For the better half of her day, Monday through Friday, my mom taught and took care of 30 second graders. She made sure they were fed, taught them how to read and stayed at school late to build a cardboard gingerbread house and staple felt snow to corkboards for the yearly classroom play that she directed herself. She did this for 35 years.
At the end of her workday, she came home to another child who was constantly growing and changing. And by herself, my mom would put all of her energy into providing me with endless guidance and emotional support. She was never lesser than others for doing this all on her own, or for working while she took care of me. The labor she put into my care as a single mom can never be downplayed.
This past month, Vice President J.D. Vance discussed rallying behind a proposed change to a Health and Human Services Department fund which helps working parents or those going to school afford child care. Under the new proposal, eligibility for the Child Care and Development Fund would expand, but the amount allotted would not increase. If enacted, married couples with a stay-at-home parent can collect benefits in addition to working parents.
Around 80% of families receiving subsidies from this fund have single working parents, many of whom are mothers.
University of Minnesota economics professor Elizabeth Davis said the proposal will make less funding available for the people the fund was created for in the first place.
“It’s gonna take that small public money and divide it up, and serve fewer families,” Davis said. “It already doesn’t serve all families who are eligible. It’s only about 15% of eligible children who receive subsidies under the CCDF right now.”
University human resources associate professor Nicole Dillard said it is problematic to dip into an already high-demand fund instead of creating a separate one for stay-at-home parents.
“It allows these negative and deficit-minded narratives about single moms to even exist in the zeitgeist because you create these tensions,” Dillard said. “When it’s really not about moms versus moms, whether you’re married, single, at home or in the paid labor force.”
Dillard emphasized that a big problem in society is making child care an individual’s problem, when in reality, it is a structural issue that federal and local governments need to provide better support for.
University Sociology professor Claire Kamp Dush noted that a possible effect of the CCDF money being split up is a negative perception of working mothers from their employers. Kamp Dush said working or single parents who might not be able to afford consistent daycare may look unreliable to their employers when they have to prioritize attending to their children.
“It hurts perceptions of women in the workforce because it makes it unequal, the amount of time they have available for work,” Kamp Dush said.
Dillard said the way certain policies are made is ineffective when it comes to finding out who might actually need government support.
“We tend to make policies around normative family dynamics, like someone that has two parents in a household,” Dillard said. “And when you make policies around these ideals and these norms, then you can’t see the other part of the populations who are most vulnerable.”
It’s no secret that Vance, along with many conservative government officials, wants to push for a more conservative idea of what an American family should look like. Past congressional proposals from Republicans, such as eliminating the Head of Household tax filing status, which provides tax breaks to single parents, prove they view single parents as not worth funding.
It’s ignorant to overlook the thousands of scenarios which could cause a woman to become a single parent, or to even view being a single mom as something negative in the first place.
Much of the refusal from the government to support single mothers comes from a long history of shaming women who work, get an education or dare to raise their children in a household without a man.
Dillard said although other programs aren’t perfect, the government should start funding childcare like they fund other things.
“We tell veterans who want to get back into the workforce, we will retrain you, we will upscale you, we will fund your job training because you may need new skills,” Dillard said. “We don’t tell them it’s your fault you went to the military, and it’s not our problem that you can’t get training. So why are we telling moms this is a private matter, and you want to work, but you need to figure out childcare.”
If we are willing to serve other parts of the population openly and without question as to why they need help, why can we not treat working and single moms the same way?
Child care is the most intensive type of labor, and it largely goes unnoticed, or is thought of as something that is automatically expected of women. I watched my mom for more than a decade provide for me, support me emotionally, encourage my educational aspirations and foster my goals and love of writing, all while balancing her own life. These mothers deserve so much more than what our government wants to give them.
The post Opinion: Single mothers need more support from our government appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.