Author Archives | Rina Cakrani, Columnist

March for our Lives and White Supremacy

The March for our Lives was hypocritical, despite the good intentions and message behind it. The conditions from which it emerged and the positive media coverage that it received due to the demographics that were involved make it hypocritical and oblivious to the radical problems that should have been addressed. The controversy of this march emerges from the fact that it was originated by and allowed to happen because of the white kids that were protesting. Their protest was considered by the media as the start of a new revolution and an inspiring movement that would commence change in the society. Nevermind the fact that brown and black kids have for many years been not only the most affected by gun violence, but also the ones that have started protests which unfortunately the media has portrayed as “thuggish.”

Although the kids affected by the Parkland shooting have the right to protest and show public outrage, the fact that they are being treated as young leaders with a vision just shows the privilege that certain groups have and others do not. The protest movement has been gentrified. If one looks at the protest pictures, one can see some images in which certain people are raising their fists in the air just like they did during the Black Power movement. Too bad that Black activists get criminalized for gestures that the so-called white activists get praise for.

Illustration by Abby Takahashi

The ultimate blow came when a recent Time Magazine cover featured the kids that were representing the March for our Lives Protest and what is considered to be their “powerful” message. The most outstanding thing to notice is that all five of them are white. As I said, I do not want to undermine these kids’ bravery, but the fact that throughout the country millions of white people showed up for a protest held for the violence shown in Parkland only highlighted the fact that they did not show up when Ferguson or Baltimore happened. It just gives another indication about which lives matter more in the United States.

The other hypocrisy is related to the inclusion of the police in the protest, oblivious to the fact that the police system is part of the problem. There can be no gun reform without including the major issue of police brutality, and especially the reform of a system that disproportionally affects the brown and black communities who have lost their trust in it. Within the gun control movement, privileged non-black influencers are ignoring the wisdom of black influencers while also asking them to be part of it just to gain recognition in the media. Brittany Packnett, activist and leader on the Intersection of Culture and Justice Movement said in a Mic op-ed that to some black students and activists, school shootings, other mass shootings and police violence are connected and deserve comparable amounts of attention.

“The key to this issue is solidarity. We have to show up for one another and one another’s issues. Don’t only show up when it affects you. Recognize that gun violence affected Alton Sterling and Stephon Clark, just like it did the young people in Parkland and Sandy Hook,” Packnett wrote for The Washington Post. Black voices are commoditized when non-black people want numbers and when they want to give the appearance of diversity without the diversity of opinions and experiences. The political climate in United States has proven that issues which affect predominantly black people are not a priority, even in social movements like March for our Lives. This is because the solutions to the issues that primarily impact the lives and experiences of black people are inherently offensive to the comfort of white people; these are the issues that require white people to address the violence of a system of white supremacy.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on March for our Lives and White Supremacy

Kardashian Culture Vultures

The Kardashians have built their careers by imitating and profiting from black culture. This is a truth that is not often spoken about but it is something that should be considered problematic and raise further questions on how white celebrities can get away with it or be celebrated for trends that black people have started. Over the years, the Kardashians have tried to alter their bodies and their hairstyles to look more like black women, consequently appropriating black culture.  We have seen over the years how Kim Kardashian and her sisters have styled their hair in cornrows and dreads which were considered as ‘innovative’ and ‘edgy’ by the hypocritical media. However, when such hairstyles were worn by Zendaya Coleman, who is a black actress, the media labelled her all sorts of things but nice ones. The Kardashians are trying to be black without understanding the significance of being black. Creating features like the curvaceous derrière and full lips which do not even match their Caucasian features and being praised by the media while making a lot of money through it, is derogatory towards black women specifically . It does nothing to empower the black community and instead steals from it and keeps doing only damage. black women have been using their hairstyles as protective styles and there is a whole story of oppression and white supremacy out of which many of these practices have stemmed from. The main problem is how it became new and fresh and fun when the Kardashiand started to do them, because it was on someone else other than a black woman. That’s where the culture appropriation element comes into play. Not to mention Kim Kardashian’s cover on Paper magazine. Her cover was shocking, but mostly due to the racist undertones and implicit mockery of black women. The cover was explicitly linked to Sarah “Saartjie” Baartman, who was paraded around Europe during the 19th century and used as a freak show exhibit due to her large bottom. Sarah was  mocked, sexualized, and profited off of, and to this day, black women still end up being treated as sexual beings if they have large backsides — the same shape that white women are now making trendy.

Illustration by Cat Burch

And then there is the case of the younger sibling of the family, Kylie Jenner, launched a line of camo bikinis, which very clearly resemble those worn by Destiny’s Child in their “Survivor” music video back in the day and were considered as something “brand new.” Not only they were not new, but these camouflage bikini sets are similar to those of Tizita Balemlay’s brand Plugged NYC. Kylie requested many of Balemlay’s items before mysteriously producing a copycat line of her own. The pieces are so similar that upon first glance, the two brands put next to one another look like one cohesive line.

We can’t say for sure to what extent they know the gravity of their actions but for sure they know how to use every situation to garner attention for themselves and to make profit. Even if this means exploiting black culture and disrespecting the struggle of the black community, especially of black women.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Kardashian Culture Vultures

An opinion on Aziz Ansari Allegations

Aziz Ansari has faced a lot of criticism regarding his alleged sexual misconduct, and new reports from the night of the event that have sparked a lot of conversation in the media about the extent to which his actions could be considered sexual assault. The event has to do with a dinner date in which a woman named Grace says that she and Ansari went back to the comedian’s Manhattan apartment where he repeatedly asked her for sexual intercourse after she had shown signs of discomfort. Her statement suggests that he was persistent with his demands and was not considerate to the fact that Grace was not enjoying all of his demands. She says she viewed the sexual encounter as “violating,” “uncomfortable” and “painful,” and although she didn’t explicitly object to his demands, she showed signs of feeling uneasy and that her verbal and non-verbal cues should have been a signal to Ansari. Although the woman has her right to express to the media how discomforted she felt, the question of if Ansari should have been the one to figure out her emotions and her uneasiness remains unclear. Why didn’t she openly reject him, choosing instead to be passive and expect him to understand what she wanted? She had the choice to express herself, but instead chose to assume the stereotypical passive position of the woman during an intimate encounter and expected the man to be the considerate one. This kind of behavior reinforces gender roles and puts, once again, the expectations on men when, in fact, this kind of encounter is intended to be reciprocal.

Illustration by Abby Takahashi

In return, the actor has released a statement in which he acknowledges that they engaged in sexual activity but says that by all indications their encounter was completely consensual. The controversy that is displayed in the media has to do with the fact that Grace was not explicitly rejecting Ansari’s demands and was not open about not wanting to engage in certain acts. Unfortunately, when we talk about sexual assault, the cases where the victim forcefully objected to the perpetrator are highlighted, but the cases where emotional and psychological discomfort are experienced by the victim should be considered as well. Sometimes, women are scared and intimidated in the moment and cannot openly express their discomfort, and the other party should make sure they are not doing anything that brings one-sided enjoyment. The expectation that because a man took a woman out on a nice date it should lead to something more is irrelevant and outdated.

Especially in Ansari’s case, although it is impossible to know for sure what he was thinking on the night that this event occurred, it is hard to believe he did not notice how uncomfortable Grace was feeling. As a performer, he uses emotional intelligence and intuition in order to reach to people’s emotions. It strains credulity to imagine he truly thought she was excited about what was happening between them. What’s more likely is that he didn’t care how she felt and treated her boundaries as a challenge. Either way, his alleged behavior was dehumanizing. Therefore, teaching and advocating for affirmative consent is clearly something that should be actively pursued and be the norm in our society; affirmative consent shifts the acceptable moral standard for sex, making it much clearer to everyone when someone is violating that standard. It also removes certain assumptions about gender roles. If both men and women are equally responsible in making sure their partners are enthusiastic about what’s happening and that the encounter is equally consensual, gender stereotypes about sexuality relating to women being the passive ones and men being the aggressive ones who dictates the course of actions–clearly noted through Ansari’s case–will begin to be dismantled. However, it’s crucial that women become more vocal about what they want instead of waiting for men to understand their emotions. In such a misogynistic culture, men think they do not need to ask for permission; therefore, it is important to take the situation under control and verbally oppose the actions if women do not want to engage in the same things as men.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on An opinion on Aziz Ansari Allegations

Affirming White Women

Illustration by Peggy Li

There are certain myths and misconceptions surrounding the question of affirmative action and who benefits from it, and many narratives have been built based on how the beneficiaries supposedly do not deserve their place in a certain institution, but are there only due to this policy. It is important to debunk these myths because many students belonging to minority groups are always at the center of criticisms and prejudices and are being considered and viewed by the society, as simply tools used to decrease the huge disparity existing among the white students and to serve the initial purpose of this policy: giving equal opportunities to underrepresented groups. However, contrary to popular belief, those that benefit the most from affirmative action are not the Black or Brown students who are usually not considered as ‘worthy’ students in their respective campuses (especially the overwhelmingly white ones) due to the reputation that has been attached to them by this policy. White female students are the ones that over the years have gained access to educational institutions due to the privilege that affirmative action has provided for them.

This fact is ironic considering that in the past few years, many female students have filed lawsuits against universities they have not been accepted to because they believed that affirmative action gave priority to other racial groups whose members only got to school, not because their applications were better, but because they were not white. In 2013 there was a case against the University of Texas by a white woman who claimed that she was denied admission because she was white. Despite the fact that her grades were not that great and her application overall was not that impressive, she still had to make a case about how she was being ‘discriminated against.’

Ironically, data shows that affirmative action helps women like her more than the marginalized groups in the US. Originally, women weren’t even included in legislation attempting to level the playing field in education and employment. The first measure was an executive order signed by President Kennedy in 1961, that was later amended by Johnson in 1967 to included sex as well. Although the policy has helped people of color in that it has provided them access to historically overwhelmingly white institutions that they would otherwise not have had the chance of attend, statistically speaking, white women have benefited disproportionately. According to a study in 1995, six million women, out of which the majority are white, have jobs that they would not have had without affirmative action.

This does not mean that the case for affirmative action should not be supported. It has benefited white women, but it is not benefiting the community of color yet as intensely, especially when it comes to the job market. School districts still spend more money on predominantly white schools and job applicants are twice less likely to be called back for an interview if their name is ‘Hassan’ and not ‘Scott.’ Black workers earn 35 percent less than white workers for the same job position and Latino workers earn even less.

What is even more ironic is that the racialization of the rhetoric used in discussing affirmative action has created such a huge misconception of it, that it has caused white women to be overwhelmingly against the policy, if only a bit less than the male counterparts. Essentially, they are against a policy that has helped them substantially, simply because of the repeated narrative of how it has helped the community of color in an unjust way; that it has favored them despite being unprepared and unqualified.

I think the only valid narrative here is that white women, despite having experienced inequality themselves, still choose to be biased towards other marginalized groups and would rather be aligned with white men who stand on the top of the hierarchy of the inequality scale, rather than become agents for the voiceless and unprivileged. Unfortunately, even the elections last year showed what kind of disappointment the community of white women in America can bring to society.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Affirming White Women

A Perspective on Cultural Appropriation

The issue of cultural appropriation has been and still is very debatable and some would say ‘controversial’, because apparently we still don’t have a clear idea of what appropriating a culture truly is like. However, this issue becomes more prominent and even more debatable during Halloween time, especially in the U.S. context. It is totally fair and important to treat this issue carefully and with the utmost caution, since there have been so many cases in which Halloween become an  extreme example  of cultural appropriation. One should be careful when deciding what costume to wear, in particular if they are white.

Illustration by Tywen Kelly

It is important to keep in mind that other people’s cultures are not costume. If you are white, you have no right to dress up as anything that belongs to the indigenous people or to Latino people or to African people. Your white ancestors (not necessarily your own, but generally speaking), probably enslaved, killed or were blatantly racist  and it would be best if one were to  stay in their  own space without violating the spaces to whom these cultures belong to. Also, it is hugely hypocritical to want to dress up as a mariachi or a Native American especially considering that most of the white students don’t even care about their existence when it comes to everyday life. In addition, the hypocrisy stands in that a major portion of the society doesn’t want Mexicans or Black people, but they love to steal from their culture; they love their food, their music, their style, but they don’t want the people. Don’t perpetuate the hypocrisy; don’t dress up as Beyonce if you feel uncomfortable with the Formation video due to the Black Power message, don’t dress up as a mariachi when you know your relatives that come to visit, would probably just be labelling every group of Mexicans that they see when you go downtown.

Appropriating culture especially for Halloween means that your culture (the white one, i don’t even know if we can talk about white culture, if that even properly exists), is the center and once a year you get the chance to experience a new one, an ‘exotic’ one, one that you would unconsciously consider inferior any other day of the year, one that belongs to a marginalized community, which already has it hard enough but now has to see all the white girls trying to do blackface so they can look like Aaliyah or Selena.  Don’t wear dreadlocks. And not just for Halloween, but ever! Is just that for Halloween, certain practices become ‘acceptable’ or ‘allowed’, when they in fact should never be permitted.

Certain cultural characteristics have been emphasized as tools for resisting the oppression that white people have historically imposed. They are there as established structures, as symbols to fight the white supremacy and to create and define the struggle. Dreadlocks are not just a hairstyle, they are an historic symbol, an emblem of remembrance of a long fought oppression. They are not yours to take, they are not ‘exotic’ or ‘edgy.’ You don’t fight that struggle. When Black people carry dreadlocks they are considered ‘thugs’; when you carry them, they are seen as ‘cute’ or ‘edgy’. You have that privilege because your life is not confined by it. Don’t enact that privilege. Don’t dress as Pocahontas, don’t dress as Moana. Most of you  consider brown girls unattractive on a daily basis (by the way, y’all brown girls are beautiful), but want to be like them and find Halloween as an  opportunity to do so. Dress as Superman or as Wonder Woman. The community of color is not fine with you ‘borrowing’ from their culture. So don’t do that.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A Perspective on Cultural Appropriation

Can you Separate a Creator from their Works? No.

History is full of tales of artists behaving poorly. Composer Richard Wagner was an anti-Semite. Novelist Charles Dickens trashed his wife and secretly shacked up with a teen actress. Painter Michelangelo Cyaravaggio was a murderer. Movie star and filmmaker Charlie Chaplin was investigated by the FBI and banned from the United States in the 1950s, as much for eloping with an 18 year old as for his leftist political views. It is generally hard for anyone to distinguish the artist from the person.

However, this difference should be noted because although an artist might be great and revolutionary for his times through his work, this does not mean that he has been good as a person. Unfortunately, there have been many cases in which an artist has been an abuser in his personal life, but this hasn’t had any negative impact on the appreciation of his work. For instance, we have Eric Gill, one of the most prominent British artists of the twentieth century, who sexually abused his daughter since she was four years old and heavily represented her in his work. And yet, this fact did not have any serious repercussions on his reputation as an artist. It seems like white men always find a way to escape from such situations and still be celebrated.

However, I find it very hard to think of the artist separately from his personal life and admire him solely for his professional work. Artists and writers often find inspiration from their lives and daily experiences, and portray them in their work. Therefore it is obvious that their work cannot be truly separated from the way they are as individuals. For this reason, I cannot accept the work of Eric Gill as phenomenal, since it stems from a sexual abuser, or the work of any other artist that has been horrendous in their personal lives.

Also, when it comes to writers or leaders I can give the same reasoning. If they preach one thing in public and act in another manner in their personal lives, which would contradict their image in the eyes of the people, I cannot think of them in high regards. For example, I will never idolize and appreciate Mahatma Gandhi, who despite initiating the peaceful protest against the British which gave independence to his country, wrote and said many misogynistic things about women. Of course he will still get credit for the benefits he brought to his country, but this doesn’t mean he should be idolized.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Can you Separate a Creator from their Works? No.

Approach Media Consciously

The media is an institution that continually has more and more impact on our lives, specifically in the way we think about the world and in the decisions we make. Media influences us on all levels, from which types of food to buy, to which candidate we should vote for in the presidential elections. Although the original purpose of the media was to present the public with information, it has been transformed into an instrument of manipulation.

The media, especially the Internet, has set new social norms among modern-day teenagers. Highly influential people with millions of followers on Instagram use the media to define and promote a certain lifestyle. Their presence is so strong and positively publicized everyday that as a consequence, young people believe that their way of life is the one to be emulated. Therefore, we see many new trends among this generation relating  to fashion, music and food, as well as norms to live by. Following these norms has been normalized and prioritized above other things. For example, you may have noticed in the past year on social media that “Supreme” or “Gucci” printed shirts was very popular and a lot of people were wearing them. What we perceive as cool to wear can easily change according to what we see online, even if we don’t fully realize it.

However, this is the most basic example of how we are influenced by the media. We gain influence in much more important matters, particularly those that are related to politics and society in general. The way we think of certain political candidates is based on what we read online or what we hear in various media outlets. We think we can be objective, but when we repeatedly hear a certain thing about someone by several sources, we might not escape its impact. That thing might not be true because nowadays the media is used by powerful people for their own purpose and it can manipulate or lie to us. Unfortunately, it can have the ultimate say when we consider a decision that will contribute to the future of society. We are bombarded with new information everyday and sometimes it is hard to recognize what is the truth and what is not. The media has become a business; many outlets find it harder to survive, therefore they prioritize the pursuit of money rather than that of the truth. They would rather promote a certain ideology or a certain individual in exchange for money needed for proceeding in this highly competitive world, rather than be objective or impartial and receive lesser attention. In such a situation, it is wise to be skeptical of the news we get and not to fall into the trap of the trends that are being set by the Instafamous.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Approach Media Consciously

Technology helps the introverts

Illustration by Eric Rannestad

We usually hear the old generation (or our parents) complain about how young people are always on their phones–that they live in a virtual world. Even in school when we were kids, we were frequently told that technology has made our lives easier, but at the same time has decreased our communicative and social abilities. We have lost our skills at creating relationships with different people and participating actively in the social scene of the community or school we are a part of. However, although the excessive use of technology has some drawbacks, I don’t believe that it should be villainized, because it can prove to be useful and beneficial in ways that many of us don’t usually think about.

The truth is that for some of us, the ability to initiate a conversation with a stranger or the willingness to go to every school party and be part of the ‘cool kids’ group has never been part of our personalities. Technology, then, has not been a negative factor of our lives, but has affected us positively. There are simple instances, such as using your phone in a social gathering in which you feel very uncomfortable and uneasy at the idea of socializing with strangers. People are often quick to judge and think it is offensive to use your phone and not focus on engaging with the environment around you, but they don’t actually think why that person is acting that way.

Introverts might use technology as a form of expression, as a platform in which they can have the freedom to show another side of them that people wouldn’t have the chance to see otherwise. Apps like Instagram or Snapchat can make introverts more confident in posting pictures, and give the encouragement to post even more when they receive pleasing comments by others. Such everyday experiences make one feel better about themselves and perhaps even enhance the motivation to talk more to people around them.

But technology is not just useful to introverts in terms of social relations. Someone might use it to share their creative work or thoughts they wouldn’t share with people they know. There is an advantage in being an unknown person on the Internet; one feels more comfortable in sharing things with people they don’t know in the real world. Also, introverts don’t feel pressured to immediately articulate themselves in a well-spoken manner like in a sudden formal face-to-face encounter with somebody new. A phone gives them the chance to think well beforehand and construct their thoughts the best way possible. They don’t feel the pressure to constantly talk either; they could just enjoy reading or hearing other people’s opinions.

This kind of freedom is something they might not have access to, especially in a college classroom setting where there is an implicit demand for verbal participation as part of the participation grade. Unfortunately, the education system and contemporary society as a whole values extroversion and the ability to talk loudly, while the introverted are always  criticized and told to change their communication habits. Social media gives introverts a voice and helps them connect with people that match their personalities and interests.

Therefore, it is wrong to always demonize the social effects of technology. It can provide emotional support to an introverted person who truly cannot find comfort in the world around them, or help them spend time with themselves and not be forced to interact with people they don’t like.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Technology helps the introverts

The Dangers of White Feminism

I consider myself a feminist but I often find that the feminist movement is heading in a problematic direction nowadays. Modern feminism is often not intersectional; it leaves out many of the women’s voices that need to be heard but are not due to the domination and privilege that white feminism has enjoyed since its beginnings. White feminism originates from the second wave of feminism and has unfortunately always prioritized gender over race, with many contradictions.

The major problem that comes from white feminism as a movement is that it fails to acknowledge many of its privileges, and even when it does so, it keeps exercising those privileges. And when those privileges are in danger, the white feminists react in their defense. During the Women’s March in January, we saw millions of women around the country protesting for gender equality, but another major reason was Trump’s election. It remains unseen whether white feminism would have been angered if the new presidency didn’t directly affect them as well. The truth is that white feminists have hardly ever stood up for feminist women of color, who clearly have a more difficult place in society. For example, hispanic women earn 54 cents to the dollar and black women earn 64. Not only do they suffer as women, but they also suffer due to their race.

White feminists haven’t been concerned with protecting those that suffer daily oppression and survive against a system that has been designed to bring them down on the basis of their race. Seeing white women as spokespeople for the movement without acknowledging the struggle that their fellow women of color undergo daily is disrespectful and humiliating. After all, according to the National Election poll, it was white women who helped elect Trump. While 57 percent of white women voted for Trump, 91 percent of black women voted against him.

The truth is, in this society, women of color are the ones that truly deserve to be called feminists because of the fight they carry against a system that emphasizes beauty standards that idolize white women, and that prefers to employ white women for certain jobs just because of the color of their skin. They have to endure how the media under represents them, like the Hollywood movie that would rather choose Scarlett Johansson for an Asian character rather than an actual Asian actress. The true feminists are immigrant women of color who have started from the bottom and have managed to raise their kids and support their families despite these circumstances.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Dangers of White Feminism

Moonlight recaptures Oscars

Despite some confusion at the Oscars on the winner of the Best Picture, “Moonlight” won the category in addition to numerous other wins. However, the impact of “Moonlight’s” victory on Oscars night goes beyond the award. For years, the Academy has been criticized for their lack of diversity in chosen nominees and also for acknowledging movies that have wrongly used white actors to portray characters that were originally people of color. The fight for recognition in the film industry has been a long one for many actors and directors of color, especially when they create works centered around prevalent issues in contemporary American society.

“Moonlight’s” victory is a groundbreaking event, because for the first time, a movie with a black staff and production crew not focused on slavery won the Best Picture Award. “Moonlight” highlights issues regarding black homosexuality that breaks present stereotypes and sheds light on  personal identity and self-discovery, providing the audience with a new and refreshing narrative that departs from mainstream Hollywood depictions of black lives. The win was not a response to the past criticism of the Oscars being so White; in fact it was a very well deserved win for the underrepresented who have to break through barriers in order to succeed in the movie industry. They made it despite the established white privilege and elitism that prevails in the movie industry.

Does this mean that the Oscars have moved on from their Whiteness and are ready to embrace a new ideology in which diversity and differences are deservingly supported? “Moonlight” is an unprecedented victory at a very significant moment for black people especially, but this doesn’t necessarily indicate that the Academy has left its white privilege behind.

As long as movies that talk about jazz like “La La Land,” yet  don’t involve black frontrunners of jazz music, continue to win awards, the Academy is still supporting and celebrating Whiteness. As long as the Academy awards Best Actor to Casey Affleck, a white man, who has been involved in numerous sexual assault cases, yet has silenced the victims with money, there is still white privilege in Hollywood.

“Moonlight” won, but the movie had to be excellent in order to win over the epitome of white mediocrity that “La La Land” was. Standards are higher for minorities than for white movies. “Moonlight” won, but their special moment still got robbed from them. The mistake that was first made, when “La La Land” was awarded Best Picture, robbed the “Moonlight” cast from hearing the name of their movie being announced. Instead, they had to witness the white cast and staff of “La La Land” go on stage and start talking about how important diversity is, when in fact the movie had almost exclusively white characters and arguably appropriates black history and  culture.

“Moonlight” serves as a statement of inspiration to its own community and perhaps this is the most important aspect of its victory. Those that thought they wouldn’t be able to make it in a world and specifically in an industry that is predominantly white now believe they can break barriers.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Moonlight recaptures Oscars