For as much of our lives as we spend online, it’s remarkably easy to take the Internet as we know it for granted — basic things like the right to browse individual websites freely and having unhindered choice in which services you use online. The web can exist in this form because Internet service providers like Comcast and CenturyLink cannot differentiate service based upon your activity. This concept is referred to as “Net Neutrality,” and it’s almost impossible to envision the web any other way. And yet, on Jan. 14, a federal court struck down the “Open Internet Rules” established by the FCC in 2010 to protect Net Neutrality. The ruling is seen as a massive win for ISPs and a potential major loss for consumers interested in the freedom of the web.
The motivation for ISPs to squish Net Neutrality is one based both on profit and on the argument of who owns the information transmitting through an ISP’s network. The FCC would argue that they fall under the same classification as radio frequencies, since they’re publically owned and licenced to companies in the service of the public interest. Meanwhile, Comcast, Time Warner and the other major ISPs believe that since they own the infrastructure responsible for the internet, they have full power to control what flows through it. Video streaming is said to make up more than 30 percent of overall Internet usage, according to a recent study by PC Mag, and is seen as a direct competitor to many of the additional services (like cable TV & on-demand video rental) these ISPs provide.
Biswarup Sen is a journalism professor on campus, currently teaching a class entitled “Media and Society,” which deals with the evolution of mass communication across the globe.
“What this tension between Comcast and Hulu reflects is a fundamental shift in the nature of content,” Sen said. “We are moving from an age of medium-specific content … to one where content is multi-platform and not identified with a particular medium. The medium, it seems, is no longer the message.”
This disconnect between medium and message is what ultimately causes new technology and innovations like Netflix to strike fear into the hearts of ISPs. Previously, renting movies, watching TV, listening to the radio and other entertainment products were separate — and massive industries have been built upon their distribution. An open web allows absolute free movement of information and entertainment. The middleman can now be cut out, but he’s not leaving without a fight.
While no ISP has yet taken steps to capitalize on the new ruling, it’s important to recognize what is now possible under the new precedent. In a public statement, Netflix details the possible future: “In principle, a domestic ISP now can legally impede the video streams that members request from Netflix, degrading the experience we jointly provide. The motivation could be to get Netflix to pay fees to stop this degradation.”
Those fees would come at a serious price: Either Netflix would have less money to licence content and develop its streaming platform, or they may end up as a price increase for subscribers.
Hope isn’t completely lost for consumers, though. Groups such as the Electronic Frontier Foundation lobby lawmakers and fight for your rights in the digital age. Their website offers convenient tools to message your representatives in Washington and get your voice heard.