A University of Minnesota Law School cold call gave Jim Hale a nickname he never forgot.
During a first-year class, professor Arthur R. Miller, the rumored inspiration behind the strict law professor-character Rudolph Perini in Scott Turow’s book “One L,” pressed Hale during a Socratic exchange.
“He said, ‘Mr. Hale, what do you think is the point of this case?’ And I explained it to him, and he said, ‘Mr. Hale, I think your reasoning is that a buttercup is a flower, and therefore, all flowers are buttercups. Is that what you mean, Mr. Hale?’” Hale recalled.
For the next six weeks, Miller referred to Hale as “Buttercup” during class.
Hale said, however, the interaction became the start of a lasting relationship. After the course, Miller offered him a paid research job, and Hale made a lasting impression on Miller as one of his greatest students.
“It is now 62 or 63 years later, and I have believed throughout that time Jim is among the very finest I have encountered,” Miller said. “He has been a wonderful member of the legal profession, and I admire him in so many ways. I only regret that life has not brought us closer together.”
More than six decades later, Hale’s legal career has taken him to great heights. He is said to have one of the highest GPAs in the University of Minnesota Law School’s history, clerked at the U.S. Supreme Court for Chief Justice Earl Warren, and has held several senior leadership roles at Target Corporation. Outside of work, he has taught university courses in law and business, served on the board of directors of several organizations, including non-profits and has written and recorded more than 100 songs.
But Hale, a 1965 graduate of the University’s law school, was put off the idea of becoming a lawyer early on. In a high school social studies class, he interviewed a lawyer to see whether the profession might suit him.
“He hated the practice of law,” Hale said. “That’s what he did for a living, but he didn’t like it at all. So I thought, ‘Well, I’m not going to do that.’”
Hale changed his mind, however, during a conversation with his political science professor in his senior year at Dartmouth College.
“He said, ‘If you don’t know what you want to do, go to law school.’ And that’s what I did,” Hale said.
As class valedictorian, Hale could choose between the top law schools in the country. Hale had been married for two years at that point, and the choice fell on Minnesota primarily because of family.
“That’s where we wanted to live,” Hale said. “That’s where I wanted to practice law.”
After law school, Hale clerked for Chief Justice Warren at the Supreme Court. One of the landmark cases during that term was Miranda v. Arizona, the 1966 decision that established the requirement that suspects be informed of key rights before custodial interrogation.
Because Warren delivered the majority opinion of Miranda v. Arizona, Hale and one of Warren’s other clerks helped draft language for the opinion that set out the requirements that are now called the Miranda warning.
Hale said that one particularly important part of the warning was including the explanation that an attorney would be provided for defendants who could not afford one.
“The feeling was that had to be stated because if the defendant is being told for the first time he has a right to an attorney, and he knows he doesn’t have a nickel to spend on an attorney, then at least he needs to also know that one would be provided for him,” Hale said.
After clerking for a year, Hale went on to private legal practice and later held a number of executive roles at Target. His work in the legal field has earned him several prestigious accolades, including The Library of Congress’s “Legend in the Law” award.
Jim said it is important for him to give back to the community, and he has done so in many ways. One of his law-related initiatives was becoming the founding chairman of the Fund for the Legal Aid Society, an organization whose sole function was to raise money to support legal aid lawyers.
“I think the first event we had raised something like $100,000, and I’m told it now raises a million dollars a year for legal aid. I’m pretty proud of that one,” Hale said.
Hale also said music remained a parallel interest throughout his life and career. A longtime friend gave him a harmonica in 1984, and he began teaching himself to play.
“I spent the whole first summer floating around in an inner tube at our lake home and learning how to play one tune,” Hale said.
He later began recording with friends through a studio arrangement that grew out of a charity fundraiser, and he now plays harmonica in studio sessions and with local bands in different genres. He even wrote a song making light of the “Legend in the Law” award he had previously gotten.
“A ‘Legend in the Law’ seemed just a little arrogant,” Hale said.
Hale said he finds songwriting to be a meaningful creative outlet.
“I especially like to write songs about my family, about my grandkids,” he said. “And then when I get worked up, I write something about the political situation.”
Asked what advice he would give current University students, Hale encouraged them to be intentional about the jobs they accept.
“There’s a good chance you’re going to have opportunities to take jobs that are really meaningful,” Hale said. “To the extent you possibly can, do that. Don’t just settle for any job — settle for a job you’re going to enjoy.”