A shield for sources is a shield for democracy | Editorial

When a source decides to speak to a journalist, the stakes can be far greater than whether their name appears in print. 

A government employee exposing misconduct could jeopardize their career. A university employee could face retaliation. A survivor sharing a traumatic experience could put themselves in harm’s way. 

Hannah Yu | Graphics Editor

For journalists, the ability to protect that source can determine whether the story gets told at all.

That is the purpose of a shield law. These laws protect journalists from being compelled by the government to reveal confidential sources or unpublished reporting materials, preserving the trust between reporters and the people who provide them information. Massachusetts, however, remains one of only nine states without a statutory shield law, making the commonwealth a national outlier. 

The Massachusetts Senate’s recent passage of shield protections on Aug. 6 is an important step in the right direction. Under current state law, state courts decide reporter privilege case by case, balancing source protection against a litigant’s need for information. 

What’s more, the Supreme Judicial Court has never formally recognized a reporter’s privilege. For journalists, this is a compromising position. Shield protections do more than prevent  subpoenas. They provide journalists and their sources greater certainty that confidential information will remain private, preserving the trust that encourages sources to come forward in the first place. 

Relationships between reporters and their sources are built on trust, and the promise of a secure exchange of information is essential to building that trust. Sources must feel confident that what they share with journalists will not expose them to retaliation or be revealed without justification. Without that confidence, sources may choose not to speak, cutting journalists off from information they need to hold institutions and people in power accountable. 

The Daily Free Press has encountered this firsthand. In our own reporting, sources have requested anonymity because they fear retaliation by our university’s administration. 

If Boston University faculty and staff feel the need to protect their identities when speaking with student journalists, imagine the pressure facing a government official considering whether to disclose critical information about systemic misconduct or abuses of power.

Anonymous sources are not an anomaly in journalism. Journalists regularly rely on confidential sources when those sources face professional, personal or physical consequences for speaking publicly. While critics often assume that confidentiality weakens journalism’s credibility, the public largely disagrees. The Pew Research Center found that roughly 80% of U.S. adults believe there are circumstances in which it is acceptable for journalists to use anonymous sources.  

If the public recognizes that there are legitimate circumstances for anonymous sourcing, and more sources are seeking anonymity to protect themselves from retaliation, the law should reflect that sentiment by protecting the relationships between journalists and the sources who depend on confidentiality. 

Protecting sources becomes even more crucial when dealing with sources who have experienced trauma. As the Global Center for Journalism and Trauma notes in its guidance, protecting sources from harm is an important principle of trauma-informed journalism. 

For survivors of abuse, trafficking, war or other traumatic experiences, a journalist’s ability to promise anonymity is not only essential to maintaining trust with a source, but can also be critical to protecting them from further harm. 

Exposing corruption and abuses by those in power has historically been one of the press’s most important roles. Whether that power sits within an institution like BU or the U.S. government, journalists rely on sources willing to speak from within. 

Protecting those relationships gives journalists a secure channel to information that institutions may otherwise have little incentive to make public, strengthening the press’s ability to demand transparency from those in power. 

These protections are especially important at a time when public trust in journalism is strained and journalists face increasing hostility for doing their jobs. The answer to declining trust cannot be to weaken the relationships that allow journalists to report the truth. 

That need is even more apparent as the Trump administration has continually tested the boundaries of press freedom and free expression. A functioning democracy depends on an independent press that can scrutinize those in power, including when the information it uncovers is uncomfortable or politically inconvenient. 

Shield protections are not a partisan safeguard or a special privilege for journalists. They are a fundamental protection for the free press. 

In a time when both press freedom and public trust are under strain, Massachusetts must recognize shield protections as a necessary safeguard for a free press and a functioning democracy.

Read more here: https://dailyfreepress.com/08/24/10/220341/a-shield-for-sources-is-a-shield-for-democracy-editorial/
Copyright 2026