UO researchers discover gaps in mobile crisis services

Originally Posted on Daily Emerald via UWIRE

The departure of Crisis Assistance Helping Out On The Streets in Eugene in 2025 has led to major gaps in services, according to University of Oregon researchers who discovered the underestimation of its impact on the city.

CAHOOTS was a mobile crisis service that stopped operating from Eugene in April 2025 due to financial issues, after 36 years in the city. The service still operates in Springfield, responding to non-emergency calls, providing transportation and a mobile crisis response as an alternative to a police response. CAHOOTS also helps de-escalate situations, provides immediate support or transportation and diverts calls from the police.

However, its exit from Eugene left many unfilled gaps in the city’s alternative response system.

“It seems like there’s still a lot of discussion in the city about, ‘How are we going to move forward and how do we want different agencies to fill this gap in services?’” Rori Rohlfs, researcher and associate professor in data science at UO, said.

Ideal Option

The City of Eugene selected Ideal Option in April 2026 to run a year-long peer navigation pilot program to fill those gaps with non-emergency support and services. Peer navigators from Ideal Option have been in downtown Eugenesince January 2026 as a separate downtown program.

The new Peer Navigation Pilot Program with Ideal Option is intended to provide services like welfare checks, non-emergency transport, proactive outreach and preventing situations from escalating. Its goal is centered on improving the community’s wellbeing, providing help for those in need and reducing pressure on emergency responders.

Ideal Option’s peer navigator contract cost roughly $250,000, and the city later allocated $500,000 for the alternative response program outside downtown Eugene, focusing on areas in West Eugene, Highway 99, River Road and the Whiteaker Neighborhood.

Its peer navigators are community members trained in trauma-informed care and crisis intervention, and have experienced challenges likely faced by clients. They help address the root cause of repeated calls for service by coordinating access to medical care, housing, treatment and judicial support.

Since launching the program in January, the city announced that nearly 250 clients completed 728 goals towards stabilization.

Issues since CAHOOTS’s exit

UO researchers in data science and sociology found CAHOOTS diverted 23% of calls that would have otherwise gone to the Eugene Police Department and rose to 50% for calls that were mutually answerable by both EPD and CAHOOTS.

“I think it’s really important to do this quantitative research to be like, ‘What even happened and what was the impact of CAHOOTS stopping services?’” Rohlfs said.

Arrest rates from emergency calls have since increased after CAHOOTS’s exit from Eugene and EPD is spending double the amount of staff time on calls that were previously answered by CAHOOTS.

Welfare check services have also decreased between EPD and Mobile Crisis Services of Lane County, a program that provides crisis de-escalation, transportation coordination and more services for people experiencing immediate behavioral health crises.

While MCS-LC does not directly provide general welfare checks, Ideal Option does and is designed to minimize police involvement. However, Claire Herbert, researcher and associate professor in sociology, said her understanding is Ideal Option’s calls may be mediated by police and the decline in calls may be attributed to residents not knowing who to call in certain situations.

Herbert recalled an experience in which she saw an individual walking down the street without pants and talking to themself. But when she called MCS-LC, she was told to call the police, which she did not want to do, as it could have further escalated the situation.

“Residents here have this really long history of knowing this is a CAHOOTS call, and if we call police, it could get worse, so I’m not going to call at all,” Herbert said. “That could explain the drop in calls for welfare checks.”

In a research paper by Rohlfs, Herbert and Nathan Burton, Herbert said their theory to explain the increase in escalated call types and arrest rates is that CAHOOTS responded to concerns when they were low level and prevented situations from escalating into police responses.

Herbert added that Eugene residents could hesitate to call MCS-LC due to their lack of familiarity with the program and because MCS-LC primarily responds to behavioral or mental health crises. In some cases, like Herbert’s, being directed to call the police could be disadvantageous.

“Eugene residents, in interviews as part of another project, have shared not wanting to call police for problems that they would previously call CAHOOTS for because in their mind, they’re like, ‘This is not a police call and calling the police could do more harm than good,’” Herbert said.

The city will collect data throughout Ideal Option’s yearlong pilot program in order to determine if additional investment is needed and how that should be carried out.

Researchers will continue analyzing the impacts of CAHOOTS’s absence from Eugene and awaiting the city’s future decisions with peer navigation services.

“The thing that I can really speak to professionally is that these have all been pretty clear negative impacts of CAHOOTS going out of service,” Rohlfs said. “And what’s the solution? Hopefully providing more CAHOOTS-like services in Eugene.”

Ideal Option did not respond to multiple interview requests from The Daily Emerald.

The post UO researchers discover gaps in mobile crisis services appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Read more here: https://dailyemerald.com/193334/news/uo-researchers-discover-gaps-in-mobile-crisis-services/
Copyright 2026 Daily Emerald