Opinion: The U.S. must continue to fight in Iran

 

On Feb. 28, 2026, the United States engaged in open hostilities with Iran. President Trump, in his initial statements, called on the Iranian people to “take over their government.” This is a call for regime change. The war has consisted largely of air and missile strikes across Iran and the Persian Gulf. However, during the first three weeks of the war, Trump and his administration provided many different explanations, timelines and goals for the war. However, Congress has not approved the strikes, and Congress is the only body with the constitutional authority to declare war. On April 1, Trump announced that the war would continue for another two to three weeks but as of April 7, Trump announced a two-week ceasefire with Iran after declaring, just hours before, that Iranian civilization will be destroyed as the U.S. targets civilian infrastructure.  Continued fighting in Lebanon threatens the ceasefire’s durability, even as negotiations begin in Islamabad, Pakistan.

The war has already come to affect Utahns. Gas prices in Utah have risen in the past month by 43%. Fertilizer costs have risen due to the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, straining Utah farmers who are already struggling with high consumer prices and production costs.

The war has had effects across the globe and has caused hardships across Iran, the wider Middle East and the United States. However, the United States has started this war and must continue to work toward regime change without intentionally bombing the civilian population. To retreat would be a disservice to the Iranian people and to the U.S. service personnel who have been killed and wounded.

The Iranian regime is oppressive

To call the Iranian regime oppressive is an understatement. In the early months of 2026, somewhere between 3,000 and 30,000 Iranian protestors were massacred by government forces in response to ongoing protests about the collapse of the Iranian economy and political repression. In 2022, Iranian police arrested, beat and tortured 22-year-old Mahsa/Zhina Amini for refusing to comply with compulsory veiling laws. Amid the subsequent protest movement, which sought more autonomy for women and girls across Iran, hundreds were killed as live ammunition was used to quell the uprising. Iran also maintains a militia force, called the Basij, used as a tool of repression and crushing of dissent.

In 2026, the United States has twice promised to assist the Iranian people in toppling the dictatorship in Iran. Now, the regime is in a precarious position, yet there have been no new protests or mass movements to topple the government. The American policy in Iran, which appears to be to bomb the nation with no clear strategic objective, is flawed. President Trump will one day commit himself to regime change, then announce that the model for this operation is the Venezuelan operation in which President Nicolas Maduro was captured and replaced by regime insiders.

This is a flaw with the American strategy in Iran. It is simultaneously hyper-aggressive and does not seek real change in Iran. For this operation to truly mean something, the United States must actively seek to topple the regime in Tehran.

The Iranian regime is an enemy of the United States

In Iranian regime propaganda, the United States is referred to as “the Great Satan.” In 1979, the regime seized 66 American hostages. Iran is suspected of involvement in the 1983 Beirut Barracks Bombing, which led to the death of 241 American military personnel stationed in Lebanon as part of a peacekeeping operation. In 1984, the Annex of the U.S. Embassy in Beirut was bombed in an attack believed to be perpetrated by Hezbollah and Iran. Since the American Invasion of Iraq in 2003, Iran has supported Shiite militias in Iraq, which have caused the deaths of at least 600 American soldiers.

The United States would be foolish to think that the regime would cease to be hostile to the United States if the current bombing campaign suddenly stopped. The United States and Israel have killed Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, Iranian security chief Ali Larijani and Iranian intelligence chief Esmail Khatib, among others. Yet the Supreme Leader has been replaced not by someone eager to make peace and moderate their relationship with the United States but by the son of the assassinated Ali Khamenei. His first statement as the supreme leader called for the war to escalate.

The global picture

Trump has begun to waver between calling for de-escalation, declaring that he will increase the bombing pressure and declaring total victory. April 7 was the ultimate example of this, with Trump declaring that he would end Iranian civilization in the morning and announcing a ceasefire in the evening.  The problem is that it is clear that Trump’s scramble to find an off-ramp for an apocalyptic deadline that he set to solve a problem he caused was inspired by rising oil prices and deep unpopularity at home. If the message that the United States will panic at the first sign of economic trouble is sent to the regime in Iran, then the United States will expose itself to economic blackmail and strangulation in the Strait of Hormuz and other parts of the world.

Take, for instance, the Taiwan Strait. The People’s Republic of China recognizes Taiwan (officially the Republic of China) as a breakaway province, not a sovereign nation. China has been preparing for a campaign to take Taiwan by force if necessary and has set 2027 as the date to be prepared to do so. The U.S. has long maintained close relations with Taiwan.  But this relationship has created a major vulnerability for the U.S., namely, U.S. dependence on Taiwanese microchips.

If China were to blockade Taiwan, as Iran has done in Hormuz, U.S. economic output would drop by a projected 11%, more than the 2008 financial crisis. As China’s military becomes more effective and the U.S. seems more concerned with economic pain than long-term national interest, as President Trump’s scramble for a ceasefire in Iran indicates, the advantage will move away from the U.S. and toward its adversaries. What happens in Iran cannot be looked at in isolation. Weakness in Iran would invite aggression elsewhere.

Regime change, not terror bombing

To be clear, President Trump’s statement that “a whole civilization will die” is an unacceptable call for U.S. forces to commit war crimes on a massive scale and should be condemned. This is not the sort of campaign the United States should engage in and is more comparable to Vladimir Putin in Ukraine than George W. Bush in Iraq. If the fighting resumes, the United States should focus its efforts on targeting the regime and military infrastructure, not terrorizing the civilian populace.

President Trump has gambled on a war of choice in the Middle East. This war has negatively affected Americans and Utahns by hitting their pocketbooks, freezing interest rates and dampening the overall economic outlook. He has sacrificed his own popularity and political prospects in pursuit of a war he promised voters he would not pursue. Unless the U.S. seeks to do something in Iran to fundamentally change the regime, we will have harmed Americans, killed Iranians, alienated allies and exposed a dangerous Achilles heel for nothing. By circumventing Congress, Trump has engaged in an autocratic abuse of power. The administration began this war without enough planning and forethought. Regardless, the war is ongoing, and it must be fought, and America must win.

 

j.vanlooy@dailyutahchronicle.com

@jvanlooy3.bsky.social

The post Opinion: The U.S. must continue to fight in Iran appeared first on The Daily Utah Chronicle.

Read more here: https://dailyutahchronicle.com/2026/04/15/opinion-the-u-s-must-continue-to-fight-in-iran/
Copyright 2026