Opinion: When reality TV stops being fun

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

When I wasn’t picking up extra shifts, sleeping in or playing Mario Kart on my family’s new Nintendo Switch, I spent my winter break catching up on the reality TV shows I missed during the fall semester.

I found myself especially drawn to “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” a show chronicling the lives of the sometimes-Mormon, sometimes-friends and sometimes-swinging community of Utah moms.

Along with my 14-year-old brother, who found himself just as morbidly curious as I was, I would sit on the couch, eyes glued and mouth agape, amazed at the inane decisions the people on my TV were making.

And to my continued amazement, much of the cast was completely sober. 

Yikes.

However, as the show went on, I started to feel uncomfortable with many of the storylines being presented as entertainment. Typical reality TV fare comprised most of the show’s drama, such as Whitney skipping Mayci’s business launch party in Season 1 or Taylor upset at the moms for not commenting on her post at the Country Music Association Awards in Season 2. However, some storylines center on the cast navigating highly sensitive topics from emotional abuse and sexual assault to suicidal ideation.

As these topics have played more of a role in the series, the emotional whiplash between such serious subjects with frivolous influencer drama has started to get to me. The show now feels less like fun reality antics and more like a psyop meant to show the dark side of the Mormon church and how religious organizations fail to protect women and children from exploitation.

All of this recently came to a head when a 2023 video involving the show’s star, Taylor Frankie Paul and her then-boyfriend, Dakota Mortensen, in a domestic violence incident published by TMZ last month. The news came right after filming paused on the show’s fifth season due to ongoing investigations into claims of domestic abuse from both Paul and Mortensen and before Paul’s season of “The Bachelorette” was set to premiere — ABC pulled the season after the video went viral.  

The disturbing content of the video was made worse by the presence of Paul’s children, who can be heard in the recording. 

With all of this coming to light, it begs the question: At what point does reality TV stop being entertaining and become exploitative?

University of Minnesota assistant professor of media and popular culture Ruth DeFoster said part of the appeal of reality TV often stems from schadenfreude, or the pleasure viewers derive from the cast’s suffering.

“The point is to see people put into difficult situations,” DeFoster said. “And from the comfort of our couch to just have a laugh, you know?”

However, DeFoster said there are lines, especially for the show’s majority female audience.

“There’s a difference between having difficult, complex, dramatic interpersonal relationships among adults, but when it becomes child abuse or relational abuse, I think it’s very clear that this largely female audience is not going to accept that,” DeFoster said. “And I think that ‘The Bachelor’ producers know that about their audience.” 

There’s definitely something to be said about the swiftness with which ABC responded to these allegations, especially considering other media companies, specifically those with a male target audience, have been less willing to address concerns regarding stars.

“Chris Brown still has how many followers on Spotify?” DeFoster said. “I think there’s a lot more accountability in female-centric spaces for sure. Like we hold our heroes to a higher standard, period.”

However, this doesn’t explain how viewers were willing to accept this content in the context of the show. After all, the allegations against Paul were nothing new — the first episode of the show portrayed Paul being arrested for the incident depicted in the video. 

University communications doctoral student Emily Scroggins said audiences expect a level of sensationalism from reality TV, and it can be difficult to distinguish between the usual drama and the serious issues that arise.

“Specifically, the way that reality TV is edited is intentionally trying to get us to treat that level of drama or conflict or content with the same cognitive load,” Scroggins said. “So either we become overly critical, or we become not critical enough.”

The nature of reality also means there is content we don’t see. Last month, cast member Jessi Draper opened up on the podcast “Call Her Daddy” about her relationship with her husband Jordan Ngatikaura and their divorce. In the episode, she makes serious allegations of emotional and psychological abuse.

Although the narrative makes it clear their relationship was in a bad place during filming, to say the least, the extent of the allegations was shocking. It’s upsetting to think that viewers had been watching real people engaged in a toxic relationship for years as entertainment.

And I think that’s why this video feels so harrowing, beyond the disturbing content. Watching this woman in her darkest moment is a reminder that these are real people, real children, whose pain is being exploited for mass viewership. 

And that just isn’t fun.

I don’t think the answer here is turning away from reality TV altogether. But we should hold space for the realities of what we’re watching and engage critically with the content that gets presented to us. 

“Reminding ourselves as we’re watching these programs that this is something that’s produced,” Scroggins said. “This is something that has an intention behind it and going into it with a form of skepticism would be the best way to engage with reality TV.”

As this incident shows, you don’t always know what’s going on behind closed doors.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-when-reality-tv-stops-being-fun/04/02/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily