Author Archives | Robert Zaller

A Last Rush to Kill

In all the death that has surrounded us this year, there has been one group that has had at least partial reprieve: the inmates on America’s 29 death rows.

 

The number of executions in America has been steadily declining — California, which with more than 700 condemned prisoners has the nation’s largest death row, has not carried out an execution since 2006, and for all practical purposes is the most expensive prison warehouse in the country. It costs three times as much to keep prisoners on death row as in a general prison population, and, nationally, they are three times as likely to have their death sentences overturned on appeal or to die in captivity as to be executed. We are the last Western democracy to retain the death penalty. An estimated four percent of death row prisoners never killed anyone at all, so that probably several dozen innocent persons have been executed since the reinstitution of the death penalty by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1976.

 

If any group of people might be in line to catch a break, it’s America’s officially condemned. And they did, earlier this year — with COVID-19. To be sure, the coronavirus has been more rampant in America’s prisons than anywhere else besides nursing homes. With death raging everywhere, a tacit moratorium on executions took hold. Between Jan. 5 and March 5 of this year, there were five executions, all in the south where they are still popular. Then, as the virus took hold, executions paused until Walter Barton was executed by the State of Missouri on May 19. Barton was 68 years old. His case had been through five trials marred by suspect evidence and recanted testimony, a prime example of the injustice of the American justice system. He protested his innocence to the end.

 

The Barton case aroused controversy, but it died down as the moratorium resumed, and there were no further executions for another 50 days. Texas then executed Billy Joe Wardlow in early July, and three sudden spurts followed: three executions in a four-day period in mid-July; two within three days in late August; two more within three days in late September; and one more in mid-November. All these bundled executions came at the behest of a single man, U.S. Attorney-General William Barr, representing the only non-state capital jurisdiction in the country, the federal government.

 

Federal death penalty jurisdiction has existed particularly to prosecute acts of treason; that is, acts committed against the country as a whole. It may be surprising to learn, however, that it is now applicable to some 60 separate offenses, including espionage, terrorism, drug trafficking and the assassination of federal poultry inspectors. In no other jurisdiction in America is anyone on death row for any offense other than homicide.

 

Before Barr’s sudden scalp-hunting, federal executions were exceedingly rare, with only three in the last 50 years. Between 1972 and 1988 the federal statute had lapsed entirely, having been declared unconstitutional in 1972 and not reinstated until the last year of the Reagan administration. The country had been none the worse, or less secure, for its absence. Even after the spate of new offenses added to it by the Violent Crime and Control Act of 1994, no federal execution had taken place since 2003.

 

This did not mean that the new statute was harmless. Dzokhar Tsarnaev, the surviving brother in the Boston Marathon case, was indicted for homicide by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, but then preempted by federal prosecution that removed the case from the state court. The reason, transparently, was that Massachusetts has no death penalty; its citizens having joined the 21 other states that have renounced it. Tsarnaev was duly convicted and condemned in a show trial whose jury forewoman openly referred to him as a “piece of human garbage.” So much for criminal proceedings, states’ rights and the will of the people.

 

Barr has not explained his rush to death for the fewer than 60 condemned prisoners in his custody, but Joe Biden has announced plans to abolish the federal death penalty when he assumes office, and, unlike his former boss, Barack Obama, he now appears to look upon capital punishment in general with disfavor. Barr seems determined to kill as many of those under his control as he can manage until his own warrant expires next month.

 

Is it the worst of the worst that Barr has chosen to execute? His first execution, on July 14, was of Daniel Lewis Lee. Faith leaders from across the country pleaded for his life. So did members of the victim’s family, one of whom said that the execution would be a “pure evil” that would “dirty” her daughter’s name. Even the former trial judge and prosecutor in Lee’s case agreed that his life should be spared. Rob Dunham of the Death Penalty Information Center said that the haste with which Lee’s execution had been carried out, with legal appeals still pending, was “unlike anything in modern death penalty history.”

 

There are two more federal executions scheduled for this year, which will make 10 in all. One of them is of Lisa Montgomery, the only woman on federal death row, who was a victim of child sexual abuse and sex trafficking and suffers from hallucinations and psychosis among other maladies. The other is Brandon Bernard, who was involved in a double homicide as part of a teenage gang and whose execution, as one of his former prosecutors has written, “would be a terrible stain on the nation’s honor.” A majority of Bernard’s surviving trial jurors agree.

 

How, then, were those picked by Barr to die chosen? Robert C. Owens, who represents both Montgomery and Bernard, says that, essentially, they were “randomly selected.” And why were they chosen at all? What lies on William Barr’s heart and conscience, if either of them operates, cannot be known. But the reason for these deaths is clear enough. When protests and riots broke out across the country after the killing of George Floyd in May, Donald Trump confronted a pandemic out of control and an economy in freefall. He fell back on the last refuge of the political scoundrel to make his case for re-election, law and order. Police broke up a peaceful protest against Floyd’s death in Washington’s Lafayette Park with the use of regular military troops only narrowly averted. Federal troops were sent into Portland and elsewhere. Trump spent the summer denouncing “anarchist” cities including New York and Chicago that had willfully thrown themselves into the arms of violent revolutionaries, and threatening to occupy them.

 

As with much of Trump’s bluster, he didn’t dare back it up. But the much more sinister Barr took his cue, and, with the federally condemned prisoners for a Selektion, he has plucked 10 to die. It is indeed a stain on the nation’s honor, and — I would not dispute the characterization of Daniel Lee’s execution by Earlene Peterson — an act of evil. In a larger sense, though, Barr is in the end a mere functionary. We will have well over 300,000 Americans dead from COVID-19 before Donald Trump leaves office, and, as a Columbia University study indicated last spring, the majority of these deaths will be attributable to the ways in which Trump knowingly concealed, mismanaged and finally attempted to exploit the worst pandemic in a century for his own political advantage. That is a larger number than died in World War II. We do not know how many the virus might have killed despite all best efforts. But, whatever else his epitaph may contain, it is safe to say that Donald Trump has been the most murderous president in our history.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A Last Rush to Kill

Nancy Pelosi Plays the Long Game

If there’s one reason why Joe Biden will be occupying the White House on Jan. 20, it’s Nancy Pelosi. Whether to bless or blast her for this outcome to the 2020 elections, the most turbulent since those of the Civil War, depends on your point of view. But the game itself belonged more to her than anyone else. She had to play it skillfully, and she did. 

Pelosi is the most capable Democratic politician on Capitol Hill since the late Tip O’Neill, and arguably the best one in either legislative branch of government since Lyndon B. Johnson. Her skills are those of the backroom and the corridor; she is not a gifted orator, and her sex would have precluded any executive ambitions she might have had. She rose as high as a woman of her generation could, and she has stayed there now into her 80s. 

Her greatest achievement has been electing Joe Biden as president. 

Pelosi was not a kingmaker. Lest we forget, there were two dozen candidates for the Democratic presidential nomination this year, and the chaos of our primary system requires the wise to withhold their bets — just ask those who thought Jeb Bush had the Republican nomination sewed up in 2016. But she threw in her stake in the summer and fall of 2019, even if not in so many words. What she did, ostensibly in response to pressure from her House caucus and other leading Democrats, was to go forward with an impeachment proceeding against Donald Trump. 

Trump committing impeachable offenses was evident from the first day of his administration, and there were many who saw impeachment as the predictable and necessary end of a lawless presidency. This was not practical, however, until Democrats regained a majority in the House of Representatives in 2018, a victory widely ascribed to Pelosi’s insistence on running a national campaign based not on Trump’s many egregious offenses but on his threat to repeal Obamacare, the health care reform bill that had owed its existence to Pelosi’s steady hand eight years earlier.   

With a Democratic majority, the House could now impeach Trump — that is, present an indictment for a trial to the Senate. What Pelosi lacked, however, and what she knew she could not get, was the two-thirds majority in the Senate required to actually convict Trump and remove him from office.  

There were those who thought that the House should proceed with impeachment regardless if only to make a permanent public record of Trump’s offenses and to vindicate the honor of the Lower House of Congress at least.  

I was among them.

It seemed to me that for Congress to remain silent in the face of a man who was inarguably guilty of precisely the offenses specified in the Constitution for removal of a president was not only to leave Trump’s own abuses unrectified, but to essentially declare an imperial presidency unaccountable by law. Why, then, did Pelosi resist all pressure to bring a bill of impeachment for a year and a half?

The answer is not far to seek: no prosecutor wants to bring a case she knows she will lose. A failed impeachment would not shame a man who knew no shame and only provides further evidence of his hold on a party and a base that had become his. There was no upside to certain defeat. In Pelosi’s world, there never is. But then, well into the beginning of the 2020 campaign and seemingly past the point when by any conventional yardstick impeachment made political sense, Pelosi abruptly reversed herself. She took it upon herself to send her troops into a battle she knew they would lose.

Only one explanation will serve for that: Pelosi lost a battle for the sake of protecting her ability to win a war.

The issue that brought Pelosi into the list was the revelation that Donald Trump had attempted to bring political and military pressure on the newly elected president of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelensky, to force an investigation of alleged profiteering by Joe Biden’s son Hunter. The objective was to embarrass the senior Biden, then regarded as the frontrunner for the Democratic presidential nomination, and possibly to derail his candidacy.

It may have been the only thing that Trump and Pelosi ever agreed on, but Pelosi too thought that Biden would be Trump’s most formidable challenger in the 2020 election. To be sure, Biden had many liabilities. His long record had scars. His two previous attempts at the presidency had ended in failure, and one in disgrace. Barack Obama had edged him out of the race in 2016, judging him not of presidential caliber. He was too old.

Pelosi had known Biden for decades. She was unlikely to have harbored illusions about him. But she would not have seen in any other contender the requisite ability, experience or temperament to defeat Trump. Above all, she wished to block the candidacy of Bernie Sanders, which she with the rest of the Democratic establishment saw as disastrous. Biden, in short, had to be rescued. Turning the tables on Trump for attempting to coerce a foreign leader into intervening in an American election was the strategy for doing so.

Impeachment would be the means. Many in Pelosi’s caucus were eager to pile their long list of charges against Trump into the bill of impeachment. She saw to it that only two survived, both relating to Trump’s communications with Zelensky about Biden. The real trial of Trump would be in the House Judiciary Committee, where Trump’s attempt to defame Biden would be shown to be baseless and his own abuse of power established.

Trump’s exoneration in the Senate would be merely anticlimactic. More importantly, the onus of accusation would be off Biden and on Trump instead. Unsurprisingly, Trump treated his acquittal in the Senate as a triumph. But Hunter Biden’s service on the board of a Ukrainian energy company run by an oligarch — a dubious enough exploitation of his father’s power and influence — was never an issue again, and when Trump tried to resurrect it at the very end of his campaign it fell flat.

The impeachment had served its purpose. All this, however, was not enough to resuscitate Biden’s own badly flailing campaign, which saw him far out of the running in the first four Democratic primaries, and with Sanders accumulating what looked to many like an unstoppable momentum for the nomination. Riding to the rescue was Pelosi’s lieutenant Jim Clyburn, the House Majority Whip, who managed to bring out enough Black voters in South Carolina to give Biden his first primary victory in three presidential campaigns. This pulse, faint as it was, signaled an orchestrated rush of virtually every other candidate in the race to endorse Biden. Nothing could have been more transparent than this sudden abdication. If stopping Trump was the common objective of everyone in the Democratic Party, stopping Sanders was that of the party establishment.

There was clear unity in this, and perhaps common consensus. But only Nancy Pelosi could have thrown the switch so swiftly and so decisively. Backroom politics had triumphed as never before since the institution of the modern primary system, and never more openly. It was one of the political coups of the century.

We will never know whether Sanders could have won a race against Trump or any of the other Democratic alternatives. Joe Biden did win. It will take time to discover what this will mean for the country. It is already clear what Biden owes to Pelosi. She played the long game for him, and she took in the chips.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nancy Pelosi Plays the Long Game

After the Iceberg, Who’s on the Lifeboat?

In my last article, I suggested that America was the Titanic, already with a gash in its side. One might consider the iceberg that had struck it the COVID-19 virus, Donald Trump or some combination of both. The virus has affected at least 10 million people and likely a good many more who have been asymptomatic but still vulnerable to its ravages. It has also killed a quarter of a million more. At the same time, it would not have succeeded nearly as well in its lethality without Donald Trump, its master spreader.

Trump first dismissed the virus as a non-starter, although he was well aware of its danger from the beginning. When he finally ordered a lockdown, he sabotaged it almost from the beginning and pushed to end it far too early. He left the 50 states to fend for themselves, denying them vital resources within his power to provide. He undermined and corrupted our premier health agencies, scoffed at science itself, promoted bizarre remedies and finally walked away from the whole business just as the country was entering the most dangerous phase of its pandemic. A spreader in his own right, he turned the White House itself into a laboratory of death. He is and forever will be the human face of the virus itself.

Of course, the Trump presidency was a disaster in itself and needed no flourish from a microbe to have created the worst threat to American democracy since the Civil War. But, COVID-19 has exacerbated the very problems that brought Trump to power in the first place. As will be recalled, he masqueraded as a populist who promised to reverse the decline of the middle and working classes after half a century’s battering. In office, he handed a trillion-dollar gift to Wall Street instead. Covid has handed it a far bigger one. Our wealthiest banks, corporations and hedge funds have seen their assets soar, in part from the looting of relief funds theoretically designed to assist small businesses and furloughed workers. When the real Titanic sank, the code of the sea was honored: women and children first. When disaster strikes on land, however, particularly economic disaster, the reverse occurs: the most vulnerable suffer first, hardest and most lastingly. The pandemic depression has been no exception. And it hurt all the harder because, for four months and counting, there has been no further relief from Washington — even relief that makes the rich richer.

When I wrote on the eve of the election last week, I envisioned three scenarios: that Trump or Biden would win narrowly or that Biden would win decisively. We now know the outcome. Biden’s victory was narrow, and appears at the moment not to include a Senate majority. It is also apparent that Trump was prepared for this, intellectually at least, and had mapped out a strategy to meet it. His relentless disparagement of mail-in ballots was meant to encourage Democrats to use them, and in this he succeeded. The result was the largely Republican in-person vote on Election Day, which was recorded as it was cast, gave the illusion of a Trump victory. At that point, Trump claimed re-election, only to caution in the same breath that it was being stolen from him by fraud and that the counting of mail ballots should stop at once in blue states. How do you win despite losing? Trump was about to give the country a master class on the subject. To understand the demonstration, you had to understand the meaning of “victory” in Trump’s vocabulary. In a sporting event or an election, victory is clear-cut: you get more goals, points or votes than your opponent. The result is conclusive. In Trump’s world, the world of business, you lose one day only to fight again the next, by fair means or foul. Defeat is only a setback; bankruptcy — a specialty of Trump’s — merely a tactic. You never lose unless you quit; you go to court instead.

And this, even while claiming victory, was what Trump announced he would do — in his case, to the Supreme Court, whose impregnable conservative majority he had just confirmed. Oh, but the Supreme Court, the ultimate guardian of our law? Yes, that court, the same one that had handed the presidency to George W. Bush in 2000 on the basis of a single vote, that of the Justice Sandra Day O’Connor, who had openly proclaimed that the election of Al Gore would be a disaster for the nation. Trump may or may not get to the Supreme Court, and the Court may or may not give him the presidency. That wouldn’t be his last throw, though. Truth, in Trump-world, is not what the facts show or what others believe, but what you can persuade them to accept. Trump continues to hold an extraordinary grip on his base of support, and he will attempt to maintain it out of office.

The immediate issue, however, is what he might do while still in it. Here, we are at a moment of Constitutional peril. We will be dealing for the next 10 weeks with a warped and narcissistic personality, without a shred of decency or concern for the common good, reeling daily from a humiliation he cannot accept or avoid and yet still fully vested with powers enjoyed by no one else on earth. It is impossible to predict where such a situation might lead such a man. We have once before faced such a crisis, and though we survived it we dare not forget it. When Richard Nixon, facing the inevitability of removal from office, was plainly in the throes of emotional and physical collapse, his Defense Secretary, James Schlesinger, gave secret instructions to the Joint Chiefs of Staff that no presidential order to the military was to be obeyed unless countersigned by Schlesinger himself. It was true then, and true now that the president has the sole authority to initiate a nuclear strike.

The issue arose most recently when Trump came out of Walter Reed Hospital after treatment for his own case of COVID-19 with dexamethasone still in his system, a drug whose effects can include paranoia and delusion that may lead to manic behavior. Given the general instability of Trump’s personality, any further dislocation of it could, patently, be fatal. I might add that Trump has just fired his own Defense Secretary, Mark Esper. The military has, more or less, pledged to stay out of the current political crisis, but one must assume that these matters are under serious discussion and that contingency plans have been made. If the Commander-in-Chief issues an illegal or irrational order, it will be the generals’ decision how to respond.

There are many other things of course that Trump might attempt short of Armageddon that could do immense harm. He could hold rallies of the faithful and foment domestic violence. He could declare emergencies and rule by decree. He could try to declare the presidential election void. Our final crisis with Richard Nixon lasted about ten days. Donald Trump has ten weeks in office. It is that time that will truly test our democracy.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on After the Iceberg, Who’s on the Lifeboat?

All Aboard the Titanic

As I write this article on Election Eve, it seems utterly in doubt who will win the presidency. It may be no more certain by the time it is posted. Donald Trump, who challenged an election result he won four years ago, will contest one he loses now. However that might fare in the courts, he will have supporters to call upon in the streets if the fanaticism they have displayed thus far is any indication.

Trump explained all this to us before, when he divided the human race into winners (the self-selected few) and losers (the dumbo many). The person absolutely chosen for the former category was Trump himself. There can be no bigger a win than in a presidential race. Ergo, Trump has no choice but to win — and we to grant him that victory, one way or another. Most of us accept the fact that we sometimes win, sometimes lose and often enough wind up in the gray middle. If that’s not an acceptable premise, then you can’t live in a democracy. Donald Trump doesn’t live in one, but by the “Alice in Wonderland” system (unique to America) in which you can win an election with fewer votes than your opponent, he is and has been for four years our leader.

Logically, then, we either live in a democracy and Trump is not our leader, or we don’t and Trump is our leader. Since most of us check off both positive boxes in the affirmative, we confess to living in absurdity. No wonder we are experiencing a collective headache. It’s very hard to affirm a contradiction. The cure for such a problem, as I devoutly hope a majority of my fellow countrymen agree, is an election that decisively votes Trump out of office.

Trump will never accept this result, but if enough others do, that will be his problem, not ours. Not everyone necessarily will do so either, of course, and if the election is close, Trump will have a battalion of lawyers and a stable of politicians at his disposal — not to mention the ultimate backstop of the Supreme Court. None of these individuals may actually believe that Trump has won, but all will find it to their advantage to say so. That is called corruption, and although corruption is always present in the body politic just as bacteria is in one’s gut, it is the death of democracy in its terminal phase.

The above scenario is a real possibility. But the damage to government has, in essence, been done. We are not simply in danger of losing our democracy; it has already been missing for four years. Congress has been neutered: unable to enforce subpoenas, control the public purse or remove a demagogue. The Supreme Court has consistently enabled a lawless executive. The Executive Branch has itself been compromised beyond recognition. True, we have had a steady erosion in our politics for some time, and Trump has been seen as a culmination of it, however unexpected. But that a personality both psychopathic and sociopathic — someone whose vision of reality is entirely a function of ego and whose attitude toward others is purely exploitive — should come to the helm of the nation was as startling as its consequences have been dire.

Much has been made not only of Trump’s sheer lawbreaking but also of his failure to observe the ordinary norms and guardrails of the democratic process. That misses the point. Trump has sometimes been forced to retreat temporarily by circumstances. He recognizes, however, no valid impediment to his will and no rule of either law or custom as anything but an obstacle to be ignored, circumvented or smashed through. That’s more than demagoguery. It is, simply, the definition of a tyrant.

Because there is still an opposition, although Trump regularly accuses it of treason; because there is still a free press, although Trump accuses it of uttering only the lies he himself is guilty of and because the courts are still open, although Trump continually seeks to obstruct and intimidate them, we are insufficiently attentive to the enormous structural damage he has done to the Republic. In a democracy, politicians have agendas, ambitions and interests, but they recognize the same elements in others and pursue their goals accordingly.

Trump may bestow favors, but he never compromises. In his world, no will exists but his own. It is for this reason that Trump makes the claims that others take as absurd boasts but which he intends with all seriousness. He means it when he says that he produced the greatest economy in world history, or that he has done more for African-Americans than anyone with the possible exception of Abraham Lincoln, or that he has done a “tremendous” job of coping with the COVID-19 crisis and none better.

Perhaps these are jests at the same time, but only in the sense that no stable reality exists for Trump to measure them by and that whatever he thinks or utters at any given moment is, for him, the sole measure of truth. Put up with this for four years, and it may take 40 to undo it; put up with it for four more and it may be too late at all. Nearly half the country supports Trump, and many have learned to mimic his mindset and behavior. These habits will be hard to quit, and the grievances they sustain difficult to redress.

Both America and the world are on the cusp of a series of interlocking crises: climate change and ecological devastation; human overpopulation and species extinction; nuclear proliferation; interlocking monopoly and global inequality; racial violence and the degradation of work. If Joe Biden can win the presidency and get through to Jan. 20, we will have in office a mediocre product of the system that gave us Donald Trump in the first place. We need better, much better — but first, we must avoid the worst.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on All Aboard the Titanic

How America Should Govern Itself

Until the 20th century, only two states in the modern world had attempted to devise a government from scratch: Haiti and the United States. Haiti has not fared well, and was occupied by the United States between 1915 and 1934. The thirteen American states, after rebelling against Great Britain, only barely kept together a rag-tag national army under George Washington. With victory in sight, they adopted a governing compact, the Articles of Confederation, which ceded so little authority to a central government as to leave the new country not only vulnerable to interstate disputes but to reconquest.

Agreeing on little else, the newly-fledged states decided to revise their compact. The result, shrouded in secrecy until it was announced, was the American Constitution. When asked what its nature was, its senior author and statesman, Ben Franklin, famously replied: “A republic, if you can keep it.” A republic can be many things, and in America it has been. The Constitution vested sovereignty, exercised through representative government, in the free white males of the country — “We, the people.” But governors, and, until 1913, United States senators, were elected by state legislatures, not by popular vote. Not for most of its history did the U.S. describe itself as a democracy, or govern itself with anything like a majority.

Nonetheless, the long-term arc of American history has been toward democracy as a political and civil culture. Abraham Lincoln called it that, defining democracy as government of, by and for the people, and added that whatever differed from that ideal, to the extent of the difference, was “no democracy.” No American ever spoke more challenging words. Lincoln was daring us to become a democracy, and to accept the risks, responsibilities and rewards of such a polity. Now, as 2020 moves toward an unpredictable end, that question is before us as it has not been for a long time.

The three branches of our government are in serious disarray. We can begin with the branch stipulated by the Constitution as the primary and most responsible one, Congress. Congress was vested with the power to make laws with (but if need be without) the president; to raise federal taxes and appropriate all funds collected; to declare war and approve terms of peace; and to supervise the conduct of the other two branches, and if need be remove judges, justices, cabinet officers, the president and the vice president from office.

The Founding Fathers set up a system of checks and balances to regulate government, but if there was any single center of sovereignty in the system it was in the two houses of Congress. Congress has lost, abandoned or seen vitiated its critical powers. Laws are largely written today by the executive branch, and those are critically shaped by private lobbying interests operating out of sight. Congress has not declared war since 1941, nor deliberated about peace since 1921. The executive branch expends funds with no effective oversight, and the Supreme Court has recently declared that the president may divert appropriations to projects specifically rejected by Congress, a ruling that goes far to negate its power of the purse altogether. Donald Trump has regularly defied subpoenas for testimony by Cabinet officers and others, although the chief such officers are appointed by and hence directly responsible to the houses of Congress.

The largest problem currently faced by Congress and the country as a whole is that our two-party system no longer exists. Although the emergence of political parties in the 1790s alarmed the Founding Fathers, it has been the practical basis of government ever since, and since the 1850s the same two parties, Republican and Democratic, have dominated our electoral process. This is no longer the case. The Republican Party has long ceased to operate within a democratic framework. As a minority interested in serving wealth and power, it has systematically worked to suppress voting, and, with Trump, to disparage and even delegitimize the electoral system as such. It is a cabal, and, with Trump, has become the enabler of a cult. Its near-unanimous refusal to remove him from office last February despite gross evidence of impeachable crimes was its final abdication of public responsibility.

The Democrats are no paragons of virtue, but there are at least dissenting voices among them that represent general interests. The executive branch of government has worked to extend its powers at the expense of Congress and the courts since the time of George Washington, and it has been nearly fifty years since any serious attempt was made to curb its overreach. That this has led us to the brink of dictatorship in Donald Trump should come as no surprise, even if his personal vulgarity and indecency continues to astonish us every day.

The Supreme Court has become the focus of discussion at the moment because of Republican efforts to pack it, as well as the federal court system as a whole. But the Court has long been a regressive institution, devoted to defending so-called property rights beginning with the “right” of slavery. Further, it has exercised a usurped power to undo legislative statutes for more than 200 years, a power nowhere suggested in the Constitution and claimed by no other judicial body I know of. It, too, is in urgent need of reform.

What, then, should be done? The largest problem of our politics is not in the present imbalance in our system of checks and balances but in the flood of private money, and therefore private interest, that distorts and corrupts every aspect of it. In a capitalist system, this is hardly surprising, and Illinois’ senior senator, Dick Durbin, only spoke candidly when he described the body he serves as a wholly-owned subsidiary of the banking system. The Supreme Court, however, removed virtually all restraint on our cash and carry politics with its 2010 decision in Citizens United that defined money as free speech. In a word, getting rid of corporate lobbyists and breaking up the monopolies they serve, is job one. It’s primarily the job of Congress to rein in the presidency. It must reclaim the powers it has lost, notably regular oversight and strict control of the purse and of war-making powers.

Congress itself, though, must look to its own houses: forbid gerrymandering districts in the House of Representatives and create a Senate in line with the Lower House, namely where each state is entitled to at least one seat but where representation is otherwise apportioned on the basis of population. (Whether a Senate is actually necessary or desirable is another matter.) Term limits on Supreme Court justices would, among other things, equalize the balance of seats to be filled on the recommendation of any one president. Presidents should be required to fill all federal vacancies promptly, and the Senate to deliberate on them within a date certain of submission.

The Supreme Court should have the responsibility to advise Congress of difficulties in the law and remedies for them, but under no circumstances to invalidate statutes. Executive orders by the president should be limited in scope and duration, and subject to Congressional review. War, of all things, should never be declared by one man or one woman, but only by the people’s representative as the Constitution demands. And, of course, we should abolish the Electoral College. Congress, in particular, will have a lot of hard work to do if these proposals are adopted, and will need to call directly on the services of nonpartisan federal agencies for expertise. This will mean a closer, more structural relation between the executive and legislative branches, with hopefully more responsible conduct by both.

It can work, clearly, in a parliamentary system of government, toward which we might possibly evolve. The larger question is whether democracy as such is compatible with the devices and imperatives of capitalism, or for that matter planetary survival. But, baby steps first.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on How America Should Govern Itself

Coming Down to the Wire

The New York Times has just invited its readers to send letters predicting the winner of the Nov. 3 election. Or maybe it should call itself The Las Vegas Times? The Times’ editorial page has done strange things lately, but this I’ll say by way of reply: I’ll save my bets for the horses. This election is too serious for sport.

I have already cast my ballot. My choices were between a candidate several magnitudes below the level of endurance, intellect and integrity needed for the presidency, and an incumbent who must absolutely be driven from office. You can probably guess whom I voted for. I hope you do the same.

There are three possible outcomes for the election, each with its own load of disaster. Donald Trump might win the election narrowly, confounding the experts and the pollsters as he did in 2016. Joe Biden could win, with perhaps a decisively larger margin but not an unchallengeable one. Or Biden could win in a landslide that no one could plausibly dispute.

If Trump wins, the country as we know it will probably not survive. Its civil institutions have been ruthlessly politicized and corrupted in the past four years by a demagogue with no concept of — let alone respect for — the law. Half the country is implacably opposed to his continuance in office, and civil disobedience or worse might well ensue. The country is hurtling toward a crisis with its pandemic, and Trump has well demonstrated his complete incapacity to deal with it. The whole country may well find itself spending a winter in Valley Forge, with no spring in sight.

If Biden wins by a merely modest margin, Trump will unquestionably challenge the result. Since 50 states vote separately, each with its own protocols, the opportunities for litigation will be legion. The goal, as already announced, will be to get the election to the Supreme Court as in 2000. With the new justice, Amy Coney Barrett, certain not to recuse herself, the Court will have a six-to-three Republican majority. The outcome will be foregone, as will the resistance to it. The military may have to settle the matter, its stated refusal to do so notwithstanding. The Constitution, in any event, will never be the same.

If Biden’s victory is a landslide, Trump may well not concede defeat, as suggested recently by Barton Gellman in The Atlantic. What would happen then is anyone’s guess. Trump might try to raise a party from among his base, backed by right-wing militias. His Cabinet might or might not support him, or be split. It might or might not invoke the 25th Amendment to strip him of his powers, or be divided on that question as well. Congress, itself divided, is by no means certain to act. Here, too, the military may find itself compelled (or tempted) to intervene.

Alternatively, Trump might neither claim victory nor concede defeat, but simply refuse to collaborate in a transition while declaring the election to have been rigged, as he has already contended it has been. Or he might use this stance to negotiate a pardon, including a promise to drop all pending or prospective suits in state courts.

Whatever Trump does or does not do, he will have 11 weeks remaining in his term. His powers as president will be fully intact. He could proclaim a state of emergency, and declare martial law. He could start a war with Iran, or with China. He could start World War III. As president-elect, even if certified by the Electoral College as his duly elected successor, Joe Biden would have no powers at all.

In other words, the days between Nov. 3 and Jan. 20 shape up to be among the most perilous in our history. Nor would the disturbances they portend end with Inauguration Day. Biden would have had little or no assistance in a transition; the intelligence given him might be inadequate, misleading or false. He may have a set of crises on his desk bequeathed by a chaotic interregnum, or by hostile powers exploiting American disarray. And he will likely have a pandemic at its height, with any response to it paralyzed at the national level.

We have had presidents incapacitated before: Grover Cleveland with cancer; Woodrow Wilson with a stroke; a dying Franklin D. Roosevelt at the end of World War II; a senile Ronald Reagan. The only thing comparable to what we will face with a post-election Donald Trump however are the last days of Richard Nixon’s presidency. Nixon did not suffer a public breakdown. As we now know, however, he was drinking heavily, talking to White House portraits, and collapsing emotionally with those who, like Alexander Haig and Henry Kissinger, were trying to steer his exit from office. But Nixon had little more than a week between the Supreme Court’s order that he surrender the Watergate tapes and his forced resignation. Trump will have his 11 weeks. Nixon had a certain reserve of character that enabled him to see things through. I would be hard-pressed to find in Trump anything describable as character, unless extreme narcissism, pathological mendacity and utter indifference to ethical norms and human values be considered as such.

We have wasted a great deal of time in this country. The past 50 years, starting from the first Earth Day in 1970, have not protected our planetary environment but considerably devastated it as a place habitable for us. This has not been America’s sole doing, of course; much of the worst destruction has been done in Asia. As the world’s hegemon, however, we have failed utterly at climate leadership, and under Trump we have been merely a retrograde force. We have taken major steps back from social justice, and our race problem is more exacerbated than in decades. Our infrastructure is shockingly decayed. We have calamitously misjudged our responsibilities in the world and our evolving society at home. This has not been the fault of one political party but of both, and of our collective judgment as a people. And it is not news, but something long obvious.

Most incoming presidents have a brief honeymoon — the difference between hope and reality — and perhaps a year to succeed or fail at an agenda. Joe Biden, if elected and inaugurated without severe controversy, will have in COVID the severest public health crisis in a century, and a correspondingly large economic one. Much of his energy will go in dealing with it, and in the arduous job of restoring respect for America abroad among friends and foes alike. Far too little will be available for dealing with the catastrophe of climate change, already upon us and brooking no further delay.

Welcome to 2020. It is not the year about to end. It is the long year about to begin.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Coming Down to the Wire

Philip Guston–Now or Never?

It’s been a bad time for just about everybody (Wall Street executives and drug company kingpins aside) but particularly for the arts. Airlines get bailed out, but no one thinks of helping Broadway, which has just canceled its season again. In more civilized societies, the performing arts are state-subsidized and great cultural institutions are not left to the whim of donors.

It’s been hard on the visual arts, too. Major shows on which museums rely on for much of their income have been canceled, and some (notably the Brooklyn and Baltimore museums) have been led to sell important works to meet maintenance costs — a practice hitherto stringently forbidden.

However, one show, already postponed, was scheduled for its opening this fall at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, with three other stops scheduled in London and the U.S. This was “Philip Guston Now,” the first large retrospective of the late Canadian-born American painter in 15 years. Guston’s story is a remarkable one, and this much-anticipated show was, for a variety of reasons, to be particularly significant.

It still will be, but for a very wrong reason — one that speaks to the miserable moment we now find ourselves in. It’s been canceled, at least for the present, and not (as with other shows) because of the pandemic. The reason, in this case, is censorship born of ignorance and gutlessness.

Guston grew up in Los Angeles in the 1920s, when the Ku Klux Klan was at its height. His first major painting, “Conspirators,“ depicted a giant Klan figure from behind, holding a concealed club. The intention was clear, and Guston’s politics, which were very much of the left, were further demonstrated in the murals he made for the Works Progress Administration in the later 1930s. With others of his generation, Guston abandoned figurative painting to embrace abstract expressionism in the 1950s. I knew him as one of that school when, opening a literary journal one day, I saw a suite of paintings by him unlike anything I’d ever seen by him or anyone else.

Abstract expressionism had, by this time, yielded to pop art, which reinstated figural representation. Guston, who appeared to have banished images wholly from his work, now returned to them, but with a ferocity nowhere seen before in his art and seldom anywhere else since Goya. I felt at once that he had captured the Sixties’ racially-charged violence, which he characterized by once again depicting Klansmen still on the American stage. These new Klan figures, however, while still menacing, were also goofy, as if they represented a repressed absurdity coming back to life.

I searched out Guston exhibitions after that, became friendly with his dealer David McKee and began to write about him. Most major critics dismissed him as someone who had betrayed his art, but opinion finally began to catch up with him, and I came to see the continuity between his abstract and figural work as a synthesis rather than a break.

Other artists found inspiration in him, and he was recast as a major figure — in fact, one of the leading artists of the second half of the 20th century, and one of permanent importance. The centennial of his birth seven years ago was noted, but not with the kind of retrospective I thought might be expected.

So when the present National Gallery show was announced, I awaited it eagerly. Its title, “Philip Guston Now,” promised not only a reckoning of his accomplishments but of his continuing relevance to today’s art.

This is the show that is now on hold — not deep-sixed, but postponed for a ridiculous four years, till 2024. Was the problem security? Financing? Trouble getting or insuring the requisite loans from other institutions and private collectors? No. None of the above. And it isn’t any trouble with the work of Guston’s early or middle years. It’s the Klansmen.

Say what? The comment by one of the National Gallery’s eminent trustees, Ford Foundation President Darren Walker, sums up the position it has taken with admirable if inane candor:

“What those who criticize this decision do not understand is that in the past few months the context in the U.S. has fundamentally and profoundly changed on issues of incendiary and toxic racist imagery in art, regardless of the virtue or intention of the artist who created it,” Walker said.

Mr. Walker is presumably referring to the killings of Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, George Floyd and the other attacks by police and vigilantes against African Americans and other minority groups that have climaxed the Trump presidency. If one were viewing the canceled exhibit through these eyes with a scintilla of intelligence, however, it would be a conclusive argument for regarding “Philip Guston Now” as more critically important to the national conversation about race and diversity than at any time in the past 50 years — far more so, I daresay, than its organizers and sponsors could have imagined when they conceived it.

No one with eyes in his head could look at look at any of Guston’s Klan figures without seeing the anger, disgust and ridicule in their creator: an anger born of understanding in them the rampant violence of a damaged and divided nation. They were relevant to the climate of the late 1960s and early 1970s, and are no less so half a century later to a society still riven by racial fear and animosity.

Mr. Walker himself is patently part of the problem. He inferentially calls Guston a racist for producing images that are “incendiary,” “toxic” and “racist” as such. Does he seriously mean that looking at them is likely to inspire viewers to burn crosses or resort to lynching? If so, then the logic of his position is that “Philip Guston Now” not be sanitized, as proposed, by adding captions to place it in “context,” but that it be canceled altogether. Cowardice, hypocrisy and sheer moral (not to say aesthetic) blindness could hardly go further.

Happily, the postponement of the show has been met with outraged protest by leading artists, curators and critics. But the damage has been done. A great American artist’s integrity has been called into question, and a great American museum has besmirched itself. Perhaps worst, we have all lost, at least for the present, the opportunity to see ourselves in a mirror of conscience at a moment when we badly need it. Call that more of Donald Trump’s legacy. But don’t lay it all on him. We all have a share in the disgrace.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Philip Guston–Now or Never?

Of Loser Suckers and Heroes

The United States has never fought a foreign war it could not probably have avoided. The War of 1812 against England was driven by so-called war hawks who eyed territorial expansion in Canada. The Mexican-American War was provoked by us with the clear intention — called “Manifest Destiny” — of conquering what is now the American Southwest and Pacific coast. The Spanish-American War was intended to complete the dismantling of the Spanish Empire that began with the Monroe Doctrine by taking Cuba and the faraway Philippine Islands. President Woodrow Wilson promised American neutrality in World War I, only to back the Allies financially and militarily from its outset and, five months after winning reelection on the slogan of “He kept us out of war,” declaring war on Imperial Germany. The attack on Pearl Harbor by Japan was the culmination of nearly a hundred years of American expansion in the Pacific which made conflict there inevitable. Protecting that sector of our postwar empire in Europe, the Middle East and Southeast Asia led us into wars in Korea and Vietnam, though no nation had attacked us. The Afghan War, which still continues, was a diversion from dealing with the real state actor involved in the 9/11 attacks, Saudi Arabia. The Iraq War, which destabilized the entire Middle East and led to several failed states, was based on a bald-faced lie. It is arguable, at least, that no American soldier need ever have died fighting on foreign soil.

We have recently heard that, while in Europe two years ago to commemorate the centennial of the end of World War I, Donald Trump declined to visit the American military cemetery at Aisnes-Marne because his hair might be mussed in the rain, and described the 1,800 soldiers who fell at the Battle of Belleau Wood as losers and suckers. One expects anything of the crudity and inhumanity of Trump, but that all but exceeded imagination.

Soldiers who die in bad and unnecessary wars, as most of ours have been, deserve the elemental regard we give to all those who have lost their lives in battle: the respect due to the fallen. We may regret, and bitterly, the reasons why they fell, and the lives they perhaps took before losing their own; we may, as humanists or pacifists, regret all war. But we do not sneer at their graves.

Trump’s indecency does, however, raise a question. What, generically, should we call soldiers who die in battle? The war that absorbed my generation was Vietnam. It was a war that seemed to many who opposed it not only wrong but wicked. The soldiers who returned alive from it were sometimes greeted with scorn and hostility, or at least suspicion. We had all heard of atrocities such as My Lai, and knew them to be only the tip of an iceberg. We could not, looking at any returning veteran, fail to wonder what he might have done in the war. We could not, also, help being ashamed for all the veterans, and for ourselves.

I never abused a veteran; I understood all who had fought in Vietnam, many against their will, as abused themselves. It nonetheless took me some time to regard them as my fellow countrymen again. I say this with some shame of my own. I’m not sure just how to describe the veterans who come home from our wars today. “Ex-servicemen” doesn’t seem to cut it. Those who come home with what we call PTSD — “shell-shock” was the more graphic World War I term — might be thought of as victims in some sort, as I finally thought of Vietnam veterans. But that’s sort of patronizing too, and it erases an important distinction, namely the one between soldiers who fight and civilians who suffer.

As for those who come back in body bags, they are of course the fallen. But that description, which applies generically to those lost in all wars, doesn’t seem satisfactory either. There is one term, though, that as used nowadays seems particularly self-serving and offensive, at least to me. I refer to the universal characterization of our war veterans as heroes. A hero, in my book, is someone who saves or protects others at risk to him or herself in circumstances we regard as praiseworthy. Not all such deeds meet this criterion. A bank robber who rescues his fellow robbers from capture is daring, but not heroic. Typically, we regard one of our own soldiers who singlehandedly kills or captures many of the enemy as a hero. But an enemy soldier who does the same to our soldiers is simply an enemy. We may recognize such a soldier as brave, but we do not regard him as heroic. The circumstances define our judgment. The act cannot simply be courageous or even self-sacrificing. The cause, when there is one, must be just.

When everyone is defined as heroic in a war by the mere fact of having participated in it, however, the idea loses any capacity to denote individuals, and applies itself simply to the war as such. If all the wars we fight are heroic — that is, just, necessary, and, as all such wars must be, ultimately triumphant — then, ipso facto, there can be nothing but heroes fighting them. This — the unspeakable vulgarity aside — is what made Trump’s dismissal of the war dead at Belleau Wood so shocking.

He was saying they had wasted their lives in a war not only without gain to themselves but anyone else, profiteers excepted. It was a horrible way to speak the truth, but, especially coming from this Prince of Liars, it conveyed truth. World War I was a suicidal war for all concerned, and it begat nothing but a bigger, deadlier war 20 years later. Had we ourselves not fought in it, it would probably have ended in a negotiated settlement, and World War II might have been averted.

The dead at Belleau Wood were part of a tragedy, not an achievement. Some of them may indeed have been valorous, but their deeds died with them, and they were, in the longer perspective of history, in vain. It does not honor those who have fallen in our current wars in Afghanistan and Iraq to call them heroes, but the reverse: it exploits them.

A principal case in point is the well-known story of Pat Tillman, the NFL tackle who, turning down a multimillion-dollar contract to enlist in the Afghan War, was purportedly killed by enemy fire in 2004. Tillman was posthumously lionized as the ideal American patriot, who voluntarily gave up fame and fortune to fight for his country. But the Taliban hadn’t killed him. After an elaborate coverup that involved the war’s senior commanding generals, his death was found to have come from friendly fire in the heat of combat. This was embarrassing, but not the actual story either. The pattern of wounds on his body indicated that he had been shot at close range, not in battle. His body armor was burned to conceal evidence, and his diary, now believed to have documented his disillusionment and disgust with the war, was confiscated. He was, in fact, planning to denounce it. That was unacceptable. All evidence now points to the bitter conclusion of Tillman’s father: “They blew up their poster boy.”

It is now sixteen years since Tillman’s death, and nineteen since the war in Afghanistan began. Since it is a heroic war, filled with heroes like Pat Tillman, it can only end in victory; but since it has in fact long been lost, its only option is to continue. Even heroes may tire of that. American politicians, so far, have not.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Of Loser Suckers and Heroes

The Man Who Came to Dinner

A very funny play, called “The Man Who Came to Dinner,” had a two-year run on Broadway in 1939-1940; it enjoyed international success and became an acclaimed movie. The plot concerned an overbearing media personality who was invited to a family dinner, never leaves and completely disrupts the household.

Sound familiar? Even prophetic? But in this year’s run, it isn’t the least bit funny. In the original script, one family suffers. In the new production, the world’s oldest democracy stands on the brink of extinction. Democracy has never been an easy achievement, and it is never guaranteed. You have to work at it, exercise it and often fight for it.

It’s set up to involve a series of regular contests called elections. The winner, when certified, assumes office for a specified term. The loser, if in office, leaves. That is a bedrock foundation for any democracy. Sometimes the results are disputed, as in our presidential elections of 1824, 1876 and 2000. In each of those cases, the actual winner of the popular vote was the ultimate loser of the election. This is an outcome we owe to the Founding Fathers, who created what now seems a very strange institution, the Electoral College, to ensure that democracy didn’t get carried away with itself.

In each of them, however, a winner was eventually declared, and the loser, however reluctantly, accepted the verdict. None of these cases, however, involved an incumbent who would be obliged to vacate office if defeated. And no incumbent, prior to the present one, has ever announced his intention to remain in office whether elected or defeated.

But Donald Trump, the showman who corruptly inveigled his way into the presidency four years ago, has gone his tyrannical predecessors one better. He does not claim that he will win the election a little over a month from now, nor does he concede that he may lose it. He suggests, rather (Trump rarely says anything directly), that no winner or loser can be certified in the prescribed way because the election will have been rigged.

There is a certain consistency in Trump’s position, but it has only become apparent now. He not only claims that an election he might lose would be rigged, but that the actual election he won four years ago was rigged as well. Rigged if you win, rigged if you lose? How can that be? Oh, Trump did claim that he’d won the 2016 election, by virtue of his Electoral College majority. But he also claimed to have won the popular vote, which by official tabulation had gone to Hillary Clinton by nearly three million. In fact, he claimed to have won that vote by Clinton’s own margin, the difference being votes improperly cast or suppressed in Blue States with the presumed connivance of Democratic state officials.

When challenged to prove his claim, Trump set up an executive commission, nominated by himself, to find the missing votes of his majority. It sat for several months, found nothing, issued no report, and was quietly disbanded. That didn’t mean there had not been funny business in the election. Trump knew whereof he spoke. The difference was that the chicanery was on his own side, with Republican secretaries in the battleground states purging the rolls of likely Clinton voters and reducing the number of polling stations in minority districts to give him razor-thin majorities.

Then there was the matter of Russian interference, openly solicited by Trump and working entirely to his benefit. The Russians are back this year, and so are Republican state operatives. In Trump’s world, every election is rigged because all sides cheat as much as they can — just as they do in his business deals. The suckers vote, or think they do. The gamesters decide who wins.

You wouldn’t be hearing a peep about that this year though, but for one inconvenient fact: Trump, his best efforts notwithstanding, is poised to lose. Therefore he must discredit the election in advance, with every resource and stratagem in his power.

If Trump can’t plausibly claim to win at the ballot box, then he must find another way in, and stall the process until he does. He’s already made clear how he intends to do that. In 2000, victory in the state of Florida was delayed by a recount of votes that ran up against a deadline for certification. Although the Florida Supreme Court ruled that the recount must proceed, its jurisdiction was usurped by the U.S. Supreme Court, which in so doing awarded the election to George W. Bush. This year, the large volume of mail ballots that will be cast in deference to the pandemic will offer far more opportunity for legal challenge and delay, making the U.S. Supreme Court—where an even larger partisan majority than in 2000 will be sitting — even more likely to be the final arbiter. And Trump has already called the toss: he says, quite openly, that the Supreme Court, not the electorate, will once again decide the presidency.

Of course, whether the Supreme Court does or doesn’t interfere in the election again is not simply at Trump’s command. The ultimate point of the suggestion is the notion that citizens themselves can no longer be trusted to elect their leaders because the process as such has been corrupted — “rigged” — to such an extent that no true count can result. Trump cannot leave office because he can have no valid successor. And, because of that, he must not only remain for a second term but indefinitely, because future elections will be equally corrupt. Logically, then, he must be president for life.

This is not merely a suppositional deduction. Trump has repeatedly voiced his admiration for fellow autocrats — Putin in Russia, Xi Jinping in China and Erdogan in Turkey — who have consolidated their reigns beyond any power of recall, and mused often about extending his authority indefinitely. He makes such comments “wittily,” but if you joke enough about something it’s fair to conclude that you’re as dead serious as you dare to admit. Trump is on record as saying that the Constitution gives the president the right to do anything he wants, and he thus regards the rule of law, like the payment of taxes, as something inapplicable to him. In short, he is a king in his own mind: and kings don’t leave their thrones.

In actuality, Donald Trump is nobody. He ran for president four years ago by means that disqualified him from office. He has violated the oath he should never have been permitted to take in every way thinkable. He is not running for election, because someone who, as Barton Gellman puts it in the current Atlantic, would not now and will not ever concede defeat, cannot possibly claim such a thing as victory.

It would be comical if it were not so tragic, and tragic if it were not so comical. So call it what it is: absurd.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Man Who Came to Dinner

Little Boy and Fat Man at Seventy-Five

This August marks the seventy-fifth anniversary of what is politely called the Atomic Age, when nuclear bombs were dropped on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, killing an estimated 140,000 and 70,000 persons respectively.  We have lived in a world ever since where the apocalypse depicted in the Book of Genesis, Noah’s Flood, is no mere fantasy but a daily possibility.  Nor are we merely dealing with an “Age,” in the sense of a period with a defined beginning and end.  Nuclear arms are with us for good, for even if all of them were to be dismantled tomorrow, there could be no ironclad guarantee that they would not reappear as long as the technology to produce them existed.  The decision to make the atomic bomb to begin with may be the most consequential one in human history. That is because history itself may be its ultimate target.

​I speak of the “decision” to make the bomb, but the truth is that the bomb was not a decision but, from the moment when the early twentieth-century physicist Ernest Rutherford discovered that the atom could theoretically be split, a fatality.  Scientists concluded that such a feat could create release the kind of energy that powered the stars, and that, properly engineered, it was only a matter of time until such a force was weaponized for use in human warfare.  The nation that achieved this first would very likely be in a position to dominate the world.  Therefore, no nation with sufficient expertise and resources could afford not to compete in the race to produce an atomic bomb, whether for offensive or defensive purposes.

​The practical limit on such a competition was that it would be enormously complex and expensive, with no results guaranteed.  Few countries, then, could realistically enter it.  Most of them were European, and with memories of the carnage of World War I still vivid and resources constrained by the Great Depression, commitment to such an enterprise was politically infeasible.

​One scientist, however, concluded that the atomic bomb had to be made, as a desperate necessity and as quickly as possible.  He was Leo Szilard, a young Hungarian working in Germany who as a Jew fled for England with the coming of the Nazis in 1933, and immediately attempted to persuade British authorities to develop an atomic bomb before Hitler could do so.  But the atom had yet to be split, and Szilard was a penniless refugee whom no one took seriously.

​By the end of the 1930s, however, atom fission had been achieved, and a new world war had begun.  A more influential figure, Albert Einstein, wrote to a more influential recipient, Franklin D. Roosevelt, urging that building an atomic bomb be explored.  Among the powers that were soon considering this as well were Germany, Imperial Japan, and Soviet Russia.  Germany’s preeminent physicist, Werner Heisenberg, passed on the information that Hitler was intensely interested in the bomb to a Danish colleague, Niels Bohr, and this news reached the United States.

​Roosevelt authorized a crash program to build the bomb, the Manhattan Project, which became the greatest research and design project ever undertaken.  Einstein did not work on it, but Leo Szilard did.  By the spring of 1945, a prototype was ready for testing.  At this point, Szilard and some of his colleagues frantically petitioned that the bomb, if successful, not be used.  They had worked intently on it to forestall a great evil, namely that Hitler would get the bomb first.  Now, suddenly, they were confronted with an evil hardly less terrible:  that the bomb would be used by anyone at all.

​The petition was suppressed.  The first atomic bomb was dropped on July 16, 1945 over Alamagordo, New Mexico in an operation code-named Trinity, presumably to invoke the blessing of the Christian deity.  Civilians were not warned or evacuated.  An uncounted number, but certainly in the thousands, were ultimately killed by the effects of fallout and radiation.  These, American citizens, were the first victims of atomic warfare.  Neither they nor their survivors were recognized or compensated.  America first made atomic warfare on itself.

​“Little Boy” was the bomb dropped on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945, a target chosen because, unlike Tokyo and other large Japanese cities, it had not already been obliterated by conventional firebombing.  Without awaiting a response from the Japanese government, a second bomb, codenamed “Fat Man,” annihilated the port city of Nagasaki.  The choice of dates and the rapid sequencing of the bombs was not accidental.  Between the attacks, on August 8, the Soviet Union declared war on Japan as per previous agreement with the U.S. and Britain, reached at a time when the fruit of the Manhattan Project was as yet uncertain.  With the success of Trinity, however, and with a Communist insurrection underway in China, it was regarded as imperative to prevent a Soviet penetration of Asia.  Little Boy and Fat Man preempted it.  Five days after Nagasaki, Japan surrendered.

​There has been long debate over the rationale for dropping the bomb.  But there is a perfectly simple explanation for it.  The bomb was used because it was made.  It was made because it was possible to make it.  Science had demonstrated that an atomic bomb was achievable; technology provided the rest.  In human warfare, what can be done is done.

​The American monopoly of the bomb lasted four years.  During that time, the United States conducted an ostentatiousseries of “tests” on Pacific atolls and later in the U.S. itself to demonstrate its intention to maintain and develop its atomic supremacy.  Pentagon planners contemplated using atomic weapons in Korea and Vietnam, the latter at that time still a French colony.  When the Soviet Union exploded its own first atomic bomb in 1949, an arms race immediately ensued, focused on the development of a hydrogen fusion bomb of vastly greater destructive potential.  By the mid-1950s, both the U.S. and the USSR had bombs with a blast potential—50 million tons of TNT and more—that made firecrackers of Little Boy and Fat Man.  Delivery systems proceeded apace, with long-range guided missiles carrying multiple warheads capable of reaching enemy territory within fifteen minutes of launch.  The world was suddenly, at any given moment, within a quarter hour of Armaggedon.

​Other nations—Britain, France, China, Israel, India, Pakistan, and North Korea—moved to develop their own nuclear arsenals, but none approached the size and power of the Superpower rivals.  By this time, scientists had calculated that a full-scale nuclear war might well render the planet uninhabitable for the human race.  It was not until the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962 brought the world to the actual brink of annihilation that steps were taken toward arms control, and not until the 1980s that a mutual reduction of armaments was seriously pursuedafter a reckless escalation by Ronald Reagan and an incident—unreported at the time—when a single Soviet technician averted nuclear war by gambling that an alert of attack was a false alarm. There is even a term of art, “broken arrows,” to describe major nuclear weapon incidents resulting in explosions, widespread radioactive discharges, and the military and civilian loss of life.  There are dozens of others that did not make the official list, and an unknown number still veiled in secrecy.

We are now preoccupied with climate change, which brings its daily train of disasters—flood, fire, drought, species extinction.  But the fact is that we have lived from moment to moment for seven and a half decades under the threat of instant and terminal catastrophe.  Even with a reduction in their arsenals, Russia and the U.S. still have enough nuclear weapons, aimed twenty-four hours a day at each other, to destroy the earth several times over.  No nuclear power has ever renounced its weapons; several are politically and economically unstable.  Others, notably Iraq and Saudi Arabia, are actively seeking nuclear capability.  China is reportedly expanding its arsenal.  Donald Trump wants to commit the U.S. to a thirty-year nuclear “modernization” program costing trillions of dollars, and to an arms race in space.  For the first time in decades, what are now the two most economically powerful nations in the world are working not to defuse their atomic arsenals but to increase them.

Little Boy and Fat Man are alive and well at seventy-five.  The rest of us are in greater mortal peril than ever.  We will remain so until we find something far more difficult than technical prowess, moral sanity.  If that day does not come, destruction will.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Little Boy and Fat Man at Seventy-Five