Author Archives | by Vivian Wilson

Opinion: Don’t sell history to the highest bidder

Amid the headlines we’re living through as United States citizens, and particularly as Minnesotans, one thing is clear: The internet and our culture are fundamentally unserious in the face of making history. 

We’ve endured a month of restless nights, bloodshot eyes and a state of blue-light-induced limbo. How could anyone get any real shuteye when hordes of LRAD-carrying law enforcement, protesters and green chemical irritants are just blocks away from their residence, in clear view just outside their bedside window?

I can’t be the only one who’s sat for hours in bed wide awake, crunching numbers, reading headlines and putting pieces together. In the wake of Operation Metro Surge, life feels markedly more precarious, where any next action taken could lead us stumbling through the floor. 

Late-night doomscrolls are compulsory now. 

On one of these, I came across what, in my opinion, is one of the most jarring social phenomena as of late. This particular short-form video featured a platform called Polymarket. It showed a poll for public opinion, not unlike those one might share on an Instagram story, asking what color to dye their hair or what restaurant to stop by for lunch. 

It was the subject matter that caught my eye alongside the betting prices. 

Right now, there’s a bet meant to gauge the exact date the U.S. will strike Iran. As of Feb. 9, about 3% of users have placed their bets on the present day.

Users of the platform are also predicting whether Jesus Christ will return before 2027. 

I might be old-fashioned, but the unabashed, public placing of bets on major foreign policy conflicts leaves a bad taste in my mouth. It feels like a satire of a bad dystopia. Following the inundation of bad news we passively witnessed in our formative years, I cannot believe this is where we have ended up. 

I remember watching casualty-counting news tickers in the early 2010s, knowing there was a big, terrible world out there. During the past decade, we’ve morally reckoned with the sheer amount of bad news in our culture, as well as our responsibility regarding its consumption. 

So why is it we’re choosing to throw our hats in the ring now? We’ve not only given into the dissociation but are choosing to reap a profit from it, no matter how small. 

This is just downstream from sports betting, which was legalized in 2018. Since then, it’s skyrocketed in popularity, but not without its glaringly obvious problems as a result of the practice ultimately being just another avenue for gambling. 

Assistant professor at the University of Minnesota’s Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication Carolina Velloso said the reasoning for its legalization ultimately came from media companies and state governments realizing what had previously been relegated to the underground posed a real opportunity to increase revenue. 

“It’s out in the open and not operating in this underworld,” Velloso said. 

In under a decade, footballs have somehow morphed into bombs, and we’re still lining up to place our bets. 

A clear throughline can be traced. Polymarket was founded in 2020, and political betting reached its current prominence during the 2024 presidential election after a steady ascent through the 2010s. 

Velloso said bets on non-sport or non-game-related events are not unusual in sports betting itself, where spectators might bet on elements like national anthem duration. 

“It’s no longer taboo or even illegal to bet on sports, so it’s just sort of become the more prominent feature in the sports broadcasts themselves,” Velloso said. “We see a lot of commercials for these sports betting companies, sometimes even broadcasters will mention these companies if their station has a partnership with one of them.”

But who exactly is using this technology?

University second-year sport management student Josiah Johnson has a degree of familiarity with Polymarket, which calls itself the world’s largest prediction market. The controversial site just recently reclaimed its place in the U.S. market on Nov. 12, following a ban placed back in 2022. 

Johnson said not all bets are overly consequential, in his experience. 

“You can bet on stupid stuff like whether or not Trump’s gonna say airplane, or if JD Vance is gonna trip,” Johnson said 

The site doesn’t just deal with life-or-death, history-page-making phenomena. The site also includes sportsbetting and Bitcoin price predictions. 

“I have used Polymarket before to bet on how many tweets Elon Musk will tweet within a given set of days,” Johnson said. “Because honestly, in my opinion, that’s just free money.” 

It makes sense this market popped up. The notion of a fortune teller without a profit incentive lands squarely in the fantasy realm. The false sense of omniscience that comes with seeing public opinion change in real time is enticing as well. 

In a democracy, though, it’s hard to ignore that the masses are flooding to make quick returns on investments instead of feeling the power vested in us to sway history ourselves through civic duty. 

Have we sold out?

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Don’t sell history to the highest bidder

Opinion: Minneapolis is a city on a hill

Minnesota and the Twin Cities have become an ideological battleground for our nation’s future, the second time in five years. 

Following the brutalization of Twin Cities residents, including but not limited to the killings of Renee Nicole Good and Alex Pretti by federal agents as a result of Operation Metro Surge, thousands have taken to the streets to protest, including two general strikes last month calling for Immigration and Customs Enforcement to leave the state. 

We’ve had the spotlight thrust upon us before. On a national level, it may seem as if we only ever receive recognition or attention when we’re on fire. But when the headlines cool down, we’re consistently ranked as one of the best, most equitable states as far as quality of life goes. In fact, we were ranked fourth nationwide in that metric just last year. 

The Twin Cities metro area lies at the helm of a state that’s forever shaped its region and the nation for the better. This is no accident. Minnesota has a legislative tradition of promoting social welfare and a long history of protest. 

Bloody Friday, the historic general strike that helped catalyze the National Labor Relations Act and guaranteed workers’ right to organize, took place in the North Loop of Minneapolis. 

Minnesota has shaped our nation and region outside of social movements as well. We’ve established a historical precedent of providing for our neighbors and enacting policies that lead our nation by example. 

Director of the Master of Public Affairs program at the Humphrey School of Public Affairs, Steve Kelley, said, in addition to the Fortune 500 companies we’re home to, the Twin Cities and the state itself have been integral to the development of the entire upper Midwest due to its geography. 

“Minneapolis and St. Paul formed as sort of an economic hub for the whole Upper Midwest,” Kelley said. 

The region would look very different without Minnesota. 

University senior economic impact analyst Brigid Tuck said the state of Minnesota has a balanced and diverse economic output compared to some of our neighboring states, many of which rely more on oil or manufacturing. 

“Our economy, in a lot of ways, reflects the structure of the United States,” Tuck said. “That is often a positive for us in the sense that we can weather economic change pretty well.”  

Culturally, our great state is also unique for its commitment to community, social welfare and innovation. A real investment in and commitment to improving our quality of life has been foundational to our state. 

Minnesota was ranked sixth in the nation for life expectancy in 2021. We’re also recognized more generally as a beacon for healthcare, with 12 of our state’s hospitals ranked among the best in the United States. 

Kelley said our state has prioritized making healthcare more accessible, serving as a precursor to the Affordable Care Act.  

“From a policy perspective, Minnesota has had commitment, for example, to making health care more affordable and trying to reduce the number of people who are uninsured, and that led to MinnesotaCare,” Kelley said.

This is just one area in which we excel. 

Tuck said the state of Minnesota has stood out in recent years for its investment on the state level in clean energy. 

Minnesota’s Clean Electricity Standard, passed in 2023, requires electric utilities to be 100% carbon-free by 2040 and includes interim targets to keep on track. 

Our investment in our state and in its people shows up outside of just us. We’re leading the nation by example in trying times, as we always have, whether it be economically, industrially, scientifically, politically or culturally. 

“It’s not just a policy-level commitment,” Kelley said. “It also shows up at the local and community level, and I think that it’s also showing up in the response of people now to support their neighbors in the face of the presence of immigration agents in the state.” 

Now more than ever, our city and our state are a flashpoint for our future. We are everything this country could be.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Minneapolis is a city on a hill

Opinion: The new status symbol

The root cause behind some of the most absurd and unprecedented popular cultural phenomena of the past year, from Trisha Paytas’ supposed congressional bid to Pantone’s color of the year being announced as cloud dancer, is our desperate thirst for authenticity.

The accessibility of luxury aesthetics caused by fast fashion, combined with self-censorious internet era media training, has created an obsession with authentic and provocative public figures. Hallmarks of personality are becoming accessorized and made status symbols to all of our detriment.

As fast fashion and dupe culture democratize luxury aesthetics, which in turn are increasingly lackluster, the true signifier of status is no longer tied to the physical. We want what cannot be acquired with two-day shipping: an authentic, interesting personality. 

We vie for and pedestalize those who have what money cannot buy: star power. That hasn’t stopped us from trying.

Remember when influencers would intentionally scrape, step on and deface their designer handbags to give the impression of a lived-in, storied feel à la Jane Birkin or the Olsen twins? Or when over-the-top bag charms became the hottest new accessory, meant to signify an individualistic flair? 

How about the return of indie sleaze and the popularity of messy, party girl aesthetics in opposition to the clean girl? 

All of this links back to desperate signaling of being a person with charm and stories to tell. A person who’s lived a life where the most sought-after bags earn years of wear from casual usage, charms have accumulated from travels and time doesn’t allow for makeup removal. 

Our culture in the post-pandemic years has taught us by example that a life well-lived looks like isolation and walking on cloud-dancer white eggshells. 

In reaction, we’re clamoring toward anything real. Celebrities who speak candidly, or as if they haven’t been media trained, are gaining cult followings. This phenomenon made headlines, as exemplified by “Mean Girls” star Renée Rapp and her catchy, sometimes jaw-dropping interview quotes, which have gone viral multiple times and spawned multiple compilations, later inspiring her 2025 single “Leave Me Alone.” 

Her positive reception shows she’s a breath of fresh air in an age of internet hypervigilance. 

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said she’s seen anecdotally how public figures who go off script become so captivating. 

“The sense that I get from my Gen Z students is that they are tired of artifice,” DeFoster said. “They are tired of corporate statements that say nothing, that stand for nothing. They’re yearning for ideological authenticity and so when they get that, they respond to it really powerfully.”

The ability to directly oppose the artifice that’s baked into being a public figure is especially compelling and enviable.

University cultural studies and comparative literature professor Timothy Brennan said he has observed a fatigue with superficial pop culture in his students as well. 

“They’re no longer willing to settle for an ironic and sardonic pessimism, even cynicism that one finds on late-night TV, which is kind of like the limits of the social and political critique that’s allowed in this country,” Brennan said. 

Capturing the public’s attention through showing authenticity makes an individual look smarter and more apt to what’s going on.

The problem here is authenticity, worldliness and true expertise are not easily obtained. 

Someone can be loud and have lived a big life, but it does not necessarily grant them the status they claim or demand. Provocation and contrarianism are not legs to stand on, but they’re easy to identify and mimic. Just like it’s easy to drag a purse through some dirt on the way home from the mall. 

The deification of authenticity lurks behind the shadows of our most nonsensical pop cultural and political happenings. As mass culture pushes toward homogeneity, minimalism and optimization, we are seeing a growing, insatiable impulse to reject it in favor of literally anything else.

As we continue to worship and uplift personality for its own sake and mistake its presence for other stifled cultural and societal values, we will continue to see false prophets and make ourselves into them.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The new status symbol

Opinion: Expecting mothers should not have to fear the unexpected

Our cultural discomfort with reproductive health and the female sex is harming and misinforming us. Our unbalanced and disparate coverage and knowledge of what pregnancy and childbirth entail leave many of those who go through it feeling unprepared. 

Yet, we tend to either over- or under-sell what childbirth is really like. More than half of the people in the United States identify as women, and even with the declining birth rate, many plan to experience pregnancy and childbirth. 

University of Minnesota nursing student Reagan Rogers said she has seen expecting patients be completely blindsided by the process.

“It’s kind of a shell shock from what I’ve seen, at least in, like, my clinical experience,” Rogers said. “They sometimes don’t really know what they’ve gotten themselves into.”  

Certified professional midwife of 10 years and co-director of Roots Community Birth Center, Rachel Voigt, said giving birth always presents surprises to clients, even if they have had multiple pregnancies before. 

“Most people aren’t prepared to give birth because it’s such a kind of wild and unpredictable life event that has such a wide range of normal,” Voigt said. 

There has long been a stigma associated with the female sex and anatomy more generally, but particularly regarding sexual and reproductive health. The first pregnancy shown on sitcom television was in the early 1950s on “I Love Lucy.” 

It was an uphill battle to allow the visibly pregnant Lucille Ball on air in the first place, and because the word “pregnant” was not allowed to be said on air, Ball’s character was referred to as “expectant.” 

This stigma’s legacy lives on in our willful ignorance of the subject. Sex education programs vary by state, and only half the population currently in school is receiving bare-minimum sex education, according to a Rutgers researcher.

Rogers said pregnancy and childbirth, along with women’s health in general, aren’t taught equitably or comprehensively in educational settings. This stems from the fact that female anatomy and physiology aren’t studied enough.

“Not only are we not teaching it, but the research really isn’t there,” Rogers said.

Mainstream media portrayals of birth tend to vary greatly as well. 

Rogers added that pregnancy and childbirth are misrepresented on television in particular. 

“It seems like this beautiful, wonderful thing that, like, doesn’t really affect a person,” Rogers said. “Then they have this baby, and then childbirth was super easy and everyone was perfect.” 

Voigt said she once sent an email to “Grey’s Anatomy” creator and producer Shonda Rhimes after seeing an episode she felt showed pregnancy in a needlessly gruesome way.

“Inaccurate portrayals of pregnancy and birth on mainstream TV are anti-feminist and doing a disservice to pregnant people by fear-mongering and portraying things so wildly inaccurately,” Voigt said. 

Stories shared online by celebrities and everyday people alike recall experiences of hair falling out in clumps, tooth loss, vaginal tearing and varicose veins, just to name a few examples. Popular narratives about the risks of pregnancy are often sensational and center on the ways that one’s body might become disfigured or less socially valuable than before pregnancy. 

A viral concern for expecting people nowadays, as shown in before-and-after photos on platforms like TikTok and Instagram, is pregnancy nose, wherein a person’s nose swells in size, most noticeably toward the end of the third trimester.

This is seemingly a reaction to how serious risks and outcomes alongside pregnancy tend to be glossed over culturally. The sensational nature of these side effects draws curious viewers in and, given our low health literacy, paints a terrifying image of what pregnancy entails.

Many concerns about side effects are also aesthetically centered. Women are faced with the pressure to snap back to a pre-pregnancy weight and mommy makeovers have established a foothold in the cosmetic surgery industry. 

When accurate narratives are not portrayed, cases of rare or extreme health complications may be rendered more common than they would be otherwise. Why is it that a significant medical event, huge health risk and the reason for our species’ survival is so widely misrepresented and still somewhat misunderstood in the general population? 

Voigt said she works to handle the real risks with care, while still being honest and accurate with clients. 

“For example, if the stillbirth rate after 41 weeks of gestation doubles, that sounds like a really big deal,” Voigt said. “But what the statistic really says is that the stillbirth rate goes from 0.5 per 100 people to one per 100 people, so it’s still a small chance. However, it’s a significant life event if someone were to experience that.” 

We owe it to ourselves to comprehensively research and learn about the effects of pregnancy to provide the most accurate and nuanced information and depictions of what creating life really entails. 

Fearmongering does not help anybody, nor does ignoring what risks there are. People deserve to know what they are getting themselves into, to prepare and act accordingly in order to properly expect the unexpected.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Expecting mothers should not have to fear the unexpected

Opinion: Expecting mothers should not have to fear the unexpected

Our cultural discomfort with reproductive health and the female sex is harming and misinforming us. Our unbalanced and disparate coverage and knowledge of what pregnancy and childbirth entail leave many of those who go through it feeling unprepared. 

Yet, we tend to either over- or under-sell what childbirth is really like. More than half of the people in the United States identify as women, and even with the declining birth rate, many plan to experience pregnancy and childbirth. 

University of Minnesota nursing student Reagan Rogers said she has seen expecting patients be completely blindsided by the process.

“It’s kind of a shell shock from what I’ve seen, at least in, like, my clinical experience,” Rogers said. “They sometimes don’t really know what they’ve gotten themselves into.”  

Certified professional midwife of 10 years and co-director of Roots Community Birth Center, Rachel Voigt, said giving birth always presents surprises to clients, even if they have had multiple pregnancies before. 

“Most people aren’t prepared to give birth because it’s such a kind of wild and unpredictable life event that has such a wide range of normal,” Voigt said. 

There has long been a stigma associated with the female sex and anatomy more generally, but particularly regarding sexual and reproductive health. The first pregnancy shown on sitcom television was in the early 1950s on “I Love Lucy.” 

It was an uphill battle to allow the visibly pregnant Lucille Ball on air in the first place, and because the word “pregnant” was not allowed to be said on air, Ball’s character was referred to as “expectant.” 

This stigma’s legacy lives on in our willful ignorance of the subject. Sex education programs vary by state, and only half the population currently in school is receiving bare-minimum sex education, according to a Rutgers researcher.

Rogers said pregnancy and childbirth, along with women’s health in general, aren’t taught equitably or comprehensively in educational settings. This stems from the fact that female anatomy and physiology aren’t studied enough.

“Not only are we not teaching it, but the research really isn’t there,” Rogers said.

Mainstream media portrayals of birth tend to vary greatly as well. 

Rogers added that pregnancy and childbirth are misrepresented on television in particular. 

“It seems like this beautiful, wonderful thing that, like, doesn’t really affect a person,” Rogers said. “Then they have this baby, and then childbirth was super easy and everyone was perfect.” 

Voigt said she once sent an email to “Grey’s Anatomy” creator and producer Shonda Rhimes after seeing an episode she felt showed pregnancy in a needlessly gruesome way.

“Inaccurate portrayals of pregnancy and birth on mainstream TV are anti-feminist and doing a disservice to pregnant people by fear-mongering and portraying things so wildly inaccurately,” Voigt said. 

Stories shared online by celebrities and everyday people alike recall experiences of hair falling out in clumps, tooth loss, vaginal tearing and varicose veins, just to name a few examples. Popular narratives about the risks of pregnancy are often sensational and center on the ways that one’s body might become disfigured or less socially valuable than before pregnancy. 

A viral concern for expecting people nowadays, as shown in before-and-after photos on platforms like TikTok and Instagram, is pregnancy nose, wherein a person’s nose swells in size, most noticeably toward the end of the third trimester.

This is seemingly a reaction to how serious risks and outcomes alongside pregnancy tend to be glossed over culturally. The sensational nature of these side effects draws curious viewers in and, given our low health literacy, paints a terrifying image of what pregnancy entails.

Many concerns about side effects are also aesthetically centered. Women are faced with the pressure to snap back to a pre-pregnancy weight and mommy makeovers have established a foothold in the cosmetic surgery industry. 

When accurate narratives are not portrayed, cases of rare or extreme health complications may be rendered more common than they would be otherwise. Why is it that a significant medical event, huge health risk and the reason for our species’ survival is so widely misrepresented and still somewhat misunderstood in the general population? 

Voigt said she works to handle the real risks with care, while still being honest and accurate with clients. 

“For example, if the stillbirth rate after 41 weeks of gestation doubles, that sounds like a really big deal,” Voigt said. “But what the statistic really says is that the stillbirth rate goes from 0.5 per 100 people to one per 100 people, so it’s still a small chance. However, it’s a significant life event if someone were to experience that.” 

We owe it to ourselves to comprehensively research and learn about the effects of pregnancy to provide the most accurate and nuanced information and depictions of what creating life really entails. 

Fearmongering does not help anybody, nor does ignoring what risks there are. People deserve to know what they are getting themselves into, to prepare and act accordingly in order to properly expect the unexpected.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Expecting mothers should not have to fear the unexpected

Opinion: ChatGPT is no oracle

When faced with a dilemma, who wouldn’t want to try their luck with a seemingly infinite answer machine? An interactive machine companion doesn’t sound like the worst idea.

We’re living in a time of “friendship recession,” where Americans today have fewer personal friendships and social support.

Recent data from the American Survey Center shows Americans have fewer close friendships now than they did previously, a number that began dwindling decades before the COVID-19 pandemic began. The survey found that 49% of Americans reported having three or fewer close friends. 

We also live in a country without socialized mental healthcare, where the depression rate remains at a historic high. 

Against all conventional wisdom and supposed right answers, this outpour of feeling in the absence of close friendship should not be directed toward artificial intelligence chatbots. We need to say no to answers that seem right and show respect to the indomitable human spirit. Like it or not, some things have no substitute. 

ChatGPT, released in November  2022 and arguably still the most mainstream household-name large language model, has its own Personal Problem Solver. As defined by IBM, Large Language Models are AI learning models that generate text in response to prompts, extracting from a database and breaking down large swaths of text into tokens, which are machine-learnable units. 

On paper, it sounds like a futuristic, ingenious idea: Synthesized data from other personal quandaries across the web, streamlined in a quick text quip, impersonal and objective. A robot oracle, or simply a listening ear. An optimized outsource of human interaction and social intelligence.

However, it’s not a suitable replacement. There is an ultimate human quality within advice. Objectivity isn’t everything, nor is it always useful or necessary.  

These AI chatbots are no confidantes, and they are certainly no therapists. Feelings are complicated, and there isn’t any formula or universal approach to most situations. 

Knowing which details and facts to parse out and which to hone is of utmost importance, and this comes from more than mere language, written or spoken. Body language, tone of voice and gestures all tell a story outside of the narrative being recalled, as does personal context and knowledge of the seeker. 

University of Minnesota second-year psychology Ph.D. student Caroline Armstrong said upon ChatGPT’s initial release, she input a friend’s dilemma just to see if it would line up with a real human response, to no avail. 

“I feel like it gave generic advice that was not necessarily more thoughtful than what I would be able to give her,” Armstrong said.

It’s not that it is going against its programming, or what it isn’t supposed to do. There’s a mismatch between consumer expectations and the capabilities of this technology. 

University first-year computer engineering student Ian Gantner said consulting ChatGPT for personal problems wouldn’t be of any help to him, so he’s never felt the urge. 

“I feel like it gives a net average response to like, if everyone in the world had that problem, you know, what’s the average thing that would work?” Gantner said. “So I don’t think it would work for me, because I don’t think the average works for most people.”  

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all approach to any problem, outside of conventional knowledge. If someone requires consultation on a personal matter to such a degree that they would consult a machine learning platform, chances are their quandary exceeds the limits of conventional wisdom. 

People are smart enough to know when they need help. What they need help with are not the facts of a situation but the in-betweens that can only be felt and perceived by a human witness or confidante. 

University computer science and engineering Ph.D. candidate Ash Milton said these chatbots cannot think, making them no substitute for human interaction.  

“It doesn’t have feelings, it can’t have empathy, it can’t have sympathy,” Milton said. “It can fake it real well, but it doesn’t actually have it.”

This tech is designed to be user-friendly. People are not. 

University first-year student William Marshall said he feels ChatGPT has ulterior motives and would prefer to talk to a peer about any personal dilemma that arises. 

“I don’t think it can actually figure out your situation,” Marshall said. “It’s just saying whatever it thinks will appease you and get you to keep using it.” 

Milton said validation should be handled delicately and at the discretion of a trained therapist. 

“A lot of the systems right now are very prompted to be validating,” Milton said. “But validation isn’t always good in specific cases, and a therapist knows that they know when validation is needed.”

Even with all of the correct programming and prompts for therapeutic uses, it doesn’t stack up to the real thing, Milton added.

“You can feed all the information to pass the certifications for therapy,” Milton said. “It might be able to do it, but at the end of the day, it’s not a person. It can’t think, it can’t have emotions.”

According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data, one in four U.S. adults says they don’t have social or emotional support. 

It seems we’re being backed into a corner where this tech is the only vestige of help. Something to talk to might seem better in the short term when someone isn’t an option. 

“You can get out your venting at something that’s a little bit more interactive than journaling is, and people can find that to be helpful,” Milton said. “There’s also the possible side of then kind of having this regression and this atrophy of being able to do your own emotional regulation.”

This technology should not be lauded for the purpose of social or interpersonal problem-solving or mental health support. Just because in some abstract sense it could help doesn’t mean it should. 

I don’t want to live in an automated, algorithmic dystopia where people can’t turn to each other or professionals when support is needed. 

Feelings can’t be outsourced.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: ChatGPT is no oracle

Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy

As a member of Generation Z, my memories of daytime TV are colored by sitting on the floor with my back against the couch, feeling my fuzzy sock-adorned feet plant in the shag carpet while watching “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” or “The Wendy Williams Show” on a sick day.

These programs, which ran through the early 2020s, saw their real peak notoriety in the 2010s, when many of us were just on the precipice of adolescence.

We weren’t the first generation to acquire this pastime. 

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said she fondly remembers indulging in 1990s daytime programming during her childhood. 

“It’s kind of the domain of, like, kids who are homesick from school,” DeFoster said. “You watch, like, Maury Povich and ‘The Ricki Lake Show.’” 

There’s a charm to these old programs. 

Kathie Lee Gifford and Hoda Kotb, cohosts of the “Today” show’s fourth hour from 2008 to 2019, have gained somewhat of a niche following for their out-of-context funny moments. Perhaps the most famous example is the Instagram account klgh_nocontext, with more than 61,000 followers and videos that have garnered millions of views. Comments express genuine shock, calling the program ahead of its time.

For the life of me, I just can’t think of a single program today with the same entertainment value or cultural hold. Daytime television today reads either overly niche or like background noise. 

We’ve also seen a lot of the nostalgic programs we’ve come to know, love and hate-watch die off. Kotb left “Today” earlier this year. The last episode of Ellen DeGeneres’ show aired in May 2022, and “The Wendy Williams Show” ended that same year. “Dr. Phil” followed in 2023. 

Watching the endless compilations, clips and cherry-picked funny moments through YouTube, TikTok and Instagram reels may satiate our appetite for scandalized and endearing programming through a greatest hits approach, but this is a means to an end. 

DeFoster said young people are not as interested in cable television when compared to their older counterparts. 

“So increasingly, we know that young people are cutting the cord,” DeFoster said. “They’re not subscribing to cable, and so that means they’re making up their pop culture diet by this hodgepodge of streaming services usually, and that’s starting to take on the role that traditional network TV and cable took.” 

Nowadays, programs seem to lag on, existing just as placeholders in the fading medium that is cable television, subsumed by the background noise it’s now becoming. A display of planned obsolescence and pure mediocrity, it has very little of the entertainment value it once held. 

Our generation was the last to experience good daytime and network programming. 

It’s not that we don’t have good television; it’s that it’s all hyper-curated and sold to us through the streaming circuit. The idea of such programming existing unto itself without needing to insist upon itself is now somewhat novel. These shows are advertised, probably just as shrewdly, but with a distinctly different flavor and approach. 

The idea of the program itself being an institution, not the carrier that delivers it to us, might be what’s missing here. These streaming services linger in the background. They roll off our tongues when listing our favorite shows and movies: It’s on Netflix, presented by Hulu, an HBO Original and so on. 

University first-year Tanner LaFavor said young people aren’t so much overly enthusiastic about streaming services as they are accepting of them because they’re so readily available. 

“I also don’t really think we like subscriptions either,” LaFavor said. “I think it’s a matter of what’s available to us, not necessarily general preference.”

Amidst growing complaints of the sheer volume of streaming services, as well as the price increases they’ve accumulated over the past few years, some cry for a return, or at least a consideration, of cable. 

DeFoster said it might not be totally over for cable. Young people could just prefer streaming due to their age rather than generational differences, a distinction that may make itself more apparent as our current television economy progresses. 

“I’ll be curious to see if there does come that tipping point where there are so many streaming services that audiences actually might find better value pivoting to cable,” DeFoster said. 

DeFoster compared network programming to Facebook, in that while it may not be the most trendy, it’s still largely popular and influential among older consumers. 

“I don’t think that cable or daytime television are ever going to completely go away,” DeFoster said. “I think it’s easy to sort of think of them as being obsolete if they’re not something that you consume.” 

Although it has undeniable staying power, quality should be considered. Some innovations have been proposed to revitalize the genre, which I hope will pick up speed. 

If streaming is going to become oversaturated and overpriced, like it’s projected to, there will be an inevitable return to what we once knew. I hope that when it does happen, we won’t be asking “Who is this even made for?” at the end of our cable exodus. 

It’s a sociologically relevant genre fading before our eyes. 

Watching its decline is saddening.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy

Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy

As a member of Generation Z, my memories of daytime TV are colored by sitting on the floor with my back against the couch, feeling my fuzzy sock-adorned feet plant in the shag carpet while watching “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” or “The Wendy Williams Show” on a sick day.

These programs, which ran through the early 2020s, saw their real peak notoriety in the 2010s, when many of us were just on the precipice of adolescence.

We weren’t the first generation to acquire this pastime. 

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said she fondly remembers indulging in 1990s daytime programming during her childhood. 

“It’s kind of the domain of, like, kids who are homesick from school,” DeFoster said. “You watch, like, Maury Povich and ‘The Ricki Lake Show.’” 

There’s a charm to these old programs. 

Kathie Lee Gifford and Hoda Kotb, cohosts of the “Today” show’s fourth hour from 2008 to 2019, have gained somewhat of a niche following for their out-of-context funny moments. Perhaps the most famous example is the Instagram account klgh_nocontext, with more than 61,000 followers and videos that have garnered millions of views. Comments express genuine shock, calling the program ahead of its time.

For the life of me, I just can’t think of a single program today with the same entertainment value or cultural hold. Daytime television today reads either overly niche or like background noise. 

We’ve also seen a lot of the nostalgic programs we’ve come to know, love and hate-watch die off. Kotb left “Today” earlier this year. The last episode of Ellen DeGeneres’ show aired in May 2022, and “The Wendy Williams Show” ended that same year. “Dr. Phil” followed in 2023. 

Watching the endless compilations, clips and cherry-picked funny moments through YouTube, TikTok and Instagram reels may satiate our appetite for scandalized and endearing programming through a greatest hits approach, but this is a means to an end. 

DeFoster said young people are not as interested in cable television when compared to their older counterparts. 

“So increasingly, we know that young people are cutting the cord,” DeFoster said. “They’re not subscribing to cable, and so that means they’re making up their pop culture diet by this hodgepodge of streaming services usually, and that’s starting to take on the role that traditional network TV and cable took.” 

Nowadays, programs seem to lag on, existing just as placeholders in the fading medium that is cable television, subsumed by the background noise it’s now becoming. A display of planned obsolescence and pure mediocrity, it has very little of the entertainment value it once held. 

Our generation was the last to experience good daytime and network programming. 

It’s not that we don’t have good television; it’s that it’s all hyper-curated and sold to us through the streaming circuit. The idea of such programming existing unto itself without needing to insist upon itself is now somewhat novel. These shows are advertised, probably just as shrewdly, but with a distinctly different flavor and approach. 

The idea of the program itself being an institution, not the carrier that delivers it to us, might be what’s missing here. These streaming services linger in the background. They roll off our tongues when listing our favorite shows and movies: It’s on Netflix, presented by Hulu, an HBO Original and so on. 

University first-year Tanner LaFavor said young people aren’t so much overly enthusiastic about streaming services as they are accepting of them because they’re so readily available. 

“I also don’t really think we like subscriptions either,” LaFavor said. “I think it’s a matter of what’s available to us, not necessarily general preference.”

Amidst growing complaints of the sheer volume of streaming services, as well as the price increases they’ve accumulated over the past few years, some cry for a return, or at least a consideration, of cable. 

DeFoster said it might not be totally over for cable. Young people could just prefer streaming due to their age rather than generational differences, a distinction that may make itself more apparent as our current television economy progresses. 

“I’ll be curious to see if there does come that tipping point where there are so many streaming services that audiences actually might find better value pivoting to cable,” DeFoster said. 

DeFoster compared network programming to Facebook, in that while it may not be the most trendy, it’s still largely popular and influential among older consumers. 

“I don’t think that cable or daytime television are ever going to completely go away,” DeFoster said. “I think it’s easy to sort of think of them as being obsolete if they’re not something that you consume.” 

Although it has undeniable staying power, quality should be considered. Some innovations have been proposed to revitalize the genre, which I hope will pick up speed. 

If streaming is going to become oversaturated and overpriced, like it’s projected to, there will be an inevitable return to what we once knew. I hope that when it does happen, we won’t be asking “Who is this even made for?” at the end of our cable exodus. 

It’s a sociologically relevant genre fading before our eyes. 

Watching its decline is saddening.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy

Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy

As a member of Generation Z, my memories of daytime TV are colored by sitting on the floor with my back against the couch, feeling my fuzzy sock-adorned feet plant in the shag carpet while watching “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” or “The Wendy Williams Show” on a sick day.

These programs, which ran through the early 2020s, saw their real peak notoriety in the 2010s, when many of us were just on the precipice of adolescence.

We weren’t the first generation to acquire this pastime. 

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said she fondly remembers indulging in 1990s daytime programming during her childhood. 

“It’s kind of the domain of, like, kids who are homesick from school,” DeFoster said. “You watch, like, Maury Povich and ‘The Ricki Lake Show.’” 

There’s a charm to these old programs. 

Kathie Lee Gifford and Hoda Kotb, cohosts of the “Today” show’s fourth hour from 2008 to 2019, have gained somewhat of a niche following for their out-of-context funny moments. Perhaps the most famous example is the Instagram account klgh_nocontext, with more than 61,000 followers and videos that have garnered millions of views. Comments express genuine shock, calling the program ahead of its time.

For the life of me, I just can’t think of a single program today with the same entertainment value or cultural hold. Daytime television today reads either overly niche or like background noise. 

We’ve also seen a lot of the nostalgic programs we’ve come to know, love and hate-watch die off. Kotb left “Today” earlier this year. The last episode of Ellen DeGeneres’ show aired in May 2022, and “The Wendy Williams Show” ended that same year. “Dr. Phil” followed in 2023. 

Watching the endless compilations, clips and cherry-picked funny moments through YouTube, TikTok and Instagram reels may satiate our appetite for scandalized and endearing programming through a greatest hits approach, but this is a means to an end. 

DeFoster said young people are not as interested in cable television when compared to their older counterparts. 

“So increasingly, we know that young people are cutting the cord,” DeFoster said. “They’re not subscribing to cable, and so that means they’re making up their pop culture diet by this hodgepodge of streaming services usually, and that’s starting to take on the role that traditional network TV and cable took.” 

Nowadays, programs seem to lag on, existing just as placeholders in the fading medium that is cable television, subsumed by the background noise it’s now becoming. A display of planned obsolescence and pure mediocrity, it has very little of the entertainment value it once held. 

Our generation was the last to experience good daytime and network programming. 

It’s not that we don’t have good television; it’s that it’s all hyper-curated and sold to us through the streaming circuit. The idea of such programming existing unto itself without needing to insist upon itself is now somewhat novel. These shows are advertised, probably just as shrewdly, but with a distinctly different flavor and approach. 

The idea of the program itself being an institution, not the carrier that delivers it to us, might be what’s missing here. These streaming services linger in the background. They roll off our tongues when listing our favorite shows and movies: It’s on Netflix, presented by Hulu, an HBO Original and so on. 

University first-year Tanner LaFavor said young people aren’t so much overly enthusiastic about streaming services as they are accepting of them because they’re so readily available. 

“I also don’t really think we like subscriptions either,” LaFavor said. “I think it’s a matter of what’s available to us, not necessarily general preference.”

Amidst growing complaints of the sheer volume of streaming services, as well as the price increases they’ve accumulated over the past few years, some cry for a return, or at least a consideration, of cable. 

DeFoster said it might not be totally over for cable. Young people could just prefer streaming due to their age rather than generational differences, a distinction that may make itself more apparent as our current television economy progresses. 

“I’ll be curious to see if there does come that tipping point where there are so many streaming services that audiences actually might find better value pivoting to cable,” DeFoster said. 

DeFoster compared network programming to Facebook, in that while it may not be the most trendy, it’s still largely popular and influential among older consumers. 

“I don’t think that cable or daytime television are ever going to completely go away,” DeFoster said. “I think it’s easy to sort of think of them as being obsolete if they’re not something that you consume.” 

Although it has undeniable staying power, quality should be considered. Some innovations have been proposed to revitalize the genre, which I hope will pick up speed. 

If streaming is going to become oversaturated and overpriced, like it’s projected to, there will be an inevitable return to what we once knew. I hope that when it does happen, we won’t be asking “Who is this even made for?” at the end of our cable exodus. 

It’s a sociologically relevant genre fading before our eyes. 

Watching its decline is saddening.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy

Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy

As a member of Generation Z, my memories of daytime TV are colored by sitting on the floor with my back against the couch, feeling my fuzzy sock-adorned feet plant in the shag carpet while watching “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” or “The Wendy Williams Show” on a sick day.

These programs, which ran through the early 2020s, saw their real peak notoriety in the 2010s, when many of us were just on the precipice of adolescence.

We weren’t the first generation to acquire this pastime. 

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said she fondly remembers indulging in 1990s daytime programming during her childhood. 

“It’s kind of the domain of, like, kids who are homesick from school,” DeFoster said. “You watch, like, Maury Povich and ‘The Ricki Lake Show.’” 

There’s a charm to these old programs. 

Kathie Lee Gifford and Hoda Kotb, cohosts of the “Today” show’s fourth hour from 2008 to 2019, have gained somewhat of a niche following for their out-of-context funny moments. Perhaps the most famous example is the Instagram account klgh_nocontext, with more than 61,000 followers and videos that have garnered millions of views. Comments express genuine shock, calling the program ahead of its time.

For the life of me, I just can’t think of a single program today with the same entertainment value or cultural hold. Daytime television today reads either overly niche or like background noise. 

We’ve also seen a lot of the nostalgic programs we’ve come to know, love and hate-watch die off. Kotb left “Today” earlier this year. The last episode of Ellen DeGeneres’ show aired in May 2022, and “The Wendy Williams Show” ended that same year. “Dr. Phil” followed in 2023. 

Watching the endless compilations, clips and cherry-picked funny moments through YouTube, TikTok and Instagram reels may satiate our appetite for scandalized and endearing programming through a greatest hits approach, but this is a means to an end. 

DeFoster said young people are not as interested in cable television when compared to their older counterparts. 

“So increasingly, we know that young people are cutting the cord,” DeFoster said. “They’re not subscribing to cable, and so that means they’re making up their pop culture diet by this hodgepodge of streaming services usually, and that’s starting to take on the role that traditional network TV and cable took.” 

Nowadays, programs seem to lag on, existing just as placeholders in the fading medium that is cable television, subsumed by the background noise it’s now becoming. A display of planned obsolescence and pure mediocrity, it has very little of the entertainment value it once held. 

Our generation was the last to experience good daytime and network programming. 

It’s not that we don’t have good television; it’s that it’s all hyper-curated and sold to us through the streaming circuit. The idea of such programming existing unto itself without needing to insist upon itself is now somewhat novel. These shows are advertised, probably just as shrewdly, but with a distinctly different flavor and approach. 

The idea of the program itself being an institution, not the carrier that delivers it to us, might be what’s missing here. These streaming services linger in the background. They roll off our tongues when listing our favorite shows and movies: It’s on Netflix, presented by Hulu, an HBO Original and so on. 

University first-year Tanner LaFavor said young people aren’t so much overly enthusiastic about streaming services as they are accepting of them because they’re so readily available. 

“I also don’t really think we like subscriptions either,” LaFavor said. “I think it’s a matter of what’s available to us, not necessarily general preference.”

Amidst growing complaints of the sheer volume of streaming services, as well as the price increases they’ve accumulated over the past few years, some cry for a return, or at least a consideration, of cable. 

DeFoster said it might not be totally over for cable. Young people could just prefer streaming due to their age rather than generational differences, a distinction that may make itself more apparent as our current television economy progresses. 

“I’ll be curious to see if there does come that tipping point where there are so many streaming services that audiences actually might find better value pivoting to cable,” DeFoster said. 

DeFoster compared network programming to Facebook, in that while it may not be the most trendy, it’s still largely popular and influential among older consumers. 

“I don’t think that cable or daytime television are ever going to completely go away,” DeFoster said. “I think it’s easy to sort of think of them as being obsolete if they’re not something that you consume.” 

Although it has undeniable staying power, quality should be considered. Some innovations have been proposed to revitalize the genre, which I hope will pick up speed. 

If streaming is going to become oversaturated and overpriced, like it’s projected to, there will be an inevitable return to what we once knew. I hope that when it does happen, we won’t be asking “Who is this even made for?” at the end of our cable exodus. 

It’s a sociologically relevant genre fading before our eyes. 

Watching its decline is saddening.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Daytime TV’s elegy