Author Archives | Robert Zaller

The Arkansas death circus

Photograph courtesy of CACorrections at Wikimedia Commons

Photograph courtesy of CACorrections at Wikimedia Commons

Arkansas: Isn’t that the place the Clintons came from?

Yes, indeed. And some of us will remember that the Man From Hope, as Bill Clinton enjoyed being called, suspended his presidential primary campaign exactly 25 years ago to return to Arkansas, of which he was still governor, to preside over the execution of a Death Row prisoner, Ricky Lee Rector.

Rector’s case was, and is, notorious in the annals of American capital punishment. Never dealing from a full deck to begin with, Rector shot and killed the police officer — a childhood friend — he’d agreed to surrender to from a previous fatal shooting that involved a quarrel over $3, and then turned his gun on himself in a suicide attempt. He survived the shot, but destroyed much of the frontal lobe of his brain, and with it his capacity for rational awareness and judgment.

That included his capacity to comprehend his own death.

Executing a person who can’t understand he’s being executed violates a cardinal principle in the law, the M’Naghten rule, which states that the punishment of death can only be properly carried out on persons who understand what’s being done to them, and why. It’s the line that separates a human being who realizes he’s committed a capital crime from an animal being put down for attempting to make a meal of a human.

Rector was given his last meal, which included a slice of pecan pie. He put the slice of pie aside, saying he wanted to save dessert for later. Then the state of Arkansas, in all its majesty, put him down.

Bill Clinton went on to become president of the United States.

Since then, Arkansas hasn’t been much in the news, except for the occasional twister. That changed this March, though, when the state’s Republican governor, Asa Hutchinson, announced the scheduled execution of eight prisoners over an eleven-day period from April 17 to April 27. No state in modern American history had ever executed so many prisoners in such a short span of time. Only 20 prisoners had been executed nationwide in 2016, most of them in the notorious jurisdictions of Texas and Georgia. Arkansas hadn’t carried out an execution since 2005.

What was the sudden rush to death?

It was the same thing that sends you to your pharmacist when you realize that the headache powder you’ve been using has passed its shelf life.

Almost all executions in the United States today are carried out by lethal injection; few states permit any other method. Some states use a single drug, but most employ a cocktail. That in Arkansas is a mixture of midazolam, a sedative; vecuronium bromide, a muscle relaxant that paralyzes the diaphragm; and potassium chloride, which stops the heart.

Arkansas’ problem was that its supply of midazolam was about to expire with the month of April. But, why not simply get more? Midazolam’s a fairly common drug, easy enough to manufacture, and in widespread therapeutic use — in its intended form and appropriate dose, to sedate. Its adoption for purposes of capital punishment, like that of other execution drugs, runs up against the supreme prohibition of the Hippocratic Oath: Do no harm. Execution being the very definition of harm, the sale of such a drug to the state in a death penalty jurisdiction would raise sticky questions for pharmaceutical companies, their distributors and the doctors who work for them.

The result has been that above-board drug suppliers, for at least nominally ethical reasons but also commercial ones — bad publicity, and even the potential threat of boycott — have slowly ceased to resupply lethal injection stocks to the 32 states that still retain the death penalty.

Rather than give up their peculiar institution, the states have made secret deals with compounding pharmacies that have agreed to furnish the materials of death. These practices, too, have come under scrutiny and criticism, and they pose the same risk that bootleg whiskey did during Prohibition: you don’t really know what’s going into the stuff.

Midazolam, in particular, has been the culprit in several high-profile botched executions, in which prisoners have twitched, gasped, lurched, convulsed and given every sign of excruciating torture as they died over periods as long as an hour or more. Being burned at the stake would have been a piece of cake by comparison.

Why, then, did Arkansas not opt for a different method of execution? Beheading works fine, as the French proved with the guillotine; firing squads get the job done too. The trouble, in both cases, is blood. Since modern publics, at least in the Western world, started to become squeamish about the death penalty in the late nineteenth century, trendy techniques have been introduced that would avoid the appearance of bloodshed: the electric chair in the 1890s, the gas chamber in the 1920s. These often produced more gruesome effects than the primitive rifle or noose, however, and they gave way to lethal injection, which delivers death by mimicking the protocols of medicine. As in surgery, the prisoner/patient is strapped to a hospital gurney before receiving the same class of anaesthetics that might be used to save lives, but administered in fatal doses.

What this means is that each execution in America is, at present, a human experiment on a live subject. There is no research on which combination of drugs, in which doses, is likely to produce an optimally painless and efficient result. Death penalty states stipulate the drugs they use (or say they use), but not necessarily the doses. No doctor is present to monitor the patient; even Josef Mengele, who presided over some of the Nazis’ most infamous prisoner experiments, had a medical degree. The states, as conservative columnists like George Will are wont to say, are supposedly the “laboratories” of democracy. The proposition is more often dubious than not. But they certainly are, in our day and age, laboratories of death.

With Arkansas last month, the laboratory became a carnival. The suddenly impending executions created a flurry of appeals that moved through state and federal courts in rapid-fire succession, including the U.S. Supreme Court.

The courts stayed some executions and permitted others, including that of Ledell Lee, who protested his innocence up to the moment of his execution but was denied the DNA testing that might have proved his claim. Other petitioners had familiar objections raised on their behalf including mental illness or incapacity, incompetent representation, failure to adequately present mitigating circumstances and the likelihood of gross suffering due to medical conditions. Five of the eight had pending clemency petitions. In all, four men were executed: Ledell Lee on April 20, Marcel Williams and Jack Jones on April 24 and Kenneth Williams on April 27. The daughter of Kenneth Williams’ victim pleaded for his life: “His execution,” she said, “will not bring my father back, or return to us what has been taken, but will only cause additional suffering.”

Needless to say, her appeal fell on deaf ears; in the world of prosecutors and executioners, only the demand for vengeance is heard and the plea for mercy is always ignored. Kenneth Williams’ death gave solace to no one, and his execution was botched. Strapped to his gurney — the same one used for the three prisoners who had preceded him — his body jerked and lurched spasmodically 15 times in swift succession, and five more times in slower rhythm.

Anyone want to guess what that felt like?

The death penalty is an American horror show, and Asa Hutchinson made a circus of it. For those of us who have watched death sentences and executions slowly decline over the past 20 years, it was like seeing the age of lynchings and cross-burnings suddenly leap back to life. I suppose we should expect anything in the era of Trump, but those 10 days in April have covered all of us in shame.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Arkansas death circus

The Arkansas death circus

Photograph courtesy of CACorrections at Wikimedia Commons

Photograph courtesy of CACorrections at Wikimedia Commons

Arkansas: Isn’t that the place the Clintons came from?

Yes, indeed. And some of us will remember that the Man From Hope, as Bill Clinton enjoyed being called, suspended his presidential primary campaign exactly 25 years ago to return to Arkansas, of which he was still governor, to preside over the execution of a Death Row prisoner, Ricky Lee Rector.

Rector’s case was, and is, notorious in the annals of American capital punishment. Never dealing from a full deck to begin with, Rector shot and killed the police officer — a childhood friend — he’d agreed to surrender to from a previous fatal shooting that involved a quarrel over $3, and then turned his gun on himself in a suicide attempt. He survived the shot, but destroyed much of the frontal lobe of his brain, and with it his capacity for rational awareness and judgment.

That included his capacity to comprehend his own death.

Executing a person who can’t understand he’s being executed violates a cardinal principle in the law, the M’Naghten rule, which states that the punishment of death can only be properly carried out on persons who understand what’s being done to them, and why. It’s the line that separates a human being who realizes he’s committed a capital crime from an animal being put down for attempting to make a meal of a human.

Rector was given his last meal, which included a slice of pecan pie. He put the slice of pie aside, saying he wanted to save dessert for later. Then the state of Arkansas, in all its majesty, put him down.

Bill Clinton went on to become president of the United States.

Since then, Arkansas hasn’t been much in the news, except for the occasional twister. That changed this March, though, when the state’s Republican governor, Asa Hutchinson, announced the scheduled execution of eight prisoners over an eleven-day period from April 17 to April 27. No state in modern American history had ever executed so many prisoners in such a short span of time. Only 20 prisoners had been executed nationwide in 2016, most of them in the notorious jurisdictions of Texas and Georgia. Arkansas hadn’t carried out an execution since 2005.

What was the sudden rush to death?

It was the same thing that sends you to your pharmacist when you realize that the headache powder you’ve been using has passed its shelf life.

Almost all executions in the United States today are carried out by lethal injection; few states permit any other method. Some states use a single drug, but most employ a cocktail. That in Arkansas is a mixture of midazolam, a sedative; vecuronium bromide, a muscle relaxant that paralyzes the diaphragm; and potassium chloride, which stops the heart.

Arkansas’ problem was that its supply of midazolam was about to expire with the month of April. But, why not simply get more? Midazolam’s a fairly common drug, easy enough to manufacture, and in widespread therapeutic use — in its intended form and appropriate dose, to sedate. Its adoption for purposes of capital punishment, like that of other execution drugs, runs up against the supreme prohibition of the Hippocratic Oath: Do no harm. Execution being the very definition of harm, the sale of such a drug to the state in a death penalty jurisdiction would raise sticky questions for pharmaceutical companies, their distributors and the doctors who work for them.

The result has been that above-board drug suppliers, for at least nominally ethical reasons but also commercial ones — bad publicity, and even the potential threat of boycott — have slowly ceased to resupply lethal injection stocks to the 32 states that still retain the death penalty.

Rather than give up their peculiar institution, the states have made secret deals with compounding pharmacies that have agreed to furnish the materials of death. These practices, too, have come under scrutiny and criticism, and they pose the same risk that bootleg whiskey did during Prohibition: you don’t really know what’s going into the stuff.

Midazolam, in particular, has been the culprit in several high-profile botched executions, in which prisoners have twitched, gasped, lurched, convulsed and given every sign of excruciating torture as they died over periods as long as an hour or more. Being burned at the stake would have been a piece of cake by comparison.

Why, then, did Arkansas not opt for a different method of execution? Beheading works fine, as the French proved with the guillotine; firing squads get the job done too. The trouble, in both cases, is blood. Since modern publics, at least in the Western world, started to become squeamish about the death penalty in the late nineteenth century, trendy techniques have been introduced that would avoid the appearance of bloodshed: the electric chair in the 1890s, the gas chamber in the 1920s. These often produced more gruesome effects than the primitive rifle or noose, however, and they gave way to lethal injection, which delivers death by mimicking the protocols of medicine. As in surgery, the prisoner/patient is strapped to a hospital gurney before receiving the same class of anaesthetics that might be used to save lives, but administered in fatal doses.

What this means is that each execution in America is, at present, a human experiment on a live subject. There is no research on which combination of drugs, in which doses, is likely to produce an optimally painless and efficient result. Death penalty states stipulate the drugs they use (or say they use), but not necessarily the doses. No doctor is present to monitor the patient; even Josef Mengele, who presided over some of the Nazis’ most infamous prisoner experiments, had a medical degree. The states, as conservative columnists like George Will are wont to say, are supposedly the “laboratories” of democracy. The proposition is more often dubious than not. But they certainly are, in our day and age, laboratories of death.

With Arkansas last month, the laboratory became a carnival. The suddenly impending executions created a flurry of appeals that moved through state and federal courts in rapid-fire succession, including the U.S. Supreme Court.

The courts stayed some executions and permitted others, including that of Ledell Lee, who protested his innocence up to the moment of his execution but was denied the DNA testing that might have proved his claim. Other petitioners had familiar objections raised on their behalf including mental illness or incapacity, incompetent representation, failure to adequately present mitigating circumstances and the likelihood of gross suffering due to medical conditions. Five of the eight had pending clemency petitions. In all, four men were executed: Ledell Lee on April 20, Marcel Williams and Jack Jones on April 24 and Kenneth Williams on April 27. The daughter of Kenneth Williams’ victim pleaded for his life: “His execution,” she said, “will not bring my father back, or return to us what has been taken, but will only cause additional suffering.”

Needless to say, her appeal fell on deaf ears; in the world of prosecutors and executioners, only the demand for vengeance is heard and the plea for mercy is always ignored. Kenneth Williams’ death gave solace to no one, and his execution was botched. Strapped to his gurney — the same one used for the three prisoners who had preceded him — his body jerked and lurched spasmodically 15 times in swift succession, and five more times in slower rhythm.

Anyone want to guess what that felt like?

The death penalty is an American horror show, and Asa Hutchinson made a circus of it. For those of us who have watched death sentences and executions slowly decline over the past 20 years, it was like seeing the age of lynchings and cross-burnings suddenly leap back to life. I suppose we should expect anything in the era of Trump, but those 10 days in April have covered all of us in shame.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Arkansas death circus

When a university loses its soul

Photograph courtesy of Daderot at Wikimedia Commons

Photograph courtesy of Daderot at Wikimedia Commons

More than six decades ago, sociologist C. Wright Mills warned of a “new universe of management and manipulation” that had entered American life, and that threatened to fundamentally alter its character and undermine its values. Mills was prescient.

Through the increasing bureaucratization of American society and standardization of American culture, he saw the imposition of a faceless rule on behalf of unnamed interests that would destroy both the practice of our collective democracy and the experience of individual freedom. I think nothing in our present-day world of digitization, hacking, and universal surveillance would have surprised him, although we lack a voice as clear and cogent as his to describe it.

Mills, as an academic, would have had few illusions about universities. Still, certain assumptions — or call them necessary fictions — persisted about the university as an institution devoted, for all its imperfections, to notionally noble callings: the disinterested creation and dissemination of knowledge collectively validated by neutral peers using accepted norms and tested in open debate; the education of young adults for informed citizen responsibilities and the opportunity for older ones to broaden their horizons; and, within the academic community, the practice of democratic discourse and decision-making.

The core basis of all these functions was the concept of the faculty as a permanent body of the university, its status guaranteed by academic freedom rooted in the institution of tenure. Tenure itself had been a development of recent vintage, and it did not protect the academic victims of McCarthyism who were emerging even as Mills wrote.

But it was understood by the generation of scholars among whom I came of age that it was the linchpin of the system, and that without it, the university could not subsist as a democratic community capable of both serving the wider world and withstanding the pressures that often came from it.

For this reason, the corporatization and bureaucratization that have steadily encroached on the university in the past several decades — a joint project of business and government — targeted tenure early on for destruction. This campaign has been largely accomplished.

The dwindling pockets of tenured faculty who remain have little prestige among and less influence on the at-will employees who are now their colleagues. The faculty as a whole has all but ceased to play a governance role in the functions and the mission of the contemporary university. It is simply, as Mills put it, managed and manipulated. In all substantive matters, including those most directly affecting its interest, integrity, and welfare, it is routinely disregarded, only to be informed as necessary of the conditions under which it will be permitted to work — or compelled to retire.

Which brings us to Drexel’s so-called Voluntary Retirement Incentive Plan, and the meeting of President Fry and senior administrators with the Faculty Senate April 18.

Note with whom the President did not meet. He neither met  with the university faculty as a whole, nor (it goes without saying) with the general staff, who are all equally affected by the “Plan.” The meeting took place in one of the Senate’s occasional sites, the assembly hall of the LeBow building, and, as is its wont, the Senate convened around circular tables that took most of the space in the hall, leaving only three rows of seats for the general faculty at the back of the room (with no microphones to make their voices heard).

The President began with an account of the University’s current financial troubles and the shared sacrifice it now entailed. He did not discuss the “Incentive” Plan, which, for those of you unfamiliar with it, offers a pittance above the severance pay that had already left Drexel at community college levels, and, for those not accepting it, whether eligible for retirement or at any other point in their careers — nothing at all. This latter — the large stick attached to the very tiny carrot — had been embedded in such weasel-worded bureaucratese that, for a good month, it was unclear not only to faculty and general staff but even to deans and the Human Resources personnel charged with implementing the Plan what exactly was meant. The obfuscatory statement that went out, and was simply repeated without elaboration, was that the existing retirement program, including medical benefits and life insurance, would no longer be “available.” The word, of course, in plain English, was that they were being eliminated. And the plain sense of that proper word was that Drexel had simply scrapped retirement benefits for all faculty and staff remaining on its payroll after August 31, 2017.

How’s that for an institution whose “ambition can’t wait?”

The President wasn’t anxious to discuss the matter. He preferred to talk about the future, about restored financial health and robust, sustainable, benefit-free growth.

He got an earful.

A faculty colleague announced to him that he and his administration had “disserved” and “damaged” the university, and treated its most distinguished and long-serving faculty with ignorance and disrespect. She pointed out, at some length and with some eloquence, that retirement for senior faculty was typically a process requiring two to three years, for faculty members themselves, their departments, and the programs and students they served. To compress this period into three months under the gun — all the time allotted before previously guaranteed benefits became “unavailable” — was to impose needless and unacceptable harm on both the faculty and the institution itself.

It was, in short, stupid and cruel.

I looked at the President and his team for a reaction; I waited for a response. There was none. If any of these questions had ever been considered by them, I saw no sign of it.

Other faculty joined in. It was pointed out that the rapid and semi-coerced retirement of senior faculty would not only deprive the university of knowledge and experience — none of which, incidentally, would be in the near term replaced — but also of institutional memory, the unquantifiable but essential component that defines a university as an ongoing, collegial body of scholars. Perhaps, though, that was part of the objective? To treat faculty not as a body but as isolated, disposable parts — in short, as expendable — is precisely what is required to turn them into such. What that makes of the university is something else; but no one at the head table was prepared to comment on the questions being raised.

If institutional memory were lost, some faculty said, individual remembrance would not be. Retired faculty, they noted, continued like alumni to serve and represent the University. To send an angry, embittered, and insulted cohort on its way would be yet another self-inflicted wound on the institution.

If that sounded like an actual threat, I think it was one. Give people the bum’s rush, and they’re likely to be very, very bummed out.

In essence, what happened April 18 was a vote of no confidence in the Drexel administration. True, it involved only a few dozen faculty, and there was no formal show of hands. Nor did everyone speak. But if the President had faced a general assembly, I am tolerably sure the response would have been very much the same, and the chorus amplified many times over.

The only give I heard from the administration was the suggestion that, in due time, some level of benefits might be restored — after all, would not the future recruitment of superior faculty be a bit difficult in the absence of any retirement package? This, naturally, made things worse. Those being stampeded into retirement on pain of losing all benefits might find those who elected to stay having them restored; might find themselves, that is, deliberately tricked. But for faculty who do stay, of course, nothing is or can be truly secured from this time forward. The Lord giveth, and the Lord taketh away.

A word or two about the benefits that are now to be eliminated, or suspended, or simply not made “available.” For senior faculty and staff in particular, the medical benefit, such as it is or has been (and it had already been cut before), is one of the obvious concerns. But the severance pay is no less an issue for many. It would be a great mistake to regard such pay as a kind of parting bonus.

Especially under the present administration, merit raises have failed to keep pace with inflation, and many senior faculty salaries are, to use the mortgage market term, underwater: that is, they are worth less than their original value in real purchasing power. Severance pay is from this standpoint simply a belated restitution of some portion of the money such faculty should have received over years and even decades of inadequately compensated service. It’s no kind of gift at all, and taking it away is breaking an implied if unenforceable contract for repayment of debt — it is, in short, a breach of faith.

But, there you have the modern university. And there, as it appears, you have Drexel.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When a university loses its soul

Ready for another war?

Photograph courtesy of Olivier Douliery/Abaca Press/TNS

Photograph courtesy of Olivier Douliery/Abaca Press/TNS

It’s clear that Donald Trump’s first hundred days haven’t turned out to be the walk in the park he envisioned. The most spectacularly unqualified and intellectually disabled leader ever freely chosen by any people on earth — that’s us, friends — can’t hide his scowl of frustration whenever he sits down for the obligatory photo op with visiting dignitaries. Otherwise, he retreats into Twitter-world, or his gated fortress at Mar-a-Lago. The most photographed person in the history of the world has suddenly become the least visible.

Signing executive orders is the easy part. You sit at a desk and hold up a piece of paper with your signature at the bottom, the one that looks like a runaway seismograph. Legislating is another matter. Who would have thought that healthcare reform was so hard? Donald Trump actually said that, in advance of having his head handed back to him on a platter by the House Freedom Caucus. Ah, well, if it’s not one deal, it’s on to the next. How about tax reform? Oh, that’s hard too, so maybe — um — we’ll go back to health care. Or not.

Here’s a hot tip, Donald. Your border wall — the Mother of All Walls, the one you decided to build when pesky neighbors in Scotland and Ireland wouldn’t let you fence off your golf courses and block the view of their own country — isn’t going to get built: too expensive, too much eminent domain and even the Texans don’t like it. Those coal mining jobs aren’t coming back either, any more than horse-drawn milk wagons in the morning. You’ll change the subject — three-year-olds are good at doing that — but people do keep score. And yours, except for that Supreme Court judge Mike Pence scarfed up for you, you know, the one who thinks truck drivers should freeze to death in their cabs rather than abandon a payload, is zero.

What’s left for a president to do?

Happily for Donald Trump, and alas for the rest of us, there’s the role of Commander-in-Chief.

When Trump was campaigning, he scoffed at foreign entanglements and military alliances. We always got the short end of the stick, from those NATO deadbeats who don’t pay their own bills to the generals who keep talking you into wars they never win. It was kind of refreshing when he said that, because some of us had grown a little tired of bombing places we couldn’t pronounce for reasons we couldn’t remember.

But what Trump has learned on the actual job — the only thing he has learned, apparently — is that the role of Commander-in-Chief is the one whose buttons work when you push them. Backwoods congressmen can frustrate you, judges from jurisdictions you never heard of can tie you up, but when you order a warship to steam ahead or a missile to launch, hey presto! It’s done.

Thus, within a week, we’ve seen battlefields ramped up on three different fronts. There were those 59 Tomahawk missiles launched against a Russian-manned airfield in Syria after a dubiously sourced chemical attack against civilians. Then came that Massive Ordnance Air Blast (“Mother of All Bombs”) detonation against some ISIS fighters allegedly holed up in bunkers on the Afghan-Pakistan border, which appears to have been the largest bomb exploded since Hiroshima. And now there’s the Seventh Fleet squadron detached to head up off the coast of nuclear-armed North Korea while we ostentatiously conduct war games south of its border and warn, in that most popular of presidential phrases, that all options are on the table.

Let’s take these gambits in order.

In 2013, when we had our last chemical warfare crisis in Syria, Barack Obama looked in vain for support from our allies or even from Congress (in which war-making authority is still nominally vested) for a missile strike he really didn’t want to launch. Everyone thought him a wuss for not simply going ahead, as he had in Libya two years earlier when he told Congress it couldn’t stop him bombing when and where he would. Libya hadn’t worked out, though, and Obama had enough failed wars on his plate already.

At that time, one of the few voices that argued Syria simply wasn’t our business was Donald Trump’s. No one paid any attention to what a flaky real estate developer had to say, but his words are remembered now. Trump didn’t bother to consult the UN or NATO or Congress when his turn came; he simply bombed. Brian Williams, from his MSNBC exile, was overjoyed; another talking head, Fareed Zakaria, gushed that Trump had finally become president in showing Bashar Al-Assad and the Russkies a thing or two. Amazing how easy it was to win enemies and frighten people! Maybe this president thing wasn’t going to be such a downer after all.

No one can really figure out why that big bomb was dropped in Afghanistan. But Trump had promised in campaigning to blow the hell out of ISIS, and here was the perfect opportunity: an invisible target, concealed underground, with civilians given notice to get out of the way. You could make up the body count any way you wanted: 36, 94 . . . just up to 700, which happens to be the estimate of the total number of ISIS fighters still left in Afghanistan before the big one exploded. It made a great photo op, a little topography rearranged with no blood and gore to spoil the shot. Was there anyone actually left in those bunkers when the bomb went off? Phantom wars have phantom victims, but we do have the Pentagon’s word for it: there really are fewer bad guys in the world now, at least until fresh recruits rush to the colors. Nor did anyone complain about the exercise except for Hamid Karzai, our erstwhile puppet in Afghanistan turned elder statesman, who griped about his country being turned into an ordnance range.

We could find ourselves pulled into Syria, a war even the generals don’t want. We’ve already spent going on 16 years in Afghanistan, a war no one expects us to ever get out of. But Korea is another matter, and here a little history is in order.

The Korean War (1950-53), now forgotten by almost everyone except those who fought in it, was as costly as Vietnam. It has had its historians, but it seems to me as poorly understood from a strategic perspective as any we’ve ever fought. Russia had just tested its first atomic bomb in 1949, and Mao Zedong had marched into Beijing at the head of a victorious insurgency. Suddenly, three-quarters of the Eurasian continent was in Communist hands, including, respectively, the largest and most populous states in the world. North Korea, situated close to our Pacific headquarters in Japan, had gone Communist, too.

The attack that precipitated the war is still lost in the murk of Cold War historiography. The journalist I. F. Stone pointed out long ago that the Seventh Fleet steamed into Korean waters and U.S. military leaves were canceled in the weeks leading up to North Korea’s supposed invasion of South Korea on June 25, 1950. At the very least, the Truman administration had military intelligence of North Korea’s “unprovoked” attack, and Stone pointed out that the first communique received about it in Tokyo spoke of a South Korean incursion against the North.

Our military proconsul in Japan, General Douglas MacArthur, wanted and contemplated war with China from the beginning of what President Harry Truman called the “police action” in Korea. He would have had strong support from the then potent who-lost-China lobby in Congress. If a war could be arranged on the Korean Peninsula, a march up to the Yalu River and into China was feasible, and proved to be the case once MacArthur was on the job. Maybe someone in North Korea got trigger-happy under the circumstances. Maybe it was the other way around.

What is clear is that our resort to war was immediate, and that this proved to be the occasion for effectively repealing Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution and putting war-making authority into the hands of the president, which means at the moment into those of Donald Trump.

This may be ancient history for us, but it’s not for the Koreans — or, for that matter, the Chinese, with whom we soon found ourselves in what is more properly called the Sino-American War.

North Korea was, as one of our military commentators put it, bombed back to the Stone Age, and China fought a costly war of regime survival. It has been a given of our relations with China ever since that Korea remains divided as it has been, and that North Korea remains within China’s sphere of control as South Korea is of ours. China no doubt has long-term hegemonic ambitions in the region that include the withdrawal of American military power and the recovery of Taiwan.

For the moment, it contents itself with naval probes in the South China Sea. But it is not prepared for any unilateral alteration in the status quo, as it has made repeatedly clear. That it must deal with an American administration so given to reckless saber-rattling and literally dismissive of diplomacy shows how dangerous the moment is, and that we have to rely on Trump’s military advisors to rein him in shows how fundamentally unbalanced our government is in every sense of the word. Nor do I think it is possible to overstate the spectacle we present to the world in using a bombastic oil man with no experience of statecraft and hardly even any acquaintance with Trump himself to fly around the world representing us without even undersecretaries to advise him which country he might be landing in.

Neither Obama nor Bill Clinton had any serious conception of the world when they took office, and neither learned very much except not to press his stupidity too far. But Donald Trump, as callow as Caligula, as suggestible as Claudius and as preening as Nero, sends one back to Tacitus for comparison.

The Romans at least had the excuse of a hereditary monarchy for their appalling run of rulers. Whom, though, can we blame for Trump but ourselves?

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ready for another war?

Lies trump the truth

Ron Sachs: CNP/Pool/Sipa USA/TNS

Photograph courtesy Ron Sachs CNP/Pool/Sipa USA/TNS

Orson Welles, the great American filmmaker, loved a good joke. He began his career with a radio broadcast about a Martian invasion of New Jersey that threw the whole country into a panic, and ended it with a movie called “F for Fake” about a Hungarian art forger and a few reflections on the fine art of scamming.

Welles was trying to make a point: truth is what you believe, and that belief is what you act on. We now have the daily spectacle of a truly fake president who does exactly that, and has raised mendacity to an art form so consummate that it seamlessly defines reality, tweet by tweet. And as for the reality of action, guess who orders our navy to cruise here or there, or our bombs to fall where he wills. Guess who keeps the nuclear strike codes at the ready, so that a war of world annihilation need never be more than a bad golf round away.

Donald Trump knows the secret of creating an entirely alternate world: lie all the time, as loudly and as often as you can, and proclaim most loudly of all that any other version of reality than yours is the absolute fake. You’re the president, which means you’re always one news cycle ahead of anyone else: you make the news.

In the old days, propaganda was a laboriously constructed fiction that was maintained with care and depended on monopoly; all independent sources of information had to be suppressed. Propaganda honored the idea of truth precisely in the lengths it went to mimic it.

In Trumpworld, propaganda is obsolete because truth itself is a fungible, ever-shifting commodity. It’s a thoroughly modern (indeed a postmodern) idea, but at the same time a very ancient one. In classical Greece, truth came from oracles that spoke through priestesses in a trance, and in Rome there was — and still is — a Mouth of Truth that would give you the honest lowdown. In the America of our entranced present, truth is what comes out of the president’s mouth at any given moment, and since he sleeps little and tweets early, we have our truth of the day waiting for us before we wake.

Other despotisms — and, make no mistake, we are living in one — destroy a free press as the first order of business. But Donald Trump likes having the media around; it is a perfect foil for him. It amplifies his message, and it gave him so much free publicity during his campaign for office that it might fairly be said to have elected him. Of course, the media spends much of its time trying to rebut Trump’s falsehoods, but in doing so, it necessarily transmits them and makes their very fakery the day’s news. All Trump has to do to draw the sting of such rebuttals is to proclaim them to be false, or simply to pass over them entirely and move on to the next subject.

Hence the phenomenon of “fake news,” which is not what the Donald says but what is said in response to him. In the ensuing confusion, the only constant is the presidential mouth. As with the Delphic oracle, which usually spoke in riddles, it hardly matters what is said. Since it is the universal source, it is the ultimate reference point of truth and all versions of reality are defined either by or against it. Trump can contradict himself as often as he likes, and he likes to do it a lot. To keep the truth spinning is the best way to keep it from ever landing anywhere.

A case in point is the recent debacle over replacing Obamacare. The bill to do so failed on successive days to come up for a scheduled vote in the House of Representatives, and was then flatly withdrawn. Since Trump had made a show of lobbying hard for it at the last minute and even bragged about its passage as it was being pulled, the “fake” media naturally interpreted this as a major political setback. Not so, roared the Donald; it was all the fault of the House Freedom Caucus, or of the Democrats, or of Speaker Paul Ryan — in whom, the president said, he retained full confidence, even as he urged the country to tune in on the television commentator who called for his resignation.

But, hadn’t Trump made the repeal and replacement of Obamacare the highest priority of his administration? Not so, the President tweeted; repeal would come, but he had never promised it within the first sixty-four days of his administration. This was “true”; he had said it would happen not in nine weeks and a day, but in the very first week. And the bill hadn’t really failed at all, because a new and improved version (perhaps throwing 50 million Americans off insurance rolls instead of only the estimated 24?) would soon be ready: except that nobody seemed to be working on it, and, oh well, we were bombing Syria anyway.

This is what carnival shills do for a living; they switch the bait while you aren’t looking. It works for awhile, but what about four years? Trump’s approval ratings, which were in the mid-forties at the time of his inauguration, are in the mid- to upper thirties now. But he was a minority president to begin with, and the minority party he presides over, which controls both Houses of Congress despite being consistently outpolled on a national basis, has repeatedly proven its ability to control, if not govern, a country whose electoral majority repudiates it.

What Trump is demonstrating for us is that a dedicated core of voters who will stick with you no matter what is more than enough to offset a disaffected but rudderless majority. In a parliamentary system, there would be a designated opposition leader; in our presidential one, the losing party is nothing but a defeated one. Who speaks for the Democratic Party, such as it is? Hillary Clinton? Bernie Sanders? Elizabeth Warren? Chuck Schumer? Trump simply sucks all the air out of the room; there is no voice but his, and like it or not, it is the one you will hear.

But what keeps Trump’s core base with him? The hope is that his failure to restore vanished manufacturing jobs and his savage cuts in the public services his followers disproportionately rely on will ultimately disillusion them. “Saturday Night Live” just ran a skit about it. But I suspect the good people of West Virginia, Michigan and Tennessee will live on hope and promises for a good while, just as people will eat food without nourishment — will eat grass, as the peasants of the Old Regime did during famines — when nothing else is available. And a few hundred people at a staged rally for the faithful will beat hundreds of thousands with nowhere to march but to City Hall and back. Richard Nixon figured that out nearly fifty years ago.

We have come to this — government by a man whose definition of the truth is a successful lie, and for whom the secret of that success is to lie nonstop — through a long process of political and social betrayal. We were lied into war in Vietnam by a president who told us, falsely, that our ships had been attacked in the Gulf of Tonkin. We were lied into war in Iraq by another president who assured us of six hundred secret enemy missile sites where not a single one existed. We have been lied to, regularly, by banks, corporations, insurers and by universities too.

The final failure of our institutions is the brazen demagogue, whose moral squalor debases the very language we use and that he utters only to abase. We don’t need a Hitler to burn our books for us; we need only a man whose proud boast is that he never reads one.

How far have we fallen? Even Richard Nixon felt the need to say that he was not a crook. Donald Trump said instead that he could shoot someone dead in the middle of Manhattan and not lose a vote.

So far, no one’s taken him up on that one. But neither has anyone given him the lie.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Lies trump the truth

Has Trump been involved with Russia?

Olivier Douliery: Abaca Press/TNS

Olivier Douliery: Abaca Press/TNS

Two Congressional committees, the one in the House at least temporarily sidelined by its chairman, Devin Nunes, are now investigating the question of Russian meddling in our 2016 election and the extent to which the Trump administration may or may not have been complicit in it.

The question is serious, but wrongly posed.

That the Russians did take a solicitous interest in our election can, I think, be stipulated. They are old hands at that, going back to their blatant manipulation of postwar elections in Eastern Europe that turned the region Communist within three years of the end of World War II. We were doing the same thing on our side of the Iron Curtain, insuring that our own preferred clients ran the show in Western Europe. We have not tolerated a government in the Western Hemisphere perceived as inimical to our interests since the announcement of the Monroe Doctrine in 1823, frequently making the point by invasion and occupation where subtler methods like bribery and assassination would not do. This is the way great powers tend to act, and, for the past hundred years at least, the United States has been Great Power Number One.

The Russians deny all charges about us, as one would naturally expect them to do. The principal charge is that they hacked the email accounts of the Democratic National Committee and of Hillary Clinton’s campaign chairman, John Podesta, releasing through third parties embarrassing if not terribly compromising information. The information was true, or at least not contested. The effect was trivial. No committee, certainly in a Republican-controlled Congress, would have bothered with the subject had there not been a more serious flip side, namely the suspicion that the Trump campaign was soliciting or receiving favors from the Kremlin, or having them extorted under threat of blackmail.

The ground of this suspicion was not only Donald Trump’s professed admiration for the autocratic rule of Vladimir Putin and his frequently expressed desire for collaborative relations with Russia. It went back to the murky involvement of Trump’s enterprises in Russia itself, the extraordinarily close connections of some of his key advisors with elements of Russia’s kleptocratic elite, and the unusual volume of communications traffic between Trump operatives and Russian counterparts.

This was complicated by Trump’s apparent devaluation of NATO, the military and political alliance that has been the linchpin of American foreign policy for nearly seventy years, and which remains the prime instrument in our dealings with Russia. Europe’s security — now both East and West — is entirely dependent on NATO, and NATO has also been the prime instrument for the West’s relentless expansion into the former Soviet sphere of influence, which culminated in the overthrow of the Russian-leaning government of Viktor Yanukovich in Ukraine in 2014.

An even modestly pro-Russian tilt by the Trump administration, therefore, would have seismic implications for America’s geopolitical position, and, while that has not yet been concretely evidenced, Trump’s coolness toward his NATO partners — the initial snub of the NATO foreign ministers meeting by his Secretary of State, Rex Tillerson, whose own business dealings are heavily invested in Russia, and Trump’s reported presentation of a “bill” for $300 billion in unpaid subsidies to Germany’s Chancellor, Angela Merkel — has understandably rattled Europe.

As always, such matters are less clear-cut than they look. Hillary Clinton, when Secretary of State, took a distinctly critical, not to say hostile view of Russian policy, and permitted herself comments on the Russian parliamentary elections of 2011 that were seen by the Kremlin as meddlesome at least, while at the same time her husband, Bill Clinton, was collecting $500,000 for a speech to a Russian bank closely tied to the government.

Paul Manafort, Trump’s campaign chairman during the critical period leading up to his presidential nomination, received tens of millions of dollars from a business relationship with Oleg Deripaska, described as one of the two or three most powerful oligarchs around Putin; yet the ubiquitous Bob Dole, the Republican Party’s standard-bearer in 1996 and the key figure in brokering the phone call from Taiwan’s president that triggered Trump’s first foreign policy crisis this year, had also lobbied the U.S. government for incidental favors, including a visa, on the same Deripaska’s behalf. There are a lot more sharks in these seas than fins that break the surface.          

We would know a lot more about Trump’s business dealings in Russia if he would release his tax returns, and that — rather than tax avoidance — is clearly the prime reason why he has not done so. We might also know a lot more about Trump’s relation to Putin if we knew why his ousted National Security Advisor, Mike Flynn, felt the necessity to lie to Vice President-elect Mike Pence about his conversations in December with Russian ambassador to the U.S., Sergei Kislyak (Flynn was also on various Russian payrolls), or why Trump advisor and Blackwater founder Eric Prince found it necessary to make a secret trip to the Seychelles Islands to establish a back channel between Trump and Putin only days before Trump’s presidential inauguration. What do you need a back channel for when you’re about to have a hot line?

We can only speculate for the moment where this web of clandestinity and deception may lead, but the operative principle should be the usual one, especially where Trump is concerned: Follow the money. The simple reality that faces us is that Trump is himself a Russian-style oligarch who happens to have been born in the U.S. and to possess American citizenship. Like other such oligarchs — one of whom was operating out of Trump Tower only three floors below Trump’s private suite — he specializes in gambling, legal or otherwise; kickbacks; money laundering; the plundering of public funds and assets; and, if he follows the pattern, fun and games with underage girls.

Of course, we had the Mafia in the White House with Kennedy, not to mention the girls; we had Halliburton with Cheney and the Bush clan in bed with the Saudi royals and so on. But we have never had a naked kleptocrat in our highest office before, who simply sees the presidency as a branding opportunity and a business killing. Those who have been waiting for Trump to become “presidential” — that is, to assume the duties and responsibilities of leading a world power and governing a nation of some 325 million — fail to realize that what they are seeing is Trump’s idea of the presidency.

It’s not enough, though, to note that Trump is a businessman who sees the White House as a personal profit center. To understand him fully, we need to look at the Russian oligarchic model. Under the Soviet system, the party elite maintained an exclusive control of capital and labor, creating a uniquely privileged governing class. When the system fell apart, this elite, rebranding itself as entrepreneurs, made off with the wealth of the nation: riches without responsibility. This created a model of perfect corruption, in which governing institutions were simply a means of facilitating plunder. That is the state that Vladimir Putin, himself by all reports fabulously rich, presides over.

No doubt Trump, whose own wealth is heavily leveraged, admires Putin the access to fortune that his virtually unchallenged authority gives him. No doubt, too, he would willingly dispense with all those impediments Putin does not have to deal with: a legislature that won’t simply do his bidding; an independent judiciary; a free press, or at least what monopoly has left of it.

When Congressmen balk him, he threatens to oust them; when judges rule against him, he questions the legitimacy of the bench; when the media trip him up, he accuses them of fake news — a category whose opposite is not truth, but propaganda. He neither has nor wishes to acquire any sense of constitutional government; he knows nothing of national economic policy or international diplomacy; he has no concept of any interest but his own. His promises, compounded of cynicism and ignorance, are lies before they leave his mouth. He’s the perfect oligarch, so perfect that he embarrasses the breed.

No doubt, Trump’s Russian connections are interesting. If they’re interesting enough, they could wind up as part of an impeachment proceeding. But in a sense they are beside the point. We’ve elected a president who thinks and acts like a thug, and where he’s learned his lessons or who he’s partnered with is finally unimportant.

He’s simply a public menace.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Has Trump been involved with Russia?

Ambition can’t wait but our salaries sure can

Photo courtesy of Drexel University

Photo courtesy of Drexel University

Opening the Internet on my home computer, I am frequently greeted by a headline in garish yellow: “Ambition Can’t Wait.” Unlike other advertisements that clutter my screen, this one has no off button.

The message, of course, is Drexel University’s. Someone designed it as a catchy institutional logo, and someone’s instructional or salary dollars — yours and mine, to be specific — paid for the consultants who dreamed it up.

Normally, unsolicited advertising isn’t worth the time it takes to avert your eyes from it. But perhaps we should spend a moment or two on the words of this particular message. They sum up Drexel’s present problems, and arguably those of academia in general.

Education does involve waiting, sometimes of an unwelcome kind. You wait for acceptance by the school of your choice, or the course or instructor you want. You wait for a dorm room, and you wait on grades. If you’re looking for a tenure-track job, you may as well be waiting forever.

But education is also about taking time.

It takes time to read a book or take a course. It takes time to think out a complex question in mathematics or philosophy. It takes a lifetime to acquire an education that, if you understand what the term means, is and always will be incomplete, because it’s a process, not a credential. Education, in the deepest sense, is about learning how to wait productively, and taking the time you need. It’s about slowing down so you can understand something, not speeding up to catch it.

Maybe ambition can’t wait, though often it probably should. But education has to wait. Rush past it and you’re an ignoramus with a degree. Get where you want in a hurry and you may find it’s not where you wanted to go.

So, “Ambition Can’t Wait” is not only a stupid slogan, it’s empty in the way most advertising slogans are. Applied to higher education, it’s just about the opposite of what you should be looking for.

Universities used to run on a slower clock, the one provided in lectures and seminars, in study by the lamp and in the arduous process of cracking problems or writing books and papers. Then administrators took them over and put them on corporate time, which is result and not quality oriented, and defined quintessentially by the buck. Ambitious administrators are the ones who can’t wait. They didn’t at Drexel.

Now we’re about to find out the price.

Several years ago, pressed to increase admissions and therefore revenue, some of those administrators decided to solicit as many student applications as possible, regardless of quality. The idea was that yield would go up as the quality went down. That meant admitting students unlikely to stay long and in many cases certain to fail. Their money, though, was as good as anyone else’s, and even if the cash flow didn’t last, there’d always be the next cohort to pick up the slack.

This policy was (a) immoral, and (b) stupid.

It was immoral, because accepting students you know are likely to fail is cheating them not only of their money but of their hopes and dreams. It was stupid, because the most elementary acquaintance with higher education will tell you it is a recipe for economic as well as academic disaster.

Underqualified students drag down the experience of education for everyone, students and teachers alike. They clog remedial classes at pointless trouble and expense. They are sold the prospect of success by those who know they are doomed to failure.

In the end, too, they sink the ship. Academic recruitment is a competitive business, and it doesn’t take long before word of your con gets around. Good students are forewarned, and stay away. Your academic rating sinks, and your reputation — hard to build, easy to lose, and twice as hard to recover — suffers. It’s a Ponzi scheme in which the ultimate loser is the university itself.

The scheme was hatched in the previous Drexel administration. Everyone had a hand in it. Administrators devised it. The Board of Trustees licensed it. The faculty tolerated it. The present administration finally stopped it, but that should have been its business from day one.

Let’s just say, though, that there’s plenty of blame to go around. University administrators admit students, but the faculty’s job is to monitor those admissions and make sure they not only maintain the academic level of the institution but strive to improve it. In this as in so many other matters related to its governance responsibilities, Drexel’s faculty laid down on the job. There are reasons for this, to be sure, beginning with a long tradition of faculty quiescence and with a Faculty Senate unworthy of the name.

But there’s no excuse.

The result of this sorry tale is damage to the university, both short and long-term. The long-term damage is to its reputation, and to the programs that will suffer or perish with belt-tightening. The present damage is to its current operations, specifically its budget. The necessity to ratchet up admissions standards led to problems last year, and a precipitous decline in what clearly were recklessly inflated enrollment expectations for this past fall. As usual at Drexel, the budgetary problems were passed down the line to individual colleges and programs.

The least one can expect of the administration at this point is candor. Secrecy and evasion are the watchwords instead. The first shoe dropped in December, when faculty annual salaries above $75,000 were frozen. The news of this came on a late Friday afternoon dump after the end of the fall quarter, with many faculty already dispersed on Christmas break.

The second shoe is dropping as I speak, and it looks to be a good deal heavier. But since the senior administration doesn’t want to be the bearer of bad news — or responsibility — it is leaving it to smaller fry to deal with it in a swirl of supposition and rumor. It’s always great for morale when the boss cops out.

Among the rumored changes are those affecting senior faculty, of whom I am one.

A plan has been bruited that would cut all medical benefit contributions to retirees, currently ranging from $3,600 to $7,200 a year, effective July 1. Those contributions were reduced from previous minimums of $400 a month to $300, so they’ve already been slashed by a quarter while medical premiums, of course, have continued to rise. Faculty who retire by June 30 would keep their benefits (for now), and also receive a lump sum retirement payment of 75 percent of their annual salary (up from the current 50 percent, but down from the 100 percent customarily paid out until 2013).

Start cleaning out those desks, guys! Ain’t it great to feel appreciated?

Rumor, of course, has a purpose: it is to spread fear. Fear creates anxiety, and anxiety breeds docility. When the actual news comes, maybe it’s not as bad as you thought, or, if it is, you can be glad it’s not worse.

There’s another way to make painful decisions, and that is collaboratively, with the participation of university stakeholders that builds a consensus based on fairness, openness, acceptance of responsibility, and a plan going forward.

The president could start by coming clean about the figures, addressing a university assembly, and taking direct questions. It’s a suggestion he might consider. But if things are done in the more usual way, administrative culprits will seek to cover their backsides, and the Faculty Senate will be left to carry out the bedpans.  

Stay tuned.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ambition can’t wait but our salaries sure can

To impeach or not to impeach

Aude Guerrucci: Sipa USA/TNS

Aude Guerrucci: Sipa USA/TNS

Almost every day, I get an invitation in my computer mailbox to join a petition calling for the impeachment of Donald Trump. How it is that I have been identified as someone who does not subscribe to Breitbart News I do not know, but I have thus far refrained from signing on. This is not because I have not made up my mind about the subject, but because I am of several minds about it.

I have said previously that I regard Trump’s election as illegitimate because his victory in swing states was enabled by voter suppression, but that is not to say it was illegal: voter suppression is an old and honored tradition that both of our major parties have followed, and the Obama administration had been very slow to combat the particular brand of it exhibited in November, namely new ID requirements, a reduction in polling places in targeted areas, and the like.

We have Trump in office for many reasons, but the decisive one is that our political system is in general designed to discourage citizen participation, most notably voting, to the maximum feasible extent. This is completely wrong if democracy is at all right, but, as matters stand, it is not illegal. It is the essence of what we have actually established by law.

The question of impeachment, too, is a legal matter, although the Founding Fathers, so precise in other matters, were content to keep the grounds of impeachment as open as possible. “High crimes and misdemeanors” are what make a president removable from office, and what these mean in any given case are left to its judges, to wit the sitting representatives of the United States Congress, to define, specify and determine.

Impeachment is thus fundamentally a political process, carried out under color of law. It is a unique species of jurisdiction as applicable to a unique office, the presidency, whose powers are correspondingly elastic, but which reach — in the current state of play — from pardoning the Thanksgiving turkey to the potential annihilation of the human race.

The discussion about impeaching Trump began before he took office, for the simple reason that he was manifestly unfit for it. It has, to this point, devolved upon two principal issues: whether as president, Trump has violated the so-called Emoluments Clause of the Constitution, which broadly speaking prohibits public officers from receiving gifts from foreign states and using their office as a tool of personal profit; and whether, during the course of his presidential campaign and since, he has permitted, encouraged, or colluded with a foreign power bent on interfering with the domestic political process. These issues are separable, but they also overlap. They encompass corruption on the one hand, and treason on the other.

The question of emoluments would appear straightforward. Trump, principally through members of his immediate family, continues to operate a commercial enterprise that does business in thirty-odd countries. He has stated that he has, or will divorce himself from direct management of this enterprise, but he has not made public the instruments by which his role is to be defined: or, rather, he showed a large table of boxes at a press briefing which purported to contain these instruments, but refused to allow the contents be examined. It would be difficult to say whether the moment was more Dickensian or Kafkaesque. Dickensian, because the notion of a power of attorney spread out in unmarked heaps of paper was as ribald as a High Victorian belly-laugh; Kafkaesque, because the farce was played out with completely straight faces by all concerned. Impeachment was designed to deal with abuses of power; it was not meant to navigate the Land of Oz.

Trump’s response to criticism of this spectacle was that nothing obliges him to divest himself of any private business because the president is exempt from conflict of interest rules to begin with. This appears to be his own take on the Nixon doctrine that if the president does it, it’s not illegal. On the other hand, if the Constitution actually does apply to him, then he has certainly been guilty of violating both the spirit and the letter of the Emoluments Clause from day one of his election. A Congressional impeachment committee armed with subpoena powers would, I am sure, have little difficulty documenting this.

The other issue is the Russian Connection. It is not surprising that Trump should have long expressed admiration for Vladimir Putin, who is exactly the kind of unfettered autocrat Trump fantasizes himself being, who by report has made himself personally rich beyond even The Donald’s dreams, and whose critics are subject to far harsher sanctions than early morning tweets. But there is also the question of how much Trump himself, and some of his closest aides, are financially invested in Russia; how much Trump may imagine a Russian-American condominium to rule Europe and the Middle East and constrain the ambitions of China in Asia and elsewhere; and how much Trump’s election campaign may have courted, benefited from, and even co-orchestrated the alleged Russian hacking of Hillary Clinton’s campaign communications as well as those of the Democratic National Committee.

On the first of these matters, Trump now states that he has and has had no business interests in Russia, his former hosting of a Miss Universe pageant in Moscow notwithstanding. This assertion was given the lie nearly a decade ago by his son, Donald Jr., who said that the Trump organization received a significant revenue stream from its Russian operations. The release of Trump’s tax returns would presumably shed light on the subject, but Trump has of course withheld them, with the support of Congressional Republicans who have circled the wagons around the Dear Leader of their party.

We do know that his former campaign manager, Paul Manafort, had such close personal ties with the Russians that he was forced to resign from the campaign last summer, and that his most peculiar choice for secretary of state, Rex Tillerson, the CEO of Exxon Mobil, was on such chummy business and personal terms with Putin that he was given a merit badge for friendship. Needless to say, such relationships implicate not only personal fortunes but public policy. Meanwhile, Trump’s national security advisor, Mike Flynn, was forced to resign three weeks into the administration for concealing his backdoor contacts with Russia’s seemingly ubiquitous U.S. ambassador, Sergei Kislyak, and his new attorney general, Jeff Sessions, has been similarly caught out.

If all this is not proof positive of sinister collusion, there is Trump’s own breezy invitation to the Russians to hack away further at Hillary last July, when the first damaging leaks about her campaign were coming out. To some, that might have seemed a jest at the time; from what we know now, it clearly bears further investigation.

Here’s where the treason part comes in. To be sure, the U.S. has little ground to be calling any kettle black on the subject of foreign interference in elections; by bullet or ballot, we have removed candidates and actual national leaders whom we deemed inimical to our interests across five continents over the past seven decades. This includes Russian allies or figures in Near Abroad states critical to its security such as Ukraine, and so turn-about in an election of our own would only be fair play from the Kremlin’s point of view. The issue, though, is what and when Trump and his team knew of such actions, and what quid pro quo may have been offered to ensure that his campaign remained the beneficiary and not the victim of Russian hacking. That would be conspiracy with a foreign power to tamper in a domestic election, which is treason with a capital T.

We don’t know for sure that Russian hacking did occur, the assertions of the CIA and other intelligence agencies notwithstanding; no public proof has yet been offered. Subpoenaed records and testimony under oath would presumably shed light on the matter, and an independent inquiry has been called for. Such things take time, however. To be sure, there appear to be a number of other issues that could rise to the level of impeachable offenses, such as the failure to duly execute the laws and the deliberate crippling of agencies designed to enforce them, the calling into disrepute of coequal branches of government, and so forth. But incompetence and name-calling are one thing; willful and demonstrable malfeasance are another. Impeachment needs a smoking gun, and, for the moment, the Russian Connection seems the best candidate.

There are, moreover, other considerations. The Republican Party establishment is trying to cope with a president it never wanted, and who brings it fresh embarrassment every day. On the other hand, it is also trying to exploit him in what Trump svengali Steve Bannon calls deconstructing “the administrative state,” by starving as many agencies and scuttling as many rules and regulations as possible, particularly those which protect the public and the environment from disaster capitalism. Trump is so outrageous that he can get away with the outrageous; and, besides, it would do the Party no good to scuttle him too early in the game. The process must be one of reaping the early harvest and then slowly distancing oneself from the ploughman. It’s easier said than done.

The Democrats, for their part, are none too anxious to have Mike Pence as president until the backlash to Republican policies has set in and he himself has been compromised sufficiently by his association with Trump. I’d like to see that happen too, because killing off the Republican Party in its present form has long been high on my wish list, with seeking the same fate for the Democratic establishment only a little further down. Unfortunately, a plague on all your houses is also a plague on the country itself, which I most certainly do not wish. Hence my several minds

Trump still has a large and supportive constituency, and it would be useful for it to be disabused of his promises to it, notably on jobs, before he has to go. On the other side, the wave of progressive resistance he has generated — the populism of the left — needs time to develop a substantive political base. From those perspectives, it would be useful if Trump could hang around a little longer. He is a perfect teaching tool on the consequences of an unreformed political system.

These are luxuries, however, the country may be unable to afford. Trump is too dangerous and irresponsible, too damaging to the country on every level, and too insupportable to bear for anyone who cares for it, to suffer for an hour. Events, too, are moving with great speed. Is it time to impeach Trump? It was never time to have elected him in the first place, and when we begin to pick up the pieces of this strangest episode in our national history, we will have to reflect seriously on the broken politics that produced him.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on To impeach or not to impeach

When a liar speaks the truth

Marcus Yam: Los Angeles Times/TNS

Marcus Yam: Los Angeles Times/TNS

In writing about Donald Trump in these pages last spring, I pointed out that part of his appeal — and his value — lay in his willingness to drive sacred cows out of the barn. Trump, and no one else, said bluntly that the American working class had been sold out. He, and no one else, said that America was giving Europe, South Korea and Japan a nearly free ride on defense and wondered why. He, and no one else, said that demonizing Russia at the risk of a new Cold War was stupid and dangerous.

These things were true when he said them and they are true now.

If he didn’t understand that jawboning a few manufacturers and building a wall to keep out people who were already going the other way wasn’t a solution to the jobs crisis or that an oafish combination of isolationism and interventionism wasn’t the answer to our hyperextended empire, well, it’s clear enough that The Donald doesn’t understand much about global economics or geopolitics. But, like the small boy at the party who points out that the host’s wig is askew or the hostess’ dress is undone, he did say the embarrassingly obvious.

Nothing, though, got the Establishment’s dander up like the now-famous response Trump gave to Bill O’Reilly when O’Reilly characterized Vladimir Putin as a “killer” and asked Trump why he was so anxious to cozy up to him: “There are a lot of killers. We’ve got a lot of killers. What do you think? Our country is so innocent?”

Now, Trump’s remark wasn’t very nuanced; he doesn’t do nuance. But if one implication of it is that we do our share of wet work and more, let the record show — as it does — that we have indeed been in the killing business for a good while, sometimes under cover of war and sometimes not. Let’s not forget the heads of states with whom we were not at war whom we have assassinated or colluded in assassinating, including Rafael Trujillo, Patrice Lumumba, and Salvador Allende, or those we failed to, although not for lack of trying, like Fidel Castro. In the case of Ngo Dinh Diem, remember, we let a supposed ally be killed. Not a terribly innocent sort of thing to do.

Editorialists across the country piled on Trump for his comment, as did Democratic Party leaders and even some Republicans such as John McCain, who seems to be the self-appointed defender of American righteousness these days. But Trump did get, if not support, then at least acknowledgment from a standard-bearer of the anti-imperialist left, Noam Chomsky. “When a Mafia don says, ‘hey, we kill people too,’” Chomsky observed, “I’m not overwhelmed, though it may be salutary in the context of the prevailing culture of denial.”

If I read Chomsky right, this is an off-handed way of saying that Trump is telling what Al Gore would call an inconvenient truth. And how many days of the week do you hear a politician telling the truth, especially about the secrets of the kingdom?

This truth-telling business, though, can be a catchy thing, especially if the Don says it’s okay. We have the Democrats (with, again, some Republicans) wanting to get to the bottom of Russia’s alleged interference in the November elections, cheered on by what Trump likes to call the fake news media. Well, Russia may have had some monkey business going on, and maybe it’s fiddling around in the Dutch and French elections — who knows, and, more to the point, why not?

Charles Grassley, the Iowa Republican senator, points out that our own meddling in European elections goes back to 1948, a point I made recently myself and with reference to the same specific election in Italy. Who knew that Republicans remembered history? Of course, Sen. Grassley was decorous enough not to mention elections we turned by assassination, as in Chile, but the point remains: if we’ve been making ourselves a party to other people’s elections for 70 years, why shouldn’t Russia have the same privilege?

Benjamin Netanyahu infuriated Barack Obama when he expressed a preference in our 2012 elections and then addressed Congress without a by-your-leave from the White House; Obama didn’t mention the money — our money — he funneled into the opposition to Netanyahu’s own 2015 campaign. Nor did Hillary Clinton seem to remember questioning the 2011 Russian parliamentary elections while serving as secretary of state when she complained that Russia had hacked her emails. It’s a different story when your ox gets gored.

The linchpin of our hyped-up Cold War with Russia has been its “invasion” of Ukraine and its subsequent annexation of the historically Russian Crimea. The villainy of this has been an article of faith in both parties, but now Rep. Dana Rohrabacher of California, like Sen. Grassley, a long-time eminence grise of Republican politics, blurts out what only isolated commentators like the Princeton scholar Stephen Cohen (and yours truly) have been saying all along: “I don’t think Putin started this. I believe the West started it when they overthrew a pro-Russian democratically-elected government that was on Russia’s border.” Sacre bleu! (These quotations are courtesy of Jeet Heer’s article in The Atlantic.) What can we expect next if our elected representatives start telling it like it is?

I don’t expect such candor to last very long. As I write, Mike Pence, Trump’s designated shovel brigade, has just finished assuring European leaders in Munich that we remain fully committed to our coup in Ukraine and our unwavering support for sanctions against Moscow. Trump, of course, has vociferously questioned those very sanctions, saying the darndest things but walking them back as soon as the more-or-less adults who surround his playpen, Pence, Rex Tillerson and James Mattis, tell him it’s time to chill.

Like all small children, The Donald is a fantasist, but he’s already made his apologies to China, South Korea and Japan, and he’ll soon get used to humble pie if not necessarily fond of it. (No apologies to Mexico yet, but the point of Mexico is having a country you never have to apologize to.)

Mind you, just because Trump says we’re no innocents doesn’t mean he intends to be one himself. He took the handoff smoothly from Obama’s Terror Tuesdays and implemented a half-baked military operation in Yemen, supposedly to get computer files, that cost a $75 million helicopter, the life of a Navy Seal and thirty-odd Yemeni civilians, women and children included. One of them was an eight-year-old girl whose photograph, plastered on the Internet, showed a buoyantly smiling child sitting on a step with a big red bow in her hair. That smile and that bow kind of got to me, especially when the girl’s identity was revealed. She was Nora al-Awlaki, the daughter of Anwar al-Awlaki, an American citizen who did broadcasts for Al Qaeda (which means that Nora was an American citizen too). Awlaki was targeted for assassination by Obama, and the hit was carried out by a drone in 2011.

A few days later, his 16-year-old son, Abdulrahman, was killed in another drone strike, along with a nephew of Awlaki’s. No one had accused Abdulrahman, also, of course, an American citizen, of any connection to terrorist activities. I suppose no one will accuse Nora either. Just a little more collateral damage in the War on Terror and the U.S. Constitution.

The American empire is safe and well with Donald Trump.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When a liar speaks the truth

Donald Trump and the unmaking of the American worker

Olivier Douliery: Abaca Press

Olivier Douliery: Abaca Press/TNS

In a world of lies, it’s sometimes best to seek truth from the devil. It’s true, he’s the Prince of Lies, but the best principle for lying is to occasionally tell the truth — it keeps the opposition off balance. That is what t I found in a Wall Street Journal article the other day, a confession of rare candor: “Never before have American companies tried so hard to employ so few people.”

The article went on to describe the well-known phenomenon of CTV, the outsourcing of the day-to-day functions of the modern corporation to contract labor, temporary workers and outside vendors, leaving only a skeleton crew of management and a few, key brain-workers as the actual staff.

Silicon Valley companies, valued in the billions but with little more than a Friday night poker club on the core payroll, are the paradigm of such worker-free businesses, but the model has spread, and the future is clear: not simply a world of atomized temp labor, on-call around the world and around the clock, but the robot, who guides you through most business calls you make and, in the friendly voice of Alexa, most decisions you take as well.

The jobless world is here. The problem is what to do with humans.

That’s where Donald Trump came in. Politics is where the mess of every society winds up.

The Democratic Party hitched its star to the American worker in the Great Depression. Automation had already made inroads into labor on the assembly line, but the war-stimulated economy of the 1940s — an economy whose product was death and its delivery systems — put a temporary, if illusory, end to the problem of unemployment. What emerged, in the afterglow of atomic victory, was something the Americans called (with no apologies to Rousseau) the social contract.

The idea was that union-organized workers and corporate management would cut a deal, exchanging labor peace in return for long-term employment at wages and benefits sufficient to offer entry into that pipe-dream of sociologists, the middle class. Government would play the honest broker in this arrangement, mediating disputes and backstopping economic downturns. The military-industrial complex would also make it the consumer of last resort, piling up generations of bombs and missiles whose object was non-utility.

This arrangement, full of suspended bad faith on all sides, lasted for the generation in which the American economy dominated the world market. By the 1970s, that halcyon era had gone. The famous falling rate of profit had returned, and the squeeze was put on workers. Their unions, grown lazy and corrupt, could no longer protect them, and they quickly vanished. The Democratic Party quietly disavowed them, while the Republican Party of Nixon and Reagan opportunistically channeled their discontent into symbolic social causes and, in the rise of megachurches, mainlined that classic opiate of the people, religion. When these did not suffice to contain populist anger, real drugs were mainlined, with Richard Nixon’s “war on drugs” serving as the best advertising campaign the Colombian and Mexican cartels ever had, and George W. Bush’s invasion of Afghanistan opening up the poppy pipeline.

Still, all this was absent of what the situation obviously called for: a genuine villain. That was introduced in the bogeyman of Big Government, a.k.a. the Welfare State, which for some bizarre reason had begun privileging the lazy, the idle and, of course, the black, against the hardworking Anglo-Saxon working class. It is a well-known principle of sociology, and one that happens to contain an actual kernel of truth, that class resentment tends to focus downward rather than upward, and that fear of the guy on the rung just below you generates far more psychological investment than anger toward the lordly billionaires in their unimaginable splendor at the top.

The Democratic Party, meanwhile, completed its suicide mission by nominating an African-American presidential candidate. This had the result of creating one of the tensest racial environments in the country since the Civil War and Reconstruction.

By the early years of the new century, however, the Republican narrative had begun to go threadbare, and with the double calamity of two failed wars and the biggest financial crash since the Great Depression, a fresh approach was needed. This came in the form of the Tea Party, ostensibly a bottoms-up repudiation of the fake nostrums peddled by both major political parties, but, as we now know, in actuality a carefully orchestrated campaign of pseudo-populism bankrolled by the likes of the Koch brothers. Its success was an important political tipping-point. It marked the supersession of both political parties (long since ideologically blended as one) except as figurehead entities. No politician was to be trusted, since government itself had now been defined as the enemy of the people. A savior could only come from the outside.

Enter Donald Trump, the businessman, as the hero. The road to Trump was paved by 30 years of Reaganite mythologizing. Good jobs, employment security and guaranteed pensions vanishing?

Big government was to blame, stifling the entrepreneurial genius of the “job-creators” in a mass of regulation and sucking up capital in high taxes to feed the Washington swamp and succor Welfare Queens. Bill Clinton dismantled welfare and cut the cord that enabled banks and investment houses to indulge in the orgy of greed that brought us the crash of 2008; good jobs did not return. The temporary solution was obvious: a crash program to repair and modernize the transportation and telecommunications infrastructure put in place by the New Deal and to replace the fossil fuels devastating the environment with green energy.

But such capital-intensive (and profit-deferred) projects required government investment, and government, remember, had been successfully defined as the enemy. So the Obama years passed, with nothing done, in my opinion, hash-slinging replacing once-unionized factory jobs, and the federal minimum — forget about living — wage stuck exactly where it had been, at $7.25 an hour.

Trump offered empathy for the unemployed blue collar workers of the Rust Belt and a promise to restore its former prosperity. He jawboned a few corporations into not killing a few jobs here and there slated for export, at least temporarily and with tax abatements that would make the transaction profitable. This provided a brief reprieve for a few thousand workers in a labor market of tens of millions stuck at historically low participation rates, where an uptick in monthly hiring brought an increase in the unemployment rate. At the same time, he stocked his Cabinet with billionaires infamous for job export and job-killing, home foreclosures and schemes to privatize the commons on behalf of Wall Street fly-by-nighters.

Trump also promised to help farmers, whom government subsidization has not prevented from going the way of the auk as giant agribusinesses monopolize American food production. Here, the villain in question was undocumented immigrant labor, and the solution was to deport eleven million such aliens—or perhaps two or three?—to clear jobs for Americans. Of course, Americans won’t work such jobs even for much higher wages than illegal immigrants, and they have long since abandoned this market. The only consequence of Trump’s immigration policies, apart from uprooted families and devastated communities, will be unpicked produce and much higher food prices. This is not to say, of course, that the exploitation of migrant labor is justifiable; importing such labor, like exporting factory jobs to foreign sweatshops, is just another way of reducing worker wages to subsistence level or below: precisely the consequence of unregulated markets described a century and a half ago by Karl Marx.

Trump, we may hope (but should not expect), is a nadir, and those beguiled by him will learn, painfully enough, how they’ve been hoaxed. That won’t do away with the underlying absence of a jobs policy in either major political party, the complexities of a global economy with staggering levels of capital concentration and income inequality or the more long-range, but no less pressing, questions of what “work” will be in a technologized world, and what kinds of activity (and compensation, both social and financial) will ultimately replace what has traditionally been defined as remunerative labor.

These are issues some other countries, for example Finland, have begun to address, but which our own current system almost forbids us to think about. What certainly isn’t going away anytime soon is the crisis of contemporary capitalism that continues to exploit such labor as is necessary as ruthlessly and efficiently as possible and leave those abandoned in its wake to their fates — and to the phony promises of politicians, or, in Trump’s case, a sleazy tycoon who regards public office as a glorified profit center and a stage for his dictatorial fantasies.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Donald Trump and the unmaking of the American worker