Author Archives | Robert Zaller

Pres. Obama fails black community

After Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown, after the killings of unarmed and unresisting African-Americans — one 12-years-old — in New York, Cleveland, Los Angeles and Charleston, North Carolina, the murder of Freddie Gray in Baltimore April 12 at last sparked serious rioting in a major American city.

How has our first African-American president responded to this?

In his first statement on the killing of Gray, Barack Obama characterized the rioters in Baltimore as “criminals,” as though their behavior was the source of violence rather than the reaction to it. Rush Limbaugh said the same.

When the President spoke again, he said, “If our society really wanted to solve the problem [posed by the riots], we could. It’s just that it would require everybody saying, ‘This is important, this is significant.’ And, that we just don’t pay attention to these communities when a CVS burns, and we just don’t pay attention when a young man gets shot or has his spine snapped, but we’re paying attention all the time because we consider those kids our kids.”

Anthony Romero of the American Civil Liberties Union sent this statement to me, nodding his approval. I wonder if he read it first. The President, you will note, cited an act of vandalism against property ahead of an unjustifiable homicide. In doing so, he reversed the sequence of events. Freddie Gray was killed, and because of that a CVS pharmacy was burned. It wasn’t the other way around, and it wasn’t, as the President’s statement reads syntactically, as if the events weren’t necessarily related at all.

Indeed, he couldn’t, or wouldn’t even characterize what had happened to Gray properly. Gray wasn’t just a victim who had been shot or had his spine broken. He was specifically the man who had his spine broken, that very particular man with his own name and no one else’s. By turning Gray into a generic victim, moreover, Obama’s rhetoric clouds the sequence of events further still. You can’t tell which event is cause and which effect or even if the three examples run together — the burned pharmacy, the (hypothetical) young man shot and the (hypothetical) young man with the broken spine — are causally related at all.

This isn’t just careless speech, it is speech designed to obfuscate. Obama is a man who prides himself on precision, a lawyer who knows the importance of stating his case exactly. So, who is it the President is really speaking to, who is it who equates cause and effect, action and response, offense given and offense taken, who, in short, blends everything into an undifferentiated blur of “violence,” the sort of thing that happens to you-know-whom and you-know-where? Correct: The President is speaking to, if not for, racist America. The message may be subliminal, but it is no less clear.

The rest of the President’s statement invites us to consider what we might do if we actually gave a damn about it all in the first place: “If our society really wanted to solve the problem [of poverty? violence? racism? — something in there], we could, it’s just that it would require everybody saying, ‘This is important…’” Such was Obama’s call to arms on the subject of race in the seventh year of his presidency.

Let me say it plainly: no white president could get away with a statement like Obama’s in the epidemic of police violence against African-Americans we have been swept up in — or, more accurately, that the public at large has just begun to pay attention to. Let’s translate it into the first person, where presidential leadership belongs: If I really gave a damn about poverty, violence, and racism, I’d issue a call to action and back it up with everything that’s in the power of the presidency to achieve.

If race is the third rail of American politics, though, for Obama it is the first and second ones too. And he’s not going to come within a million miles of touching any of them. If, for white America, Obama is the first black president we’ve had, for black America, he is the whitest president since Andrew Johnson.

It isn’t just a matter of pursuing a Nixonian policy of benign neglect. It was Obama who decided to leave Black America to suffer the worst of the Great Recession while he ministered to Wall Street. It was Obama’s defense department that turned local police departments into armored cavalry and civilian communities into war zones. It was his justice department that couldn’t be bothered to keep statistics about those who die in police actions or in police custody. It was Obama personally who called for the expansion of the death penalty, wielded disproportionately against people of color and oversaw the imprisonment and deportation of more immigrants of color, children included, than any other president in history. It was on Obama’s watch that the Voting Rights Act was gutted by a reactionary Supreme Court, while he offered no response or even complaint.

White liberals like Anthony Romero may grasp at any straw to see Obama as other than he is. Black Americans don’t voice their profound disillusion and disgust for fear the guy might turn on them even worse.

Obama will hope to get through the remaining 20 months of his presidency without having to turn Bull Connor’s fire hose loose or send tanks into the streets as Lyndon Johnson did in Newark, New Jersey, and Detroit. It wouldn’t look good on his resume. But if we are going to have a “conversation” about race again, let alone anything more substantial, it will have to wait for a future administration.

The fire this time, though, might just not wait for that.

The post Pres. Obama fails black community appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Pres. Obama fails black community

Pope Francis making questionable decisions

I’m not a member of the Catholic Church, and its mysteries don’t often concern me except when I need to understand them in a historical context. But I do have to ask what in the world is going on with the Pope Francis. He speaks for over a billion people, at least notionally, and some of the things he has been doing and saying have passed the point of the peculiar. So, if it isn’t me, someone will surely be asking the question soon: Really, Francis, what’s up?

The choice of Francis as the successor to Pope Benedict XVI was widely popular, at least in lay and liberal Catholic circles, and even non-Catholics often have a rooting interest in the papacy, which is, after all, a unique institution. The leader of China rules roughly as many people, but his position is understood to be a rotating one, and although he is an ideological and political leader, it is well understood that “Chinese Communism” is an oxymoron in what is rapidly becoming the world’s most advanced capitalist state.

Francis, on the other hand, is doctrinally regarded as having unique access not merely to ideological but ontological reality and as being inerrant in matters of faith and morals. Like any mortal, he can mistake the time of day if his watch isn’t working properly. When it comes, though, to matters of personal conduct and the proper path to salvation, he is held — as his predecessors have been since 1864 — to be the conduit of universal truth.

The church has a doctrinal position on gays, for example, and has held to it for a good while. It is a sin that must be repented, and, with divine help, abjured. Francis, however, advanced a different view not long after assuming the papacy. He opined that it was not his part to judge whether homosexuality was a mortal sin that precluded salvation. The trouble is, though, that this is precisely part of his job as the church defines it.

Technically, of course, the acts of salvation and damnation are entirely at God’s disposal. But it is the church’s job to counsel Catholics on the proper path to salvation, and to warn them against the behavior that will normally bar it. Homosexuality is not only considered a grave sin in and of itself according to church doctrine, but it is regarded as subversive of what the church considers the most fundamental of human institutions, the family.

For Francis to have offered an off-the-cuff statement, seemingly at odds with fundamental church precepts, would naturally have sent shock waves throughout the papal hierarchy.  Although the pope’s word is authoritative, it is normally the product, as in any bureaucracy, of a lengthy process of deliberation — and the bureaucracy of the Catholic Church is not any bureaucracy but has been for most of the past thousand years the biggest and most comprehensive one in the world.

For a pope to short-circuit its normal processes, is unprecedented in the modern papacy. But what is most threatening in a pope is not to question or make doctrine on the fly. It is to question the very idea of a solid doctrinal position. That is precisely what Francis did in saying, a propos homosexual conduct as such, “Who am I to judge?” The last person in the Catholic Church to say such a thing aloud was Martin Luther.

Of course, such professions of intellectual modesty have made Francis a popular figure outside the church, as has his modest personal lifestyle. He has rebuked the princes of the church for living large, and frowned on the shady machinations of the Vatican fisc. How much impact this has had on the church may be doubted, but it has made a “people’s pope” out of Francis. In the dark corners of the Curia, however, he looks more and more like a loose cannon, which is to say, dangerous.

And then there have been the very public gaffes. In the recent uproar over the Charlie Hebdo massacre and the debate about the freedom to satirize and even deride religious faith, Francis weighed in with the observation that he would punch out anyone who mocked his mother’s cherished beliefs. This didn’t sound like a ringing endorsement of free expression, and the idea of a pope as personally prepared for violence seemed an odd stance for the Vicar of Christ. Added to this was Francis’ equally colloquial remark about Mexico as a haven for drug cartels, which required him to apologize to an entire nation.

However, the one area in which Francis has received very high marks is in his unabashed condemnation of the sexual abuse scandals that have rocked the church for the past three pontificates and which have undermined its moral authority among the faithful, as have few things since the Protestant Reformation. Neither John Paul II nor Benedict was willing to address the issue head on, and both were widely suspected of trying to cover it up as far as possible. Francis, as if deliberately making amends for them (and, no doubt, hoping as they did to avert the attention of secular authorities), announced a general reckoning in the priesthood and a zero tolerance policy for the future.

This sounded fine. It was one thing for the church to harbor sinners; it was another for it to be a haven for them. Trust and innocence were the most perfect treasures reposed in the church; their abuse was the inroad of Satan himself. The people’s pope would set things to right if anyone could.

It is precisely this issue, however, that has led to Francis’ most troubling public act: his recent appointment of Bishop Juan Barros to head the southern Chilean diocese of Osorno. Barros has been widely accused of covering up sexual abuses over more than two decades by one Father Fernando Karadima, the disgraced mentor of a Catholic youth movement, and even destroying evidence of his crimes. One of Karadima’s victims has indeed alleged that Barros was personally present when Karadima behaved abusively. At Barros’ installation ceremony, hundreds of black-clad demonstrators interrupted the proceedings with cries for him to “get out of the city.”  Thousands of other protesters, including members of the Chilean Congress, chanted outside the city’s cathedral for his removal.

As the long-serving archbishop of Buenos Aires, Francis must have been aware of the accusations against Barros, and he has certainly heard aplenty about them in the last several months. This time, however, he has left it to spokesmen to declare that he sees “no reason” to rescind Barros’ appointment.

Francis owed his elevation to the papacy in good part to the fact that Latin America is now the demographic base of world Catholicism. The controversy over Barros has echoed throughout the region, even though it has received little press in the United States. Whatever the merits of the case against him, the dogged assertion of papal authority against such broad-based popular opposition — the closest thing to actual revolt within the church seen in a long time — has deeply undermined the credibility of this pope on the signature issue of his pontificate.

It is no secret that conservatives placed in key church positions by John Paul and Benedict are simply waiting Francis out instead of openly resisting him. Francis himself, after broadly hinting that he too, like Benedict, would retire from the papal throne, has lately been “speculating” that he might to do so in as little as two or three years. This can hardly be read as anything but a confession of defeat. Francis, never a papal insider, will finally be remembered as a lightweight with a loose tongue whose elevation was a mistake. His epitaph will be that he confused a shallow populism with the skills necessary to pilot a hugely complex, deeply conservative, and in many ways sclerotic institution in a new century. The Catholic Church has been in many ways the definition of an entity too big to fail, and no one should be betting against it anytime soon.  At the same time, however, the winds of secularism are blowing hard against it. John Paul, his charisma and his sense of modern public relations notwithstanding, pushed hard against those winds, as did Benedict, whose pontificate was in many ways a listless coda to John Paul’s. Francis has shown the danger of too casually yielding to them. The next occupant of the throne of St. Peter’s may have more work cut out for him than anyone can handle.

The post Pope Francis making questionable decisions appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Pope Francis making questionable decisions

When education becomes a business, students lose

Once upon a time, businesses stuck to what they knew how to do best, and education — not a business, but a collaborative enterprise serving critical social functions on a nonprofit basis — kept its eye on acquainting students with the heritage of civilization, preparing them for life in a democratic society, and extending human knowledge. That was a pretty tall order in itself, but apparently not tall enough.

Businesses, as we know, have now metastasized into something called conglomerates, greed machines that no longer want to do one thing well, or even several, but as many as possible, well or badly.

You can state an inverse relationship between the number of things you do and your success at doing them, as multitasking has taught most of us personally, but, for businesses — or the banks and brokerage houses that provide their model — not even the sky is the limit to what they’ll attempt, but only the bottom line of profitability, the so-called discipline of the market.

How badly this has worked for business — and for society generally — we can see from the still-smoking wreckage of the 2008 financial collapse. A single example may suffice: General Motors, which forgot how to make salable cars, extended itself into a new product line of “financial services,” and the hanky-panky there collapsed it to the point where it had to be bailed out to the tune of many billions of dollars by taxpayers who, like myself, had no interest in any of its products or services.

There was of course a lesson in this, namely the outrageous folly of erasing institutional barriers between business and finance, although the banks that now run the show in late capitalism have succeeded in preventing anyone from applying it.

The particular “business” I now work in, formerly known as education, displays all the hallmarks of conglomeration gone haywire, and nowhere more egregiously than at the institution where I am employed, Drexel University. Education, as a business, is distinct from most other commercial enterprises in providing its product at the direct point of service, namely the classroom.

You would think that, like an auto showroom, classrooms should be set up for the maximum gratification of the consumer, but, no, I do most of my teaching in stuffy, antiquated and minimally furnished rooms, which my students put up with remarkable forbearance, having learned higher education’s first lesson: that, if they are the primary source of its income, they are very far down on the list of its concerns.

In fact, students no longer really exist. Some time ago, they were redefined as “customers” (and my own relationship to them from teaching to servicing them). Now, a customer is, as we all know, an individual from whom the maximum of revenue is to be extracted with the minimum of value returned.

This applies not only in the classroom (where most faculty, quirkily, go against the rules by offering as much value as they can), but also in dormitory housing, meal plans and, above all, in debt enslavement. Your average graduate is the gift that keeps on giving, stoking a trillion-dollar student loan industry for years, even decades, after quitting any college premises.

Oh, yes, and you’ll be asked for alumni donations too. Regularly.

Some years ago, Drexel was featured in a Wall Street Journal article as a paradigm of the new corporate model in higher education. Those were innocent, halcyon days.

I would defy anyone to even find a university on the east side of Chestnut between 32nd and 33rd Streets, where the MacAlister-Creese complex has virtually disappeared behind a phalanx of shops, eateries and faceless dorms, with a bank in the middle to finish off the effect of a commercial district — Shake Shack U., we might call it.

Across the street on the southwest corner, meanwhile, classroom and student activity space (so abundant everywhere on campus!) has been demolished to make room for a 10-story hotel that is being called, with a maximum of chutzpah, “The Study.” Remove actual academic space and replace it with a commercial venue, and then make it sound like a shady nook to crack a book — wouldn’t George Orwell be proud of that piece of legerdemain.

And then go down a block to the oft-redesigned space that separates a desperately hemmed-in academic quad from the administration building, afloat on its isolated glory like the Pequod, and you’ll find Perelman Plaza, where the man so fond of his own face that he buys ad space in The New York Times to show it has put himself on permanent display to remind us of how he managed to remove the last visible green space on campus.

The fact that Ray Perelman is also principally responsible for destroying one of the great experiments in American education, the Barnes Foundation, only adds to the drollery. What’s next, a statue to John D. Rockefeller?

Next, in fact, has been the brouhaha about student housing, which President John A. Fry is anxious to sell but students are not eager to buy. The story behind that, of course, is the University’s drive to enlarge the student body over the past 20 years, climaxing in the come-one, come-all approach to recruitment that produced over 50,000 applications a year at one point, most of them duds.

This policy, the brainchild of Fry’s predecessor, has been belatedly rescinded, but not before having had the predictable result of depressing student quality and retention rates. It has also put a great deal of pressure on surrounding neighborhoods for housing — woe betide any city neighborhood that has the misfortune to be “home” to a university, let alone two — and that, in turn, has led to the present three-sided zoning war involving local civic associations, the Drexel administration and Drexel students.

You can guess who’s the odd man out here. The administration wants to corral as many students as possible in its own housing units, all of them pricier than local private options. In the words of one Drexel sophomore, quoted in the Feb. 6 issue of this paper, “It sounds like Drexel is trying to create a monopoly. I understand what they’re trying to do, which is make more money …”

We can stop right there. Create a monopoly? Make more money? Well, doesn’t every business do the same, especially when it has invested a great deal of money with its development partners in creating units to sell?

American universities, like the NFL, are tax-exempt institutions, and at this point I frankly don’t see what the excuse for not treating either as a business — especially as so many universities are in fact holding pens for the
NFL’s meat-grinder.

As Nicolena Stiles has noted in The Triangle, many Drexel students feel “blindsided and shocked by the University’s actions.” What they should not have been is surprised.

At least Drexel’s students are standing up for their “customer” rights. Since Fry took office, the University’s lump-sum retirement package for faculty has been halved on the pretext of rationalizing it, and a new retirement plan unilaterally imposed that will require drastically higher contributions from junior faculty.

Funny, but I didn’t see any Faculty Senate Newsletter report on the subject. Oh, the Senate doesn’t have a newsletter? Well, that’s not really surprising, since Drexel doesn’t have a Senate either, despite the office sign still up on the door of Randell 119.

In a better world, faculty would not be leaving students to fight their own battles with the administration, but would regard student welfare as inseparable from their own. In a better world, “the University’s actions” would refer not to the unilateral actions of administrators but to the consensus of an academic community. Since when, anyway, did the term “university” become synonymous with “administration?”

I can hazard a guess about that last question at least. When the faculty, as the permanent body of any university, permitted its own essential rights — the tenure system, collegial governance, and the maintenance of community — to be stripped away with hardly a ripple of protest, it betrayed its own fundamental responsibility and sealed its professional doom.

At this point, the American university system needs to be rebuilt from the ground up. Until then, it’s just us clerks and customers here, and as for the product — well, just look at what passes for an informed citizenry and a democratic society around you.

Robert Zaller is a history professor at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.

The post When education becomes a business, students lose appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When education becomes a business, students lose

Tea Party suspends Homeland Security admin. funding

Hurray for the Tea Party! The lunatics liberated the asylum, if only for a brief, shining moment. It’s one we should cherish, though, as infinitely precious.

On Feb. 27, the House of Representatives blocked an emergency bill to fund the Homeland Security Administration for three weeks. The vote was close, but clear: 222-204. Naturally, the vast majority of the nay-sayers were Republicans, but 12 Democrats did join them, which made the final difference.

Photo Courtesy Department of Homeland Security/Wikipedia Secretary of Homeland Security

Photo Courtesy Department of Homeland Security/Wikipedia
Secretary of Homeland Security

Their names should be enshrined on the Capitol Dome. They liberated their country, however briefly. But let us not forget where the lion’s share of the credit belongs: it was the Tea Party wing of the GOP that swung the vote, and commanded the bulk of it. Terrified by this populist scourge, even House Speaker John Boehner’s more reliable charges joined the stampede.

Of course, the Tea Partiers did the right thing for the wrong reasons, as is their wont. But thank the good Lord for stopped clocks. They do get the time right twice a day, which is twice more than the spinning, special interests-driven gyroscope that is Washington’s normal mode of telling time.

The Tea Partiers cut off Homeland Security’s cash flow because they were piqued by their inability to attach a rider to the emergency funding bill that would have rolled back the immigration reforms — more accurately, the relaxation of some of its more onerous administrative provisions — decreed by President Barack Obama in November.

Let’s get some of that background straight. No president has treated an immigrant population more brutally since Franklin D. Roosevelt decided to lock Japanese-Americans up in concentration camps during World War II than Barack Obama.

Under Obama’s administration, more illegal immigrants have been deported than under any predecessor, and more families miserably broken apart, with parents on one side of the border and children on the other.

More such immigrants have been jailed on the pretext of petty violations of the law, and housed for months and years at a time in conditions of squalor and misery that make FDR’s internment sites look like the Ritz Carlton. In fact, we have been operating a whole gulag system in the lower 48 states, all to punish the crime of seeking a better life.

President Obama has been deeply concerned about this, like a mad driver trying to tap down the brakes while his other foot rides the accelerator. He has told the Congress, annually, that he wants immigration reform that will provide undocumented aliens with a path, albeit a steep and treacherous one, to citizenship.

He has then ritually taken no for an answer from Speaker Boehner, and filed away his speech for another year. This is how our President engages the legislative process. He tells people what they ought to do, and then folds up his tents when they don’t do it.

To encourage them to act, he further immiserates the very people whom he notionally wishes to assist, to the point of denying them elemental human rights. Well, we did elect the guy.

The Tea Partiers have a simpler solution to America’s immigration problem: deport everyone who hasn’t got papers. Ideally, illegal aliens would get the message and go home before being kicked out — the notion popularized by Mitt Romney as “self-deportation.”

To get the message across, they want to make conditions for such aliens as onerous as possible. Hence, their demand to undo Obama’s loosening of the noose last November, itself of course a transparent ploy to woo the Hispanic vote.

Unlike other people in Washington, Tea Partiers tend to mean what they say, rather as a squalling infant does. To make their point about immigration, they are perfectly prepared to shut down government agencies. Homeland Security was simply the target du jour.

It could just as easily, and as arbitrarily, have been the Centers for Disease Control; the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms; or the Federal Aviation Administration. These agencies do their jobs well or poorly, for good or ill. As a matter of fact, none of them have been distinguishing themselves much of late.

But Homeland Security is the sacred cow of the federal government.  It exists for the one job that, above all else, Americans have been taught to require: being kept safe, at all times and under all circumstances. We have learned to do without many of the functions government once routinely undertook: safe food, clean air, public education and even postal service. But security?

In the wake of 9/11, in the atmosphere of hysteria in which the Department of Homeland Security was founded, fear became our daily bread, and the DHS its provider. It is, in fact, our Ministry of Fear, and on it our gigantic 21st century surveillance state has been erected.

Yes, the National Security Administration’s snooping long preceded it, as did the spooks of J. Edgar Hoover and James Jesus Angleton. Nor, in fact, did the DHS have anything to add to existing spy agencies and special ops projects; it has been one great boondoggle from the beginning.

It was born out of the colossal intelligence failure that made 9/11 possible. And like many another federal bureaucracy, it exists to compound the problem that created it.

Thus, DHS did not replace the CIA, FBI, NSA or any of the other dozen-odd federal intelligence agencies. It was superimposed on them, as another layer of redundancy. It is most famous, at this point, for flying air marshals around the country for sexual assignations, stripping little old ladies in public and confiscating large quantities of drinking fluids and intimate toiletries.

It must have quite a stash of house and car keys by now, too. What it has not demonstrated is the slightest capacity for improving travel safety or securing the national borders. That isn’t really the point, though.

The DHS does not exist to make us safer; it exists to make us fear for our safety. The more ineptly it executes its presumed mission, the better it executes its actual one: to keep us all on mental red alert. And that mission is the critical one in modern government, for it justifies the confiscation not only of shampoos but of civil liberties, starting with bodily privacy and ending with thought control.

Tea Partiers may or may not have figured this out; I actually doubt they have. They shut off funds for the DHS, for a few hours anyway, simply because it was a government agency, regardless of function. They didn’t care what DHS did or didn’t do. Whatever it was, they were going to shut it down until the government stopped coddling illegal aliens and their children.

Inadvertently, they left a far more interesting point on the record: that a majority of the House of Representatives was either willing to jeopardize the security of the nation or unconvinced that the uninterrupted operation of the DHS was critical to it.

Since the DHS has been advertised from the beginning as our first, indispensable line of defense against international terrorism — since it is the one government agency tasked with that function and none other — this would seem a less than resounding endorsement, both of the DHS itself and of the proposition that terrorism is “Public Threat Number One.” Fools, it seems, may sometimes speak the truths that wise men fear to utter.

Islamic terrorism, a nagging but mid-level problem until the lucky hit of 9/11, was promptly elevated to the status of an existential threat requiring an endless “war” to combat it by the unelected administration whose indifference and incompetence permitted it to occur. We have all been paying a very high price since, and none of it higher than the DHS, the security agency whose chief actual function is to keep us scared around the clock. No one has dared to call it out till now.

The Tea Party caucus has done just that, and how can we not be grateful to it? Can we move on now, please, to the CIA, the FBI and the NSA? I can’t think of the last time these agencies have not done more harm than good, or, for that matter, when they’ve ever done any good, period. You know, if we can’t be secure, we might as well be free.

The best antidote to terrorism would be to stop fighting the imperial wars that produce it. Terrorism is always a response to social ills, real or perceived. The laying waste of a wide swath of the contemporary Middle East from Libya to Pakistan by Western invasion is a very real fact. Nor is terrorism simply a present-day phenomenon.

At the end of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th centuries, Europe and the United States were swept by a wave of anarchist (and, in Russia, reactionary state-sponsored) terrorism that claimed the lives of kings, presidents and prime ministers as well as ordinary folk, and saw bombs hurled into legislatures and stock exchanges.

The world survived it, and, with World War I, devised a mass slaughter that rendered it redundant.

I won’t say exactly that the best way to deal with contemporary terrorism is to ignore it, but it is certainly far better treated as an ongoing police problem than a “war” to be fought and won. Institutionalizing an enemy only guarantees it permanence, and creates the kind of bureaucracy that feeds on perpetuating it.

So let’s defund the DHS, not for an hour or a day but for good. Our civil liberties will be the better for it, and our private lives. Maybe our security will be, too.

In the meantime, thanks be to those Tea Party nut cases. They’ve blazed the way forward.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post Tea Party suspends Homeland Security admin. funding appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Tea Party suspends Homeland Security admin. funding

Barack Obama: The Tin Man President

From time to time, I have pondered the fortunes of the Republican Party, buried deeper than King Tut seven years ago by George W. Bush and now poised to reclaim the only branch of government it does not control lock, stock and barrel two Novembers from now, with only Hillary Clinton in the way.

You remember Hillary, the shoo-in candidate who performed so badly that a funny-eared guy with a name that rhymes with the world’s most hated terrorist walked off with the Democratic nomination and cruised into the White House.

Photo Courtesy Pete Souza/Wikipedia and Insomnia Cured Here/Flickr

Photo Courtesy Pete Souza/Wikipedia and Insomnia Cured Here/Flickr

Hillary and the Republicans do have this in common: they both performed so badly in 2008 that it seemed not even divine intervention could resurrect them. And the icing on the cake is that the man who could well give the Republicans their trifecta goes by the name of Bush. And this is a guy even his mother didn’t want to see run. (Of course, Barbara must be so bored with the White House by now.)

Let’s not forget, though, to give the Democratic Party its due: no franchise has fallen from first to worst faster — not even the Phillies, who, like the Democrats, think they can still win by fielding their 2008 lineup.

After losing the Senate to the Republicans in a rout last November, senior Democrats are now doing the kind of soul-searching that the GOP did after putting up a war hero in 2008 and losing to a skinny kid from Hawaii.

What they’ve come up with so far is something like this: Democrats are after all deeply principled statesmen who believe in fairness, equality and giving a hand up now and then to the deserving poor. They just aren’t getting their message across; in other words, they’ve blown the opportunity to own Washington for the next 20 years for lack of a marketing plan.

They also agree that they made a big tactical mistake in running away from their notional leader, Barack Obama, instead of running against the other party. Obama thinks so, too, which is why he was so delighted — the politer words used in the press were “liberated” and “energized” — by the Democrats’ defeat.

Liberated from his own party? Well, yes, because never actually belonged to it, and being, now, the last Democrat standing, he has at last succeeded in defining the party as himself.

And who and what may that be?

I have tried, with Maureen Dowd, to figure Barack Hussein Obama out these past seven years. I have seen him as the “Manchurian Candidate,” cobbled together by the Trilateral Commission as a plausible cipher to run the agenda of the Permanent Ruling Class through the back door when the Republican brand became temporarily tarnished.

I don’t think that was a bad stab at the truth, because the Obama agenda — pushing a healthcare bill devised by the Heritage Foundation as reform; doubling down on the surveillance state and a failed war in Afghanistan; giving the Fortune 500 a trade bill to die for in the Trans-Pacific Partnership; slow-walking the “recovery” from the financial blowout of 2008 until wages could be permanently slashed and the last unions driven out of business; etc., etc. — was, transparently, the Koch Brothers’ dream of America.

Still, the “Manchurian Candidate” doesn’t quite do Obama justice. In the famous movie, the Laurence Harvey character, Raymond Shaw, is hypnotized whenever his mother flashes a certain card sequence at him and that sounds more like George W.

Besides, the idea that America has actually been ruled by Barbara Bush for the past quarter century is too creepy even for a horror movie. But the cinema analogy seemed to me the right track, and I think I’ve finally got it nailed down.

Barack Obama is the Tin Man.

Yes, that Tin Man, the one from “The Wizard of Oz,” who is perpetually in quest of the one thing he lacks, the one thing his designers forgot to put into him: a heart. In the book, and more famously the classic 1939 movie, the Tin Man tags along after Dorothy Gale, the girl from Kansas who gets the worst of a tornado but never loses her pluck.

He is kind of awkward, and with his moving metal parts looking in need of a lube job, he is probably a lousy foul shooter too. Still, lacking a heart is no joke. Try doing without it sometime.

Like Barack Obama, the Tin Man is not really a leader, because how, after all, can one lead without any sense of direction? That’s precisely what a heart does: it tells you where to go and what to do. So the Tin Man tags along after Dorothy, a perky kid but kind of lost herself.

In the end — but this is where movies, as they must, diverge from real life — he gets his heart, or at any rate a heart-shaped watch, as a sort of merit badge. Even in the movies, you can’t get a real heart if you’re born without one, though you get points for wanting it.

Obama is the Tin Man who doesn’t want a heart, but who likes to pretend he has one. It’s not a very convincing show, though, when you program drones in the knowledge they will kill and maim the innocent, and when you throw people into jail for exposing torturers while protecting the torturers themselves.

The interesting thing, though, is that Democrats, having shunned Obama almost from the first moment of his presidency, have now decided they want to be just like him. More precisely, they are discovering they have always been exactly who he is: the Tin Man without a heart.

Once upon a time, the Democratic Party elected a suitably patrician candidate, Franklin D. Roosevelt, who campaigned on a platform of balancing the budget that his spendthrift opponent, Herbert Hoover, had allowed to get out of whack in the midst of the Great Depression. Roosevelt then turned around and did what so many politicians do: he broke his solemn promise and spent like crazy to save the Republic. This was called the New Deal.

When FDR got warmed up, he promised us four freedoms, one of which was freedom from want. I guess you could say there was a bit of difference between Democrats and Republicans back then, though there were the Jim Crow Dixiecrats who preferred to keep the Old Plantation going. But that was a long time ago.

There wasn’t enough steam to do what the British, broke as they were, did after World War II, namely to create a national health insurance system and other civilized amenities. Lyndon Johnson’s War on Poverty was the last gasp of postwar liberalism, and, what do you know, it actually did cut poverty rates in half — for a while.

But free market capitalism couldn’t tolerate that, and so we have inched back up toward Shantytown and will soon be able to congratulate ourselves on returning to a pre-1960s, not to say a pre-1930s standard of living.

Liberalism may always be a mirage, the debt that vice pays to virtue when things get tough. Certainly it had disappeared by the 1970s, when Gore Vidal — no radical, but another certified patrician — remarked that there was only a single party in American politics with two slightly differentiated wings, the Property Party.

When the so-called New Democrats decided to reinvent themselves as Me-Too Republicans in the 1980s, the process was complete. For auld lang syne, Teddy Kennedy was permitted to hang around as the token liberal, and to pass the torch to Obama at the 2008 convention. That was a hoot.

What I like about Republicans is that they proudly strut themselves as the party of evil, which they can afford to do as they service the reigning ideology. What I like about Democrats is … well, I’m stumped there. They’re the distinction without a difference, like TV broadcasters.

They’ve got a message, certainly, which is “elect me.” They just can’t give you a reason why. Maybe it has something to do with not having a heart.

Robert Zaller is a professor of history at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post Barack Obama: The Tin Man President appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Barack Obama: The Tin Man President

Letter to the Editor | Professors shouldn’t settle

Dear Editor:

Justin Roczniak’s “The Hazards of Curtis 231” (The Triangle, Feb. 20) speaks not only for the students who have to endure substandard and even squalid classrooms at Drexel, but for a silent faculty too. Too often, I have had to teach my classes in rooms that, particularly in Randell and Curtis, insult the purpose of education. We can’t, it seems, have too many places on campus to eat, bank or shop — that is, to part with more of our money — but when it comes to the business of education, well, students have already plunked down their cash and can’t have it back, so why bother to accommodate them?

Of course, students can vote with their feet, and do, which leads administrators to organize more committees to study the problem of retention. If they ever — God forbid, I suppose — stepped into one of dreary, unventilated, underfurnished rooms with the sardine seating students must put up with, a light might just go on. But then there would be one committee less to justify the fancy suites administrators give themselves, and how would that go down?

The problem, as Roczniak notes, is not confined to Randell and Curtis, but extends across the campus. Students, needless to say, deserve better — they deserve, in fact, the best. As for the faculty who tolerate such conditions, though, they are probably getting exactly what they do deserve.

Sincerely,

Robert Zaller
Department of History and Politics

The post Letter to the Editor | Professors shouldn’t settle appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Letter to the Editor | Professors shouldn’t settle

Architecture or ‘starchitecture’? Morality in construction

The talk at Drexel University this week by the distinguished architecture critic and historian Witold Rybczynski left me with a question I didn’t get a chance to ask, so I’ll pose it here: Are there some buildings that should not be built?

Rybczynski’s talk didn’t focus on that question but raised it indirectly. His subject was the phenomenon of the “starchitect,” a coinage denoting an architect whose services are much in demand because he has established a commercially successfully brand.

This is a relatively new phenomenon, a part of our pervasive celebrity culture. Just as museums and collectors feel themselves lacking if they don’t have their own Pablo Picasso or Paul Cezanne (whatever the quality of the work), so cities and corporations now want their own Frank Gehry, good or bad.

This is bad for the starchitect, Rybczynski suggests, because it puts pressure on him to produce not original work but knockoffs of the brand his patrons have come to expect. This is bad for the cities that get them, because not only do they tend to be second-rate but they also are typically ill-suited to the environments they’re plunked down in.

It isn’t exactly Levittown, but you get the idea. Each true city has its own distinctive character and history, and a building that doesn’t respect or even consider that character does it a disservice.

These points seemed to me well-taken. The implication was that cities are ill-served by one-size-fits-all brands that don’t really fit in anywhere, but simply represent the creeping homogenization of globalism. Cities would be better served, Rybczynski suggested, by using local architects who knew the place where they worked.

Fair enough. But the starchitect system does have one advantage: it tips the ordinary balance of power. Normally, the architect serves his patron. The patron decides what kind of building he wants built, where and for how much money. The architect, in short, works within the terms of his commission, and if the patron is unsatisfied, the building doesn’t get built.

Even great architects have this rather humiliating experience. With the starchitect, though, the point is to get his name on an actual edifice. He also costs more money to begin with, another incentive to get the job done even if the patron is unhappy with the result. You build the building because you’ve bought the brand.

Ordinary architects can only dream of a situation in which their instincts and wishes prevail over those of their patrons. They work in a world in which mediocrity and even philistinism are the norm. I don’t think I’m letting any trade secrets out to say that the vast majority of modern buildings are of stunning uniformity
and banality.

This doesn’t necessarily mean that architects today are less talented. Let’s say simply that Filippo Brunelleschi and Gian Lorenzo Bernini were more fortunate in their patrons, and that architecture in their times sometimes had nobler objectives than commerce.

We can sum up the point by saying that the world would be a better place if some of the buildings that get built today — perhaps a great many of them — weren’t put up. But that is an aesthetic objection.

The question I wanted to put to Rybczynski was different: Are there some buildings that shouldn’t be built not because they are ugly or ill-situated, but because their purpose is immoral?

I think the answer to that question has to be yes, if architecture is to be considered an art and a profession and not simply a complicated artisanal trade. A fairly obvious example comes to mind: Adolf Hitler had big architectural plans, and he gave his favored architect Albert Speer a lot
of commissions.

I’d say that was work Speer shouldn’t have taken, although perhaps at a certain point he didn’t have much choice.

Some examples are less obvious. Should an atheist build a church? I’m sure it’s happened. Should anyone build a corporate headquarters for, say, Walmart or Comcast? That, too, has happened, and in the latter case a new Comcast tower is going up on Philadelphia’s much-abused skyline. Of course, architects must eat like the rest of us. And if you’re a picky eater, you’re apt to go hungry.

I don’t know how Rybczynski would have answered my question. But he did allude, somewhat delicately, to a building that has been built and that, in my view, never should have been. I refer to the new location of the Barnes Foundation.

How’s that, you say? Okay, maybe not build a concentration camp or a new Tower of Babel for Comcast, but a museum? What could be more inoffensive than that?

Glad you asked. Hitler also wanted to build museums. There was to have been a Jewish museum — not to open, of course, until the last Jew had been exterminated — to show future generations of goose-steppers what a blight on mankind the Fuhrer had removed.

But Hitler also wanted to build new museums to house all the art he’d looted from subject countries and liberated from non-Aryan owners. Should those museums have been built? Should any architect have accepted such a commission?

The point is germane, because the new location for the Barnes Foundation was built for just the same purpose: to harbor stolen goods; precisely, the $30 billion in art removed from the Barnes Foundation in Merion in 2012 in the biggest theft of art since World War II.

True, the art was moved by those legally responsible for it, and moved not from Rome or Paris to Berlin but five miles across a county line to downtown Philadelphia (although one might want to ask why hundreds of millions of dollars, much of it footed by taxpayers, needed to spent for a five-mile trek in the first place).

But a theft it was, and recognized as such by prominent artists and critics, civil rights and community activists, a former head of the National Endowment of the Arts, and protesters from around the world. The controversy surrounding the Barnes was certainly known to the architects who bid on the new museum, and to the team of Tod Williams and Billie Tsien whose design was selected. Williams and Tsien made various appearances around Philadelphia, but they confined themselves to technical discussions and presentations.

Here was what the new building would look like, they said; here were the elements and materials that would go into it. Why and whether it should be built at all did not concern them or perhaps even interest them. The requisite clearances were in place; the money had been raised; their fee was being paid. Was all the other fussing any of their business?

I’d say it was, and very much so. The Barnes Foundation was located in a building designed by one of Philadelphia’s most prominent architects, Paul Philippe Cret. Rybczynski paid particular attention to it in his lecture, pointing to the idiosyncratic features Albert Barnes himself had added to the building as a means of accentuating its cultural significance.

It sat, and does sit, on a 12-acre lot purchased by Barnes and planted with an exquisite garden and arboretum containing rare species from around the globe. The art classes taught in the building, with the collection itself as the tutorial material, were complemented by the horticultural program based on the external grounds.

The integrated whole was an enterprise of deep and noble ambition — the most important cultural project undertaken in America in the first half of the 20th century, as the critic Christopher L. Knight noted — and the building with its environs an inseparable aesthetic whole.

To remove the art collection from this setting was to eviscerate one of the most remarkable sites in the world. And there is nothing sadder in the world today — the world of art at least — than the sight of Cret’s empty building.

Williams and Tsien chose to ignore this. They went for the bucks. They were willing parties and facilitators in the destruction of a great public trust. They failed the first moral requirement of their profession: to respect the cultural tradition handed down to them. Rather, they showed no awareness that such a tradition even existed.

What goes around comes around. The America Folk Art Museum — a problem-plagued building designed by Williams and Tsien opposite New York’s Museum of Modern Art — stood in the way of the museum’s expansion plans. Down it went, despite much hand wringing
by preservationists.

A payback from the gods? No, more like an example of the crass, commercially driven hubris that cynically undermined the Barnes, and for which the plainest name is barbarism. And, after all, Williams and Tsien got paid for that building too, didn’t they?

To answer my own question: Yes, architecture is a moral profession, and must be moral to be a profession. The deep meretriciousness and falsity of the Barnes Foundation shows what results when it is practiced otherwise.

Robert Zaller is a history professor at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.

The post Architecture or ‘starchitecture’? Morality in construction appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Architecture or ‘starchitecture’? Morality in construction

The Bush monarchy continues

There aren’t many things I agree with Antonin Scalia about, and even fewer with Clarence Thomas. But the Supreme Court justices’ refusal to attend the annual State of the Union Address on the grounds that it is an exercise in puerile nonsense is a point well taken. This year’s event was a case in point.

A yearly report on the state of the nation is one of the few constitutionally prescribed duties of the president. He need not deliver it in-person; it may simply be a communication to the Congress, delivered as convenient.

These days, an email (presidentially embossed, I suppose, since we no longer use wax signets) would suffice. The ritual of an address to a joint session of the two houses is a 20th century practice. It does have the merit of bringing the two houses together, which in our world of gridlocked politics may sometimes be the only way to do it.

Photo Courtesy Pete Souza/Wikipedia

Photo Courtesy Pete Souza/Wikipedia

On the other hand, for those of us who, whether out of habit or fascination (the fascination of the abomination, of course) do tune in, there is the moral health hazard of watching one of the most unsavory institutions on earth on display.

A few years ago, I wrote an essay called “Representative Government: How Sure a Thing?” as an afterword for a scholarly volume on legislative bodies in Early Modern Europe. In it I noted how parliamentary sovereignty, having taken root in 17th-century England, had gradually spread through much of the continent and to the New World.

The Founding Fathers, although they wanted a reasonably strong executive, had placed primary authority in Congress: the power to vote taxes, make laws and declare wars.

The most astute early commentator on the early republic, Alexis de Tocqueville, certainly considered Congress the chief seat of government. He expressed skepticism as to whether the presidency could ever become a truly coordinate branch.

Well, times do change. We now refer to the imperial presidency, which is a term of opprobrium, suggesting the need for constraint when it was first adopted in the 1970s, but now merely a normative description. I might add that the modern executive is preeminent now in virtually all countries.

But it is in the United States that the acts of the executive are the most consequential, and so the American presidency is rightly an object of fascination, and sometimes of horror, around the world.

The State of the Union is now a presidential performance, nothing more or less. The assembled dignitaries — legislative, judicial, military — listen quietly, and applaud (or not) on cue.

It is a symbolic moment of deference to authority, and the opposition party, if it chafes at what it hears, can make no response but silence. Woe to those who jeer. The Prez has the microphone.

We learn, certainly, nothing about the Union in what is said. Its state is always sound. If any problems are acknowledged, they are always described as “challenges” which a resolute president (and a compliant Congress) will surely meet.

A climate crisis veering beyond human control? An inegalitarian society in which the few prosper — obscenely, unaccountably, untaxably — at the expense of the many? Wars which morph endlessly into more wars, draining blood and treasure while roads and bridges crumble and public education fades from sight? Mere challenges.

Racism? Don’t even mention it. Our first black president didn’t.

The president, having achieved the significant feat of turning a comfortable Democratic majority in both houses of Congress into a substantial Republican one in four years, looked relaxed and confident.

Well, might he take pride in his accomplishment? When he rode a wave of revulsion at the Bush administration into a historic victory in 2008, even Republicans were predicting a generation in the wilderness for their discredited brand.

It was no small feat to have brought them back so completely in a quarter of the time. President Barack Obama can take justified pride in this accomplishment. It is his alone.

Certainly, Obama entered the House chamber looking like a man who had completed his historic task. As commentators have noted, his demeanor since the crushing Democratic defeat in November — an election in which the President was almost wholly sidelined by “his” party, whose candidates feared his presence by their side as they would the plague — has been almost that of a man reborn: “liberated” is the term most often employed.

But, liberated from what? Obama no longer has the slightest hope of passing what, year after year, he has set forth before Congress as his agenda: a feeble supplement to his originally feeble economic stimulus; some form of gun control (he never did specify what); a token swipe at this country’s $2 trillion infrastructure repair and replacement bill.

The Republicans will pass immigration reform when and if they get around to it and on their own terms. They will cut away at Obamacare, not that they really oppose (it is a bonanza for the profit-driven medical industry) but simply because Democrats passed it; keep trying to gut Roe v. Wade; and make the world safe for polluters.

In short, they are behaving as if they control the White House as well as the legislature, and the fact is that they have, except briefly, controlled both since the second year of the Bill Clinton presidency, when Newt Gingrich swept the Republicans to power in Congress.

The president has said that he will have his veto pen at the ready to protect the body politic from the GOP stampede. But this is political theater. What Obama has been “liberated” from is the pretense of being a Democratic president, insofar as such an animal exists.

Oh, he’ll sound like one: soak the rich, save the environment, make education affordable — you know, all those utopian, crackpot ideas that other nations have taken for granted for decades. But he won’t even have to pretend an interest in bringing any of them to pass; even in the pathetically wan, adulterated form he offers them, they’re dead on arrival in Congress.

And a Republican Congress isn’t his fault, because, as he reminded us, he won his own elections, and what more can anyone expect?

The truth is that Obama has succeeded at the real agenda that he had from the outset: recapitalizing Wall Street and protecting its oligarchic control of the economy, extending the surveillance state and expanding the George W. Bush legacy from the boardroom to the bedroom, slow or no-walking environmental reform while doubling down on fossil fuel extraction, driving full steam ahead to impose the universally despised Common Core standards on public education, already in its death throes, etc., etc.

People are wondering whether we’re in for a revival of the Bush dynasty or the Clinton one in 2016. But the Bushes never really left office. Bill Clinton’s presidency was the second and third term of George H. W. Bush, so much so that the nominal Republican candidate in 1996, Bob Dole, had stolen the party platform out from under him.

Obama has been the third and fourth terms of George W. Bush. That’s more than a quarter century not only of one-party but one-family rule. I believe the correct term for this is monarchy.

Like Dole, John McCain and Mitt Romney were blinds for the Bush dynasty. Democrats need to be the official winners now and then to preserve the illusion of two-party governance, although when it’s actually the turn of a Bush to sit in the White House, elections can’t be allowed to stand in the way.

The Supreme Court demonstrated this in 2000 by appointing George W. President after his defeat at the polls.

If there’s any system this resembles, it’s that of Russia. Vladimir Putin has to cede the presidency every eight years by law, so he switches chairs then with his puppet prime minister, Dmitry Medvedev. Everyone knows it’s still Putin who’s in charge.

The Bush clan is a family enterprise, so the members and the generations rotate. Like the Habsburgs, their mediocrity is fabled, but they’ve learned the art of survival.

Obama, the latest family retainer, has carried water faithfully. In retirement, he’ll make a bundle, just as Clinton has done.

And if Hillary Clinton should win the 2016 election, well, small difference. There’s no warmer friendship in politics than the one Bill struck up with George H. W. You might say they’re as thick as thieves.

In fact, that’s just what you should say.

Robert Zaller is a history professor at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post The Bush monarchy continues appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Bush monarchy continues

War in Afghanistan reaches its end, or has it?

Officially, the war in Afghanistan that began on Oct. 7, 2001 has ended. In a secret ceremony last month — secret because of fear of attack — the United States struck the colors and headed home. Well, not quite.

A “residual” force of 18,000 soldiers, nearly 11,000 of them Americans, will remain indefinitely as part of something called Operation Resolute Support. (Who are the guys who dream up these names for our
killing games?)

Translation: Afghanistan, like Japan, Korea, et al., will remain part of the permanent American Occupation Zone, stakeout points in the permanent American war. Who’s the war against? Doesn’t really matter. We’ll always find an enemy when we need one — or invent one, as the case may be.

Photo Courtesy Wikipedia

Photo Courtesy Wikipedia

The lesson we learned in Iraq was that when you engage in a protracted exercise in nation-wrecking (to borrow Robert Kohler’s phrase), you can’t pull out without expecting chaos in the rubble. It’s not that we actually did care at any point what happened to the general population; our goal in Iraq, as that fiery radical Alan Greenspan pointed out long ago, was to secure our private gas pump.

As it turned out, we didn’t really need it, because we’ve discovered since that we can squeeze more oil out at home by blasting the planetary bedrock. But chaos, especially chaos in which so-called terrorists thrive, is bad for the Pentagon’s image, not to mention the commander in chief’s.

The moral is, if you’re going to lose a war, don’t leave it. So, we’re back in Iraq as if we never left. And we have no intention of quitting Afghanistan. Ever.

We will someday, no doubt, because if you lose a war that means that somebody else has won it. In the case of Afghanistan, it’s the Taliban. Once we drove them out of Kabul — or, rather, once our hired mercenaries in the Northern Alliance did (against our instruction) — they were able to disperse into the countryside where, in classic Maoist fashion, they gained a grip on the outlying provinces they’d never had when they were officially in power, and slowly began to tighten the noose around the capital.

This is familiar experience for us. It happened in Vietnam, the prototype of our modern wars of empire, where we indulged the fond illusion that prancing around in Saigon, at least by daylight, was the same as controlling the country.

No one is in the slightest doubt that, were all foreign troops withdrawn from Afghanistan, the Taliban would be running the country again the next day, as they unofficially are already. That is my definition of a lost war.

Years ago, the British, who have more experience of colonial defeat than we do so far, were advising us that the best option available was to strike a deal with the Taliban that would allow us room for a face-saving withdrawal. That didn’t happen; the Taliban had no reason to take the bait, and bided their time.

So, with our “mission” in Afghanistan (Pentagon-speak for invasion) supposedly accomplished, it seems a good time to ask the question of why we attacked the country in the first place.

The short answer would be 9/11. Al-Qaida forces (remember them?) trained in Afghanistan as guests of the Taliban, invited or not. A hitherto-shadowy figure named Osama bin Laden, formerly on the CIA’s payroll and resident in Afghanistan, claimed credit for the attack on the World Trade Center, and sneered at us in videos. This was the “casus belli.”

That the actual plot against us was operationally planned in Hamburg, Germany, funded substantially through Saudi Arabia, and carried out primarily by Saudi nationals (Osama himself being a Saudi prince) did not suggest that our real enemies were elsewhere, or was not permitted to.

Saudi Arabia was supposedly our chief Arab ally, and the fount of much of our oil. It was also the principal source of personal wealth for the family of George W. Bush, whose first reaction to the 9/11 attacks, after scrambling into a bunker, was to permit the Saudi diplomatic entourage to fly home by private plane from Washington on the day, Sept. 12, when all other nonmilitary air traffic in the United States was grounded.

We knew, in short, who our real attackers were, and we deliberately shielded them. Any wonder that the events of 9/11 have attracted conspiracy theories like bees to a flower ever since?

Like everyone else, I was stunned in the aftermath of 9/11, even as I understood that what had happened was, in the broadest sense, blowback from our adventures in the Middle East over nearly a century. We’d been attacked, and we had to respond.

We were under attack, and no one could tell — our intelligence services having apparently failed us in the most spectacular manner possible — where the next blow might fall. Afghanistan was not the correct target, but it was a plausible one, especially with Osama bin Laden helpfully putting a public face on our anonymous assailants (more grist for conspiracy theorists).

Technically, we had an excuse for military action; politically, we needed to make someone pay for what had happened to us.

At first, Bush made a distinction between al-Qaida and the Taliban. He demanded that Osama bin Laden be surrendered, which was unlikely to have been in the Taliban’s power. When their leader, Mullah Omar, demurred, air strikes followed, and then ground invasion. America was at war.

It was a phony war from the beginning. We tried fighting it by proxy, with native Afghan rebels. Until Barack Obama took office, we had little more than 30,000 troops on the ground, plus a smaller NATO contingent. This was laughably insufficient to control the country.

Even supporting this force was scanted, as Bush secretly (and illegally) diverted appropriations for Afghanistan to prepare the attack on Iraq that had been planned from his first day in power, and which was duly executed on March 19, 2003.

By that time, Afghanistan was an afterthought. It has remained so ever since — a war we pretended to fight against an adversary we no more than
symbolically pursued.

In other words, 9/11 remained, and remains to this day, unavenged.

Whether we could or should have sought to avenge it, or instead have taken the opportunity to reflect on the imperial hubris that had brought the carnage we had so lightly inflicted on others to our own shores, is another matter.

What is clear is that Afghanistan was never more than a sideshow, at least until Barack Obama decided to make a statement about it. This, over the past six years, has doubled the number of fatalities in the war without altering its result. The war was lost in 2008.

It was lost from day one, because it was never anything more than a politically expedient placeholder for the real war planned against Iraq. It is lost today, and it will be tomorrow.

John F. Kerry, in his days as a Vietnam War protester, posed a question: How do you ask a soldier to be the last man to die for a mistake? Vietnam was a lot more than a mistake, more even than a criminal folly.

Afghanistan has been the same, and, if anything, more cynically entered and fecklessly prosecuted. But we won’t be asking that sacrifice from the last soldier, not anytime soon. A war without end promises only death without end.


Robert Zaller is a history professor at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

The post War in Afghanistan reaches its end, or has it? appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on War in Afghanistan reaches its end, or has it?

How the rich benefit in a recession

Paul Krugman has a Nobel Prize in economics. I don’t. He writes for a wide audience in The New York Times. I write for a more select one in The Triangle. But I think I have something to tell Professor Krugman, because it seems to me that he is struggling to understand what should be quite obvious.

In a recent article, “Rock bottom economics,” Krugman confessed to a great puzzlement. The means to stimulate the economy, which continues to “perform” (to use a term economists have apparently borrowed from either the circus ring or a sex manual) at the so-called pre-recession level, are readily at hand.

The Federal Government needs to inject more money into the economy, since it alone can supply both capital and demand. The Federal Reserve Bank needs to raise interest rates, which at the 0.25 percent they have sat at for six years constitutes a liquidity trap, in sync with this. Hey presto: Happy days will be here again.

Krugman doesn’t understand why this hasn’t happened. Virtually all economists, he assures us, agree with his prescription; it is not only orthodox doctrine but it’s real-world tested. It works. It got us out of the Great Depression, and over assorted other bumps since. So, what’s the hang-up?

Krugman thinks economic policymakers and others whom he calls “Very Serious People” have been overly preoccupied with the fear of sparking inflation and reigniting the public debt. As he points out, though, inflation is a manageable concomitant of growth, and deflation — which Europe’s economy as a whole now teeters on — is much worse.

Even if America’s economy skirts that trap, approaching it, like dancing on the edge of a black hole, throttles any hope of a robust recovery. Jobs at best limp back; wages stagnate or decline. And both remain perilously vulnerable.

The point Krugman misses, however, is that the “Very Serious People” aren’t blinkered by their devotion to the memory of Herbert Hoover. They know exactly what they are doing, and why, and for whom. For Krugman, jobs are the number one priority in a recovery, because jobs create demand and demand fuels prosperity.

But a broad-based recovery is not, in fact, to everyone’s maximum advantage. Depression economics can be very, very good for some people, provided it’s rigged the right way. Those people are the rich.

Consider what happens under conditions of full-employment prosperity. Wages rise, because labor is at a premium. So do demands for job benefits and security. Profits rise, too, but they are cramped by inelastic labor costs. One solution for this is outsourcing, which is greatly facilitated by globalization.

Imperialism pioneered this practice; multinational corporations, the successors of empires have perfected it. Another solution, however, is to lower domestic labor costs by making jobs scarce. The way to do this is through what are now called recessions.

These are sometimes planned, as was the 1969 Nixon recession (whose goal was as much political as economic). Most often, they are the consequence of bubbles, as was the case in the crash of 2008.

Mild and short-term recessions don’t amount to much more than a haircut for labor, however painful they may be for those affected by them. To bring wages down for a satisfactory period if not indeed for good, you need something deep and sustained, a full-blown depression.

The United States entered such a depression six years ago. It has been deliberately prolonged with the objective of reducing compensation levels across the board in the manufacturing and service sectors. At the same time, productivity demands have been ratcheted up, most obviously in an ever-lengthening workweek, while job security has virtually disappeared except as a temporary bargaining chip to reduce wages and cut benefits even further.

Pensions, in particular, whose benefits once seemed secure, have been scuttled by strategic private sector bankruptcies, in which states and municipalities have now joined.

None of this could be achieved without a good long bout of hard times, and that is exactly what those at the controls of the American economy have given us. The result was graphically suggested by the recent story in Krugman’s own New York Times of a 49-year-old manufacturing worker who had been earning $18.50 an hour.

That seems like a fairly decent wage, until you reflect that a fast-food worker in Copenhagen earns $20 an hour — the minimum wage in Denmark, and what would be the minimum wage in the U.S. had wages kept pace with labor productivity in the last four decades.

Our worker lost his job, and with it the modest standard of living it had supported. Many such people, if they could get work at all in the past few years, have taken service jobs paying half what manufacturing employment once did.

But, as you may have heard, factory jobs, after decades of disastrous decline, have made a slight comeback of late. Our worker was able to get the equivalent of his old job back — except that it now paid $10.50 an hour. Instead of slinging hash, it’s ingots again for him. The problem is, the wages are still hash.

Depressions have other notable benefits, provided that interest rates are kept low enough for favored customers. Property can be bought for a song, as housing and real estate values plummet. This is called recapitalization. Monopolies form as merger rules are relaxed. Banks and businesses borrow at virtually zero rates from the friendly Fed, while charging premium rates to others and living off the spread without having to add a smidgen of value.

All of this, we’re told, staves off the dragon of inflation. Indeed it does, while facilitating an ever greater transfer of wealth from have-nots to haves. That is why the degree of economic inequality — and, as Colonel Jessep would say, is there any other kind? — has grown steadily during the Obama years.

The rich are making more, lots and lots more; corporate and financial profits are at record highs; international markets are again awash in excess capital. And almost everyone else is making less.

Paul Krugman can’t figure out why hireling bureaucrats and think tank operatives would want to succor the rich at the expense of the rest of us. Learned ignorance can be a contagious thing. And, though Krugman is, I have no doubt, a man of high and serious purpose, he’s probably making out pretty well himself.

Robert Zaller is a history professor at Drexel University. He can be contacted at op-ed@thetriangle.org.

 

The post How the rich benefit in a recession appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on How the rich benefit in a recession