Opinion: More ‘this is the place’ and less ‘I hate this place’

 

University of Utah football is playing an incredible season. Under the renewed direction of head coach Morgan Scalley, the Utes are flying high and shattering expectations. However, the toughest opponent the Utes have faced arguably hasn’t been on the field, but over the airwaves. Following his visit to Utah with ESPN College GameDay, host Pat McAfee has taken umbrage with the U, even claiming to “hate” the university. McAfee’s tirade against the U has catalyzed a coalition of college football fans against his overdramatic antics, but the damage was done.

The U is not the nasty, hateful and dangerous place McAfee claims it to be and College GameDay should apologize for the fiasco he initiated.

A crime against primetime?

McAfee is one of ESPN’s top dogs. He has spearheaded a change in College GameDay’s direction since his addition in 2023, coinciding with ever-increasing viewership.

However, being a trusted figure on national TV means McAfee owes some level of responsibility to the public. Part of this should include not leveraging his platform to needlessly badmouth defenseless universities. Which is exactly what he did when GameDay came to the U on October 24.

McAfee responded poorly to a lighthearted video produced by the U which lightly prodded at his larger-than-life persona. One student made a lighthearted impression, while another questioned McAfee’s longtime practice of disrobing his shirt before a thunderous crowd. 

McAfee’s signature field-goal kicking contest the following day heightened the uncomfortable tension between the ESPN host and the student body. The kicks, duds, went further awry when the student kicker chided McAfee for offering only $1 million as a prize.

Football faux pas

Certainly the students in the video meant no ill will towards the host. On the contrary, they were filmed in an overnight line for a chance to see McAfee live the next morning. McAfee’s whole brand is to poke fun at others, and by doing a little poking themselves, students expressed affection. Plus, a little bravado from students with a top-ranked team on game day eve should be forgivable. As for the kicker, what she said was inappropriate, but not unforgivable. Surely the adults in the room could withstand a little ribbing.

But McAfee did not choose to see things this way, going so far as to invoke Charlie Kirk’s murder in bizarre remarks made on his own show the following Monday.

“The university puts that out? Like as I’m about to go out and do an infomercial for the place? And then I’m walking in front of thousands of these people. This is how the university feels about it? It’s an uncomfortable feeling,” McAfee said. “I thought to myself, has anything, like, really scary happened at a college gathering in the state of Utah recently? Do we think we should be amplifying reasons for why people hate my guts, as a university? I don’t know. There was a lot of mixed feelings for me going out there, and then obviously the kicker goes, ‘Only $1 million?’ It’s like, all right, I hate this place. I hate this place.”

McAfee’s strange, mercurial reaction to the U’s reception of him quickly elicited unconditional apologies from both the U and ESPN. McAfee is nonetheless being a little dramatic. However, his comments could have wide-ranging negative consequences for the U.

The many hues of U

U students are certainly not absolved of all blame. Undoubtedly, the kicker’s comments before her ill-fated attempts cast the student body in a bad light and whether or not McAfee’s shirt stays on is none of anybody’s business. However, it was unbecoming of McAfee to elevate these annoyances to the extremes that he did. 

His words misrepresent the U as a dangerous, second-rate GameDay stop and an ‘avoid’ for Big 12 fans. On the contrary, the U is one of the best places to go to school on the Wasatch Front.

McAfee’s comments paint an inaccurate picture of the school, which could deter enrollment. They could also potentially wreak havoc on innocent students, including those behind the camera of the ill-fated GameDay video.

Further stoking the flames of the fiasco is that McAfee seems to be applying a double standard here. His GameDay trip to Provo the week before the ill-fated Utah visit was very, very gushy. McAfee’s overtures to the team down south even extended to being deemed ‘Brother Pat’ by the end of the morning.

However, polling by Y2 Analytics found the average respondent feels more of these warm, fuzzy feelings towards the U rather than BYU. Furthermore, the U also consistently ranks below national bellwethers of all kinds of harassment. This makes the alleged uncomfortable environment McAfee observed at Utah all the more doubtful.

Now that he’s ‘Brother’ Pat, there are several brotherly ways McAfee can make amends to the U. One way would be through a GameDay apology tour.

College GameDay should make amends

College GameDay has a unique opportunity to make amends by highlighting what a great place the U is to be at. 

The U is in the top 7% of the world’s best universities and is a globally ranked research institution.  The 2025 Student Affairs Annual Report found that 87% of students reported feeling a sense of belonging at the U. 84% expressed a strong sense of community in their lives. College GameDay can clear the air around McAfee’s comments towards the school by highlighting these aspects in a future program.

Perhaps McAfee or another host could receive a guided tour or extended look at the U’s community, campus and classes. In front of a national audience, this could fix any damage done and paint a more holistic picture of who we really are.

The U’s a great place to be

U fans are no strangers to nasty, unfair criticism of their program. At the GameDay event in question, McAfee was dismissive of the Utes, claiming “Utah hasn’t had to play anybody yet.” BYU Quarterback Max Hall once famously called the U and its fans “classless”. Another BYU player, defensive lineman Lenny Gomes, said of the U in 1993, “they’re low-class losers. When I’m making $50,000 to $60,000 a year, they’ll be pumping my gas.”

College GameDay and the U can show that our community is more than the box they’ve put us in.

 

n.wright@dailyutahchronicle.com

@saximusprime

The post Opinion: More ‘this is the place’ and less ‘I hate this place’ appeared first on The Daily Utah Chronicle.

Read more here: https://dailyutahchronicle.com/2026/11/20/opinion-more-this-is-the-place-and-less-i-hate-this-place/
Copyright 2026