Author Archives | opiniondesk

Native American patent dispute sets poor pharmaceutical precedent

The drug maker Allergan, which markets the dry-eye drug “Restasis,” recently transferred the patent to a Native American tribe because they can claim sovereign immunity to circumvent patent disputes from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. This is a deplorable move by Allergan.

Sovereign immunity, or tribal immunity, in the United States generally implies that Native American tribes have the authority to handle matters within the borders of the tribe’s land.

Under the arrangement, Allergan will grant licenses to upstate New York’s Saint Regis Mohawk tribe for the patent, as well as $13.75 million with the potential to receive $15 million in yearly royalties in the future.

The company’s social responsibility page reads like satire in light of the recent move: “Focused on corporate citizenship, leveraging our science and innovation to make a positive impact.”

If there were any previous ties between Restasis and the Saint Regis Mohawk tribe, this situation could be viewed as something more than the exploitative, anti-competitive scramble for a legal shield that it is.

In the pharmaceutical industry, drugs usually enjoy a period of protection from other companies infringing on a company’s patent. Companies with patents are protected for 20 years from copycat drugs starting on the date that the application was filed so that a company can make back the investment that was required to develop the drug.

If the drug is approved, the company also enjoys an exclusivity period on the market that can be effective for up to 7 years.

The Restasis patent was set to expire in 2014.

When Allergan began feeling pressure from competitors, the company filed patents with specifications of ingredient concentrations (active and inactive), which has extended protection up until this point. Allergan is the plaintiff in a patent infringement case that the company brought against would-be competitors.

One of the major challenges Allergan is facing concerns an inter partes review of those ad hoc patents. An inter partes review from the PTAB determines the “patentability” of claims made about patents, but can hypothetically be rebuked under the sovereign immunity doctrine.

If nothing changes, the patents will be valid until 2024.

Exploiting a tribe’s sovereign immunity designation is in no way socially responsible. Restasis generated $354 million in sales during the second quarter of this year, which is the equivalent to about 26 and a half years of annual royalties under the proposed agreement.

Recently four senators have criticized the move, and asked the Senate Judiciary Committee to investigate the matter. This is not a completely new phenomenon, but it is a recent one. For example, the University of Florida avoided an IPR under the doctrine earlier this year. The current procedure for an inter partes review is only about 5 years-old itself, and while there are a lot of kinks to be worked out, its intentions are good.

That being said, not only is this a bad move on Allergan’s part, but it would set a precedent for the pharmaceutical industry to protect themselves in this manner as well. While it doesn’t seem as though a case concerning eye drops is that important, it could open up the door for companies to do the same thing with more serious products, like chemotherapy drugs.  

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Native American patent dispute sets poor pharmaceutical precedent” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Native American patent dispute sets poor pharmaceutical precedent

Nation of Islam strengthens community’s black unity

nation

The Nation of Islam is a pillar of the black community. Outside of having a strong religious quality, it also serves to continuously allow progress in that community.

The NOI is prominent, from the introduction of black intellect to the strengthening of community and the progression of the culture.

I spoke with one committed member of the NOI, accounting senior Khallid Muhammad.

Muhammad’s parents are from Los Angeles, where they first came into contact with the Nation. They were selling papers, specifically the Nation’s newspaper The Final Call. After they met, they converted, so Muhammad was born and raised in the Nation.

During his pre-K through fifth-grade years, Muhammad went to a Muslim school. After moving to Houston, he started going to private schools.

“Things were different,” Muhammad said. “Like standing up for the Pledge of Allegiance and Christian holidays. At that time, I started to think I was weird.”

That weirdness came from the huge shift in environment based on Muhammad’s religion, but it is something a lot of black students of all ages can relate to. According to Pew Research Center, 81 percent of black college students say they have faced discrimination.

The mostly-white composition of most colleges, aside form historically black colleges and universities, does not help that discrimination.

The NOI, just like all movements and religions, has integral leaders who are either direct liaisons for the Nation or simply represent in well in their everyday lives.

“Elijah Muhammad started it all,” Muhammad said, referring to the man who leaded the NOI from the 1930s until his death in 1975. “Without him, there would be no Malcolm, no Muhammad Ali, Dr. Khalid, or Minister Louis Farrakhan.”

Before Elijah Muhammad, people never thought about the black man as god or heard that kind of language, he said. Elijah Muhammad was a black man spreading teachings from a Afrocentric frame of reference. It put black people first in the minds of themselves and always advocated for the betterment of the community and no one else.

“He gave us that sense that it’s great to black,” Muhammad said.

The first major effort for black unity in modern times was seen in the ’60 and ’70s with the Civil Rights Movement. One of the greatest civil rights leaders, Malcolm X, was part of the Nation of Islam. His teachings were rooted in black power, which at its core is meant to bring the black community together and make it self-sustainable.

That installation of self-esteem and pride in one’s people was important for the black community. Now there are people like “Moonlight” actor Mahershala Ali, who presents his Muslim beliefs openly. In a new, changing social climate, we see advocates more prominently — people like activist DeRay McKesson, author Ta-Nehisi Coates and actor Jesse Williams.

Although McKesson, Coates and Williams are not part of the NOI, the relatable way they speak to other black people is similar to that of the Nation.

“In books that I have read, they’re not Muslims themselves, but they have used the teachings of the Honorable Elijah Muhammad to help black people,” Muhammad said.

The Nation works for one common goal: to support and uplift its people. You can still see black unity today, from the renewed civil rights movement of Black Lives Matter and an overall acceptance of the LGBTQ community. It lives in black people for the sake of being black, despite any superficial differences.

“When it’s all said and done, it’s all about unity,” Muhammad said. “The Honorable Elijah Muhammad said, ‘Our unity is greater than an atomic bomb.’”

Opinion Editor Dana C. Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Nation of Islam strengthens community’s black unity” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nation of Islam strengthens community’s black unity

Guest column: Testing the hypothesis of Black Lives Matter

hypothesis

Social movements of the past were justified in their claims of inequality. The first women’s rights convention at Seneca Falls in 1848 was a step in the right direction, as were the Freedom Rides of the 1960s to fight segregation. The right direction — the only path that society ought to take — is toward social and legal equality.

Egalitarianism, the idea that all people deserve equal rights and opportunities, and individualism, the idea that individual autonomy is more important than any collective, exist in a beautiful coherence; take either as an axiom, and the other follows as a conclusion. Social progress can only ensue once these doctrines are accepted and manifest in our culture.

But the status of victimhood is alluring. The victim gains control and power over those who are not perceived to be victims. Without having to achieve anything, one is held as someone to be valued over and above those of privileged status. 

So we shouldn’t be surprised that entire movements have been erected on the premise that inequality pervades our society before rigorously analyzing that inequality. The incentives are ripe for such a religion to emerge — untested cries of victimhood are far more beneficial than the pursuit of truth.

The claim that we are indeed falling short of egalitarianism and individualism must be substantiated. As far as I know, there is no law in our country that contravenes the two ideas. Perhaps I haven’t looked hard enough.

If legal equality has been met, then only social issues remain as a possible source of injustice. In contrast to law, whereby the injustice is almost literally written in stone, social issues require other forms of evidence. The burden of proof is on whoever makes the assertion.

One assertion of Black Lives Matter, per the movement’s website, is that “Black lives are systematically and intentionally targeted for demise.” No evidence is provided to support this massive claim. But like all hypotheses, it is subject to testing.

One prediction of the above statement is that, all else being equal, a black individual is more likely to be killed by police than a non-black individual.

A study from Harvard University found that, once contextual factors are taken into account, no racial differences emerged in the data on lethal shootings. As the author notes, “In the end, however, without randomly assigning race, we have no definitive proof of discrimination”.

But for many entrenched in the movement, it’s too late for data. The narrative has been set; the power of claimed victimhood tastes too sweet to put down. This has all the symptoms of a burgeoning religion.

Dare question the narrative, and you are labeled a racist (read: heretic). Only those who have lived the black experience (read: priestly class) may even discuss the relevant issues (read: preach), while everyone may only listen and accept (read: have faith).

Religions are tolerable to the extent that they do not lead to harmful action. The tragedy is not that the message “black people are discriminated against by police” is itself a dangerous proclamation; the tragedy is, frankly: it is false or yet to be adequately demonstrated.

So while it is true that Micah Xavier Johnson was not associated with BLM, he murdered policemen because he was incensed by a false narrative promoted by the organization.

There is cause for optimism, though. While most religions are unfalsifiable, meaning that they can never be shown to be untrue, the church of Black Lives Matter makes testable claims.

It is therefore the responsibility of the thinking person to refrain from giving in to the temptation of victimhood and instead leverage the tools of reason to reach conclusions.

Social injustice is indeed a moral shortcoming of any society, but just as evil is conjuring such an inequality where one does not exist.

Guest columnist Logan Chipkin is an ecology and evolution graduate student and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Guest column: Testing the hypothesis of Black Lives Matter” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Guest column: Testing the hypothesis of Black Lives Matter

Staff Editorial: Avoid echo chambers at all costs

echo chambers

Sonny Singh/The Cougar

One part of being human is giving into personal biases even when trying to receive news. This instinct makes us want to listen to things that we agree with and condemn the things we don’t.

There’s a term for surrounding yourself with people who do not challenge your views: an echo chamber.

Social media is one of the most fertile places for echo chamber to form. Why acknowledge the fact that anything you believe in has an opposing side when you don’t have to hear that opinion? It’s tempting to just stick to the information that is easier to digest.

By closing yourself off to opposition — through who you follow on Twitter, which organizations you join and where you choose to live — you miss the other half of everything that happens. There are two sides to every story, and some outlets do a better job of telling one side of a story than reporting on both sides equally and objectively.

Now that information travels at high speeds and becomes old news in less time than ever before, it is important to listen to all sides of the story before developing your own opinions on the topic.

Diversity is a good quality to have in your news sources. The more angles you seek out on a topic, the more well-rounded your views on it become. You can hear what you agree with and also hear the point of view that you do not agree with and take their side of the argument into account.

After reading this, follow a news source you typically ridicule. Follow President Donald Trump on Twitter if you didn’t vote for him and are always critical of what he has to say. If you like to get your news from Fox or the National Review, try watching CNN or NBC as well.

More importantly, after you have balanced out your media bias, try to follow wire services that are either foreign or highly respected, such as the Associated Press or Reuters.

Echo chambers are dangerous. Do yourself a favor — read, watch and listen to news from sources you disagree with along with your usual outlets, or try to follow more objective news sources.

editor@thedailycougar.com

—
“Staff Editorial: Avoid echo chambers at all costs” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Staff Editorial: Avoid echo chambers at all costs

Peaceful protest: A beautiful American tradition

protest

Katie Santana/The Cougar

In the midst of protests and questions surrounding the severity of police brutality, NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick chose to kneel during our national anthem. Naturally, this action garnered national attention and people labeled him as anti-patriotic, while others deemed him a symbol for those whose voices are silenced.  

Over the weekend, several NFL teams chose to present a united front against President Trump’s comments criticizing the actions of players who refuse to stand during the anthem.

Not only has the message of Kaepernick’s action diluted, but a larger problem is rearing its head — the continuous policing of speech.

At the center of it all is Kaepernick. His intention was to further highlight the perceived tension between the black community and law enforcement. With high-profile killings of black men such as Trayvon Martin and Philando Castile, large sectors of the black community have rallied together, pleading for the justification of these untimely deaths and demanding a change.  

His focus wasn’t on Trump — he began his silent protest before Trump even took office. Kaepernick’s focus is the black community.

It is evident that America is divided. According to a 2016 Gallup poll, 77 percent of Americans believe our country is greatly divided on critical issues. There is an ever-widening chasm separating people from one another based on their personal convictions.

One of the problems surrounding Kaepernick’s controversy is his status. Too often we think that celebrities, athletes and other people of prominence exist solely for our entertainment and not as individuals with voices and strong ideas.   

We pick apart their statements and opinions, expecting them to share our perspective or be completely neutral. While it is true that their status grants them a larger platform, they should not be stripped of their rights because of it.

Freedom of speech is as American as it gets. This concept is the cornerstone of American identity. It is nondiscriminatory — all of us are bestowed this right. We are quick to point this out in online arguments or a heated discussion with a friend. Unfortunately, some over-generalize the uses and privileges this amendment bestows.

Our First Amendment allows us to freely speak, legally assemble and express ourselves how we see fit. There are obvious restrictions, however, such as slander or speech that could incite violence. We can voice our opinions in a fashion that does not harm other members of the community. If those situations are avoided, other restrictions should not exist — at least not from the government.  

This is where it gets gritty. People can voice their ideas in a public forum, but that does not protect them from receiving backlash from their peers. You have the right to boldly express your convictions, but let’s be clear: Not everyone is obligated to agree with you.  

It is not within our jurisdiction to police our fellow Americans’ ideas or how they demonstrate against their frustrations. We do not possess that power, nor should we desire to have it.

People differ in their views, so sensitive topics bring discourse and arguments.

Keep talking, regardless. Discourse is vital to maintain a vibrant and stimulating intellectual arena. Sadly, the concept of a free marketplace of ideas is slowly tapering off, due to myriad reasons, including news and social media.

As a country, if we truly want to reflect and live in accordance with freedom of speech, it is crucial that we stop being so easily offended; rather, we should actively attempt to engage in conversations with others whose views differ from ours.

At the end of the day, I stand by Kaepernick and others who chose to display their frustrations in nontraditional fashions. It’s their right.

Would I take a knee? No, but I surely support those who do, and that’s the beauty of it.

Alana N. Miller is an integrated communications junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Peaceful protest: A beautiful American tradition” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Peaceful protest: A beautiful American tradition

‘Segregation forever’ holds true in 2017

Segregation is still prevalent in modern schools. Segregation may be directly in the schools, or in the communities that are segregated by other factors. | Sonny Singh/The Cougar

In George Wallace’s inaugural address as governor of Alabama in 1963, he famously declared: “Segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever.”

I personally dislike his statement, and the popularity of his sentiment has permanently colored my opinion of the entire state of Alabama. I will probably never go to Alabama.

I will forever hold the belief that Alabama is the mythical child of Southern racism that somehow still stands as it recovers ungracefully from the shame of slavery. I have never been there. I have never set foot on the land or seen any physical proof, and going there is a risk I will not ever, in the privilege of my post Civil Rights-era youth, visit the state of Alabama.

I wanted to see, however, if George Wallace was right in his guess at the longevity of institutional segregation. I, like you, believe that one day he will be wrong. But how many tomorrows will we lose to this institution when every second of its existence contributes to that of several others? And what kind of promises, as a nation, are we missing out on in the process?

Wallace was right about the “segregation now” part. Even though the courts banned segregation in the 1950s, an overwhelming majority of school districts avoided integration until the Supreme Court’s decision was enforced throughout the South.

What this column is most concerned with is the “segregation tomorrow, segregation forever” part. Integration enjoyed its heyday in the late ’60s until the ’90s. Since then, academic authorities have noted a subtle and undeniable trend of re-segregation in the United States.

A practice known as school succession might be to blame for the spike in segregation that Southern districts are seeing. It works thanks to policymakers who gerrymander white neighborhoods into their own school districts, restoring a white majority in several schools across America.

According to a 2015 investigation in The Atlantic, there are 179 school districts in the U.S. “involved in active school desegregation cases.”

As time limits on the bill that enforced school integration in the South have expired, school districts, left to their own discretion, are slipping back into segregation.

A big part of Wallace’s ideology was that he did not want integration because he was sure that it would lead to a “mixing” of the races and cultures in the U.S.

It could be argued that integration is losing some of the ground it gained in the 20th century. Black and white cultures seem to exist within one another. That, I think, will never go away, and I am comfortable saying that Wallace was wrong then, and he is wrong now.

An integrated school system saw a decrease in the achievement gap between white and black students. This has widely been attributed to the fact that schools in white neighborhoods tend to house more resources that those in black neighborhoods.

The year of Wallace’s speech as the new governor of Alabama also happens to be the year that my father was born. As he entered middle school in the 1970s, he was bused to a school in a different neighborhood.

In general, he has not disclosed much information to me about this time of his life. But he did tell me about one of the best friends he ever made precisely because he was sent to another school.

I think that my dad is a pretty open-minded guy. He is moral and has an exemplary work ethic. It would be hard for me to say that he might be a different person if he had attended a different school, but if integration even slightly influenced these qualities in his character, then I am personally grateful for it.

The most upsetting and feverish claims in Wallace’s cry is “segregation forever.” I think that we must concede that the tomorrow we are facing is imperfect, and that as we slide back into de facto segregation, we take for granted the realities of a frightening and relevant past.

In each moment, we create a legacy for those who will succeed us. As current students and future lawmakers, policymakers and parents, we have the power to end the institutionalized segregation.

Though I am pretty sure his address was meant more as a declaration of intent than anything else, I wanted to see if the U.S. has proved Wallace wrong in the 54 years that have since passed. The answer, I have gathered, is not quite.

Assistant opinion editor Mia Valdez is a creative writing senior. She can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“‘Segregation forever’ holds true in 2017” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ‘Segregation forever’ holds true in 2017

Firearms over lunch: A reader defends gun culture

gun

Texans with concealed carry permits are 14 times less likely to commit a crime and five times less likely to commit a violent crime. | Dana C. Jones/The Cougar

Two weeks ago, I wrote a column arguing that “Gun obsession is an issue of a nation, not just a male one.” The story was met with contention — 50 comments’ worth — because some thought that I am anti-gun.

I am from South Central Los Angeles, and if you know anything about that area, then you know I am no stranger to guns. My parents and a lot of my extended family were in the Air Force, and my father, whom I love, owns multiple guns.

I am not anti-gun, nor am I a stranger to shooting guns or being around them. My argument, based on the comment section, was lost in translation as readers compartmentalized my points.

The next day, I received three emails. One person said every possible insult without cursing, and another replied in the form of a rebuttal column. The third one was an invitation.

Jace Allen Foulk, a computer science sophomore, reached out to me to explain gun culture from his perspective. After working out logistics, we met at Enoteca Rossa, a cafe on Bissonnet Street.

This was my first time meeting a reader. He also invited me to a gun range, but it was members-only. The owners, all UH alumni, offered to let us shoot anyway, but our appointment isn’t until Friday.

Seeing a face behind the thoughts, especially conflicting thoughts, was surreal.

“There were no proposed solutions,” Foulk said about my column.

Foulk spoke a lot about the lack of solutions offered in The Cougar’s opinion columns. That was something else we disagreed on: I responded that the solutions we offer are simply ones he does not like. 

“A solution that I would propose is instating Project Exile,” Foulk said.

Project Exile was a strategy implemented in Richmond, Va., that prosecuted felons who illegally carried firearms with harsher sentencing. After the implementation, the city saw a 22 percent yearly decline in firearm homicides.

Foulk was not the average gun lover wanting to shove information in my face. He wanted me to be aware. The more I started to realize that there is a real culture around guns, I started to ask about his personal history with them.

One-Eyed Bill

His family history with guns goes back to his great-great-grandfather, Bill, who was a German immigrant. He has lost one of his eyes, leading to a nickname: “One-Eyed Bill.” Still, he was a great shot.

In early 1900s Oklahoma, One-Eyed Bill owned an ice store. Black cowboy towns surrounded the area, and One-Eyed Bill hired a black man to work in his store.

One night as they were coming back from a party to the store on their carriage, Foulk said that they were confronted by four KKK members. One-Eyed Bill drew his gun first, and thanks to his reputation, the KKK members all stood down.

“This isn’t confirmed, but I suspect that he knew who they were because he called out their names,” Foulk said.

Foulk himself has been shooting guns since he was 4 years old, practicing with a Model 85 Taurus .38 special revolver, a small handgun.

Foulk talked about the different types of guns he has and how they work. He spoke with such breadth of knowledge that it seemed he had gone to some type special training or camp. He knew as much offhand knowledge of guns as I do about film, which is where we found common ground, leading to a half-hour Star Wars discussion.

‘One life is too many’

Whenever immersing oneself in a new culture, you must be aware of the social issues in that culture, simply because you must be able to defend your identity to people who do not understand it. When talking about firearms, the most controversial social issue is gun violence.

According to TIME Magazine, the highest homicide rates come from St. Louis, Memphis and Chicago, with about 60, 29 and 27 deaths per 100,000 people, respectively.

According to the Violence Policy Center, in 2013, the last year with complete research, more than half of 41,149 deaths from suicide were completed with firearms.

In 2017, 737 people have been killed by police with guns.

I asked Foulk about his thoughts on gun violence.

Foulk said that violence is saddening, and he understands the nature of it from growing up in neighborhoods where he would hear gun shots and sirens not long afterward. 

As he internalized this question further, Foulk’s once eloquent, smooth answers halted. He couldn’t speak for a few seconds.

“I wouldn’t say one life is too many, but one life, with an unlimited amount of possibility, it’s incredibly disheartening (for someone to die),” he said, referring to Philando Castile. 

Castile was shot and killed by a police officer in Minnesota during a traffic stop in 2016. After telling the officer about the firearm in his car, Castile allegedly reached for a driver’s license. The officer mistook the action as drawing a gun and shot him.

“As someone who concealed carries, like the Philando Castile case, that hit very close to home,” Foulk said. “I cried over that story and was frustrated with the ruling.”

Carrying on campus

State law, specifically S.B. 11, makes carrying a concealed weapon on Texas’ public university campuses, including UH, legal.

Still, there are certain places where you cannot carry a concealed weapon, like places of worship, health care facilities or most of UH’s dorms. S.B. 11 states that universities cannot “generally prohibit” people from being able to carry a concealed weapon.

Even though “generally prohibiting” is subjective, it directly affects the students that do choose to carry.

Every morning, Foulk commutes an hour from his residence hall, Moody Towers, to his car, where his weapon is stored. Moody Towers residents are not permitted to store guns in their dorm rooms. After class, he walks back to his car, stores the gun in a lockbox, then returns to his room for the evening.

Those inconveniences could be enough to argue that a less-committed gun owner would be “generally prohibited,” an infringement on state law.

Allowing students to store their weapons in their dorms would make this process much easier. Professors are allowed to store their weapons in regulatory lockboxes in their offices.

It is much safer, generally, for students to keep their weapons in their dorm, which has more security, than in a regulatory lockbox in their car.

Storing his weapon is not the only inconvenience for Foulk.

“I have to be cautious of how I use the urinal or enter a stall, so someone doesn’t think I’m showing them my gun because that’s against the law,” Foulk said.

A word of understanding

This experience of sharing thoughts with someone opposed to mine was great. We had a genuine conversation, exchanging our thoughts to understand each other, not for the sake of arguing.

I asked Foulk what he wants those who support gun regulation to truly understand.

“Most mass shootings happen in gun-free zones,” Foulk said. “A criminal by definition is not going to follow the law, and they know that there is a good chance that there won’t be any guns there.”

No matter how much some people do not like guns, they are going to be around forever. Since the first settlers landed in America, guns were there with musket and brimstone.

“Guns are a part of American culture,” Foulk said. “With gun culture, it’s adapting, like with women growing in gun ownership.”

Guns are not just a hobby for Foulk, like knitting or coin-collecting. He has grown up around the culture, making it a part of his life and his kinship.

That immersion does not make him a bad person or hard to understand.

“I’m just a regular guy,” Foulk said. “I love Star Wars, and I watch Game of Thrones.”

Opinion Editor Dana C. Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.   

—
“Firearms over lunch: A reader defends gun culture” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Firearms over lunch: A reader defends gun culture

Guest column: Where is Trump’s leadership in Puerto Rico?

A Puerto Rican walks the road to Torres’ father’s house. He taught Torres how to throw his first baseball in the destroyed field on the left. | Courtesy of Anthony Torres

Puerto Rico, an island of more than 3.4 million people, has been a United States territory since 1898. In 1917, the U.S. government declared the people of Puerto Rico official American citizens. For 100 years, Puerto Ricans have held that status, paying U.S. taxes and sending over 200,000 men and women to serve in the U.S. armed forces since World War I.

But why is this important?

We Puerto Ricans are just as American as anyone living in the U.S.

Hurricane Maria hit Puerto Rico hard. When Irma passed, many in my family were relieved that nothing too serious happened.

But when Maria came, much of the island was unprepared for the total devastation. While my grandmother in Luquillo had damage only to her second-story balcony, millions of others are currently without electricity, food, water and in many cases, even a roof on their home.

Being in Houston during Hurricane Harvey, I had to live with both my Puerto Rican and Houstonian families hit by Mother Nature’s wrath.

The U.S. government’s response to Puerto Rico has been sluggish and disappointing. President Donald Trump has claimed that efforts are “going well,” but that simply isn’t true.

When Texas and Florida were hit by Harvey and Irma, respectively, it took only days for the government to respond. Within hours of the storm, the president tweeted multiple messages of hope and encouragement.

It took the president five days after the storm to even tweet about Puerto Rico, and when he did, it was about how much debt Puerto Rico was in.

“Texas & Florida are doing great, but Puerto Rico, which was already suffering from broken infrastructure & massive debt, is in deep trouble,” he tweeted.

He then went on to claim that it is difficult to lend Puerto Rico aid due to it being surrounded by “ocean water.”

The United States spends nearly $600 billion each year on defense, and for some reason, it’s hard to lend aid to an island.

Throughout the crisis, San Juan Mayor Carmen Yulin Cruz has been publicly voicing her frustration with relief efforts. She has been working virtually nonstop to do everything she can to help the people of Puerto Rico, even going so far as to risk going in waist-high water to search for survivors.

Meanwhile, the president tweeted about professional athletes protesting.

Since the storm, Cruz has been publicly voicing how slowly the U.S. government has responded to the crisis.

“I am begging, begging anyone that can hear us, to save us from dying,” Cruz said. “If anybody out there is listening to us, we are dying, and you are killing us with the inefficiency and the bureaucracy.”

Not once did she personally attack Trump.

Then on Saturday, he tweeted, “Such poor leadership ability by the Mayor of San Juan, and others in Puerto Rico, who are not able to get their workers to help. They want everything to be done for them when it should be a community effort. 10,000 Federal workers now on Island doing a fantastic job.”

I don’t understand why he would say this. I don’t understand why he would attack someone, who clearly has had a rough couple of weeks, just because she was possibly “not nice” to him. I don’t understand why, in the middle of a situation where Americans are starving and dying, he would use it as a political opportunity.

I also don’t understand why he almost completely lacks the ability to have empathy for my people.

Leadership is being the first person to tell everyone that they are going to get the help they need. It’s maintaining constant communication with local officials affected by a tragedy and making sure they know they are being cared for.

When the storm hit, Trump was golfing at his private New Jersey resort.

By now, I’m used to the president attacking people out of malice or spite, but this time it’s personal. He has three more hurricane seasons to deal with in his first presidential term, and the storms could potentially be deadlier.

What I saw in Houston during Hurricane Harvey was the greatest display I’ve ever seen of neighbors helping neighbors. The U.S. needs to show that same compassion for Puerto Rico.

Anthony Torres is a political science senior, native Puerto Rican and former opinion editor for The Cougar.

—
“Guest column: Where is Trump’s leadership in Puerto Rico?” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Guest column: Where is Trump’s leadership in Puerto Rico?

Patent trolls no longer find easy payout after Kapersky win

patent

Earlier this year, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on the interpretation of venue laws concerning patent cases in the federal court system. A venue, in this case, refers to the location where a patent lawsuit should be heard.  

The statute that resulted from the TC Heartland v. Kraft Food Group Brands case was that a lawsuit can only be filed where the defendant “resides,” meaning the state where the company was incorporated. 

Kraft wanted to sue Heartland for patent infringement in Delaware, a state where Heartland was not incorporated or the source of its primary business. Delaware has gotten a reputation for being the most active district for patent cases.

According to a study done by PricewaterhouseCoopers in 2016, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas was second on that list, and it was overwhelmingly number one when it came to highest number of case decisions involving non-practicing entities, or “patent trolls.”

In theory, NPE’s are in the business of monetizing intellectual property rights, but in reality, a lot of these entities attempt to profit off the reluctance to go through litigation. Instead of paying the cost to fight a lawsuit in court, larger companies will settle out of court with the plaintiff.

Recently, Kaspersky Lab, an antivirus and internet security protection company, dealt with a patent infringement case from an NPE in the Texas Eastern District Court. Not only did Kaspersky win the lawsuit, but it was awarded some $5,000 in compensation.

The ruling marks a watershed moment in the fight against patent trolls for two reasons. because the lawsuit took place in the Eastern District of Texas, which has almost twice the success rate for NPE’s in the country, and because the defendant was actually awarded compensation. This marks a significant change for a district court that has historically been a revolving door for patent litigation.

Patents are an important measure for protecting innovations and their creators. In 2015, Wetro Lan bought the rights to a patent that expired in 2012 and tried to sue Kaspersky for damages. Legally, Wetro Lan could claim damages against Kaspersky’s products from 2010 to 2012, before the patent expired, even though it was a basic firewall filed in 2000.

Patent trolls make a mockery of the system. Until recently, five district courts heard just under 50 percent of the entirety of patent litigation lawsuits in the U.S. Not only did the Eastern District Court hear a major portion of these cases, but it had an uncanny success rate for NPEs.

The case between Heartland v. Kraft set the stage for curbing favoritism among federal courts regarding these cases’ venues, but the Wetro Lan v. Kaspersky case sent a message. Normally, when a big company was sued, the company had to do a cost-benefit analysis of whether or not to continue the case at hand.

The balancing act would lead to many out-of-court settlements, but now the tables have turned. An NPE must now either strengthen its infringement claims or do a cost-benefit analysis of its own.

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Patent trolls no longer find easy payout after Kapersky win” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Patent trolls no longer find easy payout after Kapersky win

Latino civil rights need to be advocated and covered

Latino

Jennifer Rodriguez is a Latina activist shown protesting for DACA students. | Courtney of Raymond Ruiz

I think that we are all fascinated by the media’s coverage of political activism.

Political protests have a way of gathering our national attention, and we all have opinions about the protesters and their varied causes. Recently, that attention has been focused on organizations like the Black Lives Matter Movement and “alt-right” groups.

But when media coverage of other minority groups fails to shine a light on similar issues of discrimination, we are a party — perhaps a reluctant party — to an injustice.

People might have a tendency to believe that other groups’ protests and rallies don’t exist because we rarely see them, or that these groups are not actively protesting injustice because they don’t garner significant media attention.

Media coverage of African-Americans and Latinos in the United States is already sparse. Most of the time, when blacks and Latinos are referenced in the media, it is in a story regarding either crime or immigration. This type of media coverage spikes around significant events, especially when those events evoke a strong community response.

According to a study done by the Pew Research Center, media coverage of Hispanics is primarily event driven. Out of 34,452 news stories observed in a six-month period, only 645 of them involved Hispanics.

News stories that involve African-Americans are covered at similar rates. The difference in news coverage of protests that are most obviously connected to either black or Hispanic communities is that black protests receive more coverage because of our nation’s imagination about the black struggle.

National Hispanic Heritage Month began on Sept. 15, and will end on Oct. 15. I think that we should dedicate some time to remembering the Hispanic activists.

Black Lives Matter activists are racially diverse. A lot of people are invested in its message. Cross-cultural activism has a long history of mobilizing in the aftermath of controversial events that involve one or more black victims.

People from Hispanic, white and Asian communities have shown support and solidarity with a tradition of an African-American struggle for justice and equality.

Black dissent has a unique gravity in the American consciousness. Though blacks and Latinos face similar issues in America, including incarceration, unemployment and discrimination, the groups mobilize differently, and as a result, public awareness of these issues vary.

Because of a long history of external oppression, African-Americans have experienced a large and visible history of activism. The Latino community, along with other minority groups, has had it as well and deserves just as much visibility in their causes.

Today, the optics are hard to ignore. So much of black oppression has been visible, and because of the magnitude of slavery, the public — both unwillingly and willingly — pays more attention to black protests.

While optics are important, we must also consider these injustices and the activists who are unseen.

Assistant Opinion Editor Mia Valdez is a creative writing senior. She can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Latino civil rights need to be advocated and covered” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Latino civil rights need to be advocated and covered