Jeff Miller is not sure how much longer he will have a job as a ghostwriter. You can likely guess why: artificial intelligence.
Large language models, according to the Associated Press, use statistics to uncover patterns in written text to generate responses which are increasingly capable of applying the syntax and nuance of human speech. In other words, AI is becoming increasingly good at mimicking the voice of humans — the task at the heart of ghostwriting.
“I think as AI improves, it will get better and better at replicating the voice of someone. And it’s already not bad at it,” Miller said. “It’s hard, I think, to overstate just how rapidly these models are improving. It’s pretty astonishing to see how quickly they get better and better and better.”
Miller ghostwrites in the tech sector, consulting companies directly or through agencies to write op-eds and articles, so he has been at the nucleus of this technological boom he argues, “is going to be as disruptive as the Industrial Revolution was, but within a much, much more compressed time span.”
Miller hates AI.
AI has yet to impact his business directly, but it does so indirectly. It minimizes website traffic, reducing a media outlet’s ability to sell advertisements and thus produce revenue. The disappearance of media outlets is then accelerated, and with it the opportunity to place op-eds. Yet it’s in Miller’s best interest to understand AI — its potential positives, its shortcomings — and adapt.
“My feeling is that if I don’t use it, other people will,” Miller said. “So I need to figure out how to use it, how to use it effectively, so that I’m not just, you know, so I’m using it to maybe accelerate what I can do and get work out faster without, you know, just producing AI slop that uses antithesis all over the place.”
An “Atlantic” article recently argued, however, that AI can’t replace ghostwriters. Miller agrees, for now: one can’t “prompt their way into a good piece.” Although there’s a more critical question the “Atlantic” article entertains that otherwise tends not to be asked in AI-concerned conversations: even if AI can generate decent prose true to any voice, should it?
With the introduction of AI into the literary world, an ongoing debate concerned with the ethicality and prowess of ghostwriting has assumed another layer of complexity. Works that confront relatively personal topics seem to illustrate most clearly the raised ethical stakes of non-human ghostwriting.
Dr. Nicole Dahmen, a professor at UO’s School of Journalism and Communication and a three-year Faculty Fellow in the Clark Honors College, is an expert on media ethics and creative nonfiction who has researched literary memoirs for years.
Memoirs have their roots in memory, and how one derives meaning from their memories, rather than solely recounting them, is a key component of literary memoirs. To narrate one’s life story to a ghostwriter will always produce a third-party representation of a series of events, according to Dahmen.
“From an authenticity perspective, do we lose trust? Do we lose faith in the story, the connection to the narrative, if it’s not actually written by the person claiming to write it?” Dahmen said of ghostwriting. “So, that’s an ethical concern: misrepresentation from the audience perspective … Okay, so then, you know, you bring in AI. And this is, of course, the ultimate question of our time: What do we do with AI, right? How do we use it ethically? How do we use it responsibly?”
Disclosing the usage of AI, for Miller, is crucial, but popular practice suggests other ghostwriters don’t feel the same.
“Ghostwriting is already a little murky, I think,” Miller said. “People are not disclosing (AI usage) for sure. But then people never disclose that it was by a ghostwriter in the first place. So I think you’re probably on stronger ground there, perhaps not disclosing that you’re using AI, because again, you’re not disclosing who the real author is in the first place.”
Although many publishers now require authors to disclose whether AI was used in the writing process, there are no standard practices to vet to-be-published manuscripts for undisclosed AI use.
Undisclosed AI usage led “Big Five” publisher Hachette to cancel its upcoming release of a horror novel, “Shy Girl,” after readers claimed it was AI slop — an increasingly commonplace term to describe low-quality digital content made with generative AI.
Readers may revolt at the thought of AI assisting the writing process, but a random sample survey conducted by Tuhin Chakrabarty, a professor of computer science at Stony Brook University, showed a 41% increase from 2024 to 2025 in the number of novels that “contained a large amount of AI-generated text.”
“It worries me a great deal that from a policy standpoint, and from a social standpoint, it’s gonna cause enormous disruption. And I — we’re not ready for it. We’re not preparing for it,” Miller said.
Many write memoirs to find meaning in the memories that still have their “claws” in them, but we’re experiencing a crisis of meaning, according to Dahmen.
“If we’re not the ones doing the writing, then is it really ever gonna let us go?”
The post AI can ghostwrite, but should it? appeared first on Daily Emerald.