The Details Behind President Hemphill’s SCHEV Claim

The Forward-Focused Digital Transformation Initiative has received pushback from students and professors alike. In the eyes of many faculty members, the motives for the changes have been vague and the communication has been lacking. Old Dominion University President Hemphill claimed that the State Council of Higher Education of Virginia told him to “eliminate” 21 educational programs. Therefore, the Mace and Crown sent a FOIA request to SCHEV to review any and all communications regarding those programs.

 

The bottom line?

Yes, there are 21 ODU educational programs that are subject to review by SCHEV.

No, SCHEV has not formally reached out to ODU Senior Leadership, including Provost Brian Payne, about these programs, especially not in the sense of the state agency mandating ODU to eliminate programs.

 

Before diving into the information obtained by the FOIA request, it’s important to directly quote what Hemphill shared at the Open Forum for students on Oct. 6, 2025. When this statement was made, it bore a lot of weight: “The fact that I have 21 programs that SCHEV, which is a state agency, has told me that we need to eliminate, we need to move away from those programs…”

 

.sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 {
display: flex;
float: none;
margin: 30px auto;
width: 100%;
border-color: #888888;
border-top-width: 5px;
border-right-width: 5px;
border-bottom-width: 5px;
border-left-width: 5px;
background-color: #dddddd;
}
.sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 p.pullquotetext,
.sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 p.quotespeaker {
color: #000000 !important;
}
.sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 .pullquotepic {
width: 250px;
margin-left: 25px;
}
.sno-story-body .sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 p.pullquotetext {
font-size: 22px;
line-height: 1.4em;
}
.sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 .quotebar {
background: #aaaaaa;
flex: 0 0 90px;
margin-top: -15px;
margin-left: -15px;
padding-left: 15px;
padding-top: 15px;
margin-right: 15px;
}
.sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 .largequote {
color: #000000;
}
.sno-pullquote-69321e06c9ce1 .quotebody {
width: 100%;
}

 

The response to the FOIA request that was sent out confirmed that there has been no email correspondence between SCHEV and ODU Senior Leadership about cutting programs. If this is the case, then why would President Hemphill make such a misleading claim to the students? Where did he get this metric of 21 programs?

 

Thankfully, the latter question can be confirmed through SCHEV’s website. Any member of the public can access data regarding university metrics. One of these data tables is called “Productivity,” which is the source of the number of programs that would be used for review. The table will be attached as a link here and attached as an excel file below. Please note that it’s important to select Old Dominion University on the site.

 

So what do the numbers mean? Essentially, there exists a minimum number of student enrollment that university programs have to meet. For example, for bachelor’s programs, a minimum of 48 students need to be enrolled in them as “Full-Time Equivalents” and a minimum of 12 students need to graduate from those programs. There is a minimum number for all bachelor’s, master’s, and doctorate programs. Additionally, the numbers on the table are taken from an average of data from the last five years.

 

Programs that struggle to meet both enrollment and graduate requirements are marked in red. These are the programs that SCHEV would target for productivity review in a memo sent to the institution. The university then has two options: discontinue the programs, or defend and continue them. If the university decides to defend its programs, a form must be filled out and sent along with any important evidence. SCHEV will then review the aforementioned data and make a final decision on whether program closures are merited.

 

Part of the reason SCHEV has yet to reach out to ODU Senior Leadership is because SCHEV is currently putting this policy, along with all the forms associated with it, through revisions. This is a process that is routinely done every five years. Per the confirmation of a SCHEV official, the timeframe for this correspondence to be sent to the university is expected to be done in the Spring 2026 semester, but not during January 2026.

 

In essence, SCHEV has not directly communicated with President Hemphill or Provost Payne regarding these programs. However, this is data that people in these academic positions are fully aware of. 

 

The bigger question lies in this: why wasn’t this directly referenced? What prevented the transparency of the data? Why was the reality of the situation worded to sound like an ultimatum was given to the university?

 

There’s no refuting that the 21 programs will be a target of “Productivity Review.” One of the reasons behind SCHEV’s review is “to utilize the degree program productivity review to promote the efficient use of resources, including minimizing unnecessary duplication of academic degree programs at public institutions.” It wouldn’t be unreasonable to assume that the faculty and student body both have, at the very least, an equal interest in continuing these programs just as Provost Payne states he and Hemphill do.

 

There were several issues that the Faculty Senate and the American Association of University Professors have shared regarding the Forward-Focused Digital Transformation Initiative’s sudden and drastic changes. Lack of communication between the faculty and ODU Senior Leadership was a key theme amongst many concerns and complaints. To them, the data and reasoning behind such a push is vague at best. Despite not showing any data evidence during the FFDTI presentation on Oct. 6, this statement was more than enough to investigate. 

 

When complaints of ambiguity and evasion surround the push for a new initiative; transparency becomes a necessity. When changes will affect not just your colleagues’ line of work, but the pursuit of education of your students, it shifts into a moral duty. 

Sources:

https://research.schev.edu/rdPage.aspx?Productivity&rdReport=productivity.Productivity_Report&UNITID=232982&rdRnd=46220

 

Read more here: https://maceandcrown.com/5720/news/the-details-behind-president-hemphills-schev-claim/
Copyright 2026