Author Archives | opiniondesk

Uber CEO leaves president’s business council, loses vital line of communication

In the midst of protests surrounding President Donald Trump’s travel ban last week, Uber received severe backlash. During the protest, the Taxi Alliance shut down their services for an hour and joined the protest at John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York.

The resistance sparked when Uber tweeted that they would turn off surge pricing during this time to be able to get people to and from the airport. This led to the creation of the #deleteUber hashtag, and more than 200,000 people deleted the app.

Many were outraged because they believed the company was trying to profit from the situation. Uber CEO Travis Kalanick also received some heat over his participation in Trump’s business advisory council.

In an email to employees, Kalanick said that he disagreed with the ban and claimed that Uber would compensate affected employees. He also said that Uber would use a $3 million fund to help employees gain access to legal counsel.

Kalanick defended his position on the council, stating, “We partner around the world optimistically in the belief that by speaking up and engaging we can make a difference… I understand that many people internally and externally may not agree with that decision, and that’s OK. It’s the magic of living in America that people are free to disagree.”

However, a few days later, Kalanick announced he would leave the business advisory council. This didn’t come as a huge surprise as many people were calling for Kalanick to step down from the position, and it seemed that for the sake of Uber he decided to do so.

In a statement, Kalanick said, “Joining the group was not meant to be an endorsement of the President or his agenda, but unfortunately it has been misinterpreted to be exactly that.”  

While it’s easy to understand how people could misinterpret Uber’s surge price tweet to believe they were trying to make profits off the protest, I don’t think leaving people stranded at the airport was necessary.

Uber wasn’t only picking people up from the airport, it was also dropping people off. People who wanted to engage in the protest did so, and if people needed to leave the airport, that didn’t undermine the protest. The protest did an incredible job of raising awareness.

The protests across the U.S. proved that people would not sit idle when unjust actions are implemented.

Kalanick also should not have left the council. It’s understandable why it happened, but Kalanick had a great opportunity to create real dialogue about the issues surrounding this ban, and much more.

Because he dropped out of the council, he can no longer advise President Trump. Being on the council gave Kalanick, along with the others involved, a direct line to President Trump. This could have been valuable in leading to actual change.

However, if people who do advocate for the interest of the American people don’t engage in such interactions, how do we expect change? As our country becomes more divided, it seems like the chance of having actual conversations on key issues is decreasing.

Instead of discouraging participation, people should engage in meaningful discussions in order to understand others and build a better society.

Fariha Jawed is an accounting and political science junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Uber CEO leaves president’s business council, loses vital line of communication” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Uber CEO leaves president’s business council, loses vital line of communication

Credit card surcharges and the First Amendment

Credit card surcharges are synonymous with cash discounts. However, eleven states, including Texas, prohibit passing credit card surcharges onto consumers as a way to cover the merchant fees associated with credit card payments. Bans on surcharges are not a new phenomenon in the United States, but when the federal ban expired in 1984, these bans were largely left to state legislatures.

The most recent case regarding this matter, Expressions Hair Design v. Schneiderman, was heard by the Supreme Court earlier this year and concerned New York businesses that fell under the ban’s jurisdiction.

The argument was made that banning a surcharge to cover the interchange fees when a customer opts for the use of a credit card in lieu of cash or other similar means was a violation of the First Amendment right of businesses.

While it is legal under the New York statute as well as many others to offer a cash discount, businesses are not allowed to label the transaction fee a “credit card surcharge.”  

The First Amendment argument is weak. The idea that it is meant to protect consumers with transparency is suspect. Aside from refusing merchants the “right” to label a cash discount or lack thereof a particular way, very little of the legal wording of these provisions mention anything explicitly regarding free speech.

A major problem with the free speech argument is that the enforcement history concerning the charges has been ambiguous over the years. Even the aim of the statute is slightly arbitrary.

Whether these statutes imply that two prices, one for credit cards and one for cash equivalents, is prohibited or these statutes are aimed at curbing “bait-and-switch” pricing tactics is not entirely clear.

If businesses were forced to convey the reason for the credit card surcharge instead of a cash discount, it would be a way of controlling speech as well.

The reason a business wouldn’t want to convey the surcharge: to avoid the awkward conversation of why their customers suddenly have to bear the brunt on the transaction costs, which I imagine is a highly prevalent phenomenon.

Behavioral economic theories play a role in the case but are hard to quantify or find legitimate empirical evidence affirming a rejection of the ban. Overall, the argument that could potentially justify the overturn of such bans are not without merit. The surcharges could transfer more power from credit card companies to consumers.

Consumer’s sentiments could change regarding the frequent use of credit cards as well as provide consumers with more information about transactions with increased transparency. All that aside, even with commercial speech taken into account, these laws most definitely regulate conduct as opposed to speech.

In effect, this renders the First Amendment argument as an appeal that comes off as little more than grasping at straws.

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Credit card surcharges and the First Amendment” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Credit card surcharges and the First Amendment

Guest Column: Sally Yates should not be applauded

Those who disapprove of President Donald Trump’s controversial ban on immigration are championing Acting Attorney General Sally Yates, who announced Monday that she would give an order that the Department of Justice would not defend President Trump’s executive order on immigration.

President Trump removed her from office Monday evening, selecting Dana Boente, the United States Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia to replace Yates as Acting Attorney General.  

Many will see Mrs. Yates as having taking the moral high ground on this issue. Those who disagree in policy or principle with President Trump’s immigration ban are siding with Yates based on those beliefs.

The Democratic National Committee has gone so far as to issue a statement calling Yates a “heroic patriot” and the Trump administration a “tyrannical presidency.”

This is false partisan rhetoric and we should be careful to avoid glorifying an act of insubordination.

President Trump issued a lawful executive order that was reviewed by the Office of Legal Counsel. If Yates disagreed so strongly with the order, she should have brought her concerns directly to the White House. If there was no consensus and her belief was that strong against upholding the order, Yates should have resigned her position before speaking out in the manner that she did.

To be sure, it is confusing why the Trump administration didn’t simply hold off on issuing this order until Sen. Sessions is successfully confirmed. The White House knew full well who was in charge of the department. With that being said, whether or not Yates or other officials at the Justice Department agree personally with the policies of the White House should have no bearing on their ability to defend it in court.

It is one hundred percent acceptable for a private citizen to disagree with the moral implications of an executive action, but it is not legal justification for refusing to carry out the duties of the office.

The President did not order her or the department to do any illegal act. The court system will have the opportunity to judge the constitutionality of this executive order and it should receive zealous defense by the DOJ as any presidential order would receive.

This situation shows a valuable lesson that regardless of personal beliefs, it is important to keep the impartiality and procedural responsibilities of the law in high regard. Partisan politics should not have come into play in such a manner as they did.   

President Trump had every right to remove Yates, and using words like hero or patriot to describe her action sends the wrong message about the law.

Guest columnist Connor Jones is a supply chain and logistics senior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Guest Column: Sally Yates should not be applauded” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Guest Column: Sally Yates should not be applauded

Google Fiber: expansion predictions and effects concerning Houston

Google Fiber is arguably the best internet in the country right now.

The difficulty for businesses to compete with 1000 MB upload and download for $70 per month cannot be understated. However, many problems in the internet industry are explained by a lack of competition from the top-down. Three of the top internet providers in the country hold around 63 percent of the internet market.

The concentration of consumers in top-level firms in this industry raises prices and lowers speeds. 

These maps perfectly illustrate problems within the industry. The largest internet providers more or less carve out their territory, and because of the large consumer base, internet in big cities might remain subpar.

Google Fiber serves not only as an excellent choice for individual internet, but as a local monopoly–buster. The more competition within an area of internet service, the faster the speeds and the lower the prices. The industry is especially sensitive to competition due to artificial depression of internet speeds and providers‘ faulty marketing.

If Comcast wanted to offer gigabyte internet for cheap, they could. However, because of the lack of local competition, they do not have to diminish their profits through providing better service.

The regulation of internet marketing lags behind as well. The reason your internet only goes 15 Mbps when you bought 50 Mbps is because the provider is technically telling you the maximum download rate, while your effective rate is much lower. 

Where does Houston come into this? Houston, in terms of internet speed across the city, ranks mediocre at best, and with Google Fiber expanding in recent years, one would think Houston is a prime choice for Google.

Houston is a rare gem because it does not have any zoning laws. This means people are allowed to construct more freely within the city limits.

Therefore, Google would not have a particularly hard time laying the necessary fiber. Unfortunately, Houston has far too many areas locked in long–term internet contracts, meaning even if Google Fiber came to Houston, the coverage would be sparse. 

The lack of motivation from Google also comes from their expansion philosophy. Generally, Google does not want to enter areas with too many people. The largest city in their upcoming expansion is San Antonio, which has about 800,000 less people than Houston.

Part of the expansion process for Google is negotiating with local governments to ensure the smoothest and best implementation for themselves. Relatively smaller cities retain less leverage in negotiations because of their smaller consumer base compared to larger cities like New York or Los Angeles.

Google Fiber is exactly what Houston needs to fire up the internet industry. The only way this will happen is through contract reforms and city council support. Google Fiber would be a big win even if some areas are not serviced because it would pressure other providers to offer better service.

Opinion columnist Cameron Barrett is an economics senior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com. 

—
“Google Fiber: expansion predictions and effects concerning Houston” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Google Fiber: expansion predictions and effects concerning Houston

Executive order cannot discern between refugees and extremists

What does a terrorist or Islamic extremist look like? Can you tell the difference between an extremist and a refugee?

There is no way to tell who is a jihadist and who is an innocent refugee.

In the first few weeks of his term, President Trump committed the biggest case of racial profiling in the history of modern society.  

Most United States citizens can agree that terrorism is a real, horrible plague on not only our nation, but the world. However, there is no justification for punishing tens of millions for the actions of a few.  

One claim is that each of the nations on the ban list has produced terrorists who have attacked the U.S.  

Banning Iranian nationals is a big issue. There has never been an Iranian national terrorist. I challenge President Trump to produce evidence otherwise.

There are also millions of Syrian refugees trying to escape a war-torn nation. There are men, women and children who have seen horrors such as Aleppo, and all they seek is freedom.

Similarly, Libya’s place on the list is almost humorous, given the fact that our nation is directly responsible for its destabilization during former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s term. One Muslim country that is not on the list is Saudi Arabia: a country historically proven to have funded terrorist organizations such as Al-Qaida.

This order is not only distasteful, it is a slap in the face to the brave, honorable men and women who, although being foreign nationals, assist our armed forces in the Middle East.

Hameed Khalid Darweesh, an Iraqi man who put himself and his family in harm’s way during the 2003 invasion of Iraq, served the U.S. as a translator. He is directly responsible for several successful missions because of his knowledge of the local languages and landscapes.

Thankfully, Darweesh was released and returned to his family. However, he should have never been detained in the first place.

To make matters worse, President Trump’s ban only pertains to Muslims from these countries. U.S. citizens, green card holders and visa holders are permitted to enter, as long as they are members of Christian or Jewish faiths. Although the president has sole authority to invite or bar immigrants and refugees to and from the U.S., his authority does not always go unchecked.

Judge Ann Donnelly, a federal judge from Brooklyn, started to pick apart the executive order by declaring that immigrants and refugees who were mid-flight during the signing could not be sent home after being detained. The problem: she left those people and border control in limbo. No one is sure who is allowed to stay and who must go.

It is understandable that, given escalated terror around the world, the Trump administration wants to protect the borders. One can even claim that desperate times call for desperate measures. However, human rights should never be violated, people should never be discriminated against and the fundamental principles of the Constitution should always be upheld.  

What most of Trump’s supporters fail to understand is that these refugees and immigrants are not knocking on the door and asking for welfare or food stamps. They are seeking asylum from unstable countries. Just like the Irish in the 1920s, or the Italians in the 1940s, these are hard-working, innocent people looking to achieve that American dream.

Give them the natural rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness that each human deserves from birth. Citizen or not, America is supposed to be the land of the free, not the land of the aggressively racist.

Opinion columnist John Brucato is an economics senior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Executive order cannot discern between refugees and extremists” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Executive order cannot discern between refugees and extremists

Guest Column: Immigration suspension creates ‘agonizing stories’

Many UH students are being affected by the new executive order. | Courtesy of Saeid Amiri

Due to the recent executive orders signed by President Trump, students from seven Muslim countries have been banned from entry to the United States.

As a University of Houston alumnus, I am being discriminated against because of the blanket ban, and I believe that the chances for permanent extension of this temporary ban are high.

It’s clear to most UH faculty members that students from these countries have contributed greatly to the University through their dedication and research. This uncertain, volatile situation is affecting the daily life of current students from these countries in terms of loss of concentration in our academic role, and has created agonizing stories for my peers and myself.

A friend of mine was about to welcome her parents, whose visas had already been issued, to the U.S., but now, their reunion has been suspended indefinitely. The spouse of a recently married student is outside the country at the moment, and there is no indication about when the couple might see each other again.

At UH, especially in the engineering and science colleges, a significant percentage of Ph.D. students are from the banned countries. Our academic contributions demonstrate how dedicated we are and show what a contribution we have been to the University and to our fields of study.

This ban also has a detrimental effect on the graduate programs in these various departments. A lack of doctoral students, and the subsequent research and publications from those students, will result in a loss in prestige for these academic departments nationally and globally.

I genuinely request the support of UH students, faculty and staff. On Monday, we received Chancellor Khator’s reassuring message. Although it is great to have the support of different offices and centers on campus, no effective change will happen if UH administration does not relay our concerns to the top decision makers.   

Saeid Amiri is a mechanical engineering graduate, class of 2015, and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Guest Column: Immigration suspension creates ‘agonizing stories’” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Guest Column: Immigration suspension creates ‘agonizing stories’

Financial inequality projected upon women

There’s essentially no argument against the fact that women of all countries, races and origins are discriminated against in some way.

Yes, America has one of the most beneficial atmospheres for women, but there are still issues that exist within our society regarding gender discrimination. It stands as a fact that this prejudice flows through nearly every aspect of society, and perhaps one of the most debilitating instances of this is the financial inequality of women.

It’s proven that women pay more for goods and services than men do. Products offered to consumers are broken down into categories of necessity and desire, and from there are divided into gender-specific groups. Usually, the only variation in these products is the color.

A recent study conducted by the New York City Department of Consumer Affairs analyzed the prices of nearly 800 products and concluded that 42% of the products sold to women were more expensive. Razors sold to women are 11% more expensive than those sold to men, and the price of shampoo price is increased by a whopping 48%.

This enigma even bleeds down into children’s toys. The exact same toy targeted toward girls with gender-specific packaging is proven to cost an average 11% more than those that are targeted toward boys or are gender-neutral. According to a Kansas City news source, in 2015, a gender-neutral scooter retailed at $29.92 while a nearly identical pink one with tassels cost $32.82. According to the same source, at another store, a gender-neutral kitchen set was priced at $138.99 while the identical one, colored in pastels, went for $172.61.

The acceptance of this entertains the idea that women are willing to pay more for these feminized products. Alongside this, there is the idea held by big business that women simply aren’t economically intelligent enough to understand the price differences regarding gender-directed products. Yale directed a study that confirmed that women pay, on average, $200 more for the exact same vehicle than one purchased by a man.

This is because women aren’t perceived as learned in things that are culturally regarded as masculine interests.

According to the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, women are paid 21.4% less than men. The issue is even more substantial when it comes to women of color. The American Association of University Women reported that, in 2014, black women earned 63% of what white men in America were paid while Latina women earned 54%.

With these women falling into higher poverty rates, the discrimination between race and gender becomes even more evident. This puts an even greater financial strain on low-income households, promotes the use of welfare and does nothing to address the issue of poverty that runs rampant through the nation.  

The price increase on gender-specific goods is illogical, and so far, there has been no acknowledgement of this controversy by the national government. Everything is considered from an economic standpoint, and the only logical reason that gender discrimination in consumer products still exists is that there is no financial benefit to equalizing these prices.

On a state level, only California and New York have passed laws making it illegal to engage in gender-based price discrimination.

As sexism flows through America in the 21st century, the gaps regarding men and women need to be closed and steps toward complete equality need to be taken. Women are being taken advantage of, and when they’re paying more and earning less in 2017, there is an evident issue at hand that needs to be eradicated immediately.

Katie Santana is a graphic design sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Financial inequality projected upon women” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Financial inequality projected upon women

At UH, too many complications when getting emotional support animals

Jane Doe is a student at the University of Houston suffering from bipolar disorder.

She is seeking treatment at UH’s Counseling and Psychological Services and got referred to UH Psychiatry, where she was diagnosed and medicated. Jane Doe was struggling with her diagnoses and lack of communication within CAPS prior to the holiday break.

She used her break as a time to think, strategize and reflect on how she could be successful.
One of the things she noticed was how much animals, particularly dogs, grounded her.

She always loved dogs but this seemed like more. However, like many students, Jane Doe lived in an apartment complex that has a strict no pets policy. She mustered up the courage to speak with her therapist about the possibility of being recommended for an emotional support animal.
Her therapist was in full support; she had read studies and believed that Jane could benefit from this type of treatment.

Unfortunately, the therapist did not know the process and told Jane to speak with her psychiatrist.
Jane’s psychiatrist gave her the runaround and referred her back to her therapist.

This time, the therapist was on board but had to tell her director because she had never done this before. Jane, like many college students, acted prematurely and adopted a puppy.

A few days after Jane adopted the puppy, her therapist emailed her to inform her it was against CAPS policy to write letters for emotional support animals.

Jane recommends that you “save your time and your tears and find a good counselor in the community if you need more serious treatment options.”

Jane’s story leads us to question why this policy was not clear and why this accommodation is not supported by our campus administrators.

The rise of mental illness

Approximately 61.5 million Americans, or one in four adults, experience a mental health impairment in any year and one in 17, representing 13.6 million people, live with a serious mental illness, such as depression or bipolar disorder.

The rise of reported mental illnesses has also created an increase in students asking for accommodations.

One of those accommodations is for an emotional support animal or ESA. By their nature, and without training, these animals may relieve depression and anxiety and help reduce stress-induced pain.

Some may be asking, “What exactly is an emotional support animal and how is different than a pet?”

Well, an emotional support animal is not a pet; it is “a companion animal that provides therapeutic benefit to an individual with a mental or psychiatric disability. The person seeking the emotional support animal must have a verifiable disability” at the Michigan State University animal and legal & historical center.

The animal is viewed as a reasonable accommodation under the Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988 to those housing communities that have a “no pets” rule.

The Fair Housing Act was created to make sure that those with physical or mental disabilities are not discriminated against unjustly. The Fair Housing Act protects against discrimination in university housing and apartments with “no pet” policies.

There has been substantial research across the health sciences that provides evidence of the human health benefits, including physiological, psychological and emotional, that can be derived from human-animal interactions.

However, universities, including UH, do not make this process a walk in the park. The process is full of hoops to jump through that can easily discourage a college student who is seeking help.

To be eligible for an emotional support animal on the UH campus, you must first request accommodations through the Center for Students with DisABILITIES.

If granted approval, you then must meet all of the requirements set by Student Housing and Residential Life. The problem with housing’s policy is that the guidelines are incredibly subjective and lacks quantitative attributes.

For example, students may not have a dog unless it has up-to-date immunizations and is spayed or neutered. This is an issue because students cannot have a dog with records prior to being approved by housing.

But before these parts of the process are even relevant, anyone needing an emotional support animal must obtain a letter from a licensed mental health professional that demonstrates there is a relationship between the practitioner and the patient along with how the animal would help the patient.

Restricting on-campus treatment

Some students may think that they would be able to receive the treatment options they need from their campus counseling center, but this isn’t always the case. Even though in Fall 2018 UH students will be pay approximately $47.36 to CAPS through their student fees, CAPS will have several new policies that restrict extremely beneficial treatment options to students.

One of those policies is that they will “NOT provide letters for emotional support animals.” However, this policy is obviously not one that is communicated amongst all staff members at CAPS. It also does not act in accordance with the U.S Department of Education guidelines as listed in Section 504 regulatory provision at 34 C.F.R. 104.3(j)(2)(i).

The Section 504 regulatory provision defines a physical or mental impairment as “any physiological disorder or condition, cosmetic disfigurement, or anatomical loss affecting one or more of the following body systems: neurological; musculoskeletal; special sense organs; respiratory, including speech organs; cardiovascular; reproductive; digestive; genito-urinary; hemic and lymphatic; skin; and endocrine; or any mental or psychological disorder, such as mental retardation, organic brain syndrome, emotional or mental illness, and specific learning disabilities.”

This act also mandates that colleges must accommodate individuals accordingly.

The Housing and Urban Development policy on emotional support animals has been on the books since 2013, and studies on emotional support animals have been a topic of public debate since at least 2010.

For our University to have unclear policies and protocols within a professional, fee-funded institution for at least four years is unacceptable. Students should utilize the services they pay for and should also be holding them accountable for their actions.

When comparing UH’s policy and guidelines regarding emotional support animals, the University of Texas is miles ahead of UH. UT has clearly stated definitions and policies that are laid out on their policies webpage.

UT does not let questions about mental health go unanswered on their webpage and lays out all relevant information and policies to allow for transparency for the students they serve.

Delaney Catlettstout is a political science senior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“At UH, too many complications when getting emotional support animals” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on At UH, too many complications when getting emotional support animals

President Trump’s executive order is within executive powers

On Jan. 27, President Trump signed an executive order that halted refugee admission for 120 days and temporarily banned entry from seven countries of concern — Iraq, Iran, Syria, Yemen, Sudan, Libya and Somalia — all in the name of better vetting.

As a result of the executive order, protests have sprung up at various airports across the country and has sparked the hashtag #NoBanNoWall. The Trump administration decided to sign the EO at 5:30 p.m. on a Friday, which is the basis of all the confusion surrounding what the EO actually said and what the provisions were. No one knew what was actually going on.

I’d be remiss if I didn’t point out that none of this should have come as a surprise. Trump promised all of these actions during his campaign for the presidency. Kudos to Trump for doing what he said he was going to do, whether you agree with him or not.

What’s in the EO

There has been a lot of hysteria surrounding the EO; it seems like people just want to react without reading what’s in it. So let me explain what the EO actually does.

First, the EO places a 120 day halt on refugee admissions to the U.S. so that the government can improve the current vetting process. The EO caps the number of refugee admissions at 50,000 per year. This isn’t crazy by any means; this has been the cap for the past four years.

Obama expanded the number of refugees admitted from the W. Bush administration, so Trump is not narrowing the number of refugees admitted — he is continuing an already existing policy.

Second, the EO places a 90-day ban on people entering from Iraq, Iran, Syria, Yemen, Sudan, Libya and Somalia. These 7 countries are not just picked out of thin air.

They come from Obama-era policy. The EO specifically refers to a policy drafted by the Obama administration: “From countries referred to in section 217(a)(12) of the INA, 8 U.S.C. 1187(a)(12).” The section of that policy is entitled “Not Present in Iraq, Syria, or any other country or area of concern.”

Then, in early 2016, the Obama Department of Homeland Security named the five other countries of concern. This is why these seven countries were named and not the other countries with terrorist ties.

The EO does mention religion when it comes to those being persecuted for their faith — i.e. Christians in the Middle East. And for those of you thinking that this kind of religious test is unacceptable, it’s actually required by law. As stated in Section 1158 of Title 8, US Code, “the applicant must establish that…religion…was or will be at least one central reason for persecuting the applicant.”

What the EO is not

For the love of everything that is good, stop calling this a Muslim ban; it is not.

The word “Islam” or “Muslim” is not found in the EO at any point. Anyone who says that the EO is a Muslim ban is clearly misinformed or lying.

If this was a Muslim ban, then the 40 or so Muslim majority countries would also be on the list. Indonesia — the largest Muslim majority nation — is not on the list. The media’s claims that the EO is a Muslim ban is perpetuating the fake news they so love to hate.

The EO is clearly constitutional. Those claiming that the EO is unconstitutional are giving two pieces of reason: the 14th Amendment and whether Trump has the ability to do what the EO states.

Firstly, Trump does have the ability to do this: it falls under the purview of the executive branch.

Those who are claiming the EO is unconstitutional are trying to prove that the Constitution applies to non-citizens, which is blatantly false. The inalienable rights apply to everyone, the Bill of Rights does not.

The 14th amendment states, “No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”

This would push the narrative that the Constitution applies to everyone, if the 14th Amendment didn’t begin by stating, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside,” which negates the application argument.

Green Card and Legal Status

The biggest confusion about the EO comes from the fact that no one seemed to know whether the EO applied to green card holders and those with legal status. According to CNN, the DHS initially said that the EO did not apply to those with special status. But, Trump advisers Steve Bannon and Stephen Miller interpreted the EO to mean the exact opposite and thus overruled the DHS.

This whole saga is ridiculous. Those with legal status and those who hold green cards have already been through extreme vetting. This is just pure incompetence from the Trump team. And if it was done deliberately, they must be called out for it.

It remains to be seen whether this EO actually does its job, but it most likely will not have an effect. The level of hysteria surrounding this EO only reinforces the fact that there is an epidemic of fake news in this country.

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“President Trump’s executive order is within executive powers” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on President Trump’s executive order is within executive powers

Immigration executive order is un-American

On Friday, Jan. 27, President Trump signed a far-reaching executive order on immigration.

This order bans immigration from seven Muslim countries – Iran, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen – for 90 days, suspends all refugee admission for 120 days and bars Syrian refugees indefinitely.

This ban that originally included people on any U.S. visa category (such as green-card holders) has since been revised to apply to people who, regardless of status, seem suspicious. What doesn’t seem to make sense is why these countries were selected. President Trump has claimed national security and preventing terrorism as the motive behind the executive order.

However, no one has been killed in the U.S. by anyone from these countries. If anything, these actions propagate Islamophobia and hatred, and further the cause of terrorists who use these type of instances to justify their behavior.

While this is the most obvious part of the ban, there are other important takeaways from the order. The order says, “The Secretary of Homeland Security, in consultation with the Secretary of State, shall submit to the President a list of countries recommended for inclusion,” implying that this ban has the potential to extend far beyond just the current seven countries. However, in some ways, it already does because no refugees from any country are allowed for 120 days.

Another alarming section of the order gives priority to non-Muslim refugees. The order declares prioritization for “refugee claims made by individuals on the basis of religious-based persecution, provided that the religion of the individual is a minority religion in the individual’s country of nationality.”

For all who refuse to admit it, this is a Muslim ban. Even though President Trump says it isn’t, that doesn’t mean his actions do not have that exact consequence.

This is obviously religion-based discrimination because all the countries included in this ban are Muslim countries. Therefore, people of minority faiths in these countries, such as Christians, will be allowed entry into the U.S.

The impacts of this ban have been widely seen this weekend, as people were detained at airports across the U.S. About 375 were impacted, in the form of being denied entry into the U.S., or stopped from boarding flights to the U.S. Large amounts of people also showed up to airports to display their support for the detained individuals.

Countries that have been included in the ban, such as Iran, have expressed how offended they are by President Trump’s actions. Since this order has been implemented, the American Civil Liberties Union has sustained a federal court order that grants an emergency stay for the people who have already made it to the U.S., or are in transit.

Besides the fact that the countries chosen don’t pose a threat to the U.S., this ban sends a very clear message to people everywhere. Following the rules, and even respecting the U.S. Constitution, does not mean you will be treated fairly. There are countless amounts of people who have waited their turn and respected the immigration process, and yet are still being denied entry into the U.S.

Whether or not you follow the rules, you still get punished.

Everything about this ban screams “un-American.” Diversity is what makes this country such a great place to live. Blocking an entire region of the world in the name of “national security” is not an effective way to stop terrorism, and instead it inhibits diversity.  

For the individuals that think people aren’t justified in being terrified for their well-being under Trump’s administration, you’re wrong.

People have every reason to feel worried or scared for all the uncertainty that is going to follow them. If this is any indication of what the next four years are going to be, people have every right to feel upset. Regardless, we need to continue to be vigilant and stand up for our rights and the rights of the people around us.

Fariha Jawed is an accounting and political science junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Immigration executive order is un-American” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Immigration executive order is un-American