As a member of Generation Z, my memories of daytime TV are colored by sitting on the floor with my back against the couch, feeling my fuzzy sock-adorned feet plant in the shag carpet while watching “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” or “The Wendy Williams Show” on a sick day.
These programs, which ran through the early 2020s, saw their real peak notoriety in the 2010s, when many of us were just on the precipice of adolescence.
We weren’t the first generation to acquire this pastime.
University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said she fondly remembers indulging in 1990s daytime programming during her childhood.
“It’s kind of the domain of, like, kids who are homesick from school,” DeFoster said. “You watch, like, Maury Povich and ‘The Ricki Lake Show.’”
There’s a charm to these old programs.
Kathie Lee Gifford and Hoda Kotb, cohosts of the “Today” show’s fourth hour from 2008 to 2019, have gained somewhat of a niche following for their out-of-context funny moments. Perhaps the most famous example is the Instagram account klgh_nocontext, with more than 61,000 followers and videos that have garnered millions of views. Comments express genuine shock, calling the program ahead of its time.
For the life of me, I just can’t think of a single program today with the same entertainment value or cultural hold. Daytime television today reads either overly niche or like background noise.
We’ve also seen a lot of the nostalgic programs we’ve come to know, love and hate-watch die off. Kotb left “Today” earlier this year. The last episode of Ellen DeGeneres’ show aired in May 2022, and “The Wendy Williams Show” ended that same year. “Dr. Phil” followed in 2023.
Watching the endless compilations, clips and cherry-picked funny moments through YouTube, TikTok and Instagram reels may satiate our appetite for scandalized and endearing programming through a greatest hits approach, but this is a means to an end.
DeFoster said young people are not as interested in cable television when compared to their older counterparts.
“So increasingly, we know that young people are cutting the cord,” DeFoster said. “They’re not subscribing to cable, and so that means they’re making up their pop culture diet by this hodgepodge of streaming services usually, and that’s starting to take on the role that traditional network TV and cable took.”
Nowadays, programs seem to lag on, existing just as placeholders in the fading medium that is cable television, subsumed by the background noise it’s now becoming. A display of planned obsolescence and pure mediocrity, it has very little of the entertainment value it once held.
Our generation was the last to experience good daytime and network programming.
It’s not that we don’t have good television; it’s that it’s all hyper-curated and sold to us through the streaming circuit. The idea of such programming existing unto itself without needing to insist upon itself is now somewhat novel. These shows are advertised, probably just as shrewdly, but with a distinctly different flavor and approach.
The idea of the program itself being an institution, not the carrier that delivers it to us, might be what’s missing here. These streaming services linger in the background. They roll off our tongues when listing our favorite shows and movies: It’s on Netflix, presented by Hulu, an HBO Original and so on.
University first-year Tanner LaFavor said young people aren’t so much overly enthusiastic about streaming services as they are accepting of them because they’re so readily available.
“I also don’t really think we like subscriptions either,” LaFavor said. “I think it’s a matter of what’s available to us, not necessarily general preference.”
Amidst growing complaints of the sheer volume of streaming services, as well as the price increases they’ve accumulated over the past few years, some cry for a return, or at least a consideration, of cable.
DeFoster said it might not be totally over for cable. Young people could just prefer streaming due to their age rather than generational differences, a distinction that may make itself more apparent as our current television economy progresses.
“I’ll be curious to see if there does come that tipping point where there are so many streaming services that audiences actually might find better value pivoting to cable,” DeFoster said.
DeFoster compared network programming to Facebook, in that while it may not be the most trendy, it’s still largely popular and influential among older consumers.
“I don’t think that cable or daytime television are ever going to completely go away,” DeFoster said. “I think it’s easy to sort of think of them as being obsolete if they’re not something that you consume.”
Although it has undeniable staying power, quality should be considered. Some innovations have been proposed to revitalize the genre, which I hope will pick up speed.
If streaming is going to become oversaturated and overpriced, like it’s projected to, there will be an inevitable return to what we once knew. I hope that when it does happen, we won’t be asking “Who is this even made for?” at the end of our cable exodus.
It’s a sociologically relevant genre fading before our eyes.
Watching its decline is saddening.