Author Archives | opiniondesk

Focus Friday: Did the Super Bowl have lasting effects on Houston?

In a way, Super Bowl LI was like the Olympics on a smaller scale. The city was touched up pretty extensively in order to entertain guests from all over the country for a short period of time. But these improvements were nowhere near temporary. Now, Discovery Green and NRG park have additions that will most likely last for a while and the best part: all of the facilities will continue to be used and will not be abandoned. It was a long-term investment that will continue to pay Houstonians and all who visit those venues back. So in a way, even though it was a major logistical nightmare for Houstonians, especially in the week leading up to it, the Super Bowl did a good job of showcasing our city to the rest of the country.
The Super Bowl is the most glamorous and dramatic American football game of the year. This event perhaps reflects everything good and bad about American society, including effort, individualism, teamwork, love, hate and conflict. The Super Bowl’s effect on Houston was essentially neutral, as the insane amount of coverage and money did not really benefit the people of Houston. Most of the benefits went towards the teams who played, the NFL and the several businesses that participated in the event. The average watcher just enjoyed a well-played football game. The Super Bowl serves as more of a pleasant distraction to the city rather than some sort of catalyst for economic gain, or just some magnet for crowded streets and businesses. It has the capacity to be a unifier in a divided and problem-filled world. Sports, in general, has an important function in life and is regarded as an indispensable factor for intellectual and moral growth. While sports are fascinating to participate in, whether as a viewer or player, the display of physical capabilities and the beauty of the human body draws us to admire these games. The problem appears as the money and glamour of these fantastic events are placed above the athletic skill. While the Super Bowl in Houston was enchanting, there is no clear determination to say it was good or bad for the city.
It’s always true that whenever a city hosts a large sports event good and bad follows. The Super Bowl is probably the greatest American (sports) attraction all year. It is a big gamble to host; you either get a lot of money and great press, or you lose. For the week leading up to the Super Bowl, Houston felt a lot of the bad effects: terrible traffic, tourists clogging up everything, press everywhere. But, even with that, it seems like we won. The city pulled off a fantastic Super Bowl week, and catered to everyone very well. We made a huge profit of $350 million, which doesn’t always happen. The (end) of the Super Bowl was fantastic (from a sports sense). We caught some very bad guys. In the end, people will remember Houston and Super Bowl 51, and that’s what matters.

—
“Focus Friday: Did the Super Bowl have lasting effects on Houston?” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Focus Friday: Did the Super Bowl have lasting effects on Houston?

Hate is becoming strategized

Hate Crime: a crime motivated by racial, sexual or other prejudice, typically one involving violence.

September 15, 1963: The 16th Street Baptist Church bombing in Birmingham, Alabama. An act of white supremacist terrorism leaves four black bodies dead.

June 26, 2011: James Craig Anderson is assaulted and murdered by a group of white men for no other reason than skin color.

June 17th, 2015: A massacre leaving nine black bodies dead in a Charleston, South Carolina, church.

Some of the most well known and documented hate crimes in U.S. history have been perpetrated by white men. Now, the social law that protects the systematically disenfranchised has become strategy for legislation and the Blue Lives Matter coalition.

In Louisiana, a law passed stating that police officers are now protected under hate crimes in the same vein as sexuality and race. Hate crimes were something that only seemed to happen to marginalized groups, and now it has been reappropriated to protect the lethal subgroup of officers that has been orchestrating oppression through executing law.

Under this new law, actions like resisting arrest and battery can be classified as a hate crime against police. Such things are up to the officers’ discretion, but as the resume shows for instances in police brutality, the slightest thought of danger can lead to shots fired.

When it comes to resisting arrest, there is video evidence of police claiming resist when it is just simply not the case. A simple nudge of a shoulder or just an involuntary reaction to real danger can be put under the umbrella of hate.

People have the natural tendency to survive. It’s an instinct. When the human body senses danger, whether it be from a wild animal or a 200 pound officer squishing them into concrete, the body’s main reaction is to tense up and protect itself.

Moreso, this is not good for protesters. Protests are passionate by nature. As we have seen with the numerous protests taking place throughout the country, they do not always end peacefully. This would be a field day for the police that emote their self issues coupled with their abuse of power to harm people.

In history, hate crimes have been not only legal but also encouraged. People treated lynchings as public events for not only the radically racist but also common people and children. The foundation of the United States was built from hate crimes against African and eventually African-American people.

Stealing people from their homes, the U.S. created an economic basis for the selling of humans in the transatlantic slave trade, which destroyed families for profit and power. Rape, kidnapping and murder: all crimes whose common denominator is rooted in hate.

Today: Race relations between police and blacks have never seen peace especially in impoverished neighborhoods. Now the current version of the lynchings, which is hate fueled murder, is the killing of unarmed black people without reasoning except loose speculation and irrational racialized fear.

With Louisiana police now having this new law at their disposal, this is a direct response to Black Lives Matter from the group of a similar name, Blue Lives Matter. The premise of Black Lives Matter is that black lives are in danger.

The danger to police lives is not comparable to the danger for black lives. Police officers are not disproportionately targeted without reason besides the color of their skin or, in this case, the color of their uniform.

When it comes to the relationship between police and the black community, it has always been one of tension. Constantly the forces sworn to protect and serve have acted as a menacing group that has unwaveringly acted against communities that are either impoverished or predominantly black.

The people in these neighborhoods and black people in general tense up when a cop is even even in their proximity. By nature, we are wary of the sense of control that is lifted from us when we interact with police. One area that is never talked about is what goes on in the mind of black people in the situation of law enforcement.

It is not of matter of statistics because this is something that is not researched. It is rather seen in the conversation that is captured in the video that we do get. With the incident in Tulsa County, there is video of an officer telling the detained “(Expletive) your breath.”

This infers the status of how the officer views this black person. In the incident with the McKinney police and the swimming pool, you can see how the white male recording the altercation is immune to orders from police but the black males are not. This shows the perceived notions that cops have on black people as opposed to white people.

This kind of thinking comes from media, literature, film and the over-representation of black people as criminals. It seeps into the mind and makes someone associate what they have been consuming to the real-life person.

The danger is the homogenization of black people as criminal or dangerous, which is a stereotype that has been stigmatized through the world.  Even the satire of Blue Lives Matter is a joke; if BLM fizzled out, Blue Lives Matter would quickly do the same.

Blue Lives Matter perpetuates a false sense of danger to police, creating excuses for them to use extreme measures when handling people. It also de-legitimizes BLM and what they are trying to do. As we have seen from the adamant force and authority that police have, this fake movement is unnecessary based on their actions.

The Dallas shootings were shocking because they happened under everyone’s noses in the midst of an already-chaotic protest that the police were trying to maintain. However, the attack from the shooter was not a result of BLM, and he was shown to be unstable and prejudice toward cops. The perpetrator does not in anyway reflect the values of the Black Lives Matter movement and was not co-signed by them, either.

We know that all police are not bad. It has been said numerous times and it will continue to be said. But the actions of a few, with zero consequences, make these instances seem warranted and make citizens feel unsafe from those that are meant to eradicate that fear.

There is no reason for children that are supposed to look at law enforcement as heroes to now look at them as a threat.

If resisting arrest is going to be labelled as a hate crime, then police brutality should be added right along with it. It all seems like the making of a dastardly equation by law: Stop and frisk times intimidation plus the hate-crime law equals a high probability for targeted attacks against minorities, all in the name of law.   

Opinion columnist Dana Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Hate is becoming strategized” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Hate is becoming strategized

Trump’s new executive orders on treaties and international aid

The effect of refuting international trade deals has its own set of benefits and drawbacks no matter how they are viewed.

It is always difficult to quantify the correlation between economic and humanitarian benefits and drawbacks when dealing with treaties. The same could easily be said for intergovernmental organizations such as the United Nations and their peacekeeping efforts.

The economic provisions of these trade deals, however, are not the concern of this column.

It was reported by the New York Times that the Trump administration was preparing two executive orders dealing with intergovernmental organizations and foreign aid. They were entitled “Auditing and Reducing U.S. Funding of International Organizations” and “Moratorium on New Multilateral Treaties,” respectively.

The subject matter of these executive orders would call for eliminating funding for the international bodies that meet certain criteria and for a review of the United States’ current and pending treaties with foreign nations.

It’s reasonable that the incredibly large amounts of foreign aid we provide other countries and its lack of transparency is a matter of concern.

Everyone involved in foreign affairs rarely knows where the copious amounts of financial support for economic and military assistance end up. So it’s a pretty safe political stance to support it, or as it is, to criticize it.

Bureaucracy and its frustrations are low-hanging fruits for any politician because they are experienced by all levels of society. The average citizen getting an identification card at the Department of Motor Vehicles is just as frustrated with the legal framework they must circumvent as an Iranian ambassador entering the U.S.

As the U.S. has seen with Afghanistan in recent history, entangling military efforts in foreign countries inevitably leads to “peacekeeping” and “rebuilding” efforts with foreign countries.

The disdain that President Trump and his administration have expressed towards the red tape in government is not without merit, regardless of the fact that it seems like a necessary evil.

Despite living in the “information age,” the United States is not headed towards some form of a  technocracy. A technocracy is defined as the management of society by technical experts, in their respectable fields.

However, the recent memos sent to Federal agencies to halt external communications lend to the idea that this will not be the chosen path of this administration. So, the government wants to stifle its own agencies’ freedom to operate while simultaneously cutting ties to third party international organizations by eliminating foreign aid and cutting multilateral treaties.

If unilateralism is the true intention behind the denunciation of multilateral treaties, these future efforts would be more respectable endeavors. In actuality, the denunciation seems like a subversive declaration of support for some countries over others.

Israel is a big example, especially considering that some of the largest campaign contributors of Trump’s campaign are major supporters of anti-Palestinian efforts.

This seems to be the case, especially since these proposed measures seem like they are aimed largely in part at withdrawing support for organizations that recognize support for Palestine and Palestinian groups.

Israel, a country slightly larger than the state of New Jersey, receives more financial assistance for security assistance from the U.S. than almost any other country in the world. Israel is also a country that continues to curb ties with intergovernmental bodies that oppose any of its policies.  The aim of these executive orders appear to cherry-pick where we provide aid as opposed to a policy that we believe we should not provide foreign aid.

Cutting ties with intergovernmental and international bodies also lessens our ability to use these organizations and their research as a third party source for enacting many of our foreign policy initiatives.

If we are going to rely on our own experts for policy initiatives, we cannot halt their communications. If we are going to rely on our third party experts, like many intergovernmental bodies, we cannot cut ties with them.

If we are going to frame these measures as “all or nothing,” it must be followed through on a practical level in that same regard.

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Trump’s new executive orders on treaties and international aid” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Trump’s new executive orders on treaties and international aid

More education spending doesn’t mean smarter students

Education quality and funding are often linked.

Liberals tend to favor higher spending and teacher salaries because it produces better results in students, while conservatives often tend to cut from education before anything else when balancing a budget.

Bill Clinton once said that higher quality schools tend to pay proportionally more of their revenue to teacher salaries than those who do not. His statement is based on the assumption that if teachers are paid more and receive more appreciation relative to their district’s budget constraints, they will subsequently teach better, which — in theory — leads to more well-rounded students.

I ran a regression to answer whether teacher pay and school quality correlate.

One limitation of this study is that the data does not match according to year; 2013-2014 spending figures are used with 2016 rankings. Figures were chosen from Wallethub because it has more precise, quantitative measures from 1-100 on school quality, rather than a simple ranking.

A lot can change in two school years, but the assumption is that state level spending is more or less equal in a two-year time frame, and one’s education quality score will remain steady within that same period. The implications of this mismatch will shrink once the later part of the study is examined. 

After running a regression that tried to answer if teacher pay and school quality were related, I found almost no correlation between teacher pay and education quality.

However, there are diminishing returns and optimization in almost all levels of economics. If a state were to experiment with a zero-dollar salary, they would likely see a mass exodus and drop in quality.

On the opposite side of the coin, if a state began paying teachers $150,000 per year, the state would likely see a flurry of new and eager teachers with a marginal increase in education quality. 

A final note concerning this study is per-pupil spending and its relation to education quality. I chose not to use aggregate spending because, of course, California will spend more than Vermont on students overall, but that is a population issue rather than a performance issue.

Per-pupil spending is the best way to control for state size while still searching for a meaningful relationship between spending and education quality. After all the data were compiled and fitted, this was the relationship between spending and education quality: 

There is seemingly no correlation between teacher pay and the quality of education produced. | Cameron Barrett/The Cougar

The amount spent per student directly correlates to the quality of education. | Cameron Barrett/The Cougar

This yielded more promising results, as spending and education quality are more strongly correlated, yet the correlation remains relatively weak. This is why I said the limitations of the study will narrow as the regressions are analyzed.

Though the education score and spending figures are mismatched, these correlations are so incredibly weak that it would be very unlikely this correlation would tighten a significant amount with matching data.

To be clear, spending is a factor in the quality of public education in the U.S., and perhaps a much more in-depth study district by district would yield different results, but the evidence provided is clear.

Spending is generally a weak predictor of education quality. Merely throwing money at problem school areas is not enough in some cases.

Columnist Cameron Barrett is an economics senior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“More education spending doesn’t mean smarter students” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on More education spending doesn’t mean smarter students

Politicians should not use children as political props

The “think of the children” tactic has gone way too far at this point. Any politician who does this should be disregarded | Tamor Khan/The Cougar

Politicians love to make you feel with them.

They want you to be blasted with the same emotions that they are purportedly feeling. And to do this, politicians parade children in front of audiences to evoke the “think of the children” thoughts that so permeate today’s political rhetoric.

It is the lowest form of persuasion. And it needs to stop, now.

Last week, as the protests against President Trump raged throughout the country’s airports, New York Sen. Chuck Schumer trotted out children to stand behind him as he delivered an “emotional” speech to the press.

Chuck Schumer should never be listened to again because of this. Nor should any politician who does this, no matter what side of the aisle that politician is on. They’re not arguing the facts; they’re arguing emotion.

The “think of the children” tactic has gone way too far at this point. It’s used at every turn to make people feel, not to actually think. Politicians use it for everything and it’s breaking down political persuasion.

Whenever Obama wanted to further his gun control legislation, the kids would be called in to remind everyone to think of the children and how they need us to protect them.

Whenever someone on the right wants to spend more on the military and continue to bomb ISIS, they remind everyone to think of the children and their safety.

Both sides are using the “think of the children” argument to further their arguments about Trump’s ban. Liberals are worried about the children who are refugees and from other countries.

Conservatives are worried about the possible terrorist attacks on the American children. It’s tiresome. And it doesn’t actually talk about the issue at hand.

When a politician uses this argument, it is ultimately because they have nothing else to say; all their other arguments have been defeated by logic or it’s just easier to use emotion.

It doesn’t make the argument stronger. There is no reliance on any sort of facts. It’s all about emotion, and when emotion gets infused into politics, politics gets dangerous.

And it’s not just when politicians are signing bills and giving press conferences to the drooling media. In 2013, Fox News reported that there had been an increase in politicians using children in ads.

This is the worst thing that could happen to the current political scene. The last election had the “Our Children are Watching” ad to hit at Trump. Why does it matter what the children are feeling?

It’s politics, not the playground.

Groups are also using children to get across their political messages. During the Super Bowl, both Audi and 84 Lumber used children to get their political messages across.

Forgetting the fact that politicizing the Super Bowl is just stupid and everyone is tired of it and just wants to watch football, it’s ridiculous that these companies would feel compelled to use children to get their message across.

If they wanted to integrate politics into their commercials, make an actual argument, don’t use children.

Politicians do it because it works. Stop letting it work. Start calling out politicians whenever they use children to try and further themselves. They shouldn’t be listened to at the least and they should be shunned at the most.

This is the lowest form of politics and it needs to stop.

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Politicians should not use children as political props” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Politicians should not use children as political props

Automation is the unavoidable future of the economy

We’re currently at 4.9 percent unemployment, and it’s only because machines are not smart or cheap enough to replace us.

The motto of entrepreneurship incubators is “disrupt your industry,” which really means “introduce technology to an established industry.” Uber decimated taxis and public transportation, Amazon Now brought two-hour delivery to large metropolitan areas and Google is advancing its machine learning algorithms along with its consumer AI.

So far, these services have managed to improve our quality of life without negative impacts to our economy. However, the systems, infrastructure and technology that power these services are still in their infancy. Our economy is about to experience a change as dramatic as the industrial revolution.

The economy has evolved before

Automation has been threatening to take our jobs since the cotton gin. And it has, but new, better jobs have come along. When agriculture was automated, our economy changed. No longer was it necessary to have 40 percent of our workforce performing manual labor.

This freed up the necessary workforce to allow the industrial revolution to take off and manufacturing jobs took over as the American employer.

The industrial revolution was also a technological revolution. It allowed automation to build cars, air conditioners, or any product significantly cheaper while requiring less human involvement.

The economy adjusted. As these middle-class manufacturing jobs left our economy, we attempted to adjust. However, our middle class has suffered and continues to be in decline.

How long before automation takes a more significant role in our economy and lives?

The current situation

Uber has become the ubiquitous transportation application. Since Uber’s pricing became competitive it’s garnered more customers, and its service has become significantly more convenient. What most don’t know is that Uber operates at a loss.

Every year, the company loses money but continues to be the most popular transportation app with no signs of slowing down. The long-term business plan isn’t eventually paying drivers less; it’s eventually not paying them at all.

Uber is banking on self-driving cars to become commercially available in the next few years. An entire fleet of cars that need no sleep, are constantly available and run on electricity. 

Retail companies have made their logistical processes as automated and intelligent as possible. Amazon Now and Amazon GO are services that are recent, and both function to connect a costumer to a product as quickly and as easily as possible.

Amazon Now is a two-hour delivery service, and it’s amazing. You can order 80 percent of your grocery needs, an Xbox controller and batteries and have them delivered to your door two hours later.

Amazon’s logistics process is the most advanced in the world, meaning that it’s the most automated. Amazon GO is a brick-and-mortar store that doesn’t need cashiers. When a customer walks in, they scan their phone, grab the food they want and walk out.

Depending on their logistics process, Amazon might even have machines stocking the shelves as well.

The future of automation

Machine learning is the software side of automation. Google has been working on a project called Deepmind. This software learns any task by running billions of simulations, adjusting the variables it’s allowed, and without instructions, quickly learning the most effective ways to accomplish its goal.

This process allows it to approach problems in ways humans would never think of. It’s most recent accomplishment is winning a game of GO, against the best player in the world. A step above Chess (as it’s believed you need a sense of intuition to win).

These systems can be taught to program, write papers and design complex structures, as well as take restaurant orders, provide better automated customer service, do research and design better versions of themselves.

Machine learning software can learn to write news articles by reading millions of reports to understand human writing patterns. It will be able to quickly draft summaries for press conferences and speeches. Bias can even be programmed in.

Innovation and automation are an unavoidable future. Profit drives innovation, and no matter what the effect it has on the middle class, companies will not stop automating processes.

Our politicians are concerned with coal and manufacturing jobs that are already obsolete and fail to see the future that’s looming.

Our economy is not prepared for a future in which the unemployment rate is constantly high or a people no longer need to work 40-hour weeks. Companies will continue to reduce overhead by cutting away the inefficient, prone to error fat that hinders profits.

Since machines run pretty lean, the only fat I see is us.

Hugo Salinas is a MIS senior and a regular contributor to Cooglife magazine. He can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Automation is the unavoidable future of the economy” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Automation is the unavoidable future of the economy

Freedom of speech works both ways on campus

American universities are spaces where ideas are raised, where we learn and begin to understand our freedoms to be individuals who speak our minds. | Ajani Stewart/The Cougar

Frederick Douglass said: “To suppress free speech is a double wrong. It violates the rights of the hearer as well as those of the speaker.”

Everyone has the same right to use their First Amendment right as long as they can do it in the proper place with proper consent. Even if they are proclaiming hateful rhetoric. Just the same way that someone who disagrees can set up across the street and publicly disagree.

During our time in college we are exposed to a whole new world. As an out of state student from Missouri, coming to the University of Houston was the first time I saw such a diverse population in such a concentrated area. This diversity is something that draws many to this University — not just the variety of race and religion, but the variety of thought.

This diversity of thought is something often extremely underrated in our academic community.

American universities are spaces where ideas are raised, where we learn and begin to understand our freedoms, our freedoms to be an individual and our freedoms to speak our minds.

The free-speech-on-campus argument often comes from a conservative platform. Conservatives have been fighting to make sure their leaders have a platform to speak. One of these controversial leaders is Milo Yiannopoulos.

Yiannopoulos performs a far-right comedy show that minimizes sexual assault, domestic violence, feminism and the #BlackLivesMatter movement. While many don’t agree with Milo’s sentiments, he does have the right to speak.

A common misconception is that free speech and assembly are allowed everywhere.

A plethora of Supreme Court cases and years of policies in the making has slowly put limits on our right to free speech and assembly.

Some of those limits include: libel, slander, fighting words and national security.

A college campus often creates zones of free speech. One of these zones on the UH campus is in front of the library in Butler Plaza.

This is why you often see the group of middle-aged white men with signs accusing students of witchcraft, adultery and sin. However, this assemblage is not acceptable throughout campus.

The Young Americans for Liberty, a libertarian organization that began in 2008, started a movement to tear down the idea of free-speech zones on campus to allow for students to exercise their rights anywhere and everywhere. The issue with this is that that is not the reality. The freedoms protected by the First Amendment have their limits. There is a chapter established at UH.

Freedom of assembly is often met with filling out city paperwork to meet the requirements set by city code for safety.

The same standard is held for universities who lack the adequate funding for a campus police force that can handle large crowds or does not want to risk intervening and further agitating protesters.

However, in most instances, Milo has the proper approval to host gatherings and events for people to hear his show. He often gets invited and sponsored by the College Republicans.

By being sponsored by a registered student organization, he has been given a platform at the University. He is given the right to speak.

What many people forget is that freedom of speech is a two-way street and often comes with consequences. Just as Milo has the right to speak, offended students have the right to resist or counter his sentiments.

This does not condone the actions of the Berkeley protesters who rioted and prevented Yiannopoulos from speaking on campus, but it serves as a reminder that both sides have a voice and have rights.

But both sides face the consequences. Berkeley protesters may get arrested or kicked out to school for defacing property or breaking school policies. Their speech, however, is protected.

If Yiannopoulos or other prominent leaders spew racists comments or marginalize a community, the marginalized have every right to speak out and demand that the person be held accountable. If a high-level official at a university said racist comments, they could be fired. Not because they don’t have the right to speak their mind, but because they, as an employee, no longer represent the interests of the university or the students.

Universities should foster civic discourse and diversity of thought. However, as students, we must remember that with freedom comes responsibility. Everyone has the right to say what they want, but this does not free them from the consequences of their statements.

Even if ones does not agree with Yiannopoulos, his freedom should be respected and acknowledged. By being open to acknowledging his rights opens the gates for student to engage civic discourse, question ideas, and respect others freedoms without name calling or insults.

Liberals calling for justice and providing legal pushback against Milo are not crying snowflakes and not all conservatives who entertain Milo’s rhetoric are misogynistic, racist, neo-nazis.
This type of name calling, while one’s right, deters from civic discourse and progress.

People from all sides of the political spectrum share the same basic rights and whether that is protesting a president or hosting a controversial speaker, the right to speak your mind, should hold value.

Delaney Catlettstout is a political science senior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Freedom of speech works both ways on campus” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Freedom of speech works both ways on campus

Republicans must stand tall in face of Trump’s call for nuclear option

The nuclear option is a complex procedure, used in times of duress, during which the ruling of the chair may be confirmed by a simple majority vote. It lays the opponents’ appeal on the table and reinterprets the rules.

The appeal process in this case is the filibuster for the nomination of Neil Gorsuch as a Supreme Court justice where the majority vote would replace the 60-vote supermajority required to stop a filibuster.

President Donald Trump recently encouraged Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell, to employ the nuclear option to ensure that Gorsuch gets confirmed. McConnell, a career politician, has been in the Senate for almost thirty years and has reversed his position on plenty of issues in the past, similar to many others.

It is difficult to deny from an objective standpoint that both he and Gorsuch, however, are highly proficient in their field because of the amount of time they have spent in it.

Harry Reid changed the Senate rules by invoking the nuclear option in 2013 to pass through nominations to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit much to the dismay of many republicans. None of the appointees, however, were for the position of Supreme Court justice and the rule change did not apply to that level of the federal judicial branch.

Justice Antonin Scalia died almost a year ago and former president Barack Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland to fill the vacancy expired under McConnell’s refusal to hold a hearing, marking the longest pending nomination to the Supreme Court in history by more than twofold.

It was an expected political gambit, considering that Obama appointed two Supreme Court judges during his administration. Despite the questionable length of time, the nomination stagnated without a hearing as McConnell played the parliamentary game.

The legislative branch of the government will have far more incumbent Democrats than Republicans in the 2018 elections. Meanwhile, the ink has hardly dried on the nominations of cabinet members for Trump’s administration as far as the executive branch is concerned.

McConnell has already tried to usher hearings for the cabinet nominations despite current lamentations from the Government Ethics Office and his own push for ethical background examinations that he expressed in a letter to Reid in 2009. Basically, two of the branches of government aren’t looking like they’re going to lose Republican control for at least the next four years, and the judicial branch is pretty much split in half concerning partisan leanings.

Republicans, especially career politicians, should maintain the integrity of their party in the face of a president that many would consider an extremist. The Republican Party and all of its ideologies have the time and stability to rebuild its political sway on all levels of the government for the first time in years.

McConnell and Senate Republicans shouldn’t let something as important as the highest court of our nation and the appointment of the next life-tenured justice be subject to a caveat confirmation at the behest of President Trump.

The presidential office has a two term limit; Senators and House representatives may serve an unlimited number of terms. Therefore, only the legislative branch truly has the opportunity to have a long term approach in mind when it comes to this country like Supreme Court justices do. Do not invoke the nuclear option and open the floodgates for the laws of our land to be interpreted by anyone that a simple majority wants.

McConnell has waited for 294 days for Garland’s nomination to expire and has been in the game for over three decades. It is imperative that he does not act in haste. Let the process play out. He may not get Gorsuch but he’ll get his party’s judge soon enough. For the first time in a while, the ball is overwhelmingly in his court.

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Republicans must stand tall in face of Trump’s call for nuclear option” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Republicans must stand tall in face of Trump’s call for nuclear option

Neil Gorsuch, the fantastic SCOTUS pick Trump needed

Neil Gorsuch is the best possible choice for a Supreme Court, and he’s the one conservatives need. | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Last week, President Donald Trump came through on another campaign promise (which he is surprisingly very good at doing) and announced his nomination for the Supreme Court. For the last year, conservatives have been dreading the announcement of who would replace the late Justice Antonin Scalia. There was fear that the person nominated as Scalia’s replacement would be his intellectual foil.

Then, during his candidacy, then-candidate Trump released a list of names of judges he would consider nominating to the Supreme Court. And to the surprise of many, they were excellent. Conservatives rejoiced! Kind of. Who knew if he’d actually nominate any of them? Who knew if he’d win?

Fast forward to Friday, when Trump nominated Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court and conservatives actually rejoiced. Not only is Gorsuch a worthy successor to Scalia, he is also the anti-Trump that is necessary on the court.

A bit of background on Gorsuch: He is currently on the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals (oddly enough, the 10th Circuit is also the court on which Trump’s sister serves). He was in the same Harvard Law graduating class as former President Barack Obama. In 2006, a unanimous vote, which included Senators Chuck Schumer and Joe Biden, approved Gorsuch for the 10th Circuit Court.

And, most importantly, he is a strict constructionist and an originalist; exactly what Scalia would’ve wanted.  

He is the anti-Trump that Trump needs to show that he is not the authoritarian monster that he is being accused of becoming. In my column about what Trump should do in his first 100 days, I remarked that the best thing for Trump to do would be to choose the anti-him to prove he’s not what people are afraid of: a crazy fascist. With Gorsuch, Trump has chosen wonderfully.

He is an excellent choice and everything that conservatives could’ve asked for, if not more. According to the philosophies of strict constructionism and originalism, the Framers’ intent does not matter. It’s all about what they wrote and how that written word applies to the law. The Constitution is not meant to be interpreted, it is meant to be read.

He’s also a great example of what a judge should be. Justice Scalia always talked about how a good judge should not always be happy with his decisions; he should not always agree with his findings. 

In 2005, Gorsuch wrote a piece for conservative magazine and intellectual think-place National Review titled “Liberals & Lawsuits.” In it, he wrote, “This overweening addiction to the courtroom as the place to debate social policy is bad for the country and bad for the judiciary.”

He also said during his speech accepting the nomination, “A judge who likes every outcome he reaches is very likely a bad judge, stretching for results he prefers rather than those the law demands.”

This is exactly what America needs in a judge. This is exceptional. Both of these quotes exemplify how Gorsuch takes his job seriously.

He also makes amazing legal decisions. There are many decisions I could pull up to exemplify why Gorsuch is fantastic choice, but there are a couple that stand out.

In 2015, Gorsuch wrote in favor of Little Sisters of the Poor. Little Sisters of the Poor is a Catholic charity which the Obama administration sued for not providing birth control. Good litmus test: are you suing nuns? If the answer is yes, you need to check yourself.

Gorsuch ruled correctly in favor of the Little Sister of the Poor, referring to their freedom to exercise their religion (the Free Exercise Clause). Unsurprisingly, Senators like Chuck Schumer are calling Gorsuch out for this. Apparently he is siding with a corporation. That speaks for itself.

He also is better than Scalia on one thing: the Chevron doctrine. The Chevron doctrine is a long standing ruling that states that in some complicated cases, the courts should defer to the federal agencies to interpret that law. This is pretty terrible, seeing as interpretation is the whole point of the judicial branch.

In the 2016 case Gutierrez-Brizuela v. Lynch, Gorsuch ruled against the Chevron doctrine. Gorsuch not only made the correct constitutional decision, he made the best possible decision.

The process to confirm Gorsuch should be easy, seeing as he is a fantastic choice, but given how the process for conservative SCOTUS picks usually goes, this is sure to be a long fight. Just ask Clarence Thomas. In the end, though, Neil Gorsuch is exactly who Trump needed.

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Neil Gorsuch, the fantastic SCOTUS pick Trump needed” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Neil Gorsuch, the fantastic SCOTUS pick Trump needed

Super Bowl LI is super politicized which is super annoying

Politics are gradually seeping into everything that we see.

It’s impossible to even watch athletes throw a ball without seeing some sort of political statement being made during breaks. Most of the more controversial Super Bowl commercials involved rhetoric about President Donald Trump and his administration’s recent passage of executive orders, especially in regards to immigration.

Everything else is already highly politicized. Is it against the rules to let sports fans enjoy something as simple as people tackling each other without having to constantly be reminded of current events that are already impossible to ignore?

Everyone knows the things that are happening in this country and how Muslim refugees and immigrants alike are getting the short end of the stick all because of the president and his political platform.

But since everyone is already discussing these commercials, why not break them down?

The fact that people are boycotting Budweiser for its commercial is beyond comprehension. Every American should have felt pride when watching that commercial. It is the quintessential American dream to come here as an immigrant with nothing but an idea and now, 141 years later, own a sizeable portion of the market.

It goes to show that America is for anyone who is willing to put in the work to succeed here.

The only people who would have gotten inflamed about the commercial are the type who would have gotten in immigrant Adolphus Busch’s face and told him to go back home if they could have. If this commercial aired any other year, no one would have cared. It would have been just another patriotic horn-toot.

But thanks to the political climate that we live in, people love to create relationships about anything that could possibly relate to politics. Budweiser even said that they were not trying to make a political statement with the advertisement.

84 Lumber, on the other hand, went on the offensive and made its commercial bluntly political and then included the rest on their website. Whether the intent was to get you to go to their website to buy lumber or actually just watch the rest of their commercial is up to the viewer.

So far, viewership for Super Bowl LI was lower than the previous two. If sports continues to become politicized, this trend will most likely continue. Politics isn’t good for business. It divides people, which normally wouldn’t matter.

Discourse and disagreement help people understand each other, but why divide people who have all come together to enjoy a sports event? It just doesn’t make sense. This year, the Super Bowl felt more like political statements occasionally interrupted by a football game.

Hopefully this does not become a frequent occurrence.

Opinion editor Thomas Dwyer is a broadcast journalism sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Super Bowl LI is super politicized which is super annoying” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Super Bowl LI is super politicized which is super annoying