Author Archives | Robert Zaller

Employees forced to settle, benefits plan offers no alternatives

Come each November, something called “Open Enrollment” comes along at Drexel. You can elect to buy into any changes in your benefits that are offered during this period, or, by taking no action, you retain your previous benefits (though not necessarily their costs, of course).

This year is a little different.

Drexel has been quietly — very quietly — working on a new retirement plan for the past two to three years. The University sprang it on faculty and staff at the beginning of the fall quarter. You can take it, but you can’t leave it, since this isn’t a modification of the existing plan but a replacement of it “in toto.” You must “elect” the new plan, because the alternative is … nothing.

That’s just a bit Orwellian now, isn’t it? An election is, supposedly, a choice between options. Even in a political election you get to choose between the lesser of two evils, though you’re voting for evil either way. But the new Drexel retirement plan is sort of like the choice your mother gives you when you don’t like what’s on your dinner plate: “Okay, you can either eat it or go to bed hungry.”

Except that we aren’t children anymore, are we?

I inquired whether the faculty senate had approved the new plan, at least as regards faculty. Well, no, the senate had seen the plan (after it was finished, of course), and had, um, discussed it. But it didn’t have any right of approval because, well, employers can change their benefit plans at will. Shared academic governance at work, see?

Actually, I don’t. When I chaired a faculty senate at a former institution, my colleagues and I directly negotiated raises, benefits and employment conditions with the administration. The idea of springing a fully formed plan on the faculty to effect a major change in retirement benefits at the last minute would have definitely been a nonstarter.

Robert wouldn’t have liked it, nor would the chair of the faculty Benefits Committee, who knew more about the subject than the guy who wrote the Employee Retirement Income Security Act law in the first place. And no one wanted to mess with him.

So, what does Drexel’s faculty senate think about the new plan? Since it hasn’t communicated the slightest information about its deliberations to the faculty, it’s kind of hard to know. After all, this is a body so open in its dealings that you have to use a PIN to even gain access to its meeting agendas.

You’d think — maybe — that the senate would want to give its opinion to the faculty it supposedly represents on a subject like the replacement of its retirement plan. If it has, I haven’t heard it. But, really, does the faculty senate still actually exist?

It was AWOL when the University cut the customary lump sum retirement payment in half a couple of years ago. It has had nothing to say about years of merit salary increases that fall laughably short of the cost of living. It does have a website and an office. It holds its own elections. But is that proof of life?

I say all this without pleasure. I wrote the original draft of Drexel’s faculty senate charter, and I served in it for a while. I have devoted a fair amount of my academic career to collegial governance, and I believe strongly that any academic institution without it is a merely a corporation with a sweetheart tax dodge. But, we are where we are, and not at Drexel alone.

Let us then examine the new retirement plan together, at least as far as it is available. When I requested a copy of the plan contract — you know, the written statement of objectives, procedures and obligations that will reciprocally bind you and the University — I was told it hadn’t been written yet.

So, dear friends, you will be “electing” a new plan whose contents and conditions don’t legally exist. All you have is a partial and selective statement of intent. It’s less than a promissory note. How about betting your future on that?

Still, let’s make do with what’s been vouchsafed us. The present Drexel plan — the one being scuttled as I speak — is inadequate, we’re told, because it sets aside (upon vesting) only 11-13 percent of one’s paycheck toward retirement. That, according to insurers and actuaries, isn’t enough.

The proper percentage, they say, should be in the range of 15-17 percent. This is because retirees are living longer, and running up more expenses — medical expenses, in a word — than previous generations.

The old benchmark for retirement income was that it should be 80 percent of preretirement wages or salary. The new one is 85 percent, and, because of the elimination of defined benefit plans (once the norm) and the relative decline in Social Security payments, achieving and maintaining that level is a crapshoot for whose final responsibility universities have now washed their hands.

When I started out in academia, my defined benefit plan plus Social Security was designed to replace roughly 75 percent of my working income, leaving me with only five percent to chip in on my own to reach the 80 percent goal. That sounds like Nirvana today.

How is Drexel’s current plan structured? You have to contribute a minimum of two percent of your income as a share of the retirement pool, which the University matches on a sliding scale as you gain seniority with escalating contributions of seven, nine and 11 percent.

You can voluntarily increase your own share, but, if not, you max out at 13 percent (two percent plus 11 percent), of which 15.4 percent comes from your end, and 84.6 percent from Drexel’s.

That doesn’t sound bad, but it only gets you to a 13 percent layaway. You can, however, put in more money on your own, assuming that your Drexel salary lets you afford it. Under the old plan you could, for example, get to the new recommended savings threshold by putting in an extra four percent of your earnings.

Drexel wouldn’t match your new contribution, wouldn’t in fact add a dime: your new calculus would be six percent plus 11 percent equals 17 percent. Drexel would still be putting in most of the money, but your share of it would jump from 15.4 percent to 35.3 percent.

What this means, though, is that you could still reach the recommended 17 percent level under the old plan by self-funding.

Lots of Drexel employees couldn’t afford it, but some could. Thus, there was no need to change the old plan to reach the recommended contribution. How, then, does the new plan help you get there more painlessly?

The answer is, it doesn’t. The maximum University contribution is still 11 percent. What’s different is that Drexel will no longer put in more money than you do at the lower rates of employee funding. If you put in the minimum two percent, that is, you won’t get a seven or nine or 11 percent match from the University. You’ll get two percent, and, despite what the villain in Orwell’s “1984” would have you believe, two plus two is still no more than four.

But — isn’t that catastrophic? If salting away 13 percent of your income isn’t enough for a secure retirement, how can four percent be?

Well, the good news is that if you put in that six percent as in our previous example, the University will not only match you with six percent of its “own” money (of course, all the money is yours, because the University earns nothing but what your labor earns for it or what donors or granting agencies are willing to put into it because of your fine work), but it will add a so-called bonus sum of three to five percent.

That gets you back to 17 percent; it gives you, in fact, exactly the same result the old University plan offered before — but only for those high rollers able to pony up their six percent stake. For everyone else, just reaching the old 13 percent level will require a substantially higher personal contribution.

Work harder. Earn less. Have a more precarious retirement, if you can afford one at all. It’s the American way. Thanks to the new retirement plan, it’s the Drexel way too.

Heads we win. Tails you lose. And have a nice day.

Robert Zaller is a history professor at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post Employees forced to settle, benefits plan offers no alternatives appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Employees forced to settle, benefits plan offers no alternatives

Nazis working for US government

As everyone knows, there was a considerable brain drain from Nazi Germany in the 1930s as leading artists and scientists, many of them Jewish, sought refuge in the United States.

Of course, there were still enough Aryan brains on hand to devise the V1 and V2 rockets, the first true weapons of mass destruction. These were considerably trumped a year later by the American invention of the atomic bomb, but, still, first is first.

After the war, American occupation authorities in Germany scarfed up as many Nazi scientists as possible. True, they’d served the most demonic regime in the history of mankind, but a brain is a brain, and what was the point of letting the Russians get hold of them instead?

Most of our new guests kept their heads down and worked quietly for our Cold War military, but one made himself a household name. This was a handsome devil named Wernher von Braun, who, voluble and charismatic, became the approved face of the good German scientist who worked for freedom and democracy.

By rights, von Braun should have been played on the screen by someone like the late Maximilian Schell, a matinee idol with a slippery smile and a accent. Instead, Stanley Kubrick cast Peter Sellers as the title character of his “Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb.” The versatile Sellers also played the American president for whom Strangelove was chief science advisor, suggesting how easily we can become what we use.

The idea of using Nazi assets in the struggle against godless Communism came from Adolf Hitler himself, who suggested late in World War II that America join forces with Germany in a crusade against Russia. A few ears were receptive to this, the most notable being those of Gen. George S. Patton, Richard Nixon’s favorite hero. But nothing came of it … apparently.

True, within a few years we had indeed made common cause with West Germany in the fight against the Soviets. This new Germany was certifiably “denazified,” to use the official term of art for purging the more egregious war criminals from positions of authority.

Of course, the only truly impeccable Germans were those who had spent the 12 years of the Third Reich in concentration camps, and not many could boast of such credentials. After the major surviving Nazis had been dealt with, there was little further talk about wartime atrocities and exterminations, while the Germans, for their part, refrained politely from bringing up the subject of saturation bombing.

Still, German and some other immigrants to the U.S. were questioned about their personal history since, technically at least, there was no statute of limitation on war crimes committed under the Third Reich. No serious background checks were conducted, however — why, after all, drag up the unpleasant past with a new ally — and a sizable number of Nazi operatives got through.

Only after decades the fact were investigations against Nazi operatives pursued, in good part as a result of the efforts of the privately funded Simon Wiesenthal Center, whose business was to hunt down Nazis who had slipped between the cracks or even had covert invitations.

The exposure and publicity generated by the center, along with what one might call the popularization of the Holocaust, resulted in belated government efforts in the U.S. and Germany to check bona fides. Some elderly retirees who had worked in America were dug up and deported — not for their crimes but for having falsified their application forms.

A problem arose, however. The deportees mostly qualified for Social Security benefits after working in the U.S. and those who did were receiving them. Each case was an embarrassment and prosecution was difficult.

It’s not particularly easy to demonstrate the facts of events 50, 60 and even 70 years ago, and not a happy thing to have to explain over and over why justice had been so long delayed. As a means of quietly disposing of these cases, therefore, the Justice Department availed itself of a legal loophole to persuade Nazis and their collaborators to leave the country voluntarily in return for retaining their Social Security income.

Dozens, including suspected former SS guards, took up the offer. They landed, unheralded and unannounced, in unsuspecting host countries that found themselves providing social services of their own for the “refugees.”

There are still four living beneficiaries of this program whose checks are being cut this month as usual. One of them, Jakob Denzinger, a former guard at Auschwitz among other concentration camps, lives in a spacious apartment in Croatia with a nice river view. His son, who still lives in the U.S. as a citizen, defends his father’s entitlement to the high life: after all, hadn’t he paid his taxes like everyone else? Uh-huh, in the country he sneaked or lied his way into in the first place.

Why be so kind to Nazis? Only a week after the story of the Social Security caper broke, the other shoe dropped.

It wasn’t just that war criminals had found easy refuge here — see that nice old man next door who always waves to children on their way to school, just as he once did when they were going to the gas chamber instead — but that the FBI and CIA actively, no, “aggressively” recruited Nazi operatives to do little jobs for them such as fingering supposed Communist sympathizers in the United States itself, and these groups may well have assisted their entry in the first place.

After all, who better to ferret out undesirables than those who had done such as a skillful job of hunting down Europe’s Jews and Gypsies? And we aren’t talking about pikers here, mere SS guards and such. We’re talking about, people like Otto von Bolschwing, a mentor and top aide to no less than Adolf Eichmann, a chief architect and implementer of the “Final Solution.”

No wonder it was so hard to track down Eichmann himself, who was hiding in plain sight in Buenos Aires. When the Israelis got to him themselves, Bolschwing appealed to his CIA handlers for protection and got it. This, according to his son Gus (who is still alive), “shouldn’t have happened.” The understatement of the century, don’t you think?

Meanwhile, the Justice Department had under pressure opened an office to seek Nazis in hiding in the U.S. — the same office that would make those generous little Social Security deals for our no-longer-wanted guests to leave quietly.

When the CIA was forced to reveal information about its own operatives, it was on the understanding that no prosecution or deportation would ensue. In other words, the small fry might go. But the worst of the worst could stay.

It’s no secret that spy agencies employ unsavory characters; not many turncoats are idealists. But the Nazis run by J. Edgar Hoover’s FBI and Allen Dulles’ CIA weren’t ratting out their own kind; not only did the U.S. have no interest in pursuing the likes of Eichmann and Josef Mengele, but, after the theatrics of Nuremberg were over, to do so would have been counter to our perceived geopolitical interests.

What useful intelligence, though, could Hoover and Dulles have hoped to extract from their Nazis? Any information they had would have been years out of date, and, unlike the clever von Braun, they had no special expertise to lend.

In the fashion of their kind, they told their employers what they wished to hear, but any other set of dubious characters could have done the same. The only conclusion one can draw is that Hoover, Dulles and their like wished to employ Nazis, in part one supposes because their anti-Communism would have been vouched for, but in part because of temperamental and perhaps ideological affinity.

Our cold warriors, inept as they mostly were, liked to consider themselves tough, unsentimental and professional — in fact, not unlike good SS men who sometimes had unpleasant tasks to perform. There was a racial undertone not far from the surface, too: the Nazis had had their Jews to deal with, not to mention Slavs, just as America had its “Negro Problem” at home.

It was J. Edgar Hoover’s FBI who suggested to Martin Luther King that he might like to consider committing suicide and Richard Nixon who rallied in private against blacks and Jews that were not so terribly far from the Nazi-race purifiers.

This was not simply a matter of a few particularly rotten apples in the barrel, either. We know that more than a thousand Nazis were employed by the CIA and the FBI, and, according to one researcher, the number is “probably much higher.” So, how many is that? Five thousand? Ten? America was not merely a secure haven for Nazis on the run, but a second career choice as well. Welcome to the Fourth Reich.

To come back once more to the movies: In 1946, Orson Welles made a film called “The Stranger” about a notorious Nazi who goes underground in a small Connecticut town until he is smoked out by a diligent investigator. In the real world, the villain wouldn’t have had to worry much about discovery. He would probably have had Hoover’s talent scouts all over him in five minutes.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nazis working for US government

US tries to rewrite history with new Vietnam timeline

Three years ago, as we were ending our disastrous war in Iraq, Barack Obama, who first emerged on the national scene by warning against it as a purposeless folly, praised it as a partnership for freedom and democracy with the Iraqi people. I gagged in disgust; perhaps you did too.

Presidents, like the rest of us, often eat their own words, but not usually when they were the right ones to begin with. Barack Obama did more than replace the truth he’d once told about Iraq with a lie; he replaced it with a myth.

The myth is that we fight our wars only for the most noble, disinterested and high-minded reasons, and under the most necessary circumstances. That war, for us, is both a reluctant calling and a sacred cause. That is a lie, one that undergirds American militarism in general.

The trouble with a lie is that sooner or later it requires other ones to defend it. The problem with a myth is that it covers everything with a lie. Obama didn’t articulate the myth of American righteousness back in 2011, but he left it as an inescapable inference.

If a war as discredited and reviled as the one in Iraq, a war itself built on the most deliberate and egregious of lies, was really a fine and principled thing, then which war we could fight would not be?

The other shoe was bound to drop, and it has. The Obama administration is now trying to sanitize the Vietnam War. It is hard to imagine a more unpromising project, but $15 million of your tax have been already gone into it. The price tag in historical truth will be far higher.

The occasion is what is billed as the 50th anniversary of the war. It’s hard to put a precise entry date on it, because we were supporting France’s efforts to hold on to its restored colony in Vietnam from 1946 on, supplanted it as a colonial power in 1954 and had “advisors” deployed from that time on to support the puppet government we created in South Vietnam.

By the time of the Kennedy administration we were already vested in fighting the wrong side of a civil war. If you want a peg to hang the full-fledged conflict on, it might be the alleged attack on the USS Turner Joy, a destroyer off the coast of North Vietnam, in August 1964.

It was that supposed incident that misled Congress into “authorizing” military action (the slippery term that now denotes Congress’ abdication of its war-making powers), and duly led to major combat engagement the following year.

The Turner Joy was never attacked, and President Lyndon Johnson was as fully aware of this as George W. Bush was that no reliable evidence existed that Saddam Hussein possessed so-called weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.

It is said that truth is the first casualty of war. In Vietnam and Iraq, lies got the war going in the first place. They just keep coming.

In the present case, the Pentagon has built an interactive Vietnam timeline on its website. It is suitable for adoption by educators, and it glorifies soldierly heroism, downplays the horrific civilian cost of the war (more than two million dead), and the popular resistance that divided America more deeply than at any time since the Civil War.

It also omits the Senate committee hearings on the war at which John Kerry, now Obama’s secretary of state and a decorated veteran, famously asked the lawmakers, “How do you ask a man to be the last man to die for a mistake?”

Of course, Vietnam was no mere mistake. It was a crime under international law, as the unofficial International War Crimes Tribunal established and headed by British philosopher Bertrand Russell pointed out.

It started with the lie that it was necessary to the defense of the homeland, it proceeded with the lie that it was being won, and it ended with the lie that it had been lost not on the battlefield but because of opposition at home — opposition that negated the heroism the Pentagon now wants us to celebrate.

I wish that last lie were the truth. I fought my own Vietnam War in the streets along with millions of other resisters, and I would like to say that we stopped the government from destroying our country. We didn’t, though.

It was a tireless and resourceful enemy that did, and a disillusioned army that drugged itself out and fragged its officers and, in the end, simply made it impossible to prolong the lie of the war further. Now, the veterans who came home from Vietnam — and the 58,000 who didn’t — are being drafted once more to revive the lie all over again.

As a professional historian I am offended by the attempt to make a noble crusade of one of the ugliest chapters in our history; as a participant in the events in question myself, I am personally outraged. (I wish the members of the legal community would take similar umbrage at Obama’s repeated savaging of the Constitution.)

The issue goes beyond historical accuracy.

What the military planners and the civilian warmongers learned from Vietnam was that distant imperial wars become unpopular when the children of the middle class come home in body bags. They fixed this problem by ending the draft; a volunteer army meant death on someone else’s dime, and the underclass from which it was largely recruited had little voice and less influence.

Just in case, the middle class was phased out too by economic contraction, leaving the pursuit of inequality as the American Dream our brave troops would fight and die for.

It worked like a charm. The mass protests of the Vietnam era are now a distant memory as we accommodate ourselves to an endless war that effortlessly morphs from one theater to another. “Vietnam” itself is a word from another century, of little if any meaning to millennials.

Where history has faded, propaganda now moves in, although Kerry (the Benedict Arnold of our time) and his sidekick Chuck Hagel, Defense secretary and also a Vietnam vet, certainly know the truth they defile. Liquidating history isn’t yet as easy as flushing it down Orwell’s memory hole, but when the Pentagon starts offering “curriculum” to the schools the future is assured.

A few aging radicals, to be sure, have risen to make a final protest. But the canonization of Vietnam is a multiyear project, and it will outlast them. Money has been appropriated; more will follow. Traveling exhibits, sanitized oral history projects, and funded symposia (attention, all scholars) are in the works.

It took a while, but in the new virtual reality world we’re being programmed to inhabit, the Vietnam War will finally be won.

Why bother, though, winning a war that’s been all but forgotten? Ah, but Vietnam is the key to the wars of the future. The myth that must be built to serve them is of American righteousness and invincibility — each, of course, the guarantee of the other.

The truth of Vietnam, even as a distant memory, is still the major impediment to that myth. Therefore, that memory must be rewritten to order. After all, if truth is the casualty of war and our wars will never end, well … you know where we go from here.

Before doublethink descends on us for good, though, there’s a memory of my own I’d like to share. Oct. 21, 2017 will be the 50th anniversary of one of the most important events in the history of our country, one that ought to be remembered along with the Fourth of July and Constitution Day. It was the March on the Pentagon, when tens of thousands of citizens breached the sacred precincts of our military temple and went up to a line of armed soldiers with the purpose of ritually levitating the Pentagon off the ground and depositing it, presumably, on some neighboring asteroid.

Some girls in the front line bared their breasts to the soldiers and placed flowers in the barrels of their guns. It was a picnic organized to defeat a war, but a very serious one. When darkness fell and the cameras could no longer record what happened, the state struck back. Heads were bloodied and limp bodies dragged off.

I breathed something that day, something in the air that had never been there before and has not returned since. It was the pungent, intoxicating odor of freedom — not our enumerated civil liberties, not the decorous take-your-turn of orderly debate, but the wild, wonderful essence of the thing itself.

Get a whiff of it sometime, if you can. It smells of truth.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on US tries to rewrite history with new Vietnam timeline

Convict is the ‘voice for voiceless’

Photo Courtesy April Saul/MCT Campus

Photo Courtesy April Saul/MCT Campus

Goddard College in Vermont marches to a different drummer. It held a commencement in early October, and it invited as its guest speaker Mumia Abu-Jamal, America’s foremost political prisoner.

Mumia is currently serving a life sentence in the shooting death of Philadelphia police officer Daniel Faulkner in 1981. Until his sentence was commuted in 2011, he had spent nearly three decades on Pennsylvania’s death row. His address was delivered via radio hook-up.

Mumia’s trial was the farce of the century — not counting I suppose all those largely anonymous trials below the Mason-Dixon line where white defendants were routinely acquitted of killing black victims by all-white juries between sips of soda pop before the phrase “civil liberties” entered the vocabulary of the South.

He was beaten silly upon arrest, of course, even though he’d been shot by Faulkner. The gun he was (legally) carrying wasn’t given a routine test for ballistics. A local cop falsely alleged that Mumia had loudly boasted of shooting Faulkner on his way to the hospital; the statement wasn’t admitted into testimony but everyone in Philadelphia had already heard it.

Evidence and witnesses were suppressed. Perjured testimony was coerced from local prostitutes on threat of prosecution; this was later recanted. The jury was vetted on racial grounds, a then-common procedure outlawed by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1986 but, although made retroactive, never applied in Mumia’s case because the practice was not objected to in the original trial.

Judge Albert Sabo, a notorious hanging judge who had Mumia bound and gagged in court, was allegedly overheard to remark that he was going to help the prosecution “fry the n—er.” You couldn’t make this stuff up. It was too grotesque to be anything but real. It wasn’t happening in a Mississippi hamlet, though, it was in the City of Brotherly Love.

Mumia has since become an international celebrity; there’s even a street named for him in a suburb of Paris. A professional journalist, he’s written several books in prison and was close to getting a National Public Radio show. The Philadelphia Fraternal Order of Police hasn’t forgotten him, either. It has not only lobbied, protested and demonstrated against every attempt by Mumia to obtain a rehearing of his case, but it has exhibited its wrath — and its clout — against anyone even remotely associated with his cause.

Last March, for example, it succeeded singlehandedly in scuttling Barack Obama’s nomination of a highly respected attorney, Debo Adegbile, to head the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department. Adegbile’s offense? He had once, 30 years ago, signed off on an National Association for the Advancement of Colored People affidavit on Mumia’s behalf.

The nomination was defeated in a Democratic-controlled Senate. Not a single one of the 52 senators who voted against Adegbile had a word to say against his record, nor would any deny that he was acting strictly within the bounds of propriety in Mumia’s case — indeed, within the bounds of any accused person’s right to legal defense and assistance under the law.

We knew that the banks own Congress, because Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois told us so. But it appears that the Fraternal Order of Police is a not-so-silent partner too.

Needless to say, Goddard’s invitation to Mumia outraged the FOP and its political lackeys. That great public servant, Republican State Rep. Mike Vereb, immediately introduced a bill in the Pennsylvania General Assembly to give crime victims and their families the right to bring a civil suit against any offender — even after release from prison — to halt conduct that they claimed would be detrimental to their peace of mind.

Governor Tom Corbett quickly announced his support for the bill, giving voters of the Commonwealth yet another reason to turn him out of office next month.

Behind bars, Mumia has become one of the most eloquent defenders and practitioners of free speech of his generation. Reason aplenty, to be sure, to shut him up. And reason for those of us who value what is left of the First Amendment to ensure that he can continue to be heard. Mumia is an astute and perceptive observer of American politics. Above all, however, he is a voice for the voiceless — the more than two million men and women in our prisons.

But, isn’t Mumia a cop-killer? We will never know with certitude who killed Daniel Faulkner, and we will never know with certitude that it was not Mumia Abu-Jamal. Personally, I have become convinced that there was likely a third shooter on the scene of Daniel Faulkner’s death whose presence was deliberately ignored or covered up.

The Philadelphia police had been gunning for Mumia ever since he had been called out by Mayor (and former Police Commissioner) Frank Rizzo, who told him publicly that his breed of journalists would be “held responsible and accountable” for their writings. The idea of the chief executive of the city threatening a private citizen with harm before witnesses tells you all you need to know about Philly justice 30 to 40 years ago. The opportunity to get Mumia, once presented, was not going to be missed.

Mumia Abu-Jamal deserved a fair trial, whatever the merits of the case against him. What he got was an absolute travesty of the law, a textbook case of political persecution against a young journalist who had become a target by associating himself with two highly unpopular groups, the Black Panthers and MOVE.

What he deserves now, apart from justice, is the right to be heard. That right, if denied to him, is also denied to the rest of us. Goddard College had the right idea. It would be even more appropriate, and significant, for a university in Philadelphia to afford Mumia a similar opportunity — Drexel, for example, would be an excellent place.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Convict is the ‘voice for voiceless’

University opts for retail over academic space

Drexel, a colleague remarked to me the other day, is a university buried inside a shopping mall. Sure looks like it to me.

It’s all a matter of priorities. The 3200 block of Chestnut Street used to be somewhat distinguished from the commercial extension of the street across the Schuylkill. No more. The MacAlister-Creese academic building — admittedly, one of the uglier structures in the city — now has a wraparound of eateries, topped off with a bank.

The plaza in front of MacAlister-Creese, which, granted, was a concrete wilderness, has now become an equally unbecoming concrete playground with chairs and tables set out for casual dining or whatever in such a fashion as to make entrance into the MacAlister wing by the people who work there a kind of steeplechase.

As for Creese, its former entranceways were scuttled entirely, and it took me a month of passing by it to realize that there was an actual way to get into the building: a tiny door made invisible because of its location beside a coffee shop called Joe.

As the slogan that draped the construction site for a couple of years while our City of Mahogany was going up proudly proclaimed: “Live. Dine. Shop.”

Not a word, alas, about “Study. Learn. Educate.”

Like I already stated, it’s a matter of priorities.

Let’s continue our survey of Chestnut Street.

On the corner of 33rd Street — across from where the University of Pennsylvania is busily eliminating the last remaining green space on Chestnut to build new dormitories — is a small Drexel building, formerly the Newman Center, with a parking lot annexed to it. It is not an ideal use of space on a crowded campus.

Beyond it, fronting Market Street, is the W.W. Hagerty Library. The library is laughably inadequate even by the standard of a respectable community college. Part of its space was hijacked by the School of Law.

Some of what remained was turned into, you guessed it, another cafe eatery. I do have to wonder whether academic credit should be given for caffeine consumption at Drexel.

Well, you might think, wait a minute. Why not use the Newman space and the parking lot to build another wing of the library, with perhaps an elevated crosswalk to connect the buildings? Alas again, there is something Drexel appears to need a lot more than a library actually befitting a university.

You’ll never guess, but it’s a hotel. Wait, though: isn’t there a Sheraton Hotel just three blocks up the street? Does Drexel really need a hotel of its own to teach the critical academic subjects of catering and hospitality? But, of course, the Sheraton is now partially owned by Penn.

If Penn had a law school and a medical school, Drexel had to have one too. That was the reasoning of our late president, Constantine Papadakis. Well, since Penn has a hotel … fill in the rest for yourself.

Someone asked me what the difference between Penn and Drexel was these days, what with our University gobbling up every bit of real estate in sight and shoveling in students by the forkful. I paused to give this due consideration. “Nothing much,” I said. “Just about three million books.”

I’m sure the new hotel will have all the latest amenities. I’ll think about them when I wonder which toilet or faucet will work in MacAlister, or which of its two elevators will be functioning on any given day. Always bring a book or a tablet with you when you go up or down, and don’t forget to bring a courtesy deodorant — you never know when you might be spending a while there.

Let’s go back to Chestnut. There used to be a tiny bit of greensward between the phalanx of buildings on the north side of the street and the Main Building. It wasn’t anything much, but at least it rested the eyes from concrete.

Now, thanks to the beneficence of that noble philanthropist, Ray Perelman — you know, the guy who helped steal the Barnes art collection from Lower Merion at a taxpayer cost of $300 million — we have … more concrete. No doubt there’ll soon be tented bazaars there, selling key chains, hot dogs and classic movie posters. If only we could pave the sky.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on University opts for retail over academic space

Eric Holder won’t be missed as Attorney General

Eric Holder’s unexpected resignation as attorney general, his tearful exit, and the unceremonious way he was shown the door all suggest a forced departure. To which may I add two words: good riddance.

Editorial assessments of Holder’s performance have noted his efforts to defend voting rights and gay equality, and his attempt to defuse racial tensions in Ferguson, Missouri, in the wake of the shooting death of Michael Brown. Enough said.

There are three things that matter about Eric Holder’s legacy, and they matter very greatly. The rest is small change.

On Holder’s watch, the surveillance of American citizens by various agencies of the state increased exponentially, which included shredding Fourth Amendment protections against the unreasonable search and seizure of private documents and communications. The serial breaches of law by these agencies were noted and censured by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court judges appointed to oversee federal intelligence collection.

This was no secret to the Justice Department, which early under Holder’s tenure moved to prosecute a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, James Risen of The New York Times, for revealing the massive intrusion of spy agencies on the private lives of American citizens. The responsibility of his office was, of course, to halt and prosecute this illicit surveillance, as with any other federal crime. Instead, he moved to shoot the messenger.

His response was the same when a contract employee named Edward Snowden blew the whistle on the National Security Agency’s unprecedented spying, which would ultimately reach to the very Senate committee investigating its activities. Holder revoked Snowden’s passport and charged him, as he has Risen and six others, with violations of the 1917 Espionage Act — more than all previous prosecutions under this act combined.

Espionage itself was not alleged; instead, they were only charged with the unauthorized possession or disclosure of information that was embarrassing to the government: in short, whistle-blowing, or in Risen’s case, the exercise of the First Amendment rights of free press.

Another class of actual criminals who have gone scot-free under Holder was the group of bankers, brokers, insurers and accountants who brought down the world economy in 2008 and have continued, thanks to government bailouts and Justice Department inaction, to prey on it to the present moment.

When a similar gang did much the same thing in Great Depression I 80 years ago (to distinguish it from our present iteration, Great Depression II), a fair number of malefactors went to jail.

The same thing happened after the Savings and Loan meltdown in the 1980s. Even the Enron debacle sent Jeffrey Skilling to jail.

In nearly six years in office — it will be six before a replacement is confirmed — Holder has not prosecuted, let alone convicted a single high-ranking figure in the world of finance, settling for the occasional minnow and the levying of fines that, for trillion-dollar corporations, hardly amount to the cost of a three-martini lunch.

The message, as with BP in the Gulf of Mexico, Massey Energy in West Virginia, and agribusiness polluters and shale frackers around the country, is a green light for economic and ecological destruction. Thanks to Holder, the next financial collapse — and the next environmental disaster — have been brought measurably closer.

The initial excuse offered by Holder for this sorry record is that it was difficult to prove legal culpability at top executive levels. No doubt it is, but where there’s a will there’s a way, as the Roosevelt, Reagan, and Bush Justice Departments all proved in their day.

When this was pointed out, Holder fell back on the astonishing proposition that as some large banks and businesses were too big to fail for the sake of the economy, some bankers and businessmen were similarly too big to jail.

The message here too was clear — don’t worry about beating the rap, because there won’t be any. This attorney general will not prosecute corporate criminals, only the shareholders who pay the actual price of his token fines.

The above malfeasances would be enough to place Eric Holder on a short list of our worst attorneys general that includes A. Mitchell Palmer, of the post-World War I Red Scare, and John Mitchell of Watergate fame.

But Holder in one bold stroke eclipsed them all. Speaking to a law school audience at Northwestern University on March 5, 2012, he defended President Obama’s targeting of American citizens for secret assassination abroad. This, he said, was within the constitutional authority of the executive.

Well, silly me. I thought the due process clause of the Fifth Amendment required the public accusation of a criminal offense and the presentation of evidence in open court before a jury of one’s peers. Not so, according to Holder.

In the case of someone acting for or abetting a terrorist organization whose apprehension might be difficult, an executive procedure designed and exercised in secret was sufficient to reach a capital judgment because, after all, the phrase “due process” in the Constitution was not defined in terms of judicial action — could be, in fact, any old process at all.

Never mind that when the amendment was written “due process” had meant trial by jury for more than 500 (now 800) years, and that secret tribunals of any kind had been expressly forbidden under English law since 1641. Even the Star Chamber courts of the Tudors and Stuarts had never claimed the right to pronounce a sentence of death on any English subject. For that matter, Hitler and Stalin themselves never asserted the legal right to target citizens for assassination in secret.

They carried out such assassinations in fact — as George W. Bush did — but they never publicly acknowledged or defended them. That was left to Eric Holder, whose name deserves infamy because of it.

Now, Holder was simply his master’s voice in this matter, as in the abuse of the Espionage Act to curb freedom of the press and protect illicit surveillance, or in the decision not to prosecute the architects of our financial collapse. His job, in short, was to front for what has turned out to be at once the most feckless and the most lawless administration in American history.

That, unfortunately, is no excuse for him, any more than it can be for any bureaucrat who claims simply to have licked boots and followed orders.

And it is worse, too, in this case than in any other. For a representative of the law to stand it on its head and to then proclaim that black is white — before an audience of future lawyers, no less — is beneath contempt. But, for precisely that reason, it cannot go unanswered. It requires the most urgent condemnation.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Eric Holder won’t be missed as Attorney General

Congress launches US into war

Two ships passed in the night in the past week. More than 400,000 people marched in New York to dramatize the ecological disaster already upon us in advance of the UN climate summit, and millions more marched across the globe. A couple of hundred miles away, Congress voted to authorize and fund a new war in Iraq and Syria by margins of 319-108 in the Republican-controlled House and 78-22 in the Democratic-led Senate.

Oh, and a war-crazed veteran named Omar Gonzalez sprinted up the White House lawn with a three-inch knife, presumably looking for his commander in chief. As usual, though, Barack Obama was nowhere to be seen. He’d made his getaway four minutes earlier by helicopter with the royal, er, First Family to the still-green acres of Camp David.

What does all this tell us, class? First, that a fair number of people are pretty concerned about the future of the planet, at least in blue states where the theory of evolution has managed to catch on. Second, that the fools and scoundrels who misrepresent us in the halls of government have plunged us once again into an oil-besotted war to prop up the military-industrial-surveillance complex, and to keep the threat represented by a few fanatics — I mean, climate sanity and the democratic process — from ever reaching the shores of the Potomac.

You can’t blame this one just on the Republicans. The vote for war was 78 percent in the Senate, 66 percent in the House. Of course, some Republicans will vote reflexively against anything proposed by the president, which may not be the worst rule of thumb to use. But a few, notably Rand Paul, had actual objections to the idea that the best thing for the two most war-ravaged nations on the planet was to pulverize them with more bombs.

Of course, war is not particularly good for the environment, and it is even less so for living things. What it is good for, apart from profiteering, is changing the subject on any other matter. Like the impending extinction of species, including our own.

Oh, yes, Obama is addressing the subject of climate change. He’s telling underdeveloped nations what they should be doing to avoid going underwater. It seems the Leader of the Free World has decided to anoint Bangladesh as the standard-bearer in the fight to save the planet.

America, alas, has more pressing obligations, like supplying the Islamic State with fresh arms and recruits. (When you see those guys driving around in Humvees, waving their General Dynamics ordnance, you have to wonder whose army you’re looking at.) Meanwhile, the desertification of California proceeds apace, while Phoenix turns into a floodplain.

The story line out of Washington is that Obama is a reluctant warrior. When he ramped up our failed war in Afghanistan, Bob Woodward assured us that he’d been rolled by his generals against his own pacific instincts. When he bombed the bejesus out of Libya without Congressional authorization (didn’t need any, he said), he was allegedly pushed into it by the furious war hawks of the European Union, David Cameron and Francois Hollande.

As he wrapped up the war in Iraq in 2011 (actually only hitting the pause button), he called it a noble cause that expressed American idealism at its best. Meanwhile, we were bombing away in Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia, winning hearts and minds the way we usually do. Now the Ebola virus is giving us the excuse to send uniforms into West Africa. Plenty of terrorists there too, and it’s only a matter of time before we start bumping into them.

You might be getting the drift by now. Obama can’t get an immigration bill out of the Republican House, but then he couldn’t get gun control
legislation even out of committee in a Democratic Senate. He’s standing there in the middle of his second term like a boy in the street whose toys have been taken away. He waits to get whomped in the midterm elections a few weeks from now.

Without a war, he’d be hard-pressed to explain why he still remains in office other than to hold Hillary Clinton’s coat. Maureen Dowd even suggested a couple of months ago in The New York Times that he should manage to get himself impeached to be put out of his misery. It was a good idea, but the Republicans, despite their protestations to the contrary, actually like Barack Obama exactly where he is.

His phantom second term in office is actually the fourth term of the George W. Bush administration but with a nominal Democrat to take the heat, and what’s not to like about that?

Speaking of a phantom president, how about a phantom war? Oh, the bombs are real enough, and so are the civilian dead we once again won’t be counting. But the enemy is — whom did you say? — an outfit named the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, or maybe the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant, or is it the Islamic State, that used to be al-Qaida, and that had a few hundred or maybe a couple of thousand fighters when it miraculously conquered a quarter of Iraq, and the next month had morphed into an army of 20 to 30,000, or was it 30-50,000?

Depends on the briefing you’re getting. And now, surprise, we’re also bombing another group, Khorasan, which no one had heard of before this week. I’m not making this up, though maybe Langley is. The Iranians have accused us of simply manufacturing terrorist organizations out of whole cloth, or maybe running them ourselves.

I dunno, but the Iranians have considerable experience in this line, what with Hezbollah and other contrivances. I just find it passing strange that we bomb people first and announce their existence second. How’s that for a war of “choice”?

It is a matter of fact that modern jihadist groups got their start either through CIA recruitment and funding, as in Afghanistan in the 1970s and 80s, or as a response to our imperial presence in the Middle East in general. Certainly we opened the gates for them in Iraq and Libya, and they have needed no invitation from us in Syria. In a real sense, then, we are fighting our own shadow. But, to repeat, real people are getting killed.

War, Randolph Bourne said, is the health of the state. He was speaking of World War I—you remember, the war that Woodrow Wilson told us would end all wars—but it might be more simply said today that war is the business of the state: and a very big business it is. What it isn’t, though, is any business of yours and mine. A runaway executive simply makes war when and as it likes, and a Congress that will impeach a president over a dress stain won’t act as we lay waste on two continents.

Meanwhile, the world got a little warmer this summer. The glaciers retreated. The polar caps continued to melt. But, first things first: somebody might be trying to plant a dirty bomb in Radio Shack. Or, then again, maybe not.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Congress launches US into war

Israeli boycott still missing point

The boycott, divest and sanctions movement against Israel continues to make weary rounds through academic associations and religious denominations. As I wrote a few months ago, the American Studies Association voted narrowly last December to endorse a boycott of Israeli academics.

More recently, the much larger American Literature Association rejected a similar motion. Now, the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) —the largest Presbyterian denomination in America — has voted, also narrowly, to divest funds from three large corporations — Caterpillar, Hewlett-Packard and Motorola Solutions — which its Committee on Mission Responsibility Through Investment has identified as enablers of Israel’s so-called occupation of the West Bank.

As I pointed out previously, Israel is a handier target for boycott and divestiture than, say, China, which has an appalling human rights record but also funds our national debt. Why, though, Israel in particular, and Israel alone? The Presbyterian Church bookstore sells a 76-page guide, “Zionism Unsettled,” which describes the object of its study as “a struggle for colonial and racist supremacist privilege.” Oh. Well, the church doesn’t officially endorse the book; it merely makes it available. Funny I haven’t seen it at Barnes & Noble, though.

The General Assembly of the church did comment to its advisory committee that the Israeli occupiers “are relentless and unwavering” in their oppression, leaving “the vast majority” of Palestinian communities and individuals “bowed and broken by systematic and intentional injustice.” This language wasn’t a close call for the church leadership, which approved it by a vote of 482-88.

There is, of course, only one country in the Middle East where Christian communities can worship freely and without fear of violence against their religion. It’s the same one, according to the Presbyterians’ resolution, that has “de-legitimated” itself by grinding Palestinians into the dust.

Israel is a far from perfect society, and certainly not immune from criticism. Israelis and Palestinians do not enjoy neighborly relations based on mutual equality and respect. Israel exerts control over major sectors of the Palestinian economy; it collects (and sometimes withholds) Palestinian taxes. It reserves to itself the right to carry out raids or bombing strikes against suspected terrorists in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. It has steadily encroached on territory which the Palestinians regard as their own.
But does all this amount to a state of occupation? Israel did indeed occupy the West Bank and the Gaza Strip between 1967 and 1993. In 1967, it conquered these territories, formerly held by Jordan and Egypt, as a result of the Six Day War, a war of survival for Israel. The Israelis promptly offered to return the conquered territories in exchange for peace and recognition as a sovereign state; this was unanimously rejected by the defeated Arab League.

For the next quarter century, the Palestinians had no governing institutions. The functions of government, including justice, security, education, health, sanitation and infrastructure, were carried out by the Israelis, whose soldiers patrolled Palestinian cities and villages. This changed with the Oslo Accords, by which the Israelis entered into peace negotiations with a newly created entity on the other side, the Palestinian Authority. The aim of the process was to produce an independent Palestinian state based on recognition of the state of Israel and the settlement of borders, displaced persons, and the status of Jerusalem, which each side claimed as its capital. Over the next several years Israel withdrew its forces from populated areas, leaving 99 percent of Palestinians under the day-to-day governance of the Palestinian Authority, subject to the controls indicated above. These controls were to be lifted with the signing of a comprehensive peace agreement.

In short, the Israeli government was a reluctant occupier. It assumed control of the West Bank and Gaza as the only alternative to its control by hostile powers that had attacked it and, in the aftermath of defeat, refused to make peace or to refer to Israel by any other term than “the Zionist entity” or “the Zionist occupier.”

These terms of opprobrium were echoed in Arab-sponsored United Nations resolutions denouncing Zionism as a form of racism. They are precisely the terms now echoed in the literature distributed by the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), and presumed by its divestiture resolution.

There is, however, no present occupation of the West Bank or the Gaza Strip in any accepted meaning of the term, nor has there been for over 20 years. There is, instead, an unresolved condition of hostility between a state recognized as sovereign by the vast majority of other states, and a stateless people across its borders, 40 percent of whom — the residents of Gaza — refuse to entertain recognition of Israel in any way, shape, or form, and whose governing councils have just joined forces with the Palestinian Authority, now the rump representative of the West Bank.

Why have the negotiations of the past 20 years failed to produce the notionally desired result, namely a peace agreement based on two states living side by side? The answer to this is deeply enmeshed in regional politics, and in America’s own relation to Israel and the wider Middle East. But one thing is clear: only one side, Israel, has ever produced a public negotiating position.

Only Israel has offered an outline of future borders, a compromise over Jerusalem or satisfaction of the claims of displaced persons. The Palestinians have merely restated their original demands, where they have responded to Israeli proposals at all. No area of agreement has ever been identified between the two sides. But that is not surprising when only one side is actually attempting to negotiate.

The only concrete result of two decades of abortive discussion has been the transfer of governing responsibility to the Palestinian Authority and the unilateral withdrawal of Israeli settlements in the Gaza Strip. The Israelis did not make these arrangements out of benevolence. The political, financial, military, and moral burden of the post-1967 occupation was a price they were no longer willing to pay by the 1990s, especially with the rise of armed resistance by the Palestinians.

One need not be particularly cynical to suggest that making this burden intolerable was part of the long-range Arab strategy for dealing with Israel. At the same time, the achievement of a measure of substantive autonomy could be advertised as a victory by the Palestinians in their struggle for independence. Both sides, in short, were able to agree on an arrangement that, for different reasons, suited their purposes of the moment. But they have not since agreed on anything else.

The fault for this impasse is, to me, unambiguous. Where one side talks and the other doesn’t, progress cannot result. At Camp David in 2000, Yasser Arafat, then head of the Palestinian Authority, made literally no response to the comprehensive proposals made by his Israeli counterpart, Ehud Barak — not even to acknowledge them.

In the most recent round of “talks,” Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu cut off the scheduled release of a final group of Palestinian prisoners after the Palestinians had refused to engage in direct negotiation for four months. It was pretty plain to everyone except the broker of the talks, John Kerry, that at this point neither side wanted to go through the sham again. You could almost hear the sighs of relief amid the ritual recrimination when both sides got up from their separate tables in their different rooms.

Palestinians (or their apologists) may describe the long failure to produce peace differently; I invite a reply. But two facts seem to me clear: the Israelis did not seek to become occupiers in 1967, and they ceased to play that role thirty years later. Palestinians have their own courts and execute their own justice. They educate their own children. They police their own streets. They have representatives abroad, and at the United Nations. Compare this, please, with the long Chinese occupation of Tibet. That’s the real thing.

The occupation at issue in the Middle East is that of Israel by the Israelis. It is that which the Muslim world as a whole has never accepted. “Zionism” is, among Israel’s enemies, the code word for those who reject Israel as such, and those who embrace the term embrace the attitude. The Presbyterians say that Israel has “de-legitimated” itself, which implies that it was legitimate at some previous point. I’d like to hear from them when that was, and when and how it ceased to be. Until then, it is the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) that has a legitimation problem to worry about.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post Israeli boycott still missing point appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Israeli boycott still missing point

War criminals at commencement?

For four years, students endure the boredom of being lectured at, and then at graduation they endure a final hour in the form of the commencement address. This rite of passage crept in a while back and has now become part of our celebrity culture: the ambassador from the real world who comes to shine his importance briefly on those who are about to enter it and the institution that shoos them into it.
Normally, this is a routine function that is taken for granted. The commencement speech is understood to be an ensemble of adjurations stitched together with platitudes, leavened with jokes, and rounded off with a pat on the back. It’s a little like listening to your aunt or uncle at Thanksgiving: bad as it is, you just wait through it until you can get to the turkey.

This year, however, serious controversy has erupted over the commencement address. The most prominent flap was at Rutgers University, where students and some faculty objected to the selection of Condoleezza Rice as the speaker. Rice has respectable academic credentials: she was a Sovietologist and provost at Stanford University. Unfortunately, she was also George W. Bush’s national security adviser and later secretary of state. In this capacity, she participated in the Bush-Cheney plot to launch war against a nonbelligerent state, Iraq. An invasion which, as former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan delicately put it, appeared to be a violation of international law, not to mention the Nuremburg Code under which we prosecuted Nazi war criminals.

When Rice, also an amateur pianist, was engaged a few years ago to perform at the Mann Center concerts, I pointed out that this was the first time an unindicted war criminal had played with the Philadelphia Orchestra. Rehabilitating her, though, is a little more difficult than in the case of, say, Monica Lewinsky. It was Rice who made the famous comment that we could not afford to let Saddam Hussein continue his ruthless pursuit of nuclear weapons, lest the smoking gun that demonstrated it for all to see be a mushroom cloud. Alas — for 4,400 dead American soldiers and the numerous uncounted Iraqis — the only mushroom cloud turned out to be the one that hangs permanently over her reputation.

There isn’t much most of us can do about the fact that Rice continues to reap substantial rewards on the lecture circuit in her post-secretarial career rather than gazing out from behind bars, but when Rutgers sent her an invite, enough people decided that they didn’t want her particular cloud over their graduation ceremonies that she thought it prudent to cancel her appearance. Note, please, that her invitation was not rescinded, nor did any university official concede that it had been, to put it mildly, inappropriate. Nor did anyone thank the student and faculty protesters for standing up for common decency and the reputation of their institution, not to mention the rule of law. They were scolded, rather, for their bad manners.

At Haverford College, protests arose over the commencement invitation to Robert J. Birgeneau, who, as chancellor of the University of California, Berkeley, had defended the use of force by campus police and Alameda County, Calif., sheriffs’ deputies who charged peacefully assembled students on Sproul Plaza with riot batons. The protesters did not demand that the invitation be rescinded, but wanted to make it conditional on Birgeneau’s willingness to address the incident publicly. Birgeneau withdrew, and Haverford President Daniel Weiss lamented the lost opportunity to “hear from one of the most consequential leaders in American higher education.”
I guess refusing to discuss one’s responsibility in the violent suppression of student dissent is what consequential leaders in American higher education do. The Haverford students were addressed instead by William G. Bowen, a former president of Princeton University, who rebuked them for their incivility. It’s a good thing Princeton students weren’t trying to exercise their First Amendment rights at Princeton during Bowen’s administration.

At Smith College, meanwhile, Christine Lagarde, the imperious head of the International Monetary Fund, backed out of her scheduled graduation address after protests at the IMF’s role in exploiting developing nations’ economies. Lagarde, too, is a piece of work. My favorite line of hers is the response she made to the ruinous economic conditions imposed on Greece by the European Union and the IMF: “I weep for the children of Nigeria.” Apparently, the spoiled brats of Greece would just have to go without dinner.

Drexel University has had its own share of bad choices, notably Carl Icahn, the corporate raider who was invited to address commencement a few years back. A non-speaker whose invitation to campus was even more of a scandal was Jiang Zemin, the butcher of Tiananmen Square. When that occurred, I suggested that Drexel might make some slight amends by inviting Wei Jinsheng, then the most prominent Chinese dissident-in-exile, to speak at graduation. No one got back to me on that one.

This raises the vexing question of how and by whom commencement speakers are chosen. At one time, faculty suggestions were entertained, though of course never acted upon. It is now a corporate prerogative reserved to senior administrators and trustees, who have naturally arrogated themselves the right to represent their institutions on this as on all other occasions. As for attending students and faculty, well, their job is to listen and applaud, which is pretty much the general routine in student and faculty matters. When they do have an opinion, it is fractious by definition, since they are excluded from any substantive university decision-making process. Father knows best.

Those who decry the protests over commencement addresses point out that if speakers are to be vetted for political correctness, there will be few qualified and fewer willing to deliver them. Almost any public figure is sure to have offended someone. But there is no First Amendment right to speak at commencements, and anyone entering the precincts of a university ought to be willing to engage in debate. This is precisely what Chancellor Birgeneau declined to do, and what former President Bowen chastised Haverford for asking.

What we ought to do is to reconsider the commencement address itself. Other visitors to a university do come prepared for questioning and discussion. That’s what participating in the life of a campus is all about. Only commencement speakers declaim from on high and presume to hold themselves above normal academic debate. If their politics are an issue, it’s because their selection is a political act in the first place, only one from which democratic process is absent. And who really needs them? If the general university community as a whole chose graduation to give a platform to those whose voices are marginalized or ignored in official culture, the commencement address might serve a worthwhile function. Otherwise, if a few words of praise and encouragement need to be delivered, surely university presidents or provosts — perhaps even a faculty member — should be articulate enough to utter them. And universities would save some money, too. Condoleezza Rice was going to get $35,000 for her pearls of wisdom at Rutgers. Surely there was a leaky roof the money could have been better spent on?

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post War criminals at commencement? appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on War criminals at commencement?

The death penalty is uncivilized

The Japanese are nothing if not stubborn. It took a visit from Hiroo Onoda’s former commanding officer, by then a retired bookseller, to persuade the erstwhile lieutenant to abandon the guerrilla outpost he had maintained in the Philippines and come home to a Japan that had been at peace for nearly 30 years. Onoda became a national hero, and his passing this year at the age of 91 was duly noted in the world press.

Less attention was paid to the story of Iwao Hakamada, who was granted a retrial this March after spending more than 45 years on Japan’s death row. Lest you think this is an impossible anomaly, it is not particularly uncommon for prisoners on America’s 33 death rows (32 state, one federal) to wait 30 years or more for their date with the needle, and some, like Hakamada, to be in their 70s before being executed.

Japan has some special refinements, though. Death row prisoners are kept in solitary confinement and may not speak to guards. Execution dates are never announced, so that Hakamada could wake up each Monday through Friday for nearly half a century not knowing whether that day was to be his last (there are no executions on weekends in Japan, so you can spend Saturdays and Sundays waiting for Monday).
Hakamada was subjected to 20 or more consecutive days of 12-hour interrogations with no bathroom breaks until he signed a confession, which he then repudiated. DNA evidence finally cleared him, but he was still not exonerated. While imprisoned he went mad, believing himself to be an omnipotent God who, having absorbed Iwao Hakamada into himself, had freed all death row inmates in Japan and abolished the death penalty.

Then there’s the Iran of the ayatollahs or George W. Bush’s “young democracy” in Iraq, where prisoners are executed by the bushel. Or Egypt, where 529 men were recently sentenced to death in a mass trial for the killing of a single police officer. Not content with this Guinness record, the court then sentenced another 683 to death en masse. And there’s Pakistan, where death is the penalty for blaspheming the Prophet Muhammad. Or China, where the families of the condemned used to be charged for the bullet used to execute them.
Civilized societies, whatever their flaws, do not execute people. We can judge for ourselves the company we’re keeping.

America has a very bad conscience about what it’s doing in putting people to death, which is why it has created the world’s most contorted system for doing so. Death sentences are subject to automatic review, and appeals can drag on for decades. Two-thirds of all death sentences are reversed at some point, some because of actual innocence but the majority because of egregious procedural errors, inadequate representation or prosecutorial malfeasance. You’d think if anyone deserved the death penalty, it would be a prosecutor who knowingly framed someone in a capital case, but no such luck. I’ve seen some, and they’re still gainfully employed in what we laughingly call the justice system. Sovereign immunity, you know.

The bad conscience comes out in the way we put our fellow citizens to death. The standard method of execution in 19th-century America was hanging. It was not an exact science and often caused prolonged suffering. The electric chair was introduced in 1890 as a more humane alternative, and it became the industry standard despite the horrific botching of its first exercise. Straining limbs, roasting flesh, and occasional spurts of fire took their toll on executioners and witnesses, and in the 1920s the gas chamber was introduced, again in the interests of delicate sensibilities. With gas, witnesses could watch the condemned thrash more freely while gasping for air. This method became a little less popular after the Holocaust, and lethal injection was introduced, being America’s current execution method.

All the while, of course, far more efficient and less painful methods were available. Modern hanging is a science; you can calculate the exact weight and drop it will take to break a person’s neck. The French used the guillotine for more than a century and a half; it was even more effective. The Chinese use of a single bullet was equally parsimonious. The problem with these procedures, though, is that they look awful. Heads tumble or explode; blood gushes.

The popularity of lethal injection (now used by the Chinese as well) derives from the fact that it works exactly the way a hospital anesthetic does, and the prisoner on his gurney looks, but for his bonds, just like a patient awaiting a lifesaving operation. Thus is the distinction between therapy and lethality effaced. The condemned prisoner lies trussed in a sealed chamber, awaiting the seepage of poison into his veins, without even the dignity of standing erect before a firing squad or sitting in a wired chair.

Because with the declining popularity of capital punishment it is more and more difficult for death penalty states to access the drugs they like to use, they have resorted to alternative chemicals, including some hitherto used to euthanize animals. Because many of them have never been used to kill humans, some executions are medical experiments performed on live subjects, and some go wrong. Recently, Oklahoma staged its first double execution since 1937. The first prisoner, Clayton Lockett, took 43 minutes to die. The second execution was postponed for fine-tuning.

The guillotine would have done the job in a couple of seconds. Bloodletting, anyone?

The courts have ruled that prisoners do not have the right to know with which chemicals they are being executed, nor from which supplier they are procured. Because the medical profession disallows doctors from participating in executions, amateurs are left to mix lethal cocktails and monitor the results (Lockett died of a heart attack). Texas tries to avoid the problem by using a single drug, and its governor, Rick Perry, has recommended this protocol to prison officials in Oklahoma.

The longer we go on killing, the worse we seem to get at it. There must be a moral in this somewhere.

Abolitionists like to point out that we are in the company of such countries as China, North Korea and Iran in retaining the death penalty, which every Western country save ours has now abolished. We may object to being classed with tyrannical states, but in fact the case is worse with us precisely because we are a democracy. In democracies, the acts of public officials are done in the name of all and are thus the acts of us all. This means the blood is on your hands and on mine. Only we don’t see it because those who work our death chambers are scrupulous never to spill a drop.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post The death penalty is uncivilized appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The death penalty is uncivilized