ASUO resolution to reform university appeals board passes in UO Senate

Originally Posted on Daily Emerald via UWIRE

ASUO, the University of Oregon’s student governmental body, is advocating for more student representation in the student conduct code appeals process — now with the support of UO’s senate.

This academic year, a total of 412 UO student conduct code violations have occurred. Of those violations, only 25 have been appealed.

According to information from the Director of Issues Management Angela Seydel, in the past three academic years, this year has had the fewest number of violations but the highest number of appeals.

Last academic year saw 606 cases with 13 appeals and the 2023-24 year saw 492 cases and 17 appeals.

At UO, violations may only be appealed if there is a procedural irregularity that affected the outcome, the action plan was inappropriate for the violation, the findings were not supported by the evidence or if new information could alter a decision if the information was known to the person appealing at the time of the administrative conference.

On April 8, ASUO’s resolution to reform the University Appeals Board passed in the UO Senate. The resolution passed with 15 affirming, 14 negating and six abstaining votes.

This resolution urges the Office of Student Conduct and Community Standards to increase the number of student representatives for UAB hearings.

Currently, each UAB review consists of one student, one faculty member and an additional seat that can be filled by a student, faculty member or administrative staff.

The ASUO resolution advocates for an additional three student representatives at each review, making five board members in total.

ASUO Senator for Seat 9, Bella Hoffert-Hay, co-authored the resolution. The fourth-year English and political science double major sees this resolution as a “jumping off point for things to continue to change.”

While the resolution passed in the ASUO Senate almost unanimously, Hoffert-Hay explained that it was more contentious in the UO Senate. She believes this was primarily due to voting members’ “concerns over privacy and student reliability.”

“We aren’t trying to reform the training students receive … that is completely up to the (UAB),” Hoffert-Hay said.

Currently, UAB “members are trained during one-hour individual or small group sessions (and) supplemental group trainings may be offered for specialized issues,” Seydel said.

Hoffert-Hay said that this resolution is simply a message that ASUO, speaking on behalf of the student population, would like to have more representation within this decision making process.

ASUO has been performing outreach in hopes of getting more undergraduate students especially to apply to be a part of the UAB. Hoffert-Hay said that they have “had 14 students apply” to be members.

Associate Vice President for Student Life and Dean of Students Jimmy Howard said he had his concerns over equitable incorporation of this resolution for the board.

Across the Big 10 Academic Alliance, eight schools, including UO, have students sitting on appellate boards. The other 10 schools in the conference utilize faculty or administrative staff only, outside of specific circumstances.

Howard said the OSCCS maintains their position that “it’s just really important to continue to have students bring the richness of their experience to the table.”

However, Howard said, “I think there’s a lot to consider about taking, you know, taking this particular action without doing our due diligence to make sure it’s the right path forward.”

Howard hopes to see more student interest in being a part of the board; however, he understands why the interest is low. “It’s a lot of time and commitment (… and) they’re signing up to see a lot of really, like, sometimes tough information.”

Despite Hoffert-Hay sharing that ASUO has had 14 confirmed undergraduate applicants for the UAB, Howard said, “We haven’t seen the applications yet.” This is an example of one of his primary concerns, that students are not interested enough in being a part of the board to create these changes.

Luke Foshay is a fourth-year student double-majoring in political science and Spanish. Foshay is currently one of three undergraduate students in the UAB. The remaining 10 are all graduate or law school students, according to Howard.

Foshay said that the hiring process consists of “(a four) short-answer question (application) and an interview/training session, as well as confirmation from the university president.”

He has been a member of the board for about a year and has sat in on one appeal. During their first hearing, “new members are typically placed with veteran staff,” according to Seydel.

“Alongside being a member of the appeals board, I am also an author of the (ASUO) resolution and working with the OSCCS to implement this change,” Foshay said.

He affirmed ASUO’s goal of ensuring that students and faculty are accurately represented within governing processes at UO.

“Most recently, we’ve seen the University try to weaponize the (student conduct code) to punish student protestors and labor activity,” Foshay said. “This reform would add more students, making sure that the process is more just, and ensuring that students get their case heard by multiple peers.”

Through continued conversation with ASUO, Howard said, “We just have to make sure that we are clear about why we’re doing it, how we can do this and how we can do this in a way that continues to maintain the student dignity and the processes are going through.”

Howard explained that despite his concerns, he believes that a reform of this nature could still occur. But ultimately, Howard added, “this is not just a change we could make overnight.”

“I just love hearing, again, directly from students, about the impact these policies and processes have on them,” Howard said. “We may not always align, but making sure that where we can align, we do.”

Both Howard and Foshay urge students, especially undergraduates, interested in being a part of the board to reach out to the office and apply. Both individuals are united in their hope for continuing student involvement in this process.

The post ASUO resolution to reform university appeals board passes in UO Senate appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Read more here: https://dailyemerald.com/187298/news/asuo-resolution-to-reform-university-appeals-board-passes-in-uo-senate/
Copyright 2026 Daily Emerald