Boston Dynamics sells robot dogs to ICE, faces internal backlash

Over 300 Boston Dynamics employees sent an open letter to company executives Sept. 8, urging them to reconsider the sale of four “Spot” dogs — the company’s canine-like robots — to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

Boston Dynamics’s robotic dog, Spot. Over 300 Boston Dynamics employees wrote to company executives, urging them to reconsider the sale of four “Spot” dogs to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in September. (COURTESY OF BOSTON DYNAMICS)

In late August, ICE posted a procurement notice saying it intended to purchase the Spot robots for $1.3 million. The announcement immediately drew backlash from employees, who put forth a petition to stop the sale. 

“BD’s proposed sale to ICE threatens that pride in our work, since this deal presents us as working directly with ICE,” the letter read. “We cannot be proud of working at BD when that work is being used by a government agency that brutalizes civilians, including some of our own colleagues at Hyundai.” 

BD is owned by Hyundai, which faced 2025 ICE raids in a Georgia factory resulting in the detention of more than 300 workers. Several workers later filed administrative claims against several federal agencies claiming the detentions were unlawful. 

The company told employees it heard their complaints about “wanting more advance notice and context regarding potentially controversial deals” in the future, but would not cancel the sale to ICE. 

“We consider this decision final, and it’s time to move forward,” interim CEO Amanda McMaster wrote in an email to all named petitioners.

ICE said it plans to deploy the robots in tunnels to prevent human trafficking and drug smuggling. The Spot dogs, which are equipped with cameras and can climb stairs, will be an additional safety tool that does not replace human judgment, according to ICE. 

Executives hosted several internal ethics roundtables providing employees additional information on how the robots would be used, after which some changed their perspectives on the issue, a BD spokesperson wrote in a statement to The Daily Free Press. 

However, employees’ concerns regarding ICE may not be so easily quelled. Employees wrote in the petition that many of them had received messages from friends and family, “asking [them] in disbelief and horror if this news is true, and how [they] can live with [themselves] if it is.”

BD called the Spot robots “potentially life-saving tools,” and said the robots are being used to keep people out of harm’s way. 

“We believe this decision is in line with our purpose of ethically advancing intelligent machines in service of humanity,” McMaster wrote. 

But intent may not always match execution, said Robin Nice, an immigration attorney at McHaffey and Nice Law Firm. The dogs create “the possibility for greater harm and violence against immigrants,” Nice said.

While the robots themselves are not weapons, Nice said they are powerful because their owners can upload new information and skills to them. 

“They are not old dogs, and they can be taught new tricks,” Nice said. 

For Emmylou Manwill, a Boston University law professor, purchasing the Spot dogs appears to be an expansion of the ICE’s dragnet surveillance — the systemic, constant surveillance of a large population.

Manwill said she worries substituting robots for humans will remove accountability from the agency’s actions. 

“We’ve seen a similar parallel in the use of drones in warfare,” Manwill said. “Once you’re removed from being there with boots on the ground, it’s harder to see what’s happening and harder to follow the chain of command and see who was in charge for decisions.”

Ananya Potlapalli, a public service fellow with Rian Immigrant Center, said the prospect of being detained without direct human authorization is a huge source of concern for her clients. Many have already become wary of simple technologies such as phone calls over fear of being surveilled. 

“Whether that’s because people wear coverings, or not having body [cameras] … there’s already been a difficulty figuring out who’s doing what,” Potlapalli said. “If you then turn over that responsibility to automation, or something that isn’t a person they can hold accountable, it becomes even harder.”

Records show BD has contracted with federal security forces for years, including the Coast Guard, Secret Service and other bureaus under the DHS. According to the company’s website, BD maintains control over its product after a sale closes by controlling software updates, warranties and licensing. 

Nice described the usage of Spot dogs as “removing humanity by one extra step.” 

“It removes the potential culpability, whether legal or otherwise, by saying, ‘Well, it wasn’t me. It wasn’t a masked agent even, it was this robot dog,’” Nice said.

Read more here: https://dailyfreepress.com/11/05/18/222233/boston-dynamics-sells-robot-dogs-to-ice-faces-internal-backlash/
Copyright 2026