Artificial intelligence brought a seismic shift to the technological landscape, and the University of Minnesota is a microcosm of the global scale. From interpreting large quantities of data collected by modern telescopes to the generative models that are hopefully not writing your essays, AI obligates individuals and institutions to wrestle with an unfamiliar, fluctuating field.
To start this three-part series, I will examine the University’s attempts to address and approach AI, how this affects different disciplines on campus and what it means for the growing AI gap between academic fields.
Earlier this semester, the University became one of the only higher education institutions to create the role of Vice Provost for AI, and Galin Jones, a statistics professor, will lead this initiative. This decision, and the inauguration of the AI Hub, are part of the University’s strategic roadmap. But AI implementation is not a straightforward decision-making process, and there is no model to follow.
“Most universities are grappling with how to manage the multifacets that are encountered with AI,” Jones said. “The point of the role is, really, to kind of bring some focus out of that chaos.”
Before the roadmap, there was the Presidential AI Taskforce, an actionable effort to understand the school’s needs.
Caroline Hilk, co-chair of the task force’s education committee, works closely with Jones to aid AI Hub navigation.
“There is no clear way through this AI landscape that we have,” Hilk said.
A large part of the initial work the taskforce did was to listen, hosting stakeholder town halls where students and faculty addressed their skepticism and concerns.
“We always wanted to, and continue to want to, invite those voices into this conversation,” Hilk said.
Hilk said these conversations made clear students wanted clarity about when and where AI use was appropriate, and so the University’s syllabus language guidelines were established. The task force also recommended that the University provide a free AI tool to help curb accessibility barriers.
The University’s Gemini partnership was an attempt to bridge the accessibility gaps between students and between disciplines, Hilk added. One student may have the top-tier ChatGPT subscription, while another may not be able to afford that.
One department may have the resources to create an AI Makerspace, while another would choose to allocate resources elsewhere.
“What we heard very consistently from faculty was ‘The University does not understand my discipline,’” Hilk said. “The dance department is not gonna need the same thing as the Econ department, or computational data science. You have to allow the decision-making to happen as close to the discipline as possible.”
The University does not mandate engagement with AI or AI literacy, at least not yet. But it does want to make sure those interested have the resources available. I imagine this is a relief for those who refute AI, whether that be due to personal ethics regarding the environment and public health or a reluctance to outsource thinking to robots.
But it does make me wonder what inequities may arise across disciplines, especially as the term “resources” can be a soft synonym for “finances.” Not every department will have a need or want to engage with AI. As some fields invest in AI while others do not, this schism could manifest as greater disparities in resources and recognition.
STEM and business fields have incentives to invest in AI, but the arts and humanities face a very different situation. This is not an exhaustive, mutually exclusive list, and it even presents a false dichotomy. We cannot separate the fields because one may philosophize efficiency and capacity over ethics and agency.
Jones’s statistical research centers around optimization algorithms — his whole career is AI. The debate of how we implement and address these tools does not neatly apply to his discipline because his discipline created the algorithms. Here, generative AI like ChatGPT and Gemini is child’s play.
“In some ways, there is no such thing as AI,” Jones said. “It’s really just a collection of kinds of tools to solve specific problems.”
Many departments do not hold obvious educational stakes in AI data. In my personal disciplines of journalism and creative writing, some argue that AI is unnecessary and even unethical within these fields.
“We all have questions about how to use [or] not use AI, and as a large language model, it’s really intervening in the central core of English literary study — the use of language,” English professor Katherine Scheil wrote in an email to the Minnesota Daily.
Scheil, who co-chaired the education committee with Hilk, said the opportunity in AI is to emphasize the value of human thought.
“Maybe it’s because I’m a Shakespeare professor, but I don’t think that human creativity can ever be completely replaced with a machine, despite the best efforts of some,” Scheil said.
Some aspects of journalism are also undergoing an AI transformation.
“Journalism is a field where, for as long as I’ve been teaching, innovation and change has been absolutely at the center of everything,” Gayle Golden said, a senior lecturer at the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication.
AI tools can help make reporting more efficient, but the human aspects are hard to replace — like interviewing and empathy — without losing something vital to the field, Golden added.
The ways AI will continue to evolve within each field will shape the gap that develops between departments. I fear greater philosophical and financial separation, but I also hope for the vitalization of human ingenuity across disciplines.
In next week’s column, I’ll add to the conversation on the sense of inevitability that pervades AI discourse, as well as students’ ethical considerations.