Nag: ICE’s failure to de-escalate

When I was covering the initial ICE protests outside of the Portland facility on Oct. 11, 2025, I  watched a group of Department of Homeland Security officers ruthlessly kick a man down and kick him again, as he was trying to stand up. This was also the first time I was pepper-sprayed by a federal officer at a peaceful demonstration, and I still remember the sting I felt in my lungs. 

Then I heard the events that transpired in Eugene last Tuesday; the random detainments of peaceful demonstrators and the open gassing of protestors after a vigil organized by the Oregon Nurses Association. This could not have been legal. 

Federal agents in the Department of Homeland Security are trained at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center , which integrates conflict resolution and de-escalation tactics into its curriculum and teaches agents to resolve conflicts without force. 

In the DHS Use of Force policy (2024), a list of guidelines was provided for all DHS law enforcement officers and agents, including ICE and Customs and Border Patrol. The policy outlines that an agent should “use only the force that is objectively reasonable in light of the facts,” with general emphasis on “respect for human life” and “safeguarding the American people.” 

The policy states that federal agents need to use safe tactics that “minimize the risk of unintended injury or serious property damage,” and officers must “attempt to identify him or herself” and  “issue a verbal warning.” 

When a verbal warning is given by a federal agent, they should give a “reasonable opportunity to voluntarily comply before applying force” and allow participants to leave the scene in a safe route. Agents can also only use force that is “reasonable in light of the totality of the circumstances,” and overuse of force is strictly prohibited. 

According to what protestors described, these policies were not followed at all. Most importantly, when the munition escalation began, no verbal warnings were given to the protestors to disperse or leave the federal building, a strict breach of protocol. 

Sophie Knoles, an active member of the Lane County Immigrant Defense Network was detained by DHS last Tuesday and explained the events leading up to use of force on the protestors.  

“After being inside and not interacting with protestors, they came out of the doors and deployed flashbangs and gas within a foot of (our) vicinity,” Knoles said. “There was no attempt of de-escalation before they deployed those, there was no telling us to step back — it was straight assault.”

Knoles was detained while protesting; she says that she didn’t try to resist detention, didn’t try to retaliate against DHS officers and that she wasn’t blocking any exits from the building. Knoles said, “I really don’t have the words to describe how violently they handled me.”

Robin Bailey, editor of the Knightly Ruby, covered the protests through the course of last Tuesday. “DHS had been using force throughout the day, and their detainments were pretty violent — they don’t use handcuffs correctly, and I have photos of a (detainee’s) skin being rubbed raw from how the DHS handled them,” Bailey said.

Bailey recounted the events before DHS started using force on protestors, and he also recalls that no formal warning or dispersal order was given before the sudden use of flash bang grenades and tear gas was deployed. 

“DHS didn’t care if we were press or if we were civilians,” Bailey said. “Everyone has the right to be there and bear witness to what’s happening — that’s what the First Amendment was made for.” 

This initial breach of protocol needs to be investigated, and someone needs to hold DHS accountable for their actions. The DHS operations failed to follow their own de-escalation protocols and training, only worsening community safety and impacting public trust in law enforcement.

The post Nag: ICE’s failure to de-escalate appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Read more here: https://dailyemerald.com/179555/opinion/nag-ices-failure-to-de-escalate/
Copyright 2026