Author Archives | by Shayne Tarquinio

Data centers are ‘flashpoint’ that UMN researchers are helping Minnesota navigate

Across the state, local governments and communities grapple with corporate development plans for data centers, drawing the attention of academic researchers. 

As physical manifestations of a global network of remote servers, known as the cloud, these facilities store, process and manage all of our digital data. While data centers have existed since the mid-1900s, the artificial intelligence boom demands exponentially more data storage, driving technology corporations to target towns across the U.S. 

For those who work in the energy sector currently, data centers are the center of gravity,  Gabe Chan, associate professor from the Hubert H. Humphrey School of Public Affairs, said.

“One of the big meta-challenges is that the energy sector is very complicated — there’s a lot of engineering, finance, economics, law and policy,” Chan said.

This complexity fuels public skepticism. Public sentiment toward data centers is increasingly negative, and it hasn’t always been this way, Chan said. Yet data center development has been eager here in Minnesota — cold winters mean lower energy costs — and sometimes, shrouded in secrecy.

“There is a need for education and capacity building so that communities can effectively engage in this technically complicated space,” Chan said. 

To fill this gap, University of Minnesota researchers are deploying their expertise. 

 

The data difficulty

Because data center infrastructure is diverse and constantly evolving, reliable third-party data is scarce. Even when companies provide environmental disclosures, the data is often insufficient or nonexistent.  

University environmental economics professor Stephen Polasky said the U.S. does not have strict corporate reporting requirements that make environmental disclosures mandatory. If companies do release energy use or water consumption reports, the accuracy of those reports comes into question. 

The problem is that a corporation has a vested financial interest in getting a project approved with minimal hassle, so they are unlikely to voluntarily highlight those energy and water vulnerabilities, Polasky said. Data provided by disinterested third parties is crucial to bridge this lack of transparency and trust.  

“People would trust the findings of, let’s say, a report coming out of the University of Minnesota than they would from a corporation,” Polasky said.

For instance, facilities rarely specify their water consumption. When a municipality supplies the water rather than the data center drawing its own, then the challenge becomes tracking, explicitly, the data center’s use. 

Hydrology professor John Nieber and Geosyntec engineer Nigel Pickering are using data centers as a case study for a state-funded project assessing the cumulative impacts of small and hyperscale facilities on local water systems.

While 20 years of state water records are available, the challenge lies in modeling the physical impact. The researchers are using LiDAR and GIS, which are mapping technologies, and Minnesota Department of Natural Resources data to map these subterranean effects.

The missing piece is transparent data from the tech companies on their exact internal water use, Pickering said, but the system could be built to ingest that data as soon as it becomes available. 

“Collecting the spatial information [isn’t] going to be a big challenge,” Nieber said. “The challenge is accurately accounting for the specific behavior of individual data center designs.”

Their tool will model how data centers consume and redistribute water, transforming unknown environmental risks into quantifiable metrics so communities can make informed choices.

The public’s environmental anxiety stems from a fundamental lack of clear information regarding what the real impacts will be, which naturally instills fear, Pickering added.

“Without having some sort of knowledge of what the impacts are, they’re not gonna want the data center at all,” Pickering said. 

In Minnesota, no one chooses their utility company. Some are concerned utility bills will increase due to the massive energy load data centers demand from a local grid if corporations are not paying their fair share.

“This is basic economic supply and demand,” Polasky said. “If you’re introducing massive new demands of electricity to the grid and the supply cannot keep pace, energy becomes scarcer and prices will inevitably rise.”

Polasky points to Northern Virginia and the mid-Atlantic states, where hyper-concentration has strained the grid and inflated consumer utility bills.

 

The equipped community

“Communities weigh these decisions all the time, figuring out whether to allow developments or not,” Polasky said. 

While offering attractive municipal tax revenues and short-term construction jobs, data centers also present complex burdens: industrial noise, infrastructure strain and long-term maintenance, said Polasky.

Seeking guidance, three southern Minnesota municipalities facing regional data center expansions approached the Regional Sustainable Development Partnership, routing the request to Humphrey School assistant professor Elise Harrington.

“They came to us saying, ‘We need better information on how local government should be thinking about this,’” Harrington said. 

Cities know how to make decisions for themselves, but, traditionally, local governments rarely engage deeply with matters of electricity and utility, said Harrington. 

Harrington and University law professor James Coleman are analyzing data center development around the country to create a decision-making toolkit for local leaders.

“Our role is not to advocate that local governments should be for or against data centers, but that they need the best information to make the right decision in close collaboration and coordination with their own residents and their own community members,” Harrington said. 

Designed as a customizable menu of options, the toolkit overlays a data-center lens onto existing municipal frameworks like land use, zoning and moratoria. However, because cities lack authority over major utilities, asking the right questions is vital. Water metrics are intuitive for cities operating local water utilities, Harrington noted, but navigating the electricity sector remains a significant blind spot.

“It’s important for any local government to know: here are the issues that are being raised about data centers in different ways, pro and con,” Harrington said. “So that you’re prepared to have those conversations, but also prepared to ask really good questions to everyone involved in the process.”

 

The role of trust

The goal of this research is not to stop data center development, said Nieber. Instead, the intent is a deeper understanding of the environmental impact. 

“What we want to do is to take an unbiased view and go in there and look at it scientifically, and come up with a result that we can defend before the public,” said Nieber. 

“Data centers are sort of a flashpoint,” Polasky said. “People are largely mistrusting large corporations and big government in general.” 

Harrington conceptualizes these challenges as information-based and relationship-based uncertainties. Information gaps — like baseline water and power consumption — can be resolved through independent research.

Academic research alone, though, cannot repair corporate-civil relationships, Harrington said, and one research project perhaps isn’t sufficient to answer all the questions people have about data centers.

“I hope that it provides some amount of transparency so that different folks within this can talk about some of the same things,” Harrington said. “Yet relationship-based uncertainty relies entirely on public discourse, relationships and trust.”

While data alone may not solve the crisis of trust, independent research ensures communities do not navigate this boom in the dark. 

“Figuring out the right response is a really important challenge for those who care about the environment, local government and deeply care about public processes and democracy,” Harrington said.

The post Data centers are ‘flashpoint’ that UMN researchers are helping Minnesota navigate appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Data centers are ‘flashpoint’ that UMN researchers are helping Minnesota navigate

Satire: Dear Diary, let me tell you about my first year of graduate school

Dear diary: Aug. 24, 2025

I just moved to Minneapolis for grad school! Everyone says amazing things about the Twin Cities. One of my friends even called it a “climate refuge,” whatever that means! Honestly, it was shocking to hear about the assassination of Minnesota representatives over the summer, and of course, my mind immediately imagined the George Floyd uprisings when I got accepted to the University of Minnesota. But I’m sure everything will be fine moving forward! What else could go wrong?

Dear diary: Aug. 26

Today was the second day of orientation for me and my fellow graduate instructors. It was already nauseating to think about instructing a classroom of 26 undergraduates. But the news hit early, and it was even harder to think about creating a syllabus or artificial intelligence expectations after that. A school shooting left two children dead.

Dear diary: Sept. 2

School started. Someone in my grad school group chat said the University career services were hosting a border control recruitment event. The message came with an email template to send to the administration to express disapproval, along with a reminder that ICE had detained an international student for two months the previous semester. 

Parking was crazy on campus.

Dear diary: Sept. 4

Taught my first class today! We had a whole chat about why AI and creative writing are incompatible. Also, embarrassing, but I had my first visit to the dentist’s office in a while (I get coverage through the program), and I need some work done. Thank goodness Boynton offers a convenient and accessible dental clinic on campus!

Dear diary: Sept. 9

Teamsters are striking! Don’t throw away the trash, or you’re crossing the picket line! 

Dear diary: Sept. 10

Conservative influencer Charlie Kirk was killed on a college campus, and a video of the shooting went viral on social media. It’s getting pretty ugly online between the right and the left right now, and most people didn’t even know who the guy was. I heard he sometimes carried his own branded hot sauce.  

Dear diary: Sept. 11

There’s a campus-wide shooting threat to people of color. My program canceled classes. The Department of African American and African Studies shut down for the day. The University administration doesn’t seem to think it’s a serious threat, though. 

Dear diary: Sept. 18

The poet CAConrad was visiting. I offered extra credit if my students attended. After the poetry reading, just as I was driving off campus, gunshots rang out. Some of my peers were stuck in the building; they had to shelter in place. The police were everywhere. 

Dear diary: Sept. 22

Turning Point USA hosted its first event after Kirk’s death right here at Northrop. The Handmaid’s Tale ladies faced off with the line of people in MAGA hats and “freedom” shirts. Security was thick. The auditorium was filled. My professor moved class to Zoom. 

Dear diary: Oct. 20

Sorry, it’s been so long since my last entry. Not many exciting things have happened, which actually feels like a good thing! Maybe the world is starting to calm down again!

Dear diary: Oct. 31

For my Halloween party, I pulled all the gothic black from my closet and went as a vampire. The worms on trays were not edible. 

A second entry tonight because a shooting in Dinkytown left someone dead. Since Dinkytown isn’t in the University’s jurisdiction, no SAFE-U alert went out to students. Students were everywhere, drunk and dressed in costumes. 

Dear diary: Nov. 5

I called out a student’s blatant use of AI today — felt good. 

Dear diary: Nov. 11

I saw the Northern Lights from my house! 

Dear diary: Dec. 6

Snow is insane. I am from Arizona. Driving in blizzards is crazy. Everyone just keeps telling me to watch out for ice. 

Dear diary: Dec. 11

Wow, the first semester of grad school is done. I got to see a lot of plays. But people were always telling me that this semester’s chaos was unprecedented! I hope that when we come back in January, things will be normal. 🙂 

Dear diary: Jan. 7, 2026

A woman named Renée Good was shot and killed by ICE in the front seat of her car today. It was filmed and went viral. Everyone has an opinion. It feels like ICE is everywhere. In my group chat, one friend said agents entered the elementary school where she works in an attempt to take children. Another friend said her neighbor and son-in-law had been detained. People are offering to get groceries for those who can’t. People are not leaving their homes. 

Dear diary: Jan. 23

I canceled our first class of the semester in support of the “ICE Out” strike. It’s negative 20 degrees, and people are still protesting. A “Classroom Safety for Instructors” visual was circulated this week. This was if ICE attempted to enter the classroom, asking for a student, which is a fear of many instructors. Number one on that infographic was for the instructor to stand between ICE and the students. Number five was for the instructor to de-escalate and ask for a subpoena. 

I made chili today.  

Dear diary: Jan. 24

A man named Alex Pretti was shot and killed by ICE outside of a donut shop. It was filmed. It seems like the outside world only knows Minneapolis because of viral violence. 

Dear diary: Jan. 30

If someone says “unprecedented times” one more time, I will quit. 

Dear diary: Feb. 12

The new border czar will pull 3,000 federal agents out of Minneapolis. Operation Metro Surge ended. 

Dear diary: Feb. 28

America goes to war with Iran. 

Dear diary: March 11

Boynton’s dental clinic is closing. 🙁

Dear diary: April 12

Our president posted an AI-generated image of him likened to Jesus Christ.

The post Satire: Dear Diary, let me tell you about my first year of graduate school appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Satire: Dear Diary, let me tell you about my first year of graduate school

Opinion: As the semester wraps up, ICE melted into the background

As the strain of finals approaches, Operation Metro Surge has become a stress of the semester’s past. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents were largely pulled out of the Twin Cities in February, and many University of Minnesota students endured the intensity while remaining dedicated to their education. 

Basically, this was the worst semester ever. But the surge didn’t stop students from having to write papers, turn in assignments, respond to discussion posts and attend labs. 

Sanskruti Sanjay Deshmukh, an international data science graduate student from India, said her transition to the United States was challenging, and she was often homesick. This winter was her first time seeing snow, and when the surge began, Deshmukh recalled feeling confused and frightened. 

“I don’t know what really that is, so I just try to stay at home, and that’s all,” Deshmukh said, referring to the surge.

Deshmukh said a professor offered to buy her groceries, and she also used the campus food bank. Her philosophy was to stay safe and stay positive.

“It was scary for me, but then every place have something weird going on anywhere you go, so I just feel like I can’t complain,” Deshmukh said.

Her education was worth any struggle, she added.

This semester, students learned how to balance their courses while living in a city under occupation. As I reported on how the surge was impacting our educational spaces, it became clear that students are privileged to a campus bubble. ICE presence was very much felt, but rarely experienced in a direct way.

Josefine Freltoft, a third-year international student majoring in chemistry, said her friends were there to support her and shop for her groceries during the height of the surge. 

“I didn’t feel like leaving the house when it was really bad,” Freltoft said. 

Freltoft described the pressure being everywhere on campus during Operation Metro Surge. 

“Walking outside, maybe you’re hearing the people whistling, and it’s, like, is that something I should be nervous about?” Freltoft said. “Walking into the classes, there’s flyers on the tables about ‘This is how you alert people around you.’” 

She described seeing a Snapchat story of students filming people getting dragged out of their vehicles by federal agents right outside their window.

“It definitely created a feeling of, ‘Wow, this is happening right here,’” Freltoft said. 

Freltoft is from Denmark, but that distinction from who ICE was targeting didn’t stop her from carrying her passport or other documentation with her. A lot of international students were doing the same, she said, even if it was just to feel safe. 

Zach Whittington, a fourth-year communications major, said he was already stressed about his course load when he also had to worry about being profiled. Whittington, who describes himself as mixed-race, also lives close to where Alex Pretti was killed. 

“It was also stressful because I never knew if I was going to get stopped by an ICE agent,” Whittington said. 

Whittington said he felt safer on campus, despite the rumors of ICE agents staying at the Graduate hotel. He is relieved their presence has whittled down, and said the community response was reassuring to witness. 

“The resources in the city, everyone coming together, spreading positivity around this situation, was nice,” Whittington said. 

The way the Twin Cities showed up leaves just as much of a lasting impression on students as the chaos itself.

“[As] an outsider, I saw community kind of banding together in a lot of ways,” Freltoft said. “It really goes to show that Minnesota is pretty tight-knit.”

Signs in the windows, offers of grocery runs, the rallies, all of it made Freltoft feel like she wanted to do her part. However, she struggled with how to respond to the conflict as an international student. 

Ultimately, she is here for her education.

That’s what students are here for. The surge’s burden on students’ stress management and daily operations was a significant hurdle we had to collectively endure. It was an incredibly difficult time, and now we’ve made it to the end of the semester. 

“It’s been really, even doubly, hard,” Deshmukh said. 

Deshmukh said she feels the need to stay positive for her family, despite living through the surge and the challenges that come with moving to a new country in pursuit of education.

“[Education is] worth doing any struggle that I come across,” Deshmukh said.

That spirit lingers at the University. Students had to double down on their studies this semester, despite the dire circumstances just beyond the University’s borders. 

Deshmukh said she is excited to be in Minneapolis for an internship this summer. As the semester ends and snow and ICE are a thing of the past, Deshmukh said she saw tulips for the first time, too.

The post Opinion: As the semester wraps up, ICE melted into the background appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: As the semester wraps up, ICE melted into the background

Opinion: As the semester wraps up, ICE melted into the background

As the strain of finals approaches, Operation Metro Surge has become a stress of the semester’s past. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents were largely pulled out of the Twin Cities in February, and many University of Minnesota students endured the intensity while remaining dedicated to their education. 

Basically, this was the worst semester ever. But the surge didn’t stop students from having to write papers, turn in assignments, respond to discussion posts and attend labs. 

Sanskruti Sanjay Deshmukh, an international data science graduate student from India, said her transition to the United States was challenging, and she was often homesick. This winter was her first time seeing snow, and when the surge began, Deshmukh recalled feeling confused and frightened. 

“I don’t know what really that is, so I just try to stay at home, and that’s all,” Deshmukh said, referring to the surge.

Deshmukh said a professor offered to buy her groceries, and she also used the campus food bank. Her philosophy was to stay safe and stay positive.

“It was scary for me, but then every place have something weird going on anywhere you go, so I just feel like I can’t complain,” Deshmukh said.

Her education was worth any struggle, she added.

This semester, students learned how to balance their courses while living in a city under occupation. As I reported on how the surge was impacting our educational spaces, it became clear that students are privileged to a campus bubble. ICE presence was very much felt, but rarely experienced in a direct way.

Josefine Freltoft, a third-year international student majoring in chemistry, said her friends were there to support her and shop for her groceries during the height of the surge. 

“I didn’t feel like leaving the house when it was really bad,” Freltoft said. 

Freltoft described the pressure being everywhere on campus during Operation Metro Surge. 

“Walking outside, maybe you’re hearing the people whistling, and it’s, like, is that something I should be nervous about?” Freltoft said. “Walking into the classes, there’s flyers on the tables about ‘This is how you alert people around you.’” 

She described seeing a Snapchat story of students filming people getting dragged out of their vehicles by federal agents right outside their window.

“It definitely created a feeling of, ‘Wow, this is happening right here,’” Freltoft said. 

Freltoft is from Denmark, but that distinction from who ICE was targeting didn’t stop her from carrying her passport or other documentation with her. A lot of international students were doing the same, she said, even if it was just to feel safe. 

Zach Whittington, a fourth-year communications major, said he was already stressed about his course load when he also had to worry about being profiled. Whittington, who describes himself as mixed-race, also lives close to where Alex Pretti was killed. 

“It was also stressful because I never knew if I was going to get stopped by an ICE agent,” Whittington said. 

Whittington said he felt safer on campus, despite the rumors of ICE agents staying at the Graduate hotel. He is relieved their presence has whittled down, and said the community response was reassuring to witness. 

“The resources in the city, everyone coming together, spreading positivity around this situation, was nice,” Whittington said. 

The way the Twin Cities showed up leaves just as much of a lasting impression on students as the chaos itself.

“[As] an outsider, I saw community kind of banding together in a lot of ways,” Freltoft said. “It really goes to show that Minnesota is pretty tight-knit.”

Signs in the windows, offers of grocery runs, the rallies, all of it made Freltoft feel like she wanted to do her part. However, she struggled with how to respond to the conflict as an international student. 

Ultimately, she is here for her education.

That’s what students are here for. The surge’s burden on students’ stress management and daily operations was a significant hurdle we had to collectively endure. It was an incredibly difficult time, and now we’ve made it to the end of the semester. 

“It’s been really, even doubly, hard,” Deshmukh said. 

Deshmukh said she feels the need to stay positive for her family, despite living through the surge and the challenges that come with moving to a new country in pursuit of education.

“[Education is] worth doing any struggle that I come across,” Deshmukh said.

That spirit lingers at the University. Students had to double down on their studies this semester, despite the dire circumstances just beyond the University’s borders. 

Deshmukh said she is excited to be in Minneapolis for an internship this summer. As the semester ends and snow and ICE are a thing of the past, Deshmukh said she saw tulips for the first time, too.

The post Opinion: As the semester wraps up, ICE melted into the background appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: As the semester wraps up, ICE melted into the background

Opinion: The unlikely couple — AI and Earth Day

A welcome way to celebrate Earth Day, students soaked up the sun in Northrop Plaza. Inside Walter Library, another Earth Day celebration was taking place: Inside the AI Hub: Earth, Energy, and Accountability. 

It may be easy to point out the irony of an artificial intelligence Earth Day collab, as AI’s sustainability track record is sad and worrisome. As someone who wants to learn about AI because of my skepticism and its environmental impact, I am both curious and doubtful about this pairing. 

The AI Earth Day event aimed to disrupt that narrative.

The Hub presented the event as an opportunity to come “learn how AI is being used for environmental research, ask the tough questions about energy and water use, and share your ideas for building technology that respects our planet.” 

As an R1 institution, the University of Minnesota has both the resources and responsibility to harness its efforts to encourage sustainable AI initiatives. 

The 2024 United States Data Center Energy Usage Report came with a call to action. U.S. data centers used 4.4% of the country’s electricity consumption in 2023. The 2028 forecast jumps to somewhere between 6.7% and 12.0%. What is needed, the report said, is research. 

Because of competition and a lack of regulations, AI was hastily made accessible to the public, and the data center industry’s booming demand makes sustainability feel like an afterthought. Research is necessary to investigate and understand this growing economic phenomenon, as well as identify solutions to mitigate resource use.

This goes beyond using AI to aid in sustainable solutions, which is becoming a possibility worldwide through optimizing energy grids and enabling precision agriculture. We have even seen this at the University with the development of programs like the AI for Earth Summer School and the AI-LEAF Institute.  

But it is AI’s development and deployment that this institution should turn its research eye toward. The good news is people have already started. 

There was a question tree at the AI Hub event where people could write a question about AI on a leaf and pin it to the display. Some of the questions were broad, like “Is the convenience of GenAI really worth its ethical and environmental drawbacks?” and “Can AI take over the world?” 

But other questions centered around the University, like “Should Gemini be so heavily advertised to students?” and “What is the University doing to offset the effects of AI and supercomputing?”

Grace Clark, an AI Hub student intern, said these questions are central to the work the Hub intends to do. 

“The heart of our strategy, both for this event and the AI Hub, is to represent student and University and faculty and staff concerns about AI, because they’re real,” Clark said. “We’re here to listen to concerns and amplify those concerns and not mitigate them.”

Daryn Ngam, also a student intern for the AI Hub, said part of AI discourse is to raise difficult questions. She recalled being frustrated when the Board of Regents approved a land sale for a Meta data center in 2023 without consulting the local community, especially given the risks to people and the environment. 

“That water is gonna be used just to power that AI center,” Ngam said. “That was something that we, as a collective, should’ve agreed upon.”

This decision showed Ngam that the University was not taking people’s sustainability concerns seriously. But that is what she and her fellow intern, Clark, want the AI Hub to stand for. 

“We can see that there’s good benefits, but the question is, where do we draw the line, and in what cases is it worth it?” Clark said. “We’re just trying to amplify the voices and see where the community best thinks that we can use it responsibly and creatively.”

The AI Hub event showcased student and faculty research at this cross-section of industries. Some sustainability-focused groups and researchers turned down the Hub’s offer to join the event, potentially due to reluctance to be associated with AI, according to Ngam and Clark. 

But Clark looks toward a more collaborative future where intentional research and development decrease AI’s environmental footprint. 

For Ngam, open conversation and accessibility are essential to the way the University community receives AI.

“If you don’t come, nothing’s gonna change,” Ngam said. “But if you do come, we can start a change.”

The post Opinion: The unlikely couple — AI and Earth Day appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The unlikely couple — AI and Earth Day

Opinion: It matters who raises the AI infant

Artificial intelligence is here, but still in its infancy. 

While reporting for this AI series, a recurring insight came up: There’s way more nuance to the spectrum of AI haters and AI lovers. 

But, as AI’s public sprawl continues into industries and the University of Minnesota’s digital infrastructure, AI-hater ethics are necessary in AI spaces to help raise what could be seen as an unruly, bad-mannered slop machine. 

The haters believe AI’s consequences outweigh the justifications of possibility, innovation and efficiency, and thus are reluctant to engage with it. I, too, am concerned about the ethical implications of AI. However, there’s an argument to be made that deep opposition is actively needed in conversations about AI’s development and dissemination. 

Public generative AI models have already transformed industry landscapes. Computer science and engineering associate professor Dan Knights said he doesn’t even write code anymore as a programmer. AI gets that job done now, and that’s just in the last few months. 

Knights sees his role as an educator in the age of AI as a conversation facilitator. The programming lab he will teach next semester will cover the basics of AI-assisted coding and hold space for deeper conversations about AI.

Education is his main intention, Knights added. First, people need to be equipped with information about AI’s uses, limitations, proponents and drawbacks.  

“Then, encourage people to recognize their own viewpoint and perspective and what lens they’re looking through,” Knights said. “And to listen to others who have potentially different perspectives and also have valuable insights.”

Classes and conversations like this can be a way for people to create a foundation of ethics as this technology inevitably alters industry landscapes. Students, who will witness AI’s maturation, are ultimately the people who move into the world with it.

Students are our future policymakers and business owners, artists and historians. They must enter AI’s shifting landscape with a solid foundation of what it means to be interacting with AI and all its ethical implications. 

For University advertising associate professor Claire Segijn, learning the tools isn’t enough. The emphasis should be on the framework of how people approach AI or any innovation.

“It’s really important to not teach students how to use one specific tool, but really to provide them with a framework so that they can learn about how to approach new technological developments in the future as well, to be open-minded,” Segijn said.

Educators and students need to have discussions about their concerns surrounding AI, especially issues of transparency, copyright, environmental impact, labor, digital vulnerabilities and biases, Segijn added. A practical and ethically-grounded foundation can help students navigate their own position and ethics on AI.

“The AI that we’re using today is going to be the worst AI that we’re going to use in our lives,” Segijn said.

Segijn designed what she calls “S.M.AI.R.T.E.R,” intended to give students a framework to do smarter work with AI tools. It’s an evaluation system that emphasizes scope, merits, areas of improvement, review and comparison, team and monetization, ethical considerations and reasoning. 

While she created the framework, Segijn said AI helped design the name. 

“Practice what you preach, right?” Segijn said, referring to the ethics of being transparent around AI use. 

Still, many students are skeptical. I have a friend who said her personal ethics around AI are simply not engaging with it. Her feelings stem from environmental concerns and a sense that AI contributed to a devaluation of human interaction, creativity and agency. It could also cause the collapse of civilization, she added.  

Haters do not want to adopt the metaphorical AI infant, and maybe AI shouldn’t be compared to a living, growing, precious thing, anyway.  

“What is really important is that there’s always a human in the loop,” Segijn said. “In the end, you’re responsible.”

If you engage with AI, you have a responsibility to consider its ethics. 

If you do not engage with AI, you still have a responsibility to consider its ethics.

“Everyone has a responsibility to ethics,” Knights said. “We all want to do the right thing.”

The answer is much messier than “Yes AI” or “No AI.” But, as students are the world’s rising leaders and AI is now an inseparable part of the global narrative, everyone’s ethics are called upon to mold our future.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: It matters who raises the AI infant

Opinion: ‘AI is bad’ is not a sufficient argument

At a dinner party a couple weeks ago, I asked two economics graduate students how artificial intelligence works in their field. They said they use it mostly for coding and data interpretation — tasks that previously took time but are now expedited with language models. 

I then turned to my fellow creative writing graduate students to ask: “Do you use AI?” I got a resounding “No!” No, because of the environmental and public health harm and the sense of infringed agency. AI will not write our poems. 

University of Minnesota journalism senior lecturer Gayle Golden said students are often reluctant to integrate AI into their workflow, even as some of the field embraces the tool’s efficiency. 

“I’m most struck with their reluctance to dive in, and I wasn’t seeing that before,” Golden said.

Golden values this hesitancy because it shows critical thinking, but this semester, especially, their resistance has grown. 

“You aren’t really gonna be able to make change in something if you don’t understand it, [if] you’re just gonna hold a sign on the outside of the data center,” Golden said. “You’re going to have to understand what this is, you’re going to have to have some proficiency. Otherwise, you’re gonna be irrelevant.”

This issue is deeper than just “AI Bad” or “AI Good.” 

University biological science and physiology major Aaron Maust likened AI’s inevitability to that of computers. But the first-year student is also concerned with AI ethics in his field and the world.  

“In life sciences fields, there’s a lot of ethics,” Maust said. “It’s the study of life, and AI, it’s not living. A lot of problems in the field are solved creatively in between people. AI, as a model, doesn’t care about that kind of thing. It’s a machine.” 

AI can, however, be a helpful study tool, Maust said, who uses it to synthesize notes and then generate a personalized quiz. Time compression on data processes is one of AI’s biggest strengths, he added.

However, Maust also holds space for concerns. 

“As far as maintaining integrity, I don’t know,” Maust said. “AI models are getting better at impersonating people, which is the concerning part.”

That, and the energy uses, job loss and impacts on local communities. AI affects everybody because it touches the environment, society, politics and economics, Maust said. 

Still, he has hope that AI could be used to address these issues, but understands its limitations as an interpretive and predictive tool.

“People can lie, and so, AI can lie,” Maust said. “It’s not separate from people. It’s an extension of people.”

Postsecondary Enrollment Options student Ariya Tikoo, who is currently studying computer science at the University, said she hopes the field centers people as its workforce, despite AI’s job-replacing dilemma.

“I think it’s more a matter of reallocation,” Tikoo said. “I would hope that that’s what the industry looks like in 10 years. I think it’s kind of dumb to be cutting people right now, because then you’re just not efficiently using people and their skills and what they have to offer.”

Tikoo said her professors are usually explicit about where AI is acceptable and where it is not. You can use it to generate a prompt, but not write your lab. 

“So people are able to think for themselves and generate their own work, but then at the same time, I think they’re aware that it can be a helpful tool,” Tikoo said. 

Trade-offs are true with any innovation, Tikoo added. But she hopes people with moral compasses will become central to AI development in a way that leads the industry consciously, while also expanding minds. Balance is part of it, even if she doesn’t have all the answers.

I teach an introductory creative writing course, and it is strictly AI-free. There is something vital at work when writing fiction, poetry and nonfiction. It is a space to flex your creative muscle. The processes AI cuts out in other fields in the name of efficiency are exactly what the arts value. 

“AI artists are not artists,” anthropology and English third-year student Tara Beaudry said. “As a creative, I do art, I write. I find [AI] takes away the humanity from being creative.” 

Beaudry said if AI sticks around, there is no best-case scenario. It is replacing meaning and what is vital to being human.  

“Meaning is being,” Beaudry said. “It’s taken away our ability to think. Our thoughts are who we are, in a way.”

A large consensus in my reporting has been that no one wants AI to replace human creativity and thought, not students nor faculty. But it does magnetize our imagination toward an AI-future.

In class last week, one of my peers’ creative essays challenged the viewpoint that AI is inevitable by enticing human imagination. Imagine a world where community and health were prioritized over productivity and profit. Imagine if all our ethical concerns around AI became central to the development and dissemination of this tool.

I wonder if we are in a window of opportunity, as we always are at the dawn of innovation. The University is a microcosm of the world, and if AI is truly as inevitable as dominant thought deems, this foundation, even here on campus, is integral to shaping the imagination of AI.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: ‘AI is bad’ is not a sufficient argument

Opinion: ‘AI is bad’ is not a sufficient argument

At a dinner party a couple weeks ago, I asked two economics graduate students how artificial intelligence works in their field. They said they use it mostly for coding and data interpretation — tasks that previously took time but are now expedited with language models. 

I then turned to my fellow creative writing graduate students to ask: “Do you use AI?” I got a resounding “No!” No, because of the environmental and public health harm and the sense of infringed agency. AI will not write our poems. 

University of Minnesota journalism senior lecturer Gayle Golden said students are often reluctant to integrate AI into their workflow, even as some of the field embraces the tool’s efficiency. 

“I’m most struck with their reluctance to dive in, and I wasn’t seeing that before,” Golden said.

Golden values this hesitancy because it shows critical thinking, but this semester, especially, their resistance has grown. 

“You aren’t really gonna be able to make change in something if you don’t understand it, [if] you’re just gonna hold a sign on the outside of the data center,” Golden said. “You’re going to have to understand what this is, you’re going to have to have some proficiency. Otherwise, you’re gonna be irrelevant.”

This issue is deeper than just “AI Bad” or “AI Good.” 

University biological science and physiology major Aaron Maust likened AI’s inevitability to that of computers. But the first-year student is also concerned with AI ethics in his field and the world.  

“In life sciences fields, there’s a lot of ethics,” Maust said. “It’s the study of life, and AI, it’s not living. A lot of problems in the field are solved creatively in between people. AI, as a model, doesn’t care about that kind of thing. It’s a machine.” 

AI can, however, be a helpful study tool, Maust said, who uses it to synthesize notes and then generate a personalized quiz. Time compression on data processes is one of AI’s biggest strengths, he added.

However, Maust also holds space for concerns. 

“As far as maintaining integrity, I don’t know,” Maust said. “AI models are getting better at impersonating people, which is the concerning part.”

That, and the energy uses, job loss and impacts on local communities. AI affects everybody because it touches the environment, society, politics and economics, Maust said. 

Still, he has hope that AI could be used to address these issues, but understands its limitations as an interpretive and predictive tool.

“People can lie, and so, AI can lie,” Maust said. “It’s not separate from people. It’s an extension of people.”

Postsecondary Enrollment Options student Ariya Tikoo, who is currently studying computer science at the University, said she hopes the field centers people as its workforce, despite AI’s job-replacing dilemma.

“I think it’s more a matter of reallocation,” Tikoo said. “I would hope that that’s what the industry looks like in 10 years. I think it’s kind of dumb to be cutting people right now, because then you’re just not efficiently using people and their skills and what they have to offer.”

Tikoo said her professors are usually explicit about where AI is acceptable and where it is not. You can use it to generate a prompt, but not write your lab. 

“So people are able to think for themselves and generate their own work, but then at the same time, I think they’re aware that it can be a helpful tool,” Tikoo said. 

Trade-offs are true with any innovation, Tikoo added. But she hopes people with moral compasses will become central to AI development in a way that leads the industry consciously, while also expanding minds. Balance is part of it, even if she doesn’t have all the answers.

I teach an introductory creative writing course, and it is strictly AI-free. There is something vital at work when writing fiction, poetry and nonfiction. It is a space to flex your creative muscle. The processes AI cuts out in other fields in the name of efficiency are exactly what the arts value. 

“AI artists are not artists,” anthropology and English third-year student Tara Beaudry said. “As a creative, I do art, I write. I find [AI] takes away the humanity from being creative.” 

Beaudry said if AI sticks around, there is no best-case scenario. It is replacing meaning and what is vital to being human.  

“Meaning is being,” Beaudry said. “It’s taken away our ability to think. Our thoughts are who we are, in a way.”

A large consensus in my reporting has been that no one wants AI to replace human creativity and thought, not students nor faculty. But it does magnetize our imagination toward an AI-future.

In class last week, one of my peers’ creative essays challenged the viewpoint that AI is inevitable by enticing human imagination. Imagine a world where community and health were prioritized over productivity and profit. Imagine if all our ethical concerns around AI became central to the development and dissemination of this tool.

I wonder if we are in a window of opportunity, as we always are at the dawn of innovation. The University is a microcosm of the world, and if AI is truly as inevitable as dominant thought deems, this foundation, even here on campus, is integral to shaping the imagination of AI.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: ‘AI is bad’ is not a sufficient argument

Opinion: Dance to data science to Shakespeare — AI’s amorphous role

Artificial intelligence brought a seismic shift to the technological landscape, and the University of Minnesota is a microcosm of the global scale. From interpreting large quantities of data collected by modern telescopes to the generative models that are hopefully not writing your essays, AI obligates individuals and institutions to wrestle with an unfamiliar, fluctuating field. 

To start this three-part series, I will examine the University’s attempts to address and approach AI, how this affects different disciplines on campus and what it means for the growing AI gap between academic fields. 

Earlier this semester, the University became one of the only higher education institutions to create the role of Vice Provost for AI, and Galin Jones, a statistics professor, will lead this initiative. This decision, and the inauguration of the AI Hub, are part of the University’s strategic roadmap. But AI implementation is not a straightforward decision-making process, and there is no model to follow. 

“Most universities are grappling with how to manage the multifacets that are encountered with AI,” Jones said. “The point of the role is, really, to kind of bring some focus out of that chaos.”   

Before the roadmap, there was the Presidential AI Taskforce, an actionable effort to understand the school’s needs. 

Caroline Hilk, co-chair of the task force’s education committee, works closely with Jones to aid AI Hub navigation.  

“There is no clear way through this AI landscape that we have,” Hilk said. 

A large part of the initial work the taskforce did was to listen, hosting stakeholder town halls where students and faculty addressed their skepticism and concerns.

“We always wanted to, and continue to want to, invite those voices into this conversation,” Hilk said. 

Hilk said these conversations made clear students wanted clarity about when and where AI use was appropriate, and so the University’s syllabus language guidelines were established. The task force also recommended that the University provide a free AI tool to help curb accessibility barriers. 

The University’s Gemini partnership was an attempt to bridge the accessibility gaps between students and between disciplines, Hilk added. One student may have the top-tier ChatGPT subscription, while another may not be able to afford that. 

One department may have the resources to create an AI Makerspace, while another would choose to allocate resources elsewhere. 

“What we heard very consistently from faculty was ‘The University does not understand my discipline,’” Hilk said. “The dance department is not gonna need the same thing as the Econ department, or computational data science. You have to allow the decision-making to happen as close to the discipline as possible.”

The University does not mandate engagement with AI or AI literacy, at least not yet. But it does want to make sure those interested have the resources available. I imagine this is a relief for those who refute AI, whether that be due to personal ethics regarding the environment and public health or a reluctance to outsource thinking to robots. 

But it does make me wonder what inequities may arise across disciplines, especially as the term “resources” can be a soft synonym for “finances.” Not every department will have a need or want to engage with AI. As some fields invest in AI while others do not, this schism could manifest as greater disparities in resources and recognition.

STEM and business fields have incentives to invest in AI, but the arts and humanities face a very different situation. This is not an exhaustive, mutually exclusive list, and it even presents a false dichotomy. We cannot separate the fields because one may philosophize efficiency and capacity over ethics and agency. 

Jones’s statistical research centers around optimization algorithms — his whole career is AI. The debate of how we implement and address these tools does not neatly apply to his discipline because his discipline created the algorithms. Here, generative AI like ChatGPT and Gemini is child’s play.

“In some ways, there is no such thing as AI,” Jones said. “It’s really just a collection of kinds of tools to solve specific problems.”

Many departments do not hold obvious educational stakes in AI data. In my personal disciplines of journalism and creative writing, some argue that AI is unnecessary and even unethical within these fields.

“We all have questions about how to use [or] not use AI, and as a large language model, it’s really intervening in the central core of English literary study — the use of language,” English professor Katherine Scheil wrote in an email to the Minnesota Daily. 

Scheil, who co-chaired the education committee with Hilk, said the opportunity in AI is to emphasize the value of human thought.

“Maybe it’s because I’m a Shakespeare professor, but I don’t think that human creativity can ever be completely replaced with a machine, despite the best efforts of some,” Scheil said.

Some aspects of journalism are also undergoing an AI transformation. 

“Journalism is a field where, for as long as I’ve been teaching, innovation and change has been absolutely at the center of everything,” Gayle Golden said, a senior lecturer at the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication. 

AI tools can help make reporting more efficient, but the human aspects are hard to replace — like interviewing and empathy — without losing something vital to the field, Golden added. 

The ways AI will continue to evolve within each field will shape the gap that develops between departments. I fear greater philosophical and financial separation, but I also hope for the vitalization of human ingenuity across disciplines. 

In next week’s column, I’ll add to the conversation on the sense of inevitability that pervades AI discourse, as well as students’ ethical considerations.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Dance to data science to Shakespeare — AI’s amorphous role

Opinion: Dance to data science to Shakespeare — AI’s amorphous role

Artificial intelligence brought a seismic shift to the technological landscape, and the University of Minnesota is a microcosm of the global scale. From interpreting large quantities of data collected by modern telescopes to the generative models that are hopefully not writing your essays, AI obligates individuals and institutions to wrestle with an unfamiliar, fluctuating field. 

To start this three-part series, I will examine the University’s attempts to address and approach AI, how this affects different disciplines on campus and what it means for the growing AI gap between academic fields. 

Earlier this semester, the University became one of the only higher education institutions to create the role of Vice Provost for AI, and Galin Jones, a statistics professor, will lead this initiative. This decision, and the inauguration of the AI Hub, are part of the University’s strategic roadmap. But AI implementation is not a straightforward decision-making process, and there is no model to follow. 

“Most universities are grappling with how to manage the multifacets that are encountered with AI,” Jones said. “The point of the role is, really, to kind of bring some focus out of that chaos.”   

Before the roadmap, there was the Presidential AI Taskforce, an actionable effort to understand the school’s needs. 

Caroline Hilk, co-chair of the task force’s education committee, works closely with Jones to aid AI Hub navigation.  

“There is no clear way through this AI landscape that we have,” Hilk said. 

A large part of the initial work the taskforce did was to listen, hosting stakeholder town halls where students and faculty addressed their skepticism and concerns.

“We always wanted to, and continue to want to, invite those voices into this conversation,” Hilk said. 

Hilk said these conversations made clear students wanted clarity about when and where AI use was appropriate, and so the University’s syllabus language guidelines were established. The task force also recommended that the University provide a free AI tool to help curb accessibility barriers. 

The University’s Gemini partnership was an attempt to bridge the accessibility gaps between students and between disciplines, Hilk added. One student may have the top-tier ChatGPT subscription, while another may not be able to afford that. 

One department may have the resources to create an AI Makerspace, while another would choose to allocate resources elsewhere. 

“What we heard very consistently from faculty was ‘The University does not understand my discipline,’” Hilk said. “The dance department is not gonna need the same thing as the Econ department, or computational data science. You have to allow the decision-making to happen as close to the discipline as possible.”

The University does not mandate engagement with AI or AI literacy, at least not yet. But it does want to make sure those interested have the resources available. I imagine this is a relief for those who refute AI, whether that be due to personal ethics regarding the environment and public health or a reluctance to outsource thinking to robots. 

But it does make me wonder what inequities may arise across disciplines, especially as the term “resources” can be a soft synonym for “finances.” Not every department will have a need or want to engage with AI. As some fields invest in AI while others do not, this schism could manifest as greater disparities in resources and recognition.

STEM and business fields have incentives to invest in AI, but the arts and humanities face a very different situation. This is not an exhaustive, mutually exclusive list, and it even presents a false dichotomy. We cannot separate the fields because one may philosophize efficiency and capacity over ethics and agency. 

Jones’s statistical research centers around optimization algorithms — his whole career is AI. The debate of how we implement and address these tools does not neatly apply to his discipline because his discipline created the algorithms. Here, generative AI like ChatGPT and Gemini is child’s play.

“In some ways, there is no such thing as AI,” Jones said. “It’s really just a collection of kinds of tools to solve specific problems.”

Many departments do not hold obvious educational stakes in AI data. In my personal disciplines of journalism and creative writing, some argue that AI is unnecessary and even unethical within these fields.

“We all have questions about how to use [or] not use AI, and as a large language model, it’s really intervening in the central core of English literary study — the use of language,” English professor Katherine Scheil wrote in an email to the Minnesota Daily. 

Scheil, who co-chaired the education committee with Hilk, said the opportunity in AI is to emphasize the value of human thought.

“Maybe it’s because I’m a Shakespeare professor, but I don’t think that human creativity can ever be completely replaced with a machine, despite the best efforts of some,” Scheil said.

Some aspects of journalism are also undergoing an AI transformation. 

“Journalism is a field where, for as long as I’ve been teaching, innovation and change has been absolutely at the center of everything,” Gayle Golden said, a senior lecturer at the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication. 

AI tools can help make reporting more efficient, but the human aspects are hard to replace — like interviewing and empathy — without losing something vital to the field, Golden added. 

The ways AI will continue to evolve within each field will shape the gap that develops between departments. I fear greater philosophical and financial separation, but I also hope for the vitalization of human ingenuity across disciplines. 

In next week’s column, I’ll add to the conversation on the sense of inevitability that pervades AI discourse, as well as students’ ethical considerations.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Dance to data science to Shakespeare — AI’s amorphous role