As a villain origin story, “Clayface” isn’t a new concept. Films focused on the villains of major heroes, showing their tragic backstories and meteoric rises to power, have existed for some time now. Unlike previous DC villain origin stories like 2018’s “Venom” or 2022’s “Black Adam,” this movie actually manages to be somewhat interesting.
“Clayface,” directed by James Watkins, follows up-and-coming actor Matt Hagen, played by Tom Rhys Harries, who crosses the wrong mob boss. The consequences of this betrayal leave him horribly disfigured and cause him to have a massive fall from grace, losing his friends, home and all of his money until he is a shell of man hiding in the Gotham Narrows.
This all changes when he meets the genius scientist Dr. Caitlin Corr, played by Naomi Ackie, who has developed an intelligent but untested synthetic skin layer able to repair extreme damage. He takes advantage of her kindness to use the technology in sinister ways.
The writers, Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, made a wise decision in bringing the story into the modern era, despite the villain’s origins being in the 1940. While some may find the “evil artificial intelligence” gambit a tad formulaic, the creators make it clear that many of the actions done in the film are Hagen’s own and he’s never really being controlled by anything more powerful.
Rhys Harries shines as Hagen, giving the Batman villain some very special depth. Audiences are able to see how Hagen slowly morphs into the more villainous Clayface. Watkins shows Hagen being abandoned by everyone around him and attempting to regain control, which only amplifies his anger and hatred. One very powerful scene is when Hagen first discovers the ability to shapeshift and begins blurring the lines between himself and those he is pretending to be.
The biggest draw of the film is the final third, once Hagen has completed his transformation into a grotesque creature, both inside and outside. There is an extremely fun, high energy night club scene where he is using his powers to their fullest extent, and you’re never truly sure what’s real. There is a great cast of characters jumping all around with a fun use of music and camera shifts to keep the event extremely exciting and engaging.
The film is not without its flaws. Like many origin stories, it takes a long time to get things started, despite jumping straight into the plot. We have to crawl through the phase where Hagen learns how his powers work and see him slowly become his villainous self. But once “Clayface” starts, the action doesn’t stop. Despite the best part of the film being the last third, the first parts are still rather interesting and still managed to be fascinating and well-acted enough to keep the audience engaged until the major events of the finale.
The most disappointing thing about “Clayface” is that it just isn’t scary. Despite being written by Flanagan, a veteran horror director and creator of hit shows like “The Haunting of Hill House” and “Midnight Mass,” the film fails to deliver the scariness it and its marketing promise. Most of the twists are clear from a mile away, and the lack of jump-scares or disconcerting music really make the horror elements seem underwhelming.
Overall, “Clayface” is a fun but scare-free action drama with compelling acting from Rhys Harries that takes a second to get going, but will still leave viewers satisfied and excited to see where Hagen goes next, which is a rather good sign for the DCU given the poorer reactions to “Supergirl” last summer.