Author Archives | by Amelia Watters

Satire: Are heterosexuals ruining society?

In the last couple of years, I, along with many others, have noticed troubling changes within established institutions. From marriage and education to even the workplace, there has been a sense that something about how we have engaged with society is just not right. 

Why do medium-ugly men cheat on beautiful women? Why did my best friend stop talking to me when I got a boyfriend? Is the love of my life really not at the bar?

These are just some of the questions I hear every day from average people trying to navigate love and life.

And it’s clear to me that all of these problems come down to one simple truth: Heterosexuals are ruining society.

In the age of Clairo, heterosexuality’s relevance in popular culture has slowly diminished. Naturally, we have seen a response from straight activists demanding retribution, a return to cultural hegemony and a recognition that, hey, their problems matter, too!

Let’s look at the male loneliness epidemic. It would be one thing to allow men to have a space to discuss their concerns with developing deep, intimate relationships outside of their romantic partners. However, what we’re actually seeing is a bunch of whiny, heterosexual men unable to get laid, likely due to their Reddit addictions and $300 monthly Zyn budgets.

They want to blame women, but when a baddie finally takes a chance on the poor, lonely heterosexual male, he inevitably fumbles the bag. Megan Thee Stallion deserved better anyway.

Speaking of manchildren, pop star Sabrina Carpenter has taken the world by storm, writing music lamenting the broken world of heterosexual partnership. This came to a head when she wrote a song requesting her lover to “Please Please Please” not embarrass her publicly, only for him to, of course, embarrass her publicly.

Unfortunately, heterosexual women are no better. I’m not alone in having lost many beautiful friends to the dreaded year-long situationship. Tears are shed, plans are cancelled and classes are skipped all over a “You up?” text from a man who wears dirty socks and doesn’t refill the toilet paper before she comes over.

For centuries, the media has led us to believe heterosexuality is the natural state of the world. 

But tell me, does this sound natural to you? 

The reality is that men and women are fundamentally different entities, socialized to find comfort within each other. 

Some may say these differences draw them together. I could not disagree more.

Women, who are naturally logical thinkers, are driven mad by the inane instincts of the college frat guy. Men, on the other hand, are pressured into relationships with women whose beauty and wit intimidate their fragile male egos. Men, to put it simply, just can’t handle all that. 

So they behave erratically, leaving their girlfriends on read, only to respond hours later with a Snap that’s 20% their face and 80% the wall of their gym’s locker room.

When their girlfriends, talking stages, or, god forbid, sneaky links respond reasonably to such actions, they switch the blame, arguing women are the emotional ones, expecting far too much of a business major with no job and who was kicked out of Tau Kappa Alpha for not paying dues.

I don’t mean to sound like I’m prejudiced against the heterosexual community. I’m just trying to ask questions and traverse an intellectual ground few have dared explore, for fear of upsetting the anti-woke agenda that is trying to reclaim the mainstream.

In contrast, we have started to see the joy, life and warmth of same-sex partnerships. From “Heated Rivalry” to the WNBA, queer art has reminded us what love can truly look like.

At least I’ve never seen my gay male friends cry over a guy they met on Grindr.

Whenever you bring up these inherent differences between men and women, inevitably, there’s always someone quick to bring up counterexamples, like Zendaya and Tom Holland or your grandparents.

But exceptions do not prove a rule, and it’s time to look at the evidence before us: centuries of failed marriages, lost talking-stages and years-long arguments over how to fill the dishwasher. When is the right time to say the heterosexual experiment has failed?

As a bisexual with a straight boyfriend, I’m empathetic to the heterosexual cause. However, even I recognize the illogical reality of choosing an opposite-sex partner.

It starts today. And it starts with me. 

So, if you’re reading this, it’s over. You know who you are.

The post Satire: Are heterosexuals ruining society? appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Satire: Are heterosexuals ruining society?

Opinion: The bathhouse ban has always been about sex

Nearly 40 years ago, Minneapolis passed a ban on public bathhouses, sites for anonymous sex and LGBTQ activism during the 20th century. 

The 1988 ordinance, though ostensibly passed to slow the spread of HIV in Minneapolis, is considered by modern historians as the result of gentrification, homophobia and growing prevalence of police raids on bathhouses, despite overall lower levels of police violence toward the queer community.

Now, the Minneapolis City Council is discussing an ordinance to reverse the ban, representing a huge step toward recognizing Minneapolis’s LGBTQ history.

University of Minnesota history doctoral student Myra Billund-Phibbs said bathhouses became a target for anti-LGBTQ activism as AIDS came to Minneapolis, leading to closures and ultimately the ordinance.

“By the mid-1980s, the baths take a huge hit socially and the scene of public sex really changes,” Billund-Phibbs said. “Even as policing is becoming tamer and less entrapping and less violent towards gay public sex than it was in the late 70s.”

For decades, bathhouses served as adult spaces primarily used by gay men to engage in sexual activity. These community centers required minimal licensing and faced lower levels of policing relative to other queer spaces.

Though bathhouses held several functions in the LGBTQ community, including providing spaces for activism, escaping violence and meeting others in the community, it’s important to remember the primary service of these bathhouses: sex. 

Public historian Noah Barth said a discomfort around gay sex is important to understanding the bathhouse ban and how queer history is discussed more broadly.

“There is a struggle to talk about sex and the sex part of sexuality,” Barth said. “We really struggle to talk about bathhouses and the multiple reasons that they were important.”

At the time of the ban, sodomy was still a felony in Minnesota, and would continue to be criminalized until 2001, when a district judge ruled these laws violated the right to privacy under the Minnesota Constitution. Spaces like bathhouses were critical for gay men to express themselves sexually, during a time when being caught having sex with a man could ruin your life.

The ordinance itself was in many ways an extension of these regulations on queer sexuality. Barth noted the original text of the ordinance attacked sexual acts associated specifically with gay men and sex workers. 

“Institutions, including the government, are always in the business of regulating specifically queer sexuality and not heterosexuality,” Barth said. “They target places like bathhouses and bars where queer sex can happen without doing that to heterosexual people.”

Billund-Phibbs said the topic of sex is missing from coverage on the ordinance. Instead of highlighting the primary purpose of bathhouses — anonymous sex — the media has framed them as predominantly community spaces.

Though this characterization may not be entirely inaccurate, it does obscure the reality of bathhouses, thus limiting our ability to truly engage with our city’s queer history.

Barth highlighted how Minnesota-specific cultural norms may have further hindered the city from speaking openly about its history of sex and sexuality.

“What we’re sort of confronting in Minneapolis is this Midwestern sensibility that doesn’t really want to talk about these topics,” Barth said. “You know, we’re not in San Francisco, we’re not New York or Chicago, and now, we are really boldly confronting the issue of sexuality in our city.”

But just because it isn’t acknowledged, it doesn’t mean that history isn’t there. Minneapolis has strippers, cruisers and LGBTQ people across the gender and sexuality spectrums, and all of these communities have played a major role in shaping our city into what it is today. 

Understanding the bathhouse ban in this context means engaging with the unsanitized reality of what these spaces meant for the community. Gay men at the time needed spaces for community, but also to simply have sex, something heterosexual individuals have always been allowed to do. 

Repealing the ordinance is an important step toward acknowledging the harm done to queer people and repairing the damage done by decades of state intrusions into the intimate lives of everyday people. 

But in order for us to reckon with the systemic erasure of the LGBTQ community in public history, we must be honest about what these spaces were for, even if that means entering uncomfortable but honest conversations about sex, sexuality and how that has impacted Minneapolis. 

“To target a specific group of people that participate in a specific group of acts is discrimination,” Barth said. “Repealing this ordinance is undoing an injustice.”

The post Opinion: The bathhouse ban has always been about sex appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The bathhouse ban has always been about sex

Opinion: Don’t ignore the secret class politics of TikTok

Online content creators of all sorts packed their bags and boarded their flights last weekend in preparation for the influencer’s Super Bowl, also known as Coachella: a weekend of Instagram posts, get-ready-with-me videos and maybe some concerts in the California desert. 

For years, brands have taken advantage of having social media’s biggest figures in one place for a weekend, with many inviting creators to spend the festival in a brand house on the company’s dime. 

In short, while the average person hoping to attend Coachella can expect to pay thousands for hotels, flights and the festival ticket itself, content creators are provided a first-class experience at minimal cost, and they get the opportunity to make money through posting content during their trip.

Meanwhile, I’m stuck at home watching Sabrina Carpenter’s set from my couch.

Despite all of that, many of us still engage with these creators, thereby funding their extravagant lifestyle. 

University of Minnesota second-year student Dylan Krenz-Bertrand said Generation Z has been socialized to place aesthetic, entertainment and moral value on displays of wealth.

“As kids, we’re conditioning them to look at these people and hold them in high regard,” Krenz-Bertrand said. “So I think it’s really capturing a lot of people, and kind of like any experience that they won’t be able to have themselves.”

Wish fulfillment is a primary reason many of us engage with social media influencers. Those reading about Madeleine White’s beautiful Santorini wedding in Vogue likely understand that they may never be able to afford attending, let alone hosting, that type of event. 

However, this admiration for wealthy influencers can go beyond a desire to live vicariously through Instagram stories. Tech heiress and TikTok creator Rebecca Ma, also known as Becca Bloom, has been dubbed the queen of “RichTok,” posting content displaying her inordinate fortune, from designer clothing hauls to trips on her private jet to feeding her cat caviar.

Although Ma has experienced backlash for flaunting her opulent lifestyle, she also receives praise for remaining down-to-earth and “riching right.”

Though if you ask me, riching right would involve a lot more philanthropy and engagement with the arts and sciences, like some millionaires of prior generations, and a lot less showing what my husband bought me for my birthday.

Not all of this grace is given evenly. Beauty influencer Mikayla Nogueira sparked controversy after posting a designer bag haul with a price tag of thousands of dollars. Viewers criticized Nogueira for her out-of-touch behavior and losing the element of relatability that made her popular in the first place.

University fourth-year student Nai Islam said she used to frequent Reddit snark pages — subreddits where users vent their frustrations about specific content creators and influencer culture as a whole. These spaces serve as an unproductive way for expressing real concerns about class, she added.

“The snark pages is like a way of reclaiming some sort of power, but by the very fact that we are snarking on these people,” Islam said. “We’re wasting our resources to let out this resentment that we feel.”

Some influencers, like White, a former model, and Ma, carried a level of wealth prior to becoming famous online. As such, there was always an awareness that their lifestyles were unattainable to an extent. 

For creators like Nogueira who did not start rich, there is an understanding of class solidarity between her and her audience. Viewers aren’t watching her for the same reason they watch Ma spend an average person’s monthly paycheck on food for her cat. 

So when they see her suddenly achieve heightened levels of wealth, it feels like a betrayal, making her the perfect target for users’ resentments.

Islam said there is an element of classism in these double standards between the old-money and new-money influencers, along with an expectation that they maintain their relatability.

“When you surpass your audience, you can’t alienate them,” Islam said. “You were relying on them for your fame, you are making relatable or seemingly down-to-earth content. But then the moment you get it big, they’re no longer gonna like you.”

Due to the way social media functions, those we make famous online will almost always exceed us in terms of social class. Popularity begets brand deals, merchandise and production deals. 

We cannot stop the influencer-viewer gap, especially when part of the appeal lies in content creators’ access to wealth. But we can change our relationship to the content we consume on social media. 

This novel era of class dynamics fostered by the internet requires a new form of class consciousness, one that recognizes the difference between the layperson and the TikToker and the role we played in giving them that status. Only then can we start to deconstruct our conflicting feelings of resentment, jealousy and admiration toward influencers.

But I’d be lying if I said watching the content creators’ disappointment with Bieberchella wasn’t a little bit cathartic.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Don’t ignore the secret class politics of TikTok

Opinion: In pursuit of community-centered public safety

In April 2025, after years of public outrage, controversy and protest, the Atlanta Public Safety Training Center, colloquially known as “Cop City,” officially opened. 

The property, which serves as a police and fire department training center, cost $67 million in taxpayer dollars. The facility’s construction was first announced in 2021 to improve the morale and retention of Atlanta’s police officers.

The project sparked criticism from local activists, who argued it would increase militarization in Atlanta’s police force and strain the environment, eventually coalescing into the “Stop Cop City” movement. Protests came to a head in January of 2023 when environmental activist Manuel Paez Teran was shot and killed by officers during a demonstration outside the training facility.

Nonetheless, the project continued, with Atlanta Mayor Andre Dickens arguing the training center would be an important measure to lowering instances of police brutality.

Which feels ironic.

Last month, Minneapolis City Council members debated the construction of a police and firefighter training facility that would cost $38 million. 

Proponents, including Mayor Jacob Frey’s administration, argued the center would be an important step toward police reform as the Minneapolis Police Department continues to recover following the murder of George Floyd.

Others, such as Council Members Soren Stevenson, Aisha Chughtai and Robin Wonsley, argue the funds could be invested in the community in other, more valuable ways.

Though the scale of the proposed Minneapolis facility is nowhere near that of Atlanta’s, the approach to addressing police brutality is similar. 

But is this really what MPD needs?

University of Minnesota law professor Amy Sweasy said police force policy varies across departments, many of which have changed in the wake of Floyd’s murder.

“Minneapolis, in particular, their police use of force policy in their policy manual has undergone significant revision since 2020,” Sweasy said. “Both as a result of the murder of George Floyd and the oversight of the court because of the consent decree that city entered into with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights.”

Reform and investigation efforts commenced almost immediately following Floyd’s death. In June 2020, the city and MDHR agreed to ban the use of chokeholds and mandate other policy changes through a temporary restraining order.

In the following years, MDHR conducted an investigation that identified a pattern of race-based discrimination and violence within MPD, reinforced by insufficient training, minimal accountability mechanisms and poor oversight from the city. An investigation from the U.S. Department of Justice yielded similar results.

The consent agreement Sweasy referenced, reached in 2023 by community members and police officers alike to address concerns from both parties, required MPD to make policy changes addressing race-based policing, designating an independent group to track their progress. 

Minneapolis completed the National Incident Management System Reset in 2024 to improve consistency, communication and training for emergency response situations.

“The number of deadly force incidents in Minnesota since 2020 has, with the exception of 2024, either stayed flat or gone down,” Sweasy said when discussing statistics from the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension that detail the number of deadly force incidents across the state.

Sweasy said she cannot speculate on what has caused these numbers to decrease or stay constant. Though any of the above reform measures could have factored into this, or possibly fewer encounters on the streets overall, the state’s strong response to the killings of Renée Good and Alex Pretti demonstrated the state’s thoughts on the issue, she added.

“What we saw here in January and the response of the community to Operation Metro Surge, it suggested to me that this community remains pretty sophisticated when it comes to these events and really understands what the issues and concerns are with the police use of force,” Sweasy said.

In considering the impact of Cop City in Atlanta, researchers from the Brookings Institution, along with stakeholders in Atlanta, St. Louis and Baltimore, emphasized the importance of community-based approaches to preventing police violence and tackling issues such as housing, poverty and discrimination that lead to crime in the first place. In this sense, Cop City can be understood within a militarized framework, rather than a public health approach to public safety.

And that’s not what we need in Minneapolis.

When we look at the factors leading to rising violence in Minneapolis, many are quick to point to the shrinking police presence since 2020. However, this perspective often ignores influences like increased unemployment, school closures and lingering racial inequities.

As Sweasy recognized, the Minneapolis community has consistently demonstrated a particular sensitivity to police violence. After two months of Operation Metro Surge, when thousands of federal officers flooded our streets and arrested more than 3,700 Minnesota residents, it’s hard to believe most Minnesotans would be looking for more militarization of our cities.

There are compelling reasons why the training facility could be valuable in maintaining the reforms passed since 2020. However, when considering the other ways this money could improve our communities, whether through building affordable housing or investing in public schools, it’s hard to believe this is the best option. 

And in a community with a demonstrated commitment to public engagement like Minneapolis, I think many of its residents would agree.

“I think this community knows a lot more about this kind of thing than they did in 2020,” Sweasy said. “And if you go back even further, 10 years before that, there’s always been a significant portion of community members who, for lots of valid reasons, have been more tuned into these issues.”

Whatever happens, Minneapolis is watching.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: In pursuit of community-centered public safety

Opinion: In pursuit of community-centered public safety

In April 2025, after years of public outrage, controversy and protest, the Atlanta Public Safety Training Center, colloquially known as “Cop City,” officially opened. 

The property, which serves as a police and fire department training center, cost $67 million in taxpayer dollars. The facility’s construction was first announced in 2021 to improve the morale and retention of Atlanta’s police officers.

The project sparked criticism from local activists, who argued it would increase militarization in Atlanta’s police force and strain the environment, eventually coalescing into the “Stop Cop City” movement. Protests came to a head in January of 2023 when environmental activist Manuel Paez Teran was shot and killed by officers during a demonstration outside the training facility.

Nonetheless, the project continued, with Atlanta Mayor Andre Dickens arguing the training center would be an important measure to lowering instances of police brutality.

Which feels ironic.

Last month, Minneapolis City Council members debated the construction of a police and firefighter training facility that would cost $38 million. 

Proponents, including Mayor Jacob Frey’s administration, argued the center would be an important step toward police reform as the Minneapolis Police Department continues to recover following the murder of George Floyd.

Others, such as Council Members Soren Stevenson, Aisha Chughtai and Robin Wonsley, argue the funds could be invested in the community in other, more valuable ways.

Though the scale of the proposed Minneapolis facility is nowhere near that of Atlanta’s, the approach to addressing police brutality is similar. 

But is this really what MPD needs?

University of Minnesota law professor Amy Sweasy said police force policy varies across departments, many of which have changed in the wake of Floyd’s murder.

“Minneapolis, in particular, their police use of force policy in their policy manual has undergone significant revision since 2020,” Sweasy said. “Both as a result of the murder of George Floyd and the oversight of the court because of the consent decree that city entered into with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights.”

Reform and investigation efforts commenced almost immediately following Floyd’s death. In June 2020, the city and MDHR agreed to ban the use of chokeholds and mandate other policy changes through a temporary restraining order.

In the following years, MDHR conducted an investigation that identified a pattern of race-based discrimination and violence within MPD, reinforced by insufficient training, minimal accountability mechanisms and poor oversight from the city. An investigation from the U.S. Department of Justice yielded similar results.

The consent agreement Sweasy referenced, reached in 2023 by community members and police officers alike to address concerns from both parties, required MPD to make policy changes addressing race-based policing, designating an independent group to track their progress. 

Minneapolis completed the National Incident Management System Reset in 2024 to improve consistency, communication and training for emergency response situations.

“The number of deadly force incidents in Minnesota since 2020 has, with the exception of 2024, either stayed flat or gone down,” Sweasy said when discussing statistics from the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension that detail the number of deadly force incidents across the state.

Sweasy said she cannot speculate on what has caused these numbers to decrease or stay constant. Though any of the above reform measures could have factored into this, or possibly fewer encounters on the streets overall, the state’s strong response to the killings of Renée Good and Alex Pretti demonstrated the state’s thoughts on the issue, she added.

“What we saw here in January and the response of the community to Operation Metro Surge, it suggested to me that this community remains pretty sophisticated when it comes to these events and really understands what the issues and concerns are with the police use of force,” Sweasy said.

In considering the impact of Cop City in Atlanta, researchers from the Brookings Institution, along with stakeholders in Atlanta, St. Louis and Baltimore, emphasized the importance of community-based approaches to preventing police violence and tackling issues such as housing, poverty and discrimination that lead to crime in the first place. In this sense, Cop City can be understood within a militarized framework, rather than a public health approach to public safety.

And that’s not what we need in Minneapolis.

When we look at the factors leading to rising violence in Minneapolis, many are quick to point to the shrinking police presence since 2020. However, this perspective often ignores influences like increased unemployment, school closures and lingering racial inequities.

As Sweasy recognized, the Minneapolis community has consistently demonstrated a particular sensitivity to police violence. After two months of Operation Metro Surge, when thousands of federal officers flooded our streets and arrested more than 3,700 Minnesota residents, it’s hard to believe most Minnesotans would be looking for more militarization of our cities.

There are compelling reasons why the training facility could be valuable in maintaining the reforms passed since 2020. However, when considering the other ways this money could improve our communities, whether through building affordable housing or investing in public schools, it’s hard to believe this is the best option. 

And in a community with a demonstrated commitment to public engagement like Minneapolis, I think many of its residents would agree.

“I think this community knows a lot more about this kind of thing than they did in 2020,” Sweasy said. “And if you go back even further, 10 years before that, there’s always been a significant portion of community members who, for lots of valid reasons, have been more tuned into these issues.”

Whatever happens, Minneapolis is watching.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: In pursuit of community-centered public safety

Opinion: When reality TV stops being fun

When I wasn’t picking up extra shifts, sleeping in or playing Mario Kart on my family’s new Nintendo Switch, I spent my winter break catching up on the reality TV shows I missed during the fall semester.

I found myself especially drawn to “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” a show chronicling the lives of the sometimes-Mormon, sometimes-friends and sometimes-swinging community of Utah moms.

Along with my 14-year-old brother, who found himself just as morbidly curious as I was, I would sit on the couch, eyes glued and mouth agape, amazed at the inane decisions the people on my TV were making.

And to my continued amazement, much of the cast was completely sober. 

Yikes.

However, as the show went on, I started to feel uncomfortable with many of the storylines being presented as entertainment. Typical reality TV fare comprised most of the show’s drama, such as Whitney skipping Mayci’s business launch party in Season 1 or Taylor upset at the moms for not commenting on her post at the Country Music Association Awards in Season 2. However, some storylines center on the cast navigating highly sensitive topics from emotional abuse and sexual assault to suicidal ideation.

As these topics have played more of a role in the series, the emotional whiplash between such serious subjects with frivolous influencer drama has started to get to me. The show now feels less like fun reality antics and more like a psyop meant to show the dark side of the Mormon church and how religious organizations fail to protect women and children from exploitation.

All of this recently came to a head when a 2023 video involving the show’s star, Taylor Frankie Paul and her then-boyfriend, Dakota Mortensen, in a domestic violence incident published by TMZ last month. The news came right after filming paused on the show’s fifth season due to ongoing investigations into claims of domestic abuse from both Paul and Mortensen and before Paul’s season of “The Bachelorette” was set to premiere — ABC pulled the season after the video went viral.  

The disturbing content of the video was made worse by the presence of Paul’s children, who can be heard in the recording. 

With all of this coming to light, it begs the question: At what point does reality TV stop being entertaining and become exploitative?

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said part of the appeal of reality TV often stems from schadenfreude, or the pleasure viewers derive from the cast’s suffering.

“The point is to see people put into difficult situations,” DeFoster said. “And from the comfort of our couch to just have a laugh, you know?”

However, DeFoster said there are lines, especially for the show’s majority female audience.

“There’s a difference between having difficult, complex, dramatic interpersonal relationships among adults, but when it becomes child abuse or relational abuse, I think it’s very clear that this largely female audience is not going to accept that,” DeFoster said. “And I think that ‘The Bachelor’ producers know that about their audience.” 

There’s definitely something to be said about the swiftness with which ABC responded to these allegations, especially considering other media companies, specifically those with a male target audience, have been less willing to address concerns regarding stars.

“Chris Brown still has how many followers on Spotify?” DeFoster said. “I think there’s a lot more accountability in female-centric spaces for sure. Like we hold our heroes to a higher standard, period.”

However, this doesn’t explain how viewers were willing to accept this content in the context of the show. After all, the allegations against Paul were nothing new — the first episode of the show portrayed Paul being arrested for the incident depicted in the video. 

University communications doctoral student Emily Scroggins said audiences expect a level of sensationalism from reality TV, and it can be difficult to distinguish between the usual drama and the serious issues that arise.

“Specifically, the way that reality TV is edited is intentionally trying to get us to treat that level of drama or conflict or content with the same cognitive load,” Scroggins said. “So either we become overly critical, or we become not critical enough.”

The nature of reality also means there is content we don’t see. Last month, cast member Jessi Draper opened up on the podcast “Call Her Daddy” about her relationship with her husband Jordan Ngatikaura and their divorce. In the episode, she makes serious allegations of emotional and psychological abuse.

Although the narrative makes it clear their relationship was in a bad place during filming, to say the least, the extent of the allegations was shocking. It’s upsetting to think that viewers had been watching real people engaged in a toxic relationship for years as entertainment.

And I think that’s why this video feels so harrowing, beyond the disturbing content. Watching this woman in her darkest moment is a reminder that these are real people, real children, whose pain is being exploited for mass viewership. 

And that just isn’t fun.

I don’t think the answer here is turning away from reality TV altogether. But we should hold space for the realities of what we’re watching and engage critically with the content that gets presented to us. 

“Reminding ourselves as we’re watching these programs that this is something that’s produced,” Scroggins said. “This is something that has an intention behind it and going into it with a form of skepticism would be the best way to engage with reality TV.”

As this incident shows, you don’t always know what’s going on behind closed doors.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: When reality TV stops being fun

Opinion: When reality TV stops being fun

When I wasn’t picking up extra shifts, sleeping in or playing Mario Kart on my family’s new Nintendo Switch, I spent my winter break catching up on the reality TV shows I missed during the fall semester.

I found myself especially drawn to “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” a show chronicling the lives of the sometimes-Mormon, sometimes-friends and sometimes-swinging community of Utah moms.

Along with my 14-year-old brother, who found himself just as morbidly curious as I was, I would sit on the couch, eyes glued and mouth agape, amazed at the inane decisions the people on my TV were making.

And to my continued amazement, much of the cast was completely sober. 

Yikes.

However, as the show went on, I started to feel uncomfortable with many of the storylines being presented as entertainment. Typical reality TV fare comprised most of the show’s drama, such as Whitney skipping Mayci’s business launch party in Season 1 or Taylor upset at the moms for not commenting on her post at the Country Music Association Awards in Season 2. However, some storylines center on the cast navigating highly sensitive topics from emotional abuse and sexual assault to suicidal ideation.

As these topics have played more of a role in the series, the emotional whiplash between such serious subjects with frivolous influencer drama has started to get to me. The show now feels less like fun reality antics and more like a psyop meant to show the dark side of the Mormon church and how religious organizations fail to protect women and children from exploitation.

All of this recently came to a head when a 2023 video involving the show’s star, Taylor Frankie Paul and her then-boyfriend, Dakota Mortensen, in a domestic violence incident published by TMZ last month. The news came right after filming paused on the show’s fifth season due to ongoing investigations into claims of domestic abuse from both Paul and Mortensen and before Paul’s season of “The Bachelorette” was set to premiere — ABC pulled the season after the video went viral.  

The disturbing content of the video was made worse by the presence of Paul’s children, who can be heard in the recording. 

With all of this coming to light, it begs the question: At what point does reality TV stop being entertaining and become exploitative?

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said part of the appeal of reality TV often stems from schadenfreude, or the pleasure viewers derive from the cast’s suffering.

“The point is to see people put into difficult situations,” DeFoster said. “And from the comfort of our couch to just have a laugh, you know?”

However, DeFoster said there are lines, especially for the show’s majority female audience.

“There’s a difference between having difficult, complex, dramatic interpersonal relationships among adults, but when it becomes child abuse or relational abuse, I think it’s very clear that this largely female audience is not going to accept that,” DeFoster said. “And I think that ‘The Bachelor’ producers know that about their audience.” 

There’s definitely something to be said about the swiftness with which ABC responded to these allegations, especially considering other media companies, specifically those with a male target audience, have been less willing to address concerns regarding stars.

“Chris Brown still has how many followers on Spotify?” DeFoster said. “I think there’s a lot more accountability in female-centric spaces for sure. Like we hold our heroes to a higher standard, period.”

However, this doesn’t explain how viewers were willing to accept this content in the context of the show. After all, the allegations against Paul were nothing new — the first episode of the show portrayed Paul being arrested for the incident depicted in the video. 

University communications doctoral student Emily Scroggins said audiences expect a level of sensationalism from reality TV, and it can be difficult to distinguish between the usual drama and the serious issues that arise.

“Specifically, the way that reality TV is edited is intentionally trying to get us to treat that level of drama or conflict or content with the same cognitive load,” Scroggins said. “So either we become overly critical, or we become not critical enough.”

The nature of reality also means there is content we don’t see. Last month, cast member Jessi Draper opened up on the podcast “Call Her Daddy” about her relationship with her husband Jordan Ngatikaura and their divorce. In the episode, she makes serious allegations of emotional and psychological abuse.

Although the narrative makes it clear their relationship was in a bad place during filming, to say the least, the extent of the allegations was shocking. It’s upsetting to think that viewers had been watching real people engaged in a toxic relationship for years as entertainment.

And I think that’s why this video feels so harrowing, beyond the disturbing content. Watching this woman in her darkest moment is a reminder that these are real people, real children, whose pain is being exploited for mass viewership. 

And that just isn’t fun.

I don’t think the answer here is turning away from reality TV altogether. But we should hold space for the realities of what we’re watching and engage critically with the content that gets presented to us. 

“Reminding ourselves as we’re watching these programs that this is something that’s produced,” Scroggins said. “This is something that has an intention behind it and going into it with a form of skepticism would be the best way to engage with reality TV.”

As this incident shows, you don’t always know what’s going on behind closed doors.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: When reality TV stops being fun

Opinion: The case for working in a restaurant

On March 21, students across campus woke bright and early on what felt like the first day of spring, donning green T-shirts and shorts in preparation for a belated St. Patrick’s Day block party.

I rolled out of bed 45 minutes before my 11:15 a.m. shift, slipped on my work shoes, tied up my hair and dug through my laundry to find my last clean button-up shirt. As my roommates got ready for a day of bar-hopping and sunshine, I poured my coffee into my to-go mug, mentally preparing for 10 hours of “Can I start you off with anything to drink?” 

Such is the life of a college server.

Waiting tables as a student definitely has its downsides. When my friends with on-campus employment are enjoying their Friday nights getting dinner or seeing a movie, I’m stuck at the restaurant trying to figure out how to refill waters, bus appetizer plates, enter entrees and run food all in the next five minutes. 

And now my phone is blowing up with the group chats discussing plans for the party later. Great.

Despite this, my fellow servers and bartenders and I willingly sacrifice our weekends to the restaurant industry. Believe it or not, some of us actually enjoy it.

University of Minnesota third-year student Billy Rannells said they started serving when they decided to go back to college, due to the flexibility and high earning potential.

“It lets me prioritize school while still making enough money to pay rent and have money for things that I want to do,” Rannells said.

University alum and server for more than four years, Shane Andersen, echoed these motivations.

“It’s very flexible,” Andersen said. “Assuming your job is well-staffed, it usually is most of the time, I get the amount of hours I want.”

Never has it been easier to tailor my schedule to precisely when I want to work. And since the busiest shifts are at night, scheduling around class is never an issue.

But the benefits of restaurant work go beyond the flexibility and pay. Working in the hospitality industry has been a formative part of my college experience, shaping how I approach both my personal and professional lives.

The work ethic you must develop to be successful in a service industry job is enormous. When your income is directly tied to your job performance, you have an incentive to put in effort beyond the bare minimum.

Additionally, serving is a fundamentally social job that requires one to develop a heightened level of awareness. It’s your job to gain a sense of your table’s personality, the type of service they’re expecting and the pace they’re looking for, and provide that to them.

“The biggest thing about the restaurant industry that I have noted is the labor of managing people’s emotions,” Rannells said. “To me, that’s the hardest part of the job is managing the people in your section.”

The advanced understanding of social cues required for a restaurant job facilitates greater problem-solving, communication and empathy, and these skills are transferable to other industries.

This is especially important as Generation Z struggles to form connections with others compared to prior generations. 

Gen Z has reported higher levels of social anxiety and demonstrated worse verbal communication skills. The term “Gen Z stare,” referring to young workers’ habits of staring blankly at irritating or confusing customers, went viral in 2024 and epitomized this trend. 

Whether it’s because of COVID-19, political polarization or simply TikTok, it seems we just can’t handle difficult social situations like we used to.

On a personal level, working in a restaurant job forces me to hold sustained interactions with strangers, which has made an immeasurable difference in my abilities to hold conversations, resolve conflict and make genuine connections with others.

“You do meet a lot of people, not just, you know, your fellow employees, but like guests at the restaurants,” Rannells said. “I think that you establish that connection with people.”

Before I joined the industry, I had only heard the horror stories of rude guests who left frivolous complaints and meager tips. However, I was pleasantly surprised to find the vast majority of tables are lovely regular people trying to enjoy a pleasant dinner with family.

Andersen shared a story of one of the first tables he ever served.

“I was obviously talking really fast and very nervous,” Andersen said. “This guy was, like, ‘Hey man, I worked at a restaurant for like 10 years, you’re fine.’ It was actually a very heartening experience.”

Learning to be a good server is a difficult process, and I’m not sure I would have gotten through it if it weren’t for my guests who showed consistent kindness and grace as I adjusted to my role.

Despite the inherent stress of the job, serving in many ways has provided me with a respite from the pressures of university life.

College can be an incredibly insular environment. When you go to school, work and extracurriculars with people around your age, you can sometimes forget just how vast the real world is.

At the restaurant, where most of my coworkers and guests are adults, complete with mortgages, kids and retirement savings accounts, I often feel more grounded in reality. No one is worrying about finals or finding an internship. The only thing you have to care about is getting through your shift and providing the best service for your guests.

That being said, waitressing is not for everyone. It can be highly emotionally draining and requires excessive mental and physical stamina. I’d be lying if I said I didn’t occasionally long for a desk job where I could sit and do my homework.

But, at least for me, the drawbacks are far outweighed by the job’s unique ability to introduce me to new people and keep me grounded when college seems determined to drive me insane.

Just don’t ask me when my friend texts me what time I’ll be at Maddie’s party during a shift that genuinely feels like an episode of “The Bear.” I might have a very different perspective.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The case for working in a restaurant

Opinion: An ode to house parties

I shiver, taking off my glove to check the address. I’ve been to this house countless times, but I still need to pull out Google Maps to make sure I’m on the right street. 

Music blares all the way down the block as college students gather, ready to forget about their midterms, work drama and internship search, at least until they run out of chips.

The door is open when I arrive, and I can hear my name called as I hang up my jacket, always fashionably late, as I get off work at 9:30 p.m. 

I move into the kitchen to drop off the snacks I brought, smiling softly to myself. This is what I’ve been waiting for all week.  

The house party, characterized by Jello shots, beer pong and long lines to the bathroom, has been a staple of youth culture for decades. 

Despite this, the phenomenon of the house party, along with much of nightlife culture, may be on life support as Generation Z seems far less interested in going out, compared to generations before them. 

One Reddit thread went viral nine months ago when a Gen Zer asked whether the house parties depicted in 1990s and 2000s movies were ever actually a thing, prompting Gen Xers to share stories from the house parties of their youth. 

This paints a picture of a generation in dire need of a good rager. And I, along with plenty of students on campus, am committed to keeping house parties alive. 

University of Minnesota second-year student Nico Campo said these parties are important for fostering a strong campus environment.

“It promotes unity,” Campo said. “I think when you bring people together and you give them some good music, get them dancing on the floor, parties can be a beautiful thing.” 

As social media continues to dominate how we socialize, house parties serve as a reprieve. They encourage us to look up from our phones and engage with true community, often through the universal language of early 2010s pop hits.

University third-year student Hayden Diaz said house parties allow her to meet more people with similar interests than she would at a bar or club.

“I feel like it’s more of a curated crowd in a way,” Diaz said. “Not that everybody’s the same, but I talked to a couple people that had similar majors or interests, just because it’s like a friend or a friend of a friend.”

Second-year student Lily Tuttle said she enjoys hosting house parties because she can create a specific vibe, while at a bar, the music and people are selected for her.

“If something’s going wrong at the bar, if the mood is off, there’s not much you can do to change it,” Tuttle said. “Whereas at a house party, you can be the catalyst for anything like that.”

House parties, especially in the cramped homes lining Dinkytown and Como, promote an enhanced sense of familiarity compared to what you find in a bar. At a house party, you can see almost everyone at once and join any conversation. 

Especially when you’re familiar with other attendees, there’s an excitement in introducing your old friends to each other, guessing who will go home with whom and watching your best friend crash out when her situationship shows up unexpectedly, all in the course of one evening.

Well, maybe not that last one.

“I’m sure there’s a philosophy behind it, but it’s very intimate,” Tuttle said. “Being in a party is more intimate than, you know, going to a bar.”

For me, house parties also invite a level of spontaneity I rarely afford myself as I balance work, school and my extracurriculars. At a house party, surrounded by many of my closest friends, I feel more comfortable letting loose and acting impulsively. Even if that means making some mistakes along the way.

I mean, it’s for the lore, right?

First-year student Ben Noble once took three high school friends to a party hosted by his college friend, Kiara. Each made a goal for themselves for the evening. Noble’s friend Brady decided to get lost before the end of the night.

At one point, Noble’s other two friends stole spoons and ice cream from the kitchen and promptly ran away.

“I run down the street to go and find them,” Noble recalled. “I have no way to get back into the party, so Brady is, of course, lost.” 

Reflecting on the incident, Noble said it felt like a bonding moment, even if it left a stain on the evening.

“That one made Kiara really mad at me,” Noble said. “But it’s a great story that we talk about a lot, and it was really funny in the moment.”

For Valentine’s Day, my friend hosted a party at her place for the first time. Through a series of unfortunate events involving broken glass, several scraped knees and a frantic search for a purple jacket (it was actually a purse), I only stayed for an hour. 

On its face, the night may have appeared like a disaster. But I loved waking up in the morning, brewing coffee with my friend who crashed at my place and hearing the gossip from my roommate, my plus-one, who knew not a single person there but still managed to have the time of her life after I left without her.

More than anything, I remember laughing, thinking this could only happen in college.

While writing this piece, I went down a rabbit hole reading stories from the Reddit thread above. It was fascinating seeing just how much meaning a party can bring to the college experience. People shared stories of meeting friends and spouses and going on adventures and sidequests they will never forget.

In my two years at the University, parties have pulled me e out of my shell in a way I could not have imagined. I’ve made friends, heard new music, spilled food on myself a heinous number of times and made memories that will last far behind my time in Dinkytown.

So if you haven’t thrown or attended a house party yet, take this as your sign.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: An ode to house parties

Opinion: An ode to house parties

I shiver, taking off my glove to check the address. I’ve been to this house countless times, but I still need to pull out Google Maps to make sure I’m on the right street. 

Music blares all the way down the block as college students gather, ready to forget about their midterms, work drama and internship search, at least until they run out of chips.

The door is open when I arrive, and I can hear my name called as I hang up my jacket, always fashionably late, as I get off work at 9:30 p.m. 

I move into the kitchen to drop off the snacks I brought, smiling softly to myself. This is what I’ve been waiting for all week.  

The house party, characterized by Jello shots, beer pong and long lines to the bathroom, has been a staple of youth culture for decades. 

Despite this, the phenomenon of the house party, along with much of nightlife culture, may be on life support as Generation Z seems far less interested in going out, compared to generations before them. 

One Reddit thread went viral nine months ago when a Gen Zer asked whether the house parties depicted in 1990s and 2000s movies were ever actually a thing, prompting Gen Xers to share stories from the house parties of their youth. 

This paints a picture of a generation in dire need of a good rager. And I, along with plenty of students on campus, am committed to keeping house parties alive. 

University of Minnesota second-year student Nico Campo said these parties are important for fostering a strong campus environment.

“It promotes unity,” Campo said. “I think when you bring people together and you give them some good music, get them dancing on the floor, parties can be a beautiful thing.” 

As social media continues to dominate how we socialize, house parties serve as a reprieve. They encourage us to look up from our phones and engage with true community, often through the universal language of early 2010s pop hits.

University third-year student Hayden Diaz said house parties allow her to meet more people with similar interests than she would at a bar or club.

“I feel like it’s more of a curated crowd in a way,” Diaz said. “Not that everybody’s the same, but I talked to a couple people that had similar majors or interests, just because it’s like a friend or a friend of a friend.”

Second-year student Lily Tuttle said she enjoys hosting house parties because she can create a specific vibe, while at a bar, the music and people are selected for her.

“If something’s going wrong at the bar, if the mood is off, there’s not much you can do to change it,” Tuttle said. “Whereas at a house party, you can be the catalyst for anything like that.”

House parties, especially in the cramped homes lining Dinkytown and Como, promote an enhanced sense of familiarity compared to what you find in a bar. At a house party, you can see almost everyone at once and join any conversation. 

Especially when you’re familiar with other attendees, there’s an excitement in introducing your old friends to each other, guessing who will go home with whom and watching your best friend crash out when her situationship shows up unexpectedly, all in the course of one evening.

Well, maybe not that last one.

“I’m sure there’s a philosophy behind it, but it’s very intimate,” Tuttle said. “Being in a party is more intimate than, you know, going to a bar.”

For me, house parties also invite a level of spontaneity I rarely afford myself as I balance work, school and my extracurriculars. At a house party, surrounded by many of my closest friends, I feel more comfortable letting loose and acting impulsively. Even if that means making some mistakes along the way.

I mean, it’s for the lore, right?

First-year student Ben Noble once took three high school friends to a party hosted by his college friend, Kiara. Each made a goal for themselves for the evening. Noble’s friend Brady decided to get lost before the end of the night.

At one point, Noble’s other two friends stole spoons and ice cream from the kitchen and promptly ran away.

“I run down the street to go and find them,” Noble recalled. “I have no way to get back into the party, so Brady is, of course, lost.” 

Reflecting on the incident, Noble said it felt like a bonding moment, even if it left a stain on the evening.

“That one made Kiara really mad at me,” Noble said. “But it’s a great story that we talk about a lot, and it was really funny in the moment.”

For Valentine’s Day, my friend hosted a party at her place for the first time. Through a series of unfortunate events involving broken glass, several scraped knees and a frantic search for a purple jacket (it was actually a purse), I only stayed for an hour. 

On its face, the night may have appeared like a disaster. But I loved waking up in the morning, brewing coffee with my friend who crashed at my place and hearing the gossip from my roommate, my plus-one, who knew not a single person there but still managed to have the time of her life after I left without her.

More than anything, I remember laughing, thinking this could only happen in college.

While writing this piece, I went down a rabbit hole reading stories from the Reddit thread above. It was fascinating seeing just how much meaning a party can bring to the college experience. People shared stories of meeting friends and spouses and going on adventures and sidequests they will never forget.

In my two years at the University, parties have pulled me e out of my shell in a way I could not have imagined. I’ve made friends, heard new music, spilled food on myself a heinous number of times and made memories that will last far behind my time in Dinkytown.

So if you haven’t thrown or attended a house party yet, take this as your sign.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: An ode to house parties