Author Archives | by Shayne Tarquinio

Opinion: On this episode of being an American

Can you believe it’s only the second episode of “The Last of Us” and we’re already at war with Iran? 

I’m kidding. I know the mushroom zombie avalanche is fake and that the war with Iran is achingly real, but my nervous system still reacts the same, initially. That deep sense of existential dread and horror gathering in my gut, keeping me at a societally-acceptable, even connectable, baseline of anxiety, is gratefully pacified by the distance of a screen. 

A friend of mine recently introduced me to this idea of living in 2D vs 3D: When our engagement with the storm beyond our door is limited to screen interaction, we live in 2D, even if it has very real effects on our emotional faculties. Sometimes, the information translates into 3D through conversations, like talking about the latest “Game of Thrones” episode with co-workers or politically sparring with your boyfriend’s brother at dinner. 

My roommates and I talk about what we’re watching, both entertainment and what we’re tracking in the news. Lately, we’ve oscillated between “Wuthering Heights” and war and “Bridgerton” and ICE. Sometimes there’s the same emotional intensity when speaking about Margot Robbie with leeches on her face and “He wants to deploy how many troops?”

With our media presented to us on a screen, does entertainment feel more like reality, or does reality feel more like entertainment? It’s not news that the media has its own commercial incentives akin to the entertainment industry — fear sells. But does the body even know the difference? 

“We have only little insights in the neurocognitive processes underlying the reading of factual as compared to fictional contents,” read a 2012 study. 

There is some distinction, according to University of Minnesota third-year psychology student Nora Doyle. News stories trigger anger and resentment, but there’s a difference when those same emotions arise from TV shows and movies.

“When there’s a sense of artistry to it, where it’s actors and whatnot, [I] appreciate how they’re able to embody these emotions,” Doyle said. “Rather than this is something that’s going on in real life, and it’s affecting me personally and everybody in the world right now.”

We know the phrase “fight or flight.” Many studies identify this stress-response in relation to what we consume, whether that be film and television or the news. 

Negative news coverage harms mental health, true. Yet it’s also true that we seek out negative TV to combat life’s stress. We all have that friend who listens to murder podcasts as a form of sleep meditation. Or the one who is painstakingly aware of every alarm the media sounds, self-detrimentally plugged into the rapid dissemination of horror and outrage that has come to characterize our virtual landscapes. 

Fourth-year astrophysics and physics major Meg Chyna has felt the effects of social media’s emotional onslaught.

“It’s just, like, dopamine hit, dopamine hit, dopamine hit,” Chyna said. “So, when you’re hit with a bunch of emotionally charged content all at once, you kind of get stuck in this vicious cycle of doom scrolling.”

Sounds like Hollywood’s worst horror film, or an unfortunate reality TV show. 

The core idea here is that 2D living is an escapist luxury — when you’re not living in a warzone or a federal occupation or working in an emergency room, you don’t live the news in 3D. You still have the privilege to escape into “The Pitt’’ for your daily panic attack. 

There’s a shift that happens when the news is right outside your door.   

In the United States, Minneapolis has had a unique experience living in 3D with Operation Metro Surge and the George Floyd uprising. For much of America, this information was taken in 2D, learned about through the news. But in Minneapolis, the 3D quality manifested in the street, classrooms and neighborhoods, and this reality encouraged people to strike and protest across the country. 

“When you see something that’s going on in your city, there is more of a feeling of something that you can do,” Doyle said. “I would see things on social media about organized meetings or protests — you can literally just go out and participate.”

Her experience during Operation Metro Surge shifted from 2D to 3D, and it changed her emotional and internal landscape. 

“You can go to memorials and see groups of people organizing demonstrations, rather than if it were going on somewhere else, you kind of have this sense of hopelessness, kind of helpless,” Doyle said. “But it is empowering to be able to go outside and actually show up and see other people that are showing up in their community.”

Chyna has had a similar experience stepping away from the screen, especially as she’s noticed some adverse effects.

“My attention span has definitely been cooked since COVID,” Chyna said. “I’m trying to kind of unlearn that a little bit.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: On this episode of being an American

Opinion: Your annual reminder that women show up!

On the last day of February, it felt like nine degrees outside. Despite the cold, 1,000 people gathered at Powderhorn Park to form a monarch butterfly mosaic as a symbol of resistance against the actions of federal agents in Minnesota. Children stomped on the ice-frozen grass, and the sectioned-off groups huddled close, awaiting artistic direction. 

I stopped by to see a friend, nestled in her assigned group with a red poster, ready to march into butterfly formation. She said the group was made up mostly of middle-aged women.

That’s one thing that needs to be honored this Women’s History Month, and especially in the wake of Operation Metro Surge: Women show up. We show up grounded in ways that suit us and serve the greater community. 

“Women have a very long history of defending democracy around the world,” public affairs professor Christina Ewig said, moderator of a March 3 panel at the Humphrey School of Public Affairs. 

The Defending Democracy: A Conversation with Minnesota Women Leaders panel featured Minnesota Solicitor General Liz Kramer and Unidos MN executive director Emilia González Avalos as panelists.

“If we think back to the democratization wave of [the] 1980s and 1990s in Eastern Europe and Latin America, women were at the forefront of those democracy movements,” Ewig said. “Women were leaders in African anti-colonial struggles and peacemakers at the end of many different African civil wars in the 2000s.” 

In the 1980s, the Chilean women’s movement promoted the idea of “democracy in the country, democracy in the home,” linking authoritarianism on the streets to abuse within households, particularly under the regime of General Augusto Pinochet, Ewig added. 

“As individuals that have often experienced discrimination in the public sphere and violence in the private sphere because of their gender, women’s life experiences often lead them to identify personally with the importance of the liberties promised by democracy,” Ewig said. 

Kramer and González Avalos are Minneapolis leaders who staunchly defend our democratic rights in the courts and in civil society, respectively. 

“Women are both the heroes and villains,” Kramer said during the panel. “It’s important to remember women are not a monolith in this country in terms of how they think or what they want to do with their time and their policy agenda.”

González Avalos said, a couple of decades ago, civil organization was often done by men and often only in private. But her vision, especially with Monarca, is of a community of everyday people who strengthen the role of a civil society. Part of that, she said, is to build an economy of love where love becomes public. 

“It’s not just something that gets to happen in the private,” she said during the panel.

I got to witness these women as defenders of their communities, and I was also able to witness women as defenders of themselves. 

At Broken Clock Brewing Cooperative, March 7, 20 women, myself included, gathered for a free self-defense class, held annually in honor of International Women’s Day. Women of all ages showed up — friends, mothers and daughters, and strangers. One of our first lessons, after serious encouragement to always arm ourselves with triple-action mace, was to use our voice. 

There was no space for being polite, the instructors said. “Stop!” we yelled as the facilitators pretended to be aggressors approaching on the street. We had to practice being loud, alert and assertive — not easy targets. For some of us, this attitude was unfamiliar; there were many I’m-uncomfortable-so-I’m-smiling expressions. 

But throughout the hour, we learned the basics of eye-poking, striking, kicking and how to maneuver out of a wrist hold. Ultimately, we were taught that we had the right to assert our space and defend ourselves if need be. We practiced fierceness because some situations necessitate it. We also laughed, because joy is often amplified in community. 

On March 8, I met with 40 other women at an Uptown mansion at Lake of the Isles for a friendship speed-dating event. In contrast to self-defense, this pink-themed gathering encouraged an openness to new experiences and sparked a connection with a stranger. Over mini-games, charcuterie and small talk, many women left with a potential new friendship and a deeper connection to the women of Minneapolis. 

Athena Papagiannopoulos, a longtime Minneapolis organizer, created Her Social Season as a way of bringing women of all ages together through intentionally curated events.  

“I really do think that if more women had more friends, they just have better connection in general, just a better community, just a better system,” Papagiannopoulos said. “This is for all women.”

Her Social Season is a newer project for Papagiannopoulos, and one of her main motivators was the use of joy and connection as antidotes to political oppression. 

“With us being under a second occupation, everyone is reacting to what’s happening, and that’s good, right?” Papagiannopoulos said. “We need community aid, but we also need to make space for joy, and I feel like it’s so easy for us to lose that.”

Papagiannopoulos also spoke of burnout as a community organizer, feeling the pressure to continuously fight the fight, to defend, to resist. 

“I kept putting off joy,” Papagiannopoulos said. “If we don’t take the time to center that, it will just never be there. I want to fight against everything we’re doing while still centering joy.”

In defense of democracy, or of the self, for the sake of forming new friendships or a giant butterfly, Minneapolis women know what it means to show up. The nurturing of community is for the benefit of all.   

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Your annual reminder that women show up!

Opinion: The American ‘other’ is ourselves

In the 1950s, political elites wanted to make the parties more distinct — a push for partisanship. Imagine that. 

Long, long ago, voting tended to be based more on geography or industry, rather than ideology. It was believed that the public didn’t know what each party stood for, and this threatened democracy. 

At the time, women’s suffrage was in its fourth decade, and the Civil Rights Movement was mobilizing. But over the next quarter-century, the Democrats and Republicans defined the lines along their ideological and policy differences. 

The era of partisanship began. 

This emboldened the classic “us versus them” mentality, that intrinsically human and historically conflicting in-party competition. We are all well aware that humans don’t have the best track record with “othering.” 

Jump to the 1970s and 80s, and Republican Newt Gingrich was gaining popularity by being confrontational and antagonistic, demonizing Democrats. Does this rhetoric sound familiar? Well, at the time, it wasn’t. Political scientists credit Gingrich for this new combative rhetoric.

“He was the language changer,” University of Minnesota political science professor Howard Lavine said.

Fast forward to today, and our parties are clearly defined by their respective social identities, which creates stereotypes. On one side, Lavine said, there are “whites, evangelical Christians, people from rural areas, people without college identifications, men,” and on the other are “women, non-whites, college graduates, people that live in urban areas and who are secular.” 

There is a generalist claim that stereotypes have to come from somewhere, but it’s negligent and insulting when a stereotype becomes someone’s entire perception of a group’s identity. And worse, it threatens the health of democracy.  

Each group instinctively feels superior to the other. Gingrich capitalized on this, and Princeton professor Julian Zelizer wrote a book all about this partisan prioritization. 

“[Gingrich believed Republicans] didn’t have to balance that with the needs of governance,” Zelizer said in an interview with Brandeis Magazine. “They didn’t have to balance that with the health of our democratic institutions.”

This above-all alignment is what makes the frenzy of polarization we see today. This is exacerbated by the language we use to describe who we deem the opposition. 

“It’s become vogue to use the worst words,” Lavine said. “Language does influence what we think, right? Our language isn’t completely detached from what our feelings are.”

It’s worsened with elite rhetoric and social media.

The right thinks the left and the left thinks the right is stupid or sick or insert any other name-calling and dehumanizing insult that feels most accessible to you. This is a flattening of the other half of the country into a caricature. 

“One amorphous blob,” University political science graduate student Nick Campos said.

Campos studies polarization and said there are two types among the mass public. The first is ideological polarization, where the different groups are rooted in different beliefs. The second is affective polarization, which is a relatively recent area of study among political scientists and represents this inclination to favor the in-party and disfavor the out-party.  

“[Affective polarization is] less about the exact issue content or actual policy battles, but instead more about how people feel about each other, about the other side, about the relationship between the two parties,” Campos said. 

In a study he co-authored, Campos argued affective polarization is made up of three distinct concepts: othering, aversion and moralization. The study found that othering and aversion, or disliking and avoiding the opposite party, were most related to anti-democratic attitudes among the public. This could look like supporting, and even excusing, a political leader despite their actions being anti-democratic. 

Democracy, because we could all use a refresher now and then, is the laws and norms that promise free and fair elections, constitutional protections, individual rights, civil liberties and checks and balances.

In the 1950s, the idea was that homogeneity was threatening these democratic institutions, and distinctive parties were seen as a solution. 

But that’s not what happened, Lavine said, as people ditched their policy preferences for party solidarity, “which is an inverse of the way democracy is supposed to work.”

Then, when polarization intensified, it led to democratic backsliding, or democratic erosion, Lavine added. In-party power becomes more desirable than checks and balances.

“The parties are willing to set the Constitution aside,” Lavine said. “They’re willing to set social norms aside.” 

An example of this is Operation Metro Surge. 

“Operation Metro Surge is probably one of the clearest examples of the government attempting to strip people of their individual freedoms,” Campos said. “Part of the reason why they feel emboldened to do this, to go and arrest people kind of unlawfully, is because they believe that their supporters will support them, right? And support them no matter what they do, or as long as they frame it as us versus them.”

This is loyalty to a fault, a dangerous fault that threatens America’s foundation. When we’re willing to support our in-group to the detriment of constitutional integrity and just for the sake of winning, then we are surely a country losing devotion to independence. 

Polarization, at large, is not inherently bad for democracy. But, certainly, what we have today is too much. 

“Don’t assume that people on the other side, don’t assume that the basis of what they believe is crazy, stupid or evil,” Lavine said, referring to what he tells his students. “Hold the belief that political opponents are acting in good faith on the basis of their values.”

This column’s intent was to dive into why thinking the worst of each other is an existential threat to democracy. Very doomsday-esque. 

“It’s easy, very easy to talk about how bad things are going, right?” Campos said. “It’s much harder to give people hope.”

So, I thought about where we began, with the 1950s push for greater partisanship and Gingrich’s creation of combative politics. Each of these movements responded to the condition of the times. 

We can construct a new political climate. We’ve done it before. 

Imagine a time not so far in the future where we learn to evolve past our in-group conditioning, where our leaders teach tolerance and respect for diversity and where our devotion to democracy rises above partisanship. Where we contend with our own hate and our own ignorances and acknowledge and debate and build and connect upon both the worst and the best parts of each other. 

Can we turn toward each other, now, and imagine a thriving United States of America?

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The American ‘other’ is ourselves

Opinion: The American ‘other’ is ourselves

In the 1950s, political elites wanted to make the parties more distinct — a push for partisanship. Imagine that. 

Long, long ago, voting tended to be based more on geography or industry, rather than ideology. It was believed that the public didn’t know what each party stood for, and this threatened democracy. 

At the time, women’s suffrage was in its fourth decade, and the Civil Rights Movement was mobilizing. But over the next quarter-century, the Democrats and Republicans defined the lines along their ideological and policy differences. 

The era of partisanship began. 

This emboldened the classic “us versus them” mentality that is intrinsically human and historically conflicting in-party competition. We are all well aware that humans don’t have the best track record with “othering.” 

Time jump to the 1970s and 80s, and Republican Newt Gingrich was gaining popularity by being confrontational and antagonistic, demonizing Democrats. Does this rhetoric sound familiar? Well, at the time, it wasn’t. Political scientists credit Gingrich for this new combative rhetoric. 

“He was the language changer,” University of Minnesota political science professor Howard Lavine said.

Fast forward to today, and our parties are clearly defined by their respective social identities, which creates stereotypes. On one side, Lavine said, there are “whites, evangelical Christians, people from rural areas, people without college identifications, men,” and on the other are “women, non-whites, college graduates, people that live in urban areas and who are secular.” 

There is a generalist claim that stereotypes have to come from somewhere, but it’s negligent and insulting when a stereotype becomes someone’s entire perception of a group’s identity. And worse, it threatens the health of democracy.  

Each group instinctively feels superior to the other. Gingrich capitalized on this, and Princeton professor Julian Zelizer wrote a book all about this partisan prioritization. 

“[Gingrich believed Republicans] didn’t have to balance that with the needs of governance,” Zelizer said in an interview with Brandeis Magazine. “They didn’t have to balance that with the health of our democratic institutions.”

This above-all alignment is what makes the frenzy of polarization we see today. This is exacerbated by the language we use to describe who we deem the opposition. 

“It’s become vogue to use the worst words,” Lavine said. “Language does influence what we think, right? Our language isn’t completely detached from what our feelings are.”

It’s worsened with elite rhetoric and social media.

The right thinks the left and the left thinks the right is stupid or sick or insert any other name-calling and dehumanizing insult that feels most accessible to you. This is a flattening of the other half of the country into a caricature. 

“One amorphous blob,” University political science graduate student Nick Campos said.

Campos studies polarization and said there are two types among the mass public. The first is ideological polarization, where the different groups are rooted in different beliefs. The second is affective polarization, which is a relatively recent area of study among political scientists and represents this inclination to favor the in-party and disfavor the out-party.  

“[Affective polarization is] less about the exact issue content or actual policy battles, but instead more about how people feel about each other, about the other side, about the relationship between the two parties,” Campos said. 

In a study he co-authored, Campos argued that affective polarization is made up of three distinct concepts: othering, aversion and moralization. The study found that othering and aversion, or disliking and avoiding the opposite party, were most related to anti-democratic attitudes among the public. This could look like supporting, and even excusing, a political leader despite their actions being anti-democratic. 

Democracy, because we could all use a refresher now and then, is the laws and norms that promise free and fair elections, constitutional protections, individual rights, civil liberties, and checks and balances.

In the 1950s, the idea was that homogeneity was threatening these democratic institutions, and distinctive parties were seen as a solution. 

But that’s not what happened, Lavine said, as people ditched their policy preferences for party solidarity, “which is an inverse of the way democracy is supposed to work.”

Then, when polarization intensified, it led to democratic backsliding, or democratic erosion, Lavine added. In-party power becomes more desirable than checks and balances.

“The parties are willing to set the Constitution aside,” Lavine said. “They’re willing to set social norms aside.” 

An example of this is Operation Metro Surge. 

“Operation Metro Surge is probably one of the clearest examples of the government attempting to strip people of their individual freedoms,” Campos said. “Part of the reason why they feel emboldened to do this, to go and arrest people kind of unlawfully, is because they believe that their supporters will support them, right? And support them no matter what they do, or as long as they frame it as us versus them.”

This is loyalty to a fault, a dangerous fault that threatens America’s foundation. When we’re willing to support our in-group to the detriment of constitutional integrity and just for the sake of winning, then we are surely a country losing devotion to independence. 

Polarization, at large, is not inherently bad for democracy. But, certainly, what we have today is too much. 

“Don’t assume that people on the other side, don’t assume that the basis of what they believe is crazy, stupid or evil,” Lavine said, referring to what he tells his students. “Hold the belief that political opponents are acting in good faith on the basis of their values.”

This column’s intent was to dive into why thinking the worst of each other is an existential threat to democracy. Very doomsday-esque. 

“It’s easy, very easy to talk about how bad things are going, right?” Campos said. “It’s much harder to give people hope.”

So, I thought about where we began, with the 1950s push for greater partisanship and Gingrich’s creation of combative politics. Each of these movements responded to the condition of the times. 

We can construct a new political climate. We’ve done it before. 

Imagine a time not so far in the future where we learn to evolve past our in-group conditioning, where our leaders teach tolerance and respect for diversity and where our devotion to democracy rises above partisanship. Where we contend with our own hate and our own ignorances and acknowledge and debate and build and connect upon both the worst and the best parts of each other. 

Can we turn toward each other, now, and imagine a thriving United States of America?

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The American ‘other’ is ourselves

Satire: Dear Becca

Hey girl! It’s been a while!! How was the retreat? Wow, this weather has been really something. Can you believe it?  

What you said about these times being “remarkably difficult” really resonated with me. Thank you so much for writing that. It was definitely the right move to give teachers the option to make classes hybrid — COVID throwback! Lol. 

Oh my gosh, I heard about those students who chained themselves to your office building! Are you OK? Do you feel safe? Do you feel the need to make a buddy system to walk across campus? I can pick you up some groceries at the Nutritious U Food Pantry if you’re scared of being harassed and interrogated just for leaving your house. 

And girl, you know I know how hard this must have been for you! Such a difficult position to be in. I really commend you on keeping the University of Minnesota so lowkey. You’re keeping our funding safe!! I mean, it’s sweet that other schools banded together to protect and preserve higher education, but your neutral, unaffected demeanor was totally giving cool girl. Love to see it. 

I just want to let you know, I’ve been having my ear to the ground, and there’s been grumbling. Like people have been talking sh—t, mostly about, you know, the ICE stuff. Sorry, I know I’m not supposed to directly say anything about it! But we’re besties, and as our friendship is built on transparency, I just had to loop you into all the tea people have been spouting this semester. 

You know me, I’m not one to keep these things from you. But some people are really upset, like chain-themselves-to-a-building-and-get-arrested upset, and they’re wondering why you weren’t confrontational toward federal agents. Girl! Don’t they know the mantra by now? Keep calm and don’t resist.  

I guess they felt you didn’t do enough to support your immigrant students or your students of color. They wanted you to explicitly state solidarity. I don’t get it, though. Your emails and statements were so sweet! About as effective as thoughts and prayers. <3

“Whether you are a Raptor, a Bulldog, an Eagle, a Cougar or a Gopher, lean into what it means to be a true Minnesotan and exhibit deep care for one another,” you wrote in your beginning-of-semester email.  

Oh, that’s the good stuff. 

And my gosh, all the extra labor on your job! I mean, being a University president is not even a political position; what did people expect you to do? Lead a freaking protest? Stand up to the president of the United States? Take meaningful actions that let your student body, faculty and staff feel cared for by you? You do not get paid that much.   

Anyway, some think that if you did make an anti-ICE scene, it would actually make some people uncomfortable. People might have felt stifled in their right to expression or even research and education if their views were opposite to those of the administration. But like you said in an email: “We can hold the space for dialogue while remaining grounded in respect for every member of our community.”

Who cares what the haters say, anyway? You’re the president! I do not doubt your devotion to this school. You, more than anyone, know how important it is to protect the safety of each and every dollar. We wouldn’t have education if we didn’t comply with the government that funds us!

Oh, I just want to say, the event for Alex Pretti was really beautiful. I heard he was such an amazing nurse, and the memo the University sent out was so touching. My only critique, and please don’t take this personally, Bex, is that I wish there were a violin performance! Opportunity missed!  

It would’ve been so scary if they came to campus, you know, the relatively untrained, armed, trigger-happy federal agents. Wow, could you imagine the uproar if they did? Really, what would you have done if federal agents came to campus and detained someone? Hopefully another nice email! 

At least you’re not who they’re targeting. But your presidential privilege made the call to shield us from being targets of the Trump administration, thank goodness. Oh, Rebecca, I am so happy I do not have your job. It seems way too stressful, truly. 

Well, that’s all from me! I hope you write back soon, but in the meantime, keep calm and don’t resist!

XOXO,

Your bestie

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Satire: Dear Becca

Opinion: How to care for your community

It was one degree outside during the Students for a Democratic Society walkout on Jan. 26. I stopped by, outskirting the chanting crowd at Northrop. It was two days after the killing of Alex Pretti, three days after Minneapolis marched in minus-20-degree weather. People were angry and grieving — are angry and grieving. 

I only stayed for a few minutes, but it was long enough to notice someone walk up to the edge of the plaza and place two hand warmers on a ledge, the disposable kind you crack and shake and last up to eight hours. They paused to straighten them out, their fingers lingering a moment on the packaging, like a little prayer for a stranger’s warmth. Then they left. 

So much reporting lately has centred around communities caring for each other. The free hot tea and samosas at protests. People biking around the world in honor of Pretti and the lives lost in detention facilities. The Minnesota Star Tribune said their out-of-state donations came from 45 other states so far, and more than 40% of their new subscribers are from other states. 

The vignettes in this Substack post are just small samples of the moments of care happening in Minneapolis. Among them is the Minnesota National Guard handing out coffee, doughnuts and hot chocolate to protesters the day after Pretti’s death.  

Here at the University of Minnesota, there are many examples of how we are caring for each other, even as many show disappointment at the administration’s response. 

In a provocative assertion of care on Feb. 6, four people chained themselves to Morrill Hall, the building that houses University President Rebecca Cunningham’s office. Each wore a black hoodie with bold, bright yellow words: “SANCTUARY CAMPUS NOW.” A construction-yellow “ICE OFF CAMPUS” sign was held between two other protesters, also in black sweatshirts. Through megaphones and chants, the demonstrators demanded the administration refuse federal agents on campus so that students and teachers would feel safe. 

“I felt motivated to push our institution to do better for undocumented and international students,” said Erin West, a graduate student who spoke in front of the crowd gathered at Morrill Hall. “[A sanctuary campus] is to make students feel safer, and make them feel like the University has their back.”

As I observed, I wondered if they would be warm enough, and who would feed them. I left before the police arrived, arresting three of the four students.

Care can be loud and demonstrative, but care can also be quiet. 

Across from Morrill Hall, there are benches on the first floor of Johnston Hall that seat cans and dried goods: oatmeal, all-purpose flour, packaged ramen, rice, pasta and beans. The hallway was empty when I was there, still and peaceful among the advising offices. This is the Little Needs Shelf, hosted by the College of Liberal Arts Student Board. There’s a bench of toiletries, too. Anyone can donate or come to scoop something up, no barriers and no questions asked. 

I went to Boynton Health’s Nutritious U Food Pantry on Thursday, Feb. 5, which opened a new operation in the basement of Coffman Union next to the Whole Music Club. This larger space, which required more volunteers and even more food to fill, was in response to higher food insecurity. 

“We know that 1 in 4 students are dealing with food insecurity on campus, and Nutritious U had outgrown the previous pantry space,” Boynton said in an email to the Minnesota Daily. 

I asked to observe, just for a bit, and was even invited to shop. Anyone — you don’t even have to be a student, and you can also shop for someone else — was allowed to collect 12 items total, one of which could be from the fridge and frozen section. There are plenty of pantry items, too. 

Nutritious U is partnered with Second Harvest Heartland, and the two organizations have created a short-term Home Delivery service, delivering a pre-packaged, non-perishable box of food to someone’s residence.  

Upstairs, on Coffman’s first floor, volunteers gathered emergency food boxes in what used to be Nutritious U’s small, compact room. It’s hard to imagine how this space could have housed all the people and goods now in the basement. 

Right across the hall, Swipe Out Hunger was handing out free meals of turkey sausage stew and vegetarian options with beans and rice.  

And in the theatre across from the free meals, a panel gathered on Wednesday for a discussion titled “What the World Needs Now: Care as a Vision, Resistance, and Hope.” The experts, as an act of care, went by their first names as a way to move away from the hierarchy that comes with titles. 

Robbin Frazier, associate director of Equity and Community Engagement in the School of Public Health’s Center for Healthy Aging and Innovation, said she woke up at 3 a.m. that morning. She said she wanted to focus her perspective on communal care as something that stems from internal work. 

“What I want you to do is just take some time this weekend, get a mirror,” Frazier said. “Just be honest with yourself and just ask about and think about your world and who you’re caring for.”

Part of care is envisioning the world we want to create, and part of that, Frazier said, is to understand our personal strengths and passions.

“Where can I invest my time, my talents, and my treasures?” Frazier said. “Who do I show up for? And speak out for? Why do I take action?” 

Care can be keeping a whistle in your coat pocket, just in case. But it can also be your teacher’s struggle to navigate an improvised hybrid modality. 

It can be checking in on a friend’s mental health or even taking yourself to one of Boynton’s drop-in consultations. 

“We also have to take care of ourselves,” Frazier said. 

Each moment counts toward a culture of care. It can be reading local news or looking up volunteer opportunities. 

Care can be as simple as smiling.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: How to care for your community

Opinion: What a wonderful time to become media literate

In an onslaught of information packaged in loaded language, bias, propaganda and polarization, we’re called to deeply examine how language’s strategic manipulations attempt to illustrate reality.

Even here, the words I’ve chosen — onslaught, polarization, manipulation — intend to bring a sense of urgency, even a fear of threat, to the tone of this column. My call to action isn’t as sexy as whistling and filming Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in the streets, but to habituate yourself to media literacy for the sake of American integrity.  

Emily Vraga, a professor in the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication, specializes in how people respond to news. Her research revolves around media literacy, which she defines as the ability to critically evaluate messages for meaning and information processes — a crucial skill in these trying times.

“At a time of very intense partisan polarization in the U.S., what we see and what we should expect to see is a lot of people interpreting the exact same situation very differently,” Vraga said. 

We’ve seen interpretations skewed in headlines and press conferences. 

People who live in the U.S. but are not citizens are referred to as vulnerable neighbors, undocumented noncitizens, illegal immigrants, illegal aliens and illegal criminal aliens. 

Alex Pretti and Renee Good, after being shot and killed by federal agents last month, have had a panoply of labels attached to their actions and deaths: constitutional observers, ICE-watchers, advocates, activists, agitators, insurrectionists and domestic terrorists, just to name a few. 

Minneapolis itself has been sensationalized as “fighting for the soul of the country,” as The Guardian put it, or “ground zero for stealing taxpayer dollars,” as Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said on Fox News.  

The multitude of labels — though perhaps inciting — are not surprising and sometimes even strategic. 

“So part of that is going to be people trying to represent things that they think will benefit them,” Vraga said. “Some part of it’s just the way humans engage with the world is always through their own perceptual lens.”

Notice here, even as you’re reading the terms above, which ones feel true and which ones do you blatantly disagree with? Imagine: Someone out there vehemently opposes your alignment. So, how do we get our own bias out of the way to simply do better? 

Hubbard associate professor Susan LoRusso said this responsibility falls on us as individuals.

“We live in such a messy information and media environment,” LoRusso said. “There’s so much bad information out there.” 

Acknowledging that while this does mean more work for the already-busy,  information-overwhelmed individual, LoRusso suggested asking these questions when evaluating potentially biased or untrue language and information: 

  • Is there loaded language? 
  • Who is responsible for this content? 
  • Who is the publisher/author? 
  • What are other sources of information saying?
  • Who else is talking about this? 
  • Is the information current? 
  • Are the images relevant and authentic? 

“Bias exists everywhere,” LoRusso said. “Media isn’t really any different.” 

However, LoRusso said not to discount news that is biased or targeted to a specific audience. Some outlets that challenge your viewpoint, no matter how mind-boggling that perspective, can keep you informed and aware, therefore beefing up your media literacy muscle. 

We’re all susceptible to the power language has over our emotions. But those who can engage critically with that language, to be simultaneously skeptical and open-minded, can engage with the entire political spectrum. 

College field representative for Turning Point USA, Dalton Nelson, who was tabling in Coffman Union the same day as the Students for a Democratic Society walkout, said he loves debate and conversation but does not get upset over particular phrases.

“I don’t really get triggered over words, ‘cause they’re just words,” Nelson said.

Nevermind what side of the aisle someone is on, Nelson said he is willing to engage with them to discuss America. 

“In the overall goal, we both want America to be the best place on Earth,” Nelson said. “It’s just the liberal viewpoint of it, and my viewpoint of how we get there is extremely different.” 

Communication studies professor Mary Vavrus said some words currently and historically employed have a reflexive impact on listeners, especially Americans. Domestic terrorist is one of those triggering terms.

“What I’m seeing and hearing is just a textbook case of a campaign to dehumanize people, whether they’re migrants, whether they’re ICE observers, whether they’re protesters,” Vavrus said. 

Vavrus added that dehumanization justifies violent action as something that is deserved. 

This framing of “deserving” is something Nelson noticed as well, particularly in the older generation of conservatives’ responses to the killings of Pretti and Good.

“No one deserves to die,” Nelson said. “If we start thinking they deserve it, we’re no better than the people who cheered when Charlie [Kirk] was shot.”

Vigilance in identifying the narratives that are emotionally gravitating is how we navigate where our own biases come from and how we’re being shaped by new information. No news story, social media post or press conference with public officials is going to endow reality to the entire situation. 

As Vraga pointed out, people will use language and share information that benefits themselves. But what happens when information is false? 

“Where we have to be really careful is where misinformation becomes essential to the fabric of the narrative,” Vraga said.

Then who do we trust for reality? The answer: ourselves. 

Vraga added that building infrastructures around media literacy is imperative. One example is to take notes from our European neighbors and bake media literacy into education. This, Vraga said, creates societies that are much more resilient to misinformation and bias and trusting of their journalistic institutions. 

“To reward information that does its best to maintain the highest standards of veracity,” Vraga said. “That, as a society, we value accuracy.”

At the very least, we should be a society that values reality. Unfortunately, there is comfort and complacency in confirmation bias. But do us all a favor and get media literate.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: What a wonderful time to become media literate

Opinion: Education is a secondhand victim of Operation Metro Surge

Students returned this semester to a stressed-out campus in a traumatized city. Operation Metro Surge has rippled its way into University of Minnesota classrooms. 

Some students and teachers are not coming to campus due to safety concerns, raising the question: Can students even engage in their education if they feel unsafe?

“It’s so scary coming back to campus,” first-year student Noah Woolford said.

The additional labor demanded by both teachers and students to navigate modality fluctuation, compounded with people’s fear of federal agents coming on campus, generates an unnerved learning environment. 

At best, the University administration has attempted to meet students where they are. Colleges have the freedom to make learning accommodations based on educational needs and formats. Under the guidance of their deans, professors who teach in-person courses have had to decide whether to keep or change the intended modality. 

“The adaptation is different between the colleges,” Woolford said. “It’s very interesting to see variants between all the schools.”

Woolford is triple-majoring in environmental policy, graphic design and global affairs, so he is exposed to a range of courses across different colleges. With an eight-class courseload, he has a vantage point in seeing how professors are adapting.

“The teachers there are either going fully remote or fully in person, and there isn’t really adaptation,” Woolford said, talking about some of his business classes. “I’ve noticed that a lot of my classmates were gone for my Carlson courses.” 

For Woolford’s graphic design class, the professor struggled with a split between virtual and in-person.

“I felt really bad,” Woolford said. “My professor was running around trying to help both of those online and in person. It was kind of unfortunate watching with my friends that were on the Zoom. They’re waiting to get instruction, like, hours into my lab, and it wasn’t my professor’s fault.”

University political science lecturer Tim Collins, who teaches in-person political science courses, said his classes would not work online.

“The need for discussion and inversion, especially just being able to see what’s on the slides at the same time, and what I’m pointing to,” Collins said. “Then, being able to break into discussion groups, as long as there are students who are on campus, it’s gonna be inherently unequal. And then, especially then, favor students who are able to come, or who are already on campus, which is already inequitable.” 

Collins added that before the semester began, students reached out to him, concerned about coming to campus, and he suggested that they speak with an academic advisor about taking a different course. As of now, he said, he records the class if a student has requested accommodations through their advisors and the dean of the College of Liberal Arts. But he said in-person learning is important.

“People learn better in groups and in person naturally, I think, as humans,” Collins said. “But also fewer distractions. If you’re at home, it’s really easy to just look down at your phone and just go down a rabbit hole and come back and things are completely different.”

In-person learning is a tried and true method, Collins added, but not everyone feels safe coming to campus, and that stress has larger implications.

“We know the stress has these profound downstream consequences on learning and cognition and health,” Collins said.  

Two days after the shooting and death of Alex Pretti and on the day of the Students for a Democratic Society walkout, Coffman Union was busy with students. 

Graphic design student Edith Soto said while she personally does not know anyone who is not attending class in person, she reads about students who have chosen to stay home on Reddit and Yik Yak. She said they are scared and uncertain. 

“I’m not choosing the online option just because I learn better in person,” Soto said, whose classes are being offered hybridly.  

Animal science major Raigen Dawson said her classes remain in person, though her major is based on the St. Paul campus.

“Even though ICE is still over there, they don’t really come on campus,” Dawson said. “But when I come up here, I have to worry about if I’m going to see them. I worry about coming in contact with one of them, or my friends coming in contact with one of them.” 

Is Operation Metro Surge’s disruption of education at the University deliberate? It’s hard to say, but the stirring of uncertainty and caution in our community is making it more difficult to be present and engage.

“I feel pretty distracted this semester with just keeping an eye on the news, and also campus events, like, ‘Oh, are we in person? What’s going to happen next?’” Eleanor Kelly said, a fourth-year political science major. 

It has been quiet and tense on campus, Kelly added. 

“If the point is to inflict fear and uncertainty on people, it’s absolutely doing that,” Collins said. “It’s also hard to learn if you don’t feel safe.” 

It’s hard to come to campus if you don’t feel safe. And for some, educational engagement may be the least of their worries. 

“If they’re not learning or engaging, then what are they doing?” Collins said. “They’re probably just afraid, and I can’t blame them.” 

When I entered Collin’s office for the interview, it seemed like he was deeply considering the precarity of this semester. He had the same weightiness that I’ve seen in many of my fellow graduate instructors and my professors who are struggling to know how to effectively teach students, especially the students deeply and directly affected by ICE’s presence. 

“If they were scheduled to be in college right now and they’re staying outside of it, or they aren’t able to participate in college or be part of it, then they’re doing nothing, probably, or just trying to help their family, or look out for each other, I hope,” Collins said. “And if that’s the case, do what you gotta do, be present for your family and your community, but goodness.”

Engagement — educational, familiar or communal — is not easy right now. However, there is an urgency to engage that makes it a necessary means of meeting this moment. If Operation Metro Surge threatens education, then we are each personally responsible for protecting our right to it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Education is a secondhand victim of Operation Metro Surge