Author Archives | Robert Zaller

After the Impeachment: Biden in Hiding, Trump at Large

If there was ever a lose-lose proposition in American politics, it was the second impeachment of Donald Trump. It had to happen and it had to fail. It had to happen because the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol demanded nothing less than the most severe penalty Congress could impose on the first act of treason ever committed by an American president, an attempted coup against Congress itself. It was bound to fail because Congress is more deeply divided and more profoundly dysfunctional than any other institution of our government.

The Founding Fathers did not want a two-party system of government. For them, “party” meant faction, as it had long meant in English politics. The Fathers had enough to deal with in bringing the 13 states into an effective union and reconciling the divergent interests they represented: borders and expansion; individual constitutions; commerce; slavery. They nonetheless formed parties, and almost immediately.

Whether in two-party or multiparty form, modern liberal governments have not found a way of conducting their business without parties, or another way of avoiding dictatorship. The systemic problem at the moment for us is that the two-party system in America, such as it was, has broken down. There is only one party in America now, in the sense of a political grouping minimally responsible for the tasks of government. It was the party that assumed majority control of both houses of Congress only on Jan. 5, and whose members — Democratic and Republican alike — had to flee for their lives on the very next day in the face of an armed mob, not “incited” but in good part organized, funded, summoned and finally set upon the Capitol building in session for the purpose of annulling a presidential election and, with further intimidation and revolt, setting a despot on his throne.

The House of Representatives did the only thing it constitutionally could in the aftermath of the Jan. 6 insurrection. It had no power to arrest President Trump. It had no power to effectively secure its own premises, the president also being Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces. It impeached Trump and sent the impeachment to the Senate for action. The Senate, having gone into recess under the now-minority leader, Mitch McConnell, had gone out of session, and McConnell refused to recall it for the next 14 days, or even to have the bill of impeachment walked the short distance between the two chambers of Congress to be received by a functionary.

After Joe Biden was at last inaugurated behind protective barriers, McConnell then received the bill only to declare it to be invalid because Trump was now a private citizen beyond the Senate’s judicial reach. 43 of the Senate’s 50 Republican members concurred with this, and Donald Trump escaped any penalty from those whose lives he had put at risk of assassination. The entirety of the Democratic caucus of both houses voted to impeach Trump and to ban him from ever seeking office again. It was an incredibly inadequate response to a man who had attempted to overthrow the government, but it was the best it could do. Clearly, that is no longer good enough.

Years ago, I watched on closed-circuit television in Athens the trial of the dictators who had seized power in Greece by military insurrection eight years before, and I reported on it in The Miami Herald. The dictators were sentenced to life imprisonment, and they died in prison. There was no dispute, then or after, about their punishment. Democracy returned to Greece, the place where it was born.

Donald Trump is simply at liberty and on the loose. He lives in elegance and at ease. He is still the leader of a mob. Joe Biden had to defend not offering him intelligence briefings on national security matters, which he could no doubt have sold for a tidy sum. Biden is still seeking bipartisan support for his legislative and general policy agenda. A month has passed, and his $1.9 trillion bill for economic relief and COVID-19 vaccination languishes while he seeks even token Republican support. There is not the slightest indication he will get it, nor does he need it for the bill to pass. Meanwhile, tens of millions of Americans face hunger, privation and eviction, as well as potential death from the disease that has already claimed nearly half a million lives.

It’s not that Biden doesn’t, or shouldn’t, understand the futility of seeking support beyond his own party. As Barack Obama’s vice president, he spent the year 2009 courting Republican votes for the Affordable Care Act. He offered concession after concession, watering down a bill lame enough to begin with. He got not a single vote for his trouble. But the Republican Party is no longer simply a party of obstruction, as it has long been whenever out of power. It is no longer even the party of Richard Nixon, who resigned in disgrace, or George W. Bush, who lied us into war. It is the party that nominated a man for president it knew could never comprehend, let alone discharge his oath of office, and that has now failed to repudiate him as a traitor to his country. Part cabal, part cult and devoid of principle, it is not a political party at all.

It is true that, at the state and local level, there are still some people of integrity who call themselves Republicans, without whom we might not have emerged this year with a duly elected president. There are a few on the gubernatorial level, and even a small minority in Congress. It is not enough to make a party.

When Franklin D. Roosevelt came to office as president in 1933, faced with a crisis that threatened the Republic, he found a Republican Party resolutely set against him and a conservative Supreme Court ready to back those who opposed and even hated him. He told the Republicans he welcomed their hatred, and he brought the Court to heel by threatening to pack it. The result was the passage of the New Deal, and 20 years of Democratic hegemony. It was not a bad run. Joe Biden might think about emulating this, and if it takes twenty years for a new conservative party to emerge in the United States, or shall I say an actual one, I am prepared to wait. Only please, Joe, stop dithering with a gang that could not disavow a traitor, and that sold its soul long ago to casino capitalism, white supremacy and the worst figure ever to emerge on the stage of a mature democratic nation.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on After the Impeachment: Biden in Hiding, Trump at Large

When should our patience run out?

Joe Biden has promised to produce results for a country that, as he himself says, is at war. He surely had a lot of problems sitting on his desk when he finally arrived at a freshly-disinfected White House on January 20. He has certainly been signing executive orders at a record pace, many of them designed to undo the baleful work of his predecessor. The one thing he hasn’t done is fight that war he talked about—the one whose cost now approaches half a million lives.

I’m glad that we’ve rejoined the Paris Agreement, though I will be gladder when the climate accords finally start to mean something to our overheated, glacier-melting world. I’m glad that we’ve scuttled the Keystone oil pipeline, though I’ll be happier to see us renounce fossil fuels altogether. I’m glad that transgender soldiers will be able to fight our unending wars again, though I wish those wars would end.

But, really, there is only one war in front of us in the here and now. We’ve lost a year fighting it. We finally have some weapons, apart from cloth face coverings, to wage it. So, where are they?

Chuck Todd, the host of NBC’s “Meet the Press,” finally asked the question that more than 300 million of us are waiting for an answer to: “When should our patience run out?”

Todd was referring to the fact that five times as many people per capita have died in the United States from COVID-19 as elsewhere in the world, and continue to do so. He was referring to the fact that, two months into the approval of two vaccines with over 90 percent effectiveness (so far), we have inoculated barely one-tenth of our population. He also threw in the point that he hasn’t been able to get a shot for his own mother, and he is admittedly one of the better-connected people on the planet.

Gotcha, Chuck.

Of course, Joe Biden didn’t create this mess. He inherited it from King Chaos, after his four years of carnival misrule, capped by the butchery of his COVID-19 response. The question is where we go from here.

There are two steps in securing vaccinations: production and distribution. Production in the U.S. is currently controlled by the two pharmaceutical companies that have secured approval for their vaccines, Pfizer and Moderna, and the affiliated units with which they have contracts. To use President Biden’s war analogy (which was also Donald Trump’s), this is equivalent to saying that planes, tanks and warships should be produced only by licensed factories, no matter what other facilities existed or could be converted to such use.

That’s not the way we fought World War II. Our current population is 331 million.

The Pfizer and Moderna doses both require two separate injections, spaced weeks apart. That’s 662 million doses to cover everyone, although some people can’t safely take the shots. Let’s say rather that we’re trying for herd immunity or coverage for 75 to 80 percent of the country. That would be half a billion doses. But some of those doses will inevitably be lost to spoilage, so we need to up the figure again. And the single-dose Johnson & Johnson vaccine is awaiting approval this month, with Astro-Zeneca’s version (already in use in Europe) somewhere on the horizon.

Which shot is best for you? And how well or long will it work against whatever mutations of COVID-19 emerge next? Well, we’re all guinea pigs now. As we know, Trump declined an offer from Pfizer to provide an additional 100 million doses of its vaccine last summer. Trump claimed that the government had 100 million doses in stock in December. His health czar, Alex Azar, said it was 40 million. The new Biden administration said it could provide no figures at all.

Supply of any kind, of course, is useless without distribution. Trump left this problem to the 50 state governors and other jurisdictions, with a scheme of algorithms that made everything worse. Local residents hardly need to be told how things have worked out in Philadelphia or in neighboring counties. In New York City, there were 50 vaccination sites—for a population of eight million. For the remainder of the state, there were a dozen sites to cover more than 40,000 square miles.

Of course, the distribution problem is less complicated if you have nothing to distribute. What, then, has Biden been doing, now more than a fifth of the way through his 100 days? He has not authorized, much less mandated, additional production facilities.

He promised the production of 100 million doses in his first 100 days, until it was pointed out to him that this rate was already being achieved. He then upped his goal to 150 million doses. Pfizer and Moderna alone say they can produce 200 million by the end of March, which would be on the 70th of Biden’s 100 days, and it is estimated that we could be actually administering two million shots a day by then. Mind you, we’ll each need two of these shots with currently approved vaccines, so that would mean a year before full vaccination is (in theory) available to everyone from these sources. President Biden has recently said that all Americans who want vaccinations will have them by the end of the summer. He has not said how.

Israel has already vaccinated its citizens. Biden has allocated $160 billion for the production and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines in his $1.9 trillion disaster relief bill. With a reconciliation procedure in the House and Senate, Congress could have put this money in the pipeline two weeks ago. Instead, Biden insisted on a White House sitdown with 10 Republicans, who lowballed his bill to $618 billion, although they agreed to the requested funds for COVID-19. Belatedly, Democrats in Congress are acting on their own.

The COVID-19 money could have been separated out at once if Biden wanted Republican votes for it, unnecessary as they were. As of this writing, nothing of this appropriation has gone out for anything. This is more than absurd. It’s bizarre. Within a month or two, new and more contagious strains of COVID-19 will be making their impact felt wide, potentially weakening the effect of the vaccines we have. Nor is this merely a direct health issue. It is also an economic and educational one, as half of another K-12 school year goes to waste. The Chinese have their kids back in class.

The COVID-19 emergency is actually a worse crisis than World War II. When the Japanese attacked us, they put only two of our then-territories, Hawaii and the Philippines, directly in jeopardy, plus a few Pacific chains. The Japanese were never in a position to strike the continental United States at any time. Each day today, we are losing as many or more lives than were lost on Pearl Harbor Day, and they are being lost at home. Joe Biden, meanwhile, waits on bipartisanship from a caucus of Congressional Republicans, a majority of whom have yet to recognize his election as president. He has neither centralized nor rationalized vaccine production or distribution. Testing and masking remain haphazard. Hospital facilities and supplies are desperately vulnerable.

When should our patience run out?

Now would be a very good time.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When should our patience run out?

When should our patience run out?

Joe Biden has promised to produce results for a country that, as he himself says, is at war. He surely had a lot of problems sitting on his desk when he finally arrived at a freshly-disinfected White House on January 20. He has certainly been signing executive orders at a record pace, many of them designed to undo the baleful work of his predecessor. The one thing he hasn’t done is fight that war he talked about—the one whose cost now approaches half a million lives.

I’m glad that we’ve rejoined the Paris Agreement, though I will be gladder when the climate accords finally start to mean something to our overheated, glacier-melting world. I’m glad that we’ve scuttled the Keystone oil pipeline, though I’ll be happier to see us renounce fossil fuels altogether. I’m glad that transgender soldiers will be able to fight our unending wars again, though I wish those wars would end.

But, really, there is only one war in front of us in the here and now. We’ve lost a year fighting it. We finally have some weapons, apart from cloth face coverings, to wage it. So, where are they?

Chuck Todd, the host of NBC’s “Meet the Press,” finally asked the question that more than 300 million of us are waiting for an answer to: “When should our patience run out?”

Todd was referring to the fact that five times as many people per capita have died in the United States from COVID-19 as elsewhere in the world, and continue to do so. He was referring to the fact that, two months into the approval of two vaccines with over 90 percent effectiveness (so far), we have inoculated barely one-tenth of our population. He also threw in the point that he hasn’t been able to get a shot for his own mother, and he is admittedly one of the better-connected people on the planet.

Gotcha, Chuck.

Of course, Joe Biden didn’t create this mess. He inherited it from King Chaos, after his four years of carnival misrule, capped by the butchery of his COVID-19 response. The question is where we go from here.

There are two steps in securing vaccinations: production and distribution. Production in the U.S. is currently controlled by the two pharmaceutical companies that have secured approval for their vaccines, Pfizer and Moderna, and the affiliated units with which they have contracts. To use President Biden’s war analogy (which was also Donald Trump’s), this is equivalent to saying that planes, tanks and warships should be produced only by licensed factories, no matter what other facilities existed or could be converted to such use.

That’s not the way we fought World War II. Our current population is 331 million.

The Pfizer and Moderna doses both require two separate injections, spaced weeks apart. That’s 662 million doses to cover everyone, although some people can’t safely take the shots. Let’s say rather that we’re trying for herd immunity or coverage for 75 to 80 percent of the country. That would be half a billion doses. But some of those doses will inevitably be lost to spoilage, so we need to up the figure again. And the single-dose Johnson & Johnson vaccine is awaiting approval this month, with Astro-Zeneca’s version (already in use in Europe) somewhere on the horizon.

Which shot is best for you? And how well or long will it work against whatever mutations of COVID-19 emerge next? Well, we’re all guinea pigs now. As we know, Trump declined an offer from Pfizer to provide an additional 100 million doses of its vaccine last summer. Trump claimed that the government had 100 million doses in stock in December. His health czar, Alex Azar, said it was 40 million. The new Biden administration said it could provide no figures at all.

Supply of any kind, of course, is useless without distribution. Trump left this problem to the 50 state governors and other jurisdictions, with a scheme of algorithms that made everything worse. Local residents hardly need to be told how things have worked out in Philadelphia or in neighboring counties. In New York City, there were 50 vaccination sites—for a population of eight million. For the remainder of the state, there were a dozen sites to cover more than 40,000 square miles.

Of course, the distribution problem is less complicated if you have nothing to distribute. What, then, has Biden been doing, now more than a fifth of the way through his 100 days? He has not authorized, much less mandated, additional production facilities.

He promised the production of 100 million doses in his first 100 days, until it was pointed out to him that this rate was already being achieved. He then upped his goal to 150 million doses. Pfizer and Moderna alone say they can produce 200 million by the end of March, which would be on the 70th of Biden’s 100 days, and it is estimated that we could be actually administering two million shots a day by then. Mind you, we’ll each need two of these shots with currently approved vaccines, so that would mean a year before full vaccination is (in theory) available to everyone from these sources. President Biden has recently said that all Americans who want vaccinations will have them by the end of the summer. He has not said how.

Israel has already vaccinated its citizens. Biden has allocated $160 billion for the production and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines in his $1.9 trillion disaster relief bill. With a reconciliation procedure in the House and Senate, Congress could have put this money in the pipeline two weeks ago. Instead, Biden insisted on a White House sitdown with 10 Republicans, who lowballed his bill to $618 billion, although they agreed to the requested funds for COVID-19. Belatedly, Democrats in Congress are acting on their own.

The COVID-19 money could have been separated out at once if Biden wanted Republican votes for it, unnecessary as they were. As of this writing, nothing of this appropriation has gone out for anything. This is more than absurd. It’s bizarre. Within a month or two, new and more contagious strains of COVID-19 will be making their impact felt wide, potentially weakening the effect of the vaccines we have. Nor is this merely a direct health issue. It is also an economic and educational one, as half of another K-12 school year goes to waste. The Chinese have their kids back in class.

The COVID-19 emergency is actually a worse crisis than World War II. When the Japanese attacked us, they put only two of our then-territories, Hawaii and the Philippines, directly in jeopardy, plus a few Pacific chains. The Japanese were never in a position to strike the continental United States at any time. Each day today, we are losing as many or more lives than were lost on Pearl Harbor Day, and they are being lost at home. Joe Biden, meanwhile, waits on bipartisanship from a caucus of Congressional Republicans, a majority of whom have yet to recognize his election as president. He has neither centralized nor rationalized vaccine production or distribution. Testing and masking remain haphazard. Hospital facilities and supplies are desperately vulnerable.

When should our patience run out?

Now would be a very good time.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When should our patience run out?

When should our patience run out?

Joe Biden has promised to produce results for a country that, as he himself says, is at war. He surely had a lot of problems sitting on his desk when he finally arrived at a freshly-disinfected White House on January 20. He has certainly been signing executive orders at a record pace, many of them designed to undo the baleful work of his predecessor. The one thing he hasn’t done is fight that war he talked about—the one whose cost now approaches half a million lives.

I’m glad that we’ve rejoined the Paris Agreement, though I will be gladder when the climate accords finally start to mean something to our overheated, glacier-melting world. I’m glad that we’ve scuttled the Keystone oil pipeline, though I’ll be happier to see us renounce fossil fuels altogether. I’m glad that transgender soldiers will be able to fight our unending wars again, though I wish those wars would end.

But, really, there is only one war in front of us in the here and now. We’ve lost a year fighting it. We finally have some weapons, apart from cloth face coverings, to wage it. So, where are they?

Chuck Todd, the host of NBC’s “Meet the Press,” finally asked the question that more than 300 million of us are waiting for an answer to: “When should our patience run out?”

Todd was referring to the fact that five times as many people per capita have died in the United States from COVID-19 as elsewhere in the world, and continue to do so. He was referring to the fact that, two months into the approval of two vaccines with over 90 percent effectiveness (so far), we have inoculated barely one-tenth of our population. He also threw in the point that he hasn’t been able to get a shot for his own mother, and he is admittedly one of the better-connected people on the planet.

Gotcha, Chuck.

Of course, Joe Biden didn’t create this mess. He inherited it from King Chaos, after his four years of carnival misrule, capped by the butchery of his COVID-19 response. The question is where we go from here.

There are two steps in securing vaccinations: production and distribution. Production in the U.S. is currently controlled by the two pharmaceutical companies that have secured approval for their vaccines, Pfizer and Moderna, and the affiliated units with which they have contracts. To use President Biden’s war analogy (which was also Donald Trump’s), this is equivalent to saying that planes, tanks and warships should be produced only by licensed factories, no matter what other facilities existed or could be converted to such use.

That’s not the way we fought World War II. Our current population is 331 million.

The Pfizer and Moderna doses both require two separate injections, spaced weeks apart. That’s 662 million doses to cover everyone, although some people can’t safely take the shots. Let’s say rather that we’re trying for herd immunity or coverage for 75 to 80 percent of the country. That would be half a billion doses. But some of those doses will inevitably be lost to spoilage, so we need to up the figure again. And the single-dose Johnson & Johnson vaccine is awaiting approval this month, with Astro-Zeneca’s version (already in use in Europe) somewhere on the horizon.

Which shot is best for you? And how well or long will it work against whatever mutations of COVID-19 emerge next? Well, we’re all guinea pigs now. As we know, Trump declined an offer from Pfizer to provide an additional 100 million doses of its vaccine last summer. Trump claimed that the government had 100 million doses in stock in December. His health czar, Alex Azar, said it was 40 million. The new Biden administration said it could provide no figures at all.

Supply of any kind, of course, is useless without distribution. Trump left this problem to the 50 state governors and other jurisdictions, with a scheme of algorithms that made everything worse. Local residents hardly need to be told how things have worked out in Philadelphia or in neighboring counties. In New York City, there were 50 vaccination sites—for a population of eight million. For the remainder of the state, there were a dozen sites to cover more than 40,000 square miles.

Of course, the distribution problem is less complicated if you have nothing to distribute. What, then, has Biden been doing, now more than a fifth of the way through his 100 days? He has not authorized, much less mandated, additional production facilities.

He promised the production of 100 million doses in his first 100 days, until it was pointed out to him that this rate was already being achieved. He then upped his goal to 150 million doses. Pfizer and Moderna alone say they can produce 200 million by the end of March, which would be on the 70th of Biden’s 100 days, and it is estimated that we could be actually administering two million shots a day by then. Mind you, we’ll each need two of these shots with currently approved vaccines, so that would mean a year before full vaccination is (in theory) available to everyone from these sources. President Biden has recently said that all Americans who want vaccinations will have them by the end of the summer. He has not said how.

Israel has already vaccinated its citizens. Biden has allocated $160 billion for the production and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines in his $1.9 trillion disaster relief bill. With a reconciliation procedure in the House and Senate, Congress could have put this money in the pipeline two weeks ago. Instead, Biden insisted on a White House sitdown with 10 Republicans, who lowballed his bill to $618 billion, although they agreed to the requested funds for COVID-19. Belatedly, Democrats in Congress are acting on their own.

The COVID-19 money could have been separated out at once if Biden wanted Republican votes for it, unnecessary as they were. As of this writing, nothing of this appropriation has gone out for anything. This is more than absurd. It’s bizarre. Within a month or two, new and more contagious strains of COVID-19 will be making their impact felt wide, potentially weakening the effect of the vaccines we have. Nor is this merely a direct health issue. It is also an economic and educational one, as half of another K-12 school year goes to waste. The Chinese have their kids back in class.

The COVID-19 emergency is actually a worse crisis than World War II. When the Japanese attacked us, they put only two of our then-territories, Hawaii and the Philippines, directly in jeopardy, plus a few Pacific chains. The Japanese were never in a position to strike the continental United States at any time. Each day today, we are losing as many or more lives than were lost on Pearl Harbor Day, and they are being lost at home. Joe Biden, meanwhile, waits on bipartisanship from a caucus of Congressional Republicans, a majority of whom have yet to recognize his election as president. He has neither centralized nor rationalized vaccine production or distribution. Testing and masking remain haphazard. Hospital facilities and supplies are desperately vulnerable.

When should our patience run out?

Now would be a very good time.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When should our patience run out?

When should our patience run out?

Joe Biden has promised to produce results for a country that, as he himself says, is at war. He surely had a lot of problems sitting on his desk when he finally arrived at a freshly-disinfected White House on January 20. He has certainly been signing executive orders at a record pace, many of them designed to undo the baleful work of his predecessor. The one thing he hasn’t done is fight that war he talked about—the one whose cost now approaches half a million lives.

I’m glad that we’ve rejoined the Paris Agreement, though I will be gladder when the climate accords finally start to mean something to our overheated, glacier-melting world. I’m glad that we’ve scuttled the Keystone oil pipeline, though I’ll be happier to see us renounce fossil fuels altogether. I’m glad that transgender soldiers will be able to fight our unending wars again, though I wish those wars would end.

But, really, there is only one war in front of us in the here and now. We’ve lost a year fighting it. We finally have some weapons, apart from cloth face coverings, to wage it. So, where are they?

Chuck Todd, the host of NBC’s “Meet the Press,” finally asked the question that more than 300 million of us are waiting for an answer to: “When should our patience run out?”

Todd was referring to the fact that five times as many people per capita have died in the United States from COVID-19 as elsewhere in the world, and continue to do so. He was referring to the fact that, two months into the approval of two vaccines with over 90 percent effectiveness (so far), we have inoculated barely one-tenth of our population. He also threw in the point that he hasn’t been able to get a shot for his own mother, and he is admittedly one of the better-connected people on the planet.

Gotcha, Chuck.

Of course, Joe Biden didn’t create this mess. He inherited it from King Chaos, after his four years of carnival misrule, capped by the butchery of his COVID-19 response. The question is where we go from here.

There are two steps in securing vaccinations: production and distribution. Production in the U.S. is currently controlled by the two pharmaceutical companies that have secured approval for their vaccines, Pfizer and Moderna, and the affiliated units with which they have contracts. To use President Biden’s war analogy (which was also Donald Trump’s), this is equivalent to saying that planes, tanks and warships should be produced only by licensed factories, no matter what other facilities existed or could be converted to such use.

That’s not the way we fought World War II. Our current population is 331 million.

The Pfizer and Moderna doses both require two separate injections, spaced weeks apart. That’s 662 million doses to cover everyone, although some people can’t safely take the shots. Let’s say rather that we’re trying for herd immunity or coverage for 75 to 80 percent of the country. That would be half a billion doses. But some of those doses will inevitably be lost to spoilage, so we need to up the figure again. And the single-dose Johnson & Johnson vaccine is awaiting approval this month, with Astro-Zeneca’s version (already in use in Europe) somewhere on the horizon.

Which shot is best for you? And how well or long will it work against whatever mutations of COVID-19 emerge next? Well, we’re all guinea pigs now. As we know, Trump declined an offer from Pfizer to provide an additional 100 million doses of its vaccine last summer. Trump claimed that the government had 100 million doses in stock in December. His health czar, Alex Azar, said it was 40 million. The new Biden administration said it could provide no figures at all.

Supply of any kind, of course, is useless without distribution. Trump left this problem to the 50 state governors and other jurisdictions, with a scheme of algorithms that made everything worse. Local residents hardly need to be told how things have worked out in Philadelphia or in neighboring counties. In New York City, there were 50 vaccination sites—for a population of eight million. For the remainder of the state, there were a dozen sites to cover more than 40,000 square miles.

Of course, the distribution problem is less complicated if you have nothing to distribute. What, then, has Biden been doing, now more than a fifth of the way through his 100 days? He has not authorized, much less mandated, additional production facilities.

He promised the production of 100 million doses in his first 100 days, until it was pointed out to him that this rate was already being achieved. He then upped his goal to 150 million doses. Pfizer and Moderna alone say they can produce 200 million by the end of March, which would be on the 70th of Biden’s 100 days, and it is estimated that we could be actually administering two million shots a day by then. Mind you, we’ll each need two of these shots with currently approved vaccines, so that would mean a year before full vaccination is (in theory) available to everyone from these sources. President Biden has recently said that all Americans who want vaccinations will have them by the end of the summer. He has not said how.

Israel has already vaccinated its citizens. Biden has allocated $160 billion for the production and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines in his $1.9 trillion disaster relief bill. With a reconciliation procedure in the House and Senate, Congress could have put this money in the pipeline two weeks ago. Instead, Biden insisted on a White House sitdown with 10 Republicans, who lowballed his bill to $618 billion, although they agreed to the requested funds for COVID-19. Belatedly, Democrats in Congress are acting on their own.

The COVID-19 money could have been separated out at once if Biden wanted Republican votes for it, unnecessary as they were. As of this writing, nothing of this appropriation has gone out for anything. This is more than absurd. It’s bizarre. Within a month or two, new and more contagious strains of COVID-19 will be making their impact felt wide, potentially weakening the effect of the vaccines we have. Nor is this merely a direct health issue. It is also an economic and educational one, as half of another K-12 school year goes to waste. The Chinese have their kids back in class.

The COVID-19 emergency is actually a worse crisis than World War II. When the Japanese attacked us, they put only two of our then-territories, Hawaii and the Philippines, directly in jeopardy, plus a few Pacific chains. The Japanese were never in a position to strike the continental United States at any time. Each day today, we are losing as many or more lives than were lost on Pearl Harbor Day, and they are being lost at home. Joe Biden, meanwhile, waits on bipartisanship from a caucus of Congressional Republicans, a majority of whom have yet to recognize his election as president. He has neither centralized nor rationalized vaccine production or distribution. Testing and masking remain haphazard. Hospital facilities and supplies are desperately vulnerable.

When should our patience run out?

Now would be a very good time.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When should our patience run out?

When should our patience run out?

Joe Biden has promised to produce results for a country that, as he himself says, is at war. He surely had a lot of problems sitting on his desk when he finally arrived at a freshly-disinfected White House on January 20. He has certainly been signing executive orders at a record pace, many of them designed to undo the baleful work of his predecessor. The one thing he hasn’t done is fight that war he talked about—the one whose cost now approaches half a million lives.

I’m glad that we’ve rejoined the Paris Agreement, though I will be gladder when the climate accords finally start to mean something to our overheated, glacier-melting world. I’m glad that we’ve scuttled the Keystone oil pipeline, though I’ll be happier to see us renounce fossil fuels altogether. I’m glad that transgender soldiers will be able to fight our unending wars again, though I wish those wars would end.

But, really, there is only one war in front of us in the here and now. We’ve lost a year fighting it. We finally have some weapons, apart from cloth face coverings, to wage it. So, where are they?

Chuck Todd, the host of NBC’s “Meet the Press,” finally asked the question that more than 300 million of us are waiting for an answer to: “When should our patience run out?”

Todd was referring to the fact that five times as many people per capita have died in the United States from COVID-19 as elsewhere in the world, and continue to do so. He was referring to the fact that, two months into the approval of two vaccines with over 90 percent effectiveness (so far), we have inoculated barely one-tenth of our population. He also threw in the point that he hasn’t been able to get a shot for his own mother, and he is admittedly one of the better-connected people on the planet.

Gotcha, Chuck.

Of course, Joe Biden didn’t create this mess. He inherited it from King Chaos, after his four years of carnival misrule, capped by the butchery of his COVID-19 response. The question is where we go from here.

There are two steps in securing vaccinations: production and distribution. Production in the U.S. is currently controlled by the two pharmaceutical companies that have secured approval for their vaccines, Pfizer and Moderna, and the affiliated units with which they have contracts. To use President Biden’s war analogy (which was also Donald Trump’s), this is equivalent to saying that planes, tanks and warships should be produced only by licensed factories, no matter what other facilities existed or could be converted to such use.

That’s not the way we fought World War II. Our current population is 331 million.

The Pfizer and Moderna doses both require two separate injections, spaced weeks apart. That’s 662 million doses to cover everyone, although some people can’t safely take the shots. Let’s say rather that we’re trying for herd immunity or coverage for 75 to 80 percent of the country. That would be half a billion doses. But some of those doses will inevitably be lost to spoilage, so we need to up the figure again. And the single-dose Johnson & Johnson vaccine is awaiting approval this month, with Astro-Zeneca’s version (already in use in Europe) somewhere on the horizon.

Which shot is best for you? And how well or long will it work against whatever mutations of COVID-19 emerge next? Well, we’re all guinea pigs now. As we know, Trump declined an offer from Pfizer to provide an additional 100 million doses of its vaccine last summer. Trump claimed that the government had 100 million doses in stock in December. His health czar, Alex Azar, said it was 40 million. The new Biden administration said it could provide no figures at all.

Supply of any kind, of course, is useless without distribution. Trump left this problem to the 50 state governors and other jurisdictions, with a scheme of algorithms that made everything worse. Local residents hardly need to be told how things have worked out in Philadelphia or in neighboring counties. In New York City, there were 50 vaccination sites—for a population of eight million. For the remainder of the state, there were a dozen sites to cover more than 40,000 square miles.

Of course, the distribution problem is less complicated if you have nothing to distribute. What, then, has Biden been doing, now more than a fifth of the way through his 100 days? He has not authorized, much less mandated, additional production facilities.

He promised the production of 100 million doses in his first 100 days, until it was pointed out to him that this rate was already being achieved. He then upped his goal to 150 million doses. Pfizer and Moderna alone say they can produce 200 million by the end of March, which would be on the 70th of Biden’s 100 days, and it is estimated that we could be actually administering two million shots a day by then. Mind you, we’ll each need two of these shots with currently approved vaccines, so that would mean a year before full vaccination is (in theory) available to everyone from these sources. President Biden has recently said that all Americans who want vaccinations will have them by the end of the summer. He has not said how.

Israel has already vaccinated its citizens. Biden has allocated $160 billion for the production and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines in his $1.9 trillion disaster relief bill. With a reconciliation procedure in the House and Senate, Congress could have put this money in the pipeline two weeks ago. Instead, Biden insisted on a White House sitdown with 10 Republicans, who lowballed his bill to $618 billion, although they agreed to the requested funds for COVID-19. Belatedly, Democrats in Congress are acting on their own.

The COVID-19 money could have been separated out at once if Biden wanted Republican votes for it, unnecessary as they were. As of this writing, nothing of this appropriation has gone out for anything. This is more than absurd. It’s bizarre. Within a month or two, new and more contagious strains of COVID-19 will be making their impact felt wide, potentially weakening the effect of the vaccines we have. Nor is this merely a direct health issue. It is also an economic and educational one, as half of another K-12 school year goes to waste. The Chinese have their kids back in class.

The COVID-19 emergency is actually a worse crisis than World War II. When the Japanese attacked us, they put only two of our then-territories, Hawaii and the Philippines, directly in jeopardy, plus a few Pacific chains. The Japanese were never in a position to strike the continental United States at any time. Each day today, we are losing as many or more lives than were lost on Pearl Harbor Day, and they are being lost at home. Joe Biden, meanwhile, waits on bipartisanship from a caucus of Congressional Republicans, a majority of whom have yet to recognize his election as president. He has neither centralized nor rationalized vaccine production or distribution. Testing and masking remain haphazard. Hospital facilities and supplies are desperately vulnerable.

When should our patience run out?

Now would be a very good time.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When should our patience run out?

When should our patience run out?

Joe Biden has promised to produce results for a country that, as he himself says, is at war. He surely had a lot of problems sitting on his desk when he finally arrived at a freshly-disinfected White House on January 20. He has certainly been signing executive orders at a record pace, many of them designed to undo the baleful work of his predecessor. The one thing he hasn’t done is fight that war he talked about—the one whose cost now approaches half a million lives.

I’m glad that we’ve rejoined the Paris Agreement, though I will be gladder when the climate accords finally start to mean something to our overheated, glacier-melting world. I’m glad that we’ve scuttled the Keystone oil pipeline, though I’ll be happier to see us renounce fossil fuels altogether. I’m glad that transgender soldiers will be able to fight our unending wars again, though I wish those wars would end.

But, really, there is only one war in front of us in the here and now. We’ve lost a year fighting it. We finally have some weapons, apart from cloth face coverings, to wage it. So, where are they?

Chuck Todd, the host of NBC’s “Meet the Press,” finally asked the question that more than 300 million of us are waiting for an answer to: “When should our patience run out?”

Todd was referring to the fact that five times as many people per capita have died in the United States from COVID-19 as elsewhere in the world, and continue to do so. He was referring to the fact that, two months into the approval of two vaccines with over 90 percent effectiveness (so far), we have inoculated barely one-tenth of our population. He also threw in the point that he hasn’t been able to get a shot for his own mother, and he is admittedly one of the better-connected people on the planet.

Gotcha, Chuck.

Of course, Joe Biden didn’t create this mess. He inherited it from King Chaos, after his four years of carnival misrule, capped by the butchery of his COVID-19 response. The question is where we go from here.

There are two steps in securing vaccinations: production and distribution. Production in the U.S. is currently controlled by the two pharmaceutical companies that have secured approval for their vaccines, Pfizer and Moderna, and the affiliated units with which they have contracts. To use President Biden’s war analogy (which was also Donald Trump’s), this is equivalent to saying that planes, tanks and warships should be produced only by licensed factories, no matter what other facilities existed or could be converted to such use.

That’s not the way we fought World War II. Our current population is 331 million.

The Pfizer and Moderna doses both require two separate injections, spaced weeks apart. That’s 662 million doses to cover everyone, although some people can’t safely take the shots. Let’s say rather that we’re trying for herd immunity or coverage for 75 to 80 percent of the country. That would be half a billion doses. But some of those doses will inevitably be lost to spoilage, so we need to up the figure again. And the single-dose Johnson & Johnson vaccine is awaiting approval this month, with Astro-Zeneca’s version (already in use in Europe) somewhere on the horizon.

Which shot is best for you? And how well or long will it work against whatever mutations of COVID-19 emerge next? Well, we’re all guinea pigs now. As we know, Trump declined an offer from Pfizer to provide an additional 100 million doses of its vaccine last summer. Trump claimed that the government had 100 million doses in stock in December. His health czar, Alex Azar, said it was 40 million. The new Biden administration said it could provide no figures at all.

Supply of any kind, of course, is useless without distribution. Trump left this problem to the 50 state governors and other jurisdictions, with a scheme of algorithms that made everything worse. Local residents hardly need to be told how things have worked out in Philadelphia or in neighboring counties. In New York City, there were 50 vaccination sites—for a population of eight million. For the remainder of the state, there were a dozen sites to cover more than 40,000 square miles.

Of course, the distribution problem is less complicated if you have nothing to distribute. What, then, has Biden been doing, now more than a fifth of the way through his 100 days? He has not authorized, much less mandated, additional production facilities.

He promised the production of 100 million doses in his first 100 days, until it was pointed out to him that this rate was already being achieved. He then upped his goal to 150 million doses. Pfizer and Moderna alone say they can produce 200 million by the end of March, which would be on the 70th of Biden’s 100 days, and it is estimated that we could be actually administering two million shots a day by then. Mind you, we’ll each need two of these shots with currently approved vaccines, so that would mean a year before full vaccination is (in theory) available to everyone from these sources. President Biden has recently said that all Americans who want vaccinations will have them by the end of the summer. He has not said how.

Israel has already vaccinated its citizens. Biden has allocated $160 billion for the production and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines in his $1.9 trillion disaster relief bill. With a reconciliation procedure in the House and Senate, Congress could have put this money in the pipeline two weeks ago. Instead, Biden insisted on a White House sitdown with 10 Republicans, who lowballed his bill to $618 billion, although they agreed to the requested funds for COVID-19. Belatedly, Democrats in Congress are acting on their own.

The COVID-19 money could have been separated out at once if Biden wanted Republican votes for it, unnecessary as they were. As of this writing, nothing of this appropriation has gone out for anything. This is more than absurd. It’s bizarre. Within a month or two, new and more contagious strains of COVID-19 will be making their impact felt wide, potentially weakening the effect of the vaccines we have. Nor is this merely a direct health issue. It is also an economic and educational one, as half of another K-12 school year goes to waste. The Chinese have their kids back in class.

The COVID-19 emergency is actually a worse crisis than World War II. When the Japanese attacked us, they put only two of our then-territories, Hawaii and the Philippines, directly in jeopardy, plus a few Pacific chains. The Japanese were never in a position to strike the continental United States at any time. Each day today, we are losing as many or more lives than were lost on Pearl Harbor Day, and they are being lost at home. Joe Biden, meanwhile, waits on bipartisanship from a caucus of Congressional Republicans, a majority of whom have yet to recognize his election as president. He has neither centralized nor rationalized vaccine production or distribution. Testing and masking remain haphazard. Hospital facilities and supplies are desperately vulnerable.

When should our patience run out?

Now would be a very good time.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When should our patience run out?

Capitalism, Covid, and Drexel

The good news about the COVID-19 pandemic is that vaccines that appear to be safe and thus far effective were developed in record time, and far more quickly than originally anticipated. It is a tribute to the medical researchers who ascertained the novel procedure for stimulating the body’s responses to the virus and produced the tool with which to do it. They are, so far, mostly anonymous to us, but their names should stand beside those like Jonas Salk, who gave us the potential to save millions of lives.

The bad news is everything else.

These medicines belong to all of us, worldwide. They should be produced in the greatest possible quantity as swiftly as can be, and distributed uniformly everywhere on earth. Jonas Salk, who gave us the first vaccine for polio, wanted not a dollar of personal profit from it. He said it made no more sense to reap financial reward from a benefaction to the human race than it was for the sun to charge us for shining.

Unfortunately, it’s a minority point of view.

In a rational — or shall we simply say a decent — world, we would have robust public health systems that, with their own laboratories and scientists, could be mobilized to combat pandemics as soon as they were recognized with the cooperation of all world governments. As many resources as necessary would be devoted to the task; all useful information would be shared as soon as available. All expenses would be paid. No profit would be made. You can make a buck off something less urgent than saving a life.

Instead, we have created a vast bottleneck in which supply for most of the world is controlled by a handful of pharmaceutical companies, directly or indirectly funded by public money, who control the medications by patent. In theory, vaccinations are available without private charge, which means, again, that public money is spent to purchase them, profit of course included. In practice, a vast black market has developed in which the rich and the connected can get their shots quickly while the rest of us wait on fate and whatever erratic dribbles of supply turn up to be distributed according to whatever the protocol of the day may be. The result, at least for the country with the world’s highest GDP, is what has been (and continues to be) 20 percent of the world’s COVID-19 cases and fatalities in an aggregate of 4 percent of the world’s population.

As bad as vaccine production has been, distribution has been worse. We can’t blame Donald Trump anymore, although perhaps a quarter of a million deaths can be laid directly at his door. On the ground, there is little more than chaos. And that’s where our great entrepreneurial university, Drexel, comes in. The nation now knows that a 22-year-old Drexel graduate student, Andrei Doroshin, with no public health experience or medical background, sold the Philadelphia Public Health Department and the City Council on the idea that his incorporated-on-the-fly Philly Fighting COVID, run by a gaggle of so far nameless fellow students, should receive and administer thousands of vaccine doses at a prime civic location, the Philadelphia Convention Center. It was to be the largest vaccination site in the city, although agreements were also pending with Lincoln Financial Field and Citizens Bank Park.

What could go wrong with this, except incompetence and corruption? Even after the city severed its contract upon learning that, among other things, Doroshin had established a for-profit arm for his scam and siphoned off vaccines for private use, Mayor James Kenney and Public Health Commissioner William Farley warmly endorsed Doroshin’s “work.” Their resignations are pending, as is that of the City Council. Philadelphia, in a word, needs a new government.

Drexel’s thus-far exceedingly muted response to the scandal has been to deny any knowledge of or participation in it by anyone beyond a few bad actors it’s not responsible for. Let me sell you a bridge with that. Drexel has a medical school and a public health program. Doroshin’s contract with the city was abundantly publicized. Really, no one at Drexel saw anything to flag here? Right on.

If this were a one-off episode we could perhaps call it a freak occurrence, at least as far as Drexel was concerned. But, scroll back a couple of weeks in your Philadelphia Inquirer and you will find the story of one Gauravjit Singh, who has been arraigned in federal court in Newark on a charge of bilking over $700,000 from two companies that had contracted to provide New York City with medical gowns from a factory in China. There was no factory; there are no gowns. And there is no more money.

Singh, who lives in Philadelphia, also does business in New Jersey and Florida, and operates a drone-building startup called Dronecast. Like Doroshin, who also has numerous irons in the fire, he does more than offer phantom gowns for hard cash.

Singh, too, is a Drexel graduate.

When I came to Drexel, it was best known for its engineering programs. Engineers design and make things. Drexel engineers were known nationally for doing this well. Gradually, business and finance became Drexel’s calling card. It redefined itself as an “entrepreneurial” university and opened a school specifically dedicated to entrepreneurship. It also gave itself a motto, prominently displayed all over campus: “Ambition can’t wait.”

Andrei Doroshin and Gauravjit Singh are beginning to give us an idea of what these slogans may mean.

I don’t mean to suggest that Drexel teaches fraud. But the business world is awash in it. The CEO of Goldman Sachs recently took a pay cut of $10 million for a scheme that will cost his company billions in fines. That leaves him still with a heftier paycheck than yours or mine, $17.5 million. What, fire him? Please, no kidding. Wells Fargo is still in business after opening millions of fraudulent accounts to siphon off its customers’ deposits, among other “enterprises.” It’s still doing much the same thing. Jail its managers? Nationalize its operations? Perish the thought.

Drexel does indicate where it thinks merit is to be rewarded in conferring honorary degrees — you know, things the rest of us have to work for. One of its recipients was Carl Icahn, who pioneered corporate raiding in the Reagan 80s, and is still in business. Another, I’ve just come to notice, is Rudy Giuliani, who received a doctorate from Drexel’s Law School in 2009. Rudy’s latest achievement, as you’ve no doubt heard, is to have joined Donald Trump in inciting the insurrection that led to the storming of the Capitol Building by an armed mob and that, but for a merciful Providence and a thin police line, might have eliminated the legislative branch of government, or at least its personnel.

Drexel’s Faculty Senate has called, by a vote of 43-3, for the rescission of Giuliani’s degree. John Fry, our entrepreneurial president, needs time to think about it.

We know, John. It’s a really hard call.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Capitalism, Covid, and Drexel

Reframing American Democracy

It’s not, alas, true that democracy has “prevailed” wit

Unfortunately, it’s untrue to say that democracy has “prevailed” with the inauguration of President Joe Biden, despite his hopeful — and also self-interested — pronouncement to the country. Democracy has just been given a fighting chance, and the odds against it are long.

To begin with, our highly imperfect party system gave us the imperfect man who is now to be our president: the Joe Biden who opposed school busing, embraced segregationist colleagues, lied about his own academic record, sponsored mass incarceration and an expansion of the death penalty, helped facilitate financial collapse with the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act, gave us Clarence Thomas for the Supreme Court and voted for the Iraq War. Lest we forget, too, the Party establishment that installed him also aborted the primary system that was meant to give a measure of popular choice to the selection of presidential candidates. If that was democracy in action, give me the old smoke-filled room again. At least we wouldn’t have to breathe the cigars.

Oh, I did vote for Biden, but that was not my democratic choice. It was the only choice I had, unless I wished to see democracy expire. It meant four more years without a rational health care system while dealing with a pandemic; ongoing wars that we lost a generation ago; and an electoral system where corporate “citizens” have free speech and actual ones have effectively none.

Mind you, I wish Biden well in whatever he can accomplish, starting with the single priority we all share: getting vaccinations in our arms as quickly as possible. And I grant him his rhetorical excess in what was a decent Inaugural Address. After all, when Franklin D. Roosevelt told the country in the midst of the Great Depression that it had nothing to fear but fear itself, there were in fact a few issues to genuinely worry about (including the survival of the political and economic system).

Part of the problem Biden will be dealing with is that there is now only one major party whose leadership is even notionally committed to democratic process. The fracture and collapse of what remains of the Republican Party is imminent, and if Donald Trump proves the occasion of it, we will have at least that to thank him for.

The Republicans came into existence when the Whig Party failed. It served its purpose in abolishing slavery, and betrayed it by selling out Reconstruction. It became Wall Street’s mouthpiece and has remained that ever since. When Roosevelt said he welcomed the Party’s hatred against his efforts to end the Depression, he gave it exactly what it deserved from everyone but the super-rich. Nothing has changed since except the Party’s determination to cling to political power at all costs, culminating in Trump’s attempt to steal the 2020 election by baselessly accusing the Democrats of doing it instead.

Nor did the false claim come from Trump alone. Even just hours after the Trump-incited riots against the election results — a goon squad exercise in autocracy that could have eliminated the legislative branch of government at one fell swoop — a sizable majority of Republican House representatives still refused to accept Biden’s victory. No comparable scene had been witnessed in an established republic since Roman consul Sulla’s dictatorial seizure of power more than 2,000 years ago — followed by proscription lists in which the assassination of his political opponents was publicly invited.

In our strange case, however, the principal target was Mike Pence, whose name was on the very same ballot that Trump claimed for his own, on a gallows erected on the Capitol steps.

Representative democracies need organized groups to encompass divergent opinion and function effectively. Responsible conservative parties are part of this spectrum. The present-day Republican Party is neither responsible nor conservative, but a clique devoted to winning and holding power by any means necessary. It is incompatible with democratic government as repeatedly demonstrated, and its submission to Trump over the past four years has assured that it will not reform itself.  Nor is this simply a consequence of Trump himself. Republicans have recognized themselves as a minority party since the New Deal, understanding that their only reliable route to power is by gaming the political system by any means available: gerrymandering electoral districts, stacking the courts and dog-whistling racism.

Democrats have not been above these tactics, but they have depended less on them. Republicans, at this point, cannot exist without them. Now they have crossed the red line between partisanship and chicanery to the embrace of a demagogue who rejected the fundamental tenet of a democratic system: accepting the outcome of a free election. What this means, if Biden and the Democrats expect to deal with the multiple crises confronting the country, is to enforce majority rule by all procedural means at their disposal. This means governing more through a ministerial than a presidential system, in which the majority party enacts its agenda without compromise or concession. Roosevelt was able to do this through large Congressional majorities and by bludgeoning a reactionary Supreme Court when it attempted to oppose him.

The ministerial system, such as that in Canada and Britain, has its own system of checks and balances on an errant executive when necessary.  This is far less the case with us, and, under less pressing circumstances, the last thing I would wish to see is a more powerful and less accountable presidency. But I don’t see much of a choice here, at least under present conditions. An opposition party that continues to question the legitimacy of an elected president and whose guiding principle is obstruction is not a participant in responsible government. In fact, with a Congress now more than three weeks in session, McConnell has not yet yielded Senate committee majorities to the victorious opposition.

If the Democrats expect to govern, they’d better snap to it. I thought the GOP was finished after the disastrous presidency of George W. Bush, which started with a judicially upended election and finished with two failed wars and the first major depression since the 1930s. So did Republicans, many of whom expected a generation or more in the wilderness.

They clawed their way back, winning the House of Representatives within two years, the Senate in six, and the White House — in another election, like that of Bush, tainted by a minority popular vote — in eight. Then, Vice President Biden was tasked with gaining bipartisan support for Barack Obama’s signature legislative effort, the Affordable Care Act. He spent a year on this, making one concession after another, and failed to win a single Republican vote in either chamber of Congress.

This is the same Joe Biden who thinks he can play ball now with the same Mitch McConnell. Heaven help him (and us) if he seriously thinks that is possible. Biden has been urged in the media to be “Rooseveltian” in the present crisis. That means not only to come up with big ideas to deal with big problems. It means using the powers of his office, emergency ones if necessary, to put them into action.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Reframing American Democracy

The Last Depravity of Donald Trump

Donald Trump is hitching one last ride on Air Force One, with a planned 21 gun salute to see him off. If anyone ever told him about Caligula and his Praetorian Guard, he might be rethinking the wisdom of this, but Trump could never go out except in a blaze of vainglory. 

I think of Richard Nixon, leaving the White House in August 1974 on a helicopter that would take him to a private departure from Andrews Air Force Base. 

Nixon gave us a brave smile, bizarre and pathetic under the circumstances of a forced resignation, but nonetheless something he had to stitch on — a politician to the last. And he gave us a wave to go with it, awkwardly swift, as if he would like to have wiped off the sky with it. Nixon put the country through a lot of hell, and Watergate may have been the least of it.

In many ways we are still paying for him, and Trump is arguably part of the price. But with all the relief of seeing him off, and all the disgust at what he had done, there was at least a smidgen of feeling for a man fallen from such a height. When he sacrificed his chief minions in a desperate bid to halt his own fall and said he was sorry to do it, you could actually believe that he meant it a bit. Wicked as he was, he was humanly so. You could see in some sense a man who had lived an American tragedy, and brought it on himself.

The same will not be said of Donald Trump. He has been analyzed from almost every perspective in the psychiatric handbook, but the diagnosis that will do is sociopath. A sociopath is one who sees others as only a means to gratify his interests and appetites, and who discards those he exploits without hesitation as soon as they no longer serve him. Such a person can be highly functional, and to all appearances even sociable. He can be a successful businessman or at least a nimble borrower and serial bankrupt; a TV host and personality; a man-about-town and friend of former presidents and pedophiles; even a president himself. Donald Trump has been all these things, and, until the last of them and quite recently, a success by his own measure: he has gotten what he wanted or needed out of each successive incarnation.

Trump’s niece Mary, herself a psychologist, has described his upraising as someone who was taught early that failure was the only sin. No doubt we are all shaped by childhood experience, but we are not simply defined by it: not everyone born to a Fred Trump is fated to become a Donald Trump. At a certain point, you are who you are, and how you got there is less important than what you do. In Donald Trump’s case the result has been uniformly catastrophic. No one, as it seems, who has lived with or worked for or associated with him has been anything but the worse for it. And that would seem as good a definition as any for having encountered a sociopath.

Notoriously, what Trump has always demanded of everyone about him is the unquestioning subservience he calls “loyalty,” namely, complete subjection to his wishes and unstinting devotion to fulfilling them. This is what he directly asked of his FBI Director, James Comey, as related in Comey’s sworn testimony. The concept that Comey, as head of the Justice Department’s chief law enforcement agency, might have any higher obligation — say, the public welfare — simply did not and could not occur to him. And, by extension, the notion that Trump himself, as the man chiefly charged with that welfare, had any responsibility beyond his own will and interest, was utterly alien to him. The country had put itself in the hands of something worse than a dictator, since even a dictator can have objectives beyond himself. But a sociopath does not, and a sociopath is, in political terms, a tyrant.

The remarkable thing about Trump is the extent to which he was able to command the loyalty he demanded, long before he ascended to political power. Of course, he bestowed rewards and paid for results. The extent to which he corrupted those who served him, however, cannot be simply explained in these terms. His personal attorney and fixer, Michael Cohen, has testified that he personally threatened some 500 individuals who in one way or another crossed Trump’s path, not merely with suits or harassments, but bodily harm. This is not the way a practicing attorney usually behaves. And Cohen has confessed that he did so willingly, as someone for whom Trump’s wish was an unquestioned command. We can say that Cohen was a shyster and a hoodlum and is now a liar, although I don’t think that simply explains the case. It is in any event hardly unique. Four-star generals and U.S. senators suffered similar degradation at Trump’s hands, and the work demanded of them was often far worse than the errands Cohen was dispatched on.

There is a particular case that stands out, however, and hopefully will not be matched again. That is Trump’s now former vice president, Mike Pence. Pence’s job was simple: to serve under all circumstances serve as Trump’s verbal shadow. The task was simple, but not always easy. Trump would contradict himself from one day to the next, having no settled policy or purpose except self-aggrandizement, and little enough memory of what he might say from moment to moment. Pence, though, never missed a beat, seconding the boss with uncanny devotion, praise and echo in one. His performance was so good — and so shameless — that, alone in the circus of Trump’s servants, he escaped Trump’s public ridicule.

His hoped-for reward, after eight years of moral prostitution, was succession to the presidency. The pandemic upended that, turning Trump’s likely reelection into a decisive defeat. His efforts to overturn it uniformly failed and led, finally, to the Constitutionally-mandated tabulation of state certifications in Congress on Jan. 6, a ritual presided over by a vice president whose sole function was to announce the tally. When Trump ordered Pence to void it on the basis of his rejected claim of fraud, his loyal servant could not do so without being deposed from the chair. Trump thereupon incited an insurrection against Congress in which the Capitol Building was occupied by an armed mob that, among other things, called for Pence to be hanged from a gallows presumably erected for the purpose. Pence’s peril was not his alone. His wife Karen, his elder daughter Charlotte, and his brother Greg were together with him in the building. All might have been killed. As it happened, the mob missed sight of Pence by a matter of seconds. Trump had all but ordered the assassination of his vice president and, at discretion, most of the members of his immediate family.

He then sat down to watch the outcome on television. Let’s just say that again: an American president sought to overturn a national election and then egged on a mob to kill his vice president and family for failing to do it for him. Of course, a mass slaughter of others, including the entire Congress, could have well ensued too.

Never in modern history has the sitting head of a country attempted to provoke such a thing against his own people. It is now being said that Donald Trump has been the worst president in American history. No. He is simply the most depraved man in the country. And, unless local courts can successfully try him for lesser charges he will, to our lasting shame, escape all but symbolic punishment.

That will damage us more than he ever could.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Last Depravity of Donald Trump