Author Archives | opiniondesk

UH’s history of segregation still apparent

segregation

The Roy G. Cullen Building, named for Hugh Roy Cullen’s only son, was just one contribution of a total of $11 million the white supremacist made to UH. | Courtesy of Kianat Haider

While UH celebrates its diversity, its history is littered with anti-black racism and segregated city streets, the impact of which still reverberates throughout Houston.

Our University originally opened as Houston Junior College, a community college funded by Houston Independent School District. Across the street lay the only local option for people of color to receive higher education: the Houston Colored Junior College, now known as Texas Southern University.

As the two colleges grew, they became private four-year universities, both aided in part by the work of Hugh Roy Cullen, a man whose name remains a fixture on campus.

For the white school, the millionaire provided funding for “working men and women and their sons and daughters.” To the black school, he donated 53 acres of land located in the Third Ward, making sure to separate the schools across racial lines.

Do not mistake this for a gesture of goodwill. Cullen was a white supremacist who referred to the New Deal as “The Jew Deal,” according to Jane Mayer’s book “Dark Money.”

He supported southern Dixiecrats’ push for segregation. His funding of each college was, in his eyes, the privatization of the separate but equal doctrine he believed in so much.

By funding the white school and relegating the school for people of color to 53 acres of undeveloped land, Cullen’s message was clear: White people should be supported for success, and black folks were meant to fend for themselves in another part of town.

This trend continued through the fight for racial equality in education, as the Houston Colored Junior College integrated and became the publicly owned Texas State University for Negroes.

The University to become UH, however, still supported in large part by Cullen’s wealth and the wealth of his family, remained a private school, meaning it was not required to integrate and continued to turn away potential students who were deemed too dark. They were sent several blocks away into Third Ward to attend TSU.

Even now, decades after UH integrated and became public, there are visible signs of the division of the past.

We have well-kept grounds, plenty of options to eat at the Student Center and incredible facilities, but if you take the METRO bus two stops in any direction, you will encounter parts of the city that were left underserved throughout the 20th century and to a large extent remain abandoned today.

It’s very clear that UH, while integrated and diverse, serves those who can afford to make it here while profiting from the exploitable labor of the communities around us, who serve as staff in restaurants and groundskeepers around campus.

One can look at the campuswide service projects we put on to see the parasitic relationship we profit and privilege from. For free, the University gets the opportunity to leverage advertising hundreds of thousands of work hours directed at a wide variety of projects in nearby communities.

Of course, the work we do is important and valuable, but the University does not act out of a sense of duty. Instead, it shops the images of our goodwill around to donors to continue the University’s outward growth.

This system fuels further gentrification and redlining, which forces the families who already fight so hard for survival to leave or die trying. In this way, our efforts to improve the lives of people who are struggling are co-opted into programs that make it more expensive to live in some of the most run-down portions of the city.

By trying to solve the symptoms of the problem, it allows us to pat ourselves on the back and ignore the long-term implications of our history. By employing people from the communities we impact and hosting the occasional service event, we permit ourselves to be complicit in the ongoing violence we benefit from.

If we are to really try to make a change, we need to abandon the desire to keep Third Ward alive for our own ends and resolve the conditions that allow for the abuse of Third Ward in the first place. We should prioritize improvements to the funding for public services instead of individual services.

Not only will this help to improve the communities from the ground up, but it can help to make the need for individual-level service unnecessary.

Our history should not damn us to continue the violence endorsed by our predecessors. It should fuel our desires to move forward and improve the status quo. We have a responsibility to fix the mistakes that have led us to the conditions that we subject others to.

I want to encourage those of you who are interested to not simply look for ways to give superficial service, but to fundamentally change the lives of those in need. We need to focus on teaching people to fish rather than simply feeding them.

Without an approach that emphasizes long-term sustainability, we will continue to simply set Third Ward for continued failure. No longer can we idly stand by as we watch our University use the poverty nearby as fuel. We have to do something more.

Staff writer Cameron Leavitt is a communications freshman. He can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“UH’s history of segregation still apparent” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UH’s history of segregation still apparent

Covering taboo topics is the art of journalism

journalism

Assistant Cooglife Editor Erin Davis interviews UH President and System Chancellor Renu Khator during Hurricane Harvey. This is journalism in its purest form: Getting the story in the midst of tragedy. | Thomas Dwyer/The Cougar

Journalism is a career that allows people the honor of documenting the world as it is. 

People go through some of the most terrible things you can imagine: murder, homelessness, poverty, war, mental illness and racism. The problem is not only that these things are happening; it is that we are not allowed to talk about them.

As a society, we do not allow ourselves to create spaces to discuss uncomfortable topics. This is why journalists are necessary. We went into the trenches in World War II, uncovered tragedies in the most sacred places — think of the Boston Globe’s Spotlight team — and meticulously covered the acts of terrorism that burned down the Twin Towers on 9/11.

We do not pick these careers for our own health. We are not risking our lives, in some instances, to further our news clips. We do this to inform a public that needs and deservesto know.

What stops us from doing journalism is both our own ethics — even though we try to be as objective as possible — and the varying ethics of our readers. Ethics cause people to say what can and cannot be covered.

We are not allowed to speak on lost lives or topics that plague our country, like racism and inequality. The ugly stuff is all off the table.

But I ask: How do we progress as a country and as a society if we do not endure these growing pains? Journalism’s role is not only to inform you. The people who are in front of the lens or behind those words are offering their stories.

The people we read about are bringing us closer to a world that we may never know. Journalism allows us to be sympathetic to people who may be as close as siblings or as foreign as strangers. 

When we cover taboo topics, the ones that might make people uncomfortable, it is important for journalists to have the freedom to tell these stories because otherwise, society will remain silent and people will suffer.

We embark on this endeavor in the hope that our readers will gain a sense of how to talk about difficult subjects. Because our lives will not go untouched by inequity or tragedy, I believe that it is worth it to cover taboo topics.

The controversy surrounding these hard topics always miss the point. The story will get wrapped up in the graphics or pain rather than the issue. This is not the result of bad journalism; rather, it’s the result of what society reacts to first, in an attempt to avoid a larger discussion.

In the same breath, there is a concern for why we do not talk about these sensitive issues. Why haven’t we talked about mental health, racism or poverty? Because the effects of those entities are harsh. It’s uncomfortable, and it hurts.

If we are to truly create a safe space, then we need to start making it acceptable to share and report on these sensitive stories. We must not do them conditionally. Spoon-feeding reality is just a step below altering it.

If you truly want these stories and to be informed, we must also allow the journalists closest to you, the ones who take classes with you, to do that.

This way we can uncover our own trenches, whether they are filled with muddy water, come in the form of new hands or bring us all a little bit closer to reality.

Opinion Editor Dana Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Covering taboo topics is the art of journalism” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Covering taboo topics is the art of journalism

The Las Vegas shooting should be considered an act of terrorism

In the wake of Monday’s mass shooting in Las Vegas — the deadliest mass shooting in American history — the United States has found itself in a precarious position at the hands of gun violence. Tragedies such as this one incite vicious debates concerning gun control and the fragile state of the nation.

Nevada has among the most lenient gun laws in the nation, allowing open carry even for assault rifles, and the correlation between these two is evidently discernible.

Few concrete details are yet known of the incident at the Route 91 Harvest Music Festival, and the death toll continues to rise with an estimation of 58 dead and over 500 in the hospital, surpassing the Pulse Nightclub casualties.

Stephen Paddock, the alleged shooter, was in possession of two assault rifles and mercilessly continued his assault until he died by suicide, according to police. Paddock, 64, was found dead in his hotel room with approximately 10 guns and numberless ammunition shells.

Nevada gun laws allow for denizens to purchase guns without registering a license with the government and has no limitations on ammunition purchases, allowing gunmen like Paddock to stock up to alarming numbers and cause high casualties.

There is also no registration of firearms or limit on them, fostering the ideal environment for such a devastating tragedy. Nevada’s policies do not differ drastically from the average thoroughness of gun laws.

Shockingly, despite committing such an appalling and horrifying act, Paddock has been overwhelmingly disassociated from terrorism. The lack of motivation is enough for law enforcement to claim that no allegations can be made thus far, but the relationship between this solicitous approach and the race of the shooter cannot be denied.

Simply put, Paddock, a 64-year-old Caucasian grandfather, cannot adopt the title of terrorist because the media has ingrained an entirely different image in the minds of the American people: the image of a bearded, olive-toned man shouting in Arabic, the association of Jihad as motivation, the persecution of an entire faith and race because of the actions of one.

As a country, we are left in a vulnerable and anguished state. We lie at a crossroads, and the burden upon our hearts is a weighted one. The inclination to offer our thoughts and prayers to the victims of such grief is indubitable, but it is no longer enough; it’s not a solution.

The real world implications of our weak and spineless gun policies are evident. In fact, they’re being lowered into the mass graves as victim after victim has their life stolen from them.

Thoughts and prayers are just counterfeit attempts at empathy, but the situation demands action and responsibility. The impacts of such terrorism will be felt by the friends and families for years to come, but our nation is prone to amnesia when it comes to hatred.

Mass shootings have become the norm in our country, and we are all culpable for this. I beg you, as people, we must distinguish that the perpetrators of terror are terrorists, regardless of skin color.

For the sake of every victim of gun violence, for Sandy Hook and Pulse Nightclub and Columbine and Virginia Tech, for the countless names and faces gone forever, please realize the jeopardy we place ourselves in everyday when we allow guns to be proliferated in our society.

Senior staff columnist Anusheh Siddique is a political science freshman. She can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“The Las Vegas shooting should be considered an act of terrorism” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The Las Vegas shooting should be considered an act of terrorism

Amid isolated funding bump, rising tuition is on legislators

tuition

UH Provost Paula Myrick Short on a panel at The Texas Tribune on Higher Ed Funding and Spending. | Courtesy of Stephen Spillman for the Texas Tribune

College tuition and fees have skyrocketed across the country in the past decade, swelling to three times the rate of inflation.

If you think college costs are rising because of administration greed or a better quality education, I hate to break it to you, but the answer is not that simple.

Tuition is rising due to state disinvestment in higher education. College costs rise due to policies created at the state Capitol by the people we elect to represent our interests.

Fall 2003 was a turning point. That semester, the University of Houston charged full-time students taking 15 credit hours a grand total of $2,266 in tuition and fees. Adjusted for inflation, that would be $3,014 today. If you enrolled in 15 hours this fall, your bill was twice that at $6,041.

Fall 2003 was the last semester that the state capped tuition. That’s right — Texas regulated something.

Previously, the state government capped tuition at public universities across the state. Now they can charge as much as they deem necessary.

The reason institutions like UH are called “public” is because they are directly funded by state taxes. Private institutions don’t receive public funding, so they often make up for it by charging students a lot more.

In 2003, the Texas Legislature realized it couldn’t cut funding for public universities and continue to cap their tuition. Now, charging students more is one of the only ways universities can make up for a lack of state funding.

What students pay at Texas universities has more than doubled since 2003, according to the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board. We have years of state disinvestment to thank.

State support for UH has dropped by about a third since 1987, according to data compiled by the Chronicle of Higher Education. State disinvestment shifts the burden of paying for college from the state to students and their families.

In UH’s current fiscal year budget, student tuition and fees fund twice as much as state appropriations. The state pays 20 percent, or $326.5 million, while students pay 42 percent, or a whopping $679.7 million.

Elected state legislators are to blame for increasing tuition — not university officials.

The pressure is on schools to painfully cut every corner of their already skeletal budgets. UH academic departments had to cut 2.5 percent from their budgets this year, while non-academic units had to cut 3.5 percent. According to a Texas Tribune report, that’s the highest internal budget cut of all the major university systems in Texas.

These cuts came even after UH received a 3 percent increase in general state funding for the next two years compared to the previous two years. This small gain does little against decades of losses.  

Paula Myrick Short, UH vice president for Academic Affairs and provost, recently spoke on a “Higher Ed Funding and Spending” panel at the Texas Tribune Festival in Austin on Sept. 23.

“We were extremely pleased and grateful to the Legislature,” she said about this year’s increase. “We always welcome more funding.”

Short said UH has moved to performance-based funding that relies on factors like graduation rates instead of classroom contact hours.  

This model, Short said, is “making the University focused on student success… Our students are our single priority.”

Investing in higher education is an investment in the state’s future. For every dollar of taxes invested in higher education, Texas gets $6.40 back.

Studies show a more educated population means a stronger economy and increased tax revenue. It also means people are more able to support themselves financially, and with less poverty, the state spends less on law enforcement and social services.  

Cost determines whether students can afford college, how much debt they’re saddled with and how much they need to work while in school.

Increased tuition and fees are barriers for students, especially for low-income, underrepresented or first-generation college students.

If the state is serious about ensuring a strong Texas economy with opportunities for all, it should increase funding to public universities.

Columnist Jackie Wostrel is a public relations sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Amid isolated funding bump, rising tuition is on legislators” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Amid isolated funding bump, rising tuition is on legislators

Blond tiny-handed man seeks tall light-eyed basketball player

Curry

Cartoon by Tamor Khan/The Cougar

Tamor Khan is a biochemistry and psychology senior. He can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Blond tiny-handed man seeks tall light-eyed basketball player” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Blond tiny-handed man seeks tall light-eyed basketball player

Where tolerance ends: A look at who is lost in America’s melting pot

melting pot

DREAMer, Youth Empowerment Alliance

UH’s Youth Empowerment Alliance offers assistance and education to undocumented students. | Courtesy of Maria Trevino-Rodriguez

There are many contributing factors to xenophobia: the passing of legislation like Senate Bill 4 in Texas and referring to the United States as a melting pot both allow for the growing appearance of racial violence and hatred.

S.B.4 is a piece of legislation that “forces local governments and law enforcement agencies to do the work of federal immigration officers,” thereby allowing local officers to imitate federal agents and subject people to racial profiling, according to the ACLU of Texas.

In late August, a federal judge blocked the move to ban sanctuary cities in Texas. This decision enforced that local officials have limited to no available recourse on matters under federal jurisdiction. Democrat-run cities, like Houston, support keeping divisive issues regarding immigration within the confines of federal powers.

Blocking the ban on sanctuary cities, as U.S. District Judge Judge Orlando L. Garcia has done, is the necessary first step in allowing immigrants to maintain their claim on the U.S. as their home and remain here without their citizenship status being questioned.

Those who have called Texas their home their entire lives — people who are our classmates, co-workers, friends and family members — will be impacted by this law if it’s implemented.

Along with the halting applications for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program — an administrative protection measure that allows undocumented people to remain safe from deportation and grants them a work permit — the government is steadfastly becoming more anti-immigrant.

When DACA goes away, so will what is left of the security that undocumented students at the University of Houston have now, though that sense of security is already a dream that seems to be slipping away.

Many of them would rather not be known out of fear of deportation in the case that they are pulled over once their drivers’ licenses expire. This essential piece of plastic grants them safety from deportation.

The U.S., while built by people who immigrated for fear of religious persecution, has long been xenophobic, or fearful of the unknown. The U.S. government has waxed and waned in terms of promoting or denouncing that sentiment.

In the 1600s and 1700s, one only had to look to the racial violence against non-whites by European settlers. In the 1800s, the increasing violence against immigrants, African-Americans and non-Protestants also spoke of an end to the tolerance that was so often lauded by Americans. 

The phrase “melting pot” was used during this time to describe the fusing and the assimilation of varying nationalities — the Americanization of these immigrants.

The early 1900s was when the eugenics movement took hold, enforcing forced sterilization of those deemed feeble-minded or poor. Through all of this, Congress passed legislation that promoted this inherent inequality, so eloquently laid out by social Darwinism.

“Melting pot” is a phrase that eradicates the value to society that different groups of people bring when they move to a new place. Cultures bring richness and offer new ways of explaining ideas. These people grant new perspectives.

S.B. 4 and the elimination of DACA are anti-immigrant directions, and those who proposed such actions are not even pretending it’s anything different.

Anti-immigrant rhetoric is increasing in the U.S. People who express such ideas feel comfortable voicing them in the public sphere, especially as President Donald Trump pardoned former Arizona Sheriff Joe Arpaio.

It’s time to fight back against these sentiments more forcefully than ever. This means being active in political groups on campus such as the Youth Empowerment Alliance, which offers assistance with college applications for undocumented students, as well as education for staff on political events to evoke an understanding for what these students are going though.

YEA strives to have these students go to college and stay in college.

Maria Trevino-Rodriguez, YEA vice president, says that what these students need to be safe is for Congress to pass “a clean bill to protect undocumented students.” This means no increase in military personnel on the border and no steps to deport these students’ parents.

Maintaining cultural diversity is essential to the American identity. The undocumented students at UH are an essential part of this story. The legislation, proposals and pardons act against what the people of this country promote: inclusion and variety of customs, cultures and people.

As students and staff of this University, we need to start that conversation with our family and our peers and allow the U.S. to be a tossed salad — not a melting pot.

Columnist Jackie Wostrel is a public relations sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Where tolerance ends: A look at who is lost in America’s melting pot” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Where tolerance ends: A look at who is lost in America’s melting pot

The morality of gentrification and the future of the Third Ward

gentrification

Gentrification does not need to happen at the expense of people being displaced. | Dana C. Jones/The Cougar

During the school year, I leave my off-campus apartment once a week and drive to the grocery store. My father is not comfortable with the idea of me driving in Houston, and he prefers that I avoid highways at all costs when I do decide to tempt fate this way. When he first dropped me off last fall, he took me on a trial run to the grocery store on Alabama Street.

We can understand why the black community in the Third Ward — or any community — would oppose gentrification. The historically black, marginalized community says no, it does not want a historically enriched, empowered and largely white community encroaching on territory it has called home since it received news of emancipation in June 1865.

The discussion about what makes communities vulnerable to socioeconomic hijacking is often lost in dialogue about gentrification and its immorality.

The neglected homes I have seen while driving through the Third Ward did not become dilapidated by accident. The residents of these houses were victims of discriminatory loan policies and could not afford repairs. When the houses fell into disrepair, they stayed that way.

The Third Ward is arguably the center of African-American culture in Houston, with strong roots to the history of African-American freedom and ownership. This historic and cultural value should pique the local government’s interest as it fights against gentrification.

Currently, with the collective efforts of community leaders at Project Row Houses, state representative Garnet Coleman, UH service groups and the OST/Almeda Corridors Redevelopment Authority, the Third Ward’s future may be an ideal one, wherein its residents’ accommodations meet the standards deserved by their legacy of freedom.

The Corridors Redevelopment Authority purchases land in the interest of revitalizing neighborhoods that are at risk of being gentrified. Rather than updating the area and leaving the previous residents out to dry, this organization makes repairs and spurs economic growth in the neighborhoods without obscuring or erasing the identity of the people who live there.

Not only is it shameful that Houston’s black residents, who have lived in these neighborhoods for decades, are under threat of obscurity; they face this threat as a result of Houston’s history of racial discrimination. This is the cruel and unrelenting reality of the inequality that can be mapped backward throughout the fabric of the city.

Discriminatory practices led to the creation and downfall of this area, but the intense economic growth that the city witnessed as the center of the energy boom should bolster Houston into the unique position of preserving these centers of African-American culture.

Houston policymakers should have protected the history of these areas in the past. If they do not protect it now, instead allowing the area to subtly and silently become whitewashed, then we are collectively failing a group who has been made vulnerable through actions that a large part of our city has benefited from.

If the city created the problems that made black neighborhoods vulnerable to gentrification, then perhaps it has a moral responsibility to rectify that vulnerability. Houston officials might even want to consider preserving the Third Ward for its rare and proud role in American history.

If not, the future of the Third Ward will join the large portions of black and, just as importantly, American history, that are disguised and ceded to the great empire of our national mythology.

Assistant opinion editor Mia Valdez is a creative writing senior. She can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

The Third Ward is arguably the center of African-American culture in Houston, and it’s currently fighting against gentrification, along with community leaders at Project Row Houses, state representative Garnet Coleman and the OST/ Almeda Corridors Redevelopment Authority.

The Redevelopment Authority purchases land in the interest of revitalizing neighborhoods that are at

During the school year, I leave my off-campus apartment once a week and drive to the grocery store. My father is not comfortable with the idea of me driving in Houston, and he prefers that I avoid highways at all costs when I do decide to tempt this fate. When he first dropped me off last fall, he took me on a trial run to the grocery store on Alabama Street.

The neglected homes that you may have seen while driving through the Third Ward did not get that way by accident. The residents who lived there were victims of discriminatory loan policies and could not afford to make repairs.  

You can see why they care about their history. Aside from forming a cultural identity with strong roots to historic African-American freedom and ownership, the value of the Third Ward, both cultural and historic, should peak the local government’s interest in the area.  risk of being gentrified. Rather than updating the area and leaving the historic residents out to dry, this organization makes repairs and spurs economic growth in the neighborhoods without obscuring or erasing the identity of the people who live there.

—
“The morality of gentrification and the future of the Third Ward” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The morality of gentrification and the future of the Third Ward

Ahistoric Confederate statues rooted in revisionism

history

A critical engagement with history would recognize that culture shifts as a society’s values and needs shift. A segregated society needed memorials that justified its racial framework. A society striving for inclusion needs a different cultural landscape. | Dana C. Jones/The Cougar

This letter to the editor is a response to another, titled “Taking down statues will remove history.” That letter was a response to an Aug. 23 column titled “Black Lives Matter protest for ‘Spirit of the Confederacy’ to be broken.”

A recent letter to the editor suggested that removing Confederate memorials risks erasing history. This misunderstands the history of the statues and misrepresents the relationship between culture and politics.

White supremacy has never been a fringe ideology in the United States. Confederate monuments commemorate a war fought to create a slaveholding republic founded, according to Confederate leadership, “upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery subordination to the superior race is his natural and normal condition.”

Had these statues been erected in 1861, they almost certainly would have explicitly memorialized the foundational racial ideology of the Confederacy.

But these statues were not erected during or immediately after the war. Instead, they were erected during an era in which white Americans, north and south, reconciled their differences through a national program of white supremacy.

The statues are not neutral markers of historical facts. Like many aspects of material culture in public spaces, Confederate statues served a political purpose. Erected during the era of Jim Crow, the statues helped create a cultural landscape supportive of the legal and social structure of racial segregation.

The statues stood in public spaces as physical manifestations of white supremacy. They stood outside courthouses where black people failed to find justice. They stood outside polling places as literacy tests and poll taxes purged black citizens from voter registration rolls.

And they did so under the direction of powerful cultural groups and with the backing of local governments.

The Spirit of the Confederacy statue in Houston, for instance, was dedicated in 1908 by the United Daughters of the Confederacy. Far from a fringe group, the UDC’s efforts to memorialize the Lost Cause myth of the Civil War had a powerful impact. Along with the many statues the group funded and erected, the UDC shaped the narrative of the Civil War in popular textbooks, rejecting any interpretation of the war that was “unjust to the South.”

The UDC’s interpretation of the Civil War was bolstered in academics by Columbia University historian William A. Dunning and his students, whose interpretation of Reconstruction held that freed people were unfit for voting and holding office, a narrative that helped legitimate Ku Klux Klan terrorism as a necessary reaction to emancipation.

In 1935, W. E. B. Du Bois, commenting on Dunning’s interpretation and the political ramifications of scholarship and education, wrote that “one fact and one alone explains the attitude of most recent writers toward Reconstruction: they cannot conceive Negroes as men.”

In other words, the UDC and the Dunning school perpetuated interpretations of history that justified slavery, KKK violence and white supremacy. Statues erected by groups that promoted this version of history cannot be separated from the racial ideology they supported.

During the 1960s, historians really began to challenge the Dunning school’s interpretation of slavery and Reconstruction. This scholarship fought hard against the preferred narratives of cultural groups like the UDC, and it only slowly trickled into textbooks and popular narratives of the Civil War.

Indeed, contrary to the author’s suggestion that removing these statues stifles debate, the movement is in many ways the culmination of more than 50 years of critical historical research, debate and public activism that has worked to dismantle the Lost Cause myth of the Confederacy.

The current desire among many to remove these monuments reflects not an effort to ignore the bad parts of history. Quite the opposite, it emerges from a drawn-out and at times painful process of facing the ugly parts of our history. It emerges from a recognition of the purpose those statues served for the groups that erected them, namely to symbolize a racial order.

That the statues have now become rallying points for a resurgence of mainstream white supremacy only confirms that these statues served that purpose. They stood silently in public spaces, waiting to lend their weight when racist ideologies needed an anchor.

Does the removal of statues eliminate racism? No. But white supremacist ideologies should no longer command a physical presence in our public spaces.

A critical engagement with history would recognize that culture shifts as a society’s values and needs shift. A segregated society needed memorials that justified its racial framework. A society striving for inclusion needs a different cultural landscape.

History is the process of change over time. Denying that change by demanding cultural landmarks remains static is more ahistorical than removing a few statues.

Keith McCall is Ph.D. candidate of history at Rice University and a former Houstonian.

—
“Ahistoric Confederate statues rooted in revisionism” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ahistoric Confederate statues rooted in revisionism

Incomplete historical narratives create misunderstandings

The only narrative in our history classes needs to be one of factual accounts. | Katie Santana/The Cougar

At one point or another, we’ve all taken a history class, and if that class piques our interest enough, we may continue that path.

But why do most history classes stick to the same old topics taught the same way with the same general themes?

How many times have we learned about the world wars? How many times have we heard the rhyme as old as time: “Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492?” These topics are important, but there are other important things that should be taught as well.

If you go into a class on the history of Native Americans, you can’t expect to learn about the Roman Empire. In general history courses, it’s important that we teach students the past in reference to the present and future, rather than precedents that are no longer as imperative to learn as they once were. 

For example, we learn that post-Civil War is when African-Americans truly began to have rights and that there were still internal battles fought to further their rights even after the war.

Classes tend to end this discussion leaving students to think that race relations are at peace, even though it is evident through police brutality and the protests like the one in Charlottesville that racial harmony has a long way to go.

Not only should we be spending more time connecting the past, present and future, but we should also include monumental facets of history that are not even covered in mainstream academia. 

The Stonewall protests, as well as the LGBTQ community, are not mentioned anywhere in any general U.S. history course. The historical narratives of American minorities are too completely written by the victors.

But, I ask you, what are the descendants of this history winning if we are shut out of a complete historical narrative, the absence of which is currently causing us social inequity and anxiety? Feminism is mentioned but only brushed over in history courses, and when it is spoken about, it mentions allegedly progressive historical figures like Elizabeth Cady Stanton.

She fought for women’s rights, but her progressive agenda stopped there, when amid rumors that black men would soon gain suffrage, she said, “We educated, virtuous white women are more worthy of the vote.”

Many historical figures are taught in a one-dimensional sense that advances a false narrative. Even to this day, not all women have the same rights as other women, making intersectional feminism absolutely necessary.

As Michael Conway wrote for The Atlantic, “Currently, most students learn history as a set narrative — a process that reinforces the mistaken idea that the past can be synthesized into a single, standardized chronicle of several hundred pages.”

Some would argue that there is too much history to be able to pack more into the already-busy courses we have. Then why do we have so much time to repeat what we’ve already been taught?

How many more times can we possibly learn about the American Revolution? If you ask me, there are some things we can cut out to make room for the past that is affecting our society today.

History needs to be a facet of understanding to better the future, and we can’t truly do that unless we cover everything. With the topics and individuals we do cover, we must make sure they aren’t taught linearly. Teachers and professors should not get to pick and choose the narrative.

Staff writer Aleena Khan is an exploratory studies freshman. She can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Incomplete historical narratives create misunderstandings” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Incomplete historical narratives create misunderstandings

Arpaio’s pardon does not excuse behavior

arpaio

Tamor Khan/The Cougar

President Donald Trump’s pardon of ex-sheriff Joe Arpaio differs drastically from presidential pardons in the past by Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan and James Cartwright in that the leader of the free world used a pardon to supersede the ruling of the judiciary.

There wasn’t just a social implication of forgiveness in this pardon — Trump was asserting his definition of justice for a nation.

Despite Trump’s announcement, courts are bringing up legal challenges to Arpaio’s would-be pardon. He will still be sentenced on Oct. 5 based on a series of criminal convictions of racial profiling.

Arpaio is reputable in the law enforcement world for being “America’s toughest sheriff” because of his racially discriminatory practices, such as detaining Latinos without charging them. The case Melendres V Arpaio was filed in 2007 under Judge G. Murray Snow and revisited in 2011 and again in 2013, when an injunction was placed on his record for arrests and targeting solely under suspicion of being here illegally.

Trump regarded the Arizona sheriff’s obsession with securing our nation’s borders with admiration, applauding him for being a “great American patriot.”

As usual, our president has polarized the masses with his tendency to hold bigots in such high esteem. Arpaio has been known to dehumanize the Latino inmates in his prisons by referring to them with derogatory slurs, abusing solitary confinement, reviving chain gangs, refusing to replace soiled clothes and sheets and locking down cells where inmates do not understand English.

Is this the model that our president believes federal prisons should look to for inspiration? A model created by a man who referred to his jail as a concentration camp?

This act displays growing contempt in the United States for violations of human rights as the government continues to enable hatred and pander toward white supremacists. Many of Arpaio’s supporters defend his practices by pointing out the decrease in crime that coincided with his tenure, but taxpayers in his district paid for multiple lawsuits each year to defend his atrocities.

The interaction between the citizens of this country and the police has always been racially charged. Black drivers and Hispanic drivers have, respectively, a 31 percent and 23 percent higher chance of being pulled over, compared to white drivers.

It is a horrifying — but not shocking — statistic, and law enforcement officers like Arpaio entrench this notion of inequality further. We are left with federal prisons becoming capital ventures as the industry becomes privatized and further dehumanized.

The prison system in America is an affliction of the justice system. Politicians employ harsh and cruel policies on inmates to sway votes by conveying how hard they’ll be on crime, but this perspective allows the populace to see them as faceless felons — the absolute scum of society. About 60 percent of inmates are nonviolent offenders, and yet they’re advertised as egregiously depraved and psychotic individuals.

All this spins the narrative of crime in favor of the elite as rates of recidivism, the tendency to return to prison, rise.

Felons are disenfranchised from voting and, therefore, alienated from any political influence that could modify or refine the prison system. Incarceration is increasingly becoming the solution to the most impoverished of society.

The most disparaged and destitute caste of society is at a loss for their dignity and their fundamental rights as incarceration rises and becomes the only alternative. The disenfranchised, voiceless portion of America needs someone to speak for them.

But it seems that in this nation, forgiveness is shown to the criminals making the arrests.

Anusheh Siddique is a political science freshman. She can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Arpaio’s pardon does not excuse behavior” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Arpaio’s pardon does not excuse behavior