us, we were already in crisis. We had endured three years of Donald Trump, thinking we could outlast him, and then, when the comedy of impeachment had played itself out, that there was no other choice. Already, as the Republican Party was completing its terminal disgrace in the United States Senate, the virus was at work among us, Death’s opportunist. No, COVID-19 is not a morality play, not a punishment for our sins. But just as it attacked the weakest and most vulnerable of us, so it has attacked human societies around the globe at their weakest points. It attacked China for its secrecy and fear of the truth. It attacked Russia for an autocratic leadership beneath which lays institutional chaos and anarchy. It has attacked us for the stain of poverty and injustice in a land of plenty, and for the original sin of racial oppression. It seems we are to pay a particularly heavy price.

Hospitals are ordinarily the place for masks, to prevent contagion. Epidemics spread contagion far and wide; pandemics spread them everywhere. That’s when everyone needs a mask, at least in public places. It’s understood that you should wear one, both to protect yourself and others. Even the droplets released in speech can carry the virus. If you don’t wear a covering for your nose and mouth, authorities have the right and duty to stop you. Such a rule applies to everyone.

Except for the president. He alone sets himself above the law. He alone believes he is the law.

Well, you may think, what’s a little presidential spittle, especially if it’s nowhere close to where you are? Except that this is the whole point. Everything the president utters has been fatally infected since day one of his administration. Infected with lies —17,000 of them, and counting. Infected with racism, the subtext where not the overt content of everything he says. Infected with hate.

And now, since the middle of the winter, infected with something more direct: Death.

Trump’s first reaction to COVID-19 was denial. It was news he didn’t want to hear, not because it portended catastrophe for the country but because it would jeopardize the sole objective of his administration: reelection. This meant deaths for tens of thousands of Americans, a number that continues to grow exponentially as Trump encourages his fellow countrymen to share his denial or to regard the deaths to come as a salutary public health measure to thin the ranks of those disinclined to vote for him. The poor would die disproportionately, crowded in cities or without adequate medical attention. Minorities would die, defined as un-American and unworthy of a berth on the Mayflower. The rich, of course, would take care of themselves, and reap a windfall from disaster as they always do. As for everyone else, the loyal followers of the man who described himself as not merely elected but “chosen,” his personal magic would protect them.

There has always been a cult-like quality to Trump’s supporters. They have been a cordon to protect him, as he has been the savior who would restore their lost world. What took that world from them, the good jobs and the secure pensions, the basic decency even in a hardscrabble life, had always been a mystery. Now added to that was the virus, arisen as if from the pits of hell. Of course, Trump’s legions would double down on him.

And, of course, Donald Trump would not wear a mask.

A mask was fear, concealment, weakness. A mask was a confession of powerlessness in the face of attack.

A mask was silencing oneself, denying oneself the power not only to speak and be heard but to be seen, fearless and bold, immune from harm and therefore able to immunize others.

Donald Trump promised us a vaccine against COVID-19, for sure by the end of the year. Then he told us we would be all right, fine, great again, even without a vaccine. How?

Because, for those putting their trust in him, Trump himself would be the vaccine.

Trump hasn’t made that as an actual claim, no more than he has literally claimed to have been sent by higher powers. As usual, he leaves you to draw the inference. We need a vaccine; we’ll have a vaccine; we don’t need one after all. Why? Because Donald says so.

When Trump finally acquiesced to numbers of the dead and dying even he could not deny, he declared war against the virus. But he was a general who gave no coherent orders. He had no strategy; he hoarded scarce resources. He lied about losses. And, when unemployment skyrocketed to Great Depression levels in a matter of weeks, he abruptly quit the field. You can’t run very well on 100,000 dead bodies. But you can’t run on 40 million pink slips either.

Trump chose the lesser number. The dead couldn’t be brought back, but jobs could, or at least the demand that workers return to them, safely or not. If Trump couldn’t run on prosperity, he could, with luck, run on recovery — or at least the promise of it. Having made the absurd claim that he could reopen the economy by fiat from the White House, he made the happy discovery that this was in fact the responsibility of governors and state health departments. All he would need to be was the cheerleader of recovery. If it worked, he would take the credit for whatever profit might result; if it failed — if tens or hundreds of thousands of avoidable deaths resulted — it would be the failure of others.

As ever, Donald Trump was betting the house. As always, the house he was betting was yours.

That would not be the only card Trump could play. He had violence on his side as well. From his inaugural address on, he had deliberately polarized an already divided country until, under the stress of a deadly pandemic, a devastated economy and prolonged social isolation, the slaying of George Floyd in Minneapolis broke it at its most vulnerable point: race. Trump’s last gamble would be a descent into social chaos, real or fancied, that would justify a law and order campaign, based if need be on military occupation under the Insurrection Act, passed by the Ninth Congress in 1807. This act, which requires the request of state governments, was invoked by George H. W. Bush during the Los Angeles riots of 1992. George W. Bush attempted to remove the request requirement, only to be halted by the united opposition of all 50 states. Regardless, Trump has already threatened to impose the Act by presidential decree alone.

Count only on one thing: Donald Trump will do anything to stay in power. And he is willing to sacrifice the health and the lives of as many people as he needs to do so.

I’ve seen and heard many things about Trump, and said them, too. But I can’t put the present state of things any better than a letter writer from Sun City, Arizona did in The New York Times of May 28: “Donald Trump is killing our country, figuratively and literally.”

It’s as simple as that.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The man without a mask

Death has a Salesman in the White House

Donald Trump had the most famous line of the 2016 presidential campaign. He said that he could shoot someone in the middle of Fifth Avenue in Manhattan and get away with it.

He’s doing it right now, and not just on Fifth Avenue alone. It’s the bet he’s making on the 2020 election too.

Trump’s got plenty of blood on his hands already. American intelligence was aware of a major viral outbreak in Wuhan, China within days of its occurrence in November 2019. epidemiologists would obviously have understood the consequences of the decision by Chinese authorities, beginning locally but soon rising to the highest levels, to suppress any public knowledge of what was happening. It would also soon have been obvious that the virus was a novel one, uncontrollable without a vaccine tailored to it.

By early January — six critical weeks into the crisis — understaffed and beleaguered health agencies were sounding alarms to senior Trump officials that a pandemic was on its way, despite Chinese denials that extended into the third week of the month. By late January, Trump’s senior economic advisor, Peter Navarro, was attempting to advise him that without action the United States could face a third of the country falling ill, resulting in one to two million deaths.

Trump didn’t want to hear about it. Donald Trump doesn’t like bad news, especially news that might keep him from golfing, holding campaign rallies or winning reelection. He doesn’t like listening to medical experts, or anyone else whose prime qualification is that they know what they’re talking about rather than fealty to him. As for the virus, he just wished it away — it would miraculously disappear, maybe with warm weather or just on its own. More precious weeks were lost, while world-respected disease-control agencies dithered or descended into spectacular levels of incompetence. We now have well over 100,000 deaths from COVID-19, not including those known but uncounted. We are only a couple of months into serious loss of life. A million deaths are not out of the question under Trump. Some 675,000  Americans died in the Spanish flu pandemic of 1918-19, one that struck hard but subsided quickly. We have, of course, no assurance that COVID-19 will do the same, and we certainly cannot depend on it. We must rather assume the worst-case scenario if we want to avoid facing it.

Trump’s initial reaction, once the reality of the virus could no longer be ignored, was a travel ban. It was late, and loose; the damage had already been done, and a general lockdown of the country was the only recourse. Trump now embraced, briefly, the role of a war president, the enemy being what he now called the “Chinese virus.” This cast a natural event, mishandled by the Chinese to be sure, as a willful assault by a wicked, alien foe, thus combining xenophobia and jingoism in classic fashion.

At the same time, Trump alternately invoked what he declared to be “total” authority in this “war” with a complete abdication of leadership in organizing and directing the lockdown, producing necessities for overwhelmed hospitals and personnel and dealing with the economic calamity of mass evictions from work. Trump’s generalship consisted of daily press briefings in which he alternately rambled and ranted, contradicting the experts he used as stage props, and going far beyond cockeyed in suggesting that the virus be treated with ingested detergent bleach or sunburn. A future age, when one happily arrives, will have the task of parsing such lunacy.

The commander-in-chief soon grew tired of his war, in which the only visible casualties were on his side. Within a couple of weeks, he simply declared victory. Easter churches were to reopen for celebratory worship, and the country was “ordered” to return to business. Contradictory to presidential opinion, Trump lacked the authority to force the country back open, and many governors, including Republicans, repined at the idea of inviting disaster. By this time, COVID-19 had become the leading daily cause of death in the United States, surpassing heart disease and cancer. But Trump could lay the blame on others for not joining his victory parade, which included military flyovers across the country assertedly to “thank” the so-called essential workers most directly in harm’s way, and to create another image of triumphant bluster. If you can’t beat ‘em, bomb ‘em. Hadn’t that been the way America had waged all its losing wars since Korea and Vietnam?

The virus was not impressed.

As the month of May progressed, Columbia University researchers released a study asserting that more than half the recorded deaths from the pandemic — 36,000, a number exceeding that of the Korean War — were attributable to the Trump administration’s failures to address it on every level. They had given the United States by far the largest number of deaths, both in gross number and per capita, of any country in the world.

To that point, the excess deaths from the virus represented mere dereliction of duty. Trump had not responded to warnings about the impending crisis, and/or aides had delayed transmitting them with sufficient urgency because of his well-known dislike of bad news, especially news that would imperil his reelection. Now, however, he was taking a deliberate step that, if followed, would virtually ensure the deaths of tens if not hundreds of thousands of Americans, with potentially uncontrolled spikes that could overwhelm the nation’s capacity to respond. Shoot ‘em dead in the middle of Fifth Avenue? Sure, why not, if that’s what reelection takes.

On its surface, such a strategy seemed suicidal. How, after all, could deaths that would force a new economic shutdown be of political benefit? But Donald Trump operates on different assumptions from yours and mine. Bet the house, and if you lose, blame someone else. It’s the principle that’s carried him through six business bankruptcies, where someone else always gets stiffed and there’s always a bank to bail you out. Trump’s wager is that summer weather will pause the virus, and the country will accept a modest excess in deaths for the benefit of a revived economy that will redound in his favor. With luck — and Donald Trump has long been the most phenomenally lucky man on earth — the real bill, when the comeback of the virus coincides with the normal onset of the flu season, won’t come due until past election day. Even then, he’ll find a way to blame others, starting with 50 state governors who simply didn’t handle things the right way and killed off a great new prosperity.

In Donald Trump’s world, there is only a sunny side to the street, and he’s the one on it. It’s a world without masks and coffins, where bad news is always someone else’s fault, and gambling with human lives is no different from gambling with chips in one of his failed casinos.

Death has a salesman in the White House.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Death has a Salesman in the White House

How the Grand Old Party Became the Grim Old Reaper

The historian Joseph J. Ellis defines a political faction succinctly as “an organized minority whose very purpose [is] to undercut the public will, usually by devious and corrupt means.” That is as precise a description as one could wish of the present-day Republican Party, so-called. What it means is that the coming November elections, if they are held, will be a contest between the one surviving political party in the country — deeply flawed, compromised and beholden to corporate interests as it is — and a cabal, now an accomplice of death itself, whose continued control of the country would threaten anything we could remotely call a democracy.

The Democrats are another matter. But the cynical marriage between political functionaries and a ruthless demagogue is a tale not told until now in our history. There was a previous near-example some 70 years ago when a junior Republican Senator from Wisconsin, Joseph McCarthy, rode the anti-Communist hysteria of the early 1950s and unleashed a four-year reign of terror that silenced dissent, destroyed lives and undermined critical American institutions. The McCarthy period kept even the war hero president Dwight Eisenhower in thrall until McCarthy finally overreached by attacking our ultimate inner sanctum, the military and sealing his fate. Then, at last, Republican senators joined Democratic ones in a vote of censure. Three years later, a broken McCarthy was dead.

The Republican Party of the 1950s was a far cry from the one that had dominated American politics from 1860 to the early 1930s.  That party, epitomized by Calvin Coolidge’s famous remark that “The business of America is business,” had long been in fealty to corporate interests, until the Great Depression brought a long and seemingly permanent generation of liberal politics to power in Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal. Between 1933 and 1969, Republicans occupied the White House for a mere eight years, and those only by courtesy of Eisenhower choosing to run as a Republican when the Democrats had themselves courted him.

As for Congress, Republicans would control it for only four years until 1994. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court, partly under political pressure, would tilt in a liberal direction as well during the middle third of the century. New Deal policies thus structured all three branches of the federal government, and Republicans (with a newly-minted liberal wing of their own) were obliged to accommodate themselves to the prevailing dispensation. When they ran unabashedly conservative Barry Goldwater for president in 1964, he lost by 16 million votes. The party of Big Business, it seemed, was history.

Of course, that last conclusion would be true only if big business itself was going somewhere. Corporate oligarchies still dominated the American economy, and their interests still dictated a party devoted if not subservient to them. The New Deal had actually rescued American capitalism in the 1930s; World War II and the Cold War had kept it busy creating what Eisenhower would dub the military-industrial complex. Together with America’s economic hegemony on the world stage, class conflict was relatively abated in the postwar years. This could not last indefinitely, however.  Other nations became competitive with us, and the twin crises of the civil rights movement and the Vietnam War had torn the country apart by the end of the 1960s. With the skills of an (evil) political genius, Richard Nixon, Republicans regained the White House in 1969. Nixon’s appointments turned the Supreme Court back to its usual position on the right. Congress would remain in Democratic hands till the mid-1990s, but six people — the president, and a five-member majority on the High Court — could give Republicans control of two of the three branches of government.  Between them, they could marginalize Congress and even render it impotent.

That, in a nutshell, has been the story of the past 50 years of American history.

Beginning in the 1970s, corporations funded conservative think tanks, advocacy groups and academic institutes to undermine the New Deal consensus, which (with the prolonged economic recession of the 1970s) rebranded big business as “job creators,” scuttled labor unions, eroded support for minority groups and made racism respectable again. Lyndon Johnson’s War on Poverty became a war on the poor as a declining middle and working class — the so-called Reagan Democrats — were coached to take their frustrations out on a service-worker underclass while what had been well-paying manufacturing jobs were exported abroad to pad corporate profits. The Democratic Party, reading from the same script, abandoned what was left of the New Deal and began to love big business, big banks and high tech.

The most significant shift for the Republicans was a new-found glorification of the presidency, which has now assumed virtually monarchical powers. The story of the Republic from its inception has been the growth of executive power, but the essential principle of conservatism, in theory at least, has been its restraint. That went definitively by the boards with Nixon’s declaration that “If the president does it, it’s not illegal,” and every Republican presidency since has essentially affirmed this nakedly despotic thesis. It was given ideological gloss a few years later in the notion of the “unitary presidency,” which proclaims that the president in himself is the Executive Branch, and most recently by Alan Dershowitz, who in his ‘testimony’ at Trump’s impeachment trial opined that if a president thinks he’s doing the right thing then what he does is beyond question. George III couldn’t have put it any better.

Which brings us to the Republicans and Trump. The reigning view, is that the Republicans have been taken captive by Trump and view him with horror. This had some initial truth. The Republicans were appalled by Trump when he ran for their nomination, not because of his manifest unfitness but because of a populist platform that called for tax increases on the rich, economic protectionism and an end to lost wars well into their second decade. Republicans had wooed workers in the 1980s with what Ronald Reagan’s vice president George H. W. Bush called “voodoo economics,” but by 2016, the scam had worn thin, and Trump was able to coopt the motley crew of angry labor, disillusioned Evangelicals, gun nuts and racists that constituted the Republican electoral base and make it his own.

Aside from protectionism, Trump seriously intended none of this but gave Republicans instead a major tax cut for the rich, a wholesale demolition of business regulations and environmental protections and an assembly-line rush of reactionary judges vetted by the Federalist Society to stack the courts for another generation.  In other words, he had kept an electoral base that was crumbling in their hands safe while gratifying the corporate barons who kept them in business in all that truly mattered. Trump had used the Republicans, but they, equally, had found use in him. His cynicism and theirs had found a common home.

There’s a bloodline stretching between McCarthy and Trump in the person of Roy Cohn, the counsel for McCarthy’s Senate investigating committee who in later life serviced the Trump business empire. More recently, a nostalgic Donald Trump had often been heard to ask, “Where’s my Roy Cohn?”, although he has now found him in William Barr. The Republicans of McCarthy’s time were willing to put up with him and take what profit it offered them.  Those of Trump’s today are, up till now, happy to do the same. The Democrats, a poor alternative, have thus far put up a miserable show. The coronavirus is a stiff cure, but maybe nothing less will do.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on How the Grand Old Party Became the Grim Old Reaper

American Amnesia: Kent State, Star Wars, and the Fourth of May

Let me begin with a confession: I know nothing about “Star Wars” except that it is a movie franchise created by George Lucas that has kept some actors, like Harrison Ford, in the air long after they should have been grounded.

What clicked with me about “Star Wars” when the first films came out was that it was a way to spread America’s fantasy about itself: that we were invariably a force for good in the world, and what could be better than to extend that force to the furthest reaches of space, conquering all the bad guys we found out there?

May the force be with you, right?

As I gather, the “force” in that phrase was really something vague and general, more or less translating as “Good luck to you.” But the force isn’t really luck. Luck is happenstance. Force is applied pressure with the intention of gaining results.

We’d tried some of that force on Earth, in real-time and in actual places. There was a country, Vietnam, that few of us had ever heard of. It was a former French colony that had gotten caught up in the Cold War while seeking independence. Vietnam was split up, like another country we knew nothing about, Korea, where we were somehow dragged into a war that wasn’t officially a war but something called a police action. It cost upwards of 40,000 American lives and several million Korean and Chinese lives, and no one won it.

Vietnam was next on the agenda. We fought there a lot longer, for no clearer reason, but this war had a more definite outcome. We lost. And we have gone on losing, in Afghanistan, in Iraq and, when this coronavirus thing is cleaned up, maybe in Iran, too.

Might as well try outer space. Ronald Reagan, the movie actor who became an actual president, thought that space was our final frontier and that we’d better militarize it before the Russians did. Donald Trump, the failed casino mogul who also became a president, thinks the same thing. He wants a Space Force. Getting a little confused (it happens to him often), he calls his current offensive against COVID-19 “Operation Warp Speed.” As in, that which is so fast it exceeds the speed of light.

Which leads, you know, to utter darkness: the place where Donald Trump has been taking us for three and a half years.

Let’s get back to Vietnam, a war most people have long since stopped thinking about if they remember it at all. It wasn’t going well, so President Nixon decided to expand it into neighboring countries Cambodia and Laos to see if he couldn’t have better luck there—as in, maybe the force would be with him in those places.

By this time, a lot of college students and others of draft age were tired of being prospective cannon fodder. The military, through its ROTC program, was an aggressive recruiting force on many campuses. At Kent State University, protests over the massive bombing that commenced the invasion of Cambodia spilled over into the college town itself. National Guardsmen were called to police the Kent State campus, without any evidence that students had been involved in acts of violence. A miscellaneous group of protesters, some students and some not, gathered on the campus grounds. Tear gas was unleashed to disperse them. Then, without provocation or warning, a 13-second rifle fusillade was fired indiscriminately into their midst.

When it was over, four students lay dead: two women, Allison Krause and Sandra Scheuer, and two men, Jeffrey Miller and William Schroeder. Nine more were wounded. America had declared war on its young, a war that, from massive student debt, mounting economic deprivation and wars without end to the casual shooting of joggers in the street, has not ceased to the present day. The logic of empire had come home: a society devouring its own.

The date was May 4, 1970. 50 years ago last week.

May the Fourth be with you.

I’m not asking that we make Kent State a day of national commemoration, though it wouldn’t be a bad idea. However, we should remember the things that have profoundly affected us and why: it’s called history. Kent State was a landmark event, and not just because of the bloodshed. It would mark the end of America’s second great rebellion. The first, familiar enough, was the Civil War, which the South initiated to preserve and extend slavery. The second was the Sixties—one that bears simply the name of its decade, the 1960s—when slavery’s successor, Jim Crow, was finally challenged on its home turf. That was when, for the first and (to this point) last time, a generation of young Americans rose up against entrenched militarism, cultural sterility and sexual repression and dared to create a world of their own.

It was a creative world, messy as all creation is, and in many ways inchoate. It never decided whether its proper engagement was on urban streets or rural communes. It wound up too often on acid. At its most focused, it was a serious and passionate attempt to realize a new vision for the country. What it didn’t have, though, were clubs and guns. The clubs were wielded by Mayor Richard Daley’s police at the Chicago Democratic Convention, where the liberalism of Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society showed its true face. The guns were fired at Kent State. Confused and undisciplined state militiamen held them. But Richard Nixon pulled the trigger.

The Vietnam War went on for five more years. The war Nixon unleashed in Cambodia would ultimately result in a genocide that killed between a quarter and a third of the country’s population.

Yes, we need to remember these things.

It’s not just a question of forgetting history—or never learning it in the first place. It’s about replacing history with fiction. The May 4 of Kent State actually happened. The May 4 of “Star Wars” is not even a fictional event, but simply an inane catchphrase tied to a calendar date. It’s the erasure of history by entertainment.

Sociologist Neil Postman wrote a book in 1985 called “Amusing Ourselves to Death.” He was warning us of the dangers of a world defined not by living but by consumption. It’s the world Donald Trump wants us to get back to as quickly as possible.

This time, the consequence may really be death.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on American Amnesia: Kent State, Star Wars, and the Fourth of May

Making the Worst Worse: Trump at Warp Speed

We weren’t ready for COVID-19, even though we could have been. Donald Trump eliminated the joint task force with China, established to get a quick jump on any potential pandemic, but we had other intelligence sources reporting on its first outbreak in Wuhan last November. We had epidemiologists and agencies trained to respond to the news and to deal urgently with the world’s latest viral threat, or so we thought.

The news got to the White House. It just didn’t get to the President, a man notoriously averse to bad news and preoccupied with his impeachment from office — a hoax perpetrated, as he told us, by his Democratic enemies in Congress. For Donald Trump, bad news is always a hoax, so how could a virus that threatened millions not be a really, really big one? And where would such a hoax come from but, once again, the Democrats?

That’s right. When Donald Trump was finally forced to shake hands with the news of COVID-19, two precious months already wasted, he called it another Democratic hoax.

No one could make this up, right? But then, no one could make up the biggest hoax of all, that Donald Trump is President of the United States. Except that, like the Coronavirus, it is all too true.

When Trump said there were only 15 cases of the virus in the United States — he referred to confirmed cases, of which there were then actually 22 — he said this was good news, and headed toward zero.

A month later, the “zero cases” were on their way past a million.

Was there no one to tell Trump that when you have one case of an epidemic you are going to have a million, and if you do nothing about it you will be getting 100 million?

Well, yes, there was. This was the number presented to Trump by his economic advisor, Peter Navarro, in late January. Navarro also mentioned that a million to two million of those infected could die. Bad for the economy. Bad, too, for Trump’s reelection, whose campaign was based on a booming economy. Bad news, period. So, of course, to be ignored.

Navarro didn’t push the issue. Neither did Alex N. Azar, head of the Department of Health and Human Services, who backed off when the boss made it clear that he wanted only happy talk from his minions. Meanwhile, the agencies supposedly on patrol were showing the results of systemic under-funding, under-staffing, and general evisceration under Trump. With the RNA of the virus finally released from China, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention started making test kits to identify and track its spread. The kits malfunctioned, not because of poor design but because of a manufacturer that failed to observe the CDC’s own protocols. How was that? The CDC is, or was, the most highly regarded epidemiological center in the world. It can’t make test kits even when it knows what it’s looking for and how the kits are supposed to function? A month was lost to this fiasco, and even now test kits fail to identify at least 30 percent of infected persons.

The Food and Drug Administration was similarly bogged down in incompetence and bureaucratic stonewalling. The directors of these respective agencies, Robert R. Redfield and Stephen Hahn, are still in their jobs. Christi Grimm isn’t. She was the Deputy Inspector General at Health and Human Services who blew the whistle on the bungled strategies and critical shortages throughout the medical supply chain that are still crippling health care delivery. Bad news, ixnay!

None of this is ancient history. Trump, after first asserting his unfettered authority over the crisis, has now dumped all direction and responsibility for it on the states, thereby unleashing pandemonium on top of a pandemic. In no other country in the world has the national government pitted itself against local ones in dealing with the greatest global health menace in a century. It is, in fact, the greatest single abdication of public service responsibility in memory, while at the same time a deliberate fomenting of chaos in a Hobbesian race to the bottom. The result is that a nation with 4 percent of the world’s population has a third of its infections from the virus.

Nor is this the worst of it. Ostensibly on the sidelines, Trump has egged on the mobs who have besieged state legislatures to “reopen” their economies, regardless of risk — including the risk posed not merely by their congregation, but by the assault weapons (and Nazi insignia) some have carried. This will ultimately kill more, as is already evident in the spike in mortality rates in states whose governors — especially Trump acolytes — have yielded to demands for the restitution of such essential services as tattoo parlors and bowling alleys. There’s no mystery in this; Trump wants to point again to a booming economy at whatever the cost in lives, and, at an even more atavistic level, to return to the demagogic mass rallies on which he feeds. What he represents — what he manifests — is contamination, pure and simple.

This seems about as bad as it can get and — for a once-great nation — is an almost inconceivable fall. But, of course, it wasn’t hard to see what was coming next. In Trump-world, the storyline is always his. If the price of goosing the economy is seeding more death, then the Donald will ride to the rescue with a wonder drug produced at “warp speed,” just in time for or shortly after the November elections. Trump had hoped to find such a drug on the quick by promoting the miraculous powers of existing ones such as hydroxychloroquine. Quack medicine being the last refuge of the scoundrel, Trump asked what we had to lose by taking it. As it turned out, the answer would be, for some, their lives; and when  Richard Bright of the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority pointed out the dangers of using an untested drug on a disease other than that for which it was prescribed, he was promptly sacked. No bad news — and no backtalk!

The latest news from the CDC is that we can expect a 50 percent or more increase in the mortality rate from the coronavirus within this month, driven by the premature social distance easings and business reopenings pushed by Trump: more from the grim reaper in the White House. But at least there’s some good news buried in the bad. Someone is still willing to speak truth to power.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Making the Worst Worse: Trump at Warp Speed

Forgot the Kool-Aid—Try Lysol Instead!

For those of you not of a certain age, a reference to drinking Kool-Aid may not ring a bell. In November 1978, 918 members of a self-styled revolutionary cult committed mass suicide on the orders of their leader, Jim Jones, mostly by drinking a cyanide-laced brew. It probably wasn’t Kool-Aid after all, but the brand name stuck. “Drinking the Kool-Aid” means believing sheer nonsense and doing something absolutely nuts.

That’s what our modern-day Jim Jones, Donald Trump, served up to a stunned press corps and a national television audience last week. He suggested that we inject disinfectant into our lungs and mainline ultraviolet light (somehow) into our bodies as a way of killing the coronavirus. The Governor of Maryland, Larry Hogan, reported that the state’s healthcare hotlines were besieged by callers asking if they should take their president’s advice. The parent company of Lysol felt obliged to issue a public statement saying that their cleaning products should not be ingested under any circumstances.

As CNN anchor Jake Tapper put it: “We’re running out of words to describe this era.” Let me try a few, though: No great nation, and probably no poor and miserable one, has ever been led by anyone combining personal vileness and unfathomable stupidity as Donald J. Trump has.

Okay, there was Elagabalus, who became emperor of Rome in the early third century at the age of fourteen, castrated himself and then demanded worship as a god. But he wasn’t elected by anybody, and he didn’t demand that anyone imitate his personal surgery.

Trump, though, is only the iceberg tip of our dysfunctionality. In the first place, he wasn’t elected to begin with but crowned by a system, unique to the U.S., that enables the loser of a presidential race to be its winner. We don’t allow our city council members to be picked that way, or anybody else. The Electoral College results that got Trump his scepter and coronet were enabled by voter suppression in key states, abetted by a court system stacked against democratic majorities. We will face the same rigged system in the fall. To call ourselves a democracy in these circumstances is something much sicker than a joke.

It is a fact that, from the day he announced his first presidential candidacy, Trump has never enjoyed majority support for a single day. George W. Bush was also a minority president, and he left office a despised one, but he did poll well in the aftermath of 9/11. Trump has never had the support of a majority of his fellow citizens on any day. In any other world but ours, that would be called a dictatorship.

On the other hand, Trump has enjoyed the consistent support of his so-called base, which has been fairly stable at or above 40 percent of the electorate. The 46 percent of voters who made Trump a president in 2016 was one thing; for many of them, he represented a brick flung at a system that they felt, with good reason, was stacked against them. That the great majority should be sticking with him into the fourth year of his term is another matter. Trump has deliberately weakened every institution of American democracy — Congress, the courts, the press, the electorate itself — with the open goal of arrogating supreme and unquestionable power to himself, and he has achieved it to an astonishing extent. He has successfully defied two of the essential powers vested in Congress by the Constitution: the power of oversight through subpoena and the power of the purse. He has largely brought the courts to heel, thanks in good part to a two-generation campaign to pack them with advocates of an untrammeled presidency. He has undermined a free press — crying “fake news” — while seeking to discredit every election that did not go his own way and even some that did.

The functioning of institutions deserves, of course, constant scrutiny and often criticism; that is how a democracy should work. But Trump has sought to discredit every democratic institution in the country, not for failing to do its job but for doing the one job basic to all of them in a system of checks and balances, namely keeping power from being monopolized in the hands of any single individual. That 40 percent of the voting population continues to support this, and the agenda of racism, sexism and xenophobia that has come with it suggests that the constituency for democracy itself is dangerously low.

I said last week that I thought Donald Trump was a plague on this country on a par with the coronavirus. At this point, I’ll have to correct myself. Donald Trump is the virus itself, and COVID-19 merely the latest and most outward expression of the damage he has wreaked on us. Yes, of course, COVID is actual, and it has been devastating everywhere. But Trump has been the principal vector of its transmission into the United States by refusing to acknowledge it to begin with, by failing to prepare for it and by failing on every level — medical, economic, political and social — to deal with it. This has meant tens of thousands of avoidable deaths, and will mean tens, if not hundreds, of thousands more. It has meant sudden unemployment for upwards of 30 million workers and looming disaster for American small businesses. Donald Trump has done his best to destroy American democracy. Now, and no less deliberately, he is doing his best to destroy the health, welfare and economy of the country as well.  COVID is not only his opportunity; it is his means.

One might reply, of course, that COVID is a disaster for Trump too, since he was planning to run for reelection on the presumed flourishing of the American economy — a lie, in fact, but just one more in his theater of lies. But Trump lives, simply, on destruction, and he has always been willing to hazard his own. If he did not wish a pandemic, he is nonetheless its agent. Having achieved the infection of every organ of our civil body politic, he now presides over the preventable spread of a disease that attacks every organ of the human body. Lysol to clean out your lungs?

Only a virus could think of that.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Forgot the Kool-Aid—Try Lysol Instead!