‘You can smell the fear when we walk into a room’: Boston University Mock Trial Organization rises to fourth in the country after second-place win at nationals

After months of preparation, three grueling rounds of competition and an 11-hour bus ride to the Superior Court of the District of Columbia in Washington, D.C., Boston University Mock Trial Organization made program history.

For the first time since 2016, BUMTO sent two teams to compete at the American Mock Trial Association’s National Championship Tournament from April 17-19. From more than 400 schools with active AMTA chapters, only 50 make it to nationals, according to the association’s website. One of BU’s teams finished second, the highest BUMTO has ever placed in their division.

The performance also bumped BUMTO’s post-season ranking — based on the past three seasons of competition — to its highest national rank in program history, fourth in the country, up four places from last year.

“Just to get to nationals, you need to be in the top 6% of competing teams in the country,” said BU B team captain Angelo Amato. “To have our A team there is always significant, but also to have your B team there is an even more massive deal.”

BUMTO is a student-led organization that teaches its members legal skills, including cross examinations, rules of evidence and trial persuasion, which they then use during trial simulations before real judges and attorneys. 

Each spring, mock trial teams from different schools compete in Regionals and Open Round Championships, and must place within the top six competitors at ORCs to advance to nationals.

BUMTO sent four teams — ranked alphabetically from A to D by skill level — to regional competitions.

BU is surrounded by some of the top-rated schools in the country, such as Yale University and Harvard University, meaning BUMTO faces some fierce competition early in the season, said Halle Ewing, a prosecution opener for BU’s B team at nationals. 

“We’re competing at the most difficult [qualifying tournament for nationals] in the country. We’re going against all of the Ivy League [schools],” Ewing said.

Still, Amato said, it’s about perspective, saying heads turned towards BU’s A team when they entered. 

“You can smell the fear when we walk into a room,” he said. 

Unlike last year, when only BU’s A team made it past the regional round, two of the four teams earned a bid to ORCs in their regional competitions.

“Every year, we’ve been seeing better and better people applying to the organization, and every year we get blown out of the water by new people,” Amato said. 

The two teams that competed at nationals had at least five first-year members with no college-level mock trial experience, he said.

During ORCs, BUMTO faced its first major surprise of the season: BU’s A team secured a bid to nationals, as well as BU’s C team, which called itself BU’s B team to comply with AMTA competition rules.

“We really wanted to try and make a push for that B team to nationals,” said Nicholas Fowles, a nationals B team character witness. “We knew we had the talent, we knew we could do it.” 

Over spring break, Fowles said, all four teams were reorganized to better fit the needs for the nationals competition. The teams prepped cases, ran through scenarios and made edits right up to the last moment, Ewing said.

The teams finished with a record-breaking weekend.

Not only did BUMTO receive some of its highest accolades in history, but lead attorney for BU’s A team, Naudia Terry, received two All-American awards, presented to the highest-performing witnesses and attorneys at the nationals.

Amato said it’s already a feat to win just one All-American award in the “big dog leagues,” let alone two. 

“To then go and [win] All-American [awards] on both sides of the competition is a humongous deal, because you compete on the prosecution and the defense and you’re basically doing twice as much work as everyone else and doing it twice as well,” he said.

BUMTO leaves its nationals run with not only milestone wins, but also more experienced members who know what it takes to get to D.C., Ewing said.

“This is a competitive team, and we do have competitive success, but I want everyone to remember that success should not come at a cost for you,” Fowles said. “It’s just a blast to get up there. No matter what a judge or a ballot might say about you, if you put your best effort forward and you have a good time doing it, that’s what this activity is all about.”

Read more here: https://dailyfreepress.com/05/06/14/220059/you-can-smell-the-fear-when-we-walk-into-a-room-boston-university-mock-trial-organization-rises-to-fourth-in-the-country-after-second-place-win-at-nationals/
Copyright 2026