Opinion: Women can’t win the fame game

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

In March, Chappell Roan once again found herself at the center of a conversation surrounding her perceived aggressive behavior. 

While staying at a hotel for Lollapalooza Brasil, a professional athlete accused Roan of sending her security guard to berate his 11-year-old daughter for walking past her while she was having breakfast. After the girl’s mother took to social media to express her daughter’s distress, people online continued to tear Roan apart for not being accommodating and seemingly being rude to her fans.  

Roan denied even seeing the family and said she had no connection to the security guard in question, adding that she was sorry for the outcome of the situation. Of course, people were still skeptical that Roan was telling the truth about the situation. 

The guard himself finally made a post clarifying that he did not work for Roan and was acting out of his own judgment. The problem with this situation is that the damage had already been done. Roan’s fate had been decided the first time she set boundaries for herself as a female celebrity.

Since she emerged as a media figure, Roan has made it clear that she refuses to be violated by paparazzi and has set a standard that she expects to be treated with decency and respect. The problem with our culture surrounding female idols is that we don’t see them as people. Because Roan has advocated for herself when she felt uncomfortable, people make negative assumptions about her moral character.    

Female celebrities are expected to achieve complete docility in the face of constant judgment. Many of the expectations of female celebrities stem from what is expected of all women, famous or not. Being told to smile more is the rite of passage for any woman who dares to go out in public.

University of Minnesota cultural studies and comparative literature graduate student Sarah Snyder said the harsh judgment cast on female celebrities has a lot to do with the criminalization of women and their autonomy.

“We sort of have to think about the ways in which women are disciplined and the ways in which this sort of quote-unquote essential nature of women is supposed to be more moral, and so in some ways, that’s a lot further to fall,” Snyder said.

University education and human development associate professor Avelina Rivero said women fall victim to internalized patriarchal standards because of how ingrained they are in our culture.

Britney Spears discussed having intense struggles with mental health in her memoir, and the impacts this had on her are unfortunately not surprising, considering how she was treated throughout her career. Being perceived by the public eye and the expectations of her as a woman were just some of the many struggles she dealt with. In one instance, interviewers asked Spears if she was still a virgin when she was only around 17 years old; meanwhile, the parents of her fans were concerned about whether she was a good role model for young girls. There was no way for her to win.

We endlessly interrogate female stars about their intentions and actions instead of questioning why we expect them to look or act a certain way at all.

Snyder said there’s a through line of misogyny that explains these unfair expectations of female celebrities.

“The double standard and pedestal-ing of women, the creation of this zone of essential perfection, excludes a hell of a lot of people from it,” Snyder said. “It’s very much a sort of white settler imaginary femininity.”

Marketing yourself as a product to be consumed by audiences, and doing so with a smile on your face, sounds like a nightmare, so it’s absurd to expect this of celebrities we purport to love.

If our culture expects an unattainable crafted version of female performance from famous women, nothing is stopping us from putting these same unfair standards on women with less privilege and influence.

Rivero said women can see this and internalize the same criticism public figures face.

“If someone’s acting that way, then maybe I should, so I can seek validation,” Rivero said. “If someone sees that a woman is being highly criticized for their behavior, they want to stay in the norm, because out of that box feels scary.”

We need more female celebrities like Roan who question the expectations and behaviors of the people around them. Fighting back against the people who push unrealistic standards on their idols is the first step to changing how our culture treats women in the spotlight.

Unfortunately, the pattern of expecting perfection from female celebrities continues to repeat itself with no foreseeable end. So next time you see this misogyny in action, question why we expect women to take harassment and vitriol with grace and why we expect perfection from them in the first place.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-women-cant-win-the-fame-game/04/07/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily