Posted on 06 February 2014.
Over 210 million Americans play video games regularly. Games enjoy popularity in most developed nations across the world. They are a large artistic medium of the 21st century. Yet, gaming seems to have an image problem when it comes to the representation of women.
Upon taking a glance at an average shelf full of games in any store in the country, you’ll be awash with plenty of buff white males either holding guns, scoring a goal or embarking upon a royal quest to save a fair maiden.
It’s a common complaint among many gamers — both male and female — who wonder why equal representation seems to be such a challenge.
One of these voices is Anna Lind, a member of the campus group Think.Play, who gave a talk on the female characters of “Mass Effect 3.”
For those unfamiliar, the game is a space opera, a saga of war and relationships that spans the galaxy. Players can construct the lead “Commander Shepard” to be any race, gender or sexuality of their choosing.
Lind specifically addressed this game because every character is given extraordinary depth without resorting to gender tropes.
“If you were to describe the characters in ‘Mass Effect 3′ without using gendered pronouns, you wouldn’t be able to tell which were male and which were female,” Lind said.
It’s a test that many other games fail — where female characters often feel like token additions or outright stereotypes.
One case of sub-par representation can be found in “Batman: Arkham Origins.” The prequel features several female villains pitted against the caped crusader, but their character development often leaves much to be desired. Such is the case with Harley Quinn — the Joker’s second-in-command, a former prison psychiatrist who falls madly in love with her patient. Within the course of “Origins’” campaign, her character lacks agency beyond being a tool of those around her. Lind feels the industry is lacking “stories about being women or just stories with women playing them out. Accuracy means portraying them as people.”
“The game industry still runs on older stereotypes about people who play games, assuming that male gamers are attracted to sexualized imagery (which is insulting to men who like to play good games) and that the most important demographic for games is male,” said Carol Stabile, a journalism and women’s and gender studies professor, in an email interview.
She also attributes the current status of female representation in games to the homogenous nature of gaming development.
“It’s still overwhelmingly white and male and there’s not a lot of push for them to incorporate other representations and perspectives,” Stabile said.
Stabile’s assertions are backed up in the data.
A 2005 survey of the game industry by the International Game Developers Association found the majority of developers to be white (83.3 percent) heterosexual (92 percent) men (88.5 percent).
“We know that diversity in production does enhance diversity in representation,” Stabile said.
While the IGDA survey is coming along in age (and is currently in the process of being updated), it falls in line with more recent numbers on diversity in the computing industry. The Computing Research Association reported in 2010 that of the current undergraduate class (among schools focusing on Ph.D.’s in computing) was only 13.4 percent female.
While it’s easy to jump to the conclusion that this lack of representation stems from within the industry, evidence exists that suggests it may be the opposite. This trend may simply the result of businesses working within their own best interest.
High-profile games with strong female protagonists have been made in the past – EA’s “Mirror’s Edge” was an inventive first-person parkour game, beloved for its unique visuals and innovative platforming.
“Bayonetta,” published by Sega, had its titular character fighting off hordes of demons in high heels.
Ubisoft’s “Beyond Good And Evil” took players on a dystopian adventure that spanned every genre in the book.
All three games received monstrous critical acclaim (Metacritic scores of 81, 90 and 83, respectively) and large marketing pushes. Still, all three sold exceptionally poorly at launch.
With so many high-profile failures and so few success stories, it’s not hard to blame large publishers from wanting to avoid risk.
Video games are a 93-billion-dollar business, and any one major game underperforming can mean studios shutting down and jobs being lost. Publishers have an incentive to avoid risk and thus only try new things when they prove to be profitable ahead of time.
But being overly adverse of risk carries a danger of its own. Senior Jennifer Appleby, a core member of Think.Play, offers her impression: “(In the gaming industry) you get the impression that this is all there is. As a result, that’s all there is.” How can the industry know that female-led games sell poorly when so few are released?
Games with female protagonists have managed to achieve success in other genres, beyond the standard action and shooter fare.
Square Enix’s mammoth “Final Fantasy” franchise has had multiple female protagonists in the past, all independent and well written.
The second season of Telltale’s popular adaptation of “The Walking Dead” is centered upon Clementine, a 10-year-old girl in the wake of the zombie apocalypse.
Portland-born business The Fullbright Company struck indie gold with their emotional adventure “Gone Home.”
All of these titles have seen profits, which may hint at an interesting demographic trend.
While the population of gamers is 45 percent female, it doesn’t mean that men and women are playing the same games on the same platforms.
“This (issue of representation) is really based on console-based games, where the gender dynamics are skewed,” Stabile said. “Not games played on mobile devices, which is actually the fastest growing segment of the market and one understood to be dominated by women.”
A 2011 study in Boston surveying gamers found that female players were more likely to play on a handheld, console or mobile device over a PC and that they preferred non-violent games over violent ones. The survey also showed a greater preference for social, puzzle and simulation titles among female players.
Ultimately, whether the cause be based in development or demographics, diversity in gaming is something to fight for.
Nobody benefits when great games are left out in the cold due to publisher disinterest. Fortunately, the situation seems to be improving. Many of the top-selling games of 2013, such as “Grand Theft Auto V,” “Call of Duty: Ghosts” and “Pokemon X/Y” allow players to choose between male and female avatars in their multiplayer modes.
Action hits “Bioshock Infinite” and “The Last of Us” have strong female characters in their narratives and even on their cover art.
As more gaming enthusiasts came across “Mirror’s Edge,” “Bayonetta” and “Beyond Good and Evil,” they praised them as games ahead of their time. As a result, all three have sequels currently in active development.
Publishers are aware of the growing female demographic, and while representation may be currently flawed, steps are being taken every day to make this art form as great as it can be.