Since “Heated Rivalry” debuted on Crave and HBO Max, fans have posted hundreds of video edits of the show, some amassing millions of views, according to NBC News. The show led to fan club nights in Los Angeles — where crowds came together to watch projected TikTok edits — and even a lookalike contest in Washington D.C. that drew thousands of RSVPs.
That’s an alarming amount of cultural energy for a show whose runtime is primarily a slow burn rather than a definitive resolution — and it’s evidence of a broader pattern echoed throughout three unrelated new releases this year.
“Heated Rivalry,” adapted from Rachel Reid’s “Game Changers” book series, revolves around two closeted ice hockey players carrying on a secret years-long relationship. It is widely regarded as one of the breakout TV hits of 2025. Since its success, Prime Video’s “Off Campus,” adapted from Elle Kennedy’s sports romance novels, has followed a similar trajectory, earning a whopping score of 92% on Rotten Tomatoes.
They might not seem like they would have the same fanbase. However, the shows have drawn similar audience behavior — fan-edits, in-person meetups, prolonged online obsession — built less around plot twists and more around slow-building emotional tension. This pattern aligns with what researchers have been documenting about Gen Z viewing habits on a broader scale.
A widely cited study from UCLA’s Center for Scholars and Storytellers surveyed roughly 1,500 people ages 10 to 24 about their media preferences. More than half of those surveyed — 59.7% — said they wanted to see more content centered on friendships and platonic relationships.
Yalda Uhls, the senior author of this study and CEO of CSS, argues that “relatable stories are the currency of connection” for Gen Z.
This interpretation fits with what audience research firm YPulse has found looking specifically at shows like “Heated Rivalry.” Gen Z viewers are, in fact, spending significant time with romantically charged storylines. What draws them in, according to YPulse, is less the explicit content itself and more the emotional connection and yearning behind it — unresolved desire, complex characters and dynamics that feel authentic.
I think part of this phenomenon stems from fatigue. Gen Z grew up on decades of shows that leaned on sex scenes to say “this is real cinema,” — think “Gossip Girl” or “The Vampire Diaries” — and that move doesn’t really hit the same anymore. If a show wants its emotional climax to actually click, it has to really sell it to the audience.
There’s also — thankfully — a generational understanding going around regarding consent and communication. Gen Z has grown up with far more conversations about boundaries than any generation before it, so relationships built on people actually talking to each other read as more compelling and digestible than ones built purely on tension.
Then there’s the explanation that’s a little harder to accept. Matt Puretz, a senior researcher at CSS and co-author of the UCLA study, stated that “ultimately, teens want to feel connected to their friends.” I think this speaks to a larger sentiment. A lot of people turn to fiction to feel a certain kind of connection — romantic, platonic, you name it — that can feel genuinely hard to find in life. That’s a lot to put on a hockey show, I agree. But it does explain why the shows that hit the hardest aren’t the ones that rush through the romantic storyline.
Both “Heated Rivalry” and “Off-Campus” spend a large chunk of their runtime in the in-between, everyday aspects of romance — flirty banter, coffee runs, late-night study sessions, crying in each other’s arms, the slow chipping-away of someone’s emotional guard — instead of sprinting to what we all already know is going to happen. If you’re someone who wants to watch a romance show to feel that warmth, you’d want to sit through the whole thing instead of being teleported to the inevitable outcome.
“Heated Rivalry” and “Off Campus” are still very much steamy shows. What’s actually shifting is narrower than “Gen Z hates sex scenes” — it’s that breaking through to a mainstream audience right now requires emotional vulnerability as a focal point, not a blurry factor in the periphery. Think about it — two shows, two completely different worlds, landing the same kind of obsessive, slightly unhinged but wholly passionate fan responses can’t be a coincidence. That’s a genre figuring out what people want from it in the moment, and adapting accordingly.