‘Wicked: For Good’ defied gravity at the box office, but does it defy expectations?

Originally Posted on Daily Emerald via UWIRE

It’s been a year since “Wicked,” and anticipation has been through the roof. How can a multimillion-dollar franchise follow a film that made such a significant cultural and emotional impact? Unfortunately, some things are too good to replicate.

“Wicked: For Good” came to theaters nationwide on Nov. 21, almost exactly a year after the release of its first counterpart, “Wicked.” Having earned $226 million worldwide in its opening weekend, this sequel has made a huge splash already, and Oscar and Grammy nominations seem to be just past the yellow brick road.

The ending of the first film left us with Elphaba (Cynthia Erivo), who had just discovered the Wizard’s (Jeff Goldblum) fraud, causing a ruckus as she denounced Oz in her leaving. This caused a rift in her and Glinda’s (Ariana Grande) friendship, and the future of the Emerald City looked bleak.

In the second film, we are reintroduced to the characters in their new roles: Glinda as a blissful public figure, Elphaba as public enemy number one, Fiyero (Johnathan Bailey) as Captain of the Wizard’s Guard, Nessarose (Marissa Bode) as a cold governor and Boq (Ethan Slater) as her discontented subordinate. The time jump is only one year, yet there is a huge shift from the character personalities and motivations with which we were familiar.

“Wicked: For Good” shined in terms of visuals; popping hues of pink, green and gold wove throughout the fantastical Oz thanks to production designer Nathan Crowley. His use of practical sets, including Elphaba’s lair and the tulip field (made up of 9 million flowers), had mesmerizing intentional detail. Another carefully-crafted aspect was the SFX makeup artistry involved in creating the Tin Man and Scarecrow, both of which took around four hours to complete.

Visual appreciation aside, the story of “Wicked: For Good” dampened in comparison to the narrative soul embedded in its prequel. After a lulling first half, the pacing took a sharp turn, cramming in a random love triangle and rushing through momentous, life-altering events.

In musical theater, first acts serve to introduce a world and its characters, construct a conflict and leave enough of a cliffhanger to incentivize theater-goers to return post-intermission. Second acts are notorious for cramming in cheap thrills to tie everything together, leaving less room for character building and narrative build-up. The two films don’t stray from this structure.

As for acting, Slater’s performance was unexpectedly powerful. Michelle Yeoh, who played the conniving villain behind the Wizard, Madame Morrible, did not leave the same impression. Her acting was incredible, as always, but her singing was simply not Wicked-level. Goldblum’s voice wasn’t ideal either, but it’s understandable that both their namesakes and talent were too perfect to pass on.

This film’s two original songs, “No Place Like Home” and “The Girl in the Bubble,” were both written by Stephen Schwartz and Grande and Erivo, respectively. Although Schwartz is a musical powerhouse, these songs fell flat. The soundtrack overall was far less iconic than the first, although that’s expected of a second act.

On the other hand, “No Good Deed” was a ballad that only Erivo would be able to deliver with such strength. It was the shining star of the entire film, and the songs that followed (aside from “For Good,” which was appropriately moving) paled in comparison.

The symbolism of greed and a fascist political structure in Oz, revealed in the rejection of Elphaba and prejudice against its animals and Munchkins, is about as blandly obvious as it could get. While its blatantness should have been enough to stir an empowering emotional impact, Elphaba didn’t motivate me to stand up to corporate greed and unjust dictatorship. This might be due, in part, to the franchise’s 400+ brand partnerships.

Aside from your typical makeup palettes and water bottles, some brand deals are raising eyebrows. Swiffer’s pink Sweep and Mop Deluxe, Febreze’s “Beautifical Blossom” Air Freshener and Cascade’s “Emerald City” dishwasher pods are all seemingly random collaborations. Why so many cleaning products? And what is the point of slapping pink and green onto any and every purchasable piece of plastic?At the end of the day, the film’s $90 million global marketing budget doesn’t change the inherent musical theater logic that second acts just can’t stand alone as well as a first. Was the essence of “Wicked: For Good” just a well-disguised, fluffy cash grab? Although a sugary and visually pleasing film, this sequel didn’t come close to defying much of anything except expectations.

The post ‘Wicked: For Good’ defied gravity at the box office, but does it defy expectations? appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Read more here: https://dailyemerald.com/176068/arts-culture/wicked-for-good-defied-gravity-at-the-box-office-but-does-it-defy-expectations/
Copyright 2026 Daily Emerald