Author Archives | Robert Zaller

The long shadow of Mumia Abu-Jamal

It’s been nearly 32thirty-two years since a 28twenty-eight-year-old taxicab driver was convicted of the murder of a Philadelphia police officer and sentenced to death. It might seem improbable to the point of impossibility that this case should have overturned the nomination of a highly regarded and apparently well- qualified nominee, Debo Adegbile, to head the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department. Yet that’s exactly what happened when the U.S. Senate rejected Adegbile on March 5 by a vote of 52-47 in what Iowa Sen.nator Tom Harkin called “the lowest point that I think thishe Senate has descended into [sic] in my 30thirty years here.”

The cabdriver in question was a sometime journalist and political activist named Mumia Abu-Jamal, a former Black Panther who had been publicly berated threatened by Frank Rizzo — more or less the equivalent of a Mafioso’s kiss of death. On the night of Dec.ember 9, 1981, Mumia’s brother, Billy Cook, who has said he was riding with his business partner, Kenneth Freeman, was stopped by OoOfficer Daniel Faulkner. Mumia happened on the scene at that moment in his cab, and — by some accounts — saw his brother being roughed up. He left the cab with the gun he legally carried. An altercation followed, in during which Mumia was shot in the chest and Faulkner killed.

Prosecutor Joseph McGill argued at Mumia’s trial that, despite his wound, he had executed Faulkner at point-blank range as he lay on the ground. The presence of a fourth party on the scene was never raisedFreeman was not mentioned during the trial, but a driver’s license application in Freeman’s name was found in Faulkner’s pocket. Freeman was arrested hours later, but almost immediately released. The vending stand that he and Cook operated mysteriously burned to the ground fivne days later, and Freeman himself was found dead, bound and naked, on the night of the MOVE bombing, May 13, 1985. The cause of his death was listed as a heart attack. It was never investigated further.

In the words of J. Patrick O’Connor, Mumia’s trial represented “a monumental miscarriage of justice from beginning to end.” Inspector Alfonzo Giordano, who took charge of the crime scene, is said to have coerced two witnesses, a prostitute and a cab driver on probation for throwing a Molotov cocktail into a schoolyard, into giving perjured testimony against Mumia. He allegedly beat the wounded Mumia in the paddy wagon, and falsely asserted that he had boasted of killing Faulkner to him. Giordano would later be convicted in an FBI corruption probe of the Philadelphia Police Department, as. So would Deputy Commissioner James Martin, who oversaw Mumia’s case.

After disruptions, Mumia himself was gagged at his trial on the order of presiding JjJudge Albert Sabo, and denied the right to represent himself as well as his choice ofown counsel , John Africa who was not a lawyer. Sabo allegedlywould later boasted that he intended to help the prosecution “fry the nigger .” Prosecutor McGill used eleven 11 of twelve 12 challenges to exclude African Americans from the jury, which as an intentionala practice was ruled unconstitutional by the U.S. Supreme Court in Batson v. Kentucky four years later. Although the cCourt’s ruling was retroactive, it was not applied to Mumia’s case.

As outrageous as the trial was, the long record of Mumia’s appeals is even worse. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that McGill’s jury summation against another defendant, Lawrence Baker, had violated the law, but refused to apply the almost identical words used by McGill in Mumia’s case, thus negating its own precedent. Mumia’s post-conviction review in 1995 was conducted by Sabo, who thus judged his own conduct. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals reversed its rulings in two previous cases, Holloway v. Horn and Brinson v. Vaughn, to deny Mumia relief under Batson v. Kentucky relief in 2008, and the U.S. Supreme Court refused to grant certiorari to rehear his petition despite the flouting of its own clear rule. Thus, from the state to the highest federal level, successive courts denied Mumia relief according to their own established precedents, a practice that became known in legal circles as “the Mumia exception.” This did not simply violate Mumia’s rights. It undermined the fundamental principle of stare decisis, by which courts, absent extraordinary circumstances, are bound to honor established precedent lest the law have no certainty. The only extraordinary circumstance in Mumia’s case was Mumia himself.

Over the years, Mumia has attracted support from organizations ranging from Amnesty International to the National Association for the Advancement of Colored PeopleNAACP. Debo Adegbile oversaw the NAACP Legal Defense Fund in its work assisting Mumia’s Third Circuit appeal. The fFund is legendary for its advocacy on behalf of minorities and the poor in capital and civil rights cases. Adegbile’s work was professionally honorable and appropriate. But he incurred the wrath of Philadelphia’s Fraternal Order of Police and the politicians who dance to its tune, notably Republican Sen.ator Pat Toomey. Toomey waged a one-man campaign to discredit Adegbile on the basis of his representation of Mumia. It was, he said in a Philadelphia inquirer Inquirer op-ed replete with falsehoods, an “affront [that] cannot stand.”

The affront, of course, is to the rule of law, which in Mumia’s case has been violated by all three branches of government: by the courts, in their violation of basic legal principles; by the executive, in the person of former Pennsylvania Gov.ernor Tom Ridge, who signed a death warrant for Mumia just as his post-conviction review was being submitted (the death warrant was stayed pending the review); and now by the U.S. Senate, which has stated, in effect, that a lawyer should be judged by the popularity of his client — or, rather, by the political weight of his foes. As for Philadelphia’s police department, it’s once again in the news, this time as the object of a wide-ranging investigation of the narcotics division. You begin to get the idea of why Justice is so often depicted as blind. In the City of Brotherly Love, it’s too painful for her to look.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post The long shadow of Mumia Abu-Jamal appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The long shadow of Mumia Abu-Jamal

The modern GOP, a party of zombies

They say there’s no room for a third party in American politics. There’s a reason for that: If there’s one thing Democrats and Republicans can both agree on, it’s making ballot access for third parties as difficult as possible. But wait: Isn’t that antidemocratic? Yes, with the small “d.” For Democrats who want their liberal wing to stay marginalized within their party rather than risk the emergence of a genuine alternative to their politics of accommodation, though, that’s just fine. As for Republicans, they did face an insurgency five years ago in the Tea Party. Because modern Republicans move easily, almost instinctively to the right, they were able to fit the Tea Partyers into their caucus, although who swallowed whom may well be debated.

Actually, though, the Republicans themselves were born as a third party in the 1850s, elbowing aside the Whigs. And if there was ever a moment when they themselves seemed ripe for extinction, it was after the election of 2008 that brought Barack Obama to the White House and gave Democrats firm control of both houses of Congress. In the aftermath of two failed wars and a financial collapse, Republican strategists foresaw a long season — perhaps as long as a generation — in the political wilderness. Surveying the wreckage of the Bush administration with rare candor, they admitted that the party was out of ideas and increasingly irrelevant to a demographically changing population.

With a little more candor, the Republicans might have said that their ideas were not so much old as wrong, at least for anyone not among the soon-to-be notorious 1 percent. After 40 years of controlling the narrative of American politics, they presided over an economy more debt-ridden, inegalitarian and crisis-prone than any since before the Great Depression. After preaching the virtues of free-market economics, their clients — the big banks and brokerage houses — were lined up for handouts from the very government the country had been tutored to despise. The terminal spectacle was of Hank Paulson, a Goldman Sachs mogul turned treasury secretary, telling Congress that if it did not write him a check for $700 billion in 48 hours, world capitalism would collapse.

When the Tea Partyers arrived on their wave of network-inspired nihilism, it seemed like the coup de grace for the Grand Old Party. And Republicans are in truth more divided today than the famously fractious Democrats ever were. It was the Tea Party caucus that forced House Speaker John Boehner into a politically disastrous shutdown of the federal government in October, just as it undercut Mitt Romney’s presidential candidacy in 2012. Republicans can’t ultimately live with the Tea Party in their ranks, but they can’t survive with it outside them either. It’s a case of the host that needs the virus that is killing it.

Yet not only is the GOP no longer moribund, but after winning back the House of Representatives in 2010 — a feat even Karl Rove could not have imagined — it is now even odds to take the Senate in 2014. So what has brought the party back from the brink?

One answer is simple: money. The Republican Party exists to protect those who have it from those who don’t, and its prime constituency, small as it is, writes the big checks. The Republican-dominated Supreme Court greased the path for the final monetization of electoral politics in its Citizens United decision and just went even further by striking down more campaign donation limits in the McCutcheon case. With half a dozen large corporations dominating the airwaves and dictating the content of what goes out over them, the mass media — long a target of conservative wrath — is safely in Republican hands.

Another answer is gerrymandering, the process of redrawing electoral districts to favor the party in power. Both parties have played this game, but Republicans have won it: thus it was that the GOP handily retained control of the House of Representatives in 2012 even though Democrats garnered more votes for House seats nationally. Voter suppression and intimidation, at which Republicans have proved themselves expert, have also discouraged minority voting; George W. Bush would never have come close enough to having the presidential election of 2000 handed to him by the Supreme Court without having many thousands of African-Americans in Florida stricken from the registration rolls or turned away at the polls.

These answers are substantive but insufficient. The more important answer lies not with what Republicans have done but with what Democrats haven’t. Between 1932 and 1968, the Democratic Party controlled the political narrative. In that time, they could have evolved into a genuinely social democratic party. Franklin D. Roosevelt had pointed them in that direction in 1944 when he offered a blueprint for a more egalitarian postwar America that would eradicate poverty, build a sustainable middle class and guarantee universal health care and education. But Roosevelt succumbed to a cerebral hemorrhage soon after, and his vision died aborning. Cold War prosperity — American economic dominance, undergirded by the growth of a permanent military-industrial complex — contributed to a mood of national complacency. Lyndon Johnson tried to revive the New Deal dream all but buried under Eisenhower and Kennedy, but it died for good with Vietnam. The Republicans rode a backlash against civil disorder into the White House in 1968, and over the succeeding decades they rewrote the American political story. African Americans were not an oppressed minority but a public menace; the poor were deserving of their condition and certainly not of taxpayer money. Anyone could succeed in America who really wanted to, and the freedom to do so was the national creed.

This story was tied to a worship of the so-called free market, given academic respectability in the 1970s by Milton Friedman and his colleagues at the University of Chicago. The enemy of freedom was big government, which stifled enterprise, strangled business in a maze of regulations, and perpetuated itself by creating permanent welfare dependencies. In Ronald Reagan, this new “conservatism” found its ideal pitchman. But as early as the Kennedy administration, Democrats had begun to abandon the alternative New Deal vision of a redistributivist government that would correct the inequities created by unrestrained capitalism and cope with the recurrent crises of the business cycle. Jimmy Carter’s domestic agenda was virtually indistinguishable from that of his Republican predecessor, Gerald Ford; Bill Clinton described himself as an Eisenhower Republican; and Barack Obama pointed out — apparently with pride — that he was less liberal than Richard Nixon had been. All of which raised the question: Why vote for faux Republicans when you could have the real thing?
The 2008 election offered Democrats a once-in-a-generation chance to redefine themselves. They missed the opportunity by nominating in Barack Obama, a man without principle, let alone vision, and as it turned out, without governing skills either. Instead of exploiting his Congressional majority, Obama bent over backward to engage and appease the Republican caucus. This was inexplicable other than in terms of preventing anything resembling a liberal agenda from re-emerging, as was his choice of a conservative and hawkish cabinet. The country had in fact elected a Republican in all but name in 2008. Nor would it have done better to have chosen Hillary Clinton, the heir presumptive in 2016 (but hold your bets).

In short, the modern Democratic Party stands for nothing. Republican principles may be demonstrably false and largely cynical, but Republicans pronounce them with passionate conviction and zeal. That is something, and something beats nothing.
The general result among the electorate is disaffection with both parties. Forty-two percent of American voters now identify themselves as independents, about twice the number of a generation ago. That is certainly an entering wedge for one or more new parties. But any real change in the political landscape will require a challenge to the reigning ideology shared by Republican and Democratic politicians alike and the moneyed interests who call the tune they dance to. It was Richard Nixon who shaped that landscape more than anyone else in the years after 1968. If there’s any proposition most people could reasonably share, it’s that Richard Nixon’s America should not be ours.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post The modern GOP, a party of zombies appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The modern GOP, a party of zombies

To kill or not to kill?

When Barack Obama announced in his State of the Union address that he would pursue his political agenda through executive order where he could not do so through legislative action, Republicans cried foul, and House Speaker John Boehner declared immigration reform dead because the president could no longer be trusted to enforce the law. This was a red herring, because Obama was not claiming new authority as such, and because Boehner’s real reason for suspending immigration reform was his inability to persuade his own caucus to pursue it.

Republicans have thus far been mute about a renewed abuse of executive authority, although it puts the constitution on the chopping block, not to say the rule of law itself. This is the disclosure that the president is getting back into the game of assassinating American citizens.

As far as we know, this practice dates back to the Bush administration, when after 9/11 it was decided to take out Americans believed to be working for al-Qaida or “associated groups” on the basis of intelligence reports. It is believed that four individuals were assassinated in this manner, although whether this was an actual count or the tip of an iceberg is unknown. Barack Obama inherited the assassination program and carried out a kill against Anwar Al-Awlaki, a citizen by virtue of his birth in New Mexico, who allegedly made propaganda videos on behalf of al-Qaida. Awlaki’s sixteen-year-old son, also an American citizen, was killed in a separate drone strike as well.

It was only with the death of Awlaki that the assassination program was revealed. Of course, American administrations had assassinated foreign leaders going back at least to the Kennedy years. But deliberately assassinating American citizens without even the fig leaf of a police raid was a new wrinkle. And announcing that citizens were prospectively in the crosshairs, as has just been done by unnamed Obama administration officials about an unidentified target, is a wrinkle on that.

Let’s be clear and simple about this. The extrajudicial murder of citizens is the hallmark of dictatorships. We tacitly approved the murder of thousands under the military dictatorship of Augusto Pinochet in the 1970s after helping bring him to power in a coup against a democratically elected government. It is not more morally tolerable to abet the murder of foreign citizens than to kill one’s own, but it is a step further toward extinguishing a domestic rule of law. For the citizens involved, it quite literally means extinction. For the rest of us, it substitutes for the rule of law with a sword of Damocles that hangs over all our heads. It replaces democracy, or for that matter any constitutional order, with an executive tyranny that spies at will on its citizens and kills at pleasure.

The spying and the killing go hand in hand. The two great revelations we have had under Obama are that the government spies on all of us without legal warrant or probable cause of suspicion; and that it reserves to itself the right to kill any of us without public charge or trial. Either of these constitutes an effective revocation of citizenship, as a denial of Fourth Amendment privacy rights and Fifth Amendment due process. It reduces us to subjects of arbitrary power.

In a speech as notorious as any ever delivered by a Nazi or Stalinist flunky and arguably even more brazen, Attorney General Eric Holder told a Northwestern University law school audience in March 2012 that targeted assassinations were not a denial of due process because unaccountable executive review satisfied constitutional requirements — in other words, that a secret tribunal acting on secret accusation was the functional equivalent of a trial in a public court of law. Even Orwell would have blanched at that, but, apart from a few civil libertarians and editorial writers, the political system didn’t bat an eye. That alone should show us how far along the road to tyranny we have gone, and how habituated we have become to accept almost any outrage in the name of security.

So, what’s going on now? We’ve been told that an unnamed individual living in Pakistan, who, according to The New York Times, “some believe is actively plotting terrorist attacks,” is under review for placement on the administration’s hit list. But why would a government as wedded to secrecy as Obama’s want a matter so sensitive to become public knowledge? Let us recall, after all, the administration’s fury at Edward J. Snowden’s disclosure of its spying program and its ham-handed attempt to threaten any foreign government that thought to offer him sanctuary.

The answer, I believe, lies in Obama’s desire to normalize assassination by selectively revealing tidbits of information designed to assure the public that a certifiable threat to public security has been identified and that his elimination has been designated as essential to the national interest by experts in the know. Thus, we are told that both the Pentagon and the CIA vetted the intelligence in this particular case and that the Pentagon, though initially reluctant to recommend a kill, finally came around to the CIA’s point of view. This sounds like a formal, substantive process of some sort, with healthy skepticism and adversarial argument — except that an American citizen’s life is being weighed in the balance without his knowledge and without reference to any of the laws and procedures by which the American government can legally take a life. And we are invited to acquiesce in the killing of a fellow citizen whose name we do not know.
The strategy appears to be working, too. The Los Angeles Times, in an editorial “troubled”by the report of a fresh targeting, lays down the following prescription:

“If the United States is again to deliberately take the life of one of its citizens without due process of law, leaders from the president on down must, at the very least, offer specific and credible proof that such action was absolutely necessary to prevent imminent attacks on Americans and that capturing the suspected terrorist was impossible.”.

The editorial doesn’t concede the right to assassinate as such, and it sweeps aside Holder’s attempt to present secret executive review as due process. But it lays down guidelines — some of them tracking Obama’s own announced criteria — for justifying a hit under theoretical circumstances. There should be “specific and credible proof” of an “imminent” attack (but how offered, and to whom?). It should be further demonstrated that there was no other way to prevent the attack (but how can this be proved, and, again, to whom?). The suggestion is that some court or other entity separate from the executive should have powers of review. But such a court would be necessarily secret, and thus fail to meet due process standards: a public charge communicated to an indicted individual with the right to confront his accusers and with the assistance of counsel to mount a defense that can challenge any and all evidence presented against him.

The Los Angeles Times declares that the government must do better if it wants the public to trust it with the “execution of U.S. citizens suspected of terrorism.” The slip of the tongue here is revealing. Suspicion is not legal determination, and “execution” can apply only to persons publicly convicted of capital crimes. To substitute “execution” for the properly applicable term, assassination, is to give the patina of law to an act that lies wholly outside it.

One might argue, in agreement with the Nazi-aligned theorist Carl Schmitt, that the true exercise of political authority lies in “states of exception” beyond all rules and norms, and that justice is merely ordinary bureaucratic administration. This would at least be an honest description of what Obama and his minions are trying to pass off as law. We could then decide whether, in any final analysis, government belongs to the people, or the people to their government.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post To kill or not to kill? appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on To kill or not to kill?

ASA and anti-Semitism

The Jewish question is now old hat. In Germany, a new generation is tired of guilt about the Nazis and just wants to get on with the business of owning Europe. It’s pretty much the same everywhere else. The Holocaust deniers may never have attained respectability, but Holocaust fatigue ultimately does the same job. It’s understandable, too. As the last of the Holocaust’s direct victims and perpetrators die out, there are other things to worry about, from global warming to the Super Bowl odds.

And then there is Israel. Just when everyone wants to get off the Jewish page, pushy Israel keeps returning us to it. Better yet, it inverts the stereotype. Instead of Jews as victims, Israel offers them as persecutors. Palestinians are the new Jews, and Israelis have locked them into concentration camps called the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. It’s terrible, of course, to treat anyone the way the Nazis treated the Jews, and if Israelis are really the new Nazis, then opposition to Israel is opposition to anti-Semitism, and consequently incumbent on all right-thinking people, quod erat demonstrandum.

Thus it is that the American Studies Association, which called for a boycott of contacts and exchange between American and Israeli scholars in a mail-ballot resolution passed Dec. 4, 2013, begins its statement by affirming its opposition “to all forms of racism, including anti-Semitism, discrimination, and xenophobia,” and its solidarity “with aggrieved peoples in the United States and the world.”

The word “Israel” does not appear in this opening paragraph; the only country mentioned is the U.S. We discover why this is so in the next one: “Whereas the United States plays a significant role in enabling the Israeli occupation of Palestine … ”, American scholars have a particular obligation to address this issue because their own country is deeply complicit in it, not to say the major obstacle to relieving Palestinian persecution. Were it not for America, the implicit argument proceeds, international pressure would long since have compelled Israel to cease and desist. There’s no mention here of the “Jewish lobby” that holds America in thrall to Israeli interests; any reference to that would be a red flag, but the coded language makes it clear enough. This statement decrying anti-Semitism is anti-Semitic through and through.

I do not, of course, mean to suggest that criticism of or opposition to Israeli policies toward Palestinians is anti-Semitic per se. Plenty of Israelis are critical of them, too, as the ASA resolution duly notes. The question is why, with no shortage of brutal, repressive and authoritarian states in the world and no end of minorities subject to adversities ranging from discrimination to ethnic cleansing, Israel alone should merit a demand for boycott and divestiture by the scholarly community. No one has provided an answer to this question because the suppositional case of Israel is distinctive for the obvious but unmentionable reason that it involves the world’s only Jewish state. What Israel does about the West Bank and Gaza is wrong by definition because Israel itself is illegitimate. It is an occupier because it is, fundamentally, a usurper.

Anti-Semitism has never been a simple phenomenon, and it isn’t in this instance either. Supporters of Israel like to point out that it is the only democracy in the Middle East. It is for this very reason, however, that it attracts antipathy. Modern democracy is secular and pluralistic, and the idea of a state that proclaims its essential character in terms of religion is antithetical to the liberal tradition. If Israel is a democracy, it can’t be a Jewish state. If it is a Jewish state, it can’t be a democracy.

Secular Israelis are sensitive to this question, and it represents an unresolved tension within Israeli society. Opponents of Israel, however, take a leap forward from this. Israel’s presumed goal is the annexation of the West Bank and Gaza to create a Greater Israel, or, short of that, the permanent subjugation of the Palestinian territories as an economic fiefdom. If you listen to the more rabid religious extremists in Israel, you can find color for this view. It nonetheless flies in the face of the record. Israel no sooner occupied the West Bank and Gaza in the Six-Day War than it offered to evacuate them in return for Arab diplomatic recognition. During the period of the Oslo Accords, 99 percent of the Palestinian population was transferred from direct Israeli control to the Palestinian Authority. In 2005, Ariel Sharon unilaterally withdrew all Israeli settlers from the Gaza Strip. In the last previous round of peace negotiations, Benjamin Netanyahu froze all West Bank settlements while awaiting Palestinian proposals. They never came.

To be sure, these actions were all self-interested; nations do not act other than in their interest. But they also indicate a substantive desire by successive Israeli governments to resolve the Palestinian issue peacefully over several decades. Had there been a like reciprocity on the other side, a settlement might have been reached a good while ago.

Boycott supporters ignore these facts in favor of a black-and-white narrative of Israeli oppressors and Palestinian oppressed. The Palestinians, preyed upon by the self-proclaimed Jewish state, are innocent of all responsibility for their condition. This is the classic canard of anti-Semitism, of evil systematically crushing virtue. We’ve encountered many versions of it before; the demonization of Israel is only the latest example. That it comes garbed in the rhetoric of politically correct anti-colonialism only makes it the more insidious.

Capsule: The academic boycott of Israel voted for last month by the American Studies Association is the latest example of an anti-Semitism cloaked in the garb of political correctness. That its sponsors deny any such intention only makes it the more obvious.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASA and anti-Semitism

Obama’s had a bad year

It seems an age ago that Barack Obama, after his convincing defeat of Mitt Romney in 2012, began his second term in office. The president had fresh wind in his sails. In his inaugural and State of the Union addresses, he laid out an agenda of gun control before a nation that appeared finally ready for a serious approach to the subject after the horror of the Newtown school shootings. He also addressed immigration and education reform, infrastructure development and repair, and a systemic effort to bring climate change under control — in short, all the unachieved goals of his first term. He spoke hopefully of bipartisan support for these goals and forcefully about Congress’ and the country’s moral obligation toward the victims of Newtown, Conn.

It was all downhill from there.

By March, gun control legislation was dead; the president was unable to get even a watered-down bill to the floor of a Democratically controlled Senate. Immigration reform, an issue even more pressing for Republicans than Democrats considering the GOP’s rout from Hispanic voters in 2012, met a similar fate in the spring. By that time, the Boston Marathon bombings had deflected attention from legislative issues onto the questions of how terrorists had so easily infiltrated the finish line of one of the year’s most popular sporting events and why Russian intelligence warnings about the bombers had been dismissed. This coincided with the continuing Congressional investigation of the assault on the 2012 Libyan consulate in Benghazi, which turned up further security embarrassments for the administration.

The ink on these subjects was not yet dry when Edward Snowden made the first revelations about the massive domestic and international spying operations being carried out by the National Security Agency and other intelligence “services,” which reached exponentially further into the personal lives of virtually every citizen in the land than under any previous administration and threatened to make obsolete not only the Fourth Amendment prohibition against unreasonable search and seizure but also the very concept of privacy. At the same time, the president was forced to acknowledge that he authorized secret, targeted assassinations of American citizens among other people. In a republic informed of its liberties, these events might have triggered mass protests, demonstrations, Congressional investigations and possibly a presidential impeachment. Here, they produced only a worldwide manhunt for Snowden himself and the ugly and indecent spectacle of the world’s military superpower threatening any nation harboring Snowden. This ended, for the time being, at least, with Vladimir Putin granting asylum to Snowden in Russia, an event that torpedoed a Russian-American summit in August.
Snowden and his collaborators continued releasing tranches of new information about NSA spying abroad, which included our closest allies, throughout the summer and into the fall, embarrassing the United States. Another summit with Brazil was a further diplomatic casualty, while the Mexican government, angry at the failure of immigration reform, poked its finger in Uncle Sam’s eye by releasing a notorious drug figure from prison. America’s hemispheric reputation fell to its lowest level in many decades, and it fared little better in Europe and Africa. Meanwhile, a diplomatic initiative to revive talks between Israel and the Palestinian Authority, announced with much fanfare in the spring, went (predictably) nowhere, and Egypt’s military pointedly ignored Obama’s call for restraint in its crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood following its overthrow of Mohammed Morsi’s elected government.

These foreign debacles climaxed with the Syrian crisis of late August and early September, following reports of a massive chemical weapon attack on the suburbs of Damascus by the forces of President Bashar al-Assad. Without waiting for independent confirmation of the reports or obtaining foreign support, Obama announced his intention to bomb Syrian facilities in reprisal and moved American warships into place. Never since World War II had the United States undertaken a major military operation outside the Western Hemisphere without the support of allies, but when Obama belatedly attempted to cobble together a coalition of the willing, he found himself wholly isolated in the world community. Deeply embarrassed, he turned to Congress for support, though despite concessions to Republican warhawks, he could not extract even the most general statement of support from either chamber. Perhaps no chief executive in our history had ever stood so nakedly exposed before both a domestic and international audience. Obama had literally nowhere to turn.

It was Putin, Obama’s bete noire, who offered him a fig leaf in the form of a proposal to destroy Assad’s chemical stockpile under international supervision. Obama accepted with alacrity, if not particularly good grace. Assad crowed that he had forced the U.S. Navy to back down. No sooner had this historic fiasco moved to the back pages, however, when the federal government was forced into a 16-day shutdown by a cabal of Tea Party Republicans determined to scuttle implementation of the Affordable Care Act, a.k.a. Obamacare. This tactic was coupled with a threatened and very narrowly averted default on the national debt.

The world watched this spectacle with a mixture of fascination, horror and disgust as it had watched the revelation of an American Big Brother apparently intent on creating a universal surveillance network a few months earlier and ready to fire on the hapless citizens of a beleaguered nation only weeks before. This time, the stakes were a possible global depression and the collapse of the monetary regime that had anchored the international banking system since the end of World War II. The 12th-hour deal that averted this merely postponed a similar reckoning until the new year, solving nothing in an American political crisis unprecedented since the Civil War and fought over largely the same issue: the resolve of a minority to nullify duly enacted statutes and overturn the statutory authority of the federal government.

A side effect of this imbroglio may be the most lasting one of all. The president was forced by the shutdown to cancel a scheduled trip to East Asia, leaving the field at a major international conference to our chief strategic rival: the Chinese. This negated the most significant diplomatic reorientation of the Obama presidency — the attempt to extricate American power from the morass of the Middle East and to confront the rising regional hegemony of China. On all fronts, then — from the Americas to Europe, Africa and Asia — the United States found itself isolated, rejected or simply unrepresented.

And the year’s still got two more months to go.

If there was any silver lining for Obama in the shutdown-and-default crisis, it was in distracting attention from the disastrous rollout of the new health care exchanges. What the next news cycle will bring is anybody’s guess, but it’s unlikely to bear any glad tidings for Obama. With more than three years to go, his presidency appears at this point dead in the water. There are no doubt many structural reasons for our national impasse, but the style and personality of the current president must bear a significant share of responsibility. Watching the country lurch unguided from gridlock to deadlock, Obama has often reminded me of a man passively observing an approaching train wreck from the sidelines and only blowing his penny whistle when the cars have crashed. It’s no way to govern, but it seems to be the only style he has.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post Obama’s had a bad year appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Obama’s had a bad year

Climate change: the great betrayal

A recent headline in The New York Times announced a grim but inevitable marker: The concentration of carbon dioxide in Earth’s atmosphere has now reached 400 parts per million. Climatologists believe this is the highest concentration seen in 3 million years, since before the existence of humans. There is no credible reason to doubt that this increase has been largely, if not almost wholly, the result of carbon emissions since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. In other words, we are well on our way to producing a climate that human life has never dealt with before and that, by the end of the present century, may well have foreclosed the climatic conditions under whose relatively benign aegis human civilization emerged. This is a gamble in which the stakes are frighteningly high and the odds grow more dubious with each passing day of business as usual.

I am trying to frame this issue as soberly as I can. Three million years ago, ocean levels were 60 to 80 feet higher than they are today. Today, such levels would submerge most Pacific islands and reshape the world’s coastlines. The continental shape of our planet, which we’ve really understood only in the past 100 years with the mapping of the poles, would be radically altered. The risen ocean would also be more acidic than any we’ve ever known — it already is — with more devastating consequences for the life it contains. The imminent melting of the permafrost, which contains vast reserves of carbon dioxide, would put the carbonization of the atmosphere beyond any possibility of human control.

The social, economic and ultimately demographic consequences of such change are similarly incalculable. Even in the remaining habitable portions of the globe, catastrophic weather events would become the norm. Food production would fall, and synthetic substitutes would be inadequate to meet the need. Resource wars would contest every advantage, no matter how small and temporary. Under these circumstances, the world would soon be divided between zones of anarchy and autocracy. Needless to say, democracy would be among the first things to go. Population would decline, at a certain point beyond hope of renewal. Those who could no longer fend for themselves or demonstrate the utility of their survival would go more quickly and perhaps be disposed of preemptively. That itself would spell the end of civilization. A Darwinian struggle for existence would ensue. The species may or may not survive in this degraded form. Whether it would continue as we have come to know it — to know ourselves — would be very much in doubt.

The West has teased itself with visions of apocalypse for a very long time, since the ancient flood myths. This time, however, we are on the verge of realizing actual disaster. No wrathful deity inflicts it on us; we are doing it to ourselves.

Our scientists understand this. So do our politicians, for the most part. The scientists can do nothing with their knowledge but counsel and warn. The politicians are better positioned to act, but they represent conflicting interests and competing nationalities. They also, for the most part, need to be elected, and no one gets elected on a Doomsday platform. So they pay lip service to the problem and suggest palliative reforms at the margin, which they then fail to enact or enforce. Religious leaders, who once preached hellfire so zealously, are now virtually silent about the real hell we are creating.

The old joke used to be, “Everybody talks about the weather, and nobody does anything about it.” But we are in fact doing plenty to it, and it is no joke.
One is tempted under these circumstances to wish for a Weather Messiah, someone with the moral authority and political capacity to shake us out of our torpor before it is too late. No such party exists or is likely to appear. There is, however, one figure who by virtue of his position is better situated than anyone else to focus attention and perhaps achieve something while it is still possible: the president of the United States.

The president can do this, in part, because the United States is by far the world’s largest climate offender. With less than five per cent of the world’s population, the U.S. emits a quarter of the world’s carbon pollution.  We could cut this figure in half with available technology and no loss to our standard of living; this is proven by the fact that European nations have already done so. We would benefit at the same time by retrofitting and modernizing our decayed and obsolete infrastructure, which is increasingly vulnerable to the catastrophic weather events that we have already begun to face. We could also begin the critical task of replacing fossil fuels with renewable energy, our only long-term hope of survival. When I say “long-term,” I am not thinking of millennia or centuries. I am thinking of decades.

We’ll never know how far along we might be in the national conversation about climate change had the Supreme Court not denied Al Gore his rightful election as president a dozen years ago and put the scion of an oil family joined at the hip to Saudi princes in the White House. Gore talked the talk; whether he would have walked the walk is something we’ll never know. President Obama put climate change on his agenda in the 2008 campaign; like Xerxes or Canute, he promised to still the waves and keep the seas from rising. But the president is given to such rhetorical gestures and to magical thinking in general — the idea that to wish or proclaim a thing is the same thing as to achieve it.

In practice, he has wasted four years in office and is now wasting four more. It is clear that he is not the leader we desperately require. The man who could not get gun control back to where it was 20 years ago or the minimum wage (relative to inflation) to where it was in 1968 is not going to get Americans to give up their SUVs. Worse, the president has undermined many of the efforts of his own agencies to implement tougher pollution standards and controls. Instead of driving a stake through the Keystone XL pipeline proposal, he has dragged out a process that will almost certainly result in its approval. This is not only a missed opportunity, but under the circumstances we face, it is also a betrayal of historic proportions. George W. Bush, a puny man, could perhaps know or do no better. But Barack Obama does know better, at least with his head. That makes him all the more tragically culpable.

Of course, Obama is just one man, and like the rest of us, he is enmeshed in a profligate global economic system that puts a premium on wasteful consumption, greed and societal indifference — the system that has brought us to our present pass. In America particularly, we ritually celebrate this system and the values that reinforce it even as it destroys us. We call it freedom, and it does confer one indubitable freedom on us: the freedom to perish.

We have had enough prophets to warn us: Henry David Thoreau, John Muir, Robinson Jeffers, Aldo Leopold, Rachel Carson, Jim Hansen and Bill McKibben. We have had enough studies and seen enough statistics. We have enough projections of our grim future. We are now at the point, if not already past it, of deciding whether we want a future that any of us would wish to see.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post Climate change: the great betrayal appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Climate change: the great betrayal

Leftists: living in a state of denial?

President Barack Obama has sent a budget to Congress, which I guess is news because he’s overlooked that particular function of the executive branch until now. However, the news that seems to have grabbed everyone’s attention is his proposal to cut Social Security benefits by recalculating the cost-of-living adjustment formula that is notionally supposed to keep their value in line with inflation. The new metric, the so-called Chained Consumer Price Index, understates inflation, especially for food and medicine. Because those items are of particular interest to senior citizens, this has suspended forks over food trays all over the country. It has also revived the oldest, most anguished question on the so-called American Left: Is Barack Obama really a progressive?

I can tell you this: No one since the New Deal-era Republican Party has waged as assiduous a campaign against Social Security as Barack Obama, and to be waking up to the fact at this late date argues either a powerful lack of attention or an intense state of denial, which pretty much amount to the same thing.

Social Security used to be the third rail of American politics. Al Gore promised to put it in a lock box during his 2000 presidential campaign. George W. Bush got away with luring the country into war on false pretenses and making us take off our shoes at the airport, but his attempt to privatize Social Security was the blunder from which he never recovered. Republicans, though, did learn from this, and they have been silent on the subject ever since.

It was President Obama who revived the question of Social Security. He tried to give this a patina of respectability by creating the Simpson-Bowles Commission, which raised alarms that the Social Security trust fund was about to go bust (it is in fact an actuarial illusion). Obama’s initial response to this was to suspend Social Security tax collection and freeze cost-of-living adjustments for two years. So seniors’ benefits have already been cut by somewhere between 5 and 10 percent, depending on which government price index you’re following, or maybe just the bill in the shopping cart.

Obama introduced a permanent cut via the Chained CPI as part of his negotiations with Republicans in August 2011 to avert a default in the national debt. The Republicans didn’t suggest it, nor did they respond to it; it was entirely the president’s project. Similarly, no one is forcing him now to revive it as part of a budget proposal that Republicans have already pronounced (as expected) dead on arrival. Obama has advertised it as a pre-emptive concession to encourage Republicans to consider the tax increases that the budget also envisages. The GOP hasn’t risen to the bait this time either, though. If the president wants to put Social Security on the chopping block, it’s strictly his affair.

So, why is Obama so gung-ho to go after the most important part of the country’s social safety net? What kind of Democratic president, in the absence of any pressure but that generated by himself, would attack the program that most crucially defines the party’s legacy and identity?

Democrats, I suppose, will have to answer that question for themselves. Watching Obama’s first year in office unfold in 2009 — a doubling-down on the failed war in Afghanistan, a free pass to the Wall Street banksters, the abandonment of the public option in the health care reform bill, and so on — I suggested in these pages, only partly tongue-in-cheek, that he was a Manchurian candidate fashioned by a murky Trilateral Commission to carry out the Republican agenda until the party had recovered sufficiently from the debacle of the Bush years to run an electable figure on its own. Four years later, I have no better explanation.

It’s the Left, though, whose state of denial is most comprehensive and, at this point, most risible. The burning question of the hour for page-turners of Mother Jones and The Nation is, “Is Barack Obama really a progressive?” Or is he merely the happy drone warrior who still runs Guantanamo and checks off his kill lists while the banks continue to foreclose and the middle class recedes into memory?

How old is this debate? I clipped out a page of The New York Times in July 2008 after then-Sen. Obama had just come out in favor of a Bush-backed bill to authorize warrantless wiretapping. The Times was disappointed in Obama, but the readers’ column was more instructive. A couple from Wilton, Conn., declared themselves so disillusioned by Obama that they might not vote at all in the November election. A lady from Tiburon, Calif., wrote that it disheartened her that he could not “find the courage to uphold the vision of the Founding Fathers against an overbearing state.” A gentleman from Manorhaven, N.Y,, observed that “hope springs eternal — but not in 2008.” Laura Stern of New York City signed off, too, noting that Obama was “a roll of the dice, and I’m not a gambler.”

Enough people did roll the dice, not once but twice. We are where we are: four more years. Only, please, let’s can the debate about whether Obama is a failed progressive or only a misguided one. They’re laughing all the way to Manchuria.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post Leftists: living in a state of denial? appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Leftists: living in a state of denial?