
Three notable Supreme Court cases were decided on June 30, examining legislation relating to birthright citizenship, transgender women and girls in school sports, and limits on political party spending on a candidate. These decisions heavily reflect the current political climate.
SCOTUS voted on an executive order signed by President Trump on his first day in office, which restricted birthright citizenship. The order stated that children born in the United States to parents that are here illegally or temporarily are not U.S. citizens, but the judges voted this order unconstitutional 5-4, referencing the 14th Amendment’s citizenship clause. One particular judge, Brett Kavanaugh, sided with the majority based on a federal law although he did not believe that this order violated the constitution. Despite the court’s decision, Trump has announced a bid to get SCOTUS to re-hear this case, something the court has not agreed to do since 1956. Despite this attempt, the ruling is still significant for the U.S. and protects birthright citizenship.
The court voted 6-3, in line with the conservative majority, to uphold state laws banning transgender girls and women from playing school sports. They voted that state laws in Idaho and West Virginia do not violate the Constitution or Title IX, thus allowing other states to determine school sports participation based on a student’s biological sex. The three liberal judges dissented because the science is still evolving and that they do not know scientifically that transgender students in sports pose a threat. This case still leaves many questions open about levels of sports in college, mixed gender sports, and regulations in states that allow transgender athletes. This case is not the first case involving transgender rights that the current Supreme Court has voted on, and it is likely not the last, but it sets a precedent for future cases.
The third case was voted 6-3 to erase limits that a political party can spend in coordination with candidates running for President or Congress. Once again the conservative majority voted to remove these caps and paved the way to unlimited independent spending in federal elections. The decision further solidifies Citizens United vs. FEC, a 2010 case that ruled that the First Amendment does not allow the government to restrict private political spending. Looking forward, this decision would allow national parties to make direct contributions to a candidate’s campaign.
These verdicts have many considerations. Erik Heyman-Meltzer, a current Global Studies major and rising senior at Drexel reflects, “I think we can take away several things from these decisions. Firstly, there is no separation between politics and the judiciary. Second, Justice Amy Coney Barrett will prove to be more of a wild card vote despite being appointed by President Trump. Thirdly, we can probably expect more seemingly erratic decisions from the court.”
Heyman-Meltzer emphasizes the uncertainty in this court. Though it has a conservative majority, some have shown they are not always willing to rule in such a way. Some of these decisions have aligned with previous rulings or political measures, while others go against what conservatives are vying for, setting precedents for the court in the future.