Can you believe it’s only the second episode of “The Last of Us” and we’re already at war with Iran?
I’m kidding. I know the mushroom zombie avalanche is fake and that the war with Iran is achingly real, but my nervous system still reacts the same, initially. That deep sense of existential dread and horror gathering in my gut, keeping me at a societally-acceptable, even connectable, baseline of anxiety, is gratefully pacified by the distance of a screen.
A friend of mine recently introduced me to this idea of living in 2D vs 3D: When our engagement with the storm beyond our door is limited to screen interaction, we live in 2D, even if it has very real effects on our emotional faculties. Sometimes, the information translates into 3D through conversations, like talking about the latest “Game of Thrones” episode with co-workers or politically sparring with your boyfriend’s brother at dinner.
My roommates and I talk about what we’re watching, both entertainment and what we’re tracking in the news. Lately, we’ve oscillated between “Wuthering Heights” and war and “Bridgerton” and ICE. Sometimes there’s the same emotional intensity when speaking about Margot Robbie with leeches on her face and “He wants to deploy how many troops?”
With our media presented to us on a screen, does entertainment feel more like reality, or does reality feel more like entertainment? It’s not news that the media has its own commercial incentives akin to the entertainment industry — fear sells. But does the body even know the difference?
“We have only little insights in the neurocognitive processes underlying the reading of factual as compared to fictional contents,” read a 2012 study.
There is some distinction, according to University of Minnesota third-year psychology student Nora Doyle. News stories trigger anger and resentment, but there’s a difference when those same emotions arise from TV shows and movies.
“When there’s a sense of artistry to it, where it’s actors and whatnot, [I] appreciate how they’re able to embody these emotions,” Doyle said. “Rather than this is something that’s going on in real life, and it’s affecting me personally and everybody in the world right now.”
We know the phrase “fight or flight.” Many studies identify this stress-response in relation to what we consume, whether that be film and television or the news.
Negative news coverage harms mental health, true. Yet it’s also true that we seek out negative TV to combat life’s stress. We all have that friend who listens to murder podcasts as a form of sleep meditation. Or the one who is painstakingly aware of every alarm the media sounds, self-detrimentally plugged into the rapid dissemination of horror and outrage that has come to characterize our virtual landscapes.
Fourth-year astrophysics and physics major Meg Chyna has felt the effects of social media’s emotional onslaught.
“It’s just, like, dopamine hit, dopamine hit, dopamine hit,” Chyna said. “So, when you’re hit with a bunch of emotionally charged content all at once, you kind of get stuck in this vicious cycle of doom scrolling.”
Sounds like Hollywood’s worst horror film, or an unfortunate reality TV show.
The core idea here is that 2D living is an escapist luxury — when you’re not living in a warzone or a federal occupation or working in an emergency room, you don’t live the news in 3D. You still have the privilege to escape into “The Pitt’’ for your daily panic attack.
There’s a shift that happens when the news is right outside your door.
In the United States, Minneapolis has had a unique experience living in 3D with Operation Metro Surge and the George Floyd uprising. For much of America, this information was taken in 2D, learned about through the news. But in Minneapolis, the 3D quality manifested in the street, classrooms and neighborhoods, and this reality encouraged people to strike and protest across the country.
“When you see something that’s going on in your city, there is more of a feeling of something that you can do,” Doyle said. “I would see things on social media about organized meetings or protests — you can literally just go out and participate.”
Her experience during Operation Metro Surge shifted from 2D to 3D, and it changed her emotional and internal landscape.
“You can go to memorials and see groups of people organizing demonstrations, rather than if it were going on somewhere else, you kind of have this sense of hopelessness, kind of helpless,” Doyle said. “But it is empowering to be able to go outside and actually show up and see other people that are showing up in their community.”
Chyna has had a similar experience stepping away from the screen, especially as she’s noticed some adverse effects.
“My attention span has definitely been cooked since COVID,” Chyna said. “I’m trying to kind of unlearn that a little bit.”