Every Wednesday, hundreds gather outside the Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Burlington, Massachusetts, to protest the conditions detainees there are subject to.
Javier Luengo-Garrido, an organizer with the Mass. chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, said he believes the Burlington facility must be shut down.
“We have heard from testimonies of people the really bad conditions that the Burlington ICE field office [has], and we do believe that any kind of detention, in long-term or short-term, should have stopped in Burlington,” he said.
The Burlington facility, which serves as the headquarters of ICE activity in New England, is both a field office and an intake center, designed to process those arrested by ICE and detain them until they are transferred to a long-term detention facility.
If an immigrant is detained in Massachusetts, “their initial stop is going to be the Burlington facility where they’ll be processed,”said Sarang Sekhavat, the chief of staff of the Mass. Immigration and Refugee Advocacy Coalition.
The detention period set by the Department of Homeland Security for hold rooms, such as the Burlington facility, was increased from 12 to 72 hours last June, according to the Colorado Times Recorder.
But the Burlington facility is “not meant for anything more than 24 hours,” said Sekhavat.
U.S. Rep. Seth Moulton, who is running for Senate, said in an interview with The Daily Free Press, he has visited the Burlington facility repeatedly and witnessed “inhumane conditions.”
Since his oversight visits began, he said he has noticed “minor changes,” including slight improvements in the food, a promise to improve sleeping conditions for those who have to stay overnight and accountability with individual cases.
The Boston DHS field office did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
Todd Palmer, a board member of the Greater Assabet Indivisible Network who has been partaking in the protests outside the facility since last July, said despite the 72-hour detention period, some detainees are kept in the Burlington facility for “days at a time.”
According to data gathered by the Colorado Times Recorder, there have been at least 126 violations of the 72-hour hold limit in the Burlington facility. The longest recorded stay was almost 1,855 hours — over 77 days.
“Nobody should be held in those conditions for more than a few hours,” Palmer said.
Paul Belfanti, president of the Immigrant Support Alliance, said that shutting down the Burlington facility “would make a lot of us feel better,” but recognized it would not stop ICE operations. Even if shut down, he said, “it would be resurrected” somewhere else in the region.
Moulton said there are benefits to having the Burlington facility in New England.
“They’re inhumane conditions, so we don’t want people staying there too long,” he said. “But lawyers and families want them in Massachusetts long enough to file petitions for their release.”
The complexities of the system have created a “double-edged sword,” Moulton said.
Belfanti said being detained in Burlington allows detainees to be close to family and their legal team.
“It’s preferable to be held in the area, as opposed to Louisiana or Texas, where not only are you completely isolated and separated from anyone you know, but you’re also likely to be in a jurisdiction that, when your hearing comes up, you’re going to have judges that are the least sympathetic in the system,” he said.
However, Jay Duchin, a member of Bearing Witness, says the proximity of Burlington in New England does not make a difference given the conditions of the facility and the swiftness with which many detainees get moved to other locations.
“They aren’t allowed to get visits, so you might as well be somewhere else,” Duchin said. “They have a very well-oiled machine … they try very hard to be as fast and efficient as possible to get people out of there.”
Duchin said detainees are not receiving due process.
“It’s hard to believe this is America, because this is not the America a lot of us know,” Duchin said
Palmer said the argument in favor of keeping New England facilities a “false characterization.” Instead, he said he hopes the system is entirely reformed.
“My solution would be [to] stop holding people that do not need to be detained, let them out on bond, or don’t arrest them in the first place, and give them an immigration hearing,” he said.
Moulton acknowledged that there is “not an obvious solution” to the problem.
Sekhavat said he’s unsure whether Burlington should be shut down, but the existence of the ICE facilities is the root of the problem.
“The fact that this kind of detention exists at all is really the problem — it’s not that it’s here in Massachusetts, it’s just that it exists, period,” he said.
While the Burlington facility remains open, demonstrations outside it persist. Bearing Witness has been demonstrating outside the Burlington facility consistently for 51 weeks, while GAIN has hosted “Justice4All” events every Thursday for the past 31 weeks.
Protestors also hand out free food and children’s books to families leaving from their visitation appointments, according to Palmer.
Moulton said the continued protests “remind ICE employees that they’re being watched, that we’re going to hold them accountable and that fellow Americans want the detainees to be treated with dignity and American values.”
The protests help engage the community in these issues, but Belfanti said he doesn’t expect it to vastly change ICE’s behavior.
“I think it’s motivated some people to become more active in their resistance and their protest, but I don’t think it’s changed the way that ICE operates,” he said.
Sekhavat said he would be “hard pressed to see if [protests alone] could make much of a change,” but in the future, when the Trump administration is no longer in power, he wants “to make sure that people don’t just forget about this.”