Author Archives | Robert Zaller

Hillary Clinton’s slip of tongue conveys truth

Flickr: William Murphy

Flickr: William Murphy

Donald Trump was asked a hypothetical question recently. He gave a candid answer, as is his wont, for if there is one thing that can be said about Mr. Trump it is that he does not overthink his answers, if he thinks them at all. The question was whether, in the event that abortion lost its current constitutional protection and became illegal again, women receiving abortions as well as physicians giving them should be subject to punishment. Trump’s response was that he would expect both parties to be sanctioned.

This provoked an immediate uproar, not only from pro-choice groups as one might expect, but from pro-life ones as well. Trump beat a hasty retreat: he had touched the third rail of American politics, and gotten well burnt. The politically correct answer to have given was that, assuming Roe v. Wade to be overturned, it would be up to the wisdom of individual state legislatures to grapple with the question of which laws to write within the compass of the Supreme Court’s new writ. That would have been a non-answer, but of course that is exactly what the best political answers are. Instead, Trump gave not a correct but a reasonable reply, which was that persons violating the law are normally subject to the penalties that accompany them.

If one remains strictly on the plane of reason, it is hard to see this reply as objectionable. Laws are not laws if there is no penalty for breaking them; otherwise, they are mere suggestions or advisements. In a medical abortion there are two responsible agents, the woman requesting it and the doctor performing it, and if such abortions are declared illegal then, subject to whatever extenuations there may be, it is not evident why both parties should not be liable to whatever prosecution the law provides.

For pro-choice advocates, such laws would necessarily be unjust, and the penalties that came with them would likewise be so. What surprised me, however, was that pro-life groups were as vociferous in denouncing Trump as pro-choice ones were. Surely, if the taking of an unborn life were a heinous crime, then a woman requesting or consenting to it would be guilty of a very grave act. One might, according to circumstances, wish to counsel or educate such a woman rather than punish her, but to say that no woman should ever be punished for it, no matter how deliberate her conduct or how often she repeated it, would be to say that women should not be held accountable as responsible legal agents, and in that sense were not educable at all. Such a conclusion would put our attitudes toward women back a good two hundred years and more. It would entail a view of them as perpetual children needing constant male supervision and control.

Pro-choice advocates don’t get off the hook so easily either, though. If the pro-life view of women seeking abortions seems to be, at best, as victims of circumstance needing guidance and support, pro-choicers depict such women as bravely electing to arrange their own lives and assert their autonomy. But abortion on demand means that any reason for an abortion is as good as any other, and that it is therefore an act without moral implications as such. One woman may regard her abortion as an affirmation of personal freedom. Another may simply not wish to ruin her time-share vacation in Cuernavaca. But neither choice, objectively, is more significant than the other. This is why, when pushed to the wall, pro-choice advocates prefer to describe those who seek abortions as needy or desperate in some way—very much, indeed, as pro-life groups do. In both cases, the logic of their positions drive them to infantilize women. Those who support ‘life’ are reluctant to acknowledge that some women who seek abortions are perfectly knowledgeable about them. Those who support ‘choice’ are equally reluctant to concede that some women seek them purely as a matter of convenience. The preferred models, therefore, are either Little Nell or Joan of Arc. There isn’t much room for actual women between them.

No sooner had the Trump furor died down when Hillary Clinton, fearless champion of choice, found herself equally under attack. Clinton’s sin was to refer to the developed product of a fertilized egg as an “unborn person.” Team Clinton immediately claimed that the candidate had misspoken, but, in fact, Hillary was reaching for a term that, in the world of choice, does not exist. We refer to the stages of pre-natal growth as those of a zygote, an embryo, and a fetus. A fetus is generally described as a developing organism from its third month to its ninth, but it seems awkward to many if not most people to apply the same term to a tiny, featureless creature and to one fully formed and prepared for birth.

The problem is far simpler for a woman who wants to give birth. She doesn’t think of what she’s carrying as a fetus, unless perhaps she’s a medical professional. She thinks of it as her “baby” or her “child,” precisely the terms she will apply to it after its birth. She is in no doubt that it is a person, and fantasizes or attempts communication with it. When it moves in the womb, she may regard its activity as intentional and purposive. A woman who decides against birth, however, especially if she has done so only some weeks or months after discovering conception, must sharply revise her vocabulary. Few women are willing to ask to have a baby or a child removed from them. The term ’fetus’ doesn’t fit the case any better. The typical reference would be to an ‘unwanted pregnancy,’ or, more discreetly, a ‘problem.’ The trick is to convert a concrete thing, a developing life, into an awkward or unwanted situation. A situation is something that can be remedied, and a remedy is a good, a positive thing. The remedy in the case of an abortion is an intervention or ‘termination.’ One terminates a mortgage, a vacation, a game of cards. One terminates a pregnancy. The idea that one is extinguishing something, let alone killing it, becomes, literally, unthinkable. And, as Hamlet says, there is nothing but thinking makes it so.

This brings us back to Clinton’s faux pas. Hillary wasn’t pregnant, but merely trying to describe the situation of someone who was. She found herself in need of the word to describe the subject of that situation. The subject was unborn, yes, but an unborn what? Child, baby, fetus wouldn’t do; “life” was perhaps better, but that would beg the question of what kind of life it was. And, of course, the only kind of life a woman can carry is a human one. Hillary was not going to say, “unborn human.” So, still looking for the most neutral, noncommittal term, she reached and tripped over “person.”

Ouch. If a “human” is not something you kill, especially in the womb, then a person is no better, because ‘person’ is a term applied only to humans, and it suggests moreover not only biological but ontological status. The Catholic Church (and other religions) speak of the person not only as a being with human form and capacity, but as one with a soul. And a soul is that which is inseparably connected to a person, a thing than can belong to nothing else and has a value both absolute and independent of any and all circumstance—in short, of any situation. To separate a soul from its body, especially an innocent, dependent body, sounds like a pretty terrible thing to do. And that, Hillary assured the pro-choice community, was absolutely not what she meant to say.

To be sure, the term ‘person’ does not necessarily imply commitment to the concept of a soul (though I doubt Hillary would want to wrangle with that problem, either). It does, however, suggest in secular usage a being endowed with rights, and the idea that an unborn, uh, offspring (a term favored by some medical dictionaries) possesses rights is precisely the trap that pro-choice advocates are most anxious to avoid. Which is why they jumped all over Hillary.

Hillary, of course, backtracked at once, just as Trump had. That solved her political problem. It did not solve the problem that advocates of choice have, however, and which they persistently fail to confront. One woman’s unborn child—perhaps the dearest, most precious thing in the world to her—is another’s unwanted pregnancy, and the same woman can come to hold both views. I have heard the subject of an unwanted pregnancy described as a thing, a blob, or even a cancer. Can it be that in a given case, though, a being previously described as a baby, a child, or a person can become a clump of unwanted tissue simply as a matter of choice? Is the fetus something on which we can confer or withdraw rights simply at pleasure? We have, and approve laws that make the killing of a pregnant woman a double homicide. If a woman is killed on her way to an abortion, though, by what standard do we say that two “persons” have died? If we confer on the dead fetus the condition of someone who had a right to life, on what basis do we overrule its mother’s decision that it was a merely a growth that had no such right and could be excised at will?

I have no simple answer to these questions, and I find the idea of compelling a woman to carry a child to term against her will repugnant. But I would like to know, from those who favor choice, on what basis they would ground human personhood, and with it any system of morality that is not subjective and arbitrary. It seems to me a question that has been ducked for too long.

  

The post Hillary Clinton’s slip of tongue conveys truth appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Hillary Clinton’s slip of tongue conveys truth

Taking Trump seriously

Wikipedia: Gage Skidmore

Wikipedia: Gage Skidmore

Let’s get the disclaimer out of the way first: Donald Trump is an egomaniacal demagogue who knows little and cares less about law, diplomacy, or any of the other fine arts of statecraft. Electing him president would be like shooting the rapids with a junkie at the helm. Whether Ted Cruz would make an even worse president is a judgment I leave to the discriminating sensibilities of Republican primary voters who have whittled down a field of 17 to, respectively, the most irresponsible candidate their party has ever produced, and the most viscerally hated one.

That said, it must also be noted that a successful demagogue is, by definition, someone with his finger on the pulse of, and at least a substantial part of, the public. In fact, any demagogue who isn’t successful is soon dismissed as a crank or a fool. The cameras turn away toward the next entertainment, and that story is done. Say what you will, though, The Donald is neither a crank nor a fool. Even if his campaign were to implode tomorrow, he has had one of the most wildly successful rides in American political history for nearly a year.

Pundits who try to explain Trump’s appeal generally do so by putting down his supporters as bigoted, know-nothing losers who like to carry guns into churches and who are, worst of all, middle-aged white males. Sorry, but that isn’t enough to explain the success of someone who has won 21 of 34 primary contests to date, and has been the runner-up where he hasn’t won. So, maybe we should listen to what the man is saying. Maybe it’s time to take Donald Trump seriously, and examine his view of America in the world.

One of the first bricks The Donald dropped was to express his admiration for Vladimir Putin. Since the American political establishment has spent the last decade and a half demonizing Putin, this was a Category A political heresy. Barack Obama promised to push the reset button with Russia when he came into office, but our relations with Moscow are worse than ever, and our intelligence agencies rate the Russians as our chief security “threat.” Trump obviously doesn’t see things that way. Casually expressing regard for Putin isn’t a policy view. But then the other brick dropped: Trump questioned the necessity for maintaining NATO, our chief defense bulwark in the world and our most explicit safeguard against Russian expansion.

It’s a funny thing, but I had the same thought myself twenty-odd years ago, when the Cold War supposedly ended. The Soviet Union had imploded, leaving the Russia that remained shorn of a third of its former territory and nearly half its population. That remnant endured its worst decade since World War II as it made the wrenching transition from gangster socialism to gangster capitalism, and was virtually prostrate on the world stage. Why, I wondered, did we need to maintain a formal military alliance against a country that posed no threat to anyone but itself?

The answer was not long in coming. Using NATO and the European Union as our tools, we rushed in to claim Eastern Europe as the spoils of our Cold War victory, erecting a new cordon sanitaire around the borders of Russia itself to deny it any possibility of reasserting its influence, and reducing it permanently, in Obama’s candid phrase, from a world power to a “regional” one: a sort of bloated Poland. At the same time, we ginned up NATO itself as an arm of our own expansionist interests in the Middle East and North Africa.

And how, exactly, has all that worked out? In Europe itself, the legacy of NATO-EU aggrandizement is, to date, a pair of bloody civil wars in the former Yugoslavia and Ukraine respectively, the latter still in progress. In the Middle East and North Africa, the toll is, to date, a trail of failed states and raging wars from Afghanistan to Libya, plus the rise of the world’s first acknowledged terror state in the so-called ISIS Caliphate. As for the profit of these ventures, ask the citizens of London, Paris, and Brussels exactly what NATO’s exploits have brought them.

Until Donald Trump, no major party candidate in the U.S. had questioned the purpose and utility of NATO in a supposedly post-Cold War Age. No other candidate, either, has challenged the necessity not only of the 70,000 American troops on European soil, but the comparable military investment in Japan and South Korea—all dating, to this point, 60 years and more. Trump would like to know why the EU can’t pay for its own defense, and why equally wealthy Asian allies can’t either.

The implied answer would seem to be that, without America’s nuclear shield, the nations we “protect” would need nuclear arsenals of their own—Europe against Russia, Japan against China, and the South Koreans against North Korea. Trump sees no reason why South Korea and Japan should not acquire nukes if they really feel they need them. This flies in the face of 50 years of nonproliferation agreements, but whether the world would be less safe if South Korea and Japan had their own means of containing North Korea and, as need be, China, is an assumption rather than a fact. Certainly, that the present nuclear club can sustain its monopoly indefinitely is neither likely nor, frankly, defensible, and as matters stand nonproliferation is simply an excuse for a closed shop. (The EU, in any case, contains two nuclear powers already, and Japan is dickering with a nuclear-armed India for protection against China.)

What Trump seems to be calling for is a case-by-case examination of our so-called strategic alliances around the globe. He wants to know whether they are necessary to our security, and what we get in return. That is a fair question. He points out that we have spent a great deal of money for a very long time defending Japan and South Korea, in the process saving them a corresponding expenditure of their own. The result? Japan makes our cars and South Korea makes our steel, while our plants close and our industrial capacity has withered. Just how, to put it in Trumpese, is that a good deal for us?

As if this weren’t bad enough, both Republican and Democratic administrations have bought into the gospel of free trade, happily abetted by academic economists who know where their own bread is buttered. Notionally, free trade benefits everybody — if, by everybody, you mean multinational corporations exporting good jobs and leaving once-skilled American workers to sling hash. Trump’s supporters don’t need advanced degrees to figure this out; they see padlocked gates and foreclosed futures, and they get the point a lot quicker than their supposed betters. No wonder The Donald draws a crowd when he tells ‘em that Uncle Sucker has been had—and that Beltway politicians and lobbyists (an interchangeable species) have sold the American working class down the creek. It just happens to be the truth.

Of course, Bernie Sanders has been saying much the same thing about free trade (although not about our imperial entanglements). But it is Trump who has forced the academic apologists for NAFTA, the TPP, et al. into finally admitting that free trade has been a swindle for American workers —Trump, and the legions he has galvanized.

Trump’s line is that he will make America great again. He doesn’t say exactly what he means by this, because the slogan is vacuous. What he does mean is that he will put America’s relationships through the prism of self-interest, and will insist on getting at least equal value for whatever bargain he strikes. Whether that would turn into a means of dismantling our global empire or simply managing it more advantageously would be the question. Anything, though, that challenges the arrogant presupposition of America as the world’s divinely appointed savior, leading it by the hand or twisting it by the arm, is a thought worth entertaining.

Donald Trump is not a serious man, but the Trump phenomenon does deserve to be taken seriously. Maybe only a jokester could cut through the official cant that surrounds our moribund empire, and jolt us into examining its costs and consequences—for ourselves, and everyone else. Maybe only a businessman who lives off his bankruptcies could lift the lid on the systemic fraud of capitalism itself, and the destruction it casually wreaks on those whose labor it exploits and then discards. Are Trump’s followers angry? Maybe more of us should be. I look around at the devastation wrought in my own profession through corporatization, with once self-governing faculties reduced to at-will employees working harder and harder for less and less while tuition rates go through the roof for their students, and I wonder how long my colleagues will want to put up with it.

See you at the next Trump rally? No, I won’t be there. But maybe we should stop looking down our noses at those who will. As Paddy Chayevsky put it forty years ago, they’re mad as hell, and just maybe they won’t take it anymore.

      

      

The post Taking Trump seriously appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Taking Trump seriously

A society that poisons its young

Wikipedia: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Digital Visual Library

Wikipedia: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Digital Visual Library

When during the Great Depression Franklin D. Roosevelt described a third of the population of the United States as ill-fed, ill-clothed and ill-housed, he didn’t say how many had been that way before. It was a lot. As Henry George had observed in his classic study, Progress and Poverty (1879), progress not only went hand in hand with poverty in America, but generated it. This was poverty of a very special kind, too, since in addition to material deprivation it brought a new kind of experience: that of shame. It has been the case ever since that the poor in America are expected to feel, before even hunger or cold or homelessness, a diminished sense of personal worth and a heightened one of self-blame. Whether one bears any personal responsibility for one’s lot or not, being poor is the ultimate American crime.

Only during the Dustbowl Thirties, when the livelihoods of millions literally blew away before their eyes, was there any sense that poverty was not essentially the fault of the poor themselves. When Roosevelt invoked his famous one-third, he was thus suggesting that, perhaps, this number was higher than mere moral laxity would warrant. It took an economy that had come to a virtual standstill for such an idea to be credible, and for poverty to be seen as a problem for anyone but the poor.

World War II solved the Great Depression and created full employment, at least for a brief while. But poverty was still rife in the shadows, and it took the Civil Rights movement of the ’50s and ’60s — essentially a middle class African-American uprising — to help expose it. When Lyndon Johnson declared his War on Poverty in the 1960s, he made it at last a matter of national conscience. Unfortunately, this war coincided with the one against Vietnam, which destroyed the New Deal whose legacy Johnson had hoped to complete. We — or, I should say, the poor among us — have been paying the price of our great imperial misadventure ever since. The War on Poverty had decreased the percentage of Americans living in poverty by nearly half, at least by the government’s reckoning. From that point, beginning with the long recession of the 1970s and continuing into the Reagan Eighties, that number rose steadily again. It continued to rise, except briefly in the 1990s, under Republican and Democratic administrations alike, until the Great Crash of 2008 ushered in a new era of poverty. Unlike the Great Depression of the Thirties, however, banking and business elites did not share in the massive wealth destruction of the Crash, for they soon not only recovered but exceeded their former profitability.

How many Americans should be regarded as poor today? The federal government’s laughable measurements suggest that perhaps 15 percent of the total population, and 20 percent of children, should be regarded as living in poverty. But if you regard, as I do, anyone who lives from paycheck to paycheck (assuming the employment of at least one family member), or in such condition that an unexpected bill of, say, a thousand dollars can precipitate a financial crisis, then that number is much closer to half of all Americans. The relevant measure of poverty is thus not the constant or recurrent experience of hunger or homelessness, real as such facts are for tens of millions among us, but the chronic insecurity that leaves one without the resources to meet adversity or even ordinary bad luck. To be poor is, simply, to live suspended over an abyss.

This brings us to Flint. In our long national retreat from Franklin Roosevelt’s promise of a world free of want as the birthright of all Americans, we have poverty not only maintained but deliberately created as a result of policies that, having produced communities almost entirely dependent on single industries, facilitate their desertion of them in pursuit of cheaper labor and higher profits. This is not a phenomenon unique to America—one has only to think of the destruction of the British Midlands—but the United States is the only advanced Western nation without a jobs policy aimed at protecting citizen employment. And killing jobs makes poverty: it is the only perfect one-to-one equation in economics.

Once, Flint, Michigan was synonymous with General Motors, which employed 80,000 of its residents. GM began to bail out on Flint in the late 1970s, and by 1989 the city’s deliberate destruction had been chronicled in Roger and Me by its most famous native son, the filmmaker Michael Moore. Roger made Moore a national figure — and Flint the country’s poster child of urban decay. By the early 2000s, everyone who could afford to escape Flint had done so. That trapped a population of about 100,000 which, in a collapsed real estate market that the Great Crash would crater completely, could not sell out at a price that would enable it to move, or sell at any price at all. As in such cases generally, women and children were the most vulnerable, and the most apt to be left behind. They were left a prey to rising crime and drug rates, too, and finally, in a state of destitution and anarchy, of their ultimate predator, the State of Michigan and its Republican governor, Rick Snyder.

The story is now familiar, and not in Flint alone. The State took over a city government that, without resources, could no longer function, and subjected its helpless residents to a Darwinian experiment in cost-cutting. Part of this involved decoupling the city’s water supply from Detroit’s, and forcing it to use the local river, contaminated by decades of industrial pollution. Chemical treatment was supposed to make it potable; instead, it released lead from corroded pipes that, combined with other toxins, made for a witches’ brew that ran brown and stinking from household taps. Children exposed to it suffered irreversible brain and organ damage. Resident protests were ignored; evidence of catastrophic health effects was suppressed. Michigan had created its own Warsaw Ghetto, in which a captive population was wilfully subjected to mass poisoning—that is, to genocide. The story has concentrated on the water issue, but Flint’s destruction, as of the Rust Belt generally, has been a process of decades. Lead in the baby’s bathwater or from a mother’s nipple was only the coup de graçe.

Similar stories have begun to come out of other depressed communities such as Sebring, Ohio, but Flint stands for now as the prime case of a city deliberately and quite literally marked for death. Lyndon Johnson’s War on Poverty can now be seen as an aberration in the America’s history. The real and enduring war is the one against the poor themselves.

General Motors, meanwhile, is a story of another kind. Having steadily lost market share despite destroying Michigan’s working class, it diversified into so-called financial products services and went bankrupt in the Great Crash, only to be bailed out by the federal government and restored to profitability courtesy of the American taxpayer. In Darwin’s world, some species thrive, and others perish. But it really helps to have a friend in Washington.

The politicians have discovered Flint on the presidential campaign trail, and Hillary Clinton, always alert to a political or corporate buck, has rushed to cash in on the city’s misery. Certainly there is no better symbol of the depths the country has reached after 50 years of reaction. A society that eats its young writes its own epitaph. As for a society that poisons them . . . well, as Tom Jefferson memorably said, “I tremble for my country when I consider that God is just.”

Of course, Jefferson was talking about slavery, not hydro-contamination. And he kept on keeping slaves.

The post A society that poisons its young appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A society that poisons its young

Justice Antonin Scalia’s legacy of original intent

As Shakespeare would say, nothing became him in life so much as the leaving of it . . . Antonin Scalia died as he had lived, enjoying himself in a haunt of privilege, preparing to shoot animals for pleasure. Well, he would have been a droll figure if he had not managed to do so much harm, but he does leave us with an object lesson as to why the U.S. Supreme Court is a pernicious institution that has no business functioning as it does in a democracy.

Other countries have high courts; none has the power for nine officials, appointed for life, to overturn the laws passed by popularly elected assemblies with the independent concurrence of a chief executive, also popularly elected. Let us remember, while we are parsing Justice Scalia’s doctrine of original intent, that the Constitution says nothing at all about the Court’s assumed power, exercised since Marbury v. Madison, to reshape or annul legislative enactments. The British get along without such a body; in fact, they get along without a written constitution of any kind. I get it that the pope thinks he is divinely inspired to read the original intent of Scripture, little as I may agree with the idea. But that nine clerks can tell us what the assemblage of politicians, landowners, and slaveholders who met in Philadelphia two and a quarter centuries ago to write a governance document had in mind, and that their view of what those worthies thought and meant, transposed from an agricultural Republic of three million souls to a postindustrial one of three hundred million, should bind us hand and foot, has to be the most peculiar idea ever foisted on a supposedly self-governing people. Slavery, people used to say, was America’s “peculiar institution.” I think we can fairly apply the term to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The doctrine of original intent — that justices should seek to discern what the Founding Fathers intended in 1787, and restrict themselves to applying the law, including statute law, to such matters only as they considered and in such a manner as they would approve today — is now popularly associated with Scalia, but it is very much older than that. It’s an idea preposterous on the face of it, an exercise in judicial necromancy, but it does provide ideological cover for a particularly pernicious kind of conservatism. A good illustration of it in action is the career of Justice Felix Frankfurter, who was appointed to the Supreme Court by Franklin Roosevelt, and who died in 1965. Frankfurter was, in his early career, a liberal whom Roosevelt seemed to have good grounds to believe would be a reliable supporter of the New Deal. Little by little, however, he moved to the right, until he wound up a deep-dyed reactionary who justified his opinions by reference to original intent. No doubt, he was sincere in his conviction. We can always find good reasons for approving what we see in the mirror; the beauty industry depends on it. Whether it is a rationale for judicial policy-making is another matter.

There is a good and simple reason for rejecting original intent, the absurdity of long-distance mind-reading to one side. The Founding Fathers themselves didn’t agree on it. They gave us a blueprint for government—“a Republic, if you can keep it,” in Ben Franklin’s famous words—but they differed themselves about what it meant and how it should be applied. Their disputes are enshrined in the Federalist Papers. What one gleans from them is only the sensible conclusion that they expected their arguments to continue, and that each generation would have to sustain the nation according to its own lights.

Meanwhile, looking back at the 200 plus year history of the Supreme Court is a singularly unedifying experience. In a federal system such as ours, such a court serves the useful and perhaps indispensable function of sorting out discrepancies between state courts and legislatures from the national ones. That it can overturn Congressional acts and decide issues of national controversy, however, is a very far stretch indeed. The proper recourse for poorly conceived statutes is the electorate, which can and should turn miscreant legislators out of office. It does not do for nine unaccountable jurists to do the people’s job for them, or to decide what it is.

The Court’s actual role has been, largely, to protect or invent property rights on behalf of powerful interests. Its most notorious ruling, the Dred Scott case, is the classic example. Dred Scott not only found that the institution of slavery was customary, nor simply legal in the states where it obtained, but that free states were bound to cooperate in enforcing slave codes not their own making and, beyond even that, that the Constitution itself recognized the right to property of human persons. This was not only without foundation, but contrary to the clear evidence in the original debates that such a claim had been rejected. The Dred Scott Court therefore created “rights” where none existed or were intended but were in fact deliberately excluded. A convention of slaveowners could have come up with nothing worse. After Dred Scott, it was clear that the nation’s course was set for the civil war that would cost 700,000 lives. That’s what judicial tyranny can get you.

During the First Gilded Age of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the Court consistently upheld property rights, including the taking of property for commercial and monopolistic enterprises, over the rights of labor to organize and agitate for safe and humane working conditions and living wages. It beat back a variety of progressive reforms, already introduced in Europe, that have left us a century later with us with the worst systems of health, welfare, employment security, and child protection of any major Western country. Only very rarely, and only as a result of great social and political pressure, did the Court consider what the Constitution set out as its own stated goal—to promote the general welfare. The Court even went so far, in considering criminal procedure, as to declare that actual innocence was not a sufficient ground for appeal to it, an idea no judicial tribunal had ever put out before. In a titular democracy, it beggars belief the harm we entitle nine people to do.

Justice Scalia’s own name is most associated with the decision in Citizens United (2010) that corporations are “people” with First Amendment rights of speech, which — since certificates of legal registration have no vocal cords or working brains — means in practice that those who operate them can buy actors or politicians to speak the lines scripted for them, regardless of the interests or opinions of shareholders. I won’t go into the effects Citizens United has worked on our electoral system, which are plain for all to see, but simply consider it as an application of original intent doctrine. You will not find any indication of corporate rights in the Constitution for the simple reason that corporations did not exist in the late 18th century. It may therefore seem a particularly tortured form of reasoning to equate the rights of actual persons with legal fictions, but where did the fiction not exist in the first place? Dred Scott created a phantasmal right to human enslavement, and the Gilded Age Court a corporate right to worker dispossession and exploitation. Now, Citizens United has conferred on the corporation the blaring rights to silence democracy itself.

As for Scalia, his own career on the bench best gives the lie to original intent doctrine. If original intent is to be persuasive as a reading of the Constitution, it should be, when properly ascertained and argued, obvious and convincing to all. But few justices in Court history have found themselves so frequently in a minority of one as Scalia, and none prior to him have been so abrasively dismissive of his colleagues, to the point of intellectual contempt. So, it would seem, what original intent really means is what Antonin Scalia thought it meant at any given time, whether anyone else saw it his way or not. And what not agreeing with him meant was that you were a jerk.

So, if original intent ever had a meaning, it plainly died with Scalia himself. Tom Jefferson, Ben Franklin, James Madison — those guys only thought they understood the text they labored to produce through a hot Philadelphia summer. Antonin Scalia was the only person who could have told them what they were really doing. But he wasn’t around then, and he’s no longer with us now. Wouldn’t it better to stop casting spells to read defunct oracles, and let democracy speak directly for itself? But for those who have used this legal mumbo-jumbo to stifle the will of the majority, that’s the last result they want.

The post Justice Antonin Scalia’s legacy of original intent appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Justice Antonin Scalia’s legacy of original intent

The year democracy became a joke

Donald Trump said he could stand on Fifth Avenue and shoot someone, and not lose any votes. I believe it, too.

First of all, it’s a hypothetical — the Donald doesn’t really mean it. Secondly, if he did, he’s right: it wouldn’t have any effect, unless the victim were a Trump supporter. (In Manhattan, this would be unlikely.)

Why is this so? Because our democracy has finally morphed into full-time, round-the-clock entertainment, and in entertainment anything goes and nothing is believed. When a guy is shot on TV, we know that he will get up and collect his paycheck. That’s the make-believe that Trump is invoking when he projects himself as the hero of his own Western. There’ll be one less bad guy in the world, maybe several, and no one will really get hurt. Trump himself is a celebrity entertainer, so how could we take the whole scenario seriously?

But Trump is auditioning to be the president of the United States, and, after several months atop the polls among Republican voters, some people are taking this very seriously. Jeb Bush, for one. George Will, for another. Michael Bloomberg, too.

Welcome to Absurdo-Land.

We could start with the idea of an electoral process that runs 18 months, half of it pivoting on what the good folks of Iowa, fed on way too much corn, think about public affairs. It isn’t just that Trump has the support of about a third of Republican voters, but that the unholy trio of Trump, Ted Cruz and Ben Carson scarf up about 60 percent of the vote. That correlates roughly to the number of Iowa Republican voters who describe themselves as Evangelical or born-again Christians. Oh, my. We really do seem to be getting the democracy we pay for, at least in the Ethanol State. And, bite on this: Trump is far and away the best candidate of these three. Carson, who led for a while in the Iowa polls, thinks that Joseph built the Egyptian Pyramids. And Cruz thinks that he himself did. At least Donald knows that he’s wearing a clown suit.

Further down, there’s Marco Rubio. Asked why he celebrated the birthday of the Prince of Peace by buying hardware from his local gun shop on Christmas Eve, he answered that if ISIS came down the street looking for his family, his private arsenal would be his last line of defense.

Central casting, where are you?

The Democrats aren’t really much less bizarre. Their national poll leader is Hillary Clinton. Wait, wasn’t that the lady who lost a shoo-in nomination to a guy with big ears and a foreign-sounding name eight years ago? Yup, the same. And what has the Hillary done to burnish her stellar credentials since? Well, there was a turn as Secretary of State, notably distinguished by her cheerleading the destruction of Libya, now a failed state and a haven for those selfsame ISIS fighters who are about to terrorize Marco Rubio’s neighborhood. And, deja vu all over again, we get a septuagenarian senator who’s about to knock her off just as Barack Obama did, or I very much miss my guess.

Obama, who’s said he isn’t endorsing anyone until the primaries are over, did allow that Hillary was the most qualified candidate other-than-a-vice-president to take charge of the Republic on Day One in American history (translation: unless Joe Biden gets into the race after all). George and Abe, move over on those monuments. If this is the case, though, it must be because nothing succeeds like failure. Clinton’s entire accomplishment in politics, as far as I can see, has been to make herself by every measure the least trusted figure in American public life.

Do both our major parties have a death wish? Or is it simply that everyone knows that, whoever runs and whoever wins, Wall Street rules as usual? And isn’t that why our elections have turned into such a stupefying farce? The emptier our politics get, the louder they become. In its final end-stage, democracy becomes pure noise.

Which brings us to the sleeper candidate of 2016, Bernie Sanders. Because there’s always got to be one honest contender in the race, just so the cynics can’t announce that the Emperor has no clothes.

Trump and Sanders are, in certain respects, two sides of the same coin. This point has been made ad nauseum by establishment pundits, but it bears further examination. Trump boasts that his campaign is entirely self-funded (actually, not true), and that he is beholden to no interest — that he is his own man. Sanders says that he is funded exclusively by small donors, which appears to be the case. He too has no drawstrings, and his entire net worth appears to be roughly what Clinton got for speaking twice to Goldman Sachs in one year. Both men promise big changes. Trump says he is going to make America great again, how and by what standard to be determined later. Sanders says he will make both healthcare and college affordable. Which promise is the more incredible is yours to judge.

In some ways, though, Trump and Sanders are not the outlier candidates they’ve been made to seem, but very traditional. Shakespeare’s King Lear, shaking his fist skyward, says he will do such things as will be the terror of the earth though he knows not what they are. This sounds very much like the Donald. In fact, it sounds very much like Obama too. Didn’t Obama promise us all change we could believe in eight years ago? He never bothered to explain what that change would be, but people bought the credit coupons. Now they hold the empty paper bag. Trump figures that what works once can work again. You just have to amp it up a little.

Sanders, though, the self-avowed socialist, a traditional figure? Well, yes. Tuition-free public higher education? Fifty years ago, we had that. Public health insurance? Otto von Bismarck introduced the first such plan in the 1880s, and remember this was a guy who started his career as a supporter of serfdom. You could call Sanders the most quaintly conservative candidate in the race. Everything he wants is so — 19th and 20th century. Ah, socialism, where is thy sting? If Sanders represents the left, it’s only because the center of American political gravity has moved to the right of Genghis Khan. We are certainly to the right of every developed country in the world on almost any issue you could name. If everything Sanders dreams of were to come to pass, we would be approximately where we were with the 1948 Democratic Party platform. And the chances of that, in our gerrymandered, media-distracted, corporate-controlled world, fenced and policed by the nine-headed hydra of the Supreme Court, is, at present, effectively nil.

When Rome lost its liberty, the Caesars gave it panem et circenses — bread and circuses. The election of 2016 is the circus. But nobody’s handing out free bread. Serfs don’t get that benefit.

The post The year democracy became a joke appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The year democracy became a joke

Is Merkel the modern day Mother Teresa or Ilse Koche?

I don’t suppose the Time Magazine issue featuring German Chancellor Angela Merkel as its person of the year sold very well in Greece. Merkel made Time’s cover for opening Germany’s borders to an unprecedented flow of Syrian and other refugees, even as other European states were either hedging their bets or simply closing their borders. By year’s end, some 1.1 million migrants had been accepted, and the German government was largely preoccupied with the daunting task of settling them. Merkel’s apparent humanitarianism and generosity, even in the teeth of mounting resistance in Germany and in her own party, made her a shining light to Time’s editors in a year when the human race was not exactly distinguishing itself in general.

At the same time, however, Merkel was coming down in classic jackboot fashion on Greece’s short-lived attempt to get out from under the German-dictated austerity policies that have driven unemployment levels above 25 percent, wiped out a third of the country’s economy, and shorn its population of hope. In Athens, Angela Merkel is about as popular as Ilse Koch, the mistress of Buchenwald.

So, which Angela is it really, Mother Teresa or Frau Ilse?

A closer look at Merkel’s immigration policy may give us a clue. Germany has had a very flexible idea of its borders for a long time. Before World War I, Wilhelmine Germany talked of a “Drang nach Osten” or drive to the East. The war stripped it of territory instead. Hitler not only revived Germany’s aggressive ambitions, but led the country in a quest for so-called “Lebensraum” or living space that projected a German settlement of Eastern Europe entailing the clearance of thirty million Slavs. Where were these Slavs to go? The chimneys of Auschwitz gave a general idea. In his recent, book, “Black Earth: The Holocaust as History and Warning,” Timothy Snyder argued that Hitler was obsessed with the idea of a future struggle for survival on an increasingly contested planet. His plan did have a concrete and lasting result: approximately thirty million East Europeans were in fact killed, starved, or worked to death during his years in power, including six million Jews.

After World War II, Germany got payback, as ethnic Germans long settled in Eastern Europe were expelled with scant ceremony. This was Germany’s first major influx of refugees, and it left a lasting mark. Some forty years later, the reunification of a divided Germany at the end of the Cold War meant the reintegration of nearly twenty million East Germans into a single federal state for the first time since 1945. This, too, was difficult and traumatic, for under Communist rule East Germans had developed habits of thought and behavior not readily assimilated into the capitalist culture of West Germany. A quarter century later, this process is still not complete.

West Germany did, over the years, become home to “guest workers,” mainly recruited from southern Europe and Turkey, who eventually formed permanent immigrant communities. These groups were looked upon with suspicion, and, especially after reunification, the neo-Nazi youth groups known as skinheads had sometimes violent confrontations with them. The skinheads were not simply the bastardized offspring of Hitler’s master race theories, but part of an underemployed population resentful of foreigners competing for scarce jobs.

Against this background, a policy of welcoming Syrian refugees on an open-ended basis would seem most unlikely for a Conservative German Chancellor.
To understand why Merkel laid out the welcome mat, we must consider both political and economic factors. Germany’s domination of the continent through the European Union and the Eurozone has become so complete that the German Chancellor is the de facto president of Europe. In the wake of the financial crash of 2008, Germany wrote the austerity policies (beneficial to itself) that have devastated the economies not only of Greece but of Spain, Portugal, and, to a lesser extent, Italy and France. Greece has been the hardest hit of these countries, but Spain has experienced comparable levels of unemployment, and the French President Francois Hollande has just declared a state of economic emergency. At the same time, Germany has revived the “Drang nach Osten” in tandem with the United States, steadily expanding the European Union and the North Atlantic Treaty Organization into the former Soviet bloc countries of the East. This policy culminated in the coup d’etat against the government of Ukraine in 2013 that installed a Western-backed regime, resulting in the civil war that has wracked the country since.

Given the last episode of German expansion into Eastern Europe, Germany’s leaders have not been eager to advertise their most recent push, and both the European Union and the U.S. have given them cover. Austerity, too, is a political policy cloaked as an economic one, but here as well the Germans have been able to wield the institutions of the EU, notably the European Commission and the European Central Bank, to achieve the desired results. The tide of refugees flooding Europe from Syria and the other failed states of the Middle East and North Africa, however, presented a more nakedly political question. The EU was unable to devise a common policy to deal with it. East European states, some within the EU and some not, abruptly closed their borders and interned refugees in what looked uncomfortably like concentration camps, complete with barbed wire. This was not an image that Germany, above all, wished to project.

Unable to broker a common policy in her first stand-alone test as Europe’s political dominatrix, Merkel compensated by committing Germany itself to an open-door policy on refugees that gave her the moral high ground — and the cover of Time. She did this, apparently, with little consultation with her party’s leaders, no preparation for the German public’s response, and no long-term plan for integrating a large alien population into the fabric of German life. Merkel would have had a practical consideration in mind, however. Germany’s aging population, like that of other European countries, faces a shortage of able-bodied workers, both to service its economy and finance welfare and pension costs. Beggaring the Mediterranean South has been one means of addressing this problem, as young Greeks and others have migrated to Germany in desperate search of employment. The Syrian refugees, however, constitute a much larger pool, and the fact that they are disproportionately young, male, and single make them, on paper, an ideal source for menial labor and value extraction.

The backlash has been, of course, only too predictable, and Merkel has now done a 180, threatening to deport the refugees she welcomed only a few months ago. Where they would go is another question. Rarely has a recent political leader made so rash a blunder, and the refugee fiasco, together with austerity, will no doubt define Merkel’s legacy.

America’s perennial immigration problem along its southern border has meanwhile come back into the news courtesy of Donald Trump, who wants a Fortress America literally walled off north and south. (Lucky us, with oceans east and west.) Of course, there wouldn’t be an America at all without immigrants, starting with those Pilgrim Fathers who crossed the Atlantic without papers either. The simple truth about Mexican immigrants is that their labor puts the food on our plates, and that American farmers have connived with authorities for a century to ensure the illegal workforce that brings in the crop at starvation wages and returns maximum profit. Our limitless hunger for drugs and our penchant for supporting the most brutal Latin dictators we can find has driven a further population of political refugees across the border too, fleeing a violence less well publicized than that in Syria or Iraq but hardly less lethal. The problems of Mexico and Central America are not all of our own making, but we contribute mightily to them, and in doing so make them our own too.

I can’t remember an administration that’s treated undocumented migrants (including genuine refugees) worse than Obama’s has since Dwight Eisenhower deported a million Mexicans in 1954. We have more migrants in detention, including children, than at any other time in our history; we are busily breaking up families through deportation at an ever-accelerating pace. It isn’t Congress or the law that’s forcing Obama to do this; it’s presidential compassion. For you can bank on this: whenever Obama makes a speech expressing sympathy or concern for anyone, the hammer will come down somewhere.

As for America admitting a million Syrian refugees, or even the paltry ten thousand the President was shamed into suggesting a few months ago, don’t bet your lottery ticket on it. It has a much better chance of paying off.

The post Is Merkel the modern day Mother Teresa or Ilse Koche? appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Is Merkel the modern day Mother Teresa or Ilse Koche?

The Stasis of the Union: It’s in utter shambles.

By the time you read this, Barack Obama will have delivered his valedictory State of the Union Address; as I write it, his speechwriters will be making their last-ditch efforts to make a sow’s ear into a silk purse.

What might this speech actually have sounded like if composed in the depths of Obama’s conscience? How might he have honestly summed up seven years in office, and the state of the country soon to be handed to an unlucky successor? Maybe it would go something like this:

“My fellow Americans,

The state of the Union is, of course, awful. The stock market slide suggests we may be ready to fall back into the depression (it’s all right if I use the d-word down here in the cozy depths between us, isn’t it?) that most people who aren’t bankers or CEOs never actually got out of. Sure, I got the official unemployment rate down to 5 percent by pretending that the millions of people who’ve been unable to find work at decent wages or any wage at all, and who perhaps in their 40s or 50s will never find work again, simply don’t exist. I know a bunch of ‘em myself and I’ll bet you do too—if you aren’t actually one yourself—but, shhh, they’re the disappeared ones, you know, like those folks in Argentina the generals used to drop from airplanes or bury in mass graves under stadiums. Out of sight, out of mind.

For those of you still working, well, you don’t need me to tell you that you’re working longer hours for less in hopes of an eventual pension that will turn out to have been underfunded or never funded at all. No one will ever be held to account for this systemic fraud because, you know, sovereign immunity and all that kind of thing.

If you’re looking to eke out your Golden Years on Social Security, that’ll be a real ha-ha. Sure, your Social was never designed to be a general pension, just your really basic poverty-level stipend, and the cost of living adjustments never covered inflation either—which, by the way, the Federal Reserve and I have managed to pretend doesn’t exist, so that I’ve become the first President since 1935 to decide (three times, no less!) that no cost-of-living adjustment was necessary because the cost of living hadn’t gone up. Yo, seniors, your medical bills aren’t any higher, are they? No increase in premiums and co-pays, right? No higher drug costs, correct? Oh, yeah, that Martin Shkreli guy tried to raise the price of his life-saving drug from $13.50 a pill to $750, but hey, he’s going to jail, right, so you won’t notice that Pfizer just raised the roof on just about every drug they sell.

Well, that was the blessing of Obamacare, which enshrined the corporate monopolies of for-profit medicine forever and kept us the only government in the world that doesn’t do competitive bidding on drug prices. It’s really a gas when the Republicans vote to repeal the Unaffordable Care Act every other day, when it was actually taken right out of the Heritage Foundation’s playbook to begin with. Your tax dollars at work, mainlined from Medicare right into the bottom line of Big Pharma and the Medical-Industrial complex, as we fondly call hospital conglomerates around here.

Pushing a Republican health care bill through Congress without a single Republican vote was certainly my signature accomplishment. It made voters so angry that they promptly voted a Republican majority into Congress so that progressive legislation would be the dead on arrival for the rest of my term, and in gratitude for this they nominated Mitt Romney to run against me in 2012—probably the only guy in the country who couldn’t have beaten me.
What I’m really proudest of, though, is this: not a single banker or corporate executive anywhere in this great nation of ours went to jail for turning the economy into a giant Ponzi scheme and nearly taking it for good. Thanks to the Fed’s version of political correctness, we never even had to call the biggest crash since 1929 an actual depression, and what a whopper of one it was! There’s usually a price to be paid when things mess up that bad, but I made good and sure that John Q. Public picked up the tab. Folks (see, I like to call people “folks,” so maybe they won’t notice they aren’t citizens anymore) got tossed out of their homes and jobs by the millions, but the banks and brokers and insurers and corporations all got recapitalized at the public trough and were raking in more dough than ever before you could say Barack Hussein Obama.

Think they were grateful for that, though? You’ve never met a banker, obviously! They got so snarky when I had to pitch a few pennies to keep the states from going bankrupt that I had to call ‘em into the White House and remind them that I was the only one standing between them and the pitchforks. You remember that line, don’t you? Greatest one of my presidency. And, darn right, I did keep the pitchforks away, but don’t think it was easy. Why, even Reagan had to toss a bunch of bankers into the clink over the savings and loan crisis in the ’80s, and that wasn’t a pimple on the crash of 2008. That’s politics, though. You’re only as good as the last favor you’ve done for the Big Guys, and your favors are never good enough.

Well, I could go on and on! Remember all that transparency I promised you back on the campaign trail in 2008? So, I served up the most secretive government in American history, and the biggest surveillance state anywhere, anytime. When nosy reporters got on my case about it, I whipped out the good old Espionage Act of 1917—you remember, the one designed to ferret out spies and traitors—and threw that book at them. No bankers in jail, thank you, but reporters, definitely yes. State secrets are state secrets, after all, and what you don’t know won’t hurt you—until it does, ha ha!

Not much time to talk about foreign policy, but that always kind of bored me. I did promise to get out of Afghanistan and Iraq, but you know these long imperial wars never end, and no American president ever admits to losing a war, that’s a rule. Iraq was a failed state before I got to it and Afghanistan never had a state to begin with, but I did crash Libya all on my own and they’ll never be able to take that away from me. Oh, and I would have bombed Syria back in 2013 if I could, but no one wanted a piece of that action back then and now the Russians have decided to do it themselves. But I have rented out our air force to the Iranians in Iraq, and between us we managed to level Ramadi—you’ll remember that line from Vietnam about having to destroy a village in order to save it.

You will bring up that promise I made about closing down Guantanamo Bay, won’t you? Well, that was a political hairball, but I found some foot-draggers in the Pentagon who would find a way to keep even prisoners cleared for release just where they were. Don’t blame Barack! Truman had the guts to fire Douglas MacArthur for insubordination, even though all the guy did was to win World War II. But of course I wouldn’t dream of removing some pencil-pusher who gave the lie to a major campaign promise, especially when he was doing just what I really wanted.
I could go on about the reset button with Russia that turned into a new Cold War, or how the Chinese ate our lunch in Asia, or . . . but you get the idea, and, as I said, foreign policy really does bore me.

That leaves climate policy and race relations, I guess, and of course guns. You all remember how I would always make a terrific speech about climate control just before opening up the Atlantic or the Arctic for drilling, or approving the first oil exports in decades. Yes, I killed the Keystone XL pipeline after dithering around long enough so that the Canadians didn’t need it anymore. And I give such tearjerkers about how we have to deal with the gun epidemic that I even make myself cry. That’s my MO: make a speech, and walk away. Then do the opposite, or nothing at all. But you’ve probably noticed that by now.
I could have told you this eight years ago, but electing an African-American president was going to set race relations in this country back a century. Except that it looks more like a hundred and fifty years now—you know, the Civil War.

I guess that’s about it. You know I’m not going to endorse anybody for president during the primaries—how could I hold my nose hard enough, especially for you-know-who? But I will tell you this: You’ll be wishing for the good old days of Barack Obama before the last hanging chad is counted. That’s the way it works. Don’t forget I told you so.”

The post The Stasis of the Union: It’s in utter shambles. appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Stasis of the Union: It’s in utter shambles.

Capitalism, our very own Death Star

A few years ago, a movie called “Melancholia” appeared that depicted the imminent death of Planet Earth from the approach of a rogue planet that had wandered into our solar system, and, like an evil twin, was headed straight for us. I don’t know how plausible the science is for that, but then, you don’t go to the movies for astronomy lessons. The point of the film was to show how its characters reacted to the prospect of sudden extinction. We all face personal extinction sooner or later, and, since genocide became popular in the last century, we’ve begun to have some experience of collective manmade extinctions as well. Some biologists have begun to speculate what the next dominant species on Earth might be after we render our planet uninhabitable for ourselves, and, of course, there is much talk about colonizing other worlds these days. The point about “Melancholia” is what happens when there’s no future at all and no way out; the death planet (itself lifeless) makes all escape impossible. It is Fate itself, in its most distilled and urgent form.
If such a scenario were real, what would be our response? Some might think we’d descend into an orgy of rape and looting, or line up for government-issued suicide pills as in the old Stanley Kramer film about nuclear annihilation, “On the Beach.” But I’ll bet our corporate masters would urge us to go out in a shopping spree. The last bottom line, after all, has to be a black one.
Our planet does in fact have a dark star, but it isn’t approaching us from outer space. It’s right here among us, sprung from us. It’s called capitalism, the insanely distorted form of labor extraction and market exchange that is now celebrated as our collective social destiny. It’s the giant heat engine that’s turning up the temperature of the globe, and spawning those once in a hundred or thousand year weather events that the past year, with a helping hand from a strong El Nino, have made the new normal. What 2015 has shown us is a preview of what awaits us a few years down the line. To be sure, the climate as such won’t kill us, though it may take a Black-Death-sized bite out of humanity’s soon-to-be unsustainable numbers. But the resource wars of the future that it will surely spawn could conceivably take us over the brink. The future, right now, looks like an unpleasant time to be in.
A German thinker, currently unfashionable, helped us understand the mess we were creating for ourselves, though he proved unduly optimistic about cleaning it up. A hundred and fifty years ago, Karl Marx patiently explained the distinction between use and commodity value for us, or the difference between goods produced for consumption in response to concrete human needs and those produced not for use but only sale and resale. The difference (although Marx didn’t have the analogy at hand, the internal combustion engine not yet having been invented) is between turning on a car ignition to go someplace and turning it on simply to let it run. Run an engine without moving it forward and you produce not motion (utility) but waste. In short order, the engine will stall. That is the simplest diagram of what a commodity economy looks like, and what it will do.
Of course, you might regard a perfect commodity economy as a contradiction in terms. Some of the things we produce we must certainly use; we all have to eat. But so-called commodity markets, based on pure financial speculation, approach this condition; and such markets have increasingly dominated the economy as a whole. They also, periodically, crash it.
Marx observed this in his own time, and the two consequences it invariably produced: capital concentration and mass immiseration. He also understood the revolution in technology that had made both the creation and control of a large urbanized workforce possible. Marx had no illusions about the agriculturally-based economy that had preceded industrial capitalism, or the elites that ruled it. But food is a product for use, however its price and availability may be manipulated, and those who produce it must also be allowed to consume it. Industrial capitalism alone had produced mass populations that could be considered superfluous, and therefore allowed to starve.
But as technology had enslaved man, so, Marx felt, it promised liberation as well. The machine offered abundance, and with it the prospect of release from the age-old round of toil that human survival, at least above the level of primitive society, had required, or, more properly, that had been exacted from it. The machine itself, however, first required liberation from its own bondage in the form of private capital. This would not come from gradual political reform through the liberal state, now as two centuries ago the fond illusion of its advocates. It would necessitate revolution. Fortunately, however, the means to achieve this were to hand: the very concentration by capital in the hands of a progressively smaller elite, both symbolized and concretely embodied in the factory, made an abrupt, radical, and final transfer of power possible.
Marx was concerned, reasonably enough, with the misery of human beings; he did not envision the misery of the planet itself. The appalling effects of early industrialization—poisoned rivers, polluted skies, stunted laborers and their children, and some of the worst mortality rates in human history—were apparent even to conservatives. But few were able to imagine the long-term consequences for the natural world itself, which capitalism had reconceived not as a nurturing if sometimes capricious mother but as a passive site for value extraction, much like human labor itself.
We know better now, to our cost. Nature has immense powers of recuperation, but they are not limitless, and if we force it into new paths it will take us on a very unpleasant journey. We know something, too, about technology. It is not fundamentally a set of processes or a sum of machines and gadgets, but a state of mind, an attitude toward ourselves and our surroundings, our being-in-the-world. We can’t, as Marx thought, liberate the machines by taking over the factory floor (the factories are no longer here in any case), because if we continue to use and power them in the same way, as instruments of rapacity, then they will finally own us and ruin the earth. You can do away with capitalists and still have capitalism, if you blindly import the capitalist mindset into the brave new world of revolution: this was the lesson of twentieth-century communism, which in Russia and China, wreaked some of the most extreme ecological devastation on the planet.
In this sense, Marx’s precursor Jean-Jacques Rousseau was more prescient, because he saw that the human problem was not simply a matter of material distribution and control but of issues fundamental to humanity as such. We aren’t going to solve the mess we’re making of the natural world by inventing better machines. We need more careful, mindful and cherishing human beings, and there’s no easy blueprint for that.
At the same time, the capitalists are all too much with us. Never before in history have so few commanded so much wealth and power worldwide, and never with so much arrogance and so little responsibility. Thinking ourselves through to a world we can still hope to live in will require our best attention; we cannot have it while mindless greed rules us and shapes our most intimate lives and thought. Our institutions, deformed by unaccountable power, are compromised and corrupt, and we need look no further than our farcical political season to see how far we have derogated from whatever fond hopes the founding fathers once had for their famous experiment. Fortunately, we still have good and wise and modest minds among us—Wendell Berry, Bill McKibben, Naomi Klein—and our survival instincts, we must hope, have not been warped beyond repair. But we must see clearly, and soon, the dark star that is approaching—that has, I mean, arisen from us. And we must disenthrall ourselves from it. This is the work we all have to do.

The post Capitalism, our very own Death Star appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Capitalism, our very own Death Star

Keep calm and face terrorism rationally

On the morning of September 11, 2001, I got a phone call from my son. He told me to turn on the TV, and I saw the World Trade Center towers burning. Ash, some of it human ash, drifted over from Lower Manhattan to Brooklyn. Some of it, I realized, was falling on the hospital in Brooklyn Heights where I had been born.
I was stunned and a bit crazy about this, like everyone else. Not quite everyone; the Bush administration made sure that a plane with Saudi embassy personnel got out of the country the next day, when all other commercial flights were banned. 15 of the 19 hijackers who had attacked New York and Washington were Saudis.
We’ve never had a public accounting of the Saudi involvement in 9/11. That wasn’t going to happen under George W. Bush, who was joined at the hip with the Saudis through the family’s oil interests. It hasn’t happened under Barack (never look back) Obama either. Obama never met a secret he didn’t want to keep, at least from you and me, and this was the biggest hush of all. Conspiracy theories flourished in the silence, which added to the national paranoia, which in turn was perfectly okay with those who found fear a useful commodity.
Terrorists hit the jackpot with 9/11, but so did the Security State, already well ensconced but now given license to erect a surveillance regime of totalitarian dimensions. There was a brief struggle with the Constitution; the Constitution lost. Liberty bit the dust and it’s been gagging ever since.
After 9/11, America went into cringe mode at home, but lashed out overseas. The Saudis were off limits, but Afghanistan made a good whipping-boy. Osama Bin Laden, who claimed bragging rights for 9/11, was hiding out there; Al Qaeda had training bases on the ground; the fundamentalist Taliban were made to play the part of the terrorist state actor. Never mind, of course, that the Taliban themselves were largely the creation of Pakistan’s security apparatus, the ISI. We needed a target, and Afghanistan fit the specs. No target, no war. And the Bush regime had declared a war on terror.
If you’ve noticed, we fight wars all the time, all over the globe. The only ones we actually declare, though, are for publicity purposes. Fear is (always) the common denominator. Once upon a time, the medical-industrial complex declared a “war” on cancer. Many decades and many, many billions of dollars later, cancer is still around, as of course it always will be. Richard Nixon declared a war on drugs, and the intention of that was to quadruple the American prison population, to make war zones of large tracts of Central and South America, and to create instant millionaires both in and out of government. How’s it going otherwise, by the way? The heroin epidemic in Maine is so bad now that the governor recently threatened to call out the National Guard to cope with it.
The War on Terror is faring no better, so, naturally, we double down on it. It’s not supposed to go better, of course; the idea is not to win the war but to prolong it indefinitely. We whacked the mole of Al Qaeda (though it’s still happily in business, thank you), but, never to fear, hatched its successor ISIS in our Iraqi prisons. ISIS has had a good run lately, climaxing in the attacks in Paris last month, though the so-called caliphate is really a loose franchise operation with a home base that consists of a bank network, a Twitter account, and a lot of sand.
Paris is our glamour capital; even the Nazis left it unscathed, and so, first when Charlie Hebdo was hit in January and now with the far deadlier and more sophisticated November attacks, we’ve got the wind up again. It hasn’t helped that the attacks have coincided with the Republican primaries, an audition for demagogues with a national megaphone. Donald Trump, having started out as a tin-pot Mussolini, has graduated since Paris into full Hitler mode, and his rhetoric drives the rest of the crowd. Continental walls to keep out unwanted immigrants, and detention centers to keep them while they’re rounded up for deportation? No problem. Torture à la carte for suspected terrorists? Sure. And, Guantanamo forever. If we run out of space there, let’s just take over the rest of Cuba as a prison island.
It takes very little to bring out the worst in us. September 11 was more than sufficient, and Paris has been good enough, especially with the issue of admitting Syrian refugees on the burner. The atmosphere is now more poisonous than at any time since 9/11, and it is likely to result in fresh wind for the Permanent War syndrome that is the default option of American politics. It won’t be just another turn of the wheel, either. We have become so inured to the routine of terror—the colored alerts, the habitual presence of men in fatigues with machine guns in public places, the constant injunction to see something and say something—that it takes little to stimulate our fear reflex, and our compliance to command. Meanwhile, there is the reinforcing effect of Paris itself, where we see the reflection of our own 9/11 hysteria in that of the French and their feckless president, Francois Hollande, whose immediate response to attack was a bombs-away strategy without rhyme or reason. We are ready to accept tyranny even before it is imposed on us; indeed, to embrace it with a sigh of relief. At last, we will say, we have been able to do worse to ourselves than our enemies ever could. Maybe now someone will make us safe?
There is, though, another option. We could start by recognizing that we face, in fact, not an “enemy” but a ragtag troop of barbarians spouting nihilistic jargon supposedly cribbed from a holy book. It is nonsense to describe the measures to deal with it as somehow involving what Samuel Huntington called a “clash of civilizations.” What we should call ourselves at this juncture is perhaps an open question, but ISIS represents, literally, nothing at all. It commits crimes and atrocities and acts of vandalism on historical monuments; it is a public menace. We need to understand where it came from and what fuels it, but it is, as Al Qaeda was after 9/11, essentially a police problem. We have been mistaking ourselves for a long time by militarizing our response to it, even if now and then military force may be a useful tool.
We need, above all, a sense of proportion. Since 9/11, over 3,000 lives have been lost to terrorism on American soil. This isn’t World War II, which claimed the lives of 2.6 percent of the world’s population. It isn’t London during the Blitz, or Baghdad today, where a trip to the market can cost you your life. Terrorism is, finally, a symptom of social malaise and political injustice, cynically manipulated and opportunistically exploited. We have exploited it ourselves, in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria and scores of other places. We object to it not in itself—state terrorism is the commonest form of terror—but when it is turned against us. If we really want to get rid of it, we should stop practicing it ourselves, or fostering the conditions under which it flourishes. In the meantime, we can cope, without losing our cool or tossing our liberties into the nearest trash bin.
The first modern terrorist was Francois Ravaillac, a Catholic zealot who assassinated King Henry IV of France in 1610. In the late 19th century, acts of terrorism were so frequent in Europe that, after a bomb had been thrown into the French National Assembly in the 1890s, its speaker calmly dusted himself off and said, “Now, where were we?”
The French could use a little of that sangfroid now. So could we.

The post Keep calm and face terrorism rationally appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Keep calm and face terrorism rationally

Scary candidates shed light on an even scarier reality

We’ve become accustomed to joke candidacies in recent presidential primaries, to voters embracing hitherto obscure personalities who, in more mundane elections, they wouldn’t trust for dog-catcher. Herman Cain, the pizza king, represented this phenomenon (thus far confined to Republican primaries) in 2012; Ben Carson, the retired neurosurgeon, sometime pitchman and self-professed born-again Christian, is the stand-in this time. Cain, as you may recall, briefly led the polls before Republican voters sobered up and nominated Mitt Romney—which, admittedly, was sobering up with a vengeance.

We’ve had actual joke nominees for office—Dan Quayle for Vice President in 1988; Sarah Palin for the same job in 2008. Maybe it’s the office that’s the joke? Quayle, of course, actually spent a term in office, and he and Palin had prior public service, if that’s the word. But Cain, and now Carson, came completely out of right field. Nobody outside of the pizza and snipping businesses had ever heard of them, and they were as innocent of political experience as a baby’s backside. Yet both soared to the head of the field, and Carson is still a close second to Donald Trump as I write.

You’ll notice I don’t mention Trump. (Interestingly, the Donald himself apparently toyed with the idea of being George H. W. Bush’s running mate himself in 1988. That would have made for quite a pair!) Trump, though still a political novice, is anything but obscure: self-promotion has been his entire career. Cain and Carson, in contrast, seemed to come from Purgatorial obscurity. They figuratively invented themselves before the public eye, with whatever fact or fiction they chose to combine. Cain really did sell pizzas. In Carson’s case, as we are learning day by day, fiction has been by far the preponderant element.

Like Trump, Cain and Carson are the products of a reality TV culture. Reality TV specializes in plucking ordinary Americans out of nowhere and giving them a shot at fame and fortune, a version of the lottery where the prize is less money than face time, and, for the lucky few, an “entertainment” career of some sort. Their biography is their performance, for nothing else distinguishes them. Trump has sold his biography for decades, but then he’s been the host, not the contestant, in the Reality sweepstakes. Cain had and Carson has only the song and dance of themselves, an act they were putting on for the first time before a national audience. Off-handedly, they suggested positions on this political issue or that, but what they were selling was the personality that, speech by speech, they invented for us.

Both Cain and Carson are, of course, African Americans, and that has been critical to their success, particularly with conservative white audiences. The reason for this has been suggested: they signify not a mysterious transcendence of the race factor in American politics among conservatives, but a backhanded repudiation of Barack Obama. Without mentioning Obama, Cain and Carson opposed everything the first African American president was held to stand for, and Carson, as a physician, has particularly delighted audiences by denouncing Obamacare, the President’s so-called signature achievement. It’s an old trick: every stigmatized social group is presumed, at least publicly, to have exceptions—“good” Jews who don’t care about money, “good” blacks who aren’t violent. Their function is not to disprove the negative stereotype, but to confirm it. In the end, the exception vanishes; the stereotype remains, stronger than ever.

We have come to see of late just how careless or indifferent Carson is about “Ben Carson,” the persona he has created for himself. There is, for example, the howler about his having been offered a scholarship to West Point (embroidered with a tale about sitting down with the late general William Westmoreland, of Vietnam fame). The problem with the story is that West Point doesn’t offer scholarships; it is tuition-free for all cadets. This means that Carson could not have misremembered his application; he could never have made it. Most people who lie try to be credible, at least for awhile; Ben Carson wanted to be exposed, because the people who had bought into his persona were not going to blame him for fibbing or even hallucinating, but the media for persecuting him. And this, up to now, has been the result.

Carson has similarly told us of late of a violent youth in which he had even threatened his mother with bodily harm. This, too, is deeply puzzling on the surface, because Carson’s appeal, when he began to catch on, came from a soft-spokenness and calmness of demeanor almost uncanny in a would-be politician. The contrast with the bombastic Trump was obvious and intentional, but it touched a deeper chord as well, for the stereotypic African American is not only violent but loud: once again, Carson was portraying himself as the exception to the rule. Yet, having carefully cultivated this image for months, he then set out to contradict it: the original Carson, as it turned out, was every bit as violent, as filled with rage, as the stereotype would have him.
The moral of Carson’s story was, of course, that he had been born again through evangelical Christianity, and thus saved from himself. In short, he was a black man who had become something other than black; who confirmed the stereotype of the violent African American while exempting himself from it. Whites, particularly evangelical whites, could thus forgive the sinner who had repudiated the greatest sin of all: that of being black.

It is hard to imagine Carson keeping up this high-wire act for long, and he seems already to have peaked. His “campaign”—which at this point has apparently devolved into a lucrative book tour—never seems to have been much more than an attempt to turn a quick buck. Nor would it be of much interest, except for what it tells us about the state of our democracy. Yes, it has exposed and exploited a deep-seated racism, one that suggests that the election of Obama in 2008 was not the watershed event in our national life so many hoped it would be, but a signal for the huge racial backlash that has engulfed the waning days of his administration. But there’s more to it than that.

Absurdist candidates such as Carson and Trump gain support, at least in Republican quarters, not despite their lack of personal or political credibility, but because of it. The more their unfitness is exposed, the more tenaciously their core supporters rally around them. This has nothing to do with who these candidates really are—a huckster and a blowhard, respectively—but what their personas represent. To call them outsider or anti-establishment figures tells us nothing. They are the negations of a political process that increasing numbers of people feel has failed them, or more pointedly, that exploits and dumps them, exporting their jobs, bilking their pensions, ridiculing their hopes and values, and above all making mock of the idea that they can have any say over their own destinies. Democracy itself, for them, is the real cheat; their disempowerment by the government, the faceless bureaucracies, and the corporate and financial elites that rule them, is complete. Their country has been stolen out from under them, and they are beleaguered strangers in it.

Some of this has to do with the shrinking (or mythical?) middle class, and some of it with the shrinking proportion of whites in the population. But it is a reality-based experience. It is a fact, not an illusion, that a union-based manufacturing economy has been replaced by an unsecured service one; that wealth has been extracted at alarming rates from the toil of the many by a small ownership elite; and that the two political parties, once in office, operate as one. It is not only useful but necessary to say that Obama, elected as the candidate of change, has been Wall Street’s obedient servant for seven years, from the bank bailouts to the Trans-Pacific trade partnership, and that Obamacare itself has simply dumped the care of the poor on the backs of the middle class in the interest of for-profit medical monopolies. A fabulating doctor sued six times for malpractice and a billionaire casino mogul are a poor way to express them, but the grievances are real, and deep.

What Carson and Trump thus express is a hunger for a leader completely outside the existing system, one not bound by constitutional rules or niceties. This is not a novel situation. Long ago, when the city-states of ancient Greece fell into strife over class inequities, they had resort to an outside figure who was given plenary powers by which everyone would be bound. Such a figure was called a tyrannos, which we translate as “tyrant.” The tyrants of old were not baneful figures, but, it was hoped, impartial arbiters who would restore peace and justice, and, thanked for their labors, would then depart. Sometimes, the system worked; but the gradual connotation that tyranny gained—of arbitrary power used for hateful and despotic ends—was the fruit of bitter experience. More and more people have become willing to take the gamble, though, and that is what Carson and Trump finally represent. They are comic figures, yes, and Trump in particular is a poor imitation of Mussolini. But don’t make the mistake of laughing them off.

The post Scary candidates shed light on an even scarier reality appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Scary candidates shed light on an even scarier reality