“Her green plastic watering can…”
So begins “Fake Plastic Trees,” Radiohead’s legendary 1995 rock ballad about a world composed of — well, plastic. As anyone familiar with the song well knows, its lyrics abound with mentions of the synthetic: a “fake Chinese rubber plant,” a “cracked polystyrene man,” the narrator’s “fake plastic love.” Far from decorative, imagery like this poignantly mines one of our society’s most intense phobias — that of the unreal, imitative, or transient — to convey the tragedy of holding onto people who’d rather not hold onto us.

But how fair is that phobia? Not very, it turns out.
Consider arguably the most ordinary thing it stigmatizes: consumer plastics. Besides there — unsurprisingly — being zero studies estimating the causal effect of dosing a human with plastic particles, what few observational studies exist turn up a fairly prosaic picture. According to one recent review, for instance, 32 case-control and 11 cohort studies encompassing over a million patients found virtually zero evidence that microplastics elevate overall cancer risk or mortality.
The lone exception to this rule was lung cancer, which exactly one study found could predict one’s level of exposure to phthalates — a chemical additive used in plastics, rather than plastic particles themselves. But that study worked backward, looking at people who either did or didn’t have lung cancer and checking their exposure before the fact. When researchers instead monitored healthy controls over time to see if cancer developed, the link between cancer and plastics ultimately vanished.
A similarly nuanced story emerges when we account for plastic’s environmental impact. Assuming it weighs eight grams, a standard plastic bag only takes 0.6 megajoules of energy to produce. By contrast, a standard cotton bag requires 17.5 megajoules. This disparity partly explains the United Kingdom Environment Agency’s finding that a cotton bag would have to be reused 131 times in order to break even with a plastic bag’s carbon footprint — a figure which grows by 131 every time the plastic bag itself gets reused.
But what about pollution? Here as elsewhere, it’s all too easy to miss the forest for the trees. As study after study has shown, a supermajority of ocean plastic originates from a remarkably small number of the Earth’s rivers. These rivers, in turn, cluster among a tiny minority of nations — India, the Philippines, Brazil, Indonesia — where plastic pollution is often downstream of poorly funded waste management systems, permissive cultural attitudes toward littering or both.
All of which is to say that plastic is rarely as problematic as factors that seldom see the light of the press. On the other hand, once we consider the things plastic is certain to enable by virtue of its chemical properties — its malleability, sterility, durability — the sign of its presumed costs flips. Worried about public health? Good luck managing without plastic-derived IV bags, dialysis machines and surgical tools. Concerned for the planet? Nearly all environmental sensors depend on some kind of polymer to function properly.
Of course, these uses are just a subset of plastic’s full resume. Inspecting that resume with even a minimal degree of focus highlights accomplishments more extensive than arguably any other technology: prolonging the shelf life of food via airtight packaging, insulating electrical wiring so it can safely transport energy, shielding water pipes from corrosion, enabling the construction of housing. As a rule, if you rely on it, it relies on plastic.
And maybe that needn’t be such a bad thing. As noted earlier, we often discount the value of an object or experience if it fails to deliver what we expect from the “real thing.” Indeed, this is famously the exact wording used by the final verse of “Fake Plastic Trees”:
“She looks like the real thing / She tastes like the real thing / My fake plastic love”
Less well known, however, is the lyric which immediately follows: “But I can’t help the feeling.” However fake or plastic the object of his affection, the pull our narrator feels toward her is real as can be. As a result, the synthetic alternative gives him an animating impulse — a highly imperfect one that may leave him feeling worn out, sure, but one nonetheless.
In case it wasn’t clear, the point here isn’t that the synthetic is always better than the genuine, but rather the opposite: the genuine isn’t always better than the synthetic. Whether because it demands more from us, fails to do what we need or — perhaps most common of all — simply can’t be attained, the “real thing” often can’t live up to its stated promise. And that hurts. But it almost never means that we can’t still make do.