St. Louis CITY SC made history on Oct. 21 after defeating the Columbus Crew in a penalty shootout to win the 2026 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup and secure the first trophy in the club’s history.
After 120 minutes without a goal at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field in Columbus, Ohio, CITY SC prevailed 5-3 in the shootout, converting all five attempts to claim the championship. The victory marks a major milestone for a club that began competing in Major League Soccer in 2023.
The match’s decisive moment came from goalkeeper Ben Lundt, who entered the second half after captain Roman Bürki was forced off with a head injury caused by a collision with Crew winger Anass Zaroury. Lundt saved Columbus midfielder Santiago Rodríguez’s opening penalty, giving St. Louis an early advantage in the shootout.
CITY capitalized on the opportunity as Timo Baumgartl, Lukas MacNaughton, Chris Durkin and Damion Downs all converted their attempts before Daniel Edelman stepped up to take the decisive fifth penalty. Edelman powerfully sent his shot into the back of the net, securing the victory.
The successful shootout capped a somewhat stagnant and difficult night for CITY’s attack. Columbus controlled much of the match, limiting St. Louis to five shots while producing 16 of its own. Despite the difference in attacking opportunities, CITY held firm and kept the Crew off the scoreboard through extra time.
Bürki’s departure added another obstacle for St. Louis. Before his injury, the longtime team captain had been instrumental in keeping the match scoreless, making several critical saves during Columbus’ strongest attacking stretches. Lundt, however, delivered when the match reached its decisive moments, preserving the clean sheet and giving CITY the opportunity to win its first trophy.
The championship carries significance for a city with a long history in American soccer. CITY became the 11th club from St. Louis to win the U.S. Open Cup, with the city’s previous champion being the Busch Seniors in 1988.
The title also provides a significant achievement for a relatively young MLS franchise. CITY’s inaugural season in 2023 saw the club finish first in the Western Conference, which ignited new audiences of support and drew high attendance from the very beginning. The Open Cup victory now gives that history its first major piece of silverware.
The championship comes with another reward. By winning the tournament, St. Louis qualified for the 2027 Concacaf Champions Cup, returning to the continental competition for the first time since 2024.
For CITY, the victory establishes the club as a champion and adds a new chapter to St. Louis’ soccer history, bringing a trophy back to a city that has waited nearly four decades to celebrate another U.S. Open Cup winner.