Author Archives | Robert Zaller

MOVE: The Shame of the City Without End

When I moved to Philadelphia in August of 1987 to take up a position at Drexel University, the ashes on the MOVE bombing had hardly begun to cool. I knew little at the time about the decision by then-Mayor Wilson Goode to solve a local noise problem by dropping a bomb — not a turn of phrase but an actual incendiary explosive — on the roof of 6221 Osage Avenue, a building in the midst of a crowded West Philadelphia neighborhood. I knew little about Philadelphia itself, having never visited the city before my job interview. I did know, by then, that the resulting blaze on the roof had not only burned down the building below but a good part of the neighborhood around it. I knew that eleven residents of the building, including five children, had been killed in the blaze, with police gunfire greeting those trying to flee. I did want the job, but also a few better answers to the question of how and why Philadelphia had become the first city known to me to have bombed its own citizens.

From the little I had gathered, MOVE was a fringe Black collective whose members had taken the surname of Africa from their self-styled founder, John Africa, who was making the point that all African Americans involuntarily brought to America had been stripped not only of their freedom but their identity, and were known not by their own names but by their masters’. The names they had left behind could not be recovered, and, although some African Americans had adopted new ones — the former Cassius Clay having assumed the most famous one, Mohammed Ali — the new names were as much an arbitrary identity as the ones slaveowners had once given them, even if now freely chosen. The members of MOVE were making a point that could not be made otherwise: that only by adopting the surname that recovered the one identity that could not be denied them, their common place of origin, could they affirm both the heritage that others had attempted to deny them and the bondage in which, symbolically and in fact, they and others like them still lived.

The members of MOVE were not alone in making such a gesture. A Black activist born Malcolm Little had taken the name of Malcolm X, also to discard a “slave” identity; so had others. But MOVE was a commune, dedicated to living together in the city. In the America of the early 1970s — and the Philadelphia of Police Commissioner and then-Mayor Frank Rizzo — after the urban riots of the 1960s and the assassinations of Martin Luther King and Black Panther leaders, such an experiment was not likely to be accommodated.

Wanting to know more, I went to a public meeting about the MOVE bombing on the Penn campus. I made the suggestion that there had been miscommunication on both sides, with a horrific tragedy the result. I was immediately challenged by an angry woman who said I had no idea what I was talking about. Her name was Pam Africa. And she was right.

The MOVE bombing was not an aberrant episode; it was the culmination of a decade-long war that had first escalated in a full-scale police assault against the original MOVE enclave in Powelton Village in the summer of 1978. This was a shootout in which police surrounded MOVE’s property and fired indiscriminately into a building occupied by children as well as adults. MOVE members fired back in self-defense. A police officer, James Ramp, was killed in the crossfire. When the shooting stopped and MOVE members surrendered, there were savage beatings. Although it was never established who had fired the fatal shot, Ramp’s wound forensically indicated it had come from police fire. Nine MOVE members, male and female, were nonetheless charged with murder. All were convicted, and sentenced to life imprisonment. Collective guilt was ordained; collective injustice was meted out. The path to the bombing was laid out.

Two years later, a young Black journalist named Mumia Abu-Jamal was arrested for the slaying of another Philadelphia police officer, Daniel Faulkner, in an altercation involving Abu-Jamal’s brother. With no prior criminal record, he had been publicly targeted by Rizzo. A supporter of MOVE although not a member, Abu-Jamal was tried and sentenced to death before a judge, Albert Sabo, who admitted to perjured testimony and openly declared his intention to “fry the n*****.” MOVE, along with Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and other international organizations, denounced the trial. That was enough. MOVE was now associated with the deaths of two Philadelphia police officers. Vengeance was inevitable. When Wilson Goode proclaimed it a terrorist organization, its offense being disturbing the neighborhood, its eradication was predicated.

Two members of the so-called “MOVE Nine” would die in prison, and a third within six months of his release. All served forty years of a sentence without basis in law. Debbie Sims Africa, who had given birth to her son in prison, was not reunited with him until 2018. The sentences stand; all of the surviving members of the Nine are free only on parole. Ramona Africa, the sole survivor of the bombing, was the only person tried and sentenced to prison in connection with it.

It was not until November 2020 that Philadelphia’s City Council extended an apology for the bombing, one not joined by Mayor Jim Kenney. No compensation was offered to the survivors. No marker indicates the site. But, with the Council statement and the release of the last of the MOVE prisoners, it seemed that a corner might have been turned.

Now, however, the crowning shame has come. The bodies and remains of the incinerated bombing victims, instead of being returned to family members, were held for six months in the city morgue, where they decomposed and were in some cases crushed by machines. Two juvenile bone fragments, one of a pelvis and the other of a femur, were given by a city commission to a Penn professor, Alan Mann, and housed in the Penn Museum’s notorious Morton Cranial Collection. One of Mann’s students, Janet Monge, used videos of the fragments as illustrations in her course, “Real Bones: Adventures in Forensic Anthropology.” She is now a curator at the Penn Museum. Mann retained custody of the bones, and took them with him when he moved to Princeton University in 2001, where they were also shown online. The bones were returned to Penn in 2016, and then to Professor Mann, who denied knowledge of their whereabouts although they were in his home. They belonged, as is now believed, to Tree and Dalisha Africa. They were fourteen and twelve years old, respectively.

I have come to know Pam and Ramona Africa personally. I have learned their story. I have attended their rallies and marched in their protests. They are brave, dedicated, and resilient. What they and their family have suffered can never be sufficiently atoned. This latest insult, the theft and desecration of children’s bones, is an unforgivable obscenity. The city of Philadelphia burned these children alive. Its principal university knowingly profaned their smallest, most pulverized remains. No amends can made for this. Philadelphia can only live with its shame. And we must all bear it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on MOVE: The Shame of the City Without End

The look in Derek Chauvin’s eyes

What America does, the world sees.

The trial of Derek Chauvin for the murder of George Floyd was broadcast internationally, and it was not simply an American audience, myself included, that was spellbound in horror at what the digital recording by Darnella Frazier revealed about nine minutes and 29 seconds of our national life. Equally horrific things go on around the world in one way or another every day. Some of them directly or indirectly involve us; for example, the wedding parties or funerals in places like Yemen and Afghanistan that get bombed to smithereens by our drones. Some of them go virtually unnoticed or at least unacted upon, like the recent civilian massacres in Tigray on the contested Ethiopian-Eritrean border. Some of them are slowly being enacted in real time. Vladimir Putin has his knee on the neck of the imprisoned Alexei Navalny as surely as if he were physically present to do it, and if Navalny dies, the crime will be all of Russia’s to avenge. And sometimes the larger crime is the failure of an entire judicial system to hold a hate murder to account, as in the case of the killing of a 65-year-old Frenchwoman, Sarah Halimi, tortured and thrown to her death from the window of her apartment for the crime of being Jewish.

It’s America the world looks at, though. That’s partly because we are rich and powerful. But it’s more importantly because we were the one nation to emerge from the 18th-century Enlightenment, whose preeminent ideal was—summed up in the words of our first lawgiver, Thomas Jefferson—that all men were created free and equal.  

Jefferson belied his own words in uttering them as a slaveholding plantation owner, which he remained to the end of his days. But he knew, at least, that what he inherited and would bequeath was a curse that he felt would undo the nation he and his fellow founders had made. He was very nearly right, and it took 700,000 lives, North and South, to lift the curse. More than a century and a half later, we have not dealt with its legacy. Yet, contemporaries in Europe still looked at our Civil War as not only the trial of a distant country, but as something on which their own hopes and futures were staked. That’s why, a quarter of a century later, the French gave us the Statue of Liberty to stand in the harbor of our greatest city. It was meant to remind us, and them, of the promise we had given.

Because our promises were great, our sins seem greater.

Which brings us to Derek Chauvin’s eyes. 

There were a lot of eyes at the scene where George Floyd was crushed to death. Floyd’s own, thrust against the police tire where his face lay, his head striving vainly for air, unable to see the man who was taking his life.

There were the eyes of Chauvin’s fellow officers, holding down Floyd’s legs or scanning the bystanders who slowly assembled on the sidewalk opposite to stare and beg for Floyd’s life. There were the passersby who walked or drove by, and merely glanced.

It’s because of the steady gaze of Darnella Frazier’s camera, though, that we can see Derek Chauvin and his eyes directly from first to last.

Prosecutor Stephen Schleicher, in his trial summation, said over and over again to Chauvin’s jurors that they could believe what they saw with their eyes. That’s not always the case, or enough of it.

But the weight of the evidence was, finally, the weight of Chauvin’s knee on Floyd’s neck, minute by minute until the end, and even after.

We all saw the act, and the law told us what to call it.

What we have no name for, no name that begins to be adequate, is what appeared in the eyes of Derek Chauvin himself. The counts against him—second and third degree murder, and second degree manslaughter—do not accuse him of intentionally causing Floyd’s death. It could not be said that, as the law would require, Chauvin meant to purposefully kill Floyd while he did so, except in the sense that his whole life and career, and our entire national history, stood behind it.

The prosecution had a photograph, labeled Exhibit 17, showing Chauvin in the act of causing Floyd’s death. You see in it the effort and concentration to keep his knee applied to Floyd’s neck, but also (so to call it) a certain abstractedness too. Part of it was the confidence of a man physically in control of a situation he had created and determined that no one would challenge it. Chauvin was doing what we know he had done before; for instance, another man was similarly treated by him, face down in a puddle of water and also begging for air.

That episode had lasted 10 minutes and had not been fatal. Chauvin thus knew from experience (and how many experiences?) that he could do to others what he was doing to Floyd, that he could walk up to the line without stepping over it, or necessarily facing any consequences for it if he did: the initial report of Floyd’s death had mentioned only a “medical incident” in the process of an arrest. Chauvin knew that he could act with impunity, and that the power of life and death was in his hands. And when he threatened the bystanders opposite him with mace if they gave him difficulty, it was with the knowledge that they, too, could not impede him.

But it is through the entirety of Frazier’s recording that we can scrutinize the full panoply of expression on Chauvin’s face, above all in his eyes. The human face is a wonder of expressiveness, the moment to moment register of a life. The nearly nine minutes and 29 seconds of it captured by Frazier that coincided with Chauvin’s taking of a life is remarkable both for what is there and what isn’t. Chauvin’s body is fully engaged in what it is doing: his features, beyond the level of consciousness required for the performance of any deliberate act, are not. He is doing what he has done before and will do again, knowing himself invulnerable in the moment—his control of the situation, as he knows, is total, and all he needs to project to onlookers is precisely that self-knowledge. He can, in this moment, permit himself a certainty, a lassitude, such as a king might feel when he has uttered a command he knows will be obeyed. The command, when given, exists in a different realm, no longer a part of the king’s will but of the subject’s obligation. Chauvin, of course, is not only giving the command but executing it for himself as well. In this sense, he is more than a king: He does not need subjects, only (if they are present) witnesses who observe but are powerless to intervene.

You cannot do such a thing without at some point becoming robotic yourself. That is what I saw in Chauvin continuing to kneel on Floyd’s unresponsive and finally lifeless form for a full three minutes after he had ceased to breathe. It was the paramedics who had to pull him off Floyd; he could not release him. Morally, he had entered the realm of death himself.

Derek Chauvin is not a monster. He is a man we have permitted to become monstrous, and the question is whether we will continue to permit others to be so too. It is a question of whether we want to continue not only as a democratic society, but a civilized one.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The look in Derek Chauvin’s eyes

No Exit: The American Withdrawal from Afghanistan

“The wrong war, at the wrong place, at the wrong time, and with the wrong enemy” —  so General Omar Bradley described Douglas MacArthur’s push to extend the Korean War into China in 1951. We did get a war with China, and what is misnomered the Korean War should really be called the Sino-American War. 70 years later, no peace treaty has formally ended it; it was the first of our forever wars, the latest of which, in Afghanistan, we are now trying to quit.

Let me say that I give Joe Biden credit for his announcement that we will at last end our formal military “commitment” in Afghanistan, 20 years to the day after it never should have begun. It is hard to say you have lost a war, and for an American president almost fatal — just ask Richard Nixon. But Biden had, in a sense, no choice, at least morally. Although he supported the war at the beginning along with almost everyone else, he had concluded by 2009 that it no longer had an objective, and that the surge in forces being pushed then by the Pentagon was only a further waste of blood and money. We know this because Barack Obama, in his recently published memoir, singled Biden out as the lone voice opposing the surge in his administration. Since it did in fact fail, Obama might have seemed forthright not only to admit his own mistake, but to credit Biden for seeing it. What he really did, however, was to box his former vice president into a corner. If he had thought the war a lost cause 12 years ago, how could he defend it now? If it was the right thing to do, it was also the thing he finally had no choice about. The rap will be his to take.

What got us into Afghanistan in the first place? That unhappy nation had become a pawn in our Cold War with the Soviet Union, whose invasion of the country in 1978 triggered 20 years of carnage. By 1996, the Taliban, a group of Islamic militants originally recruited by us, had declared themselves the government. They proved convenient targets after the World Trade Center attacks, because Al Qaeda had bases in the Afghan hinterland, and Osama bin Laden, the self-proclaimed mastermind of 9/11, was their “guest.” But the Taliban had no direct role in 9/11, which was operationally carried out from Hamburg, Germany, and if any state actor was implicated in it it was Saudi Arabia, whose government had long funded terrorism. Attacking our principal Arab ally was unthinkable, however, not least because of the long-standing business connections between the Saudis and the family of President George W. Bush. Afghanistan was a handy substitute.

Bush was trapped from the first in his own lies. The Taliban, easily routed at first, agreed to surrender their weapons. That, however, would not satisfy the thirst for vengeance Bush had whipped up, in part as a distraction from his own failure to heed the intelligence warning of a coming attack on American soil. The Taliban, once our creature, had to be crushed in its entirety, and a democratic, secular, pro-Western government installed in its place. Some Taliban leaders, and Osama himself, found refuge in Pakistan (where much of the Afghan war was actually fought), or in the Pashtun tribal areas where the Taliban had their chief base of support. A long guerilla war ensued. Meanwhile, our puppet government in Kabul became a sink of corruption, and the army we trained to fight for it had no interest in anything but wages and looting. It was Vietnam all over again, and by the time Biden entered the White House, the Taliban, stronger than ever, had virtually encircled the capital. Air power, our only weapon, was the one thing that held it back. But air power never controlled a country, and the Taliban have only to bide their time. It has been waiting us out for a decade, and it can wait us out a little longer.

Biden intends to withdraw the 2,500 regular military we still have in the country, which is no more than a tripwire against the recapture of Kabul. That will leave an indeterminate number of Special Forces and contractors, but they will not be an official presence: only the last to go. We’ll also have an embassy, with a force to protect it. I assume helicopters will be at the ready when it’s time to evacuate.

What will happen when we go? The Taliban never fully controlled Afghanistan even when they were in power, and the warlords who contested them a generation ago will do so again. Outside powers will also have an interest, especially Pakistan and Iran. India will oppose Pakistan as it has before; we will oppose Iran; China will see opportunities; and Russia will want to counter Beijing. It’s called the Great Game, and it’s been played in Afghanistan for thousands of years. One way or another, we will no doubt be part of it. Great Powers have never been able to leave the place alone, or learn the folly of their meddling. The British, who were much better at empire than we are, got their comeuppance in Afghanistan. The Russian invasion of it would trigger the collapse of the Soviet Union. Even Alexander the Great couldn’t conquer it. It’s a desperately poor country. But the Afghans have enjoyed their own chaos for a long time. They will again.

What do we believe behind? An estimated 241,000 dead, all in vain. A generation of Afghan women, about to be thrust back into the Middle Ages — we will see how many of them we accept as refugees, or how many are able to escape at all. A further legacy of hatred for us in the Muslim world. And what is it we bring home? The almost 800,000 men and women who have rotated out of our longest official war, many maimed in body or spirit, and many simply embittered as the veterans of Korea, Vietnam and Iraq were before them. You saw some of them storming the Capitol on January 6, or among the 22,000-strong “Lobby Day” march, barely reported, later that month in Virginia. All wars have a cost. It may be that ours has only begun.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on No Exit: The American Withdrawal from Afghanistan

There Is No Constitutional Right to Bear Arms

The Second Amendment to the Constitution is among the most debated 30 words in American history: “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”

If one reads only the last 14 words of this sentence, it seems to unambiguously affirm the right of citizens to gun ownership. But that’s not what the sentence as a whole states. The 16 words that precede them limits such ownership to a single purpose, namely participation in a “well regulated Militia.” This phrase, subtended by its intended purpose, means participation in a state-authorized force for the protection and preservation of the Commonwealth.

In plain English (and this is about as plain as you can get), Americans may own guns to use for service in a militia; that is, a body of armed men defending the security and integrity of each of the several states of the Union. It did not mean a federal land force, for which the appropriate term was “army.” There was no such force in existence when the Constitution was ratified in 1787, the army of the Revolutionary War having been disbanded. The First Article of the Constitution envisioned such a force, and a navy to go with it, but left its provision and support to Congress.

This might include the use of state militias to enforce federal laws and to “suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions,” but only under command of officers chosen by the states themselves. The president was to be the Commander-in-Chief of such forces and of state militias when pressed into federal service.

In short, the federal forces were to be substantially composed of state militias. Commanded by the president, they retained their own officers and were dependent on biannual appropriations from Congress. They were not to be a standing force, but raised and supported for as long as necessary. The intent was that the militias themselves were to be the only permanent military force in the new nation. This may seem strange to us, but the Revolutionary Army itself was largely composed from colonial militias, and there was deep suspicion of standing national armies. With this in mind, we can better understand state militias themselves.

They were the only regular armed force in the country. Lacking permanent arsenals of their own, they were dependent on the private arms of those who joined them. Without such private ownership, they would have been impossible to maintain as constituted.

Private or semi-private militias (and such did exist as in the slave patrols of the South) were potentially dangerous, and thus the militias for which weapons might be kept by gun owners themselves were described as “well regulated,” i.e., authorized by and subject to the states. This, then, was the only gun ownership protected as a right under the Constitution.  Of course, guns had other purposes too. They were used for hunting and occasionally for self-defense. Like any other commodity, they could be lawfully purchased, sold or inherited.

They could also be regulated, with laws governing their acquisition and use. In a rural society, their uses were obvious. But their possession existed as a right for one purpose alone—militia service. If you were not eligible for such service, your ownership of a gun was, subject to whatever rules pertained, only a legal entitlement. But it was not a right, and it certainly would not have been singled out by a Constitutional amendment except for its necessity in the common defense.

That necessity no longer exists.

State militias and federal forces maintain their own arsenals, and so the Second Amendment is an anachronism, relevant to a former time but not to ours. It should thus be repealed, as it no longer serves any purpose.  There is precedent for this in the 21st Amendment, which repealed the language of the 18th Amendment prohibiting the use of alcohol. A simple act of repeal would not make gun ownership illegal, but merely subject to the same requirements and restrictions as any other commodity. State and federal laws would govern its possession and use.

In fact, many such laws already exist and have for a long time. The problem is that there is little will and less capacity to enforce them, and that they do not begin to address the culture of fear, greed and social pathology that makes the gun industry the great untouchable of American life.

If there is a single great impediment to rationally approaching the gun problem, however, it is the Supreme Court’s 2008 decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, written by Justice Antonin Scalia and adopted by a 5-4 Court majority. This stated that the ownership of firearms was a Constitutional right “unconnected with service in a militia” and to be upheld as such, subject only to the restrictions governing other protected rights. Not since the Dred Scott decision declaring slavery to be a Constitutionally-protected property right has any Court made a more brazen, not to say outrageous ruling. With a stroke of the pen, Scalia struck 16 words from an Amendment to the Constitution, namely tying gun ownership as a general right to military service. His excuse for this was that the clauses containing these words were merely “prefatory,” whereas the clause that followed them was the “operative” one. Since those first clauses set out the conditions under which the last one obtained, Scalia was not only literally rewriting the text of the Constitution, but the laws of grammar as well. Several hundred thousand gun deaths later, we can gauge the effects of Scalia’s pen replacing that of James Madison.

As Justice John Paul Stevens pointed out in a scathing dissent, Heller overturned a prior Court ruling in U.S. v. Miller that had banned the ownership of sawed-off shotguns on the basis of their inapplicability to militia service, a decision upheld for seven decades. The only remedy for Scalia’s mischief, Stevens wrote, and the logical one in a modern society, was to revoke the Second Amendment itself, the course I have favored here. This would not ban gun ownership itself. It would simply eliminate it as a constitutionally protected right to serve a purpose that no longer existed.

That could facilitate the enactment of essential gun laws, and perhaps even give legislators the courage to pass them. And that might give us something on our nightly screens beside the unending stream of massacres in malls, playing fields, schools and churches that make us the spectacle of the civilized world.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on There Is No Constitutional Right to Bear Arms

What Does Drexel University Want to Stand for?

Be careful whom you honor.  The Swedish Academy gave its Nobel Prize in Literature to Gunter Grass, at the time generally recognized as Germany’s most important postwar novelist, and, in certain ways, its social conscience.  But Grass had left something important out of his vita, namely that he served late in World War II as a member of the SS.  That news made things look a little different.  Too late, though.  You can take certain things back, but not, at least so far, Nobel Prizes.

Honorary academic degrees normally attract little attention.  I’ve never quite been able to figure out what they’re for, since, unless they’re given to past or prospective donors, there is no necessary connection between the institutions that grant them and those who receive them.  The general idea, though, is that both backs get scratched a little.  The institution basks in someone else’s fame, possibly fleeting, or the recipient is associated with a place more or less reputable.

It seems harmless.  But sometimes there’s blowback.  Such was, and is, the case with the degree granted Rudy Giuliani by Drexel’s then-Mack School of Law in 2009.  There was no good reason to grant it to Giuliani twelve years ago.  There is every reason, and necessity, to withdraw it now, and no conceivable reason not to, unless Drexel wants to align itself in perpetuity with the man who most publicly assisted, abetted, and to a significant degree orchestrated the recent attempt to overthrow the Constitution of the United States.

Giuliani started out as a liberal Democrat who voted for George McGovern in the 1972 presidential election.  Seeing a career opportunity, he abruptly embraced Reagan Republicanism after 1980, and was rewarded, first with the Assistant Attorney-Generalship of the Justice Department, and then as the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York, in which latter capacity he won a name for himself prosecuting Mafia crime families (but also the reproach of erstwhile mentors and allies for prosecutorial overreach and misconduct).  On a second try, he was elected mayor of New York, and was given credit for reducing the city’s crime rate through aggressive stop-and-frisk policing that grossly violated minority rights, and, in several notorious cases, resulted in torture and homicide.  (The crime rate in the city had in fact already been declining steadily.)

Then came 9/11.  Giuliani appeared to rally the city and even the country in its aftermath, and Oprah Winfrey declared him “America’s mayor.”  A more careful analysis of his performance showed not heroism, however, but gross negligence and misjudgment before the event, indifference to the health and safety of first responders and New Yorkers generally, betrayal and contempt for the afflicted and the dead, and personal profiteering on a grand scale.

The World Trade Center had been attacked by terrorists before, in 1993.  Despite its evident vulnerability and against all expert advice, Giuliani insisted on locating the city’s Office of Emergency Management—its essential command and control structure—in the Center, along with a large quantity of flammable fuel.  After 9/11, Giuliani tried to place the blame for this decision, which had been wholly his, on the head of the OME director, Jerome Hauer, only to be publicly confronted with Hauer’s eight-page memorandum opposing it.

The 1993 attack also revealed the wretched obsolescence of the Fire Department’s radio communications.  Giuliani refused all requests to modernize them, with the result that the equipment failed when 343 firefighters were ordered to evacuate the burning towers eight years later and never received the command, trapping them fatally.  Giuliani subsequently lied to the 9/11 investigative commission, saying that the firefighters had refused to evacuate but insisted on continuing to remain in the burning buildings.  Their deaths, with those of many others they might have helped lead to safety, were on his head.  So, in addition, were those of first responders tasked with cleaning up the WTC site, who lacked adequate protection gear, including respirators (which Giuliani discouraged, as presenting a bad image).  Instead, resisting attempts by federal agencies to evaluate health conditions in the city, Giuliani insisted that the air around the site, and for New Yorkers generally, was safe.  It was not.  New Yorkers continue to die prematurely from their exposure to lethal chemicals to the present day.  Giuliani has never acknowledged or taken responsibility for these additional deaths, whose full tally may never be known.  But perhaps the ugliest aspect of the story was his haste, after gold and silver deposits in the World Trade wreckage had been fully recovered, to remove the remains of still-unidentified victims, including firemen, who were in some cases deposited in Staten Island’s aptly-named Fresh Kills Landfill.

That was the man Drexel honored in 2009.

The man who betrayed his city has gone on to betray his country.  As lead counsel for his then-law firm, Bracewell & Giuliani, he defended PurduePharma, the company whose relentless promotion of opioids triggered the deadliest drug epidemic of the past generation.  He worked to discredit the Mueller Report.  He ran shotgun for Donald Trump’s efforts to pressure Ukraine to dig up dirt on Joe and Hunter Biden, a blow against the American electoral system that resulted in Trump’s first impeachment.  Giuliani’s own multifarious contacts in Ukraine included ones with, among others, Dymytry Firtash, characterized by the U.S. Justice Department as an “upper echelon” associate of “Russian organized crime.”  Giuliani himself is currently under investigation for, among other things, bribery, money laundering, obstruction of justice, mail and wire fraud, conspiracy to defraud the United States, and failure to register as a foreign agent—by the Southern District of New York, the court he once headed.

All that, though, pales beside Giuliani’s efforts to discredit the result of the 2020 U.S. presidential election, including more than five dozen state and federal lawsuits brought by him and dismissed with astonishment and contempt in court after court.  Nor was this merely Rudy’s personal sideshow, but part of a concerted effort to overturn the election, capped at last by the funding and deployment of the armed mob that stormed the U.S. Capitol on January 6 to prevent the certification of the election by Congress itself.  That mob, shortly before it moved on the Hill, had been addressed by Giuliani himself, whose message to it was, “Let’s have trial by combat.”

That wasn’t mail fraud.  It was treason.

The next day, President Brennan O’Donnell of Manhattan College condemned its alumnus, Rudy Giuliani, as among “the loudest voices fueling the anger, hatred, and violence” that drove the Capitol mob, calling his conduct “a repudiation of the deepest values of his alma mater.”

Four days later, the New York State Bar Association, responding to hundreds of complaints, initiated proceedings to remove Giuliani from its membership.  On the same day, a suit for his disbarment was filed with the New York State Supreme Court.  The day after that, Middlebury College revoked its own honorary degree to Giuliani, describing his behavior as “an insurrection against democracy itself.”

From Drexel?  A near-unanimous resolution to withdraw Giuliani’s degree from its Faculty Senate, seconded by a resolution from the Executive Committee of Drexel’s AAUP Chapter, a petition from the Law School’s student body, and a letter from a group of emeritus faculty.  And, after, two full months, complete silence from the University administration, the Board of Trustees, and, not least, the Law School itself.

Does bad news just go away when you don’t respond to it?  For Drexel’s own upper echelon, the answer is apparently yes.

My favorite characterization of Giuliani’s legal team in Pennsylvania was that of State Attorney-General Josh Shapiro, who called its members “nutballs.”

Is that how Drexel wants to rebrand itself now?  As Nutball University?

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on What Does Drexel University Want to Stand for?

What Losing Socialism Has Cost Us

“Socialism” (or its even scarier cognate, communism) was for a good part of the 20th century the equivalent of what COVID has become for us, the terrible virus that lurked everywhere and perpetually threatened destruction to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

After the Bolshevik Revolution, it had a home, at least theoretically, in the geographically largest nation in the world, Russia; and after 1949 in the most populated one, China. The fight to contain or roll it back was called the Cold War, and the potential cost of doing so, in the Atomic Age, was the destruction of the planet — a cost from which successive administrations did not shrink, at least until the nuclear standoff called the Cuban Missile Crisis brought us to the brink of actual disaster. Future historians can look back and make some sense of that if they are able to.

Russia shed communism in 1991, or what had supposedly passed for it. China did not repudiate its own version of it, but slipped quietly into the autocratic capitalism it faces us with today. Republicans like to keep the bogeyman of Communism alive, still attached to even mildly helpful initiatives such as President Joe Biden’s relief and infrastructure bills, but, since hardly anyone still remembers what the word was supposed to mean, they interchangeably denounce “liberalism” or “progressivism,” signifying anything that involves the government with the exception of tax cuts for the rich or voter suppression laws. If politics, as George Orwell suggested, is the art of corrupting language to the maximum possible extent, then-Senator Mitch McConnell and Representative Matt Gaetz have few peers. It has to be admitted that Soviet Russia and Communist China had little to do with anything Karl Marx would have understood as socialism, collective ownership of the means of production.

Looking at them with rose — or red — colored glasses, Americans vaguely identifying themselves as liberals or socialists saw in them what they wanted to see up to about 1970, namely societies that sought to promote the general welfare rather than the wealth of a few. And it was true that, in theory, this was the professed goal of so-called socialist states. That perception had real-world effects, particularly as the capitalist world wrestled with the devastating effects of the Great Depression of the 1930s that virtually shut the global economy down. If capitalism could lead to such systemic paralysis, why not give communism a try? The result of this was a mid-century period when developed Western countries experimented with something called social democracy, namely the attempt to graft populist reforms onto a capitalist framework. This was galvanized by World War II. The fight against Nazi Germany had to be one not only against tyrannical fascism but for something else. “Democracy” alone — parliamentary governments whose leaders were chosen by popular vote — would not fill the bill, since it had not prevented an economic collapse that had exposed transparent social injustice. And in the wake of the war, communist parties in France and Italy had come uncomfortably close to winning national elections with their programs.

To forestall the possibility that Soviet-style communism might not only succeed by violent revolution or military occupation but peacefully at the ballot box, Western leaders undertook to offer reforms premised on the idea that stable prosperity was compatible with, and indeed dependent on, government-supported welfare programs. This was enunciated in President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s so-called “Four Freedoms” speech of 1941, which included a “freedom from want” that defined economic security as a basic human right. Roosevelt meant this as a permanent extension of the social commitments of the New Deal, while in Britain, the Beveridge Commission envisioned a broad postwar program to create what would come to be known as the welfare state. Nor were these merely national initiatives; Roosevelt and Prime Minister Winston Churchill jointly affirmed the principle of social welfare in the Atlantic Charter, and it was universalized after the war in the United Nations Declaration on Human Rights.

The grand rhetoric of freedom from want did not mean an abandonment of the national interests of the victorious Western powers, or of capitalism, with its boom and bust cycles of prosperity that made economic insecurity a standing threat. The fine print of Roosevelt’s promise enjoined worldwide free trade and tariff reductions, which favored advanced industrial countries at the expense of developing ones. Britain, which elected a Labour government in 1945, did go some distance toward a welfare state, creating a national health care system and, for a time, nationalizing some basic industries and services. In most of Western Europe, a system of social services was instituted, including government-run or regulated health care, child and elder care and unemployment benefits. Strong union pressure contributed to much of this, but underlying it was the fear, particularly acute in the postwar period, of Soviet expansion. Russia had occupied most of Eastern Europe during the war, asserting political control over it and introducing its version of communism, with state ownership of the means of production, centralized economic planning and a one-party system. It advertised itself as more stable, efficient and socially just.

As we have seen, it had considerable appeal through communist political parties in the West. And, somewhat more belligerently, it was backed by the world’s largest army, which had just defeated Adolf Hitler. All these reasons, and the additional problem of resettling millions of war-displaced refugees, impelled West European governments to play a more active role than they had formerly, including the provision of social benefits. Some of their policies might have occurred in the ordinary course of events.

Some, such as urban policing, public education and sanitation, were already in place. But the prime impetus for the welfare state was the challenge of the communist model. Western states could tout the benefits of freedom and opportunity. But economic security was precisely what the capitalist model had failed to provide, and what a planned economy with guarantees of subsistence and benefits seemed to offer. In the ideological battle between capitalism and socialism, the former had to demonstrate what, besides spasmodic growth and sudden contraction, it could work.

The welfare state was the West European answer. The U.S. did not follow suit, except for an expansion of public sector post-secondary education. It was not until the mid-1960s that a very limited public health program, Medicare, was instituted for seniors and the disabled over the fierce opposition of the medical profession, and a so-called War on Poverty, abandoned far short of its goal, was undertaken as the only general effort to realize freedom from want in the richest country on earth. America has been very generous to its wealthy, but for the rest of the country, any effort at social equity has been routinely decried as “socialism” — a term that carries its own terrible if never precisely defined opprobrium.

These events have coincided with a massive turn to the right in the past half-century. The reasons for this are many, but perhaps the major one has been the abandonment of socialism as a coherent ideology and a political goal. This climaxed with the fall of the Soviet Union, whose last leader, Mikhail Gorbachev, admitted catastrophically that, after seven decades, it had not achieved true socialism. With China, too, now a  de facto capitalist society, there is no present alternative to the capitalist order. It seems no coincidence that we are also on the brink of ecological disaster and global anarchy. The question to be asked perhaps is whether socialism, with its dream of a just and egalitarian society, failed us, or whether we failed socialism.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on What Losing Socialism Has Cost Us

How Close We Came to Tyranny

Spring has arrived, and a responsible federal government is back in Washington, D.C. We’d all like to get back to business, namely dealing with a global pandemic, creating a green economy (the only kind we can afford) and having a baseball season that runs from April to October.  While we do that, it is worth pausing for a moment to think about the nightmare we inflicted on ourselves and have only just begun to escape.

We were ruled, not governed, for four years by a demagogue whose aim was autocracy and whose instinct was tyranny. We need to understand how such a man could have ascended to the highest office of the world’s oldest democracy. We must weigh the damage we suffered from him and appreciate the difficulty we face in undoing it.

Let us begin with the man himself: Donald Trump, a cheap grifter with an insatiable ego who had staggered through four decades gaming the bankruptcy system in casino gambling and real estate speculation, skirting the seamier edges of celebrity culture but always on the edge of its contempt—a clown, in short. That such a man could aspire to, let alone achieve a place of responsibility in a mature political system should have been unthinkable. But circumstance conspired to offer him an opportunity in the middle of the second decade of our century, and, with a gambler’s throw, he seized it.

Trump battened on a carcass called the Republican Party. It has been a matter of courtesy for some time to call the Republicans a party, in the sense of a political grouping with the capacity for national government.  The last Republican to run for president with any sense of purpose or fitness for the job (apart from Dwight Eisenhower, a war hero whose candidacy was sought by both major parties) was Herbert Hoover, whose humanitarian relief work in post-World War I Europe saved many lives but tragically failed to meet the challenge of the Great Depression.

Eisenhower gave a leg up to Richard Nixon, whom he chose as his vice president. He also gave free rein to the most dangerous demagogue to precede Trump, Joe McCarthy, and acquiesced in his party’s characterization of the New Deal and the battle against fascism as “twenty years of treason.” One could go on through the story of Ronald Reagan and both Bushes, but suffice it to say that by the time Trump announced his candidacy in 2015, the Republicans—having lost the trust of most of their constituency—were ripe for a hostile takeover by an outsider whose chief appeal was that he had no connection to the party, having spent most of his life a registered Democrat.

That got Trump halfway home. He should, in any functioning system, have been dead meat in a general election—his opponent, Hillary Clinton, famously confessed her incredulity at not being supported by three-quarters of the country. But, in Clinton, the Democrats had nominated the second most unpopular political figure in the country after Trump himself.  It might have seemed, and perhaps it was, as if both parties had a death wish. And that wish nearly came true, for all of us.

What gave Trump the presidency—apart from Russian meddling, voter suppression, Jim Comey and an Electoral College that installed the loser of the popular vote? It was, put simply, that he ran against both political parties, even if under the nominal banner of one. His victory said one thing, loud and clear: that the country, or at least a very substantial proportion of it, was fed up with the political process as it stood, and it was willing to roll the dice on someone who gave voice to that sentiment. Trump the gambler took us all into the casino. Literally, no one knew what to expect of him. And that was precisely his appeal: he was the hammer to smash the anvil.

Trump himself most likely had none but the haziest idea of what he intended, other than to enjoy the power that was suddenly his and to profit from and cling to it as long as possible. He proceeded at first with relative caution, relying on the operatives and opportunists—a Reince Priebus, a Steve Bannon—who surrounded him. But his underlying instincts soon began to emerge. His first was that he needed a populist base of support independent of any institutional party and loyal to him alone. He achieved this, in classic demagogic style, by holding massive post-electoral rallies featuring himself alone; it was to be, throughout his presidency, his chief occupation. Sure enough, his followers crawled out of the corpse of the Republican Party (with a fringe of Independent voters and former Democrats) and became his.

Trump had beaten his first opponent, the Republican Party, and Party elders now offered him their obeisance. His next target was the government itself. He attacked the courts when they opposed him; he neutered Congress, bypassing it with a flurry of executive orders and negating its legislative authority by undermining its laws and its power of the purse. His main target though was the Executive Branch he headed, and he aimed to make it a pure instrument of his will. He recast the Justice, Commerce, and Agriculture Departments as political tools and forced agencies—from the hydra-headed Intelligence bureaus to the National Weather Service to the Centers for Disease Control—to bend their data and expertise to his will.

Those agencies he saw as mere impediments, such as the State Department, he simply ignored, taking over their functions himself. He lavished money on the military but humiliated a succession of generals unwise enough to agree to serve on his cabinet or staff—the former being the institution he gutted most directly, forcing its secretaries to grovel in praise before him in a scene unprecedented in the history of any democratic country. In a coup de grace, he inveigled the chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff to accompany him in a rout of peacefully protesting citizens outside the White House.

Most presidents have role models among their predecessors; Trump simply pronounced himself the greatest president of all, with a nod only to the last president to openly war with his government, Andrew Jackson. But his true admiration was reserved for despots such as Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, whom he praised for guaranteeing themselves life tenure in power. It was that, as he made clear repeatedly, that he wished for himself, masking his intention only under a casual veneer that hardly concealed it. And it was that goal he pursued, from refusing to accept the possibility of defeat in the 2016 election to rejecting the fact of it in the 2020 one, and then waging the campaign to overturn its result that culminated in the lethal attack on Congress that he summoned and commanded—a near-reenactment of the Reichstag Fire that consolidated Adolf Hitler’s power in Germany in 1933.

We came closer to losing our country on January 6 than all but a few have admitted. It took a world war to deal with Hitler, but Donald Trump is alive and well, still undealt with and still effectively in command of a Republican Party whose ruins he walks on. Our institutions held, but barely, and the oligarchic, antidemocratic elements in our political culture have if anything more deeply rooted themselves. Yes, there’s a new sheriff in town. But, as Will Kane learned in “High Noon,” one man’s badge alone won’t save it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on How Close We Came to Tyranny

The Era of Minority Rule

The story of party politics in America is a tangled one, but that of the past 50 years is particularly instructive. It has been during that time that a majoritarian two-party system in the United States steadily transformed into a minoritarian one, thanks to a relentless assault by the Republican Party on the fundamental principles of popular democracy. That assault has only intensified with the election of Joe Biden and the present paper-thin majorities enjoyed by Democrats in both Houses of Congress. It has now arrived at a crisis.

The Founding Fathers didn’t want a party system, and they didn’t want democracy either. Rather, they wanted a “republic” that would act as a buffer between the notionally sovereign people and the actual exercise of government.

Only for the “People’s House,” the House of Representatives, was there a direct popular vote for all free male citizens, themselves a minority of the country. Senators were chosen by state legislatures, and the president and vice president by an Electoral College whose representatives were typically (but not necessarily) bound by the popular vote—a questionable practice still with us today.

After the contested election of 1800, the vice presidential election was folded into that of the presidency, so that the selection of the vice president is automatic with the choice of the president. This means that the president chooses his potential successor in the event of incapacity, death or impeachment: a monarchical authority worthy of an Old Regime despot.

The people of the United States thus have no direct choice in either of the two national offices provided by the Constitution. The problem of creating a national government at all in the 1780s was that of reconciling the evident need for such an authority with the interests, suspicions and discords of the 13 former British colonies, now become “states,” each with its own government, courts, laws and militia. It was a heroic feat to accomplish this, involving numerous compromises, most importantly ones for the accommodation of slavery. Farsighted observers, including the slaveholder Thomas Jefferson, saw the issue of slavery as the one likeliest to undo the new Republic.

In 1860, with the election of the first successful presidential candidate of the new Republican Party, Abraham Lincoln, the moment of division arrived. The Republicans were not an anti-slavery party as such, nor was Lincoln an abolitionist. The issue of slavery, however, made them de facto Federalists, the term applied in the debates over the new Constitution to those who favored a strong central government against the anti-Federalists, who wanted to preserve as much state sovereignty as possible. What Lincoln wished was not to abolish slavery—much as he personally detested it—but to preserve the Union.

Lincoln saw that the only way to do so was through the civil war at last forced upon him by Southern secessionists, and he did not hesitate to fight it to the last drop of blood required. That blood, as it turned out, was his own. The Unionist Republicans turned, rapidly enough, into a party of commerce, industry, monopoly and, by the time of Teddy Roosevelt, imperialism. What they rejected was the more sophisticated form of imperialism represented, in Roosevelt, by internationalism.

America would make its own way in the world on its own terms—by conquest. This was misnomered isolationism. America’s job was not to mind its own business but to impose its model of it. With the end of World War II, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Harry Truman persuaded Congressional Republicans to join the effort to make the world safe for American interests. This was called the era of bipartisanship, a consensus about how America, with its nuclear monopoly, was going to rule the world. It meant creating a global system of military alliances and bases and fighting regional wars when necessary.

By 1952, Republicans who had bitterly opposed entering World War II were happy to nominate one of its heroes, Dwight D. Eisenhower, to be president, and in 1964 Barry Goldwater, who contemplated nuclear war with equanimity. If Republicans had, by and large, adopted the postwar Democratic playbook on foreign policy, they were also compelled to accept the essential features of the New Deal, including worker unionization and welfare programs. This was because, after 1932, they had become the minority party they have been ever since.

Democrats controlled both Houses of Congress routinely until the 1990s and the presidency in every year between 1933 and 1969, except for the administration of Eisenhower, a nonpartisan figure courted by Democrats and Republicans alike. Not until 2017 were Republicans able to control both the White House and Congress, and only then thanks to the one-term presidency of Donald Trump.

Within two years, Democrats had won back control of the House of Representatives. Now, albeit narrowly, they once again control both the presidency and both Houses of Congress. These are theirs to lose; Republicans cannot win them. By the early 1970s, Republicans came to realize that they were a quasi-permanent minority. Under a political master, Richard Nixon, they began to reinvent themselves as a neo-antifederalist party based on racism and cloaked in “states’ rights,” a new class war that emerged from the 1970s politics of scarcity, and a coalition of groups largely united by cultural fear and resentment.

All politicians lie; so do all political parties. But the Republican Party itself became a party of lies, beginning with Nixon’s own—not only those about the Watergate scandal that brought him down, but also the fictitious existence of a “silent majority” of Americans alienated by the social protest of the 1960s. A majority that’s silent, you see, is a contradiction in terms, because to be part of any majority is by definition to speak or act. Nixon’s “silent majority” was a political fiction, an empty container into which he hoped to pour inchoate prejudices and resentments. Above all others was racism, the most easily manipulated prejudice of a society only just beginning to come to terms with a 350-year legacy of slavery and its Jim Crow successor.

From that came Ronald Reagan’s “welfare queens” of the 1980s, George H. W. Bush’s unabashed appeal to race in the Willie Horton ads of his 1988 presidential campaign, and finally the brazen race-baiting of the Trump years. From that lie proceeded all the rest: that cutting taxes for the rich spurred prosperity for all (what George H. W. Bush aptly called “voodoo economics”); that slashing essential public services in education, housing and transportation simply drained the so-called “Washington swamp”; and that economic deregulation promoted not unchecked monopoly and financial crashes but healthy competition and “creative destruction,” in the long-abused phrase of Joseph Schumpeter.

Still, this could not produce reliable victories without an election in 2000 marred by Supreme Court intervention (ironically, an usurpation of the unquestioned jurisdiction of a state court) and another in 2016 by foreign interference and voter suppression. Both cases denied the clear winner of the national popular vote office. The logical result of these shenanigans was not only Donald Trump’s refusal to acknowledge his defeat in 2020 but of the majority of Republicans in Congress, who have yet to acknowledge Joe Biden’s election despite the physical attack fomented against them by Trump on Jan. 6.

The reason given for this is their fear of Trump’s ire and that of his supporters. But the real one is perhaps simpler: Republicans don’t lose because they mustn’t lose, and so no opposition party can legitimately claim victory under any circumstance.

There’s a word for that, but it isn’t democracy—or republic, either.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Era of Minority Rule

What Donald Trump Can Do For His Country

The Donald is back. He wowed them at the Conservative Political Action Conference in Orlando—normally a sedate affair as such things go, but this time Trump was cheering on his concluding address like a revivalist tent at white heat. For people outside the tent, namely the majority of the country who drove Donald Trump from the presidency only four months ago, it looked like a banished nightmare come back to life. But I’d like to tell you why we should welcome Trump back and encourage him to stick around. Yes, he inflicted desperate damage on the country, and that damage continues—Donald Trump is not merely a demagogue but a destroyer, pure and simple.

But there’s one thing that needs demolishing in the land, and Trump is the man to do it. That is the Republican Party. The Republican Party began with Abraham Lincoln and ended up with Donald Trump. That’s a heck of a long way down. From Reconstruction, Republicans moved within a generation to Wall Street. They haven’t budged since except, briefly, under Teddy Roosevelt, and they kicked Teddy out.

The Republicans have been a minority party since the Great Depression, and the presidents they elected have ranged from the dismal to the disastrous. Dwight Eisenhower: the war hero who beat Adolf Hitler, hid under the sheets while Joe McCarthy tyrannized the country. Barry Goldwater thought of nuclear war as an elaborate picnic. Richard Nixon was, well, Richard Nixon. Ronald Reagan crushed unions, killed what was left of the New Deal and sabotaged the government he supposedly led. George W. Bush lied us into two wars we are still fighting and brought us the greatest economic collapse since 1929. And those are only the highlights. I don’t want you to think I’m too fond of Democrats.

For generations, they made a deal with the Devil to enable segregation in the South. They got us into our biggest wars. On the whole, they got along perfectly well with Wall Street themselves. But for a modestly liberal wing that makes noise but not policy, they are a right-of-center party. We could use a progressive party in the country. Maybe even a new conservative one, although the Democrats fill that bill pretty well. But right now they are the only party we’ve got. And our politics won’t go anywhere until we have cleared the debris that still calls itself the Republican Party.

Some Republican intellectuals (and I used the word advisedly) have been appalled at what Donald Trump has meant for the party and have left it.  Some politicians have retired or gone into the wilderness. But, for those who hope to resuscitate it, it’s worth looking at what they argue it’s really about. John Thune, the Senator from South Dakota who serves as Mitch McConnell’s Minority Whip, recently put the case this way to CNN: “Do [House Republicans] want to be the party of limited government and fiscal responsibility, free markets, peace through strength and pro-life, or do they want to be the party of conspiracy theories and QAnon?” Let’s unpack this a bit. The federal bureaucracy has grown steadily through Democratic and Republican administrations alike; it’s the nature of the beast.

What Republicans have done is cut essential services and regulatory functions or shift resources from where they’re needed (for example: public schools, public housing and public health) to where they’re not (for example: new weapons systems that keep the military-industrial complex flourishing). Reagan cut the federal public health budget by 30 percent, and it’s been progressively starved, particularly by Republicans, ever since. That’s what made us such easy pickings for COVID-19.

Fiscal responsibility? From 1969 to 1993, Republicans controlled the White House for 16 of 24 years. There was never a balanced budget in that time or in 12 years after under George W. Bush or Trump. As Dick Cheney famously said, Ronald Reagan taught us that balanced budgets don’t matter—unless Democrats are in the White House, as he forgot to add. Free markets? Yes, with tax cuts, subsidies, write-offs and “incentives” that have fostered monopolies, propped up dysfunctional or climate-destroying industries, shifted the tax burden onto a middle class whose steady decline has resulted in bitterness, division and—Donald Trump.

Peace through strength?  Pick your missile. Pro-life? Perish the thought if Roe v. Wade were ever repealed. But there are votes in promising it. John Thune tells us exactly what the Republican Party is not, has not been and never will be. The reliably vapid David Brooks, writing recently in The New York Times, concedes that the Republican Party is now the captive of “an apocalyptic personality cult,” meaning of a leader he dislikes. But, he says, it can come back as a “multi-racial, working-class coalition” that will also be “a champion for those who didn’t complete college, don’t want to leave their hometown for the big city, [and] have a set of traditional values centered around their faith.”

What world is David living in? The Republican Party embraced racism when the Civil Rights Act cracked the Dixiecrats’ stranglehold on the South in the 1960s; Ronald Reagan sweet-talked this into the Party’s DNA and Donald Trump blared it, throwing xenophobia and anti-Semitism into the bargain. Reagan snared a disaffected white working class abandoned by the Democrats, and blue collar workers followed Republicans for a generation until they got the message that they were worse off than ever.  Imagining the party that shuns a $15 minimum wage is going to retrofit itself as the friend of the working stiff is downing the Kool-Aid with a chaser of bleach. And as for that near-zero population that was a dying breed in Thornton Wilder’s “Our Town,” good luck there.

David Brooks’ party is three-fourths fantasy and one-fourth ghost. The fact is that Republicans have been a minority party since the 1930s. It has no core but the corporate class that funds it.

It wins elections only when Democrats lose them, as after the Korean and Vietnam Wars. It has no strategy for victory except suppressing Democratic votes, and so, in 43 states, it has introduced over 250 bills aimed at doing exactly that since the November elections.

It fell naturally into the arms of a Donald Trump, a man dedicated to serving only the simplest and ugliest interest: himself.

It had, and has, no other place to go. So, let Trump finish the job of killing off a bankrupt and moribund party at long last. Yes, he won 46.8 percent of the popular vote for president in November. On that same day, his nationwide approval rating stood at 34 percent. Republican politicians would desperately love to escape him, but he has consolidated a base around himself—a majority within a minority—that they dare not offend and cannot win over.

They can only be taken down with him. The risk in this is that Trump will spread his personal toxicity further, and that is a serious consideration.  But he can’t win the presidency again and will only pull down candidates yoked to him. Individual Republicans for whom one might have had a modicum of respect have left the scene or been fatally marginalized. The rest of them have sold their souls, many long ago. Now their time has come.

Let’s give the Devil a chance to collect.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on What Donald Trump Can Do For His Country

Half a million, and counting

The official American death toll from COVID-19 has now passed 500,000, with the last 100,000 in the past month. That is, by an unchallengeable margin, the largest loss of life to the virus of any country in the world. And we are still only 4 percent of the world’s population.

Congratulations, America. Who says we’re not still the world’s leader?

It once seemed unthinkable but is now very likely that we will surpass the estimated toll of the 1918 flu pandemic: 675,000 lives. There was no vaccine for the flu then. We have two for COVID, with a third in the works and a fourth widely distributed in Europe. China has its own vaccine. As does Russia. And India. They all work, and they all work off the same medical technology, stimulating antibodies without injecting the activating components of the virus.

This doesn’t mean that you should try to make your own homebrew. But it does mean that many other large laboratories—those of Eli Lilly, for example, or of Merck, or of the federal government itself—could be producing already approved vaccines in quantity, thus eliminating the artificial shortages that have repeatedly shut down vaccination sites across the country, so that at present only 5.5 percent of the population has been fully vaccinated. As thousands die.

Pray ask, why?

Welcome to American medicine.

Capitalist medicine is the largest and most profitable sector of the American economy. Your tax money, as well as what is left as your own, pays for it. Sure, it delivers a service, one that ranks us (the last time I looked) in a tie for 37th place with Slovenia for health outcomes. And leaves us with no competitor anywhere for cost.

Medicine now runs not on prevention and care, but drugs and vaccines. We manufacture the diseases we suffer from, and then the cures for what we’ve created. We created the COVID pandemic, of course not purposely but as a consequence of habitat destruction and poor health protocols. Now there’s a killing to be made off it, thanks to patents. A patent is a government-issued monopoly for new inventions, whose ostensible function is to encourage such inventions and the investments they typically require. They are thus a guarantee of profit.

Not all inventions, even if successful, are profitable. That’s where marketing comes in. And the medical industry, particularly its pharmaceutical branch, is remarkably ruthless and successful at promoting its products and nostrums. Think, please, of the opioid pandemic, still very much with us. Some useful but addictive medicines for severe pain were sold as quick hits for minor discomforts. Doctors were partly bribed and partly pressured into prescribing them. The result was not only death but major social breakdown, even to the ruin of whole communities. But it made a lot of dough for a long time.

Pfizer and Moderna, the companies that produced the COVID vaccines used by us, have already profited handsomely. That is particularly the case with Moderna, a relatively small company that had never produced an FDA-approved product before. The Trump administration capitalized it to the tune of $400 million, and it came through—or rather, the scientists who worked for it did. It risked nothing but a non-existent reputation. It rakes in pure profit.

Now, I’m not begrudging Moderna the reasonable rewards of its success. But its product belongs to the public because we paid for it, and in the midst of a pandemic, its production and distribution, as rapidly as possible, is the only arguable concern. The federal government has the authority to compel this. The Trump administration did not do so. The Biden administration has not. Pfizer declined government funding for its vaccine but was guaranteed government purchase of it, so that we are refunding its costs and insuring its profits. It, too, can be compelled to share production and distribution with others.

To put the matter simply: If there are a dozen roads out of hell, why should we be limited to two? Of course, production is no better than its distribution. That, in a country of 330 million people with thousands of jurisdictions, was going to be the far more complicated task. The Trump administration gave little (if any) discernible thought to it, since no question existed for Trump beyond Election Day. The result was that, as in the case of all dealing with the pandemic, the 50 states were left to face all problems arising from vaccine distribution. Once again, the Biden administration has been unconscionably slow to act.

What could have been done, and what should now be done? The federal government should, from the beginning, have asserted and enforced binding protocols for masking and testing. Such protocols should have extended to the order and priorities of vaccination, based on health agency advisements and in consultation with the states.

There was general agreement that the most vulnerable sectors of the population ought to be first vaccinated, namely those in (largely unregulated) nursing homes and those designated as essential workers, a category generally if vaguely understood to include those performing vital economic and medical services that brought them unavoidably into contact with others. After that, vaccinations were to extend downward chronologically to senior citizens and then to the general population.

That, lacking the necessary oversight, control and funding, has been a colossal mess. Who gets the vaccine first is one question; how and where is another. Since supplies are erratic and drastically insufficient, there is no predictable delivery. Since there is no mandate about how to serve particular areas, there is no way of knowing from day to day what is available and to which sites. Hospitals? Clinics? Pharmacies? Large halls and convention centers? Sports stadiums? Back alleys? How do you reach the housebound? What do you do with counties that have no hospitals or stadiums? Who is a qualified, supervised distributor?

As we know, Drexel has made its own minor contribution to the chaos.  Perhaps it will be a footnote, someday, in the history of Philadelphia. As for the story of COVID-19, when it is finally told, it will be one of many small and largely anonymous acts of dedication and sacrifice, and one very large one of lives lost for nothing except for incompetence, irresponsibility and greed.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Half a million, and counting