Opinion: Secondhand shopping isn’t fun anymore

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

If you’ve spent any amount of time trying your luck at thrift or vintage stores, you’ll quickly realize prices have skyrocketed in recent years.  

It’s not just pricing that’s changed. If you want to own a 2000s Hollister tank top or an oversized vintage Harley-Davidson t-shirt, you’re unlikely to find it at the local thrift store anymore.

Popular culture’s obsession with nostalgia has made vintage clothing and accessories into some of the most coveted finds for both in-person and online shopping.  

University of Minnesota apparel design and retail and consumer studies professor Kathryn Reiley said the demand has gained traction as thrifting and vintage fashion markets have maintained their relevance and popularity.

“It kind of started becoming popular in the early 2000s, and now more and more people want to wear it,” Reiley said. “The store owners and the online website owners know that it’s becoming more popular, so they know that they can increase their prices and make more of a profit.”

Stores popping up in Minneapolis and beyond offer a variety of vintage apparel, but a good portion of it isn’t realistic for the budget of a college student. Curating a wardrobe of vintage clothing and accessories can lead you to go well over your typical budget. 

Online marketplaces like Depop, Poshmark and Vinted also make selling vintage pieces readily available to more sellers who have a tendency to upcharge. It has become nearly impossible to find stylish pieces that haven’t already been bought out by someone looking to resell clothing online, or at their vintage boutiques, for five times the original price.

“It’s getting harder to find really good items because the resellers are taking all the good things from thrift stores and selling it online,” Reiley said.

Known scornfully as “Depop warriors,” many young people have started sifting through thrift stores in search of various clothing, accessories and shoes that they can dub as unique and curated as a selling tactic to mark up pre-owned fashion.

University second-year student Finch Lamothe said social media also plays a role in how vintage items are priced.

“I feel like with social media, people can try to put value on a specific item and kind of create a false sense of want,” Lamothe said. “Like if somebody made a post hyping up a specific vintage Pokémon card, that can drive prices to go up and create this false scarcity.”

It’s understandable to want to make a profit when you’re selling something online, but the intense demand for vintage fashion and the competitive online markets have completely sucked the fun out of shopping.

People who rely on thrifting for a large part of their wardrobes, or those just looking for cool, inexpensive finds, now have to compete with people looking to bolster their side hustles.

A combination of corporate greed and high demand for thrifted and vintage clothing has led businesses that are more accessible to the everyday consumer, like Goodwill, to overcharge for clothing they get for free from donations.

Lamothe said these corporations are usually at the core of the increase in thrift prices.

“I would say it probably has something to do with the company itself wanting a larger margin of profit,” Lamothe said. “I think they probably feel like they’re trying to raise the price as much as they can while still retaining customers to kind of maximize that profit.”

The rise in thrift shop worship also ties into issues of class. Before it was socially acceptable, or even desirable, wearing thrifted clothing was viewed in a negative light. Communities that rely on thrifted fashion could also face a limited selection of clothing, despite the fact that they would have been looked down upon for wearing used clothes only a couple of years ago.

As consumers, we do have some say in how we spend our money. Rejecting exorbitant prices for thrifted fashion can show sellers they can’t continually take advantage of buyers.

Although it may give you a rush to find a sought-after piece of clothing online or at a curated vintage store, don’t give in to ridiculous pricing.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-secondhand-shopping-isnt-fun-anymore/03/24/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily