On Sept.4, news broke that Lindsay Clancy, infamously on trial for strangling her three children in 2023 while in the midst of an alleged psychotic episode, would not be acquitted by reason of insanity due to last-minute deliberation by a single juror. Almost immediately, impassioned conversations arose questioning many aspects of Clancy’s case: the jurors’ true motives, the technical validity of the court proceedings, the evidence,or the lack thereof, presented in the case and, most centrally, the uncomfortable realities presented by this aberrant example of motherhood under postpartum psychosis.
The National Institute of Health describes postpartum psychosis as “an atypical picture compared to affective or psychotic episodes unrelated to pregnancy,” with symptoms such as “auditory, visual and olfactory hallucinations … delusions … confusion, and bizarre behavior” that manifest suddenly and progress rapidly in the period of time following childbirth. The NIH also states that postpartum psychosis markedly increases the risk for suicide, and, “in rare cases, even infanticide.” In other words, the tragedy that befell the Clancy family was rare but far from unprecedented. In fact, it may be more common than many realize. Certain countries, like Canada and the UK, classify the infanticide a child under the age of one by their mother under a lesser criminal charge than other intentional killings due to the profound period of mental and situational difficulty brought on by childbirth.
Despite this, many still believe Ms. Clancy to be fully culpable for the deaths and thus morally reprehensible. U.S. Representative and outspoken conservative Brandon Gill (R-Texas) rejected the notion that Ms. Clancy’s actions were beyond her control in a statement made on a Fox News segment, saying “I don’t have an ounce of sympathy for Lindsay Clancy.” Moreover, Gill called for the death penalty in a post on X.
Is this outrage justified? Ms. Clancy, herself a labor and delivery nurse, spent the months preceding the tragedy desperately begging for help, ultimately being prescribed 13 separate psychiatric medications after dozens of psychiatric consultations.
Even her former mother-in-law Susan Clancy testified in support of her character, describing her as a “wonderful mother” whose mental health had starkly declined following the birth of her youngest child.
Moreover, Lindsay Clancy herself documented grappling with unpredictable and torturous thoughts over a period of months. “I’m so desperate to get a mental break from taking care of everyone that my mind is trying to find something physically wrong with me,” she wrote in a diary entry from November 2022.
Still, society is divided on whether or not to show mercy after such a horrific act. To be clear, this mercy is hardly the same as approval, recognizing the horrifying brutality of the children’s deaths and stepping back to take the broader picture into account are not mutually exclusive.
It seems to me, however, that we’ve witnessed the court of public opinion demonizing the actions of women in impossible situations before. The most recent example that comes to mind is the case of Gypsy Rose Blanchard, who, in 2015, plotted with her boyfriend to kill her mother who had been intentionally physically disabling her in a condition called Munchausen by Proxy. Munchausen by Proxy, like postpartum psychosis, is rare but serious, involving a caretaker fabricating their victim’s symptoms in order to gain sympathy, sometimes even forcing them to undergo unnecessary medical procedures. In Blanchard’s case, her mother had not only lied about her daughter’s health but also her age and mental capacity, convincing Gypsy Rose Blanchard that she was both younger than she was and that she suffered from cognitive disabilities which were later proven nonexistent. Both cases involve profoundly mentally ill mothers inflicting grave physical and emotional harm to their children.
Although Clancy’s case leaves behind the mother and Blanchard’s the daughter, both were treated similarly in the public eye, with a lack of crucial understanding beyond sensationalist headlines or bite-sized rants on social media leaving no room for the messy, complex reality of motherhood, mental illness and the bounds of moral responsibility when affected by the experience of both.
While reactions to the Clancy case still swing widely in either direction and proposed support continues to fragment public opinion, there can be no doubt that we as a society must learn to tolerate discomfort, seek much more information than we’re accustomed to and recognize all examples of motherhood and family dynamics.
Additionally, we must not overlook the role that both misogyny and racial dynamics play in this instance. While the backlash to Ms. Clancy’s trial has been great, there has also been significant support, with crowds of primarily women rallying outside the courthouse in solidarity with someone who has been disproportionately thrust into the limelight due to mental health struggles many new mothers are forced to navigate in the dark.
By contrast, a recent murder investigation involving a Black mother, Deja Coleman, did not see this widespread support despite the cases being strikingly similar: both women worked in healthcare and both had a history of postpartum difficulty, Coleman’s stemming from severe sleep deprivation due to her long shifts at work.
From this, the question remains: who gets a narrative of public compassion, and in what capacity? Some say that, if Ms. Clancy had been a man, she wouldn’t receive any of the support and sympathy she has been granted. I argue, however, that if she had been a man we might not have heard about the case at all, as a staggering eight men killed their entire families since the Clancy trial began yet none managed to garner the nation’s attention like Lindsay Clancy.