Author Archives | Robert Zaller

It’s time to retire the Nobel Prize

It’s time, after 115 years, to retire the Nobel Prize. This year’s award in literature proves it. Yes, the Swedish Academy and the Academy of Sciences gives out Nobels in a bunch of fields, including the hard sciences and the dismal one, economics (this year given for pioneering work on — sound the trumpets! — contracts). The awards in physics and chemistry are generally given for work known by and comprehensible to maybe half a dozen people around the globe. Aside from specialists, they elicit a gigantic yawn from everyone else. There’s the Nobel Peace Prize, which is generally reserved for warmongers shaking hands. Henry Kissinger, the world’s oldest unindicted war criminal, received one. So did Barack Obama, a few months into his presidential term of office. Who’d have thought he’d wind up the first American president to pass his entire presidency at war without letup, and on half a dozen fronts?

If the science prizes elicit a yawn, maybe the peace prize rates a sigh. But the only award most people pay any attention to is the one in literature. The Nobel Prize in lLiterature has become such an annual circus that those considered likely candidates are handicapped by Ladbrooke’s. For example, a hot tip near the time of this year’s award announcement reduced the odds on Don DeLillo from 66:1 to 14:1.

The award, as everyone now knows, went to Bob Dylan. Say again?

It isn’t as if the Nobel Prize Committee hasn’t been messing up for some time; in fact, from the very beginning. The first winner for literature was that master story-teller, Sully-Prudhomme. Surely you’ve read his works? His competition only included Leo Tolstoy: you know, the guy who wrote “War and Peace.” Over the years, the winners have included such household names as Verner von Heidensten, Karl Anton Gjellerup, and Henrik Pontoppidan. Tolstoy, who lived into the tenth year of the award, never won.

Of course, you can’t always get it wrong in over the course of a hundred years, even if you just open the phone book at random. Writers of eminence have won the award, although the taste of the Swedish Academy runs decidedly to the middle-brow, with a heavy tilt toward Scandinavian masters. But even a partial list of omissions includes, besides Tolstoy, Thomas Hardy, Anton Chekhov, Marcel Proust, Paul Valery, Rainer Maria Rilke, Robert Musil, Franz Kafka, Virginia Woolf, James Joyce, Nikos Kazantzakis, Jorge Luis Borges. This doesn’t count non-Western writers, whom the Academy only began to recognize recently. And even when it picks a good writer, it typically ignores a better one. Wislawa Szymborska, a worthy poet, won the prize for Poland, while a truly great Polish poet, Zbigniew Herbert, was ignored. Odysseus Elytis received the award for Greece, but Yannis Ritsos, a world figure, did not. And so on.

It’s all been a harmless parlor game to this point, or, if you attend to the politics behind each award, a nasty dogfight. If the choice is bizarre, as in the recent cases of the completely unreadable Elfride Jelinek or the court jester Dario Fo, you can simply shrug. But the Dylan case is simply a willful assault on literature. Aside from a memoir, Dylan is not a writer at all, just a balladeer. He got his award for song lyrics and maybe the way he sung them, which would be sort of like giving Robert Frost the Nobel Prize (he didn’t win it either) not for his poems but for the way he read them.

Full disclosure: I’ve never liked Bob Dylan as a singer. His voice, even when young, was raspy and nasal. Even if you thought, though, that he was a vocal master, the point is what he was singing rather than simply the way he sang it. And, on the page, his lyrics, considered as literature, are of surpassing banality. Here’s a sample:

In the courtroom of honor, the judge pounded his gavel

To show that all’s equal, that the courts are on the level

(“The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll”)

“Courtroom of honor” is a meaningless mouthful, “gavel” and “level” are weak rhymes, and the sudden turn from the high-toned to the colloquial (“all’s equal,” “on the level”) falls utterly flat. Nor do we ever find out much about the song’s subject, Hattie Carroll, except that her killer got off lightly. But, worse yet:

While preachers preach of evil fates

Teachers teach that knowledge waits

Disillusioned words like bullets bark

(“Bringing It All Back Home”)

Really, how lame, how subliterate can you get? That preachers preach is a simple-minded tautology; likewise, that teachers teach. “Preach of evil fates” is subgrammatical, too; you preach “about” or “on the subject of,” not “of” something. “Evil fates” is likewise painfully awkward and banal, and I have never heard that teachers “teach that knowledge waits” (which knowledge? Where? Why?). The sense of the sentence, without further reference, is nonsense; but worse still “awaits.” “Words” are not disillusioned, only the speakers of them; disillusioned speech can hardly suggest “bullets;”; and “bullets,” needless to say, do not “bark.” Okay, Jack, you’ll say, but these are metaphors. The trouble is that they’re terrible ones, even by the standards of pop lyrics; they take you nowhere and tell you nothing.

Let’s try once more, this time from “Don’t Think Twice It’s All Right”):

I didn’t say you treated me unkind

You could have done better but I don’t mind

You just kinda wasted my precious time

But don’t think twice, it’s all right.

No, I’m not going to say that “unkind” should be “unkindly,” or that “kinda wasted” should have been “simply wasted”; these lines are obviously meant to be demotic. Shakespeare did the same thing. But this isn’t Bottom the Weaver, where the colloquial is made into delightful buffoonery and contrasted with the styles of elevated speech. This is just clicheé wrapped in banality, however soulfully projected. Literature, it ain’t.

Dylan has had his learned defenders before, notably Christopher Ricks, who devoted a book to proving him a poet on a par with Keats or Yeats. The New York Times editorialized that Dylan’s selection was “a blessed relief” (from what?), and that his work “achieves greatness in its breadth and beauty.” And Joyce Carol Oates, the perennially disappointed Nobel candidate, calls the choice of Dylan “inspired,” adding only her opinion that Tthe Beatles may have been even more deserving. But no one’s likely to top the accolade of Sara Danius, the pPermanent sSecretary of the Swedish Academy, who in announcing the award, likened Dylan to Homer and Sappho. Well, who knew? Asked by a reporter whether she thought Dylan really deserved a Nobel, Ms. Danius snapped, “Of course he does. He just got it.”

That remark may not get a prize. But it sure takes the cake.

Actually, the award to Dylan can be better understood as another poke in the eye for Uncle Sam. The last American to win the literature prize was Toni Morrison in 1993, and members of the Academy have openly scoffed at the value of contemporary American writing. You may or may not think that DeLillo or Oates or Philip Roth are significant authors, but they have all accumulated a serious body of work. At the least, they do not write subliterate sentences.

Two important poets died within a day of each other this past summer, Geoffrey Hill and Yves Bonnefoy. Neither got within a mile of the Nobel Prize; they were far too distinguished for that, and their reputations are the more secure for it. But that persons of literary standing have jumped on the Dylan bandwagon shows that the joke has gone too far. Literature at the highest level is one of the most challenging forms of human thought. To travesty it mocks the very idea of culture. Given a world already drowning in kitsch, we can ill afford to erase the distinction between good and bad altogether.

I’ve got nothing against balladeers, and it is a truism that much great art is based in popular tradition. Villon sang for his supper too. But there is no such thing as literature without standards of value, and to compare the author of tThe “Iliad” and tThe “Odyssey” to the songwriter of “Blowin’ in the Wind” and “The Times They Are A-Changin’” . . . well, the rest really is silence.

One point more. Prizes can be more or less harmless in their place. But no prize ever added a syllable of value to a single sentence ever written, and when the award sets itself up above the work, it’s time to close shop.

Arrivederci, Nobel.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on It’s time to retire the Nobel Prize

Why Donald Trump deserves more credit

Flickr: Gage Skidmore

Flickr: Gage Skidmore

Don’t get me wrong. Donald Trump is the most irresponsible candidate ever to run for high office. It is beyond bizarre to imagine him heading a so-called major party ticket for the presidency. If he won, chaos would ensue from day one, if we even got that far. Worldwide markets would crash. Nuclear powers less than friendly to us would be on alert. The country would go on an immediate impeachment watch, and we’d all be praying that Vice President Mike Pence, the hack Governor of Indiana, would take the oath of office as quickly as possible without the need for the Pentagon to intervene.

So, what on earth do I mean by owing something to The Donald? Let us count his blessings.

Trump has done more than anyone else, even George W. Bush, to destroy the Republican Party — the gang that gives the idea of republican government a bad name. If the GOP started off as the antislavery party, or at least the one that took credit for the idea, it had evolved within a few decades into a front for Wall Street. Teddy Roosevelt was the last of its members to question whether savage capitalism was what the Founding Fathers had in mind in, as they say, forging a nation. That was over a hundred years ago, and T. R. was banished from the feast.

With the Wall Street Crash of 1929, the Republicans lost control of government for more than a third of a century, with the exception of the Eisenhower presidency. Ike, like Trump, was a Republican only by courtesy; the Democrats would gladly have run him on their own. What was called in those years “bipartisanship” was only the crumbs the Democrats left on the table to preserve the illusion of a two-party system. So-called liberal or moderate Republicans were allowed to participate on the condition that they embraced New Deal reforms and the new age of cooperation between capital and labor. But the sunny uplands of mid-century prosperity were based on the biggest bubble of all: America’s brief postwar dominance of the postwar world economy. When that waned, the gloves came off and the great squeeze-down of the middle class — mostly a misnomered working class briefly pampered with a living wage — began. Wall Street needed a party again, and the GOP happily reenlisted.

The Republicans got another huge break with the civil rights movement, which belatedly embraced by John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson, cost the Democrats their racist constituency in the South. Republicans now represented both Wall Street and what was politely called “nativism”. In the heady days of Ronald Reagan, the Republicans came close to squaring the political circle, passing themselves off as the representatives of capital and labor at the same time. This was what Mussolini and Hitler had done earlier in Europe, with the addition of the clerical element.

George W. Bush nearly wrecked the show, sleepwalking through 9/11, flailing out at Afghanistan and Iraq, and allowing Alan Greenspan to blow his bubbles at the Federal Reserve Board on the ruins of the Clinton-repealed Glass-Steagall Act. By 2008, Republican leaders were gloomily predicting a long season in the political wilderness such as they’d experienced under Franklin Roosevelt, if not worse. Intellectually and politically, their party felt bankrupt — and it was.

Then came the rescue. Barack Obama gifted Congress back to the Republican Party, allowing them control of the House of Representatives in 2010 and the Senate in 2014. But further signs of distress arrived with the Tea Party, a populist revolt on the right that made clear that a critical segment of the Party’s electoral base was alienated from it. Only forty-strong in the House, and still nominally within the Republican caucus, the Tea Party soon became the tail that wagged the party elephant, giving grief to corporate boardrooms used to the legislative discipline of the Bush years. The warning they represented went unheeded, however, and the party turned to the perfect establishment candidate, Mitt Romney, in 2012.

Enter the party of one, Donald Trump. Having made a lifelong study of suckers, Trump was able to see the body of Republican voters that was ripe for the plucking. This was the Rust Belt working class that, seduced by the dumb hope that the people with all the money were going to make new jobs to replace the ones they’d shipped abroad, had been voting Republican since the ’80s. What this group had failed to notice was that the plutocrats who were now to be their “saviors” had immiserated them to begin with — when not by off-shoring them by plundering still-viable companies of their assets to make a killing. Remember Romney, the self-proclaimed “job creator”? The racket he ran through the Bain Capital investment firm was precisely intended to cannibalize firms and then discard them.

The Tea Party showed that working-class Republicans were finally beginning to recognize the scam they’d fallen for. Trump presented himself to them as not only someone who was empathetic to them, who massaged their resentments, expressed their anger and validated their prejudices, but as one who could be trusted to deliver on his promises. Romney was a job-destroyer, but Trump could point to jobs he had actually created (at least in between serial bankruptcies) — you can’t run a boardwalk casino or build a hotel without actual, on-site American labor.

The result, and I think it will be a lasting one, was to peel off the Republican working class. It belongs to Trump now, and it will probably stick with him for a while if he is defeated, or until he flops on his face if elected. Trump has also made substantial inroads among the Evangelicals that Ted Cruz thought he owned (forgetting that people who worship on Sunday still need to work on weekdays), and they may not be brought back into the fold so easily either. In short, Trump has shattered the fragile electoral coalition that has returned Republicans to office starting with Nixon. Even his overt appeals to racism have been strokes of genius, politically speaking, because by openly exploiting prejudices Republicans courted in code, he has forced other GOP leaders to disavow their own most effective strategy for winning votes among the dispossessed. Trump is running against Hillary Clinton since July because she is the last obstacle on his path to the White House. His real campaign has been against the Republican Party, and he may have shattered it.

For this, we all owe him — temporarily at least — a heartfelt thanks. The Republican Party has simply been running interference for Wall Street for the past century, and has gotten the Democrats to follow suit. They are at present the sole clients of the American political system. If you want a conservative political party in America, go ahead and make one. Ditto if you want a liberal party. Right now, neither one exists, as Bernie Sanders’ unsuccessful run proved for the Democrats.

Trump has also laid waste to a number of other sacred cows, mostly related to our imperial posture in the world and its ruinous costs. He wondered out loud about the need for NATO and the new Cold War it has ginned up with Russia. He questioned the hypocritical monopoly of the nuclear arms club (nukes for me, but not for thee). Above all, he has lambasted the trade agreements that have destroyed America’s manufacturing base, wiped out millions of jobs, lives, and futures, and left us with a financialized economy that has no creed, just greed. All of this is heresy to both political parties.

For this, too, Trump deserves our thanks.

Unfortunately, though, the Donald’s only interest and concern is his own ego. He cares about nothing except himself. To be sure, such patent rascality has proved perversely entertaining in our funhouse political world. No one has been able to take their eyes off Trump for the past year. The problem, however, is that governing a country isn’t a vaudeville act.

So our train wreck of an election heads for its Hoboken Station, ready to slam into the platform, scatter the passengers, and pull down the pillars. And the only thing as improbable as turning over the Republic to Donald Trump, is turning to Hillary Rodham Clinton to save it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Why Donald Trump deserves more credit

The race between two deplorables

The presidential race between the two deplorables seems to be tightening by the day. Hillary Clinton can’t understand why.

The other day, she wondered aloud why she wasn’t beating Donald Trump by 50 points. A lot of people appalled by Trump are wondering why any candidate isn’t beating him by 50 points — as many Republicans feared would happen when they started jumping ship on The Donald (only to be asking now for tow ropes to be let back on). So, Hillary’s question is a good one, even if the mere fact of her asking it suggests the answer.

Let’s take Hillary’s number seriously, and see what it says — not about the American electorate, but about her.

If Hillary were in fact beating Trump in a two-person race, her majority would be 75 percent to 25 percent. But there are two other parties on the ballot, the Greens and the Libertarians, and their respective candidates have held pretty steady in the polls at about 10 percent. So, let’s take that off the top. That would leave the numbers between Clinton and Trump at 70 percent to 20 percent.

Who does Clinton think would actually vote for Trump? She’s already told us, in her now-infamous “basket of deplorables” comment. Half of Trump’s supporters, she said then, were “irredeemable” racists and bigots. They were voting for Trump because he was the perfect projection of their own hatemongering. Inferentially, they would probably vote for the devil too, because he’s your go-to guy if you’re beyond redemption.

At the time, Trump was polling roughly 40 percent of the national vote, give or take the usual margin of error. Half of that would be the 20 percent who would remain if Clinton were in fact beating Trump as she thinks she should be.

So, translation: Only a devil-worshipper would vote for Trump, and about a fifth of the American electorate falls into that category. Write ‘em off. They don’t belong in a decent democracy. They shouldn’t really be voting at all, and they should certainly never be allowed near any position of public responsibility. In short, they shouldn’t have citizenship.

So, Hillary will concede the “deplorables” to Trump, while making clear that her administration would have nothing to do with them. They would be the invisible deportees of the Republic, presumably held until we could find some country willing to take them.

You know, Donald Trump suggests only deporting 11 million undocumented immigrants, and he’s even willing to let some of them back. Hillary’s list would be 30 million to 40 million. Maybe they could settle Siberia.

What, though, about the other 20 percent of Trump supporters — the ones who should be voting for Hillary, and giving her that 70 percent majority she thinks she’s entitled to? Those folks, she allows, aren’t hopelessly bad, just deluded. And why is that? It’s hard to say, but maybe many of them have been on hard times for awhile, despite the great Obama recovery that has still left the job market 2.1 million short of where it was in 2007 and the proportion of the working age population employed at its lowest figure in decades. They shouldn’t actually be punished supporting Trump; in fact, they’ll even have a few crumbs tossed their way, a little day care for the kids and that $12 minimum wage Clinton doesn’t bother talking about anymore (perhaps because some municipalities have already raised it to $15). But then they’ll have to shape up for that second term Hillary’s advertising has already promised us.

So, in Hillary-world, two out of every five voters are either bad or stupid. There is another possibility, though, which she doesn’t appear to have contemplated. In fact, it is not only a possibility; it is the reality. Most voters (and, by definition, all non-voters) don’t want her to be president. That includes a substantial number of people who plan to vote for her anyway. A recent poll showed that Clinton was regarded as “trustworthy” — one would say the minimum qualification for any job — by fewer than one-third of all respondents. In other words, roughly a third of those who say they’ll vote for Hillary Clinton to be their president wouldn’t regard her as properly qualified to clean their homes or collect their trash.

Clinton is frequently urged by supporters to reintroduce herself to the public, to show her human empathy, to emphasize her commitment to public service. This, after a quarter century’s exposure — as first lady, senator, Secretary of State, and two-time presidential candidate — has made her the best-known and most scrutinized public figure in the country.

Just maybe, Hillary may have already introduced herself to us one time too many. Maybe we know her all too well.

There’s the Hillary who actively supported her husband’s policies on mass incarceration, purging the welfare rolls and giving the banks free rein to bankrupt the economy, before belatedly having second thoughts about them.

There’s the Hillary who was in favor of approving the Iraq War before she was against it, but not until a near-unanimous opinion declared it the greatest American foreign policy blunder in modern times. .

There’s the Hillary who was against gay marriage until she was for it.

There’s the Hillary who touted the now-infamous Trans-Pacific Partnership as the “gold standard” of all trade treaties, before she decided it was a bad deal after all.

The Hillary who can’t produce the somehow-deleted e-mails from the private server she falsely claimed having had permission to use, and the evidence they may or may not have contained about selling access to the State Department under her watch.

And then there’s the compassionate Hillary. You know, the one who helped delete a whole country, Libya, from the map, and then crowed Roman-emperor style to reporters, when its ruler was killed in the streets: “We came. We saw. He died.” Or the Hillary who responded to the assassination of our ambassador to Libya and members of his staff, when she felt she’d been grilled about her responsibility for it long enough, “What difference does it make? They’re dead, aren’t they?”

That’s probably enough Hillary for most of us. But there’s another, more delicate subject that people prefer to trip around. It’s the Clinton marriage. A wife, even a first lady, who turns a blind eye to her husband’s philandering is exercising a private right, and Hillary Clinton would hardly have been the first first lady in such a predicament. No previous first lady, however, and perhaps no one in American history, has been exposed to such prolonged and public humiliation as Hillary Clinton was by the Monica Lewinsky scandal. At the time, I thought she could have struck a resounding blow for feminism by walking away from Bill Clinton, and given women everywhere an example of pride and independence. But Clinton, Inc. wasn’t going to junk its plan for a double presidency and a political dynasty. Whatever her private feelings, Clinton sublimated them into a quest for power already declared before her husband left office. She has let nothing stand in her way since, including her biggest obstacle (besides her own resumeé), Bill himself.

Do we want that particular power couple back in the White House? Couldn’t we just have the Sopranos instead? Or the Macbeths?

The problem, of course, is that the actual alternative is the Trumps. But that does not excuse the Democratic Party for having nominated Hillary Clinton; rather, it only makes its choice the more, well, deplorable. And, faced with the candidates the parties have delivered, the long-overdue question is, is this system working? Or, more accurately, for whom is it working? For this is not an election cycle that has simply produced two singularly unpalatable choices. It is a system that effectively freezes the wishes and will of the vast majority of the population out — the majority that wants a health care system that doesn’t bankrupt its users, an educational system that doesn’t lay students under a cross of debt, an economic system that doesn’t dump workers on the garbage pile, an environment one can hope to live in, and, in general, a future worth having. Other countries, far from perfect, have long since solved these problems, or at least seriously addressed them. Ours, year after year, election after election, does not.

Unions, when they existed, used to bring collective bargaining power to the table to win the working conditions they sought. We all belong to a single great Union, though: it’s called the United States. Suppose voters did what organized workers used to do when presented with a lousy contract? Suppose they just went on strike, and demanded to renegotiate the whole compact?

The results might be interesting. And we could start, I think, by getting rid of the two sham parties that have come to monopolize our political process, and denied us a government of the people.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The race between two deplorables

What should we do about an “election from hell”?

Recently, I received an invitation to participate in a discussion about the election this week at Drexel. The objective was to consider the candidates and the issues, and to urge Drexel students to vote.

I replied that I would be happy to offer an opinion about the election, but that I could not encourage anyone to vote. I didn’t hear anything further from the sponsors, so I have decided to express myself here.

The phrase “election from hell” was coined by the ‘New York Times’ columnist Charles M. Blow in an op-ed column last May, when the primaries were still in progress and the major parties two months away from officially selecting their candidates. But it was clear enough that, barring an act of God or an access of sanity, the Democrats would nominate Hillary Rodham Clinton, and the Republicans Donald J. Trump. God did not choose to intervene. Hell has gotten a lot hotter since May.

We have had elections before where the candidates aroused no enthusiasm, or even unease and distaste. But we have never had one before in which both major party candidates were actively distrusted or even detested by a clear majority of the electorate. It’s hardly cause for wonder, then, that this election season has been so much about hate. To begin with, the candidates themselves are hated.

At first blush, this is perplexing. We have primaries so that the voters of each party can pick the candidates they prefer. How, then, did the electorate come to be confronted — to confront itself — with the choices it liked least, and, for the majority, not at all?

The answer to this question, that of candidate selection, is complex, but the particular circumstances of this election can be described briefly. What we’ve witnessed in 2016 is a populist revolt on both the left and the right against the parties themselves and the policies they represent. Republican voters rejected 16 establishment candidates (well, Ben Carson was in a world of his own) in favor of an insurgent who had only recently registered with their party, and who denounced it for having betrayed their interests. Democratic voters nearly chose a lifelong political independent who had never belonged to their party at all, and who likewise espoused a program—universal health insurance, tuition-free higher education, and urgent attention to climate change—that was anathema to party leaders. Bernie Sanders might well have been the Democratic nominee (and Donald Trump not the Republican one) had independent voters, who constitute 42 percent of the electorate, been permitted to vote in the primaries, but they were excluded from most of them. When nearly half the electorate is accorded no guaranteed role in the choice of presidential candidates, it’s scarce wonder that people are apt to be dissatisfied with the results.

One can give establishment Republicans, this much credit, that they have been with few exceptions appalled by the hostile takeover of their party. It almost certainly wouldn’t have happened had not the plethora of candidates in their contest not enabled Trump to win many early primaries with a relatively low percentage of the vote. Still, they did deserve him. The Republicans created an electoral base by conning working class voters and Evangelicals into believing they represented them, and when Trump disabused them at long last, he rode the tidal wave of their anger to the nomination, and, if he can rile enough people up, he might just ride it to the White House too.

It is less easy to forgive the Democrats. Donald Trump is a mountebank — if the term is unfamiliar, please look it up, because it precisely describes him. To say that he is unqualified in every respect for public office is to grossly understate the case. That’s not necessarily a disqualifier for Republicans — think George W. Bush, think Sarah Palin — but he is in addition a complete rogue, and rogue elephants are not the kind Republicans like to breed. So, having survived the Bush years thanks to the healing ministrations of Barack Obama, who gave them back both houses of Congress, they now face a serious implosion. If Trump should win, he will not court Republicans; they will bend the knee to him. (You think Vladimir Putin kept John Kerry cooling his heels on his last state visit to Moscow? Wait to see how long Paul Ryan waits on Donald Trump.) The party could divide; it could even perish. It wouldn’t be missed. Trump has already taken its base with him.

The Democrats, in contrast, were offered the best candidate they’d put up in decades, a genuine progressive, unbeholden to elites and substantively addressing issues of popular concern: our broken health care and education systems, our crumbling national infrastructure, the disgrace of deep poverty and the obscenity of unaccountable wealth. Here was a rumpled, elderly figure without graces of speech or manner, self-exiled at the margins of the political scene for thirty years, but capable, simply through the force of his convictions and his evident personal rectitude, of doing what no one else had done for decades: of arousing the young, and giving a generation being schooled to give up on itself the sense of a future worth fighting for.

The Democrats could never have produced such a figure by themselves, so, naturally, they had to figure out a way to stop him.

I never got starry-eyed over Bernie Sanders. He is a moderate social democrat, and the reforms he was touting had been taken for granted for decades in Europe. Some of them had already existed in America. Tuition-free public higher education? Hey, I had it when I was going through college in New York, and so did everyone else; it was taken for granted. Universal, single-payer health care? It was on the platform of the Democratic Party in 1948, and in that same year, the British, still on wartime rationing and dependent on Marshall Plan aid, gave it to themselves. Sixteen years into the 21st century, it might fairly be said that Bernie Sanders was just trying to bring America abreast of the 20th.

Nor did (or do) I agree with Sanders about every public issue, or every question of value. I was troubled, too, by the conventionality of his thinking about foreign affairs, and his failure to address the toxic legacy of our imperial posture in the world. But he was something I hadn’t seen in a long time, and had almost given up on: a candidate of hope.

So, the Democrats turned instead, with as close to unanimity as any Stalinist Politburo, to the very embodiment of a broken and corrupted system, a figure already rejected eight years earlier by the voters of her own party, the anti-change, anti-hope candidate: Hillary Clinton. How’s that, folks, for a thumb in your eye?

Barack Obama, of whom the best that can be said is that he has wasted eight years of our political history, has repeatedly declared Hillary Clinton to be “the best-qualified person” ever to seek the American presidency. Leaving aside Washington, Jefferson, and Lincoln, let’s examine the claim.

Clinton began her independent political career with an attempt to overhaul the American health care system, a task delegated her by her husband. She failed, so completely that the opposition party took control of the Congress essentially on that issue. Thereafter she had no public role, but she did support her the initiatives that made Bill Clinton’s presidency the most retrograde Democratic administration in American history: job-killing NAFTA; a crime bill that raised America’s incarceration rate to the highest in the world; a welfare “reform” bill that threw a million kids into poverty; and, for the coup de grace, the repeal of the Glass-Steagall wall between commercial and investment banking that greased the skids for the worst depression since the 1930s.

Clinton got into the U.S. Senate on the coattails of Al Gore, who substantially outpolled her in New York in his own failed pursuit of the presidency, and was reelected in the Democratic Congressional landslide of 2006. In her Senate years, she made not a single speech anyone could remember except the one supporting war with Iraq, by general consensus the worst American foreign policy disaster of modern times. Her name appears as a sponsor on only three public bills, all local services for constituents. They included one that renamed a post office.

Eight years in her only elected position. She renamed a post office.

Clinton ran for the presidency on this stellar record in 2008, and with a near-monopoly of party endorsements and donors, all seemed poised for the restoration that would complete the family narrative the Clintons had schooled us to regard as our own national destiny: first Bill, then Hillary, the first husband and wife presidential duo in history (“Two for the price of one,” as Bill had breezily promised us at his own inauguration). But a jug-eared junior senator from Illinois came, seemingly from nowhere, to spoil the plot and steal the office. Hillary settled for secretary of state, Obama’s concession to the Clintons’ vengeful fury and the price of their support. In this job, she managed to wipe a rather large state, Libya, off the map, leaving a warlords’ paradise and a de facto North African capital for the Islamic Caliphate. When Muammar Gaddafi, who had held the country together, was hunted down and spitted like a dog in the street, Hillary crowed, “We came, we saw, he died.” When Chris Stevens, our ambassador to Libya, was then murdered with his aides in Benghazi, she told a Senate panel she felt had grilled her too long on the subject, “What difference does it make? They’re dead.”

Your perfect presidential resume. You’ll notice I haven’t mentioned the e-mails, or the sordid commerce in State Department access for contributions to the Clinton Foundation — foreign policy for sale. Best qualified for the country’s highest office? How about least: or, if you’re considering the alternative, perhaps second least.

Paul Krugman, Noam Chomsky and even Bernie Sanders tell me I must vote for Hillary Clinton lest Donald Trump become president. They tell me it is my duty. But my vote isn’t a duty, it’s my right as a citizen, and a right is something one freely chooses to exercise according to judgment and conscience. My judgment tells me that Hillary Clinton is incompetent and corrupt. My conscience tells me that I cannot accept even a particle of responsibility for putting Bonnie and Clyde back in the White House.

Come November, one of two terrible candidates will become the next president-elect. Don’t blame me for the result, or yourselves. But, if you’re as offended by them as I am, do something about the political system that produced them, and the parties that anointed them. That sounds a lot closer to the common duty we owe our democracy.

Wikipedia: Furfur

Wikipedia: Furfur

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on What should we do about an “election from hell”?

Democracy at the Nadir

Wikimedia: Gage Skidmore

Wikimedia: Gage Skidmore

Democracy, as practiced in ancient Athens, consisted of direct citizen participation in government through collective membership in a single, sovereign assembly, which united all three functions of government: executive, legislative and judicial. A similar combination of powers was tried in the revolutionary France of the 1790s, where a committee of the assembly, the Twelve, carried out executive functions. Of course, the French legislature was an elected one, given the size of France and more or less organized factions soon developed in it. Nor did it fare particularly well, since, beset by foreign invasion and domestic resistance, it issued in the Terror that sent thousands of French citizens to the guillotine.

The Roman Republic, a longer-lived experiment, recognized the reality of class division by providing for separate, though coordinate, legislative bodies, the aristocratic Senate and the popular Plebeian Assembly. Executive functions were assigned to two consuls, one from each constituency. In practice, the Senate predominated, but the Plebeian Assembly was an at least marginal check on it. Rome’s imperial success ultimately did the Republic in, a fate that in somewhat different form appears likely to be that of the United States as well. This would not have surprised our Founding Fathers, who did not expect permanence from any political institutions, including the one they set up.

The alternative model for a democratic polity was the party system, which developed out of the factional groupings in Britain’s Parliament and which hearkened back in part to the Greek model through an executive based on the system of ministerial responsibility, in which the majority party of the House of Commons also formed the executive, with the supreme judicial function resting in the unelected House of Lords. In the United States, the judiciary evolved as a separate branch, tied to established law by the rule of precedent, but in practice often going its own way — i.e., responding to powerful political interests and, very occasionally, to populist pressure. The U.S. also put in place a presidential system, formally separating the executive and legislative functions although requiring them to cooperate in the passage of statutes.

Modern party systems come in two versions. In the first, characteristic of mature polities, the system is dominated by two large parties which alternate in power. In the second, multiparty systems make it a rare occurrence for any single party to gain a legislative majority, requiring coalition governments formed through political bargaining and power-sharing.

The tendency of two-party systems is toward ideological convergence, their official rhetoric notwithstanding. This has been the case in the United States, where only major issues or crises — the question of slavery, or the response to the Great Depression — seriously divides the parties. There was a substantial convergence between the Conservative and Liberal parties in Great Britain during the 19th century, as there is today between Conservatives and Labour. Rhetorically, the parties appeal to what they define as broad national interests, although they also cultivate regional and class constituencies. Thus, until, the 1960s, the Democratic Party assumed the role of protecting the Jim Crow regime in the South, whose racist remnants have since then been sponsored by Republicans.

The interests that two party-systems represent most faithfully, however, are those of established elites. As those elites concentrate wealth and power, their care and feeding become the almost exclusive preoccupation of the parties. Eugene Debs, the perennial Socialist candidate for president, observed a hundred years ago that Democrats and Republicans were merely different wings of a single party that serviced a radically inegalitarian capitalism.

His observation was true when he made it. It is equally true today, at a moment of systemic crisis. The concentration of wealth and hence of power, has rarely, if ever, been as great as it is today, not only in the United States but around the world. In the U.S., 62 Americans have as much wealth as 150 million of their fellow citizens combined. The top 1 percent of the population have as much wealth as the bottom 90 percent. This is politically, socially, economically and morally dysfunctional and, to the very large extent that it represents the conscious theft of the fruits of labor, backed by unjust laws and the police powers resting on a vast penal system and force administered directly in the streets, it is wicked.

A popular rebellion against this situation has been building for some time. Its manifestations have been various, from the short-lived Occupy movement of 2011 to the recent Brexit vote in Britain and the ongoing strikes and demonstrations in France against a nominally “Socialist” government that has aligned itself with austerity policies and is trying to pass a bill eroding worker rights and protections by parliamentary maneuver. The rebellion has encompassed both the left and the right wings of the electoral spectrum, as seen in the mass support both for Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders in our own presidential campaign. This year, as it seemed for awhile, the plutocratic “center” would not hold.

As it happens, though, it appears that it will do just fine.

Donald Trump, the clown Mussolini, has hijacked what remained of the post-George W. Bush Republican Party, resuscitated through the joint efforts of Barack Obama and John Roberts. Poised a year ago to return the Bush dynasty or some surrogate to the White House, the Republicans were flummoxed by the revolt of their base, tutored over the past forty-some years to vote reliably against its own interest. The Democrats, serenely confident in their own corporate-vetted candidate, Hillary Clinton, meanwhile looked to yawn their way through a perfunctory primary process on the way to reinstating their own dynasty, its rejection in 2008 by their voters in favor of a jug-eared junior senator with a name that rhymed with the world’s most wanted terrorist notwithstanding. From deep in the political wilderness, a rumpled, 74-year-old backbencher, previously unaffiliated with the Party, put together an insurgent candidacy that very nearly sent Hillary home to her knitting.

Had Bernie Sanders won the Democratic nomination — it was oh so near but at the same time oh so far, with Hillary’s superdelegates always in reserve to negate the popular vote — the Wall Street Party of Demopublicans would have been left without a single reliable candidate to run the political show. No doubt it would have muddled through — Sanders was a middling reformer at best by European social democratic standards and Trump, for all his theatrics, was a businessman — but to have a race between a largely self-funded candidate who lived off free media and a self-proclaimed socialist who disdained all corporate financing competing for the presidency would have been a most palpable hit at the bought-and-paid for kleptocracy enshrined by the Supreme Court in its notorious Citizens United decision.

Sorry: not to be. It’s Trump versus Clinton. The 2016 presidential election will be between two of the most disliked, distrusted and plain-out despised candidates ever presented to a voting public: a race to the bottom in every sense of the word.

Apart from a few has-beens ostentatiously trying to burnish their resumes for history, Republicans have trooped in behind Trump. The betting is that, in office, the clueless casino magnate will have to rely on seasoned and reliable professionals to pursue any sort of an agenda, let alone fend off impeachment or military revolt. And then there are the politicians who put Hitler into power in 1933, with every confidence they could control the guy’s wild streak. No, Trump isn’t a Hitler, not even a Mussolini. But those who think he’ll docilely take orders from his Dick Cheney don’t know the first thing about him.

Karl Rove, writing in The Wall Street Journal, thinks the Democrats have bigger problems than the Republicans. He may have a point. Republicans have sunk about as far as a political party can go over the past 15 years, even as a sham operation. But Democrats are the ones who have been losing market share for the past several decades. The Republicans have essentially been a minority party since the New Deal, with no more than a quarter to a third of the electorate identifying itself with them. The Democrats were for most of this period a consistent 20 points above them in terms of voter affiliation. That advantage has now been virtually erased. Only 29 percent of polled voters now regard themselves as Democrats, while self-described Republicans are within a poller’s margin of error at 26 percent. The rest of the country — 42 percent — describes itself as independent, i.e., alienated. In a two-party system, nearly half the electorate is thus saying, a plague on both your houses. This is a formula for a multiparty system, or maybe just a breakdown of the system entirely.

The Republicans will have a wake at their convention in Cleveland, but the Democrats will have a brawl in Philadelphia. Another candidate with Clinton’s profile might be simply a disappointment, as John Kerry was the disappointment of Howard Dean’s candidacy in 2004. But Hillary Clinton has always been a remarkably polarizing figure and with the baggage of her husband’s administration behind her — and maybe out in front too, since Bill seems to be Donald Trump’s secret weapon in this campaign — the paddy wagons are already being prepared for protesters in and out of the Convention Center. More and more Republicans and top Wall Street executives, on the other hand, say they are perfectly prepared to accept and even vote for her. With friends like that, the Democrats will hardly lack for enemies in the fall — and the party for reasons to split.

Ben Franklin hedged his bets when he described the product of the constitutional convention of 1787 as “a republic, if you can keep it.” The Founding Fathers knew a thing or two about rough-and-tumble politics. But Trump and Clinton? No electorate ever deserved that. None before, in America, has yet seen it.

The post Democracy at the Nadir appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Democracy at the Nadir

Thinking about how Donald Trump made it

Flickr: Gage Skidmore

Flickr: Gage Skidmore

Andrew Sullivan, writing in the current issue of New York Magazine, calls the possibility of a Donald Trump presidency “an extinction-level event,” the life-form under threat being American democracy. That’s a pretty severe threat level for a species that’s been around, for better or worse, for more than two and a quarter centuries, and which has been the model for every other democracy on the planet. It’s a question that deserves to be considered, because the idea of a Trump presidency is in fact gaining credibility, and even respectability, by the day.  

How did Trump get this far, as the only major party candidate other than Wendell Wilkie to have been neither a professional politician nor a military hero? Wilkie, of course, ran as the liberal Republican alternative to Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1940. He waged a sporting campaign, and supported Roosevelt’s war effort before and after Pearl Harbor. In short, he was, by his lights, a gentleman and a patriot. No one would accuse Trump of being a gentleman, and if by a patriot you mean someone with a decent respect for his fellow countrymen, their traditions, and the Constitution, you don’t mean the Donald either.

Of course, we’ve had racists, demagogues, and crackpots run for president, and draw votes, too:  Strom Thurmond in 1948, George Wallace in 1968, Ross Perot in 1992. None of them have ever made it to the top of a Republican or Democratic ticket before though: and Trump is more than a little of all three. We’ve also had, in recent years, a remarkable dumbing-down of our candidates for public office. Remember Sarah Palin, now a Trump enthusiast? And how about Ben Carson on a presidential debating stage, with his quaint theories about who built the pyramids? One good reason for the ascent of Trump was the quality of the hucksters opposing him. When it came down in the end to Ted (“Lucifer in the Flesh”) Cruz — the most hated man in the Senate against the most hated casino operator in Atlantic City — the blackjack table won after all.  And, as for the Democrats, after a due canvass of the available talent, whom do they come up with but the most viscerally despised woman in American politics?

We are getting Trump, in short, in good part because of the level of the competition.

Some of this has to do with the leveling, reality TV quality of our political culture. It’s been several decades now since we started electing show people to high office, notably Ronald Reagan. Trump, when he flies in for a rally, lands his plane to the theme of “Air Force One”, the film where Harrison Ford plays the president. And what got Hillary the only juice of her campaign was sitting down to dinner with George Clooney.

It’s always been the fashion to laugh at politicians, and that is generally a good thing, particularly in a democracy. It’s the only profession, in fact, whose participants sit down annually to laugh at themselves. But the thralldom of both major parties to Wall Street, and the new Gilded Age they have abetted and enabled, is no laughing matter. In Italy some years ago, a prostitute was elected to the national assembly. If you ask most people, Congress consists of nothing but prostitutes. It would be a difficult thesis to disprove.

The result of this perception is that most politicians campaign now as anti-politicians, or, to use the term of art, outsiders. They don’t fool anyone, and they haven’t since Richard Nixon told the country that he wasn’t a crook, but what choice do you have when your approval rating hovers around 10%? Tax collectors aren’t loved. Nor are Robo-callers who interrupt you at dinner. But no one is more genuinely and heartfully despised than a politician.

That, too, explains Trump. He’s sniffed around politicians for a long time, but he clearly isn’t one of them. He says whatever comes into his head whenever it strikes him to. He changes his tune from day to day on every subject under the sun, and gets credit for candor. He publicly admires people we’ve officially labeled tyrants, such as Vladimir Putin, and wins votes when he does it. Putin, after all, doesn’t have to worry about his legislature. What Trump is telling us is that he doesn’t intend to worry about his, either. Try, if you like, to imagine a Ted Cruz shutting down the government on a President Trump. There’d be martial law, and a padlock on the Capitol Building.

The country is ready for Trump because, one way or another, he promises to get things done. Just what things they are no one can be quite sure, but they’d be interesting, and most people think they’d be a little different. We know that as of now nothing at all gets done except at the behest of the plutocratic elite we’ve taken to calling, with fair statistical accuracy, the 1%. Why should things be any different under Trump, a certified member of that class? Because the Donald is always different, from day to day. And one of these days might—who can tell?—just be your day for a change.

Whereas the only day Barack Obama ever offers you is a Monday.  And Hillary Clinton promises more of the same. She’d keep her word, too.    

Barack Obama’s presidency has been a study. Politicians lie, but he is the only one whose compass is true south: whatever he says, you know he means the opposite. When he says we’re going to get a handle on climate control, you know he’s about to announce oil drilling in the Atlantic, or the Arctic, or the lunar Sea of Tranquillity. When he says we’re going to get out of a country we’ve been bombing for a decade, you know we’re loading the next rack. When he says we’ve got to be humane in our treatment of undocumented workers, you know we’re about to ship some more children back to hell.

Trump is refreshing because what he says is so outrageous that you know he can’t mean it in the first place — or can you? In a political world that consists of nothing but slickly packaged lies, the unpredictable will at least keep you tuned on the Leader. Which is, come to think of it, the very definition of tyranny: a world without certainty because it is a world without rules.

So, would a Donald Trump presidency qualify as an extinction-level event for our democracy? It would likely be a constitutional crisis from Day One. What else, though, have we got on our hands already? Mr. Sullivan thinks that what he calls “late democracy” is characterized by the retreat of educated elites, the vulgarization of politics as entertainment, and bizarre demands for egalitarianism in all walks of life regardless of effort or achievement. All of these things, it is true, have occurred, but what lies behind them is an age of radical inegalitarianism, the looming destruction of work, and the rise of a technofascism that, worshipped in the educational curriculum as STEM, has hollowed out citizenship and left a culturally illiterate population at the mercy of giant corporations and their political servants. At least, in Donald Trump, we can see the face of the beast, and in his very crudity and vulgarity the reassuring sign of some humanity, however debased.

Sullivan ends his essay by calling for the good old Republican establishment to turn its back on Trump, find another candidate, and save its soul even at the cost of an election. Too late. The Republicans, after a brief start of horror at finding Trump their nominee, have climbed on his bandwagon, and the Republican electorate has followed suit. That’s because he has provided the Party bosses assurance lately that he will give them their jollies, starting with a Supreme Court reactionary to replace Antonin Scalia, and because they smell in him not a disaster but a winner.  

Hillary Clinton, meanwhile, looks more and more like a loser. She has nothing to offer but more of Obama, which is what got us Trump in the first place. Meanwhile, the Democratic Party establishment is absolutely determined to reject the one candidate who consistently outpolls Trump. But the Democrats have been losers for a long time now.     

The post Thinking about how Donald Trump made it appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Thinking about how Donald Trump made it

A Clinton Sanders ticket

Youtube: corbettreport

Youtube: corbettreport

Bernie Sanders never got the time of day from day one.  Too old; too Jewish; representing too small a state; a loner who hadn’t even registered as a Democrat before he decided to run for the party’s presidential nomination. Above all, just plain broke — perhaps not even a millionaire, let alone a billionaire — in a blood sport, politics, where the coin of the realm is the ticket of entry. When Sanders said he’d raise his own money from small donors and refuse any from PACs, bundlers, and corporations, he was simply dismissed as a harmless gent who’d wandered off the grounds of the retirement home.

It wasn’t until large and enthusiastic crowds started following him around—and ponying up some serious dough—that the media started paying Sanders slight and reluctant attention. There’s never been a day when it has entertained the possibility that he could actually win the Democratic nomination. Even the Democratic Party establishment, which treated him as the butler might an unkempt intruder at a lawn party — and rigged the nomination rules entirely against him — was fairer than the media.  Party rules say that unelected superdelegates — those loyal hacks and dogcatchers who represent its insurance against any insurgent candidacy — may not be counted in any tabulation of pledged delegates selected in the primary process because, well, the whole idea is that they aren’t pledged.  That, though, is what the media has routinely been doing. The fact is, that with fewer than 55 percent of pledged voters, Hillary Clinton will probably fall a couple of hundred votes short of the Convention majority she needs for the nomination. Instead, though, we’re regularly told she’s more than 90 percent of the way home. It’s patently untrue, mathematically obvious that it’s untrue, but the media keeps squawking it anyway. Give up, Bernie, and just go home. So what if you keep winning primaries and attracting the crowds Hillary would die for. You think we’re letting anyone slip through the gates that Comcast and Disney — not to mention Goldman Sachs — can’t control?

The story of the 2016 elections so far is that the Republican establishment failed to keep their own intruder, the unlikely Donald Trump, from crashing the party and making off with the raffle, but the Democrats appear likely to succeed in doing so. Hillary Clinton may have been the worst candidate they could have found, but, hey, the Party machine spewed her out — twice. Barack Obama may have saved us from her eight years ago (but only at the cost of himself); Bernie Sanders could be doing it today, but, unlike Barack, Bernie isn’t Wall Street-vetted, and that’s an end to that.

Clinton will need Sanders in the fall, though, and the question is what price he can or should exact for his help. Bernie has said he will support the ticket and work to deny the Republicans the White House, but there’s working and working. He can make a pro forma endorsement, deliver a speech or two, and otherwise sit the campaign out on his porch. He’d be entitled to:  he owes the Democrats nothing, and maybe the Clintons even less after Bill’s famous comment that Bernie’s idea of reforming Wall Street was to shoot every third banker. (And why wasn’t that at least as big a Hillary-killer as his remark in South Carolina eight years ago that Barack Obama was telling “the biggest fairy-tale I ever heard?”  Ah, but the media amplifies what it wants to, and muffles what it wants put to sleep. Ask Howard Dean, whose campaign in 2004 got deep-sixed by a harmless war whoop a couple of days after he suggested that media conglomerates might be broken up.)  

Right now, it appears that Sanders will try to extract his pound of flesh in the form having his pledged votes counted on the Convention floor and trying to nail a couple of progressive planks into the Party platform. It may make him and his supporters feel that their whole campaign hadn’t just been a mirage, but the practical effect will be zero. There is only one thing Sanders can do to project the progressive debate into the fall election, and give it a purchase in a Democratic administration. That is to demand a spot on the ticket as the price of actively campaigning with—and for—Clinton.

Vice presidents are usually chosen to balance a ticket, not tilt it, and it is already obvious that, having been pushed to the left thus far by Sanders, Clinton now plans to pivot right to attract disaffected Republican voters. If she does poorly in the remaining primaries, however, her Democratic base may look vulnerable. Given the likely disarray of the Republican convention, moreover, she will wish to project the image of a party united around her, and fractious support for Sanders in Philadelphia will dilute if not erase an important part of her campaign strategy. In short, even if Bernie were not to play the spoiler directly, he still has cards in his hand.

The question is what he could gain for himself as part of a unity ticket with Clinton, and where that would leave the movement that, either within or outside the Democratic tent, he has made it clear he wants to keep going — and leading. Let’s look at the potential benefits and costs.

The vice presidency, as a former occupant of the office once put it, is not worth a bucket of warm spit. The job, as traditionally defined, is to be the President’s loyal surrogate and supporter. Joe Biden has played this role for the past eight years. We presume he’s won some battles inside the White House; we know he’s lost some. But, until very recently, there has never been any public distance between him and Obama, and some of that has no doubt stemmed from Obama’s coolness to the idea of Joe as his successor. On the other hand, Biden’s predecessor, Dick Cheney, was so powerful a figure that his notional boss, George W. Bush, was widely regarded as his puppet — an impression that, at least for the first five years of the Bush administration, was essentially true.

Clinton is unlikely to be bullied by a Vice President Sanders, and, if Sanders were to take an independent line, he would probably be frozen out of policy discussions. That, however, wouldn’t necessarily be a bad idea. The vice presidency is a constitutional enigma; it is second in line in executive authority, but it has few defined functions and no enumerated powers. But it is also separately designated on the national ballot, so that one does not vote for a president with a vice president, but for a president and a vice president. This means that, constitutionally, the vice president is an independent figure. Thomas Jefferson, as vice president, was a bitter political enemy of President John Adams, and they opposed each other for the presidency in 1800 in a campaign of singular nastiness. Sanders wouldn’t need to go that far to stake out his own position and keep a progressive agenda in front of the American public. The fact of his public position as one of only two constitutional officers elected by the entire people would give him a unique platform; he would be, in effect, a kind of tribune, representing an at least substantial portion of the population. Perhaps most importantly, he would represent, for the first time in at least 50 years, a progressive in national office. Of course, the idea is to get such a figure into the top job, but, failing that, the vice presidency could be an important stepping-stone to the Oval Office.

To assert one’s own independence while not appearing to undermine the administration of which one was nominally part would be an artful political act indeed. Some would, no doubt, accuse Sanders of selling Mrs. Clinton out; some would accuse him of selling himself out. Without Sanders, though, Clinton will certainly either pick an anodyne running mate, or someone — an Elizabeth Warren, a Sherrod Brown — she felt confident of being able to neuter politically.  The progressive left, having misplaced its bets on Barack Obama in 2008 and demonstrated the futility of a protest movement disengaged from the political process in the Occupy movement, would spend four more years in the wilderness. Sometimes the wilderness is the right place to be, but, after two false starts, it’s time for progressives to show some concrete result for their efforts.  

The question, assuming that Sanders would be interested in joining Clinton to begin with and that Clinton herself would feel the need of a unity ticket strongly enough to accept him, is whether Sanders would not lose so much credibility with the supporters who have enabled his campaign thus far that whatever he might say or do would be fatally compromised. For sure, it would be a gamble. And, from a genuinely progressive point of view, the question would be whether anyone on the left could ever be forgiven for putting Hillary Clinton in the White House. But that would be another question.

Of course, in this season of surprises anything is still possible, and the last primaries could show a Clinton so vulnerable that the superdelegates might panic and try to parachute Joe Biden in, or even turn to Sanders himself. One thing’s for sure:  anyone who thinks Donald Trump’s a pushover in November is in for the biggest surprise of all.

The post A Clinton Sanders ticket appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A Clinton Sanders ticket

Political party suicide

Wikipedia: Gage Skidmore

Wikipedia: Gage Skidmore

The major party nominees for president in the current election seem set. Donald Trump will now likely amass the 1,237 delegate votes he needs to become the official Republican nominee, no other candidates remaining active in the race. Bernie Sanders continues to run doggedly against Hillary Clinton and will likely leave her short of the 2,383 elected delegate votes she needs at the Democratic convention. But Hillary will, barring an unforeseen collapse or a Justice Department indictment over her e-mailer server, come to the convention with a plurality of such delegates, and with the vast majority of the Party’s 712 unelected superdelegates committed to her.

According to polls, this is a prospect that nauseates a majority of the electorate whose votes have made it possible.

Donald Trump is disliked/distrusted/openly loathed by about 65% of likely general election voters. The same view is held of Hillary Clinton by some 56% of the electorate. This is different from the customary indifference with which voters contemplate their presidential choices. In 1976, Jimmy Carter ran against Gerald Ford. So far as I am aware, no one ever hated Gerald Ford and a fair number of Americans were grateful to him for not being Richard Nixon. No one had ever heard of Jimmy Carter. The contest between George H. W. Bush and Michael Dukakis in 1988 elicited a giant yawn. The same was true of that between George W. Bush and Al Gore in 2000, although plenty of people would soon regret their indifference.

Perhaps this is the way it should be, since democracies regularly produce mediocrities for political office, a point observed in the 1830s by Alexis de Tocqueville. Considering the vast powers for harm now concentrated in the American presidency, perhaps it is not the worst outcome that we need seldom fear electing someone with the imagination and intelligence to use them. The balance of powers so artfully constructed for us by the Founding Fathers has long since broken down. It is chiefly stupidity and ineptitude that save us. Consider where we might be now had George W. Bush not been so stupid, or Barack Obama so inept. Consider Richard Nixon, who was neither stupid nor inept, and had a wide streak of evil. People still shudder at the Nixon presidency, and with good reason.

In 2016, people are doing a lot of worrying about Donald Trump. Thinking of Hillary Clinton does not necessarily make them feel better. It is one thing to choose between mediocrities, or even  the lesser of two evils. It is another to choose between candidates who inspire active repugnance. The common wisdom is that Hillary wins this race because she scares people less, and that when she gets the nuclear black box she is less likely than Trump to mistake it for a Christmas toy. I’m not buying that assumption, though. Voters are angry this year, and if there was ever a candidate on the American scene who knows how to not merely elicit fear and anger but to channel it, it is Donald Trump.

No single group in America is more terrified at the prospect of nominating Trump than those who are about to do it, namely the leaders and functionaries of the Republican Party. The real story of the 2016 election thus far is the revolt of the Republican base—a hybrid collection of the disgruntled and the disaffected, put together Frankenstein-style in the 1970s and 1980s by clever (and, even by American standards) cynical operatives—against the Party establishment. (A similar revolt has taken place among Democrats, but chiefly involving the disenfranchised young and, to this point, falling short of success.) The two living past Republican presidents, Bush père et fils, have both announced they will not attend the Party convention, not that they will be missed. The Party’s immediate past presidential candidate, Mitt Romney, openly denounces Trump. His running mate, the now-Speaker of the House of Representatives, Paul Ryan, has withheld his endorsement, at least for the moment. Ryan has challenged Trump to prove that he is actually a Republican, which of course he is not, except opportunistically. Oh, yes, he does favor tax cuts for the rich, deporting Mexican workers, and bloating the Pentagon to the size of a Thanksgiving parade balloon—all good talking points on the Romney-Ryan campaign trail four years ago—but he also favors gay rights, détente with the Russians, and job protection for what’s left of the middle class. What kind of Republican is that?   

Which brings us to the Republican Party’s golden opportunity this year.

There has been much talk in recent months of anti-Trump Republicans deserting the official Party nominee and backing a third candidate. Last fall and winter, Michael Bloomberg, the billionaire former mayor of New York, offered himself as a national savior on an independent ticket. Bloomberg withdrew when it appeared that only his wife, his dog, and a couple of newspaper pundits took him up on the offer, but that was when there still seemed a chance of stopping Trump’s march to the Republican nomination.  

Trump and Bloomberg actually have a good deal in common. They are both billionaires and both narcissists of the first water. Both have long regarded themselves as indispensable to the survival of the Republic. Bloomberg, of course, has run New York City, a harder job than being president. He ran it so well, in his own estimation, that he insisted on a third term in defiance of the City Charter, and got away with it. That is no doubt a maneuver that Trump has noted for his own playbook.

Bloomberg, who is nominally a Republican (it depends on the day of the week), is now being floated again as an alternative candidate, along with Ryan, Senator Ben Sasse of Nebraska, and a few other luminaries of similar wattage. The idea is not necessarily to win, but to preserve the ideological purity of the Party from Trump’s profane hands, and to prevent a down-ticket disaster. The problem, as Republican elders see it, is not only that the Party will split over this strategy, but that its electoral base will be irretrievably shattered.

This is a false concern, however, because that shattering has already occurred. The Reagan Democrats who left the Democratic Party fold in the 1980s have wandered off the reservation again. They’re supporting Trump, and they’ll accept no substitute. They’re not going to be charmed into backing the party of Wall Street again, not for the foreseeable future. Similarly, Trump has lured social conservatives and Evangelicals away from such former darlings as Mike Huckabee and Rick Santorum, and Ted Cruz wasn’t able to keep them in the fold either. People who clip coupons for a living — I mean the Goldman Sachs, not the Walmart kind — aren’t going be enough to keep the Republican Party in business. Try as one may, an electoral base chiefly consisting of the 1% or even the 10% isn’t going to get you to a national majority of 50% + 1.

But that’s where the beauty of 2016 comes in, and why Hillary Clinton is such a godsend to the Republican Party.

A third-party candidate—who would really be only the unofficial candidate of the Republican establishment—doesn’t need to win the election to become president. He or she doesn’t even need to come in more than a distant third, as the breakaway Dixiecrat Strom Thurmond did in 1948, or George Wallace in 1968. The only thing necessary would be to win enough states to prevent either Trump or Clinton from getting 270 votes in the Electoral College. In a really close race, winning only three Electoral College votes—say, those of Rhode Island or Wyoming—would be enough to throw the election into the House of Representatives, where the Republican Party will, by all calculation, retain a comfortable majority. Thus, as a Republican Supreme Court elected George W. Bush president in 2000 by a 5-4 vote, a simple majority of the 438 members in the Lower House could elect the next president. It would even be more a democratic procedure:  the Republicans in Congress, unlike Supreme Court justices, are actually elected by somebody, and they’d be 50 times more numerous than the infamous Five who gave us Bush. All the Republicans would have to do would be to hold ranks in the House, which would be Speaker Paul Ryan’s job. If Ryan himself were the “unofficial” Republican candidate, the House members would only have to vote for the man they chose for the third slot in the Constitutional pecking order to replace Barack Obama in the first one.  

Of course, you might say that electing a president who won only one—or maybe three, or perhaps five—states would be seen as outrageous. But, that’s the way the Founding Fathers set it up for us. They weren’t big fans of democracy either. And who, really, will complain? A majority of voters don’t want Trump or Clinton, and they would likely breathe a sigh of relief to be spared either of them. The rump Republican victor would have four years to rebuild the Party’s base, or at least build one of his or possibly her own (just think:  President Nikki Haley!).

If the Republican Party survives, in short, its neck will have been saved by its bête noire, Hillary Clinton. Of course, Hillary wouldn’t have been able to do it alone, not without the Democratic primary voters who turned their backs on the best chance they’ve had to renovate their own Party in 50 years,

So, which party is it exactly that is trying to commit suicide in 2016?  Hard to tell.

The post Political party suicide appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Political party suicide

The coming realignment of American politics

I’ve been watching American elections—and sparingly participating in them—for a long time. Sparingly participating, because I take my one 300th million share of the popular will in which our sovereignty is supposed to reside seriously, and I regard my vote as something to be earned by persons aspiring to office rather than bestowed on crooks, timeservers, and political prostitutes who provide legal services for the rich. I learned long ago that politicians lie at the feet of a master– Lyndon Baines Johnson, who swore up and down that he’d keep us out of Vietnam. (His opponent, Barry Goldwater, was all too truthful: he promised us a nuclear confrontation with the Soviet Union, and, having just survived one courtesy of John F. Kennedy, I was pretty sure he’d deliver.)

I didn’t feel virtuous about my hiatus from the ballot box, but I did feel a little less besmirched by it. I can proudly say that I’ve never voted for a Clinton, and I can promise you I never will. I’ve kept my respect for only one presidential candidate in my lifetime, George S. McGovern. He would probably have made a terrible president, but he was as close to a completely decent man as I’ve ever seen in American politics. (I leave third-party candidates to one side, as, with the exception of George Wallace and Ross Perot, respectively a demagogue and a lunatic, they’ve never stood a chance even for registering a serious protest vote.)

I held my nose and voted for John Kerry in 2004, not because I was anything but disgusted at what he had become since he testified as a Vietnam Veteran Against the War in the early 1970s, but as a protest against the Supreme Court’s stealing the previous presidential election from everybody and given us George W. Bush. I took a chance on Barack Obama in 2008, and lived to regret it even before he took office. The 2012 election, with Obama opposed by Mitt Romney, was as deeply depressing a spectacle as any since Richard Nixon ran in 1968 against the remnants of what had once been Hubert Humphrey.

What I’m saying is that America has lived in the trough of a very long political reaction that has consumed most of my lifetime, dominated by a minority party that by rights should have gone to the dogs long ago but has figured out a way to keep its ideology in power if not in every case itself, so that, rain or shine, both major parties have delivered government of, by, and for what has now become known as the 1 percent—the moneyed interest that has dominated the country as at no time since the post-Civil War era, and, until now, with significantly less resistance. You could say this much for the Robber Barons of the 19th century, that they did build an industrial colossus, however brutally. Our current one-percenters, however, have presided over the dismantling of our manufacturing structure, bankrupting us all for the benefit of their Panamanian accounts.

When a system as ossified as ours has persisted as long as it has, the tendency is to regard it as immutable. That is the mistake cynicism makes, because, eventually, history provides the unexpected. Its subterranean plates may grind slowly, but when enough pressure builds up, something gives, and the ground moves. That may finally be happening in 2016.

Change was in the air in 2008, but Obama stuffed a wet sock in it. Frustration with this produced a dual reaction—the Tea Party movement of 2010, and the shorter-lived Occupy insurgency of 2011. Then came time for another presidential cycle to anesthetize the Republic—the Mormon millionaire against the man who, by his own description, stood guard at the gates of Wall Street to ward off the pitchforks of the unruly masses.

2016 was supposed to have been yet worse, with the Clintons and the Bushes going at it again, shamelessly corrupt dynasties primed by Citizens United cash. But a couple of unexpected things happened. A white-maned Brooklyn Jewish senator from Vermont with all the charm of a nagging uncle and an egotistical casino magnate whose favorite line on his Reality TV show was “You’re fired!” upset the applecarts of both parties, overturning the cozy complicity of Democratic and Republican establishments alike with bankster politics, and provoking, at least on one side, something not seen in American politics since 1968—political violence. Of course, the scuffling at Trump rallies isn’t a patch on the violence that resulted in the assassinations of Martin Luther King, Jr. and Bobby Kennedy half a century ago. Those events were the climax of an era of mass protests and urban rioting that had divided the country more deeply than at any time since the Civil War, and, with its best leaders slain, led to its rightward lurch under Nixon. Nothing like that is yet on the horizon. But business as usual is out this year, as even Hillary Clinton has figured out. The two major parties will adapt, or, just possibly, die. Bernie Sanders has given the Democrats a blueprint for renewal, for which they have been thus far largely ungrateful. Donald Trump, on the other hand, is a wrecking ball poised to demolish a party that has supped too long on its sins. The party of Lincoln died long ago; that of Richard Nixon has now run its course. Its final product was Ted Cruz—“Lucifer in the flesh” in John Boehner’s forever-to-be-memorable phrase—and Trump is its pallbearer. American conservatism doubtless has a future—suspicion of government is too important a function to be left to anarchists alone—but it will need to rest on something more than a Faustian bargain with the devils of racism and greed.

The only authentic conservative in this year’s race is, paradoxically, Sanders. What he is offering the Democratic Party is a return to its New Deal roots. Every major point in his platform represents either the unfinished business of the New Deal, or simply Theodore Roosevelt Republicanism. Single-payer health care available to all as a fundamental social right? The British adopted this in 1948, at a time when they were still living on wartime rationing with an economy kept afloat only by Marshall Plan aid. Harry Truman, who represented the conservative wing of the Democratic Party, adopted guaranteed health care as a plank in the 1948 Democratic Party platform. Tuition-free education in public colleges and universities? No pipe dream, nor simply the spendthrift giveaway of European welfare states, but precisely the system in place when I went to college myself, and got my bachelor’s degree from the City University of New York. Breaking up too-big-to-fail banks, formerly known as monopolies? Trust-busting Teddy Roosevelt broke up U.S. Steel in 1901, and the Republic survived. Bernie Sanders really isn’t a figure of the 21st century. He simply wants us to finish the business of the 20th.

What Sanders has really accomplished, though, is in giving the lie to the assumption that, with Citizens United, our politics was permanently in the hands of billionaire donors like the Koch brothers who could buy elections at will. On donations averaging $27 a pop, Sanders has raised more money than any candidate of either party. If he’s laying off campaign workers now, it’s not for lack of money to pay them.

Sanders and Trump both represent something new in modern American politics, the rise of the independent voter. Forty-two percent of American voters now identify themselves as political independents; only 29 percent do as Democrats, and 26 percent as Republicans. This division isn’t a fluke; it has held steady for several years now. Since the process of choosing a president has been monopolized by the two major parties almost from the beginning of the Republic, this means that a plurality that approaches a majority of the country must settle for a process that does not directly represent it, if at all. Forty-plus percent of the electorate may identify with neither Democrats nor Republicans, but the U.S. Senate contains only two independents, Bernie Sanders and Angus King.

Sanders has run for president on the Democratic ticket for a simple reason: the entire election process, from appearance on state ballots to attention by the media, is rigged to preserve the monopoly of the two establishment parties. As for Trump, he no longer conceals his contempt for the party whose nomination he seeks, and he will have staged a coup d’état if he gets it. He has pried loose the Reagan Democrats cast adrift by the failure of the labor movement in the 1970s, and marginalized the Bible Belt social conservatives and their Tea Party fellow travelers. That has left only the exposed Wall Street base of the party, whose money can’t buy the self-financed Trump and whose disdain doesn’t faze him. It’s pretty hard to see anyone reconnecting these pieces, magnetized to begin with only by Nixon’s scowl and Reagan’s smile.

Sanders, on the other hand, is trying to put something together: the old Progressive movement that represents the enduring liberal strain in American politics, and that coalesced for awhile in the New Deal politics that defined the Democratic Party in the middle decades of the last century. The strategy of his campaign is to revive the old Roosevelt brand, whether in the party or outside it. If he is its presidential nominee, his problem will be to lead it without compromising his core convictions; if he is not, it will be to keep the liberal cause he has revitalized alive. Either task will take political gifts of a high order. Bernie Sanders could lead to a future worthy of the country’s better instincts if he can hold the movement he has galvanized together, serving as a bridge to younger leaders.

Donald Trump leads nowhere.

The post The coming realignment of American politics appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The coming realignment of American politics

Representative democracy is a messy business

Flickr: whiteafrican

Flickr: whiteafrican

How long should it take to elect a president? In a ministerial-style European system (the Canadians have it too), the contending political parties each choose a “leader” behind closed doors who will represent them in a general election and who automatically assumes power as prime minister if his or her party wins a majority of legislative seats. In a two-party system, this is a simple procedure; where there is a significant third party or a multiparty system, the leader of the party with a plurality of seats is “asked” to form a government by a ceremonial monarch or president, and attempts to negotiate a coalition with another party or parties until he or she is assured of a legislative majority. That is the case, for example, in Israel, where the leading party usually wins no more than a quarter of the seats. The fun and games in such a system therefore begins after the election, when the horse-trading over cabinet seats and policy positions begins, also behind closed doors. Sometimes a deal is struck quickly; sometimes it drags on for weeks or months. Sometimes it doesn’t happen at all, as is presently the case in Spain. Then you have a new election and start all over again.

Nobody ever said that representative democracy wasn’t a messy business.

In America, the process is reversed. The president is directly elected, and it is the contest to choose the candidates of the two major parties that takes all the time, and I do mean time. America has fifty states, and each has a primary election or caucus at a date of its own choosing between January and June of the election year, preceded by six months to a year of politicking during which the prospective candidates introduce themselves to the parties whose nomination they seek and to the public at large. This makes the election process an eighteen to twenty-four month ordeal within a four-year cycle, during which many a voter doubtless comes to wish that all the candidates would just get on a plane and go crash somewhere. The good news is that the president is chosen on election day, with no haggling after—unless, of course, the race is too close to call, as it was in 2000 when the Supreme Court stepped in on dubious legal grounds and decided the winner by a 5-4 vote, thereby negating the ballots of about 120 million Americans and making the choice for us themselves.

The primary system has been with us for about a century, when Theodore Roosevelt thrust it upon us in the course of his ill-fated bid for the Republican Party nomination in 1912. Until then, political candidates were chosen, European-style, behind closed doors. Sometimes, party bosses picked well-known figures or military heroes. Sometimes, they chose totally obscure individuals, for reasons best known to themselves. Teddy Roosevelt himself ran in 1904 against a certain Judge Alton B. Parker. Never heard of him? Neither had anyone else at the time. TR, the sitting president, won handily.

Our present system, clearly, is a Rube Goldberg contraption run wild. Iowa and New Hampshire, two of the least demographically representative states in the Union, hold their primaries first. Then a battery of states from the Old Confederacy weigh in, a consolation prize for having been compelled to remain within the Union against their will. New York doesn’t vote until April. California, the largest state in the Union, votes at the very end in June.

Each state sets its own rules. Some states have elections, some with crossover balloting and some restricted by voter registration, so that registered Democrats alone can vote for the Democratic candidate and registered Republicans for the Republican one. This seems logical, for unaffiliated voters can easily cast spoiler votes to tilt the nomination process. On the other hand, when they vote in the general election, all voters, regardless of registration, are free to select anyone they please, so that restricting their choices in the primaries makes less if any sense. This is complicated by the fact that about 40% of the electorate identifies itself as independent and registers with neither party. In states that do not permit crossover balloting, therefore, the largest group of voters is excluded from the primary process altogether.

It only gets more interesting from there. Some states don’t have regular-style elections but, as in Iowa, caucuses, where interested voters show up, listen to argument and lobbying, and cast their votes in quasi-anarchic conditions in which an accurate count is more or less anyone’s guess. In some states, the winner of a majority or plurality of votes wins the commitment of the entire slate of convention delegates; in some cases, the votes are apportioned proportionally or by congressional district. Pennsylvania Republican delegates are chosen by a unique system: of the state’s 71 delegates, only 17 are pledged by the outcome of the vote, while the remaining 54 are free to choose any candidate they like—in other words, they are not elected at all.

The Democrats have their own wrinkle on the process. Of their 5,477 delegates, 4,765 are chosen by election or caucus, winner-take-all or proportionally, but 712 so-called superdelegates, normally party officials or functionaries, are free, like the 54 Pennsylvania Republicans, to choose anyone they like. The Democrats introduced this system in the 1980s to give party professionals a hand on the electoral lever—in other words, to negate the entire primary process if it produced an unacceptable result, say, an independent running for the nomination outside the party establishment itself. Can you say Bernie Sanders?

Ironically, the result of this little insurance policy will be to deny the party establishment’s preferred candidate, Hillary Clinton, a primary victory without the help of superdelegates. Clinton has won about 55% of the delegates in the state balloting to Sanders’ roughly 45%. With less than a quarter of the pledged delegates still to be chosen, Clinton would need to win nearly 70% of this remaining number to get the 2,383 votes she needs to win the nomination without unelected superdelegate support. In other words, what she almost certainly could have won on her own will have to be handed to her by party functionaries.

The Republicans, of course, are dealing with an insurgent candidacy of their own, that of Donald Trump. Almost every prominent Republican in the country apart from Chris Christie has been trying to stop Trump ever since his campaign gained traction. This effort will almost certainly fail. The party will nominate a candidate its professionals hate this coming July, whom they fear will drag it down to calamitous defeat if not wreck it entirely. This is a fate the Republicans have entirely earned, were the alternative for the country not Hillary Clinton.

About two-thirds of the country hates and fears Trump about as much the Republican party sachems do, though not necessarily for the same reasons. Nearly as many people have a negative view of Clinton. The country will then, courtesy of the party system, be presented with a choice most people feel to be unpalatable if not downright scary.

In 2000, when the country was presented with a choice between Al Gore and George W. Bush, most people wished they could have voted for Bill Clinton instead. In 2016, most of them will probably wish they could vote for Barack Obama, and, really, Bill Clinton was a scalawag and Obama is a below-average college professor.

How did things get this bad? I’ll try to figure that out next week.

The post Representative democracy is a messy business appeared first on The Triangle.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Representative democracy is a messy business