I, for one, snored through my phone buzzing with the 2:27 a.m. notification of Phil Knight’s billion-dollar donation on Sept. 23. By the time I rolled over in the morning to check my phone, it was in The New York Times. My jaw dropped, not only because a national outlet appeared to have a bigger heads up than students, but because I couldn’t understand how we are now building an engineering school all of a sudden.
I started rummaging through my memory and my phone for any evidence of students asking for this. I understand that adding a new program may be considered an attractive addition to get more out-of-state students, but why this program and why now, amid a $65 million budget deficit?
Don’t get me wrong. No one’s arguing if adding an engineering program would be beneficial to UO in the long term. But when donors knock on the door offering a billion dollars to construct a new program from the ground up, we need to discuss the needs of current students before those of hypothetical ones.
Faculty are being laid off, and significant cuts are being made to the programs students pay tens of thousands for. Even before the shortfall was announced, students were stuck taking certain language classes and finishing their degrees through online hybrid classes through the University of Minnesota just last year. We shouldn’t have to abandon these programs to create new ones.
When I asked if there was any demand for this, I was directed to several sources about national industry demand, not student demand. I was told by UO spokesperson Angela Seydel that ASUO representatives “voted to approve a degree in engineering back in January 2020.” This initially gave me the impression that they were on the same page.
But ASUO President Quadrian Gill expressed that they were caught off guard by the decision to build a new school. He said that “now we have this new excitement around something that’s not even here” while ignoring programs that help students to “explore new ideas, explore new communities, have tough conversations that you would have never had before.”
Gill believes UO administration is following the broader national trend away from liberal arts education; as a result, the university is turning into “a place we simply exchange a piece of paper instead of having a true academic community.”
Administration has explained that these types of donations are directed gifts, meaning that the financial contribution is allocated for a specific purpose, which is absolutely understandable. But nothing prevents the administration from pursuing other options for the deficit.
Directed gifts can be (and often are) negotiated, and administrators have the option to propose a different use, ask for part of the gift to be flexible, or ask about a separate gift. And while it’s true that that one-time donation won’t fix a recurring deficit, an endowment or a multi-year commitment can act as a temporary cushion during this difficult economic period and make a massive difference for students.
Ultimately, a billion dollars is nice, but it would be nicer for it to have been aimed at the student programs that are actively atrophying. Shiny new buildings don’t always attract new students, but well-funded student services do. Mr. Knight, would you consider a future gift aimed at the student services that are actively struggling?
The post Benton: Could we focus on the deficit before building a new school? appeared first on Daily Emerald.