Author Archives | Kat Benton, Opinion Columnist

Benton: Oregon’s not turning red … right?

This year’s midterm elections are arguably the most impactful in the last decade. Despite the current Republican stronghold in Washington, D.C., there is a predicted nationwide “blue wave” of Democratic representatives as sentiment against the Trump administration continues to build. That includes reliably red states like my home state, Texas.

Yet Oregon, a staunchly blue state, might have its first Republican governor in nearly forty years as the race between incumbent Tina Kotek and Christine Drazan remains neck and neck. As a first-time voter, I was puzzled, so I asked around.

Third-year Jonah Dyk thinks that Kotek and the broader Oregon Democratic Party don’t believe they “need to do anything to win over people… and are instead catering to monied interests.” Dyk credited Kotek with some wins, like helping win pay for striking workers, but still thinks “she’s trying to play both sides,” and he doesn’t “think it’s really working very well.”

Drazan, though, may be a risk Oregonians aren’t willing to take right now, according to Ione Cafaro, vice president of marketing for BridgeOregon, a campus chapter of a nationwide group teaching students how to have conversations about sociopolitical issues. Cafaro expressed that some voters are “worried that she’s going to be a Trump ally. Reasonably so in this day and age … there’s a lot of party bias.”

Witnessing the student body’s lack of enthusiasm for either candidate convinced me that hearing directly from Kotek and Drazan was the best way to understand their perspectives. If voters can’t get a clear read on them, would watching the debates help?

I tuned in expecting nuanced policy arguments, but instead watched two elected officials play hot potato with accountability on live television. Kotek tried to tie her opponent to Trump at every opportunity, despite Drazan previously expressing disagreement with some of his policies. However, Drazan fared no better, dismissing the governor’s accomplishments by claiming Kotek’s “solution to every problem is a new tax,” a massive exaggeration.

Answers to questions about future policy promises were strategically vague. Proposals sounded like suggestions, vague enough that neither candidate could be pinned down but pleasant enough to score points with voters, such as Drazan’s ambiguous promise to “reduce bureaucracy” in the second debate.

By the end of the debates, their ideas sounded more like something I’d hear in a class discussion group than in a high-stakes political debate. They provided no clear plans or policies, and some issues, like higher education, seemed to catch the candidates entirely off guard. The only thing the candidates agreed on was that the issues were “important” to them, a “top priority,” even, but seldom important enough to go into specifics.

With our politicians behaving this way, it’s no surprise that the race is so close. Voters are tired of career politicians who prefer lip service to civil service and coast on being the lesser of two evils.

Ballots are due Nov. 3. Whatever you decide, read past the sound bites, because the candidates sure aren’t going to do it for you.

Neither candidate responded to requests for comment.

The post Benton: Oregon’s not turning red … right? appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: Oregon’s not turning red … right?

Benton: Could we focus on the deficit before building a new school?

I, for one, snored through my phone buzzing with the 2:27 a.m. notification of Phil Knight’s billion-dollar donation on Sept. 23. By the time I rolled over in the morning to check my phone, it was in The New York Times. My jaw dropped, not only because a national outlet appeared to have a bigger heads up than students, but because I couldn’t understand how we are now building an engineering school all of a sudden.

I started rummaging through my memory and my phone for any evidence of students asking for this. I understand that adding a new program may be considered an attractive addition to get more out-of-state students, but why this program and why now, amid a $65 million budget deficit?

Don’t get me wrong. No one’s arguing if adding an engineering program would be beneficial to UO in the long term. But when donors knock on the door offering a billion dollars to construct a new program from the ground up, we need to discuss the needs of current students before those of hypothetical ones.

Faculty are being laid off, and significant cuts are being made to the programs students pay tens of thousands for. Even before the shortfall was announced, students were stuck taking certain language classes and finishing their degrees through online hybrid classes through the University of Minnesota just last year. We shouldn’t have to abandon these programs to create new ones.

When I asked if there was any demand for this, I was directed to several sources about national industry demand, not student demand. I was told by UO spokesperson Angela Seydel that ASUO representatives “voted to approve a degree in engineering back in January 2020.” This initially gave me the impression that they were on the same page.

But ASUO President Quadrian Gill expressed that they were caught off guard by the decision to build a new school. He said that “now we have this new excitement around something that’s not even here” while ignoring programs that help students to “explore new ideas, explore new communities, have tough conversations that you would have never had before.”

Gill believes UO administration is following the broader national trend away from liberal arts education; as a result, the university is turning into “a place we simply exchange a piece of paper instead of having a true academic community.”

Administration has explained that these types of donations are directed gifts, meaning that the financial contribution is allocated for a specific purpose, which is absolutely understandable. But nothing prevents the administration from pursuing other options for the deficit.

Directed gifts can be (and often are) negotiated, and administrators have the option to propose a different use, ask for part of the gift to be flexible, or ask about a separate gift. And while it’s true that that one-time donation won’t fix a recurring deficit, an endowment or a multi-year commitment can act as a temporary cushion during this difficult economic period and make a massive difference for students.

Ultimately, a billion dollars is nice, but it would be nicer for it to have been aimed at the student programs that are actively atrophying. Shiny new buildings don’t always attract new students, but well-funded student services do. Mr. Knight, would you consider a future gift aimed at the student services that are actively struggling?

The post Benton: Could we focus on the deficit before building a new school? appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: Could we focus on the deficit before building a new school?

Benton: Jaded and jobless: Where did all the entry-level jobs go?

I have a love-hate relationship with my laptop these days. What used to be a cherished tool for entertainment and discovery now looks at me each morning, daring me to open it and check my email for what is sure to be another rejection for a job I don’t remember applying to. Or maybe write a few dozen more cover letters.

Even by the rest of the country’s standards, Oregon’s job market is struggling. Whether it be the advent of artificial intelligence or the lagging economy, everybody seems to have a different reason why the entry-level job market is so barren of opportunities. And barren it is, even on campus.

The strain on the job market disadvantages students seeking work, as campus jobs are be- coming increasingly unavailable due to the recent campus-wide hiring freeze. It’s becoming so normal that not being able to find a job is now somewhat of an icebreaker when meeting new people on campus.

It’s how I came to meet Ava Rodgers, a multidisciplinary science major on the premed track who was also facing the same issue. Driven to learn and hopeful for an application boost, she earned a phlebotomy certificate and learned to draw blood. Yet when the time came to enter the workforce, she “couldn’t find any phlebotomy jobs.”

Dani Amtmann, head of the Career Readiness Coach team at the UO Career Center, painted a clear picture of just how prevalent the issue is. Citing data from Handshake, coaches have seen “a 13.8% increase in average applications per UO student.” But when more applicants are coming in with fewer jobs to apply to, vying for a job feels less like interviewing and more like a high-stakes game of musical chairs.

While the sentiment is not applicable to every student, coaches have noticed that more students are expressing worries of not being able to find a job. Amtmann voiced that it’s “very common to see students apply for more jobs to get the same number of interviews in today’s market,” which has “less opportunities for part-time jobs, internships and entry-level talent.”

While we may not control the job market, we can certainly control how we react to it. Amtmann mentioned that Career Readiness Coaches have seen success in helping students create “highly tailored documents (resumes and cover letters) and tapping into industry connections.”

The Financial Wellness Center’s workshops can be useful for students looking to build savings for a rainy day. Tennille Wait, assistant director of financial wellness at the center, “(encourages) students to start with the basics: create a realistic budget and track their spending.”

There are so many resources available on campus for students and after graduation, like the afore- mentioned Financial Wellness Center, Career Centers and alumni organizations.

We can’t fix the job market. But between tailored resumes, career coaching and putting in the work to grow our savings, we can make the waiting a little less painful.

The post Benton: Jaded and jobless: Where did all the entry-level jobs go? appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: Jaded and jobless: Where did all the entry-level jobs go?

Benton: Where are all the student protestors?

When I pass the federal building on my route to school these days, I usually see one of two scenes: Either a crowd of older adults protesting the current administration or an empty street corner soundtracked by engines and hurried footsteps. But the most interesting part is what’s always missing: students.

Student activists have always been widely considered the backbone of American political movements, yet students today remain a minority at both local rallies and nationwide protests. To make things more puzzling, economic conditions are worsening across the country, particularly for young adults. So where are the students?

Online publications like “The American Prospect” have suggested students may not view protests as effective or worth the risk. Students now can be forced to choose between peacefully advocating for important is- sues and keeping a clean student record. If they protest, they could face disciplinary consequences significantly impacting their lives, such as when some universities tried to deny student protesters their diplomas.

However, student activists haven’t “gone” any- where. They’re just focusing on the most effective ways to reach their goals. While classic protests may have worked in a political system that relied on people in power acting in good faith, unorganized protests without a specific goal are largely ineffective in a political landscape that prides itself on crushing dissent.

The student-run Radical Organizing and Activism Resource Center has served as a hub and resource center for leftist organizations on campus since the early 1970s. ROAR Co-director Carter Franks said that when it comes to protests on campus, “There tends to be upticks in the amount of engagement that matches the current political moment,” and “The key is whether or not (students) stick around after all the protests are done.”

And in recent years, students seem to be sticking around more. Each year following the Palestine Soli- darity Encampments, organizations under the ROAR umbrella have picked up more and more wins, such as alerts for when immigration agents are in the area, bargaining for student workers, medication abortions for students and allocating $15 million toward decar- bonization efforts on campus.

Franks added that “protests are just the tip of the iceberg, and they are not the majority of the work” that ROAR does. Protests can be a great tool for change, but “much of the work (ROAR does) is done through the slow process of democracy … and by the countless meetings that are held before a campaign demand can even be decided.”

There may never have been more reasons to get involved in community organizing, especially with so many people struggling through today’s political and economic climate. That may be why the students are more present elsewhere: in the meetings, coalitions and campaigns that rarely make it onto a street corner.

So instead of asking where the student activists are, maybe we should ask how we can support them. The next time I pass the federal building, I’ll try to remember that an empty corner isn’t the same as an empty movement.

The post Benton: Where are all the student protestors? appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: Where are all the student protestors?

Benton: From Minneapolis to Delaney Hall: the deaths we stopped counting

The deaths of Alex Pretti, Keith Porter and Renee Good still feel like a nightmare that many of us haven’t awakened from yet. When shots rang out in the streets of Minneapolis, the surge in public outcry was intense and immediate. But as the chaos faded into memory, the Trump administration seemed to have achieved exactly what it had wanted for months: the public off its back.

The senseless violence exhibited by ICE agents incited fury from every corner of the country that lasted for months on end. Over time, though, the crowds dwindled as the federal authorities shifted to other, less violent strategies in public, as reported by NBC News.

But as we’re six months removed from these incidents, what has that rage translated into? With government forces now comfortable taking lethal action against Americans, what are our leaders doing to prevent more violence?

Long story short, not enoughJunior planning, public policy and management student Calder Slingerland said, “I don’t think the media or politicians at the local, state or national levels have appropriately addressed ICE’s continued disappearing of community members,” explaining that, “In many ways, the media is complicit in dropping the story, but government reactions haven’t been strong enough to protect our community. We can’t let injustice go unpunished.”

But unpunished it went. Every agent involved in Porter, Pretti and Good’s deaths kept their jobs. Good’s killer even made hundreds of thousands of dollars off the killing on a GoFundMe set up in his name, but the public’s attention had already shifted to the next hot topic.

Junior Katie Ruecker described the force ICE uses in their operations as “disgusting” and “abhorrent,” condemning the “shooting of innocent civilians” and arrests that even members of Congress have compared to kidnappings.

Yet, despite the story’s eventual fading into the background, the deaths have only continued at an accelerated rate. Except this time, the most vulnerable among us are the ones being targeted: the immigrants in their custody.

Detainees across the country are being mistreated, with people inside fearing for their lives. At Fort Bliss, Texas, alone, immigrants in custody report poor conditions and threats from guards who intend to force detainees into signing voluntary deportation paperwork while the voluntary deportation rate is rising. There are accounts of physical and sexual assaults and allegations of torture inflicted by guards.

In another case, immigrants held in New Jersey’s Delaney Hall detention center are currently on a hunger strike, protesting the poor conditions in the facility. In response, community organizers outside quickly mobilized protesters to put pressure on federal authorities. Even New Jersey Sen. Andy Kim showed up outside the building and, while asking to check the conditions inside and exercising his legal right to oversight, was pepper-sprayed by law enforcement.

As of June 3, CBS News has reported that the deaths in immigration custody are on track to hit a new record, with 18 deaths in the first half of 2026 alone. Nearly a fifth of which were suicides — a number rising rapidly, an Associated Press Investigation found.

Grief without consequence is just weather, and anger without action is still complacency.

We have already decided, collectively, that these deaths are acceptable. The outrage came, the cameras left and the killing continues. So how many more are we willing to tolerate before we call it what it is?

The post Benton: From Minneapolis to Delaney Hall: the deaths we stopped counting appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: From Minneapolis to Delaney Hall: the deaths we stopped counting

Benton: EPD gave Martin Siller a badge. Nobody gave him a leash.

While a picture may be worth a thousand words, no words in the English language can quite capture the gravity of the video that ultimately forced Martin Siller out of the Eugene Police Department.

The community has been in an uproar since the emergence of bodycam footage showing Siller, a now-former officer with the EPD, in his car the night of the January 30 protest at the federal building. The footage recorded a vile, albeit wide-ranging, conversation with what Chief Chris Skinner suggested was a former colleague from Utah’s West Valley Police Department, where Siller had once worked.

The pair spoke about swinger cruises, infidelity and swapped stories of fellow officers engaging in brutal domestic violence. From the comfort of his quiet, cushioned, temperature-controlled service vehicle, Siller made fun of protestors doused in tear gas by federal agents. He lauded the federal agents, mocking “unemployed” protestors and spewing racist stereotypes. At one point, Siller mused about walking a trail during his shift, quipping that he needed a leash.

It’s essential to point out that the bodycam footage was not obtained through a typical public records request; it instead emerged during the criminal proceedings against a protester. Without said proceedings, this footage could never have come to light.

The video predictably inflamed the already-tense relationship the EPD has with the community, a fact Eugene resident Kevin Cronin was quick to point out at last week’s city council meeting. Cronin expounded upon the disturbing pattern of inappropriate behavior, citing a litany of sexual harassment accusations within the EPD, rape accusations involving on-duty officers, domestic violence incidents involving officers and, of course, their reversed rollout of Flock Safety, a controversial license plate surveillance program.

University of Oregon family and human service major Alekhya Bhupalam thinks that the footage
speaks to why there’s a broader mistrust between the public and EPD, asking if the officers who are supposed to protect us can make vulgar comments like that: “Behind the community’s backs, how
are we supposed to trust them?” An officer feeling comfortable enough to admit to on-duty misconduct while being filmed certainly raises a few questions. Has this behavior happened before, and what else could officers be saying when they don’t think they’re being supervised?

The problem doesn’t lie solely with the words Siller spoke, but also with his relaxation in saying
them. His voice never wavers or shows any signs of hesitation. He didn’t even bother to lower his voice to hide it because he didn’t think he needed to.

EPD did not respond to questions about why Siller was on the phone in the first place. However, spokesperson Melinda McLaughlin said their reporting system includes “an independent police auditor, citizen review board and internal affairs system.” Yet she said the conduct Siller displayed is exactly the type of behavior employees would be expected to report. So, in his seven years at the EPD, nobody heard anything concerning?

A reporting system is only as effective as the people willing to use it. If seven years passed without a single flag raised on Siller, the question isn’t just about him — it’s about everyone who worked alongside him, as well.

Siller resigned before facing accountability, but he was right that we can’t just let our officers do whatever they want. But without closure, the uncomfortable question remains: Can we be expected to feel safe and confident in our law enforcement officials when they can so casually show disdain for our community?

The post Benton: EPD gave Martin Siller a badge. Nobody gave him a leash. appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: EPD gave Martin Siller a badge. Nobody gave him a leash.

Benton: UO’s 170,000 square-foot question

Each morning on my way to class from the bus, I pass the towering steel skeleton of a new athletic building, with a mechanical symphony of construction equipment hammering away. To some undergraduates, it’s background noise. But to students who saw departmental funding or entire faculty positions cut, it’s getting harder not to notice what comes up and what goes down.

Construction is well underway for the Hatfield-Dowlin Complex Practice Field Expansion, an indoor athletics training facility slated to open next year. The plan for the building is formidable, including a meeting space, indoor field, nutrition and recovery areas, expanded weight rooms and players’ lounge. Standing at nearly 100 feet and spanning 170,000 square feet, the facility is also entirely funded through private philanthropy.

The expansion marks a new addition to the athletics program’s increasing collection of buildings filled with state-of-the-art technology, with the number and size of the facilities resembling a small college of its own. Dan Lanning himself noted the change, saying that in a “healthy university, you’re going to see some buildings going up.” That confidence is harder to share when the sheer scale of construction stands in stark contrast to the slow attrition of staff members and academic departments happening at the same time.

It’s hard for an undergraduate without a connection to athletics to ignore a continuous pattern of donors funding athletic programs, used by only a small portion of students, over academics. The tension created by the funding imbalance has only worsened as time goes on, especially as recent, sudden budget cuts remain controversial for many students, faculty and staff members.

Blaise Malczewski, director of organizing for ASUO, expressed that the administration and the Board of Trustees are “prioritizing private funding for athletics in the same year that they made large-scale cuts to academic programs and fired student workers and non-student staff that make the university function.”

When I contacted UO Giving for a statement about whether comparable donor funding goals exist for non-athletic student services and whether these donations displace philanthropic capacity that might otherwise go to academics, they said that “many donors support both athletic and academic programs,” and “give to the programs they care about.” I was also directed to the Oregon150 initiative, which aims — and will likely achieve — its goal to raise $500 million for student success and capital priorities.

But when asked directly what percentage of athletic giving is concerning for students, the response offered raw giving totals from five years ago without engaging the question. The numbers were certainly there. The answer wasn’t.

This is not intended as an indictment, but rather an inquiry into why our culture prioritizes certain institutions over others and what it means to ‘grow’ as a university. When buildings go up, the support for the average student — whether through scholarships or the staff who make UO function — should rise with them.

In a year or so, the cranes will eventually come down, and the construction equipment will disappear. I’d like to think that by that time, something else will rise with it. Maybe a department restored, a staff position refiled or an answer from someone in charge. Until then, I’m still waiting.

The post Benton: UO’s 170,000 square-foot question appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: UO’s 170,000 square-foot question

Benton: Suing big tech is one thing. Fixing it is another.

The verdict was small — after all, $6 million barely makes a dent when it comes to punishing trillion-dollar companies. But the thing about dominoes is that they don’t need to be big to set off a chain reaction. They just need you to tip over the first tile.

The topic of social media addiction has taken the spotlight again after Meta and Google lost their case against a 20-year-old woman. As a result of using their platforms from the age of six, she later developed mental health conditions, such as depression, anxiety and body dysmorphia. It’s been widely known for years that social media platforms are detrimental to developing minds, but this is the first time a company has been forced to pay damages for its addictive algorithms.

This is hardly the first time a social media company has been forced to answer for how its algorithm negatively impacts minors, either. Banning children from social media is an idea that has increasingly gained traction among the legislative community worldwide, with countries from all over the world going toe-to-toe with these companies and winning. There has already been a social media ban for minors under the age of 16 in Australia, and the European Union has added more privacy protections for minors, with more momentum growing.

Yet despite the United States Congress’ loose grip on the tech landscape, it has somehow taken an even softer approach to regulating social media companies, no doubt because of the money they spend lobbying our legislators. Now that there have been numerous failed attempts by the legislature to hold Meta and Google accountable, like the stalled Kids Online Safety Act, child safety is now being left to the courts. So now that the courts have demonstrated themselves to be an effective tool to penalize social media companies, what does that mean for the rest of us?

Not everyone is convinced that the verdict will turn into real change. University of Oregon Management Department Head Laura Lanahan remains skeptical that the verdict will lead to any industry corrective measures, given how difficult it is for new companies to enter the market and compete with the larger companies. Because “their positioning in the market is just far too large,” it becomes more difficult for the government to intervene and “put forth corrective market mechanisms,” she said.

But others see a simpler path forward. To students like Addison Sobotta, a senior studying art and technology and environmental studies, the fixes are straightforward — companies just aren’t doing them. Remove the endless scrolling, limit notifications and “if there is intentional addictive engineering going on, (social media companies) should be held accountable,” Sobotta noted.

What’s important to remember is that the story isn’t over yet. In fact, both Meta and Google intend to appeal the judge’s decision.

Our judicial system still has the opportunity to overturn the ruling, making it all the more urgent to keep up the pressure. We must ensure that another generation of kids doesn’t get sucked into exploitative algorithms that exist only to make trillion-dollar companies richer.

The post Benton: Suing big tech is one thing. Fixing it is another. appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: Suing big tech is one thing. Fixing it is another.

Benton: UO made a bet when it cut The Ph.D. Project. It’s already losing

We are a year into Donald Trump’s war on the American education system, and universities across the country are learning that compliance is easier than resistance — and is just as costly. The first caught in the crossfire are exactly the ones who you’d expect: the students with the least amount of institutional protection and the fewest places to turn.

The Department of Education’s investigation into the University of Oregon began in March 2025, in an effort to target universities it claimed had violated Title VI due to their partnerships with The Ph.D. Project. The Ph.D. Project is a nonprofit organization that provides resources to underrepresented students to help them earn doctoral degrees. UO worked with The Ph.D. Project during the 2022-2023 and 2023-2024 academic years.

The university maintains that it did not end its relationship with the program because of federal pressure, but the broader picture suggests otherwise. UO is just one of 45 universities that have received directives from the DOE to cut programs or risk losing federal funding; 31 of them chose to settle with the Trump administration, although UO is not on the official list of settlements.

UO Spokesperson Angela Seydel characterized the university’s partnership with The Ph.D. Project as a “limited relationship,”amounting to little more than sending a student and a couple of staff members to the organization’s annual conference, with the student receiving no financial aid for their attendance. In a statement to The Daily Emerald, UO said, “We consider the matter resolved. We have reviewed all of our practices and believe that we are in compliance with the law.”

Despite initially expressing reluctance, correspondence between the Department of Education and the UO’s Office of Civil Rights reveals that the university relented. UO agreed to terminate its partnership with The Ph.D. Project immediately and committed to reviewing and reporting to the DOE, within 90 days, a full list of its institutional memberships and partnerships, along with the stated purpose of each.

Many students, like third-year student Aysia Rattanaphosy, found the lack of student consultation before cutting the program unacceptable. She noted that students were “ill-informed” in how administrators went about “announcing this decision to the student body.”

If this wasn’t about federal pressure, then how do we explain the timing of it all? Why sever ties with The Ph.D. Project at the precise moment that all the other schools are choosing to settle, and let the controversy fade into the background?

The reality is that compliance won’t earn UO any goodwill from the Trump administration. Capitulating to these demands will not satisfy them, nor will it change how the DOE views diversity programs. The administration is already moving to revoke UO’s Performance Partnership Pilots for Disconnected Youth waivers, a program designed to support students they have chosen to label “illegal immigrants.”

The Trump administration itself doesn’t consider the current investigation to be over yet. According to The Oregonian, the federal government has not yet finalized the matter surrounding UO’s involvement with The Ph.D. Project.

Yes, the university’s relationship with The Ph.D. project was limited, and limited enough to where it was considered reasonable to cut it without a fight. But the Trump administration’s appetite for concessions is insatiable. When they come back – and they will – are we prepared to resist it?

The post Benton: UO made a bet when it cut The Ph.D. Project. It’s already losing appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Benton: UO made a bet when it cut The Ph.D. Project. It’s already losing

The federal building protests: One broken window, zero answers

The Jan. 30 protest at the Eugene Federal Building didn’t just damage a window,but rather it exposed how quickly narratives form before evidence has the chance to surface. Statements and condemnations were swiftly issued, commentary circulated nationally and the public was left to sift through competing versions of reality.

I learned about it through the decade’s unlikely news outlet: Donald Trump’s Truth Social. His post described how a riot in Eugene began when protesters smashed a window of the federal building. To protect federal property, federal agents were left with no choice but to use force.

Soon after, local officials, including Eugene Police Department Chief Chris Skinner, Mayor Kaarin Knudson and Governor Tina Kotek, almost immediately released statements condemning the violence at the federal building, notably choosing not to speak out against the use of tear gas on protesters.

However, users on the r/Eugene subreddit offered a different account. Some protesters claimed online that a federal agent was the one who broke the window. They argued that the use of tear gas endangered bystanders and was disproportionate for what amounted to vandalism.

The situation was complicated further when James Anderson, an independent journalist with the CommunityMattersPNW YouTube channel, released footage of the protest that appeared to show a federal agent smashing a window. As a result of this discord, the video became a kind of political Rorschach test for the community. Those who already agreed with federal agents’ tactics sided with the government’s narrative, while those who didn’t remained skeptical.

When evidence emerges, it usually clarifies the narrative. Yet the footage didn’t bring an end to the debate; it only deepened it. As more information came out, the broader picture looked increasingly unclear.

Anderson, who arrived after some damage had already occurred, said that people at the protest whom he had “never seen do activism before.” He noted that “people (appeared) overwhelmed,” seeming “frustrated” by the lack of pushback from local officials about the increasingly aggressive tactics used by federal agents — and by what they perceived as silence from those same officials. The speed of the official responses was striking, especially given that video footage had not yet been released when those early statements were made.

When I initially contacted the Eugene Police Department seeking clarification, I was directed to Chief Skinner’s previous statement and referred to the Portland office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. In a statement to The Daily Emerald, FBI Portland’s Public Affairs office explained that in the aforementioned video, the federal agent was only “tossing a crowd control munition” through the “already broken window.” They alleged that the window in the video was “the same window broken by rioters.” The FBI has since added those it suspects of being the vandals to its infamous Most Wanted list.

The most revealing aspect of Jan. 30 may not be who struck the glass first, but how quickly certainty replaced inquiry. Before the footage was public, conclusions were already drawn. Before conflicting accounts were reconciled, positions were entrenched. In a political climate defined by speed and spectacle, the timeline of the reaction may tell us as much as the event itself.

While it’s unclear who started the riot at the federal building, it is absolutely clear where our local and federal officials stand. Rather than immediately believing the narratives we’re presented with, we must take the time to research and reflect before jumping to conclusions. While we may not be able to change how our government responds, we can certainly control how we absorb it.

The post The federal building protests: One broken window, zero answers appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The federal building protests: One broken window, zero answers