Utah is popular for its extensive animal diversity and density and prominent outdoor access. Hunting is an economic stimulant, paying for about $331 million in salaries. The purported ripple effect of this industry is upwards of $925 million.
Decreasing mule deer populations influenced the Utah legislature to pass HB 125 in 2020. The bill mandated actions to increase the number of deer by culling predators when mule deer populations drop below a certain level or when the mortality rate is above 7% in certain areas.
Then, in 2023, the legislature passed HB 469. Originally a broad wildlife omnibus bill, a last-minute provision was added that removed many previous restrictions on cougar hunting. One of the bill’s sponsors, Sen. Scott Sandall, explained his reasoning on the floor, stating that Utah is seeing an “increase” in cougar numbers across the state. The legislature did not debate the bill further.
Opposition to the bill
Utah reports the state’s cougar populations to have increased from 2004 levels, but below a 2016 peak, and are now decreasing. Cougar populations are notoriously difficult to measure. The bill includes the legalization of lethal snares and the ability to hunt mountain lions year-round with a basic hunting license and without a bag limit. Hunters are still required to provide proof of the harvest within 48 hours and the GPS coordinates.
HB 469 also expanded trapping rules and reduced some previous restrictions governing cougar hunting and guiding.
In 2023, the Mountain Lion Foundation and the Western Wildlife Conservancy went to court, arguing HB 469 violated the 2020 Cconstitutional Aamendment E, which mandated the state must provide reasonable regulation of hunting and fishing activities and promote wildlife conservation and management.
The Utah Court of Appeals would place the case under advisement, arguing the topic was by nature political, and in turn, non-justiciable. They also argued the amendment did not mandate the protection of any particular species.
Later in 2025, the same plaintiffs appealed to the Supreme Court after being dismissed in a district court. The Supreme Court has not yet issued a final ruling on the case.
Utah’s mountain policy
HB 469 remains in effect. As of 2026, the ethicality of lethal snares and traps are still being debated. A majority of people are against snaring and trapping, including many houndsmen. Those against the use of snares and traps argue they are unethical and pose a public safety risk, as these traps can ensnare non-target species, as well as kill or harm pets.
Denise Peterson, a researcher who has developed predictive models of cougars and the founder of Utah Mountain Lion Conservation, thinks traps and snares should not be used to obtain mountain lions. “The hopes are that the animal’s head will go through there, and then as soon as they start fighting it, that tightens down and just suffocates the animal, if not causing a very deep laceration,” Peterson said in an interview with The Chronicle. “They’re very indiscriminate. With traps, you’re basically waiting to see what wanders in. The trap doesn’t know if it’s a lion or a bobcat or a deer or whatever.”
Peterson said hunting is indeed a part of Utah’s roots, and is not anti-hunting. “We’re not anti-hunting at all, but we are pro-data-driven management,” she said. “We have no ambitions to end lion hunting in Utah. That’s not the goal.”
She emphasized the importance of “ethical sportsmen.” “If you are an ethical hunter and you take hounds out, and you tree a cat, they can be strategic in the cat that they take,” Peterson said. “Ethical sportsmen are generally the strongest advocates for making sure that all wildlife is managed sustainably.”
A study on mountain lions
The Utah Division of Wildlife (DWR) states in its 2024 Mule Deer Plan that predator reduction is effective when deer populations are below carrying capacity, predation limits growth, enough predators are removed, and the removal occurs at the right time and scale.
In 2025, the DWR would launch the Watershed Restoration Initiative (WRI) Predator Management Study 7707, aiming to “implement focused predator removal to reduce predator densities” and monitor the effects it has on the deer population.
The study is funded by the non-profits Utah Wild Sheep Foundation (UWSF) and Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife. Both contributed $150,000 for the study. Supporters of the study, such as DWR spokeswoman Faith Jolley, say it is mandated by law. It states no need for public opinion in its initiation.
The study has seen stark pushback from members of conservation groups and scientists. Critics say the study lacks substantiated evidence and necessary failsafes.
Austin Green, assistant professor at the U and a wildlife biologist, is “concerned” by the lack of monitoring programs. “It’s always concerning to see something where an extensive species control program is going into effect without an established or a very strong monitoring program,” he told The Chronicle.
Considerations
Green believes the lack of a failsafe if things go wrong could lead to issues down the line. “It takes time to get the data for them,” Green said. “Before we implement anything, we should consider that.”
Green says cougar populations are estimated by using habitat models rather than direct counts because the animals are elusive and “wide-ranging.” “They’re extremely territorial, they’re extremely good at avoiding human beings,” he said. “Our estimates are much more based on habitat suitability analysis than actual population estimates.”
Green also cited concerns about the spread of Chronic Wasting Disease, an increasingly common prion disease that infects and eventually kills deer but not mountain lions.
“There is some evidence that suggests that mountain lions preferentially prey upon mule deer suffering from CWD. The disease can be sequestered within mountain lions, and the disease load decreases as it passes through their digestive tract, and it cannot be passed from mountain lion to other individuals,” Green said. “That would absolutely suggest that mountain lions can decrease the prevalence of CWD on landscapes.”
Common goals
When asked how common it is for conservation groups to differ on methods and philosophies, Green said that the Wild Sheep Foundation’s “sole goal” is to increase the population of bighorn sheep. “The wild sheep population in Utah is very, very low,” he said. “Because of that, they’re going to probably want to do everything they can to increase the population numbers of their particular species of interest.” The Wild Sheep Foundation did not respond to requests for comment.
According to the website, the study is expected to run for a minimum of three years, beginning in late 2025 and continuing through 2028. Cougar removals are authorized year‑round through 2029, and data analysis is expected to continue into 2031.
The Chronicle asked Peterson and Green what they hoped to see in the coming years as the study matured. Green said he’d hope to see “way more research.” “That’s why my biggest concern for the implementation of this current program is the lack of research on the area and on the species in question,” he said.
Peterson said that the legislature must work to understand the nuance prior to acting. “They really have to step back and first understand the actual role that mountain lions play in Utah in terms of limiting the spread of chronic wasting disease, because that is so poorly understood,” she said. “So if they insist on doing this study, I would like a moratorium placed on it for now, until they can define better metrics for how they determine if this is a success.”
j.downward@dailyutahchronicle.com
The post Experts concerned about state cougar hunting regulations appeared first on The Daily Utah Chronicle.