U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth released the decision to publicly livestream Nidal Malik Hasan’s execution by firing squad, the man responsible for killing 13 people in the Fort Hood shooting in Nov. 2009. His execution is set for Dec. 3rd 2026.
It’s hard to grasp that the conversation involving the modern public execution in America would even be a question today. The last public execution in the US was held almost 100 years ago. Our values should have greatly evolved since then.
President Donald Trump had previously voiced his endorsement for the public streaming of the execution; however, after intense backlash, the decision to livestream it has since been revoked. Trump reasoned in a social media post on X, “many very good and well meaning people would rather not watch him die, through streaming, or through any other visual device.”
Though the execution will no longer be livestreamed, the decision to stream it in the first place has left a stain on our country’s reputation.
Sydney Moneke, a third year political science major at the University of Oregon, holds strong opinions on capital punishment to begin with, however the integration of livestreaming adds much more. “I’m firstly, certainly anti-death penalty. I don’t think we should be punishing people’s crimes in the form of another crime. Secondly, I don’t think that us as a free country livestreaming an execution really sets a great precedent,” Moneke said.
Hegseth’ made the decision to publicly livestream essentially to send a message out to scare people out of doing anything similar. “There’s serious consequences for these types of things,” Hegseth said in an interview on Real America’s Voice.
However, there is no evidence that the death penalty, as opposed to a life sentence, actually deters crime at all. States with no death penalty actually have much lower murder rates than those with the death penalty as reported by the Death Penalty Information Center.
It’s clear that our country just wanted to make a spectacle out of a human being’s death.
This choice to publicize an execution might have done the exact opposite in deterring future crime. Steven Brence, a professor of Philosophy at the University of Oregon said, “You risk providing radical Islamic groups fodder for propaganda, because you have this image of an Arab concerned with wars in Muslim countries being shot and killed by a firing squad.”
Punishing an awful crime with another awful crime isn’t a good look, and making a public display of it doesn’t make it look better either.
“Not a pretty sight. It could definitely serve as a harmful function in making Hasan a martyr,” Brence said.
It seems this decision would have done no good at all, as it did irreversible harm to our county’s reputation, and would have likely done harm to whoever chose to watch it. “Livestreaming an execution could cause post-traumatic stress disorder in the viewing public…Experts said watching the event could result in lasting harm for viewers,” The Guardian wrote.
“I am pleased that it’s not going to happen; in some ways I’m delighted by the whole thing because it sort of exposes the depravity and some of the core commitments and understanding of what this administration has of human nature. Politicians deliberately use fear to control the population. We head more in that direction all the time.” Brence said.
The death penalty is a breach of human rights to begin with; the government wanting to make a spectacle of this cruelty is very telling of how far they are willing to go.
The post Gaviglio: Public execution shouldn’t even be in the conversation appeared first on Daily Emerald.